Specific Lipid Studies in Complex Membranes by Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy

Solid-state NMR protocols for unveiling dynamics and (drug) interactions of membrane-bound proteins

Magic angle spinning solid-state NMR (MAS ssNMR) is a versatile tool for studying the structure and dynamics of membrane proteins, as well as their interactions with ligands and drugs. Its power lies in the ability to provide atomic-level information on samples under physiological-like conditions. Moreover, it can illuminate dynamics across a wide range of timescales with great relevance to membrane protein function and dysfunction. In this protocol paper, we highlight key aspects of sample preparation, data acquisition, and interpretation, based on our own experience and the broader literature. We discuss key protocol steps along with important considerations for sample preparation and parameters for ssNMR measurements, with reference to the special requirements of membrane-based samples. Such samples display physiologically relevant dynamics across different motional regimes that can be probed by NMR but also can interfere with certain NMR measurements. We guide the reader through the whole process from sample preparation to complex NMR characterization techniques. Throughout the report, we refer back to examples from our own prior work on the interactions between cytochrome c and cardiolipin-containing membranes, with a discussion of the lipid dependence and interactions with a peroxidase-activity inhibitor. We conclude with a short discussion of alternative and new methods that are further boosting the power and versatility of ssNMR as a tool to study membrane-bound proteins and their ligands or drug interactions.

Isolation and Molecular Characterization of the LTA Precursor Molecule Glc2-DAG, a Potential Target for Antibiotics

Bacterial infections present a major global health threat, often displaying resistance to various antibiotics. Lipoteichoic acid (LTA) is a vital component of bacterial cell envelopes of Gram-positive bacteria, crucial for cell integrity, cell division, and host inflammation. Due to its essential role for bacteria, LTA and its biosynthesis are also attractive drug targets, however, there is only scant molecular knowledge on LTA and its precursor molecules in membranes. Here, we report the isolation and molecular characterization of diglucosyldiacylglycerol (Glc2-DAG), the glycolipid precursor molecule that anchors LTA in the bacterial plasma-membrane. Using a tailored growth medium and purification protocols, we isolated 13C-isotope labelled Glc2-DAG from bacteria, which can then be used for high-resolution NMR studies. Using solution-state and solid-state NMR, we show an in-depth molecular characterization of Glc2-DAG, including in native-like membranes. Our approach may help to identify antibiotics that directly target LTA precursor molecules, and it offers a tool for future investigations into the role of Glc2-DAG in bacterial physiology.

Topological Heterogeneity of Protein Kinase C Modulators in Human T-Cells Resolved with In-Cell Dynamic Nuclear Polarization NMR Spectroscopy

Phorbol ester analogs are a promising class of anticancer therapeutics and HIV latency reversing agents that interact with cellular membranes to recruit and activate protein kinase C (PKC) isoforms. However, it is unclear how these esters interact with membranes and how this might correlate with the biological activity of different phorbol ester analogs. Here, we have employed dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) NMR to characterize phorbol esters in a native cellular context. The enhanced NMR sensitivity afforded by DNP and cryogenic operation reveals topological heterogeneity of 13C-21,22-phorbol-myristate-acetate (PMA) within T cells utilizing 13C-13C correlation and double quantum filtered NMR spectroscopy. We demonstrate the detection of therapeutically relevant amounts of PMA in T cells down to an upper limit of ∼60.0 pmol per million cells and identify PMA to be primarily localized in cellular membranes. Furthermore, we observe distinct 13C-21,22-PMA chemical shifts under DNP conditions in cells compared to model membrane samples and homogenized cell membranes, that cannot be accounted for by differences in conformation. We provide evidence for distinct membrane topologies of 13C-21,22-PMA in cell membranes that are consistent with shallow binding modes. This is the first of its kind in-cell DNP characterization of small molecules dissolved in the membranes of living cells, establishing in-cell DNP-NMR as an important method for the characterization of drug-membrane interactions within the context of the complex heterogeneous environment of intact cellular membranes. This work sets the stage for the identification of the in-cell structural interactions that govern the biological activity of phorbol esters.

Host defence peptide plectasin targets bacterial cell wall precursor lipid II by a calcium-sensitive supramolecular mechanism

Antimicrobial resistance is a leading cause of mortality, calling for the development of new antibiotics. The fungal antibiotic plectasin is a eukaryotic host defence peptide that blocks bacterial cell wall synthesis. Here, using a combination of solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance, atomic force microscopy and activity assays, we show that plectasin uses a calcium-sensitive supramolecular killing mechanism. Efficient and selective binding of the target lipid II, a cell wall precursor with an irreplaceable pyrophosphate, is achieved by the oligomerization of plectasin into dense supra-structures that only form on bacterial membranes that comprise lipid II. Oligomerization and target binding of plectasin are interdependent and are enhanced by the coordination of calcium ions to plectasin's prominent anionic patch, causing allosteric changes that markedly improve the activity of the antibiotic. Structural knowledge of how host defence peptides impair cell wall synthesis will likely enable the development of superior drug candidates.

M. van Beekveld R, Breukink E, Weingarth M, Wylie BJ. Coordination of bilayer properties by an inward-rectifier K+ channel is a cooperative process driven by protein-lipid interaction

Physical properties of biological membranes directly or indirectly govern biological processes. Yet, the interplay between membrane and integral membrane proteins is difficult to assess due to reciprocal effects between membrane proteins, individual lipids, and membrane architecture. Using solid-state NMR (SSNMR) we previously showed that KirBac1.1, a bacterial Inward-Rectifier K+ channel, nucleates bilayer ordering and microdomain formation through tethering anionic lipids. Conversely, these lipids cooperatively bind cationic residues to activate the channel and initiate K+ flux. The mechanistic details governing the relationship between cooperative lipid loading and bilayer ordering are, however, unknown. To investigate, we generated KirBac1.1 samples with different concentrations of 13C-lableded phosphatidyl glycerol (PG) lipids and acquired a full suite of SSNMR 1D temperature series experiments using the ordered all-trans (AT) and disordered trans-gauche (TG) acyl conformations as markers of bilayer dynamics. We observed increased AT ordered signal, decreased TG disordered signal, and increased bilayer melting temperature with increased PG concentration. Further, we identified cooperativity between ordering and direct binding of PG lipids, indicating KirBac1.1-driven bilayer ordering and microdomain formation is a classically cooperative Hill-type process driven by and predicated upon direct binding of PG lipids. Our results provide unique mechanistic insight into how proteins and lipids in tandem contribute to supramolecular bilayer heterogeneity in the lipid membrane.

Cooperative Gating of a K+ Channel by Unmodified Biological Anionic Lipids Viewed by Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy

Lipids adhere to membrane proteins to stimulate or suppress molecular and ionic transport and signal transduction. Yet, the molecular details of lipid-protein interaction and their functional impact are poorly characterized. Here we combine NMR, coarse-grained molecular dynamics (CGMD), and functional assays to reveal classic cooperativity in the binding and subsequent activation of a bacterial inward rectifier potassium (Kir) channel by phosphatidylglycerol (PG), a common component of many membranes. Past studies of lipid activation of Kir channels focused primarily on phosphatidylinositol bisphosphate, a relatively rare signaling lipid that is tightly regulated in space and time. We use solid-state NMR to quantify the binding of unmodified 13C-PG to the K+ channel KirBac1.1 in liposomes. This specific lipid-protein interaction has a dissociation constant (Kd) of ∼7 mol percentage PG (ΧPG) with positive cooperativity (n = 3.8) and approaches saturation near 20% ΧPG. Liposomal flux assays show that K+ flux also increases with PG in a cooperative manner with an EC50 of ∼20% ΧPG, within the physiological range. Further quantitative fitting of these data reveals that PG acts as a partial (80%) agonist with fivefold K+ flux amplification. Comparisons of NMR chemical shift perturbation and CGMD simulations at different ΧPG confirm the direct interaction of PG with key residues, several of which would not be accessible to lipid headgroups in the closed state of the channel. Allosteric regulation by a common lipid is directly relevant to the activation mechanisms of several human ion channels. This study highlights the role of concentration-dependent lipid-protein interactions and tightly controlled protein allostery in the activation and regulation of ion channels.

Specific Lipid Studies in Complex Membranes by Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy

Specific interactions with phospholipids are often critical for the function of proteins or drugs, but studying these interactions at high resolution remains difficult, especially in complex membranes that mimic biological conditions. In principle, molecular interactions with phospholipids could be directly probed by solid-state NMR (ssNMR). However, due to the challenge to detect specific lipids in mixed liposomes and limited spectral sensitivity, ssNMR studies of specific lipids in complex membranes are scarce. Here, by using purified biological 13 C,15 N-labeled phospholipids, we show that we can selectively detect traces of specific lipids in complex membranes. In combination with 1 H-detected ssNMR, we show that our approach provides unprecedented high-resolution insights into the mechanisms of drugs that target specific lipids. This broadly applicable approach opens new opportunities for the molecular characterization of specific lipid interactions with proteins or drugs in complex fluid membranes.