Fragment-Based Phenotypic Lead Discovery: Cell-Based Assay to Target Leishmaniasis

How to Find a Fragment: Methods for Screening and Validation in Fragment-Based Drug Discovery

Fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) is a crucial strategy for developing new drugs that have been applied to diverse targets, from neglected infectious diseases to cancer. With at least seven drugs already launched to the market, this approach has gained interest in both academics and industry in the last 20 years. FBDD relies on screening small libraries with about 1000-2000 compounds of low molecular weight (about 300 Da) using several biophysical methods. Because of the reduced size of the compounds, the chemical space and diversity can be better explored than large libraries used in high throughput screenings. This review summarises the most common biophysical techniques used in fragment screening and orthogonal validation. We also explore the advantages and drawbacks of the different biophysical techniques and examples of applications and strategies.

NMR spectroscopy can help accelerate antiviral drug discovery programs

Small molecule drugs have an important role to play in combating viral infections, and biophysics support has been central for contributing to the discovery and design of direct acting antivirals. Perhaps one of the most successful biophysical tools for this purpose is NMR spectroscopy when utilized strategically and pragmatically within team workflows and timelines. This report describes some clear examples of how NMR applications contributed to the design of antivirals when combined with medicinal chemistry, biochemistry, X-ray crystallography and computational chemistry. Overall, these multidisciplinary approaches allowed teams to reveal and expose compound physical properties from which design ideas were spawned and tested to achieve the desired successes. Examples are discussed for the discovery of antivirals that target HCV, HIV and SARS-CoV-2.

Overview of Research on Leishmaniasis in Africa: Current Status, Diagnosis, Therapeutics, and Recent Advances Using By-Products of the Sargassaceae Family

Leishmaniasis in Africa, which has been designated as a priority neglected tropical disease by various global organizations, exerts its impact on millions of individuals, primarily concentrated within this particular region of the world. As a result of the progressively grave epidemiological data, numerous governmental sectors and civil organizations have concentrated their endeavors on this widespread outbreak with the objective of devising appropriate remedies. This comprehensive examination delves into multiple facets of this parasitic ailment, scrutinizing the associated perils, diagnostic intricacies, and deficiencies within the existing therapeutic protocols. Despite the established efficacy of current treatments, they are not immune to deleterious incidents, particularly concerning toxicity and the emergence of parasitic resistance, thus accentuating the necessity of exploring alternative avenues. Consequently, this research not only encompasses conventional therapeutic approaches, but also extends its scope to encompass complementary and alternative medicinal techniques, thereby striving to identify innovative solutions. A particularly auspicious dimension of this study lies in the exploration of natural substances and by-products derived from some brown algae of the Sargassaceae family. These resources possess the potential to assume a pivotal role in the management of leishmaniasis.

N-Phenylpyridine-3-Carboxamide and 6-Acetyl-1H-Indazole Inhibit the RNA Replication Step of the Dengue Virus Life Cycle

Dengue virus (DENV) is a Flavivirus that causes the most prevalent arthropod-borne viral disease. Clinical manifestation of DENV infection ranges from asymptomatic to severe symptoms that can lead to death. Unfortunately, no antiviral treatments against DENV are currently available. In order to identify novel DENV inhibitors, we screened a library of 1,604 chemically diversified fragment-based compounds using DENV reporter viruses that allowed quantification of viral replication in infected cells. Following a validation screening, the two best inhibitor candidates were N-phenylpyridine-3-carboxamide (NPP3C) and 6-acetyl-1H-indazole (6A1HI). The half maximal effective concentration of NPP3C and 6A1H1 against DENV were 7.1 μM and 6.5 μM, respectively. 6A1H1 decreased infectious DENV particle production up to 1,000-fold without any cytotoxicity at the used concentrations. While 6A1HI was DENV-specific, NPP3C also inhibited the replication of other flaviviruses such as West Nile virus and Zika virus. Structure-activity relationship (SAR) studies with 151 analogues revealed key structural elements of NPP3C and 6A1HI required for their antiviral activity. Time-of-drug-addition experiments identified a postentry step as a target of these compounds. Consistently, using a DENV subgenomic replicon, we demonstrated that these compounds specifically impede the viral RNA replication step and exhibit a high genetic barrier-to-resistance. In contrast, viral RNA translation and the de novo biogenesis of DENV replication organelles were not affected. Overall, our data unveil NPP3C and 6A1H1 as novel DENV inhibitors. The information revealed by our SAR studies will help chemically optimize NPP3C and 6A1H1 in order to improve their anti-flaviviral potency and to challenge them in in vivo models.

Fragment-Based Lead Discovery Strategies in Antimicrobial Drug Discovery

Fragment-based lead discovery (FBLD) is a powerful application for developing ligands as modulators of disease targets. This approach strategy involves identification of interactions between low-molecular weight compounds (100-300 Da) and their putative targets, often with low affinity (K_D ~0.1-1 mM) interactions. The focus of this screening methodology is to optimize and streamline identification of fragments with higher ligand efficiency (LE) than typical high-throughput screening. The focus of this review is on the last half decade of fragment-based drug discovery strategies that have been used for antimicrobial drug discovery.

Antileishmanial activity of 5-nitroindazole derivatives

Background

Currently, there is no safe and effective vaccine against leishmaniasis and existing therapies are inadequate due to high toxicity, cost and decreased efficacy caused by the emergence of resistant parasite strains. Some indazole derivatives have shown in vitro and in vivo activity against Trichomonas vaginalis and Trypanosoma cruzi. On that basis, 20 indazole derivatives were tested in vitro against Leishmania amazonensis.

Objective

To evaluate the in vitro activity of twenty 2-benzyl-5-nitroindazolin-3-one derivatives against L. amazonensis.

Design

For the selection of promising compounds, it is necessary to evaluate the indicators for in vitro activity. For this aim, a battery of studies for antileishmanial activity and cytotoxicity were implemented. These results enabled the determination of the substituents in the indazole derivatives responsible for activity and selectivity, through the analysis of the structure-activity relationship (SAR).

Methods

In vitro cytotoxicity against mouse peritoneal macrophages and growth inhibitory activity in promastigotes were evaluated for 20 compounds. Compounds that showed adequate selectivity were tested against intracellular amastigotes. The SAR from the results in promastigotes was represented using the SARANEA software.

Results

Eight compounds showed selectivity index >10% and 50% inhibitory concentration <1 µM against the promastigote stage. Against intracellular amastigotes, four were as active as Amphotericin B. The best results were obtained for 2-(benzyl-2,3-dihydro-5-nitro-3-oxoindazol-1-yl) ethyl acetate, with 50% inhibitory concentration of 0.46 ± 0.01 µM against amastigotes and a selectivity index of 875. The SAR study showed the positive effect on the selectivity of the hydrophilic fragments substituted in position 1 of 2-benzyl-5- nitroindazolin-3-one, which played a key role in improving the selectivity profile of this series of compounds.

Conclusion

2-bencyl-5-nitroindazolin-3-one derivatives showed selective and potent in vitro activity, supporting further investigations on this family of compounds as potential antileishmanial hits.

Fragment-Based Phenotypic Lead Discovery To Identify New Drug Seeds That Target Infectious Diseases

Fragment-based lead discovery has emerged over the last decades as one of the most powerful techniques for identifying starting chemical matter to target specific proteins or nucleic acids in vitro. However, the use of such low-molecular-weight fragment molecules in cell-based phenotypic assays has been historically avoided because of concerns that bioassays would be insufficiently sensitive to detect the limited potency expected for such small molecules and that the high concentrations required would likely implicate undesirable artifacts. Herein, we applied phenotype cell-based screens using a curated fragment library to identify inhibitors against a range of pathogens including Leishmania, Plasmodium falciparum, Neisseria, Mycobacterium, and flaviviruses. This proof-of-concept shows that fragment-based phenotypic lead discovery (FPLD) can serve as a promising complementary approach for tackling infectious diseases and other drug-discovery programs.

Discovering High Potent Hsp90 Inhibitors as Antinasopharyngeal Carcinoma Agents through Fragment Assembling Approach

Hsp90 is a new promising target for cancer treatment. Many inhibitors have been discovered as therapeutic agents, and some have passed Phase I and II. However, no one is approved by FDA yet. Novel and druggable Hsp90 inhibitors are still demanding. Here, we report a new way to discover high potent Hsp90 inhibitors as antinasopharyngeal carcinoma agents through assembling fragments. With chemotyping analysis, we extract seven chemotypes from 3482 known Hsp90 inhibitors, screen 500 fragments that are compatible with the chemotypes, and confirm 15 anti-Hsp90 fragments. Click chemistry is employed to construct 172 molecules and synthesize 21 compounds among them. The best inhibitor 3d was further optimized and resulted in more potent 4f (IC50 = 0.16 μM). In vitro and in vivo experiments confirmed that 4f is a promising agent against nasopharyngeal carcinoma. This study may provide a strategy in discovering new ligands against targets without well-understood structures.

Sodium Tetraphenylborate Displays Selective Bactericidal Activity against Neisseria meningitidis and N. gonorrhoeae and Is Effective at Reducing Bacterial Infection Load

Neisseria meningitidis and Neisseria gonorrhoeae, two highly related species that might have emerged from a common commensal ancestor, constitute major human threats. Vaccines are available to prevent N. meningitidis infection, whereas there are only a limited number of antibiotics available for N. gonorrhoeae Unfortunately, some strains of these species are rapidly evolving and capable of escaping human interventions. Thus, it is now urgent to develop new avenues to fight these bacteria. This study reports that a boron-based salt, sodium tetraphenylborate (NaBPh₄), displays high bactericidal activity and remarkable specificity against N. meningitidis and N. gonorrhoeae Other closely related commensal species such as Neisseria lactamica, which is found in the normal flora of healthy individuals, were found to be less affected even at 5-fold higher doses of NaBPh₄ This specificity was further observed when much lower sensitivity was found for more distant Neisseriaceae species (such as Neisseria elongata or Kingella oralis) and completely unrelated species. Significant boron uptake by N. meningitidis cells was observed after incubation with 5 μM NaBPh₄, as measured by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry, suggesting that this drug candidate's target(s) could be located intracellularly or within the cell envelope. Furthermore, mutants with slightly decreased susceptibility displayed alterations in genes coding for cell envelope elements, which reduced their virulence in an animal model of infection. Finally, a single dose of NaBPh₄ resulted in a significant reduction in bacterial burden in a mouse model of N. meningitidis bacteremia. Although numerous boron-containing species were previously reported for their complex biological activities, the observation of this narrow selectivity is unprecedented and of potential importance from a therapeutic standpoint.

Fragment-to-Lead Medicinal Chemistry Publications in 2018

This Perspective, the fourth in an annual series, summarizes fragment-to-lead (F2L) success stories published during 2018. Topics such as target class, screening methods, physicochemical properties, and ligand efficiency are discussed for the 2018 examples as well as for the combined 111 F2L examples covering 2015-2018. While the overall properties of fragments and leads have remained constant, a number of new trends are noted, for example, broadening of target class coverage and application of FBDD to covalent inhibitors. Moreover, several studies make use of fragment hits that were previously described in the literature, illustrating that fragments are versatile starting points that can be optimized to structurally diverse leads. By focusing on success stories, the hope is that this Perspective will identify and inform best practices in fragment-based drug discovery.

Precision medicine review: rare driver mutations and their biophysical classification

How can biophysical principles help precision medicine identify rare driver mutations? A major tenet of pragmatic approaches to precision oncology and pharmacology is that driver mutations are very frequent. However, frequency is a statistical attribute, not a mechanistic one. Rare mutations can also act through the same mechanism, and as we discuss below, “latent driver” mutations may also follow the same route, with “helper” mutations. Here, we review how biophysics provides mechanistic guidelines that extend precision medicine. We outline principles and strategies, especially focusing on mutations that drive cancer. Biophysics has contributed profoundly to deciphering biological processes. However, driven by data science, precision medicine has skirted some of its major tenets. Data science embodies genomics, tissue- and cell-specific expression levels, making it capable of defining genome- and systems-wide molecular disease signatures. It classifies cancer driver genes/mutations and affected pathways, and its associated protein structural data guide drug discovery. Biophysics complements data science. It considers structures and their heterogeneous ensembles, explains how mutational variants can signal through distinct pathways, and how allo-network drugs can be harnessed. Biophysics clarifies how one mutation—frequent or rare—can affect multiple phenotypic traits by populating conformations that favor interactions with other network modules. It also suggests how to identify such mutations and their signaling consequences. Biophysics offers principles and strategies that can help precision medicine push the boundaries to transform our insight into biological processes and the practice of personalized medicine. By contrast, “phenotypic drug discovery,” which capitalizes on physiological cellular conditions and first-in-class drug discovery, may not capture the proper molecular variant. This is because variants of the same protein can express more than one phenotype, and a phenotype can be encoded by several variants.

CellFy: A Cell-Based Fragment Screen against C-Type Lectins

Fragment-based drug discovery is a powerful complement to conventional high-throughput screening, especially for difficult targets. Screening low-molecular-weight fragments usually requires highly sensitive biophysical methods, because of the generally low affinity of the identified ligands. Here, we developed a cell-based fragment screening assay (cellFy) that allows sensitive identification of fragment hits in a physiologically more relevant environment, in contrast to isolated target screenings in solution. For this, a fluorescently labeled multivalent reporter was employed, enabling direct measurement of displacement by low-molecular-weight fragments without requiring enzymatic reactions or receptor activation. We applied this technique to identify hits against two challenging targets of the C-type lectin receptor (CLR) family: Dendritic Cell-Specific Intercellular adhesion molecule-3-Grabbing Nonintegrin (DC-SIGN) and Langerin. Both receptors are involved in pathogen recognition and initiation of an immune response, which renders them attractive targets for immune modulation. Because of their shallow and hydrophilic primary binding site, hit identification for CLRs is challenging and druglike ligands for CLRs are sparse. Screening of a fragment library followed by hit validation identified several promising candidates for further fragment evolution for DC-SIGN. In addition, a multiplexed assay format was developed for simultaneous screening against multiple CLRs, allowing a selectivity counterscreening. Overall, this sensitive cell-based fragment screening assay provides a powerful tool for rapid identification of bioactive fragments, even for difficult targets.