The role of angled-tip microcatheter and microsphere injection velocity in liver radioembolization: A computational particle-hemodynamics study

Numerical assessment of the performance of a new multi side-hole catheter design in liver radioembolization

Numerical fluid-particle dynamics simulations, such as Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD), are widely used to study blood flow and microsphere transport in medical treatments like radioembolization (RE), a therapy for unresectable liver tumors. RE involves injecting 90Y-labeled microspheres via a microcatheter into a hepatic artery to irradiate cancer cells. This study uses simulations on three patient-specific hepatic arteries to evaluate microsphere distribution in RE, focusing on two catheter designs: a standard end-hole catheter (EHC) and a novel multi side-hole catheter (SHC). Key parameters include cancer scenario and catheter tip position. Three performance indexes are introduced: the matching deviation index (MDI), targeting deviation index (TDI), and tumor-flow deviation index (TFDI). Results show the SHC outperforms the EHC with better MDI (3.67 vs. 8.36 percent points) and TDI (6.04 vs. 10.24 percent points) values, suggesting the SHC's cross-flow effect improves microsphere dispersion and alignment with flow split. The TDI values for SHC often match the TFDI, making the latter a potential performance predictor. The SHC demonstrates superior performance when tumors are located downstream from the catheter tip, while for localized tumors, superselective treatment is recommended, minimizing the catheter's impact on therapy.

In Vitro Investigation of Microcatheter Behavior During Microsphere Injection in Transarterial Radioembolization

PURPOSE

To experimentally investigate the behavior of a clinically used microcatheter during transarterial radioembolization (TARE) microsphere injection in a successively bifurcating in vitro model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A symmetrical phantom was developed which bifurcated 3 times into 8 outlets. A blood-mimicking fluid was pumped through the phantom using a physiological representative waveform. Holmium-165 microspheres were injected in a pulsed manner at 3 different locations using a standard microcatheter and a rigid counterpart with same dimensions as a control. Motion of the catheter was studied with a top- and side-view camera on the phantom. Microspheres were collected at each outlet and their distribution over the 8 outlets was analyzed.

RESULTS

Due to the pulsatile flow in the phantom, strengthened by the pulsatile microsphere injection, the clinical catheter showed maximum displacements of 0.87 mm within a vessel with a diameter of 3.6 mm. This motion resulted in a different microsphere distribution for the clinical catheter compared with the rigid counterpart (75.9% vs 49.4% of the microspheres went to outlet 1-4, respectively).

CONCLUSION

In this in vitro model, the motion of the clinical catheter affected distribution of microspheres. Since the pulsatile administration of microspheres resulted in increased motion of the clinical catheter, standardizing microsphere administration could be beneficial to reduce interprocedural differences in TARE.

CLINICAL IMPACT

Our study demonstrated that microsphere distribution during transarterial radioembolization (TARE) is affected by catheter motion. Furthermore, increased catheter motion was observed as a result of the injection profile. Predictive tools such as the contrast CBCT and scout dose use different injection profiles compared to therapeutic TARE injections, potentially altering catheter tip behaviour and microsphere distribution, which could compromise their predictive values. Additionally, current TARE microsphere injection guidelines provide limited details, which may lead to variability across institutes and interventional radiologists. Standardizing injection techniques could reduce catheter motion variability and may facilitate more consistent and predictable microsphere distribution patterns.

A Multi-Scale Computational Model of the Hepatic Circulation Applied to Predict the Portal Pressure After Transjugular Intrahepatic Portosystemic Shunt (TIPS)

Transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) is a widely used surgery for portal hypertension. In clinical practice, the diameter of the stent forming a shunt is usually selected empirically, which will influence the postoperative portal pressure. Clinical studies found that inappropriate portal pressure after TIPS is responsible for poor prognosis; however, there is no scheme to predict postoperative portal pressure. Therefore, this study aims to develop a computational model applied to predict the portal pressure after TIPS ahead of the surgery. For this purpose, a patient-specific 0-3-D multi-scale computational model of the hepatic circulation was developed based on preoperative clinical data. The model was validated using the prospectively collected clinical data of 18 patients. Besides, the model of a representative patient was employed in the numerical experiment to further investigate the influences of multiple pathophysiological and surgical factors. Results showed that the difference between the simulated and in vivo measured portal pressures after TIPS was -1.37 ± 3.51 mmHg, and the simulated results were significantly correlated with the in vivo measured results (r = 0.93, p < 0.0001). Numerical experiment revealed that the estimated model parameters and the severity of possible inherent portosystemic collaterals slightly influenced the simulated results, while the shunt diameter considerably influenced the results. In particular, the existence of catheter for pressure measurement would markedly influence postoperative portal pressure. These findings demonstrated that this computational model is a promising tool for predicting postoperative portal pressure, which would guide the selection of stent diameter and promote individualization and precision of TIPS.

Adaptive design of experiments to fit surrogate Gaussian process regression models allows fast sensitivity analysis of the input waveform for patient-specific 3D CFD models of liver radioembolization

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Patient-specific 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models are increasingly being used to understand and predict transarterial radioembolization procedures used for hepatocellular carcinoma treatment. While sensitivity analyses of these CFD models can help to determine the most impactful input parameters, such analyses are computationally costly. Therefore, we aim to use surrogate modelling to allow relatively cheap sensitivity analysis. As an example, we compute Sobol's sensitivity indices for three input waveform shape parameters.

METHODS

We extracted three characteristic shape parameters from our input mass flow rate waveform (peak systolic mass flow rate, heart rate, systolic duration) and defined our 3D input parameter space by varying these parameters within 75 %-125 % of their nominal values. To fit our surrogate model with a minimal number of costly CFD simulations, we developed an adaptive design of experiments (ADOE) algorithm. The ADOE uses 100 Latin hypercube sampled points in 3D input space to define the initial design of experiments (DOE). Subsequently, we re-sample input space with 10,000 Latin Hypercube sampled points and cheaply estimate the outputs using the surrogate model. In each of 27 equivolume bins which divide our input space, we determine the most uncertain prediction of the 10,000 points, compute the true outputs using CFD, and add these points to the DOE. For each ADOE iteration, we calculate Sobol's sensitivity indices, and we continue to add batches of 27 samples to the DOE until the Sobol indices have stabilized.

RESULTS

We tested our ADOE algorithm on the Ishigami function and showed that we can reliably obtain Sobol's indices with an absolute error <0.1. Applying ADOE to our waveform sensitivity problem, we found that the first-order sensitivity indices were 0.0550, 0.0191 and 0.407 for the peak systolic mass flow rate, heart rate, and the systolic duration, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the current study was an illustrative case, the ADOE allows reliable sensitivity analysis with a limited number of complex model evaluations, and performs well even when the optimal DOE size is a priori unknown. This enables us to identify the highest-impact input parameters of our model, and other novel, costly models in the future.

MIDOS: a novel stochastic model towards a treatment planning system for microsphere dosimetry in liver tumors

PURPOSE

Transarterial radioembolization (TARE) procedures treat liver tumors by injecting radioactive microspheres into the hepatic artery. Currently, there is a critical need to optimize TARE towards a personalized dosimetry approach. To this aim, we present a novel microsphere dosimetry (MIDOS) stochastic model to estimate the activity delivered to the tumor(s), normal liver, and lung.

METHODS

MIDOS incorporates adult male/female liver computational phantoms with the hepatic arterial, hepatic portal venous, and hepatic venous vascular trees. Tumors can be placed in both models at user discretion. The perfusion of microspheres follows cluster patterns, and a Markov chain approach was applied to microsphere navigation, with the terminal location of microspheres determined to be in either normal hepatic parenchyma, hepatic tumor, or lung. A tumor uptake model was implemented to determine if microspheres get lodged in the tumor, and a probability was included in determining the shunt of microspheres to the lung. A sensitivity analysis of the model parameters was performed, and radiation segmentectomy/lobectomy procedures were simulated over a wide range of activity perfused. Then, the impact of using different microspheres, i.e., SIR-Sphere®, TheraSphere®, and QuiremSphere®, on the tumor-to-normal ratio (TNR), lung shunt fraction (LSF), and mean absorbed dose was analyzed.

RESULTS

Highly vascularized tumors translated into increased TNR. Treatment results (TNR and LSF) were significantly more variable for microspheres with high particle load. In our scenarios with 1.5 GBq perfusion, TNR was maximum for TheraSphere® at calibration time in segmentectomy/lobar technique, for SIR-Sphere® at 1-3 days post-calibration, and regarding QuiremSphere® at 3 days post-calibration.

CONCLUSION

This novel approach is a decisive step towards developing a personalized dosimetry framework for TARE. MIDOS assists in making clinical decisions in TARE treatment planning by assessing various delivery parameters and simulating different tumor uptakes. MIDOS offers evaluation of treatment outcomes, such as TNR and LSF, and quantitative scenario-specific decisions.

Spatiotemporal Analysis of Particle Spread to Assess the Hybrid Particle-Flow CFD Model of Radioembolization of HCC Tumors

OBJECTIVE

Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models can potentially aid in pre-operative planning of transarterial radioactive microparticle injections to treat hepatocellular carcinoma, but these models are computationally very costly. Previously, we introduced the hybrid particle-flow model as a surrogate, less costly modelling approach for the full particle distribution in truncated hepatic arterial trees. We hypothesized that higher cross-sectional particle spread could increase the match between flow and particle distribution. Here, we investigate whether truncation is still reliable for selective injection scenarios, and if spread is an important factor to consider for reliable truncation.

METHODS

Moderate and severe up- and downstream truncation for selective injection served as input for the hybrid model to compare downstream particle distributions with non-truncated models. In each simulation, particle cross-sectional spread was quantified for 5-6 planes.

RESULTS

Severe truncation gave maximum differences in particle distribution of ∼4-11% and ∼8-9% for down- and upstream truncation, respectively. For moderate truncation, these differences were only ∼1-1.5% and ∼0.5-2%. Considering all particles, spread increased downstream of the tip to 80-90%. However, spread was found to be much lower at specific timepoints, indicating high time-dependency.

CONCLUSION

Combining domain truncation with hybrid particle-flow modelling is an effective method to reduce computational complexity, but moderate truncation is more reliable than severe truncation. Time-dependent spread measures show where differences might arise between flow and particle modelling.

SIGNIFICANCE

The hybrid particle-flow model cuts down computational time significantly by reducing the physical domain, paving the way towards future clinical applications.

A Hybrid Particle-Flow CFD Modeling Approach in Truncated Hepatic Arterial Trees for Liver Radioembolization: A Patient-specific Case Study

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is the most common form of primary liver cancer. At its intermediate, unresectable stage, HCC is typically treated by local injection of embolizing microspheres in the hepatic arteries to selectively damage tumor tissue. Interestingly, computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has been applied increasingly to elucidate the impact of clinically variable parameters, such as injection location, on the downstream particle distribution. This study aims to reduce the computational cost of such CFD approaches by introducing a novel truncation algorithm to simplify hepatic arterial trees, and a hybrid particle-flow modeling approach which only models particles in the first few bifurcations. A patient-specific hepatic arterial geometry was pruned at three different levels, resulting in three trees: Geometry 1 (48 outlets), Geometry 2 (38 outlets), and Geometry 3 (17 outlets). In each geometry, 1 planar injection and 3 catheter injections (each with different tip locations) were performed. For the truncated geometries, it was assumed that, downstream of the truncated outlets, particles distributed themselves proportional to the blood flow. This allowed to compare the particle distribution in all 48 "outlets" for each geometry. For the planar injections, the median difference in outlet-specific particle distribution between Geometry 1 and 3 was 0.21%; while the median difference between outlet-specific flow and particle distribution in Geometry 1 was 0.40%. Comparing catheter injections, the maximum median difference in particle distribution between Geometry 1 and 3 was 0.24%, while the maximum median difference between particle and flow distribution was 0.62%. The results suggest that the hepatic arterial tree might be reliably truncated to estimate the particle distribution in the full-complexity tree. In the resulting hybrid particle-flow model, explicit particle modeling was only deemed necessary in the first few bifurcations of the arterial tree. Interestingly, using flow distribution as a surrogate for particle distribution in the entire tree was considerably less accurate than using the hybrid model, although the difference was much higher for catheter injections than for planar injections. Future work should focus on replicating and experimentally validating these results in more patient-specific geometries.

Larraona G, Sangro B, Bilbao JI, Aramburu J. Computational study of a novel catheter for liver radioembolization

Radioembolization (RE) is a medical treatment for primary and secondary liver cancer that involves the transcatheter intraarterial delivery of micron-sized and radiation-emitting microspheres, with the goal of improving microsphere deposition in the tumoral bed while sparing healthy tissue. An increasing number of in vitro and in silico studies on RE in the literature suggest that the particle injection velocity, spatial location of the catheter tip and catheter type are important parameters in particle distribution. The present in silico study assesses the performance of a novel catheter design that promotes particle dispersion near the injection point, with the goal of generating a particle distribution that mimics the flow split to facilitate tumour targeting. The design is based on two factors: the direction and the velocity at which particles are released from the catheter. A series of simulations was performed with the catheter inserted at an idealised hepatic artery tree with physiologically realistic boundary conditions. Two longitudinal microcatheter positions in the first generation of the tree were studied by analysing the performance of the catheter in terms of the outlet-to-outlet particle distribution and split flow matching. The results show that the catheter with the best performance is one with side holes on the catheter wall and a closed frontal tip. This catheter promotes a flow-split-matching particle distribution, which improves as the injection crossflow increases.

Balloon-assisted radioembolization via the proper hepatic artery to treat a left liver hepatocellular carcinoma and portal vein tumor thrombus with an inaccessible left hepatic artery: A case report

Although yttrium-90 (90Y) transarterial radioembolization (TARE) is an effective treatment for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) with portal vein tumor thrombus (PVTT), inability to cannulate tumor-feeding vessels can preclude its use. In this case we demonstrate the feasibility of employing balloon occlusion within the proper hepatic artery to treat a left lobar HCC and PVTT with an inaccessible left hepatic artery. Vessel angulation prevented subselection of the left hepatic artery, and subsequent mapping studies indicated significant non-target radiotracer activity. Through occlusion of the proper hepatic artery by a balloon microcatheter, flow alterations were created that led to uptake of the 90Y microspheres by the tumor while sparing the non-diseased liver parenchyma. Thus, this innovative approach may permit the use of TARE in patients when proximal tumor vessels are inaccessible.

Computational Fluid Dynamics Modeling of Liver Radioembolization: A Review

Yttrium-90 radioembolization (RE) is a widely used transcatheter intraarterial therapy for patients with unresectable liver cancer. In the last decade, computer simulations of hepatic artery hemodynamics during RE have been performed with the aim of better understanding and improving the therapy. In this review, we introduce the concept of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modeling with a clinical perspective and we review the CFD models used to study RE from the fluid mechanics point of view. Finally, we show what CFD simulations have taught us about the hemodynamics during RE, the current capabilities of CFD simulations of RE, and we suggest some future perspectives.

A highly parallel simulation of patient-specific hepatic flows

Computational hemodynamics is being developed as an alternative approach for assisting clinical diagnosis and treatment planning for liver diseases. The technology is non-invasive, but the computational time could be high when the full geometry of the blood vessels is taken into account. Existing approaches use either one-dimensional model of the artery or simplified three-dimensional tubular geometry in order to reduce the computational time, but the accuracy is sometime compromised, for example, when simulating blood flows in arteries with plaque. In this work, we study a highly parallel method for the transient incompressible Navier-Stokes equations for the simulation of the blood flows in the full three-dimensional patient-specific hepatic artery, portal vein and hepatic vein. As applications, we also simulate the flow in a patient with hepatectomy and calculate the S (PPG). One of the advantages of simulating blood flows in all hepatic vessels is that it provides a direct estimate of the PPG, which is a gold standard value to assess the portal hypertension. Moreover, the robustness and scalability of the algorithm are also investigated. A 83% parallel efficiency is achieved for solving a problem with 7 million elements on a supercomputer with more than 1000 processor cores.

Realistic boundary conditions in SimVascular through inlet catheter modeling

OBJECTIVE

This study aims at developing a pipeline that provides the capability to include the catheter effect in the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations of the cardiovascular system and other human vascular flows carried out with the open-source software SimVascular. This tool is particularly useful for CFD simulation of interventional radiology procedures such as tumor embolization where estimation of a therapeutic agent distribution is of interest.

RESULTS

A pipeline is developed that generates boundary condition files which can be used in SimVascular CFD simulations. The boundary condition files are modified such that they simulate the effect of catheter presence on the flow field downstream of the inlet. Using this pipeline, the catheter flow, velocity profile, radius, wall thickness, and deviation from the vessel center can be defined. Since our method relies on the manipulation of the boundary condition that is imposed on the inlet, it is sensitive to the mesh density. The finer the mesh is (especially around the catheter wall), the more accurate the velocity estimations are. In this study, we also utilized this pipeline to qualitatively investigate the effect of catheter presence on the flow field in a truncated right hepatic arterial tree of a liver cancer patient.

CFD Simulations of Radioembolization: A Proof-of-Concept Study on the Impact of the Hepatic Artery Tree Truncation

Radioembolization (RE) is a treatment for patients with liver cancer, one of the leading cause of cancer-related deaths worldwide. RE consists of the transcatheter intraarterial infusion of radioactive microspheres, which are injected at the hepatic artery level and are transported in the bloodstream, aiming to target tumors and spare healthy liver parenchyma. In paving the way towards a computer platform that allows for a treatment planning based on computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations, the current simulation (model preprocess, model solving, model postprocess) times (of the order of days) make the CFD-based assessment non-viable. One of the approaches to reduce the simulation time includes the reduction in size of the simulated truncated hepatic artery. In this study, we analyze for three patient-specific hepatic arteries the impact of reducing the geometry of the hepatic artery on the simulation time. Results show that geometries can be efficiently shortened without impacting greatly on the microsphere distribution.

Transarterial drug delivery for liver cancer: numerical simulations and experimental validation of particle distribution in patient-specific livers

Background: Transarterial therapies are routinely used for the locoregional treatment of unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). However, the impact of clinical parameters (i.e. injection location, particle size, particle density etc.) and patient-specific conditions (i.e. hepatic geometry, cancer burden) on the intrahepatic particle distribution (PD) after transarterial injection of embolizing microparticles is still unclear. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) may help to better understand this impact.Methods: Using CFD, both the blood flow and microparticle mass transport were modeled throughout the 3D-reconstructed arterial vasculature of a patient-specific healthy and cirrhotic liver. An experimental feasibility study was performed to simulate the PD in a 3D-printed phantom of the cirrhotic arterial network.Results: Axial and in-plane injection locations were shown to be effective parameters to steer particles toward tumor tissue in both geometries. Increasing particle size or density made it more difficult for particles to exit the domain. As cancer burden increased, the catheter tip location mattered less. The in vitro study and numerical results confirmed that PD largely mimics flow distribution, but that significant differences are still possible.Conclusions: Our findings highlight that optimal parameter choice can lead to selective targeting of tumor tissue, but that targeting potential highly depends on patient-specific conditions.

On the importance of spiral-flow inflow boundary conditions when using idealized artery geometries in the analysis of liver radioembolization: A parametric study

In the last decades, the numerical studies on hemodynamics have become a valuable explorative scientific tool. The very first studies were done over idealized geometries, but as numerical methods and the power of computers have become more affordable, the studies tend to be patient specific. We apply the study to the numerical analysis of tumor-targeting during liver radioembolization (RE). RE is a treatment for liver cancer, and is performed by injecting radiolabeled microspheres via a catheter placed in the hepatic artery. The objective of the procedure is to maximize the release of radiolabeled microspheres into the tumor and avoid a healthy tissue damage. Idealized virtual arteries can serve as a generalist approach that permits to separately analyze the effect of a variable in the microsphere distribution with respect to others. However, it is important to use proper physiological boundary conditions (BCs). It is not obvious, the need to account for the effect of tortuosity when using an idealized virtual artery. We study the use of idealized geometry of a hepatic artery as a valid research tool, exploring the importance of using realistic spiral-flow inflow BC. By using a literature-based cancer scenario, we vary two parameters to analyze the microsphere distribution through the outlets of the geometry. The parameters varied are the type of microspheres injected and the microsphere injection velocity. The results with realistic inlet velocity profile showed that the particle distribution in the liver segments is not affected by the analyzed injection velocity values neither by the particle density. NOVELTY STATEMENT: In this article, we assessed the use of idealized geometries as a valid research tool and applied the use of an idealized geometry to the case of an idealized hepatic artery to study the particle-hemodynamics during radioembolization (RE). We studied three different inflow boundary conditions (BCs) to assess the usefulness of the geometry, two types of particle injection velocities and two types of commercially available microspheres for RE treatment. In recent years, the advent in computational resources allowed for more detailed patient-specific geometry generation and discretization and hemodynamics simulations. However, general studies based on idealized geometries can be performed in order to provide medical doctors with some basic and general guidelines when using a given catheter for a given cancer scenario. Moreover, using an idealized geometry can be a reasonable approach which allows us to isolate a given parameter and control other parameters, so that parameters can be independently assessed. Even though an idealized geometry does not match any patient's geometry, the use of an idealized geometry can be valid when drawing general conclusions that may be useful in patient-specific cases. However, we believe that even if an idealized hepatic artery geometry is used for the study, it is necessary to account for the upstream and downstream tortuosity of vessels through the BCs. In this work, we highlighted the need of modeling the tortuosity of upstream and downstream vasculatures through the BCs.

Personalized Dosimetry for Liver Cancer Y-90 Radioembolization Using Computational Fluid Dynamics and Monte Carlo Simulation

Yttrium-90 (Y-90) transarterial radioembolization uses radioactive microspheres injected into the hepatic artery to irradiate liver tumors internally. One of the major challenges is the lack of reliable dosimetry methods for dose prediction and dose verification. We present a patient-specific dosimetry approach for personalized treatment planning based on computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations of the microsphere transport combined with Y-90 physics modeling called CFDose. The ultimate goal is the development of a software to optimize the amount of activity and injection point for optimal tumor targeting. We present the proof-of-concept of a CFD dosimetry tool based on a patient's angiogram performed in standard-of-care planning. The hepatic arterial tree of the patient was segmented from the cone-beam CT (CBCT) to predict the microsphere transport using multiscale CFD modeling. To calculate the dose distribution, the predicted microsphere distribution was convolved with a Y-90 dose point kernel. Vessels as small as 0.45 mm were segmented, the microsphere distribution between the liver segments using flow analysis was predicted, the volumetric microsphere and resulting dose distribution in the liver volume were computed. The patient was imaged with positron emission tomography (PET) 2 h after radioembolization to evaluate the Y-90 distribution. The dose distribution was found to be consistent with the Y-90 PET images. These results demonstrate the feasibility of developing a complete framework for personalized Y-90 microsphere simulation and dosimetry using patient-specific input parameters.

In Vitro Study of Particle Transport in Successively Bifurcating Vessels

To reach a predictive understanding of how particles travel through bifurcating vessels is of paramount importance in many biomedical settings, including embolization, thromboembolism, and drug delivery. Here we utilize an in vitro model in which solid particles are injected through a rigid vessel that symmetrically bifurcates in successive branching generations. The geometric proportion and fluid dynamics parameters are relevant to the liver embolization. The volumetric flow field is reconstructed via phase-contrast magnetic resonance imaging, from which the particle trajectories are calculated for a range of size and density using the particle equation of motion. The method is validated by directly tracking the injected particles via optical imaging. The results indicate that, opposite to the common assumption, the particles distribution is fundamentally different from the volumetric flow partition. In fact, the amount of delivered particles vary substantially between adjacent branches even when the flow is uniformly distributed. This is not due to the inertia of the particles, nor to gravity. The particle distribution is rather rooted in their different pathways, which in turn are linked to their release origin along the main vessel cross-section. Therefore, the tree geometry and the associated flow streamlines are the prime determinant of the particle fate, while local changes of volumetric flow rate to selected branches do not generally produce proportional changes of particle delivery.