Lignin Depolymerization: A Comparison of Methods to Analyze Monomers and Oligomers

Synthetic Lignin Oligomers: Analytical Techniques, Challenges, and Opportunities

Lignin is the second most abundant renewable material after cellulose. However, its economic use is currently relegated to low-value energy production. This biomaterial holds great potential as a source of renewable biofuels, bio-based chemicals, advanced materials, and integrated biorefineries. Fractionation and depolymerization methods yield liquid repositories of promising aromatic monomers and lignin oligomers (LO) that retain many of the structural components found in the native material. However, analyzing this complex mixture is challenging due to the wide range of molecular sizes and heterogeneous chemical structure, which makes their structural elucidation a critical obstacle - unlocking the full potential of lignin hinges upon developing appropriate standards and analytical methods to address existing knowledge gaps. This review provides a comprehensive examination of current analytical techniques for elucidating the chemical structure of lignin oligomers, exploring synthesis methods, molecular structures, and their advantages and limitations. Built upon these findings, opportunities for synergy between synthetic oligomers and lignin utilization can be revealed, such as bioactive compound production and biorefinery integration. Moreover, we underscore the need for standardized analytical methods to facilitate the design of lignin oligomer standards and their diverse applications.

Depolymerization and demethylation of lignin for sustainable coloration and functionalization of silk fabric

Conversion of agricultural biomass waste into textile dyes enhances both the environmental sustainability and the textile industry's green and sustainable development. This study introduced a novel strategy to transform the lignin (LN) from corn cob to a polyphenol-rich dye through depolymerization followed by demethylation. The successful modifications were confirmed via FT-IR, UV-vis, and NMR analysis. Depolymerization and demethylation significantly reduced the molecular weight and particle size of LN, from 2797 to 865 g/mol and 3.9 to 0.9 μm, respectively. Consequently, the dye had a 36.1 % higher dye exhaustion rate on silk fabric compared to the unmodified LN. After mordanting with Al3+ ions, the dyed silk fabrics achieved color fastnesses of grade 3-5, meeting the requirement (≥grade 3) for commercial use. Furthermore, demethylation resulted in a 3.7-times increase in the content of phenolic-OH groups of the dye, significantly improving the UV protection and antibacterial properties of the dyed fabrics. The dyed fabrics did not show cytotoxicity to the human skin cells, indicating the high safety for textile use. This work provides a novel way to add value to LN biowaste while simultaneously preparing a functional LN-based dye.

Online Mass Spectrometric Characterization of Oligomeric Products in High-Pressure Liquid-Phase Lignin Depolymerization Reactions

Lignin depolymerization involves complex reactions that occur in heterogeneous environments, leading to the formation of a wide range of products with diverse molecular structures. The complexity of these products arises from the different bond strengths and locations within the lignin polymer, which makes it difficult to fully understand the reaction pathways. Conventional analytical techniques often fall short of providing a clear and comprehensive picture of the reaction mechanism. This highlights the need for more advanced methods that can offer real-time, in situ analysis to probe product evolutions and unravel the detailed mechanisms of lignin depolymerization. Herein, we present a concise perspective of the recent developments in online mass spectrometry, particularly its applications in probing heavy oligomeric products formed during lignindepolymerization. After introducing the current analytical technologies and analytical challenges, we focus on the development of online mass spectrometric method, especially those combined with batch and flow-through reactors, for the real-time characterization of lignin depolymerization products. Several key case studies are highlighted. Finally, we discuss the potential opportunities and remaining challenges in this field.

Characteristic study of Candida rugosa lipase immobilized on lignocellulosic wastes: effect of support material

For the first time is reported the comparison of solid biocatalysts derived from Candida rugosa lipase (CRL) immobilized on different lignocellulosic wastes (rice husk, brewer's spent grain, hemp tea waste, green tea waste, vine bark, and spent coffee grounds) focusing on the characterization of these materials and their impact on the lipase-support interaction. The wastes were subjected to meticulous characterization by ATR-FTIR, BET, and SEM analysis, besides lignin content and hydrophobicity determination. Investigating parameters influencing immobilization performance revealed the importance of morphology, textural properties, and hydrophobic interactions revealed the importance of morphology, textural properties and especially hydrophobic interactions which resulted in positive correlations between surface hydrophobicity and lipase immobilization efficiency. Hemp tea waste and spent coffee grounds demonstrated superior immobilization performances (7.20 U/g and 8.74 U/g immobilized activity, 102.3% and 33.5% efficiency, 13.4% and 15.4% recovery, respectively). Moreover, they demonstrated good temporal stability (100% and 92% residual activity after 120 days, respectively) and retained 100% of their immobilized activity after five reuses in the hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl palmitate in hexane. In addition, the study of enzymatic desorption caused by ionic strength and detergent treatments indicated mixed hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions in rice husk, vine bark, and spent coffee grounds supports, while hemp tea waste and green tea waste were dominated by hydrophobic interactions.

Bio-oil Fractionation According to Polarity and Molecular Size: Characterization and Application as Antioxidants

Bio-oil obtained from biomass pyrolysis has great potential for several applications after being upgraded and refined. This study established a method for separating bio-oil into different fractions based on polarity and molecular size to extract phenolic and polyphenolic compounds with antioxidant properties. The fractions were analyzed using various spectroscopic and chromatographic techniques, such as GC/MS, FTIR, UV-vis, SEC, DOSY-NMR, 13C-NMR, and 31P-NMR. The antioxidant properties of these fractions were tested by examining their ability to improve the oxidative stability of biodiesel. The results strongly connected the bio-oil's chemical functionalities and antioxidant power. During solvent fractionation, dichloromethane could extract phenolic structures, which were subsequently size-fractionated. The subfractions with lower molecular weight (in the order of monomers and dimers) outperformed the antioxidant potential of the crude bio-oil. Heavier subfractions from dichloromethane extraction did not show good antioxidant abilities, which was related to the low hydroxy group content. After solvent extraction, phenolic oligomers remained in the water-insoluble/dichloromethane-insoluble fraction, which showed good antioxidant potential despite its low solubility in biodiesel.

Perspective on Lignin Conversion Strategies That Enable Next Generation Biorefineries

The valorization of lignin, a currently underutilized component of lignocellulosic biomass, has attracted attention to promote a stable and circular bioeconomy. Successful approaches including thermochemical, biological, and catalytic lignin depolymerization have been demonstrated, enabling opportunities for lignino-refineries and lignocellulosic biorefineries. Although significant progress in lignin valorization has been made, this review describes unexplored opportunities in chemical and biological routes for lignin depolymerization and thereby contributes to economically and environmentally sustainable lignin-utilizing biorefineries. This review also highlights the integration of chemical and biological lignin depolymerization and identifies research gaps while also recommending future directions for scaling processes to establish a lignino-chemical industry.

Effect of Dynamic and Preferential Decoration of Pt Catalyst Surfaces by WOx on Hydrodeoxygenation Reactions

Catalysts containing Pt nanoparticles and reducible transition-metal oxides (WOx, NbOx, TiOx) exhibit remarkable selectivity to aromatic products in hydrodeoxygenation (HDO) reactions for biomass valorization, contrasting the undesired aromatic hydrogenation typically observed for metal catalysts. However, the active site(s) responsible for the high selectivity remains elusive. Here, theoretical and experimental analyses are combined to explain the observed HDO reactivity by interrogating the organization of reduced WOx domains on Pt surfaces at sub-monolayer coverage. The SurfGraph algorithm is used to develop model structures that capture the configurational space (∼1000 configurations) for density functional theory (DFT) calculations of a W3O7 trimer on stepped Pt surfaces. Machine-learning models trained on the DFT calculations identify the preferential occupation of well-coordinated Pt sites (≥8 Pt coordination number) by WOx and structural features governing WOx-Pt stability. WOx/Pt/SiO2 catalysts are synthesized with varying W loadings to test the theoretical predictions and relate them to HDO reactivity. Spectroscopy- and microscopy-based catalyst characterizations identify the dynamic and preferential decoration of well-coordinated sites on Pt nanoparticles by reduced WOx species, consistent with theoretical predictions. The catalytic consequences of this preferential decoration on the HDO of a lignin model compound, dihydroeugenol, are clarified. The effect of WOx decoration on Pt nanoparticles for HDO involves WOx inhibition of aromatic ring hydrogenation by preferentially blocking well-coordinated Pt sites. The identification of preferential decoration on specific sites of late-transition-metal surfaces by reducible metal oxides provides a new perspective for understanding and controlling metal-support interactions in heterogeneous catalysis.

Identification and characterization of lignin depolymerization enzymes in Bacillus subtilis strain S11Y isolated from a tropical environment in Malaysia

Biological pretreatment using microbial enzymes appears to be the most promising pre-treatment technology for the breakdown of recalcitrant lignin structure. This research focuses on the identification and characterization of lignin-depolymerizing enzymes in Bacillus subtilis strain S11Y, previously isolated from palm oil wastes in Malaysia. The draft genome sequences of this highly lignin-depolymerizing strain revealed that the genome lacked any of the well-known dye-decolorizing peroxidase or catalase-peroxidase that are commonly reported to be involved in lignin depolymerization by bacteria, indicating that strain S11Y has distinct sets of potential lignin depolymerization genes. The oxidative stress-related enzymes Cu/Zn type-superoxide dismutase (Sod2) and a heme-containing monofunctional catalase (Kat2) were identified in the genome sequences that are of interest. Their lignin-depolymerizing ability were evaluated by treating Alkali lignin (AL) with each enzyme and their degradation ability were evaluated using gel-permeation chromatography (GPC), ultrahigh-pressure liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (UHPLC/MS), and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC/MS), which successfully proved lignin depolymerizing ability. Successful evaluation of lignin depolymerizing enzymes can be applicable for lignin pretreatment process in green energy production and generation of valuable chemicals in bio-refinery.

Unraveling lignin degradation in fibre cement via multidimensional fluorometry

Pulp fibre reinforced cement (fibre cement) has the potential to become a forerunner in mitigating the carbon dioxide (CO2) footprint of non-structural materials for residential and commercial structures. However, one of the significant bottlenecks in fibre cement is its poor chemical stability in the alkaline cement matrix. To date, probing the health of pulp fibre in cement is lengthy and laborious, requiring mechanical and chemical separations. In this study, we have demonstrated that it is possible to understand the chemical interactions at the fibre-cement interfaces by tracking lignin in a solid state without using any additional chemicals. For the first time, multidimensional fluorometry is employed for the rapid assessment of the structural change (degradation) of lignin in fibre cement as an indicator of pulp fibre health; providing an excellent platform for the germination of resilient fibre cement with high content of natural lignocellulosic fibre.

Lignin-derived new hydrogen donors for photoinitiating systems in dental materials

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study is to develop amine free photo-initiating system (PIs) for the photopolymerization of dental methacrylate resins, using seven new hydrogen donors HDA-HDG derived from β-O-4 lignin model.

METHODS

Seven experimental CQ/HD PIs were formulated with Bis-GMA/TEGDMA (70 w%/30 w%). CQ/EDB system was chosen as the comparison group. FTIR-ATR was used to monitor the polymerization kinetics and double bond conversion. Bleaching property and color stability were evaluated using a spectrophotometer. Molecular orbitals calculations were used to demonstrate C-H bond dissociation energies of the novel HDs. Depth of cure of the HD based systems were compared to the EDB based one. Cytotoxicity was also studied by CCK8 assay using tissue of mouse fibroblasts (L929 cells).

RESULTS

Compared to CQ/EDB system, the new CQ/HD systems show comparable or better photopolymerization performances (1 mm-thick samples). Comparable or even better bleaching properties were also obtained with the new amine-free systems. Comparing to EDB, all HDs exhibited significantly lower C-H bond dissociation energies by molecular orbitals calculations. Groups with new HD showed higher depth of cure. OD and RGR values were similar to that of the CQ/EDB group, ensuring the feasibility of the new HDs in dental materials.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

The new CQ/HD PI systems could be potentially useful in dental materials, presenting improvements in restorations' esthetic and biocompatibility.

Review on the preparation of fuels and chemicals based on lignin

Lignin is by far the most abundant natural renewable aromatic polymer in nature, and its reserves are second only to cellulose. In addition to the rich carbon content, the structure of lignin contains functional groups such as benzene rings, methoxyl groups, and phenolic hydroxyl groups. Lignin degradation has become one of the high value, high quality and high efficiency methods to convert lignin, which is of great significance to alleviating the current energy shortage and environmental crisis. This article introduces the hydrolysis methods of lignin in acidic, alkaline, ionic liquids and supercritical fluids, reviews the heating rate, the source of lignin species and the effects of heating rate on the pyrolysis of lignin, and briefly describes the metal catalysis, oxidation methods such as electrochemical degradation and photocatalytic oxidation, and degradation reduction methods using hydrogen and hydrogen supply reagents. The lignin degradation methods for the preparation of fuels and chemicals are systematically summarized. The advantages and disadvantages of different methods, the selectivity under different conditions and the degradation efficiency of different catalytic combination systems are compared. In this paper, a new approach to improve the degradation efficiency is envisioned in order to contribute to the efficient utilization and high value conversion of lignin.

Comprehensive approach of methods for microstructural analysis and analytical tools in lignocellulosic biomass assessment - A review

The trend in the modern world is to replace fossil fuels with green energy sources in order to reduce their environmental impact. The biorefinery industry, within this premise, needs to establish quantitative and qualitative analytical methods to better understand lignocellulosic biomass composition and structure. This paper presents chemical techniques (chromatography, thermal analysis, HRMS, FTIR, NIR, and NMR) and physicochemical techniques (XRD, optical and electron microscopy techniques - Confocal fluorescence, Raman, SPM, AFM, SEM, and TEM) for the microstructural characterization of lignocellulosic biomass and its derivatives. Each of these tools provides different and complementary information regarding molecular and microstructural composition of lignocellulosic biomass. Understanding these properties is essential for the design and operation of associated biomass conversion processing facilities. PAT, monitored in real-time, ensures an economical and balanced mass-energy process. This review aimed to help researchers select the most suitable analytical technique with which to investigate biomass feedstocks with recalcitrant natures.

Microbial lipid biosynthesis from lignocellulosic biomass pyrolysis products

Lipids are a biorefinery platform to prepare fuel, food and health products. They are traditionally obtained from plants, but those of microbial origin allow for a better use of land and C resources, among other benefits. Several (thermo)chemical and biochemical strategies are used for the conversion of C contained in lignocellulosic biomass into lipids. In particular, pyrolysis can process virtually any biomass and is easy to scale up. Products offer cost-effective, renewable C in the form of readily fermentable molecules and other upgradable intermediates. Although the production of microbial lipids has been studied for 30 years, their incorporation into biorefineries was only described a few years ago. As pyrolysis becomes a profitable technology to depolymerize lignocellulosic biomass into assimilable C, the number of investigations on it raises significantly. This article describes the challenges and opportunities resulting from the combination of lignocellulosic biomass pyrolysis and lipid biosynthesis with oleaginous microorganisms. First, this work presents the basics of the individual processes, and then it shows state-of-the-art processes for the preparation of microbial lipids from biomass pyrolysis products. Advanced knowledge on separation techniques, structure analysis, and fermentability is detailed for each biomass pyrolysis fraction. Finally, the microbial fatty acid platform comprising biofuel, human food and animal feed products, and others, is presented. Literature shows that the microbial lipid production from anhydrosugars, like levoglucosan, and short-chain organic acids, like acetic acid, is straightforward. Indeed, processes achieving nearly theoretical yields form the latter have been described. Some authors have shown that lipid biosynthesis from different lignin sources is biochemically feasible. However, it still imposes major challenges regarding strain performance. No report on the fermentation of pyrolytic lignin is yet available. Research on the microbial uptake of pyrolytic humins remains vacant. Microorganisms that make use of methane show promising results at the proof-of-concept level. Overall, despite some issues need to be tackled, it is now possible to conceive new versatile biorefinery models by combining lignocellulosic biomass pyrolysis products and robust oleaginous microbial cell factories.