Coordination-Induced Spin-State Switching with Nickel(II) salpn Complexes: Electronic versus Steric Effects and Influence of Intermolecular Interactions

Coordination Induced Spin State Transition Switches the Reactivity of Nickel (II) Porphyrin in Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

Electron spin plays a critical role in chemical processes, particularly in reactions involving metal complexes with unpaired electrons. However, more definitive state-to-state experiments are needed to better elucidate the role of electronic spin. Herein, we chose nickel (II) 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(pentafluorophenyl) porphyrin 1 as a catalyst, which allows switching from a low spin to a high spin state of Ni (II) center through an axial pyridine coordination, for electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). When pyridine is present, we observed β-hydrogenation of porphyrin through electron transfer followed by proton transfer. In contrast, hydrogen evolution mainly occurs via the concerted proton-coupling electron transfer without pyridine coordination. Similar distinct spin-dependent selectivity was also observed in chemical reduction of 1 by CoCp2 with subsequent addition of pyridinium p-toluenesulfonate. Computational calculations using density functional theory demonstrated that the transition from low spin to high spin state enriches the ligand's electron density after one-electron reduction, leading to preferential protonation of β-periphery rather than meso-position or metal center.

Mechanisms for the Spin-State Switching of Strapped Ni-Porphyrin Complexes Deposited on Metal Surfaces: Insights from Quantum Chemical Calculations

The incorporation of molecular switches on nanodevices requires both the intactness of the molecule once deposited on a substrate and the persistence of the reversible switching feature. Recently, the reversible spin-switching of strapped Ni(II)-porphyrin complexes deposited on Ag(111) surface is demonstrated with low-temperature scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). The spin transition is accompanied by the coordination change of the metal center, a phenomenon denominated in coordination-induced spin-state switching (CISSS). In this contribution, the spin switching of the deposited strapped Ni-porphyrin molecules using different quantum chemistry approaches is explored. This calculations inform about the geometry and electronic structure of the adsorbed molecules and the origin of the voltage-dependent switching promoted by the STM tip. Two different mechanisms are inspected to elucidate the key role of the tip, mainly the electron injection between the tip and the molecule and the differential stabilization of the two spin states by the applied electric field between the tip and the silver surface. This study puts in evidence the relevance of the pyridine ligand contained in the strap in the transport properties as in the CISSS process itself.

Computational design of metal hydrides on a defective metal-organic framework HKUST-1 for ethylene dimerization

Catalytic ethylene dimerization to 1-butene is a crucial reaction in the chemical industry, as 1-butene is used for the production of most common plastics (e.g., polyethylene). With well-defined tuneable structures and unsaturated active sites, defective metal-organic frameworks have recently emerged as potential catalysts for ethylene dimerization. Herein, we computationally design a series of metal hydrides on defective HKUST-1 namely H-M-DHKUST-1 (M: Co, Ni, Cu, Ru, Rh and Pd), and subsequently assess their catalytic activity for ethylene dimerization by density functional theory calculations. Due to the antiferromagnetic behavior of dimeric metal-based clusters, we comprehensively investigate all possible multiplicity states on H-M-DHKUST-1 and observe multiplicity crossing. The ground-state reaction barriers for four elementary steps (initiation, C-C coupling, β-hydride elimination and 1-butene desorption) are rationalized and C-C coupling is revealed to be the rate-determining step on H-Co-, H-Ni-, H-Ru-, H-Rh- and H-Pd-DHKUST-1. The energy barrier for β-hydride elimination is found to be the lowest on H-Ru- and H-Rh-DHKUST-1, attributed to the weak stability of agostic arrangement; however, the energy barrier for 1-butene desorption is the highest on H-Rh-DHKUST-1. Among the designed H-M-DHKUST-1, Co- and Ni-based ones are predicted to exhibit the best overall catalytic performance. The mechanistic insights from this study may facilitate the development of new MOFs toward efficient ethylene dimerization and other industrially important reactions.

Vapochromic effect in switchable molecular-based spin crossover compounds

Coordination complexes based on transition metal ions displaying [Ar]3d⁴-3d⁷ electronic configurations can undergo the likely most spectacular switchable phenomena found in molecular coordination chemistry, the well-known Spin Crossover (SCO). SCO phenomena is a detectable, reproducible and reversible switch that occurs between the high spin (HS) and low spin (LS) electronic states of the transition metal actuated by different stimuli (i.e. light, temperature, pressure, the presence of an analyte). Moreover, the occurrence of SCO phenomena causes different outputs, one of them being a colour change. Altogether, an analyte in gas form could be detected by naked eye once it has triggered the corresponding HS ↔ LS transition. This vapochromic effect could be used to detect volatile molecules using a low-cost technology, including harmful chemical substances, gases and/or volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that are present in our environment, in our home or at our workplace. The present review condenses all reported iron coordination compounds where the colour change induced by a given molecule in its gas form is coupled to a HS ↔ LS spin transition. Special emphasis has been made on describing the nature of the post-synthetic modification (PSM) taking place in the material upon the analyte uptake. In this case, three types of PSM can be distinguished: based on supramolecular contacts and/or leading to a coordinative or covalent bond. In the latter, a colour change not only indicates the switch of the spin state in the material but also the formation of a new compound with different properties. It is important to indicate that some of the SCO coordination compounds discussed in the current report have been part of other spin crossover reviews, that have gathered thermally induced SCO compounds and the influence of guest molecules on the SCO behaviour. However, in the majority of examples in these reviews, the change of colour upon the uptake of analytes is not associated with a spin transition at room temperature. In addition, the observed colour variations have been mainly discussed in terms of host-guest interactions, when they can also be induced by a PSM taking place in different sites of the molecule, like the Fe(II) coordination sphere or by chemically altering its inorganic and/or organic linkers. Therefore, we present here for the first time an exhaustive compilation of all systems in which the interaction between the coordination compounds and the vapour analytes leads to a colour change due to a spin transition in the metal centre at room temperature.

Chemically and Light-Driven Coordination-Induced Spin State Switching (CISSS) of a nonheme-iron complex

The new Fe(II) complex [Fe(trident)(bmik)](ClO4)2 (1) (trident = bis(2-pyridylmethyl)benzylamine and bmik = bis(1-methylimidazole)ketone) exhibits a change of magnetic moment in dichloromethane (DCM) solution upon addition of pyridine which is attributed to the Coordination-Induced Spin State Switching effect (CISSS). By attaching a photoisomerizable azopyridine sidegroup to the tridentate ligand the complex [Fe(azpy-trident)(bmik)](ClO4)2 (2; azpy-trident = [N,N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)]-3-(3-pyridylazo)benzylamine) is obtained. As detected by Evans NMR spectroscopy, 2 reversibly changes its magnetic moment in homogeneous solution upon photoirradiation which is attributed to intermolecular Light-Driven Coordination-Induced Spin State Switching (LD-CISSS). Further support for this interpretation is inferred from concentration-dependent Evans NMR measurements.

Reversible coordination-induced spin state switching in a nickel(ii) complex via a crystal-to-crystal transformation

An unprecedented CISSS behavior driven by a single-crystal-to-single-crystal (SCSC) process is found in a dinuclear nickel(ii) complex, which provides a new strategy for developing external-stimuli molecular magnetic materials.

Effect of Diamine Bridge on Reactivity of Tetradentate ONNO Nickel(II) Complexes

Two new square planar ONNO nickel(II) complexes C2_core and C3_core have been synthesized and characterized by single crystal X-ray diffraction, NMR spectroscopy, thermogravimetry, and DFT calculations. The experimental results revealed the effect of the length of diamine bridge in the ligand on the behavior of the studied complexes in the reaction with N-heterocyclic aromatic amines, while DFT calculations provided a basis for the rationalization of this observation. The complex with propylenediamine bridge (C3_core) readily reacts with pyridine and its derivatives to form high-spin (paramagnetic) complexes with octahedral geometry as characterized by X-ray diffraction; electron-donating substituents on the pyridine ring facilitate the coordination of axial ligands. In contrast, the complex with ethylenediamine bridge (C2_core) does not undergo such a reaction because of the high deformation energy of the core required for the formation of C2_Py complex.

Theoretical modeling of the singlet-triplet spin transition in different Ni(II)-diketo-pyrphyrin-based metal-ligand octahedral complexes

The structural stability, charge transfer effects and strength of the spin-orbit couplings in different Ni(ii)-ligand complexes have been studied at the DFT (B3LYP and CAM-B3LYP) and coupled cluster (DLPNO-CCSD(T)) levels of theory. Accordingly, two different, porphyrin- and diketo-pyrphyrin-based four-coordination macrocycles as planar ligands as well as pyridine (or pyrrole) and mesylate anion molecular groups as vertical ligands were considered in order to build metal-organic complexes with octahedral coordination configurations. For each molecular system, the identification of equilibrium geometries and the intersystem crossing (the minimum energy crossing) points between the potential energy surfaces of the singlet and triplet spin states is followed by computing the spin-orbit couplings between the two spin states. Structures, based on the diketo-pyrphyrin macrocycle as the planar ligand, show stronger six-coordination metal-organic complexes due to the extra electrostatic interaction between the positively charged central metal cation and the negatively charged vertical ligands. The results also show that the magnitude of the spin-orbit coupling is influenced by the atomic positions of deprotonations of the ligands, and implicitly the direction of the charge transfer between the ligand and the central metal ion.

A Fluorescence-Detected Coordination-Induced Spin State Switch

The response of the spin state to in situ variation of the coordination number (CISSS) is a promising and viable approach to smart sensor materials, yet it suffers to date from insensitive detection. Herein, we present the synthetic access to a family of planar nickel(II) complexes, whose CISSS is sensitively followed by means of fluorescence detection. For this purpose, nickel(II) complexes with four phenazine-based Schiff base-like ligands were synthesized and characterized through solution-phase spectroscopy (NMR and UV-vis), solid-state structure analysis (single-crystal XRD), and extended theoretical modeling. All of them reveal CISSS in solution through axial ligating a range of N- and O-donors. CISSS correlates nicely with the basicity of the axial ligand and the substitution-dependent acidity of the nickel(II) coordination site. Remarkably, three out of the four nickel(II) complexes are fluorescent in noncoordinating solvents but are fluorescence-silent in the presence of axial ligands such as pyridine. As these complexes are rare examples of fluorescent nickel(II) complexes, the photophysical properties with a coordination number of 4 were studied in detail, including temperature-dependent lifetime and quantum yield determinations. Most importantly, fluorescence quenching upon adding axial ligands allows a "black or white", i.e. digital, sensoring of spin state alternation. Our studies of fluorescence-detected CISSS (FD-CISSS) revealed that absorption-based CISSS and FD-CISSS are super proportional with respect to the pyridine concentration: FD-CISSS features a higher sensitivity. Overall, our findings indicate a favored ligation of these nickel(II) complexes in the excited state in comparison to the ground state.

Solid state mononuclear divalent nickel spin crossover complexes

Spin crossover complexes containing 3d⁴-3d⁷ transition metal ions with tunable electronic configurations in appropriate ligand field environments have been extensively investigated. In contrast, the development of 3d⁸ divalent nickel complexes displaying such a spin crossover behavior is far behind. The increasing number of X-ray single crystal structures along with magnetic evidence and thermodynamic equilibrium indicate that bistable divalent nickel complexes are gradually recognized to be a formal member of the "spin crossover family". Unfortunately, the rarity of nickel spin crossover complexes is occasionally mentioned. This Perspective article highlights examples of mononuclear 3d⁸ nickel spin crossover complexes in dynamic rearrangements with characterized solid state structures from the viewpoint of types of ligands utilized.

Improving the Light-Induced Spin Transition Efficiency in Ni(II)-Based Macrocyclic-Ligand Complexes

The structural stability and photoabsorption properties of Ni(II)-based metal-organic complexes with octahedral coordination having different planar ligand ring structures were investigated employing density functional theory (DFT) and its time-dependent extension (TD-DFT) considering the M06 exchange-correlation functional and the Def2-TZVP basis set. The results showed that the molecular composition of different planar cyclic ligand structures had significant influences on the structural stability and photoabsorption properties of metal-organic complexes. Only those planar ligands that contained aromatic rings met the basic criteria (thermal stability, structural reversibility, and appropriate excitation frequency domain) for light-induced excited spin state trapping, but their spin transition efficiencies were very different. While, in all three aromatic cases, the singlet electronic excitations induced charge distribution that could help in the singlet-to-triplet spin transition, and triplet excitations, which could assist in the backward (triplet-to-singlet) spin transition, was found only for one complex.