Comparison of capillary electrophoresis-based immunoassay with fluorescence polarization immunoassay for the immunodetermination of methamphetamine using various methamphetamine antibodies

Capillary electrophoresis-based immunoassay and aptamer assay: A review

Over the last two decades, the group of techniques called affinity probe CE has been widely used for the detection and the determination of several types of biomolecules with high sensitivity. These techniques combine the low sample consumption and high separation power of CE with the selectivity of the probe to the target molecule. The assays can be defined according to the type of probe used: CE immunoassays, with an antibody as the probe, or aptamer-based CE, with an aptamer as the probe. Immunoassays are generally divided into homogeneous and heterogeneous groups, and homogeneous variant can be further performed in competitive or noncompetitive formats. Interacting partners are free in solution at homogeneous assay, as opposed to heterogeneous analyses, where one of them is immobilized onto a solid support. Highly sensitive fluorescence, chemiluminescence or electrochemical detections were typically used in this type of study. The use of the aptamers as probes has several advantages over antibodies such as shorter generation time, higher thermal stability, lower price, and lower variability. The aptamer-based CE technique was in practice utilized for the determination of proteins in biological fluids and environmentally or clinically important small molecules. Both techniques were also transferred to microchip. This review is focused on theoretical principles of these techniques and a summary of their applications in research.

Disposable electrochemical immunosensor array for the multiplexed detection of the drug metabolites morphine, tetrahydrocannabinol and benzoylecgonine

Heroin, marijuana and cocaine are widely abused drugs. Their use can be readily detected by analyzing urine for the metabolites morphine (MOR), tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) or benzoylecgonine (BZC). A multiplex immunosensor is described here for detection of MOR, THC and BZC using screen printed carbon array electrodes modified with gold nanoparticles. Antibodies against MOR, THC and BZC were immobilized on eight electrodes in a sensor array simultaneously, and a competitive assay was used for the detection. The free analytes in the sample compete with bovine serum albumin-conjugated analytes for the immobilized antibodies on the sensor surface. The array is capable of detecting the three drugs simultaneously within 20-40 min. The method has a high sensitivity, with detection limits as low as 1.2, 7.0, and 8.0 pg.mL^-1 for MOR, THC and BZC, respectively. Cross reactivity testing was preformed to monitor any nonspecific binding. The results revealed good selectivity. Urine samples were spiked with the 3 drugs and tested with the multiplexed immunosensor. Recovery percentages ranged between 88 to 115%. Graphical abstract Schematic presentation of the multiplexed immunosensor for drugs of abuse,viz. tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), morphine (MOR), and benzoylecgonine (BZC)) by using an array of modified electrodes.

Clinical applications of capillary electrophoresis based immunoassays

Immunoassays have long been an important set of tools in clinical laboratories for the detection, diagnosis, and treatment of disease. Over the last two decades, there has been growing interest in utilizing CE as a means for conducting immunoassays with clinical samples. The resulting method is known as a CE immunoassay. This approach makes use of the selective and strong binding of antibodies for their targets, as is employed in a traditional immunoassay, and combines this with the speed, efficiency, and small sample requirements of CE. This review discusses the variety of ways in which CE immunoassays have been employed with clinical samples. An overview of the formats and detection modes that have been employed in these applications is first presented. A more detailed discussion is then given on the type of clinical targets and samples that have been measured or studied by using CE immunoassays. Particular attention is given to the use of this method in the fields of endocrinology, pharmaceutical measurements, protein and peptide analysis, immunology, infectious disease detection, and oncology. Representative applications in each of these areas are described, with these examples involving work with both traditional and microanalytical CE systems.

Rapid screening and determination of designer drugs in saliva by a nib-assisted paper spray-mass spectrometry and separation technique

A method for the rapid screening and determination of amphetamine-type designer drugs in saliva by a novel nib-assisted paper spray-mass spectrometry procedure is described. Under optimized conditions, the limit of detections for amphetamine derivatives (model samples: o-, m-, p-chloroamphetamine and o-, m-, p-fluoroamphetamine, respectively) were determined to 0.1 μg/mL by the nib-assisted paper spray-mass spectrometry method. This method is easier and has a higher sensitivity than similar methodologies, including atmospheric pressure/matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry and electrospray-assisted laser desorption ionization/mass spectrometry. Data obtained using more classical separation methods, including liquid chromatography and capillary electrophoresis, are also reported.

Capillary electrophoresis-based immunoassays: principles and quantitative applications

The use of CE as a tool to conduct immunoassays has been an area of increasing interest over the last decade. This approach combines the efficiency, small sample requirements, and relatively high speed of CE with the selectivity of antibodies as binding agents. This review examines the various assay formats and detection modes that have been reported for these assays, along with some representative applications. Most CE immunoassays in the past have employed homogeneous methods in which the sample and reagents are allowed to react in solution. These homogeneous methods have been conducted as both competitive binding immunoassays and as noncompetitive binding immunoassays. Fluorescent labels are most commonly used for detection in these assays, but enzyme labels have also been utilized for such work. Some additional work has been performed in CE immunoassays with heterogeneous methods in which either antibodies or an analog of the analyte is immobilized to a solid support. These heterogeneous methods can be used for the selective isolation of analytes prior to their separation by CE or to remove a given species from a sample/reagent mixture prior to analysis by CE. These CE immunoassays can be used with a variety of detection modes, such as fluorescence, UV/Vis absorbance, chemiluminescence, electrochemical measurements, MS, and surface plasmon resonance.

Capillary electrophoresis-based immunoassay

Capillary electrophoresis-based immunoassay (CEIA) is a developing analytical technique with a number of advantages over conventional immunoassay, such as reduced sample consumption, simpler procedure, easy simultaneous determination of multiple analytes, and short analysis time. However, there are still a number of technical issues that researchers on CEIA have to solve before the assay can be more widely used. These issues include method to improve the concentration sensitivity of the assay, requirement for robust separation strategy for different analytes, and method to increase the throughput of the assay. The approaches to solve these issues are reviewed. Several studies have been devoted to develop general separation strategies for CEIA, and to enhance the sensitivity of detection. The recent development of microchip-based CEIA is encouraging and is likely to address more drawbacks of CEIA, particularly on the throughput issue.

Enhancement of immunocomplex detection and application to assays for DNA adduct of benzo[a]pyrene

The stability of antibody and formation of immunocomplexes are essential to high-sensitivity capillary electrophoresis immunoassays (CEIA). However, little attention has been paid to enhancing or maintaining immunocomplex formation and antibody stability to improve the performance of CEIA. We report here the use of nonspecific proteins, such as bovine serum albumin (BSA) and rabbit immunoglobulin (rIgG), to enhance immunocomplex formation and to stabilize antibodies and immunocomplexes for immunoassays. Complexes between DNA adducts of benzo[a]pyrenediol epoxide (BPDE) and their antibodies were examined using capillary electrophoresis with laser-induced fluorescence detection (CE-HF). A tetramethylrhodamine (TMR)-labeled single-stranded oligonucleotide (16-mer) containing a single BPDE adduct was used as a fluorescent probe to study its immunocomplexes with a monoclonal antibody (8E11). To examine the formation of larger complexes, a TMR-labeled secondary antibody (anti-mouse), a primary antibody (mouse monoclonal antibody 5D11), and BPDE adducts in cellular DNA were used. We demonstrate that the use of nonspecific proteins stabilized the antibody and greatly enhanced the formation and stability of the immunocomplexes, resulting in substantial improvements in the detection limit (10-fold) and the reproducibility of the analysis. Another advantageous consequence of the stabilization was a 150-fold reduction of the concentration of the antibody needed for the immunoassay, resulting in reduced background and cost. We successfully applied this technique to the determination of DNA adducts of BPDE using a competitive immunoassay. The results from both small complexes (between a primary antibody and an oligonucleotide) and larger complexes (among a secondary antibody, a primary antibody, and cellular DNA) indicate that the technique can be extended to other immunoassays. We suggest that nonspecific proteins may assist the formation and stabilization of antibody-antigen complexes by maintaining the correct conformation of the antibody and antigen for optimum binding.

Effects of the competitor on antibody-hapten binding in immunoassays

The effects of competitors on antibody (Ab)-hapten binding in an immunoassay were investigated using a goat antimethamphetamine (MA) antibody (Ab). An N-4-aminobutyl derivative of methamphetamine (4-ABMA) was conjugated with keyhole limpet hemocyanine (KLH) and used as an immunogen. The antiserum was purified by affinity chromatography with various ligands, including 4-ABMA-protein conjugates, free haptens, and protein G. Direct and indirect competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) were conducted with a competitor of 4-ABMA-fluorescein isothiocyanate (4-ABMA-FITC). The results were compared to those of ELISA with a different competing antigen, 4-ABMA-ovalbumin (4-ABMA-OVA), in terms of sensitivity and specificity. In both direct and indirect assay formats, the sensitivity was much improved with 4-ABMA-FITC, compared to that with 4-ABMA-OVA, suggesting that different labels on the same haptenic moiety for competitors considerably influence the assay performance. All the purified Abs also showed a distinct feature of strong affinity for benzphetamine with 4-ABMA-FITC, whereas they had their respective binding specificities with 4-ABMA-OVA. Comparing the results to those from other assay systems, we determined that the assay sensitivity was dependent on both the system and the competitor employed, and that the specificity was primarily dependent on the competitor used.

Detection of specific antibodies using immunosubtraction and capillary electrophoresis instrumentation

Solution-phase immunoassays based on capillary electrophoresis (CE) separations have been shown to be rapid and simple to perform. The potential for sample matrix interference and incompatibility with multiplexing conditions for antibody detection when dealing with real samples, however, has prompted the development of an assay that utilizes an immunosubtraction methodology. A model assay for the detection of specific antibodies that relies on solid-phase extraction, CE and laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) detection is described. The method, called immunocapture-immunosubtraction (ICIS), incorporates an antibody capture/purification protocol using magnetic particles. The detection of specific antibodies is achieved by CE-LIF analysis of a probe solution following incubation with the captured antibodies. As an example of the ICIS assay's capabilities, the relative quantification of anti-fluorescein in serum is presented.

Capillary electrophoresis-based immunoassays

This review covers the progress and developments in the field of capillary electrophoresis immunoassay (CEIA) over the past three years. Because many excellent descriptions of the principles of these methods are available (e.g., in the reviews listed in this article), no elementary introduction is given to the field of immunoassays (IAs) or CEIAs. This report focuses exclusively on experimental results, dividing the CEIA papers into the categories of direct, indirect, and microchip electrophoretic immunoassays. In the last section, a brief summary of the current status of the CEIA field is presented.

Analysis of codeine, dihydrocodeine and their glucuronides in human urine by electrokinetic capillary immunoassays and capillary electrophoresis-ion trap mass spectrometry

Screening for and confirmation of illicit, abused and banned drugs in human urine is a timely topic in which capillary separation techniques play a key role. Capillary electrophoresis (CE) represents the newest technology employed in this field of analysis. Two rapid competitive binding, electrokinetic capillary-based immunoassays are shown to be capable of recognizing the presence, but not the identity, of urinary opioids, namely codeine (COD), codeine-6-glucuronide, dihydrocodeine (DHC), dihydrocodeine-6-glucuronide, morphine (MOR), morphine-3-glucuronide and ethylmorphine (EMOR). In these approaches, aliquots of urine and immunoreagents of a commercial, broadly cross-reacting fluorescence polarization immunoassay for opiates were combined and analyzed by capillary zone electrophoresis or micellar electrokinetic capillary chromatography with laser induced fluorescence detection. With the fluorescent tracer solution employed, the former method is shown to provide simple electropherograms which are characterized by an opioid concentration dependent magnitude of the free tracer peak. In presence of dodecyl sulfate micelles, however, two tracer peaks with equal opioid concentration sensitivity are monitored. These data suggest the presence of two fluorescent tracers which react competitively with the urinary opioids for the binding sites of the antibody. Assay sensitivities for COD and MOR are comparable (10 ng/ml), whereas those for DHC and EMOR are about four-fold lower. Furthermore, glucuronides are shown to react like the corresponding free opioids. Analysis of urines that were collected after administration of 7 mg COD and 25 mg DHC tested positively in both assay formats. The presence of the free and conjugated codeinoids in these urines and their identification was accomplished by capillary electrophoresis-ion trap mass spectrometry (CE-MS). This confirmatory assay is based upon solid-phase extraction using a mixed-mode polymer cartridge followed by CE hyphenated to the LCQ mass spectrometer with electrospray ionization in the positive ion mode. With this technology, MS2 is employed for proper identification of COD (m/z 300.4) and DHC (m/z 302.4) whereas MS3 provides unambiguous identification of the glucuronides of COD (m/z 476.5) and DHC (m/z 478.5) via their fragmentation to COD and DHC, respectively. MSn (n > or = 2) is shown to be capable of properly identifying the urinary codeinoids on the 100-200 ng/ml concentration level.

Capillary electrophoresis in clinical and forensic analysis: recent advances and breakthrough to routine applications

This paper is a comprehensive review article on capillary electrophoresis (CE) in clinical and forensic analysis. It is based upon the literature of 1997 and 1998, presents CE examples in major fields of application, and provides an overview of the key achievements encountered, including those associated with the analysis of drugs, serum proteins, hemoglobin variants, and nucleic acids. For CE in clinical and forensic analysis, the past two years witnessed a breakthrough to routine applications. As most coauthors of this review are associated with diagnostic or forensic laboratories now using CE on a routine basis, this review also contains data from routine applications in drug, protein, and DNA analysis. With the first-hand experience of providing analytical service under stringent quality control conditions, aspects of quality assurance, assay specifications for clinical and forensic CE and the pros and cons of this maturing, cost-and pollution-controlled age technology are also discussed.

Influence of the antibody purification method on immunoassay performance: hapten-antibody binding in accordance with the structure of the affinity column ligand

The effects of ligands for immunoaffinity chromatography on the immunoassay were investigated with three goat anti-methamphetamine (anti-MA) antibodies (Abs). An N-4-aminobutyl derivative of methamphetamine (4-ABMA) was conjugated with proteins and used as immunogens. All the antisera produced were purified by affinity chromatography with various ligands of 4-ABMA-proteins and of haptens as well as protein G: 4-ABMA-bovine serum albumin (4-ABMA-BSA), 4-ABMA-keyhole limpet hemocyanine (4-ABMA-KLH), 4-ABMA-ovalbumin (4-ABMA-OVA), MA, 4-ABMA, and amphetamine were used as ligands. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was conducted to examine characteristics of the purified Abs with the 4-ABMA-OVA competitor coated. The results obtained revealed that characters of the purified Abs were closely related with chemical structures of ligands used. The Abs from the MA and the amphetamine columns showed better sensitivities than those from the others in each antiserum. Particularly, the Ab from the amphetamine column gave the best results in terms of sensitivity and specificity. The recognition or the affinity of the Ab selected was considered to be affected by the structure of the ligand concerned. These results suggest that the Ab purification method should be considered as an important parameter which has great influence on the performance of immunoassays with polyclonal Abs.

Analysis of urinary drugs of abuse by a multianalyte capillary electrophoretic immunoassay

This paper characterizes a novel multianalyte competitive binding, electrokinetic capillary-based immunoassay for urinary methadone, opiates, benzoylecgonine (cocaine metabolite) and amphetamines. After incubation of 25 microliters urine with the reactants for several minutes in the presence of an internal standard, a small aliquot of the mixture is applied onto a fused-silica capillary and the unbound fluorescein labelled drug tracers are monitored by capillary electrophoresis with on-column laser induced fluorescence detection. The multianalyte assay is shown to be rapid, simple, quantitative, capable of recognizing urinary drug concentrations > or = 30 ng/ml and suitable for screening of patient urines. Data are demonstrated to compare well with those obtained by routine screening methods based on enzyme multiplied immunoassay techniques and fluorescence polarization immunoassays. The electrokinetic capillary assay has been validated via analysis of external quality control urines and confirmation analysis of patient urines using GC-MS.

Screening for urinary amphetamine and analogs by capillary electrophoretic immunoassays and confirmation by capillary electrophoresis with on-column multiwavelength absorbance detection

This paper characterizes competitive binding, electrokinetic capillary-based immunoassays for screening of urinary amphetamine (A) and analogs using reagents which were commercialized for a fluorescence polarization immunoassay (FPIA). After incubation of 25 microL urine with the reactants, a small aliquot of the mixture is applied onto a fused-silica capillary and unbound fluorescein-labeled tracer compounds are monitored by capillary electrophoresis with on-column laser-induced fluorescence detection. Configurations in presence and absence of micelles were investigated and found to be capable of recognizing urinary D-(+)-amphetamine at concentrations > about 80 ng/mL. Similar responses were obtained for racemic methamphetamine (MA) and 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA). The electrokinetic immunoassay data suggest that the FPIA reagent kit includes two immunoassay systems (two antibodies and two tracer molecules), one that recognizes MA and MDMA, and one that is geared towards monitoring of A. For confirmation analysis of urinary amphetamines and ephedrines, capillary electrophoresis in a pH 9.2 buffer and multiwavelength UV detection was employed. The suitability of the electrokinetic methods for screening and confirmation is demonstrated via analysis of patient and external quality control urines.