Recurrent loss of chromosome 22 and SMARCB1 deletion in extra-axial chordoma: A clinicopathological and molecular analysis

Brachyury expression is highly specific for chordoma: A tissue microarray study involving 14,976 cancers from 135 different tumor types and subtypes

Brachyury protein plays a role in defining the midline of bilaterian organisms. Commonly expressed in chordomas, brachyury immunohistochemistry is used to distinguish chordomas from their differential diagnoses. However, brachyury expression has also been described to frequently occur in other cancer entities. To better comprehend the role of brachyury expression in cancer, a tissue microarray containing 14,976 samples from 135 different tumor entities and 608 samples of 76 different normal tissue types were analyzed by immunohistochemistry. Brachyury staining was found in 55 (0.44 %) of the 12,409 interpretable tumor samples, including 37 (0.3 %) with weak, 10 (0.08 %) with moderate, and 8 (0.06 %) with strong positivity. Brachyury staining strongly predominated in chordomas. Of ten chordomas, 7 were strongly and 3 moderately positive. Only 5 of the 134 analyzed further tumor categories showed brachyury staining, 4 of which originated from testicular germ cells. Brachyury positivity occurred in 21.4 % of 42 yolk sac tumors, 15.2 % of 46 embryonal carcinomas, 4.4 % of 562 seminomas, and 2.4 % of 41 teratomas of the testis. Our data support the previously suggested high specificity of brachyury for chordoma detection, and demonstrate that germ cell tumors represent the only additional group of unrelated cancer entities expressing brachyury at a significant level.

Clinicopathologic and Molecular Characterization of SMARCB1-Deificient Sinonasal Carcinomas -A Systematic Study from a Single Institution Cohort

BACKGROUND

SMARCB1-deficient and SMARCA4-deficient sinonasal carcinomas are rare, with only a few systematic studies available in the literature. Secondary EWSR1 gene abnormalities have been reported in SMARCB1-deficient tumors. This study aimed to systematically investigate SWI/SNF complex-deficient sinonasal carcinomas in a single-institution cohort, perform clinicopathologic characterization, and explore the underlying molecular mechanisms.

METHOD

Immunohistochemistry (IHC) of INI1 and BRG1 was performed on tissue microarrays containing tumor tissue from 149 consecutive sinonasal carcinomas. Single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) array and EWSR1 gene fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analyses were conducted on SMARCB1-deficient sinonasal carcinomas. Clinicopathologic characterization was studied.

RESULT

Of the 149 sinonasal carcinomas, 7 (4.7%) showed SMARCB1 loss, while none demonstrated SMARCA4 loss. All patients were male and presented with advanced-stage tumors. Four SMARCB1-deficient sinonasal carcinomas exhibited basaloid morphology, two displayed eosinophilic tumor morphology, and one had mixed morphology. Homozygous and heterozygous SMARCB1 deletions were identified in 4/6 and 2/6 cases respectively. Heterozygous loss involving genes neighboring SMARCB1 gene, including EWSR1, was observed in four cases. One tumor showed a heterozygous loss of the entire chromosome 22q. EWSR1 FISH assay revealed concordant heterozygous EWSR1 loss in these five cases.

CONCLUSION

SMARCB1-deficient carcinomas account for 4.7% of sinonasal carcinomas in this single-institution cohort, while SMARCA4-deficient tumors are even rarer, with none identified. SMARCB1-deficient sinonasal carcinomas exhibit a broad spectrum of morphologic and immunohistochemical features. These carcinomas show complex genetic alterations, with homozygous SMARCB1 deletions present in the majority of cases.

Rare Extra-Axial Chordoma of the Anteromedial Thigh: A Case Report

Chordomas are rare notochordal malignancies typically occurring in the axial skeleton. Less than 100 extra-axial chordomas have been reported. We describe a unique chordoma of the anteromedial thigh. The clinical presentation of extra-axial chordomas is highly variable; thus, recognizing this entity in the differential diagnoses of extra-axial bone/soft tissue tumors is important.

Extraaxial Poorly Differentiated Chordoma: Clinicopathologic and Molecular Genetic Characterization

Poorly differentiated chordoma (PDC) is an aggressive subtype of chordoma characterized by SMARCB1 (INI1) loss and a dismal prognosis. It typically involves the axial skeleton, most commonly the skull base and the cervical spine. To our knowledge, only 5 cases of extraaxial PDC (EAPDC) have been reported, and the natural history of these tumors is not fully understood. We studied 6 cases of EAPDC, with the goal of better understanding these exceptionally rare tumors. The tumors occurred in 4 women and 2 men, ranging from 37 to 68 years of age (median, 57.5 years) and involved or originated in the left knee joint (3 cases), right knee joint (2 cases), and right wrist (1 case). Grossly, all were solid and lobulated, with areas of necrosis. Histologically, the tumors were identical to axial PDC, with sheets and lobules of overtly malignant-appearing epithelioid-to-rhabdoid cells with prominent nucleoli. Mitotic activity and necrosis were present. By immunohistochemistry, all cases expressed keratins and brachyury and were SMARCB1 deficient. Molecular genetic analysis identified SMARCB1 loss-of-function alterations in 4 of the tested cases, including mutations (2 cases) and copy number loss (2 cases). DNA methylation profiling of 4 cases of EAPDC showed clustering with axial PDC. Clinical follow-up (6 patients; median, 11.5 months; range, 1-26 months) showed 4 patients to have received transfemoral amputation and 1 extraarticular resection. None received neoadjuvant radiotherapy; 1 received neoadjuvant chemotherapy and 1 adjuvant chemotherapy/immunotherapy. Local recurrences were seen in 2 patients at 7 and 8 months; 3 patients developed metastases 7-11 months after surgery. Two patients were alive with metastatic disease (at 7 and 13 months), 1 died of disease (20 months), and 3 were disease free (1-26 months). We conclude that EAPDC are aggressive malignancies with an unusual predilection for the knee joint and unknown pathogenesis.

Extra-Axial Poorly Differentiated Chordoma Initially Misdiagnosed as Epithelioid Sarcoma

Poorly differentiated chordoma is an exceedingly rare, aggressive subtype of chordoma. These tumors typically arise in the axial skeleton of young patients, most commonly the skull base, followed by the cervical spine. Herein, we present a 60-year-old patient with longstanding knee pain and nondiagnostic imaging, initially thought to be due to osteoarthritis. No discrete mass-forming lesion was identified by radiology. Synovial histology at the time of arthroplasty revealed a multinodular proliferation of epithelioid-to-histiocytoid cells with a moderate amount of eosinophilic-to-clear, vacuolated cytoplasm. Scattered cells with high-grade nuclear atypia were present. A diagnosis of metastatic carcinoma was considered due to immunohistochemical positivity for keratin and GATA3. However, a diagnosis of epithelioid sarcoma was rendered based on clinical context, morphology, and loss of immunohistochemical expression for SMARCB1 (INI1). However, upon re-review of the tumor, brachyury was retrospectively added to the immunohistochemistry panel and showed strong positivity, thus prompting amendment of the initial diagnosis of epithelioid sarcoma to extra-axial poorly differentiated chordoma. Given the rarity of this diagnosis, molecular testing was performed which revealed a unique SMARCB1 molecular profile with a single-nucleotide variant in addition to the commonly reported loss of chromosome 22q. This report of an ultra-rare sarcoma in an uncommon anatomic site highlights multiple potential pitfalls in the diagnosis of poorly differentiated chordoma, emphasizes the importance of brachyury immunohistochemistry in rendering a correct interpretation, and underscores an opportunity for further molecular analysis to better define the molecular profile of this entity.

Conventional Spinal Chordomas: Investigation of SMARCB1/INI1 Protein Expression, Genetic Alterations in SMARCB1 Gene, and Clinicopathological Features in 89 Patients

The partial loss of SMARCB1/INI1 expression has recently been reported in skull base conventional chordomas, with possible therapeutic implications. We retrospectively analyzed 89 patients with conventional spinal chordomas to investigate the differences in the immunohistochemical expression of SMARCB1/INI1 and the underlying genetic alterations in the SMARCB1 gene. Moreover, we assessed the correlation of clinicopathological features (age, gender, tumor size, tumor location, surgical margins, Ki67 labelling index, SMARCB1/INI1 pattern, previous surgery, previous treatment, type of surgery, and the Charlson Comorbidity Index) with patient survival. Our cohort included 51 males and 38 females, with a median age at diagnosis of 61 years. The median tumor size at presentation was 5.9 cm. The 5-year overall survival (OS) and 5-year disease-free survival (DFS) rates were 90.8% and 54.9%, respectively. Partial SMARCB1/INI1 loss was identified in 37 (41.6%) patients with conventional spinal chordomas (27 mosaic and 10 clonal). The most frequent genetic alteration detected was the monoallelic deletion of a portion of the long arm of chromosome 22, which includes the SMARCB1 gene. Partial loss of SMARCB1/INI1 was correlated with cervical-thoracic-lumbar tumor location (p = 0.033) and inadequate surgical margins (p = 0.007), possibly due to the high degree of tumor invasiveness in this site. Among all the considered clinicopathological features related to patient survival, only tumor location in the sacrococcygeal region and adequate surgical margins positively impacted DFS. In conclusion, partial SMARCB1/INI1 loss, mostly due to 22q deletion, was detected in a significant number of patients with conventional spinal chordomas and was correlated with mobile spine location and inadequate surgical margins.

Poorly differentiated extra-axial extraskeletal chordoma diagnosed by methylation profiling: case report and analysis of brachyury expression in SWI/SNF-deficient tumors

Chordoma is a rare malignant tumor with notochordal differentiation, usually affecting the axial skeleton of young patients. We report a case of a high-grade epithelioid tumor involving the synovium and soft tissues of the knee in a 74-year-old male patient. The preliminary biopsy was inconclusive, but a diagnosis of metastatic clear-cell carcinoma of unknown origin was suggested. However, imaging studies did not reveal any primary lesions. The resection specimen consisted of nests and sheets of oval to polygonal cells with discernible cell borders, clear or lightly amphophilic cytoplasm, and round to oval nuclei with occasional well-visible eosinophilic nucleoli. Rare atypical mitoses, necrotic areas, and bizarre nuclei were noted. The biopsy and resection specimens underwent a wide molecular genetic analysis which included methylation profiling. The DKFZ sarcoma classifier assigned the methylation class chordoma (dedifferentiated) with a calibrated score of 0.96, and additionally, a loss of SMARCB1 locus was noted in the copy number variation plot. To verify these findings, T-brachyury and SMARCB1 immunostaining was performed afterward, showing diffuse nuclear positivity and complete loss in the tumor cells, respectively. To assess the prevalence of T-brachyury immunopositivity among SWI/SNF-deficient tumors and to evaluate its specificity for poorly differentiated chordoma, we analyzed a series of 23 SMARCB1- or SMARCA4-deficient tumors, all of which were negative. After incorporating all the available data, including the absence of any morphological features of conventional chordoma, the case was diagnosed as poorly differentiated chordoma. As illustrated herein, the utilization of methylation profiling in the diagnostic process of some carefully selected unclassifiable soft tissue neoplasms may lead to an increased detection rate of such extremely rare soft tissue tumors and enable their better characterization.

Translational Aspects of Epithelioid Sarcoma: Current Consensus

Epithelioid sarcoma (EpS) is an ultra-rare malignant soft-tissue cancer mostly affecting adolescents and young adults. EpS often exhibits an unfavorable clinical course with fatal outcome in ∼50% of cases despite aggressive multimodal therapies combining surgery, chemotherapy, and irradiation. EpS is traditionally classified in a more common, less aggressive distal (classic) type and a rarer aggressive proximal type. Both subtypes are characterized by a loss of nuclear INI1 expression, most often following homozygous deletion of its encoding gene, SMARCB1-a core subunit of the SWI/SNF chromatin remodeling complex. In 2020, the EZH2 inhibitor tazemetostat was the first targeted therapy approved for EpS, raising new hopes. Still, the vast majority of patients did not benefit from this drug or relapsed rapidly. Further, other recent therapeutic modalities, including immunotherapy, are only effective in a fraction of patients. Thus, novel strategies, specifically targeted to EpS, are urgently needed. To accelerate translational research on EpS and eventually boost the discovery and development of new diagnostic tools and therapeutic options, a vibrant translational research community has formed in past years and held two international EpS digital expert meetings in 2021 and 2023. This review summarizes our current understanding of EpS from the translational research perspective and points to innovative research directions to address the most pressing questions in the field, as defined by expert consensus and patient advocacy groups.

Current challenges and practical aspects of molecular pathology for bone and soft tissue tumors

This review shows the extraordinary change molecular pathology has induced in the classification, diagnosis, and clinical practice of molecular pathologists dealing with sarcomas. We have primarily focused on the practical aspects of molecular studies and the current and mid-term challenges for our subspecialty, ending with ten tips for the next generation of sarcoma molecular pathologists.

A Rare Case of Adult Poorly Differentiated Chordoma of the Skull Base With Rapid Progression and Systemic Metastasis: A Review of the Literature

Chordoma is a rare tumor that arises from chordal tissue during fetal life. Recently, the concept of poorly differentiated chordoma, a subtype of chordoma characterized by loss of SMARCB1/INI1 with a poorer prognosis than conventional chordomas, was established. It predominantly occurs in children and is rare in adults. Here, we report a rare adult case of poorly differentiated chordoma of the skull base with a unique course that rapidly systemically metastasized and had the shortest survival time of any adult chordoma reported to date. The patient was a 32-year-old male with a chief complaint of diplopia. MRI showed a widespread neoplastic lesion with the clivus as the main locus. Endoscopic extended transsphenoidal tumor resection was performed. Pathological findings showed that the tumor was malignant, and immunohistochemistry revealed a Ki-67 labeling index of 80%, diffusely positive brachyury, and loss of INI1 expression. The final diagnosis was poorly differentiated chordoma. Postoperatively, the residual tumor in the right cavernous sinus showed rapid growth. The patient was promptly treated with gamma knife three fractions. The residual tumor regressed, but the tumor developed systemic metastasis in a short period, and the patient died seven months after diagnosis. This report of a rapidly progressing and fatal adult poorly differentiated chordoma shows the highest Ki-67 labeling index reported to date. Prompt multidisciplinary treatment should be considered when the Ki-67 labeling index is high.

SMARCB1/INI1 loss in skull base conventional chordomas: a clinicopathological and molecular analysis

Introduction

The loss of SMARCB1/INI1 protein has been recently described in poorly differentiated chordoma, an aggressive and rare disease variant typically arising from the skull base.

Methods

Retrospective study aimed at 1) examining the differential immunohistochemical expression of SMARCB1/INI1 in conventional skull base chordomas, including the chondroid subtype; 2) evaluating SMARCB1 gene deletions/copy number gain; and 3) analyzing the association of SMARCB1/INI1 expression with clinicopathological parameters and patient survival.

Results

65 patients (35 men and 30 women) affected by conventional skull base chordoma, 15 with chondroid subtype, followed for >48 months after surgery were collected. Median age at surgery was 50 years old (range 9-79). Mean tumor size was 3.6 cm (range 2-9.5). At immunohistochemical evaluation, a partial loss of SMARCB1/INI1 (>10% of neoplastic examined cells) was observed in 21 (32.3%) cases; the remaining 43 showed a strong nuclear expression. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis was performed in 15/21 (71.4%) cases of the chordomas with partial SMARCB1/INI1 loss of expression. Heterozygous deletion of SMARCB1 was identified in 9/15 (60%) cases and was associated to copy number gain in one case; no deletion was found in the other 6 (40%) cases, 3 of which presenting with a copy number gain. No correlations were found between partial loss of SMARCB1/INI1 and the clinicopathological parameters evaluated (i.e., age, tumor size, gender, tumor size and histotype). Overall 5-year survival and 5-year disease-free rates were 82% and 59%, respectively. According to log-rank test analysis the various clinico-pathological parameters and SMARCB1/INI1 expression did not impact on overall and disease free-survival.

Discussion

Partial loss of SMARCB1/INI1, secondary to heterozygous deletion and/or copy number gain of SMARCB1, is not peculiar of aggressive forms, but can be identified by immunohistochemistry in a significant portion of conventional skull base chordomas, including the chondroid subtype. The variable protein expression does not appear to correlate with clinicopathological parameters, nor survival outcomes, but still, it could have therapeutic implications.

A chronicle review of new techniques that facilitate the understanding and development of optimal individualized therapeutic strategies for chordoma

Chordoma is a rare malignant bone tumor that mainly occurs in the sacrum and the clivus/skull base. Surgical resection is the treatment of choice for chordoma, but the local recurrence rate is high with unsatisfactory prognosis. Compared with other common tumors, there is not much research and individualized treatment for chordoma, partly due to the rarity of the disease and the lack of appropriate disease models, which delay the discovery of therapeutic strategies. Recent advances in modern techniques have enabled gaining a better understanding of a number of rare diseases, including chordoma. Since the beginning of the 21st century, various chordoma cell lines and animal models have been reported, which have partially revealed the intrinsic mechanisms of tumor initiation and progression with the use of next-generation sequencing (NGS) techniques. In this study, we performed a systematic overview of the chordoma models and related sequencing studies in a chronological manner, from the first patient-derived chordoma cell line (U-CH1) to diverse preclinical models such as the patient-derived organoid-based xenograft (PDX) and patient-derived organoid (PDO) models. The use of modern sequencing techniques has discovered mutations and expression signatures that are considered potential treatment targets, such as the expression of Brachyury and overactivated receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs). Moreover, computational and bioinformatics techniques have made drug repositioning/repurposing and individualized high-throughput drug screening available. These advantages facilitate the research and development of comprehensive and personalized treatment strategies for indicated patients and will dramatically improve their prognoses in the near feature.