Oncologic outcome in surgical management of jugular paraganglioma and factors influencing outcomes

Surgical results, technical notes and complications of jugular foramen lesions via retroauricular infratemporal fossa approach

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to evaluate the clinical effect and safety of the postauricular infratemporal fossa approach (ITFA) in resecting jugular foramen lesions.

METHODS

All 25 patients undergoing microsurgery via postauricular ITFA from March 2015 to May 2023 in the Department of Neurosurgery, Tangdu Hospital, Air Force Military Medical University were included. The clinical and radiological data were retrospectively analyzed. Regular follow-up was carried out.

RESULTS

The mean age of all patients was 50.5±8.9 years, and 14 of them were female and 11 were male. Among the cases, lower cranial nerve schwannoma accounted for 60 % (15/25) of all tumors, jugular foramen paraganglioma accounted for 20 % (5/25), and the remaining 20 % included meningioma, chondrosarcoma, plasmacytoma, and salivary gland tumors. Total tumor resection was performed in 18 cases, subtotal tumor resection in 7 cases and partial resection in 1 case. Seven patients underwent gamma knife radiotherapy after surgery. Transient lower cranial nerve dysfunction occurred in 8 patients, and permanent lower cranial nerve dysfunction occurred in 2 patients after surgery. One patient developed facial paralysis, and one patient presented hearing loss.

CONCLUSIONS

The postauricular ITFA achieved a relatively high total tumor resection rate and a lower incidence of neurological functional disorders. It is an alternative and suitable surgical approach for resecting jugular foramen lesions. Maximizing the preservation of neurological function is preferred, especially when radical resection cannot be achieved. Stereotactic radiotherapy could be used for residual tumors.

[Simultaneous occurrence of facial neurinoma in internal auditory canal and middle ear paraganglioma in patient. Unusual combination and difficult surgical task]

CLINICAL CASE

The 59-year-old patient complained of hearing loss on the left, ear murmur for a long time, periodic pain and discomfort in the left ear, dizziness for 6 months. She was found to have concurrent vestibular schwannoma in the internal auditory canal and temporal bone paraganglioma. Both tumors were removed in one operation. The schwannoma was removed by translabirinth access due to preoperative deafness, while the glomus tumor was removed during this access. Postoperative biopsy showed the presence of two unrelated diseases: paraganglioma (ICD-0 code 8690/3) and schwannoma (ICD-0 code 9560/0).

Modern Management of Complex Tympanojugular Paragangliomas: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

Tympanojugular paragangliomas (TJPs) are slow-growing tumors arising within the middle ear or jugular foramen. The development of modified skull base approaches and the increasing use of stereotactic radiosurgery have provided more modern techniques in the management of TJPs. Several factors dictating approach selection, and resulting clinical outcomes have been inconsistently described.

METHODS

A systematic review of the literature describing modern management of complex TJPs was performed and summarized. A random-effects meta-analysis was performed to describe the rate of tumor control, complications, and symptom improvement in patients undergoing radiosurgery or surgical resection.

RESULTS

Nineteen studies were identified with a total of 852 TJP patients. A minority (153 patients) underwent radiosurgery while 699 underwent surgery. On meta-analysis, there was a 3.5% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.5%-6.4%) tumor growth rate following radiosurgery and 3.9% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.8%-6.0%) recurrence rate in surgical resection, with no significant moderator effect between the 2 groups (P = 0.9046). Complication rate for radiosurgery was 7.6% (95% CI: 2.8%-12.4%), differing significantly from surgical complication rates of 29.6% (95% CI: 17.1-42.0%, P = 0.0418).

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic radiosurgery and surgical resection for TJPs have similar rates of tumor recurrence. Radiation is associated with less risk and lower morbidity, yet there is comparably modest reduction of the tumor size. In sum, the data suggest that radiosurgery is a reasonable management option for patients with minimal symptoms who are high risk for surgery. Microsurgical resection should be reserved for patients with lower cranial neuropathies or those who have failed radiation treatment.

Comparison of surgical outcomes between early and advanced class of jugular paragangliomas following application of our modified surgical techniques

To compare the safety and effectiveness of surgical treatment of jugular paragangliomas (JPs) following the application of our modified surgical techniques. Fifty-six patients with JPs were analyzed for tumor classification, surgical outcomes, and intratumor blood vessels. The gross total resection in C1-2 (100%) was significantly greater than that in C3 and D (66.7%). Good postoperative facial nerve (FN) function (House-Brackmann I-II) was achieved in 89.5% C1-2 cases, which was not significantly different from C3 and D (93.3%) (P = 0.694). Preoperative and postoperative lower cranial nerve (LCN) deficits correlated with the Fisch's classification of tumors (P < 0.05), and intraoperative blood loss was greater in advanced tumors (P = 0.050). Further study showed that the cross-sectional area of intratumor blood vessels was positively associated with intraoperative blood loss (P < 0.001). Surgical excision of JPs is a safe and effective strategy, and early surgical treatment is a good option for patients with C1-2 tumors without surgical contraindications.

Comparison of Lower Cranial Nerve Function Between Tympanojugular Paraganglioma Class C1/C2 With and Without Intracranial Extension: A Four-Decade Experience

OBJECTIVE

To compare preoperative and postoperative lower cranial nerve (LCN) function between Class C1 and C2 tympanojugular paraganglioma (TJP) with/without intracranial intradural (Di)/extradural (De) extensions, according to the experience of a single surgeon over four decades.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review.

SETTING

Quaternary referral center for otology and skull base surgery.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A chart review was conducted of all the patients operated for C1/C2 TJPs from September 1983 to December 2018. The tumors were classified as: Limited-Group (C1/C2 without Di/De extensions) and Extended-Group (C1/C2 with Di/De extensions).

RESULTS

Of 159 patients, 107 (67.3%) were women; the mean age at surgery was 46.5 years. The Limited-Group (56.6%) comprised C1 (41.1%) and C2 (58.9%) tumors; the Extended-Group (43.4%) comprised C1+Di/De (14.5%) and C2+Di/De (85.5%) tumors. The prevalence of preoperative LCN palsy was 11.9 times higher in Extended than Limited tumors: 61.9% versus 4.9% (p < 0.05). The risk for postoperative LCN palsy was 4.7 times greater in Extended than Limited tumors: 29.2% versus 12.9%, p = 0.01.

CONCLUSION

Especially in younger patients, complete removal of Limited C1/C2 tumors, before they extend intracranially, reduces the risk of dysfunctionality of LCNs and the burden of residual tumor. The incidence of new tumors increased over four decades. However, new-postoperative LCN palsy did not occur in any Limited C1/C2 tumors operated after the year 2000, and declined to less than 10% of Extended C1/C2 tumors.

Extracranial temporal bone paragangliomas: Re-defining the role of otologic surgery within the scope of function-preserving multimodal concepts

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this study was to present our concept in the management of extracranial temporal bone paragangliomas and demonstrate the outcome after primary surgical management of the middle ear component, with an individualized indication for adjuvant radiotherapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The records of all patients treated for extracranial jugulotympanic paragangliomas by means of primary surgical management between 2010 and 2021 were studied retrospectively.

RESULTS

Twenty-nine patients made up our study sample (mean age 58.8 years). 15 cases were managed solely by means of surgery. Out of the remaining 14 cases with reduction of the middle ear component, adjuvant irradiation was performed in 11 cases, whereas a wait-and-scan strategy was adopted at the patient's request in three cases. No further growth was detected in our study cases.

CONCLUSION

Our protocol seems to be associated with an acceptable quality of life and a satisfactory oncologic outcome.

The Application of Sigmoid Sinus Tunnel-packing or Push-packing of the Inferior Petrous Sinus in the Microsurgical Management of Jugular Paragangliomas

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the outcomes of microsurgically treated jugular paragangliomas with control of bleeding from the inferior petrous sinus.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective patient review.

SETTING

A single university hospital.

PATIENTS

Forty-three patients with jugular paragangliomas were diagnosed in the past 7 years in our clinic.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Surgical tumor control, intraoperative blood loss, intraoperative management of the facial nerve, and the preoperative and postoperative function of the lower central nerves.

RESULTS

Twenty-six patients underwent microsurgical treatment. Eighteen tumors were class C2 (69.2%), six were class C3 (23.1%), and two were class CDe1 (7.7%). Gross total tumor resection was achieved in 92.3% of the patients. The mean blood loss during surgery was 438.5 ml. The recurrence rate was 3.8% over a mean follow-up of 29.2 months. New facial palsy and lower cranial nerve deficit occurred in 42.3 and 11.5% of the patients, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The infratemporal fossa approach type A with sigmoid sinus tunnel-packing or push-packing technique facilitated the control of bleeding from the inferior petrous sinus and improved the outcomes of microsurgical treatment for jugular paragangliomas.

Surgery of the lateral skull base: a 50-year endeavour

Disregarding the widely used division of skull base into anterior and lateral, since the skull base should be conceived as a single anatomic structure, it was to our convenience to group all those approaches that run from the antero-lateral, pure lateral and postero-lateral side of the skull base as “Surgery of the lateral skull base”. “50 years of endeavour” points to the great effort which has been made over the last decades, when more and more difficult surgeries were performed by reducing morbidity. The principle of lateral skull base surgery, “remove skull base bone to approach the base itself and the adjacent sites of the endo-esocranium”, was then combined with function preservation and with tailoring surgery to the pathology. The concept that histology dictates the extent of resection, balancing the intrinsic morbidity of each approach was the object of the first section of the present report. The main surgical approaches were described in the second section and were conceived not as a step-by-step description of technique, but as the highlighthening of the surgical principles. The third section was centered on open issues related to the tumor and its treatment. The topic of vestibular schwannoma was investigated with the current debate on observation, hearing preservation surgery, hearing rehabilitation, radiotherapy and the recent efforts to detect biological markers able to predict tumor growth. Jugular foramen paragangliomas were treated in the frame of radical or partial surgery, radiotherapy, partial “tailored” surgery and observation. Surgery on meningioma was debated from the point of view of the neurosurgeon and of the otologist. Endolymphatic sac tumors and malignant tumors of the external auditory canal were also treated, as well as chordomas, chondrosarcomas and petrous bone cholesteatomas. Finally, the fourth section focused on free-choice topics which were assigned to aknowledged experts. The aim of this work was attempting to report the state of the art of the lateral skull base surgery after 50 years of hard work and, above all, to raise questions on those issues which still need an answer, as to allow progress in knowledge through sharing of various experiences. At the end of the reading, if more doubts remain rather than certainties, the aim of this work will probably be achieved.

Head and neck paragangliomas: A two-decade institutional experience and algorithm for management

Objectives

Paragangliomas of the head and neck and cranial base are typically benign, slow‐growing tumors arising within the jugular foramen, middle ear, carotid bifurcation, or vagus nerve proper. The objective of this study was to provide a comprehensive characterization of our institutional experience with clinical management of these tumors and posit an algorithm for diagnostic evaluation and treatment.

Methods

This was a retrospective cohort study of patients undergoing treatment for paragangliomas of the head and neck and cranial base at our institution from 2000–2017. Data on tumor location, catecholamine levels, and specific imaging modalities employed in diagnostic work‐up, pre‐treatment cranial nerve palsy, treatment modality, utilization of preoperative angiographic embolization, complications of treatment, tumor control and recurrence, and hereditary status (ie, succinate dehydrogenase mutations) were collected and summarized.

Results

The mean (SD) age of our cohort was 51.8 (±16.1) years with 123 (63.4%) female patients and 71 (36.6%) male patients. Catecholamine‐secreting lesions were found in nine (4.6%) patients. Fifty‐one patients underwent genetic testing, with mutations identified in 43 (20 SDHD, 13 SDHB, 7 SDHD, 1 SDHA, SDHAF2, and NF1). Observation with serial imaging, surgical extirpation, radiation, and stereotactic radiosurgery were variably employed as treatment approaches across anatomic subsites.

Conclusion

An algorithmic approach to clinical management of these tumors, derived from our longitudinal institutional experience and current empiric evidence, may assist otolaryngologists, radiation oncologists, and geneticists in the care of these complex neoplasms.

Level of Evidence

4

Comparative Neurologic Outcomes of Salvage and Definitive Gamma Knife Radiosurgery for Glomus Jugulare: A 20-Year Experience

Objective  This case series investigates management of glomus jugulare (GJ) tumors utilizing definitive and salvage Gamma Knife stereotactic radiosurgery (GKSRS). Methods  A retrospective chart review was performed to collect data. Statistical analysis included patient, tumor, and treatment information. Results  From 1996 to 2013, 17 patients with GJ received GKSRS. Median age was 64 years (range, 27-76). GKSRS was delivered for definitive treatment in eight (47%) and salvage in nine (53%) patients. Median tumor volume was 9.8 cm ³ (range, 2.8-42 cm ³ ). Median dose was 15 Gy (range, 13-18 Gy). Median follow-up was 123 months (range, 38-238 months). Tumor size decreased in 10 (59%), stabilized in 6 (35%), and increased in 1 patient (6%). Overall neurological deficit improved in 53%, stabilized in 41%, and worsened in 6% of patients. Overall cause-specific survival was 100%, and actuarial local control was 94%. Eighty-eight percent of patients without prior resection experienced neurologic deficit improvement, while 25% of patients with prior resection experienced neurologic improvement ( p  = 0.02). Conclusion  Gamma Knife radiosurgery provides effective long-term control of GJ and overall improvement or stabilization of neurological deficit in most patients. Patients with prior resection are less likely to experience improvement of neurologic deficit.

Jugulotympanic paragangliomas in southern Finland: a 40-year experience suggests individualized surgical management

Treatment of jugulotympanic paragangliomas (JTPGLs) remains challenging with no clear guidelines for management or follow-up. The aim of this retrospective case-note study was to assess long-term results of operatively and conservatively managed JTPGLs between years 1974-2013. A total of 36 patients with JTPGLs were identified. Clinical characteristics and management outcomes of patients were reviewed. Data were extracted on demographics, symptoms, timing of diagnosis, tumor location and size, embolization, and management, including pre- and post-operative imaging, analysis of operative techniques, and follow-up. Pulsatile tinnitus and hearing loss were the most common presenting symptoms. Thirty-four (94 %) patients were treated with primary surgical therapy and two (6 %) with radiotherapy. The surgical approaches included endaural approach for Fisch Class A tumors and a variety of approaches for Fisch Class B-D tumors with an increasing predilection for function-preserving surgery. Eight (24 %) patients received subtotal resection. Five (15 %) patients had a local recurrence within 10 years after primary surgery. Two (6 %) patients suffered a permanent cranial nerve (CN) deficit after primary surgery. We advocate radical surgery when tumor resection is possible without compromising CNs. Function-preserving surgery with at least a 10-year follow-up for Fisch Class B-D tumors should be considered if CNs are in danger.

Less-aggressive surgical management and long-term outcomes of jugular foramen paragangliomas: a neurosurgical perspective

OBJECTIVE The aim of this study was to analyze the neurological functional outcome and recurrent risks in surgically treated jugular foramen paragangliomas (JFPs) and to propose an individualized therapeutic strategy. METHODS Clinical charts and radiological information were reviewed retrospectively in 51 consecutive cases of JFPs. Less-aggressive surgical interventions were adopted with the goal of preserving neurovascular structures. Scheduled follow-up was performed. RESULTS The mean age of the patients in the cases reviewed was 41.6 years, and the group included 27 females (52.9%). The mean preoperative Karnofsky Performance Scale (KPS) score was 78.4. The mean lesion size was 3.8 cm. Forty-three cases (84.3%) were Fisch Type D, including 37 cases (72.5%) of Type Di1 and Di2. Thirty-seven cases (72.5%) were Glasscock-Jackson Type III-IV. Gross-total resection and subtotal resection were achieved in 26 (51.0%) and 22 (43.1%) cases, respectively. Surgical morbidities occurred in 23 patients (45.1%), without surgery-related mortality after the first operation. The mean postoperative KPS scores at discharge, 3 months, 1 year, and most recent evaluation were 71.8, 77.2, 83.2, and 79.6, respectively. The mean follow-up duration was 85.7 months. The tumor recurrence/regrowth (R/R) rate was 11.8%. Compared with preoperative status, swallowing function improved or stabilized in 96.1% and facial function improved or stabilized in 94.1% of patients. A House-Brackmann scale Grade I/II was achieved in 43 patients (84.3%). Overall neurological status improved or stabilized in 90.0% of patients. Pathological mitosis (HR 10.640, p = 0.009) was the most significant risk for tumor R/R. A 1-year increase in age (OR 1.115, p = 0.037) and preoperative KPS score < 80 (OR 11.071, p = 0.018) indicated a risk for recent poor neurological function (KPS < 80). Overall R/R-free survival, symptom progression-free survival, and overall survival at 15 years were 78.9%, 86.8%, and 80.6%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS Surgical outcomes for JFPs were acceptable using a less-aggressive surgical strategy. Most patients could adapt to surgical morbidities and carry out normal life activities. Preserving neurological function was a priority, and maximal decompression with or without radiotherapy was desirable to preserve a patient's quality of life when radical resection was not warranted. Early surgery plus preoperative devascularization was proposed, and radiotherapy was mandatory for lesions with pathological mitosis.

Systemic Inflammatory Syndrome Associated with a Case of Jugular Paraganglioma

Jugular paraganlioma is a benign, slow-growing tumor originating from the paraganglion cells and it is associated with catecholamine secretion. Paragangliomas can secrete Interleukin-6 (IL-6) and present as a systemic inflammatory syndrome; these characteristics have not been previously associated with jugular paragangliomas. A 63-year-old man with a jugular tumor in the skull base was referred to our hospital for an evaluation of pyrexia, back pain, and acute inflammation. His serum IL-6 level was elevated on admission and it decreased after radiotherapy. This is the first known case of a jugular paraganglioma exhibiting systemic inflammatory syndrome.

Lower cranial nerves function after surgical treatment of Fisch Class C and D tympanojugular paragangliomas

The aim of this study was to report the postoperative lower cranial nerves (LCNs) function in patients undergoing surgery for tympanojugular paraganglioma (TJP) and to evaluate risk factors for postoperative LCN dysfunction. A retrospective case review of 122 patients having Fisch class C or D TJP, surgically treated from 1988 to 2012, was performed. The follow-up of the series ranged from 12 to 156 months (mean, 39.4 ± 32.6 months). The infratemporal type A approach was the most common surgical procedure. Gross total tumor removal was achieved in 86% of cases. Seventy-two percent of the 54 patients with preoperative LCN deficit had intracranial tumor extension. Intraoperatively, LCNs had to be sacrificed in 63 cases (51.6%) due to tumor infiltration. Sixty-six patients (54.09%) developed a new deficit of one or more of the LCNs. Of those patients who developed new LCN deficits, 23 of them had intradural extension. Postoperative follow-up of at least 1 year showed that the LCN most commonly affected was the CN IX (50%). Logistic regression analysis showed that intracranial transdural tumor extension was correlated with the higher risk of LCN sacrifice (p < 0.05). Despite the advances in skull base surgery, new postoperative LCN deficits still represent a challenge. The morbidity associated with resection of the LCNs is dependent on the tumor's size and intradural tumor extension. Though no recovery of LCN deficits may be expected, on long-term follow-up, patients usually compensate well for their LCNs loss.