Programming of a repressed but committed chromatin structure during early development

Zygotic gene activation in mice: profile and regulation

The zygotic genome is transcriptionally silent immediately after fertilization. In mice, initial activation of the zygotic genome occurs in the middle of the one-cell stage. At the mid-to-late two-cell stage, a burst of gene activation occurs after the second round of DNA replication, and the profile of transcribed genes changes dramatically. These two phases of gene activation are called minor and major zygotic gene activation (ZGA), respectively. As they mark the beginning of the gene expression program, it is important to elucidate gene expression regulation during these stages. This article reviews the outcomes of studies that have clarified the profiles and regulatory mechanisms of ZGA.

Control of zygotic genome activation in Xenopus

The fertilized frog egg contains all the materials needed to initiate development of a new organism, including stored RNAs and proteins deposited during oogenesis, thus the earliest stages of development do not require transcription. The onset of transcription from the zygotic genome marks the first genetic switch activating the gene regulatory network that programs embryonic development. Zygotic genome activation occurs after an initial phase of transcriptional quiescence that continues until the midblastula stage, a period called the midblastula transition, which was first identified in Xenopus. Activation of transcription is programmed by maternally supplied factors and is regulated at multiple levels. A similar switch exists in most animals and is of great interest both to developmental biologists and to those interested in understanding nuclear reprogramming. Here we review in detail our knowledge on this major switch in transcription in Xenopus and place recent discoveries in the context of a decades old problem.

Zygotic Genome Activation in Vertebrates

The first major developmental transition in vertebrate embryos is the maternal-to-zygotic transition (MZT) when maternal mRNAs are degraded and zygotic transcription begins. During the MZT, the embryo takes charge of gene expression to control cell differentiation and further development. This spectacular organismal transition requires nuclear reprogramming and the initiation of RNAPII at thousands of promoters. Zygotic genome activation (ZGA) is mechanistically coordinated with other embryonic events, including changes in the cell cycle, chromatin state, and nuclear-to-cytoplasmic component ratios. Here, we review progress in understanding vertebrate ZGA dynamics in frogs, fish, mice, and humans to explore differences and emphasize common features.

Competition between histone and transcription factor binding regulates the onset of transcription in zebrafish embryos

Upon fertilization, the genome of animal embryos remains transcriptionally inactive until the maternal-to-zygotic transition. At this time, the embryo takes control of its development and transcription begins. How the onset of zygotic transcription is regulated remains unclear. Here, we show that a dynamic competition for DNA binding between nucleosome-forming histones and transcription factors regulates zebrafish genome activation. Taking a quantitative approach, we found that the concentration of non-DNA-bound core histones sets the time for the onset of transcription. The reduction in nuclear histone concentration that coincides with genome activation does not affect nucleosome density on DNA, but allows transcription factors to compete successfully for DNA binding. In agreement with this, transcription factor binding is sensitive to histone levels and the concentration of transcription factors also affects the time of transcription. Our results demonstrate that the relative levels of histones and transcription factors regulate the onset of transcription in the embryo.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.23326.001

The DNA in a fertilized egg contains all the information required to form an animal’s body. In order for the animal to develop properly, particular genes encoded in the DNA are only active at specific times. The DNA is wrapped around proteins called histones, which allows the DNA to be tightly packed inside the cell. However, histones can block other proteins called transcription factors from binding to the DNA to activate the genes. Young embryos initially develop with all of their genes switched off, relying on the nutrients and other molecules provided by their mother. After some time, the embryo starts to switch on its own genes to take control of its own development, but it was not clear how this happens.

Joseph et al. investigated how genes are activated in zebrafish embryos, which are often used as models to study how animals develop. The experiments show that competition between histones and transcription factors for binding to DNA controls when genes are switched on. In young fish embryos, there are so many histones present that transcription factors have no opportunity to bind to DNA. Over time, however, the numbers of histones decrease, allowing transcription factors to bind to DNA and switch on genes.

Histones and transcription factors regulate the activity of genes throughout the life of the animal. Therefore, competition between these two types of protein may also control gene activity in other situations. A better understanding of how gene activity is controlled could allow researchers to more easily grow different types of cell in the laboratory or to reprogram specific cells in the body. As such, these new findings may aid the development of therapies to regenerate organs or tissues that have been damaged by injury or disease.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.23326.002

The timing of zygotic genome activation

After fertilization, the embryonic genome is inactive until transcription is initiated during the maternal-to-zygotic transition. How the onset of transcription is regulated in a precisely timed manner, however, is a long standing question in biology. Several mechanisms have been shown to contribute to the temporal regulation of genome activation but none of them can fully explain the general absence of transcription as well the gene specific onset that follows. Here we review the work that has been done toward elucidating the mechanisms underlying the temporal regulation of transcription in embryos.

The epigenome in early vertebrate development

Epigenetic regulation defines the commitment and potential of cells, including the limitations in their competence to respond to inducing signals. This review discusses the developmental origins of chromatin state in Xenopus and other vertebrate species and provides an overview of its use in genome annotation. In most metazoans the embryonic genome is transcriptionally quiescent after fertilization. This involves nucleosome-dense chromatin, repressors and a temporal deficiency in the transcription machinery. Active histone modifications such as H3K4me3 appear in pluripotent blastula embryos, whereas repressive marks such as H3K27me3 show a major increase in enrichment during late blastula and gastrula stages. The H3K27me3 modification set by Polycomb restricts ectopic lineage-specific gene expression. Pluripotent chromatin in Xenopus embryos is relatively unconstrained, whereas the pluripotent cell lineage in mammalian embryos harbors a more enforced type of pluripotent chromatin.

Nuclear reprogramming: the zygotic transcription program is established through an “erase-and-rebuild” strategy

Oocytes display a maternal-specific gene expression profile, which is switched to a zygotic profile when a haploid set of chromatin is passed on to the fertilized egg that develops into an embryo. The mechanism underlying this transcription reprogramming is currently unknown. Here we demonstrate that by the time when transcription is shut down in germinal vesicle oocytes, a range of general transcription factors and transcriptional regulators are dissociated from the chromatin. The global dissociation of chromatin factors (CFs) disrupts physical contacts between the chromatin and CFs and leads to erasure of the maternal transcription program at the functional level. Critical transcription factors and regulators remain separated from chromatin for a prolonged period, and become re-associated with chromatin shortly after pronuclear formation. This is followed temporally by the re-establishment of nuclear functions such as DNA replication and transcription. We propose that the maternal transcription program is erased during oogenesis to generate a relatively naïve chromatin and the zygotic transcription program is rebuilt de novo after fertilization. This process is termed as the "erase-and-rebuild" process, which is used to reset the transcription program, and most likely other nuclear processes as well, from a maternal one to that of the embryo. We further show in the accompanying paper (Gao T, et al., Cell Res 2007; 17: 135-150.) that the same strategy is also employed to reprogram transcriptional profiles in somatic cell nuclear transfer and parthenogenesis, suggesting that this model is universally applicable to all forms of transcriptional reprogramming during early embryogenesis. Displacement of CFs from chromatin also offers an explanation for the phenomenon of transcription silence during the maternal to zygotic transition.

DNA replication initiates at domains overlapping with nuclear matrix attachment regions in the xenopus and mouse c-myc promoter

Only a very few origins have been mapped in different multicellular organisms, and they do not share detectable consensus sequence elements. Moreover, it is not clear if origins are localized at similar positions in the corresponding locus in genomes of different organisms. Here, we have mapped DNA replication origins in the c-myc locus both in Xenopus and mouse, allowing a comparison of the corresponding sites in three different animal species (Xenopus, mouse, human). An origin of DNA replication is present in the three homologous c-myc loci. In Xenopus, a main DNA replication origin was located 3 kilobases (kb) upstream of the active c-myc promoter, whereas, in mouse, we detected an origin 1 kb upstream of the promoter, as previously mapped in human c-myc. We also identified a nuclear matrix attachment region in both Xenopus and mouse, which is localized to two different regions of the c-myc promoter region. However, in both cases, the nuclear matrix attachment sites are close to the DNA replication origin mapped in the locus. These data suggest that global features of chromatin organization in different organisms may contribute to DNA replication origin localization.

Specification of a DNA replication origin by a transcription complex

In early Xenopus development, transcription is repressed and DNA replication initiates at non-specific sites. Here, we show that a site-specific DNA replication origin can be induced in this context by the assembly of a transcription domain. Deletion of the promoter element abolishes site-specific initiation, and its relocalization to an ectopic site induces a new origin of replication. This process does not require active transcription, and specification of the origin occurs mainly through a decrease in non-specific initiation at sites distant from the promoter. Finally, chromatin immunoprecipitation experiments suggest that site-specific acetylation of histones favours the selection of the active DNA replication origin. We propose that the specification of active DNA replication origins occurs by secondary epigenetic events and that the programming of chromatin for transcription during development contributes to this selection in higher eukaryotes.

Cyclin-dependent kinase 8 is expressed both maternally and zygotically during zebrafish embryo development

Cyclin-dependent kinase 8 (cdk8) regulates transcription by phosphorylating RNA polymerase II and TFIIH. The mechanism of zygotic transcription activation during vertebrate embryonic development is poorly understood. Here we describe the cloning and developmental expression pattern of zebrafish cdk8 mRNA. It is highly conserved, sharing 79% DNA and 95% amino acid sequence identity with human cdk8, thereby indicating an important role for the protein. Northern blotting and whole mount in situ hybridisation revealed expression of zebrafish cdk8 maternally, following the onset of zygotic transcription at the mid-blastula transition (MBT) and throughout embryonic development.

Incomplete RNA polymerase II phosphorylation in Xenopus laevis early embryos

Phosphorylation of RNA polymerase II largest subunit on its C-terminal domain (CTD) heptapeptide repeats has been shown to play a key role in the regulation of mRNA synthesis and processing. In many higher metazoans, early embryos do not synthesise mRNAs during the first cell cycles following fertilisation. Transcription resumes and becomes an absolute requirement for development after several cell cycles characteristic of each species. Therefore, CTD phosphorylation has been investigated during early development of the African clawed-frog Xenopus laevis. Fertilisation is shown to trigger an abrupt dephosphorylation of the CTD. Phosphorylation of the CTD resumes concurrently with the mid-blastula transition (MBT). Both are advanced with polyspermy and increased temperatures; they do not occur when replication is impaired with aphidicolin. In Xenopus laevis somatic cells, a set of monoclonal antibodies defined distinct phosphoepitopes on the CTD. Two of them were absent before the MBT indicating that the CTD lacks the phosphorylation at the serine-2 position of the heptapeptide. The possible contribution of RNA polymerase II phosphorylation to the developmental-regulation of maternal mRNA processing in embryos is discussed.

TBP is not universally required for zygotic RNA polymerase II transcription in zebrafish

General transcription factors TFIIA, B, D, E, F, H, and RNA polymerase II (Pol II) are required for accurate initiation of Pol II transcription. The TATA binding protein (TBP), a subunit of TFIID, is responsible for recognition of the TATA box, a core element shared by a category of class II promoters [1]. Recently, novel TBP-like factors (TLFs) have been described in metazoan organisms [2]. In spite of the numerous in vitro studies describing the general role of TBP in RNA polymerase II (Pol lI) transcription initiation, the precise function of TBP and the newly described TLF is poorly understood in vivo. We inhibited TBP and TLF function in zebrafish embryos to study the role of these factors during zygotic transcription. A dominant-negative variant of TLF mRNA and a TBP morpholino antisense oligo was used to block either TLF or TBP function. Both TBP- or TLF-blocked embryos developed normally until the midblastula stage; however, they then failed to gastrulate. Several zygotic regulatory genes were downregulated by a block in either TBP or TLF function, while others were differentially affected. These results suggest that TBP is not universally required for Pol II transcription in vertebrates and that there is a differential requirement for TBP and TLF during early embryogenesis.

Analysis of HIV-1 Tat effects in Xenopus laevis embryos

Tat is one of the regulatory proteins of the HIV-1 virus. To date, besides the transactivation activity, a myriad of effects exerted by HIV-1 Tat on cellular and viral genes have been observed. The present study investigated the in vivo effects of HIV-1 Tat protein in the Xenopus embryo. We adopted the Xenopus system since expression of putative regulatory factors in the embryo has been widely used as a quick and effective first screen for protein function. Xenopus' early development is well characterized by stage-specific phenotypes, therefore, an in vivo HIV-1 Tat-mediated aberrant phenotype can easily be detected and analyzed. HIV-1 Tat protein expression through injection of synthetic mRNA into zygotes produced a marked delay in gastrulation leading to altered specification of the anterior-posterior axis and to partial or total loss of anterior structures. HIV-1 Tat effects resulted in a general suppression of gene expression, including that of Xbra and gsc, two early genes whose expression is required for proper gastrulation. The specificity of Tat effects was demonstrated by injecting a 'loss of function' mutant (Tat-C37S), lacking a single cysteine residue, which did not yield any effect. Both Tat and Tat-C37S were found to be localized mainly in the nucleus. The importance of subcellular targeting for the effects caused by HIV-1 Tat was demonstrated by injecting a second mutant (Tat-BDM), carrying an altered nuclear localization signal sequence. The Tat-BDM protein localized in the cytoplasm and accumulated at the cell membrane. Embryos injected with Tat-BDM mRNA did not develop beyond gastrulation. The importance of proper protein conformation and subcellular localization in determining Tat effects is discussed.

The mouse mammary tumor virus promoter adopts distinct chromatin structures in human breast cancer cells with and without glucocorticoid receptor

Steroid receptors represent a class of transcription regulators that act in part by overcoming the often repressive nature of chromatin to modulate gene activity. The mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter is a useful model for studying transcriptional regulation by steroid hormone receptors in the context of chromatin. The chromatin architecture of the promoter prevents the assembly of basal transcription machinery and binding of ubiquitous transcription factors. However, in human breast carcinoma T47D cells lacking the glucocorticoid receptor (GR), but expressing the progesterone receptor (PR), nucleosome B (nuc B) assumes a constitutively hypersensitive chromatin structure. This correlation led us to test the hypothesis that the chromatin structure of nuc B was dependent on GR expression in T47D cells. To examine this possibility, we stably co-transfected the MMTV promoter and the GR into T47D cells that lacked both the GR and the PR. We found that in T47D cells that lack both the GR and the PR or express only the GR, nuc B assumes a constitutively "open" chromatin structure, which allows hormone independent access by restriction endonucleases and transcription factors. These results suggest that in GR(+)/pr(-) T47D cells, the MMTV chromatin structure permits GR transcriptional activation, independent of chromatin remodeling.

Control of gene expression in Xenopus early development

We examine the control of gene expression before and through the MBT in Xenopus laevis. The generalized repression of transcription that occurs before the midblastula transition (MBT) is regulated by a dynamic competition between chromatin and transcription complex assembly. Conditions favoring the access of basal factors (TBP) or transactivators can overcome this transcriptional repression. Changes in DNase I hypersensitivity patterns of the chromatin during early development show that it is more accessible to DNase I before the MBT (and by extension to other DNA interacting proteins) than after the MBT. We also show that at the level of genomic domains, organization of the chromatin matrix attachment sites is random before MBT. We propose that these three components, chromatin domain structure, DNA accessibility, and the transcription complex-chromatin dynamic competition, combine to regulate transcription in the embryo before and through the MBT.

Rearrangement of chromatin domains during development in Xenopus

A dynamic change in the organization of different gene domains transcribed by RNA polymerase I, II, or III occurs during the progression from quiescent [pre-midblastula transition (pre-MBT)] to active (post-MBT) embryos during Xenopus development. In the rDNA, c-myc, and somatic 5S gene domains, a transition from random to specific anchorage to the nuclear matrix occurs when chromatin domains become active. The keratin gene domain was also randomly associated to the nuclear matrix before MBT, whereas a defined attachment site was found in keratinocytes. In agreement with this specification, ligation-mediated (LM)-PCR genomic footprinting carried out on the subpopulation of 5S domains specifically attached to the matrix reveals the hallmarks of determined chromatin after the midblastula transition. In contrast, the same analysis performed on the total 5S gene population does not reveal specific chromatin organization, validating the use of nuclear matrix fractionation to unveil active chromatin domains. These data provide a means for the determination of active chromosomal territories in the embryo and emphasize the role of nuclear architecture in regulated gene expression during development.

Rearrangement of chromatin domains during development in Xenopus

A dynamic change in the organization of different gene domains transcribed by RNA polymerase I, II, or III occurs during the progression from quiescent [pre-midblastula transition (pre-MBT)] to active (post-MBT) embryos during Xenopus development. In the rDNA, c-myc, and somatic 5S gene domains, a transition from random to specific anchorage to the nuclear matrix occurs when chromatin domains become active. The keratin gene domain was also randomly associated to the nuclear matrix before MBT, whereas a defined attachment site was found in keratinocytes. In agreement with this specification, ligation-mediated (LM)-PCR genomic footprinting carried out on the subpopulation of 5S domains specifically attached to the matrix reveals the hallmarks of determined chromatin after the midblastula transition. In contrast, the same analysis performed on the total 5S gene population does not reveal specific chromatin organization, validating the use of nuclear matrix fractionation to unveil active chromatin domains. These data provide a means for the determination of active chromosomal territories in the embryo and emphasize the role of nuclear architecture in regulated gene expression during development.

Translation of maternal TATA-binding protein mRNA potentiates basal but not activated transcription in Xenopus embryos at the midblastula transition

Early embryonic development in Xenopus laevis is characterized by transcriptional repression which is relieved at the midblastula stage (MBT). Here we show that the relative abundance of TATA-binding protein (TBP) increases robustly at the MBT and that the mechanism underlying this increase is translation of maternally stored TBP RNA. We show that TBP is rate-limiting in egg extract under conditions that titrate nucleosome assembly. Precocious translation of TBP mRNA in Xenopus embryos facilitates transcription before the MBT, without requiring TBP to be prebound to the promoter before injection. This effect is transient in the absence of chromatin titration and is sustained when chromatin is titrated. These data show that translational regulation of TBP RNA contributes to limitations on the transcriptional capacity before the MBT. Second, we examined the ability of trans-acting factors to contribute to promoter activity before the MBT. Deletion of cis-acting elements does not affect histone H2B transcription in egg extract, a finding indicative of limited trans-activation. Moreover, in the context of the intact promoter, neither the transcriptional activator Oct-1, nor TBP, nor TFIID enable transcriptional activation in vitro. HeLa cell extract, however, reconstitutes activated transcription in mixed extracts. These data suggest a deficiency in egg extract cofactors required for activated transcription. We show that the capacity for activated H2B transcription is gradually acquired at the early gastrula transition. This transition occurs well after the blastula stage when the basal transcription machinery can first be complemented with TBP.

Inhibition of transcription of class II, but not class III and I, genes in Xenopus postblastular embryos overexpressed with the TBP-binding protein, Dr1 (NC2beta)

Dr1 (NC2beta) is known to effectively repress transcription of class II genes, and much less effectively class III genes, but not class I genes through its binding to the TATA-binding protein (TBP), which is the major component of the basal transcription factor for polymerases II, III, and I. Previously, we isolated Xenopus Dr1 cDNA, and demonstrated that its mRNA is transcribed in oocytes and is inherited into early embryos, but its level decreases in later stages. Here, we overexpressed Xenopus Dr1 in Xenopus embryos and, found that the overexpression significantly reduces the levels of poly(A), cytoskeletal actin and histone H4 mRNAs, and the labeling of heterogeneous mRNA-like RNA in postblastular embryos, without affecting tRNA and rRNA syntheses. These results indicate that the overexpressed Dr1 specifically down-regulates the transcription of class II, but not class III and I, genes, and suggest that Dr1 plays an important role in the control of transcription in Xenopus embryogenesis.

Maternal histone deacetylase is accumulated in the nuclei of Xenopus oocytes as protein complexes with potential enzyme activity

Reversible acetylation of core histones plays an important regulatory role in transcription and replication of chromatin. The acetylation status of chromatin is determined by the equilibrium between activities of histone acetyltransferases (HATs) and histone deacetylases (HDACs). The Xenopus protein HDACm shows sequence homology to other putative histone deacetylases, but its mRNA is expressed only during early development. Both HDACm protein and acetylated non-chromosomal histones are accumulated in developing oocytes, indicating that the key components for histone deposition into new chromatin during blastula formation are in place by the end of oogenesis. Here we show that the 57 kDa HDACm protein undergoes steady accumulation in the nucleus, where it is organized in a multiprotein complex of approx. 300 kDa. A second, major component of the nuclear complex is the retinoblastoma-associated protein p48 (RbAp48/46), which may be used as an adaptor to contact acetylated histones in newly assembled chromatin. The nuclear complex has HDAC activity that is sensitive to trichostatin A, zinc ions and phosphatase treatment. The 57 kDa protein serves as a marker for total HDAC activity throughout oogenesis and early embryogenesis. The active HDACm complex and its acetylated histone substrates appear to be kept apart until after chromatin assembly has taken place. However, recombinant HDACm, injected into the cytoplasm of oocytes, not only is translocated to the nucleus, but also is free to interact with the endogenous chromatin.

Transcriptional repression by XPc1, a new Polycomb homolog in Xenopus laevis embryos, is independent of histone deacetylase

The Polycomb group (Pc-G) genes encode proteins that assemble into complexes implicated in the epigenetic maintenance of heritable patterns of expression of developmental genes, a function largely conserved from Drosophila to mammals and plants. The Pc-G is thought to act at the chromatin level to silence expression of target genes; however, little is known about the molecular basis of this repression. In keeping with the evidence that Pc-G homologs in higher vertebrates exist in related pairs, we report here the isolation of XPc1, a second Polycomb homolog in Xenopus laevis. We show that XPc1 message is maternally deposited in a translationally masked form in Xenopus oocytes, with XPc1 protein first appearing in embryonic nuclei shortly after the blastula stage. XPc1 acts as a transcriptional repressor in vivo when tethered to a promoter in Xenopus embryos. We find that XPc1-mediated repression can be only partially alleviated by an increase in transcription factor dosage and that inhibition of deacetylase activity by trichostatin A treatment has no effect on XPc1 repression, suggesting that histone deacetylation does not form the basis for Pc-G-mediated repression in our assay.

Developmental changes in RNA polymerase I and TATA box-binding protein during early Xenopus embryogenesis

Xenopus early embryos are transcriptionally quiescent until the midblastula transition (MBT). We have examined the question of whether the absence of rRNA synthesis is related to a deficiency in the RNA polymerase I (pol I) transcription machinery. Previously we have demonstrated that the maternally provided pol I transcription factor UBF already binds to the inactive rRNA genes of pre-MBT embryos (P. Bell et al., 1997, J. Cell Sci. 110, 2053-2063). Here we have analyzed the fate of pol I and the TATA box-binding protein (TBP) through immunofluorescence and immunoblotting experiments. Pol I stockpiled in the egg is taken up by in vitro assembled pronuclei and concentrated into numerous distinct nuclear domains. Comparable storage sites of template-free pol I are also seen in nuclei of blastula to neurula stage embryos. In contrast, the amount of TBP is relatively low in oocytes and eggs but increases dramatically during the cleavage stages. Most of the newly synthesized TBP colocalizes with the stored form of pol I in the extranucleolar domains of blastula/gastrula embryos. The amount of TBP per embryo reaches peak values at the blastula/gastrula stage and then rapidly declines to normal somatic levels. The positive correlation of maximal TBP levels with the timing of the MBT suggests that overproduction of TBP is required for the formation of productive transcription complexes.

The Oct-1 POU domain directs developmentally regulated nuclear translocation in Xenopus embryos

Early embryonic development in Xenopus is characterized by transcriptional repression which is relieved at the mid-blastula stage. Here we show that most of the maternally inherited POU domain transcription factor Oct-1 is retained in the cytoplasm during early development, and that it gradually translocates to the nucleus around the mid-blastula transition. Overexpressed epitope-tagged Oct-1 exhibits highly similar localization properties compared to endogenous protein. The amino acid sequence that directs this developmentally regulated nuclear translocation resides in the POU domain. Our findings may suggest that cytoplasmic retention of Oct-1 facilitates or contributes to the repression of Oct-1 target genes before the mid-blastula transition.