Comparison of bovine and porcine beta-lactoglobulin: a mass spectrometric analysis

Native mass spectrometry for the investigation of protein structural (dis)order

A central challenge in structural biology is represented by dynamic and heterogeneous systems, as typically represented by proteins in solution, with the extreme case of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) [1-3]. These proteins lack a specific three-dimensional structure and have poorly organized secondary structure. For these reasons, they escape structural characterization by conventional biophysical methods. The investigation of these systems requires description of conformational ensembles, rather than of unique, defined structures or bundles of largely superimposable structures. Mass spectrometry (MS) has become a central tool in this field, offering a variety of complementary approaches to generate structural information on either folded or disordered proteins [4-6]. Two main categories of methods can be recognized. On one side, conformation-dependent reactions (such as cross-linking, covalent labeling, H/D exchange) are exploited to label molecules in solution, followed by the characterization of the labeling products by denaturing MS [7-11]. On the other side, non-denaturing ("native") MS can be used to directly explore the different conformational components in terms of geometry and structural compactness [12-16]. All these approaches have in common the capability to conjugate protein structure investigation with the peculiar analytical power of MS measurements, offering the possibility of assessing species distributions for folding and binding equilibria and the combination of both. These methods can be combined with characterization of noncovalent complexes [17, 18] and post-translational modifications [19-23]. This review focuses on the application of native MS to protein structure and dynamics investigation, with a general methodological section, followed by examples on specific proteins from our laboratory.

Ion mobility-mass spectrometry shows stepwise protein unfolding under alkaline conditions

Although native mass spectrometry is widely applied to monitor chemical or thermal protein denaturation, it is not clear to what extent it can inform about alkali-induced unfolding. Here, we probe the relationship between solution- and gas-phase structures of proteins under alkaline conditions. Native ion mobility-mass spectrometry reveals that globular proteins are destabilized rather than globally unfolded, which is supported by solution studies, providing detailed insights into alkali-induced unfolding events. Our results pave the way for new applications of MS to monitor structures and interactions of proteins at high pH.

Dimerization of lipocalin allergens

Lipocalins are one of the most important groups of inhalant animal allergens. The analysis of structural features of these proteins is important to get insights into their allergenicity. We have determined two different dimeric crystal structures for bovine dander lipocalin Bos d 2, which was earlier described as a monomeric allergen. The crystal structure analysis of all other determined lipocalin allergens also revealed oligomeric structures which broadly utilize inherent structural features of the β-sheet in dimer formation. According to the moderate size of monomer-monomer interfaces, most of these dimers would be transient in solution. Native mass spectrometry was employed to characterize quantitatively transient dimerization of two lipocalin allergens, Bos d 2 and Bos d 5, in solution.

Extracting structural information from charge-state distributions of intrinsically disordered proteins by non-denaturing electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) exert key biological functions but tend to escape identification and characterization due to their high structural dynamics and heterogeneity. The possibility to dissect conformational ensembles by electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) offers an attracting possibility to develop a signature for this class of proteins based on their peculiar ionization behavior. This review summarizes available data on charge-state distributions (CSDs) obtained for IDPs by non-denaturing ESI-MS, with reference to globular or chemically denatured proteins. The results illustrate the contributions that direct ESI-MS analysis can give to the identification of new putative IDPs and to their conformational investigation.

In silico investigation of pH-dependence of prolactin and human growth hormone binding to human prolactin receptor

Experimental data shows that the binding of human prolactin (hPRL) to human prolactin receptor (hPRLr-ECD) is strongly pH-dependent, while the binding of the same receptor to human growth hormone (hGH) is pH-independent. Here we carry in silico analysis of the molecular effects causing such a difference and reveal the role of individual amino acids. It is shown that the computational modeling correctly predicts experimentally determined pKa's of histidine residues in an unbound state in the majority of the cases and the pH-dependence of the binding free energy. Structural analysis carried in conjunction with calculated pH-dependence of the binding revealed that the main reason for pH-dependence of the binding of hPRL-hPRLr-ECD is a number of salt- bridges across the interface of the complex, while no salt-bridges are formed in the hGH-hPRlr-ECD. Specifically, most of the salt-bridges involve histidine residues and this is the reason for the pH-dependence across a physiological range of pH. The analysis not only revealed the molecular mechanism of the pH-dependence of the hPRL-hPRLr-ECD, but also provided critical insight into the underlying physic-chemical mechanism.

An electrostatic charge partitioning model for the dissociation of protein complexes in the gas phase

Electrosprayed multi-protein complexes can be dissociated by collisional activation in the gas phase. Typically, these processes follow a mechanism whereby a single subunit gets ejected with a disproportionately high amount of charge relative to its mass. This asymmetric behavior suggests that the departing subunit undergoes some degree of unfolding prior to being separated from the residual complex. These structural changes occur concomitantly with charge (proton) transfer towards the subunit that is being unraveled. Charge accumulation takes place up to the point where the subunit loses physical contact with the residual complex. This work develops a simple electrostatic model for studying the relationship between conformational changes and charge enrichment during collisional activation. Folded subunits are described as spheres that carry continuum surface charge. The unfolded chain is envisioned as random coil bead string. Simulations are guided by the principle that the system will adopt the charge configuration with the lowest potential energy for any backbone conformation. A finite-difference gradient algorithm is used to determine the charge on each subunit throughout the dissociation process. Both dimeric and tetrameric protein complexes are investigated. The model reproduces the occurrence of asymmetric charge partitioning for dissociation events that are preceded by subunit unfolding. Quantitative comparisons of experimental MS/MS data with model predictions yield estimates of the structural changes that occur during collisional activation. Our findings suggest that subunit separation can occur over a wide range of scission point structures that correspond to different degrees of unfolding.

Protein-protein binding affinities in solution determined by electrospray mass spectrometry

Electrospray ionization (ESI) allows the transfer of multi-protein complexes into the gas phase, thereby providing a simple approach for monitoring the stoichiometry of these noncovalent assemblies by mass spectrometry (MS). It remains unclear, however, whether the measured ion abundance ratios of free and bound species are suitable for determining solution-phase binding affinities (K(d) values). Many types of mass spectrometers employ rf-only quadrupoles as ion guides. This work demonstrates that the settings used for these devices are a key factor for ensuring uniform transmission behavior, which is a prerequisite for meaningful affinity measurements. Using bovine β-lactoglobulin and hemoglobin as model systems, it is demonstrated that under carefully adjusted conditions the "direct" ESI-MS approach is capable of providing K(d) values that are in good agreement with previously published solution-phase data. Of the several ion sources tested, a regular ESI emitter operated with pressure-driven flow at 1 μL min(-1) provided the most favorable results. Potential problems in these experiments include conformationally-induced differences in ionization efficiencies, inadvertent collision-induced dissociation, and ESI-induced clustering artifacts. A number of simple tests can be conducted to assess whether or not these factors are prevalent under the conditions used. In addition, the fidelity of the method can be scrutinized by performing measurements over a wide concentration range. Overall, this work supports the viability of the direct ESI-MS approach for determining binding affinities of protein-protein complexes in solution.

Relation between proteins tertiary structure, tryptophan fluorescence lifetimes and tryptophan S(o)→(1)L(b) and S(o)→(1)L(a) transitions. Studies on α1-acid glycoprotein and β-lactoglobulin

We measured fluorescence lifetimes and fluorescence spectra (excitation and emission) of tryptophan residues of α(1)-acid glycoprotein (three Trp residues) and β-lactoglobulin (two Trp residues) in absence and presence of 450 μM progesterone. Progesterone binds only to α(1)-acid glycoprotein. In absence of progesterone, each of the two proteins displays three fluorescence lifetimes. Addition of progesterone induces a partial inhibition of the S(o) → (1)L(a) transition without affecting fluorescence lifetimes. The same experiments performed in presence of denatured proteins in 6 M guanidine show that addition of progesterone inhibits partially the S(o) → (1)L(a) transition and its peak is 15 nm shifted to the red compared to that obtained for native proteins. However, the S(o) → (1)L(b) transition position peak is not affected by protein denaturation. Thus, the tertiary structure of the protein plays an important role by modulating the tryptophan electronic transitions. Fluorescence emission decay recorded in absence and presence of progesterone yields three fluorescence lifetimes whether proteins are denatured or not. Thus, protein tertiary structure is not responsible for the presence of three fluorescence lifetimes. These characterize tryptophan substructures reached at the excited states and which population (pre-exponential values) depend on the tryptophan residues interaction with their microenvironment(s) and thus on the global conformation of the protein.

Irreversible thermal denaturation of cytochrome C studied by electrospray mass spectrometry

This work uses electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) in conjunction with hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) and optical spectroscopy for characterizing the solution-phase properties of cytochrome c (cyt c) after heat exposure. Previous work demonstrated that heating results in irreversible denaturation for a subpopulation of proteins in the sample. However, that study did not investigate the physical reasons underlying this interesting effect. Here we report that the formation of oxidative modifications at elevated temperature plays a key role for the observed behavior. Tryptic digestion followed by tandem mass spectrometry is used to identify individual oxidation sites. Trp59 and Met80 are among the modified amino acids. In native cyt c both of these residues are buried deep within the protein structure, such that covalent modifications would be expected to be particularly disruptive. ESI-MS analysis after heat exposure results in a bimodal charge-state distribution. Oxidized protein appears predominantly in charge states around 11+, whereas a considerably lower degree of oxidation is observed for the 7+ and 8+ peaks. This finding confirms that different oxidation levels are associated with different solution-phase conformations. HDX measurements for different charge states are complicated by peak distortions arising from oxygen adduction. Nonetheless, comparison with simulated peak shapes clearly shows that the HDX properties are different for high- and low-charge states, confirming that interconversion between unfolded and folded conformers is blocked in solution. In addition to oxidation, partial aggregation upon heat exposure likely contributes to the formation of irreversibly denatured protein.

Monitoring the Tanford transition in beta-lactoglobulin by 8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonate and mass spectrometry

The fluorescent dye 8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonate (ANS) is known to interact with proteins by conformation-specific hydrophobic interactions and rather nonspecific electrostatic interactions. To which category the complexes detectable by mass spectrometry (MS) belong is still the subject of debate. Here, the Tanford transition in beta-lactoglobulin (BLG) is exploited as an experimental device to expose hydrophobic binding sites by an increase in pH, rather than, as usually done, by lowering the pH. Complex formation is monitored by electrospray ionization (ESI)-MS and fluorescence spectroscopy. Both techniques reveal stronger ANS binding to BLG at pH 7.9 than at pH 5.9, suggesting that dye binding inside the calyx, which is known to be hydrophobically driven in solution, can contribute to the complexes detected by ESI-MS. Electrostatic interactions between the protein and the ANS sulfonate group can only be weaker at pH 7.9 than at pH 5.9, supporting the interpretation of the results by the protein conformational change. Lysozyme is used as a negative control, which shows no variation in the interaction with ANS in the same range of pH, in the absence of conformational changes. However, comparison of MS and fluorescence data at variable pH for BLG and myoglobin (Mb) suggests that conformation-specific ANS binding to proteins is detectable by ESI-MS only inside well-structured cavities of folded structures, like the BLG calyx and apoMb heme pocket. Indeed, ANS interactions with highly dynamic structures or molten globules, although detectable in solution, are easily lost in the gas phase.

In vivo aggregation of bovine beta-lactoglobulin is affected by Cys at position 121

Bovine beta-lactoglobulin (BLG) has been widely used as a model system to study protein folding and aggregation and for biotechnology applications. Native BLG contains two disulfide bonds and one free cysteine at position 121. This free thiol group has been shown to be responsible for the irreversibility of BLG denaturation in vitro, but nothing is known about its relevance during protein folding inside the cell. Here, we report the expression of soluble wild type recombinant BGL in Escherichia coli cells at about 109 mg rBLG/g wet weight cells and a comparison between the aggregation of wt BLG and its variant C121S upon intracellular expression. We show that in E. coli C121SBLG is more prone to aggregation than the wild type protein and that their different behavior depends on the oxidation of disulfide bonds. Our results underline the key contribution of the unpaired cysteine residue during the oxidative folding pathway and indicate BLG as a useful tool for the study of protein aggregation in vivo.

Effects of zinc binding on the structure and dynamics of the intrinsically disordered protein prothymosin alpha: evidence for metalation as an entropic switch

Prothymosin alpha (ProTalpha) is a small acidic protein that is highly conserved among mammals. The human form has 110 amino acid residues (M.W. 12.1 kDa; pI approximately 3.5) and is found to be expressed in a wide variety of tissues. ProTalpha plays an essential role in cell proliferation and apoptosis, and it is involved in transcriptional regulation of oxidative stress-protecting genes. Despite the multiple biological functions ProTalpha has, the protein does not adopt a well-defined three-dimensional structure under physiological conditions. Previous studies have shown that the interaction between ProTalpha and some of its protein targets is significantly enhanced in the presence of zinc ions, suggesting that zinc binding plays a crucial role in the protein's function. In this work, we use nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry to characterize the structure and dynamics of ProTalpha and its complexation with Zn2+. We found that zinc binding causes partial folding of the C-terminal half of ProTalpha, especially the Glu-rich region, while the N-terminal portion of the protein remains largely unstructured. The metalated protein also exhibits a significantly reduced flexibility. ProTalpha shows a high specificity for Zn2+, and the interactions with other divalent cations (Ca2+, Mg2+) are much weaker. On the basis of the site-specific information obtained here, as well as the results from previous studies, we propose that the conformational and dynamic changes upon zinc binding may act as an entropic switch that greatly facilitates the binding to other proteins.

Method for identifying nonspecific protein-protein interactions in nanoelectrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The nonspecific self-association of proteins in nanoflow electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (nanoES-MS), and the influence of experimental conditions thereon, are investigated using the protein ubiquitin (Ubq) as a model system. Extents of nonspecific protein association generally increase with protein concentration and, interestingly, with decreasing ES spray potential. The extent of self-association is also sensitive to the duration of the accumulation event in an external rf hexapole. Notably, the relative abundance of metal (Na+ and K+) adducts generally increases with the size of nonspecific Ubq multimer. This result suggests that the gaseous ions of monomeric and nonspecific multimeric Ubq have, on average, different ES droplet histories, with monomer ions originating earlier in the ES process than the nonspecific multimeric complexes. This finding forms the basis for a new method for distinguishing between specific and nonspecific protein complexes in ES-MS. A reporter molecule (Mrep), which does not bind specifically to the proteins and protein complexes of interest, is added to the ES solution at high concentration. The distribution of Mrep bound nonspecifically to gaseous ions of the proteins and protein complexes, as determined from the ES mass spectrum, is used to determine whether a given protein complex originates in solution or whether it forms from nonspecific binding during the ES process. The method is demonstrated in cases where the ions of protein complexes detected by nanoES-MS originate exclusively from nonspecific association, exclusively from specific interactions in solution, or from both specific and nonspecific interactions.

Analysis of protein mixtures by electrospray mass spectrometry: effects of conformation and desolvation behavior on the signal intensities of hemoglobin subunits

The determination of solution-phase protein concentration ratios based on ESI-MS intensity ratios is not always straightforward. For example, equimolar mixtures of hemoglobin alpha- and beta-subunits consistently result in much higher peak intensities for the alpha-chain. The current work explores the origin of this effect. Under mildly acidic conditions (pH 3.4) alpha-globin is extensively unfolded, whereas beta-globin retains residual structure. Because of its greater nonpolar character, the more unfolded alpha-subunit can more effectively compete for charge. This leads to suppression of beta-globin signals under conditions where the protein ion yield is limited by the charge concentration on the initially formed ESI droplets. More balanced intensities are observed when operating under charge excess conditions and/or in a solvent environment where both proteins are unfolded to a similar degree (pH 2.2). However, even in these cases the overall alpha-globin peak intensity is still twice as high as that of the beta-subunit. The persistent imbalance under these conditions originates from the different declustering behaviors of the two proteins. A considerable fraction of beta-globin undergoes incomplete desolvation during ESI, thereby reducing the intensity of bare [beta + zH](z+) ions. When including the contributions of incompletely desolvated species, the overall alpha:beta ion intensity ratio is close to unity. The alpha:beta intensity imbalance can also be eliminated by a strongly elevated declustering potential in the ion sampling interface. In conclusion, important factors that have to be considered for the ESI-MS analysis of protein mixtures are (1) conformational effects, resulting in differential surface activities, and (2) dissimilarities in the protein desolvation behavior.

Detection of the equilibrium folding intermediate of beta-lactoglobulin in the presence of trifluoroethanol by mass spectrometry

Nano-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (nano-ESI-MS) was used to monitor the effect of trifluoroethanol (TFE) on the conformational properties of beta-lactoglobulin (BLG). TFE stabilizes protein secondary structure, particularly alpha-helices. However, it also acts as a denaturant above critical concentrations. In the case of BLG, TFE at low concentrations is known to induce formation of an equilibrium intermediate that contains non-native helical structure. Such an intermediate is thought to form also under physiological conditions, playing a role in BLG folding in vivo by preventing aggregation. This well-characterized system was chosen in order to test species distributions obtained by nano-ESI-MS. BLG spectra at increasing concentrations of TFE at pH 2 indicate transient accumulation of a conformer whose charge-state distribution (CSD) falls between that of the native and that of the denatured protein, indicating that the TFE-induced, partially folded form can be selectively monitored by this technique. The condition of its maximum accumulation corresponds to 16% TFE, in excellent agreement with results from solution experiments. In contrast, titrations with methanol or acetonitrile (ACN) reveal apparent two-state transitions from native to fully unfolded BLG. At 10% TFE, the protein appears to be still fully folded at room temperature but, if unfolding is elicited by the combination with other denaturing agents, e.g. heat or low concentrations of ACN, it proceeds via formation of the intermediate. Thus, TFE can also induce formation of the BLG intermediate in synergism with generic denaturing agents. This study indicates good agreement between ESI-MS and other biophysical methods monitoring protein conformational transitions in the presence of TFE.