Evolution and changing trends in surgery for benign Parotid tumors

Patient-Reported Quality-of-Life Outcome Measure After Parotidectomy

Importance

There is a lack of reliable, patient-reported quality-of-life (QOL) instruments to address the multidimensional nature of patient-centered outcomes for patients undergoing parotidectomy. The Parotidectomy Quality of Life Index is a new 35-item validated patient-reported outcome instrument specific to recovery after parotidectomy.

Objective

To establish and validate a comprehensive English-language patient-reported QOL instrument specific to parotidectomy.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This survey study was conducted in 2 phases: first, in a single-institution cohort (October 12, 2021, to March 7, 2022), and second, as an anonymous web-based survey enrolled via printed promotional brochures and social media platforms (March 13 to July 31, 2023). Inclusion criteria were age at least 18 years and parotidectomy within the last year. For test-retest reliability, a subset of phase II participants volunteered to answer the survey a second time within 2 weeks. Data were analyzed from March 8, 2022, to November 3, 2023.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Item rankings from phase I participants were used to narrow the original 61-item survey down to 45 items in the phase II survey. To assess construct validity, an exploratory factor analysis was performed. Cronbach α and pairwise Pearson correlation coefficients were used to measure internal consistency, reliability, and redundancy. Test-retest reliability was evaluated using intraclass correlation coefficients.

Results

Phase I enrolled 38 individuals, of whom 30 completed the survey (15 women [60%]; 21 participants [84%] aged >40 years). Phase II enrolled 342 participants, of whom 317 completed the survey (305 women [89%]; 284 participants [83%] aged >40 years). A total of 42 items across 7 domains were selected based on exploratory factor analysis. After Cronbach α and pairwise correlation analysis, 33 items across 6 multi-item domains and 2 standalone items were incorporated into the final QOL instrument. Cronbach αs for each of the final 6 domains were at least 0.77, suggesting excellent internal validity. Pairwise correlations did not show strong correlations (ie, none ≥0.80), suggesting minimal redundancy between domains. Younger age was significantly associated with a lower global score. Participants with malignant tumors scored lower on 4 of the 6 multi-item domains. Test-retest reliability coefficients for the domains ranged from 0.82 to 0.93, indicating very good reproducibility over a 2-week interval.

Conclusions and Relevance

These findings suggest the Parotidectomy Quality of Life Index demonstrated excellent internal validity and test-retest reliability. With further external validation, this instrument may provide opportunity for quality improvement in clinical practice and has potential as a key patient-reported outcome in future parotidectomy clinical trials.

Comparisons between partial and total sialoadenectomy for benign submandibular gland tumors: A systematic review and meta-analysis

This study aimed to compare postoperative efficacy and functional outcomes between partial sialoadenectomy (PS) and total sialoadenectomy (TS) in patients with benign submandibular gland (SMG) tumors. We systematically searched PubMed, Web of Science, EmBase, Cochrane Library, China Biomedical Literature, and CNKI from inception to 2024, following PICOS criteria (Population: Adults with benign SMG tumors; Intervention: PS; Comparison: TS; Outcomes: Salivary function, neurological complications, recurrence, operative duration, dry mouth, infection/hematoma; Study design: RCTs/observational studies with ≥ 6-month follow-up). The protocol was prospectively registered (PROSPERO CRD42024595824). Risk ratios (RR) were calculated for dichotomous outcomes, and weighted mean differences (WMD) for continuous outcomes, using random-effects models. Heterogeneity was quantified by I2 statistics and Q tests. Sensitivity analyses included leave-one-out methods, and publication bias was assessed via funnel plots and Egger's test. The analysis of findings was guided by the GRADE (Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation) framework to evaluate evidence certainty, while also considering the size of intervention effects in alignment with GRADE methodology. From 1014 screened studies, 7 studies (3 RCTs, 4 cohort studies) involving 399 patients (PS: n = 188; TS: n = 211) were included. PS demonstrated superior static saliva flow (WMD = 0.24, 95 %CI 0.13, 0.35)and reduced neurological complications (RR = 0.22, 95 %CI 0.10, 0.49), operative duration (WMD = -14.19, 95 %CI -23.4, -4.99), and dry mouth (RR = 0.12, 95 %CI 0.03, 0.49). However, there were no significant differences between the two groups in stimulated saliva flow (WMD = 0.01, 95 %CI -0.01, 0.04), tumor recurrence (RR = 3.23, 95 %CI 0.13, 77.99), postoperative infection (RR = 0.25, 95 %CI 0.03, 2.26), and postoperative hematoma (RR = 0.36, 95 %CI 0.08, 1.72). GRADE revealed moderate-certainty evidence for functional outcomesbut low/very low certainty for neurological complications, recurrence, operative duration, dry mouth, postoperative infection and hematoma. The current results demonstrate that partial sialoadenectomy offers significant advantages over traditional total sialoadenectomy.It is recommended that clinicians consider adopting new surgical procedures for the treatment of benign tumors of the submandibular gland in the future.

National Trends and Benchmarks for Operative Time and Hospital Length of Stay in Parotidectomies

OBJECTIVE

The extent of parotidectomy for benign tumors has de-escalated in the United States. We aim to define modern benchmarks for operative time and hospital length of stay (LOS) in parotidectomy and identify risk factors that may prolong these benchmarks.

STUDY DESIGN

This is a retrospective cross-sectional study of all adults who underwent parotidectomy for a primary parotid neoplasm between January 2011 and December 2021 using the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program database.

METHODS

The extent of parotidectomy was defined using Current Procedural Terminology codes. Prolonged operative time and LOS were defined as above the 75th percentile (longer than 194 minutes and more than 1 day, respectively). Multivariable logistic regression was used to identify patient and surgical risk factors that predict prolonged operative time or LOS.

RESULTS

Benign parotidectomies are mostly performed as outpatient procedures in the United States (average LOS <1 day). Prolonged operative time was independently associated with malignant tumors versus benign tumors (adjusted odds ratio [aOR]: 2.7, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 2.4-3.0), total parotidectomy with facial nerve sacrifice versus lesser extent of parotidectomy (aOR: 2.3, 95% CI: 1.7-3.0), and simultaneous reconstructive procedures versus none (P < .001 for all). These features were similarly independently associated with prolonged LOS (P < .001 for all). Complication rates were universally low.

CONCLUSION

The majority of superficial parotidectomies in this country are performed as outpatient procedures requiring <3 hours of operative time, with low complication rates. Malignant tumors, greater extent of parotidectomy, and simultaneous procedures were independently associated with prolonged operative time and LOS. These national benchmarks can inform operating room and hospital bed resource assignments.

Postoperative pain after parotid surgery-comparison between superficial/total parotidectomy and extracapsular dissection: a prospective observational study

PURPOSE

To evaluate postoperative pain and discomfort after parotid surgery with regard to different surgical approaches.

METHODS

This clinical study was carried out at a single tertiary referral center (2021-2022) and included 2 groups of adult patients (mean age 56.6 ± 12.7 vs. 53.4 ± 14.1 years) following elective parotid surgery due to a parotid tumor of any entity. The first group (SP/TP group) consisted of 31 patients after superficial parotidectomy (SP) or total parotidectomy (TP) (n = 31). The second group (ECD group) included all patients who had undergone extracapsular dissection (ECD) (n = 51). Primary endpoints comprised pain on ambulation as well as maximum and minimum pain (NRS 0-10) on the first three postoperative days (PODs). A neuropathic pain component (evaluated on POD 1 and 3), the analgesic score (collected from the patient file on POD 1-3), treatment-related side-effects/pain-associated impairments, and patient satisfaction (all measured on the 1st POD) were defined as secondary endpoints. Patients were surveyed using the standardized and validated "Quality Improvement in Postoperative Pain Treatment" (QUIPS) questionnaire and the painDETECT® questionnaire. Comparisons were performed using independent t tests, Wilcoxon tests, and χ2 tests, and the respective effect sizes were calculated.

RESULTS

Looking at the first postoperative day, patients of both groups (SP/TP vs. ECD) reported comparable pain on ambulation (2.8 ± 2.0 vs. 2.6 ± 1.8; p = 0.628, r = 0.063), maximum (3.5 ± 2.2 vs. 3.5 ± 2.3; p = 0.992, r = 0.002) and minimum pain (1.1 ± 1.04 vs. 1.0 ± 1.2; p = 0.206, r = 0.157). Furthermore, there were no significant differences in pain-related restrictions or pain medication requirement. The patients in both groups were equally satisfied with their pain therapy (p = 0.282, R = 0.135). The sum score of the painDETECT® questionnaire delivered clearly negative (< 12) results on average (POD1: 6.81; POD3: 6.59); no significant difference between the groups was found (p = 0.991, R2 < .001).

CONCLUSION

Neither surgical technique on the parotid gland was significantly superior to the other in terms of postoperative pain perception. Overall, postoperative pain can be classified as mild to moderate following parotid surgery. A neuropathic pain component could be excluded for the acute postoperative phase.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

The study was registered in the German Registry for Clinical Studies (DRKS) (application No.: DRKS00016520).

A Rare Diagnosis of Parotid Gland Follicular Lymphoma Arising in Warthin Tumor: Case Report and Literature Review

Introduction: A Warthin tumor is a benign salivary gland neoplasm, mostly found in the parotid gland. The number of reported Warthin tumors has increased over the years due to better diagnostic modalities and health system modernization. Warthin tumor rarely transforms into a malignant tumor; in this work, we present all cases reported in the English literature of different types of lymphomas within Warthin tumors. In this case, we present a low-grade follicular lymphoma arising within a Warthin tumor. Clinical report: A 64-year-old man presented to an oral and maxillofacial surgery clinic with a growing right facial mass. The medical history was significant for stable angina pectoris, hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, obesity, and a 20-pack-year smoking history. Fine needle aspiration suggested a diagnosis of Warthin tumor. A contrast CT scan of the parotid gland demonstrated a 2.9 × 2.7 × 4.1 cm diameter mass. The patient underwent right superficial parotidectomy. Histological examination of the mass revealed a low-grade follicular lymphoma arising in a pre-existing Warthin tumor. The postoperative PET CT showed no distant disease, and bone marrow biopsy during hematologic evaluation confirmed Stage 1 low-grade follicular lymphoma. The patient received 24 Gy of VMAT radiation therapy to the right parotid gland and continued hematologic follow-up. Conclusions: Based on a literature review, this is one of the few well-documented cases reported of low-grade follicular lymphoma within a Warthin tumor. This case highlights the importance of the thorough evaluation and diagnosis of parotid masses. Furthermore, this case reopens the debate on the "wait and see" approach regarding Warthin tumors. Fine needle aspiration-based diagnosis should not be considered final, as some malignant characteristics can be missed if declining surgery.

Outcomes of a modified technique of partial parotidectomy and novel parotid tumour position classification from a single surgeon prospective database

BACKGROUND

Conservative parotidectomy for benign tumours reduces facial nerve palsy, without increasing local recurrence. We report a modified technique of partial parotidectomy and using a novel description of tumour position, explore relationships between tumour position and histological margins, facial nerve palsy and local recurrence.

METHODS

A prospectively collected single surgeon parotidectomy database was analysed, including tumour location (superficial/deep lobe; central/peripheral) and outcomes. A partial parotidectomy identified the facial nerve and the proximal portion of its branches with a macroscopically clear resection margin. Mean follow up was 5.9 years for pleomorphic adenomas.

RESULTS

Three hundred and three patients underwent parotidectomy; 257 (84.8%) were superficial and 46 (15.2%) deep lobe. Tumour position was recorded in 291: 236 (81.1%) were peripheral tumours and 55 (18.9%) central. Histological margin involvement was similar in central and peripheral tumours, both overall and for superficial and deep lobe tumours, but was commoner in central deep lobe tumours, (P = 0.003). Temporary partial facial nerve palsy occurred in 21 (6.9%), with one permanent partial nerve palsy (0.3%). Deep lobe tumours and total parotidectomy were associated with facial nerve palsy (P = 0.01). Facial nerve monitoring reduced the risk of palsy (P < 0.01). Local recurrence of pleomorphic adenomas was uncommon, occurring in 3 (2.0%) of 151 patients.

CONCLUSION

This series confirms the safety and adequacy of more conservative partial parotidectomy for benign tumours, highlighting most tumours are peripheral, but not more prone to histological margin involvement or local recurrence, and with routine intraoperative facial nerve monitoring, is achieved with low facial nerve palsy rates.

Extracapsular Dissection Versus Traditional Parotid Surgery: A Comprehensive Review of Techniques and Outcomes

Parotid tumours, encompassing both benign and malignant forms, present significant challenges in surgical management. Traditional parotid surgery, including various forms of parotidectomy, has long been the standard approach, aiming for complete tumour removal while addressing potential complications such as facial nerve injury. However, extracapsular dissection (ECD) has emerged as an alternative technique, focusing on excising the tumour along with a thin layer of surrounding tissue, which may offer benefits in preserving healthy glandular tissue and reducing postoperative complications. This review comprehensively compares ECD and traditional parotid surgery techniques, evaluating their efficacy, outcomes, and associated complications. We analyse clinical studies and evidence to assess differences in tumour recurrence rates, facial nerve function preservation, and overall patient recovery. Additionally, the review explores the indications for each surgical approach, considering tumour characteristics and patient-specific factors. The findings suggest that while ECD may offer advantages in terms of reduced postoperative complications and improved preservation of glandular tissue, traditional parotidectomy remains a robust method for managing complex cases. This review aims to inform clinical decision-making by presenting a detailed comparison of both techniques, ultimately guiding surgeons in selecting the most appropriate approach for individual patients.

Case-tailored indicated extracapsular dissection versus "one-size-fits-all" nerve dissection: Has the bet been won?

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the study was to trace the development of surgical therapy in a large cohort, examine its changes at one single institution that has been specializing in salivary gland pathologies over the last 22 years, and to determine the extent to which a possible shift in the surgical therapy of parotid benign tumors towards less radical methods was correlated with a change in the incidence of facial palsy and Frey's syndrome.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective clinical study.

METHODS

A retrospective evaluation of the records of all patients treated for benign parotid tumors at a tertiary referral center between 2000 and 2022 was carried out. Surgical methods were classified into four groups: extracapsular dissection, partial superficial parotidectomy, superficial parotidectomy and complete parotidectomy.

RESULTS

A total of 4037 patients were included in the study. Our analysis demonstrated an increase in the total number of parotidectomies for benign lesions from 71 (2000) to 298 (2022), mostly due to the increase in extracapsular dissections (from 9 to 212). The increased performance of less radical surgery was associated with a significantly decreased incidence of perioperative complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study showed that the increased performance of less radical surgery was associated with better functional outcomes over the years.

Surgical management of Warthin tumor: long-term follow-up of 224 patients from 2002 to 2018

PURPOSE

Warthin tumors (WT) are the second most common benign parotid gland neoplasms. They can occur as synchronous or metachronous lesions in 6-10% of cases. This study aims to compare the complication rate in 224 patients who underwent extracapsular dissection (ECD) or superficial parotidectomy (SP) for the treatment of a WT.

METHODS

This retrospective study was conducted at the Department of Maxillo-Facial Surgery at the University of Naples "Federico II" from February 2002 to December 2018 on a group of patients who underwent surgical treatment for WT. The type of surgical technique was chosen based on Quer's classification. The complications evaluated were facial nerve palsy, hematoma, Frey's syndrome, and bleeding.

RESULTS

A total of 224 patients treated from 2002 to 2018 for Warthin tumor were included in the study. Two hundred elven had solitary tumors (94.1%) and 13 had multicentric lesions (5.8%), of which 9 cases presented synchronous lesions and 4 cases presented metachronous lesions. Extracapsular dissection (ECD) was performed in 130 patients (58.3% of cases) and superficial parotidectomy (SP) in the other 94 (41.7% of cases).

CONCLUSIONS

We consider both surgical techniques as valid. In our opinion, it is essential to study each case based on Quer's Classification to obtain the best surgical outcome. Based on a lower observed rate of complications such as facial nerve palsy, Frey's syndrome, and bleeding, ECD seems to be the best option for the surgical treatment of Quer Class I lesions.

Continuous intraoperative neuromonitoring of the facial nerve predicts postoperative facial palsy in parotid surgery: a prospective study

PURPOSE

Facial palsy (FP) is the most significant complication of parotidectomy. Currently, the use of intermittent intraoperative neuromonitoring (iIONM) in parotid surgery facilitates nerve detection, which is paramount to nerve protection. Continuous IONM (cIONM), as applied in thyroid surgery, enables real-time information on electrophysiological nerve status through continuous nerve stimulation, thereby allowing consequent amplitude analysis. To date, the application of cIONM in parotid surgery has not been noted in literature.

METHODS

We performed parotidectomies with anterograde facial nerve visualization using cIONM in 32 consecutive patients in a prospective study (German Register of clinical studies-DRKS 00011051) during the period October 2016 to January 2020. After the facial trunk had been exposed, an atraumatic stimulation electrode was placed and the nerve was stimulated at 3 Hz, at a low threshold (0.62 ± 0.06 mA), for the entire duration of the preparation. Selected electrophysiological parameters were collected and compared to postoperative facial nerve function, measured by the House-Brackmann grading system.

RESULTS

In the post hoc analysis, a significant correlation between a drop in amplitude (< 50% of the "baseline" amplitude) and postoperative FP was recorded (p = 0.001). True positive prediction of FP was noted in 14 out of 16 patients and true negative in 10 out of 16. The sensitivity was 87.5% (AUC 0.75), with a high negative predictive value of 83.3%.

CONCLUSION

cIONM has significant value in predicting postoperative FP in parotidectomy. Future development of an acoustic/optic warning system in IONM devices could prevent nerve injury in real time.

Ability for fine needle aspiration and frozen section to predict extent of parotidectomy

INTRODUCTION

Several diagnostic modalities with various sensitivity and specificities can be used to evaluate a parotid mass. The aims of this project were to compare the diagnostic actionability, accuracy, and ability to accurately predict extent of surgery for FNA and frozen section during the evaluation of a parotid mass.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review of patients who underwent parotidectomy for a parotid mass from January 1, 2015 to January 30, 2022 was conducted. Actionability was defined as a pathology diagnosis or the histologic grade of a lesion, as this provided clear and useful information for the surgeon to act upon. Diagnostic accuracy was determined by comparing FNA and frozen section results to final pathology. Accuracy of extent of surgery was determined by comparing predicted extent of surgery from the FNA or frozen section result to the extent of surgery predicted by the final pathology.

RESULTS

A total of 626 patients were included in this study. FNA was obtained in 396 (63%) patients, while all neoplasms were evaluated by frozen section analysis. FNA diagnosis was actionable in 318 (80%), while frozen section diagnosis was actionable in 616 (98%) patients. Exactly 294 (92.5%) FNA diagnoses were accurate compared with 600 (98%) frozen section diagnoses. The FNA diagnosis predicted appropriate extent of surgery in 294 (74%) while the frozen section diagnosis predicted appropriate extent of surgery in 600 (96%). Among the 396 patients with FNA, frozen section was significantly more likely to accurately predict appropriate extent of surgery compared with FNA (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Frozen section is more likely to yield actionable and accurate results compared with FNA. Additionally, frozen section is better than FNA in predicting the appropriate extent of surgery.

Centripetal Versus Centrifugal Facial Nerve Dissection in Superficial Parotidectomy: Comparison of the Two Methods at a Tertiary Care Center

OBJECTIVES

To compare the intraoperative and postoperative parameters of two techniques of facial nerve dissection: Centripetal vs Centrifugal.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective study.

SETTING

Academic tertiary referral centre.

METHODS

In our study, cases of superficial parotidectomy were randomly selected from the outpatient departments of ORL & HNS. Of these patients, 30 underwent standard anterograde dissection group (Group A) and 30 underwent retrograde facial nerve dissection (Group B). All the patients were assessed pre-operatively, intra-operatively and post-operatively to compare the various parameters.

RESULTS

The most common complaint in both groups was parotid swelling. The operative time for A was shorter at 2.1 h as compared to 1.9 h min in group B. The resolution of symptoms was nearly comparable in both groups. Facial nerve palsy was slightly more in group B but the difference was not statistically significant.

CONCLUSION

The operative time and post-operative complications were both comparable between AFND and RFND, implying both techniques can be used by surgeons depending on the individual cases.

Surgical management and side effects of parotid gland surgery for benign lesions: a retrospective analysis of our experience from 2012 to 2021

Surgery is the treatment of choice for tumours in the parotid gland. We evaluated complications following parotid surgery. We conducted a retrospective study on 554 patients undergoing parotid surgery for benign parotid tumours from 2012 to 2021. We analysed complication rates between extracapsular dissection (ECD) and superficial parotidectomy (SP). We found 19 capsular ruptures in patients undergoing ECD (5.34%) and five among those undergoing SP (2.52%) [p < 0,05]; 16 cases of temporary facial paralysis among those undergoing ECD (4.49%) and 35 in patients undergoing SP (17.67%) [p < 0,05]; and eight instances of permanent facial nerve paralysis in patients undergoing ECD (2.25%) [p > 0,05] and 13 in patients undergoing SP (6.56%). Among the mid-term complications described were: 22 salivary fistulas among patients operated with ECD (6.18%) [p > 0,05] and 17 in patients with SP (8.58%) 17 sialoceles in those who underwent ECD (4.77%) and seven with SP (3.53%) [p > 0,05]. Regarding late complications, we found: surgical wound dehiscence, pathological scarring (keloid), Frey's syndrome, and recurrence, which affected 45 patients with ECD (12.64%) and 21 with SP for dehiscence (10.6%) [p < 0,05]; 28 keloids in patients with ECD (7.86%) and 15 in patients with SP (7.57%) [p > 0,05]; 12 cases of Frey's syndrome in patients with ECD (3.37%) and 36 with SP (18.18%) [p < 0,05]; and finally 22 recurrences in patients who underwent ECD (6.18%) and 13 in patients who underwent SP (6.56%) [p > 0,05], including 30 in the 273 patients with pleomorphic adenoma and five in the 214 patients with Warthin's tumour. We can conclude that the onset of the different complications after parotid gland surgery are related to the surgery performed. Our data confirm that there is a tight relationship between type of surgery performed and type of complication.

Results of 301 Parotidectomies: A Twenty-Year Experience of One Single Institution

To evaluate demographic, clinical, surgical and histopathological results and complications of 301 parotidectomies performed in southern part of Turkey. The results of 297 patients undergoing 301 parotidectomies between 2000 and 2019 were retrospectively reviewed. Four patients underwent bilateral parotidectomy. Age, gender, side and size of lesion, postoperative facial nerve function (FNF) for benign tumors and types of surgery were evaluated. There were 172 male and 125 female patients. The mean age was 52.53 ± 16.67 years (range 11-90 years). Patients with malignant tumor had higher mean age than the patients with benign diseases (p < 0.001) and the mean age of Warthin tumor (WT) patients was significantly higher than pleomorphic adenoma (PA) (p < 0.001). There was a significant male dominancy in WTs than the PAs (p < 0.001). The mean size of the malignant tumors was significantly higher than the benign tumors (p = 0.012). The mean of cigarette smoking value (pack/year) was higher in WTs than the PAs (p < 0.001). WT incidence was slightly higher than PA in between years 2010 and 2019 (p = 0.272) compared to between years 2000 and 2009. Fine needle aspiration biopsy had a sensitivity of 96% and specificity of 78% for the benign tumors. Tumor location (p < 0.001) and tumor size (p = 0.034) had negative effect on the postoperative FNF. The incidence of WT had a significant rise in the last decade. Deep lobe tumors and increased tumor size had effect postoperative FNF. Experience of surgeon is more important than nerve monitoring to prevent facial paralysis. Partial superficial parotidectomy was available methods for small benign tumors in tail of the parotid gland.

Proposal for a novel classification of benign parotid tumors based on localization

OBJECTIVE

Postoperative facial nerve paralysis is the most problematic complication after surgical treatment of parotid tumors. Localization of tumors is highly relevant for the surgical approach, but existing classification systems do not focus on the association between localization and surgical technique. Therefore, we created a new localization-based classification system for benign parotid tumors and investigated the characteristics of tumors in each localization and the frequency of postoperative facial nerve paralysis by retrospectively applying the classification to previous cases.

METHODS

First, we defined 6 portions of the parotid gland (upper, U; lower, L; posterior, P; anterior, A; superficial, S; deep, D) by dividing the transverse plane into an upper and lower portion at the mandibular marginal branch, the longitudinal plane into a posterior and anterior portion at the midline of the parotid anteroposterior diameter, and the sagittal plane into a superficial and deep portion along the course of the facial nerve. Then, we defined 8 locations by combining the 6 portions in all possible ways (i.e., U-P-S, U-P-D, U-A-S, U-A-D, L-P-S, L-P-D, L-A-S, L-A-D). We used this classification to define the tumor localization in 948 patients who had undergone partial superficial parotidectomy for benign parotid tumors and then investigated the incidence, histopathological type, signs/symptoms, diagnosis, surgery, and complications in each area.

RESULTS

Pleomorphic adenomas comprised approximately 70% of tumors in the upper portion but only approximately 35% in the lower portion. The rate of postoperative facial nerve paralysis was significantly higher for tumors in deep locations than in superficial locations (33.9% vs 14.9%, respectively), and the odds ratios for postoperative facial nerve paralysis in the U-P-D and U-A-D locations were 7.6 and 4.8 compared to the L-P-S location. When maximum diameter, operation time, bleeding volume, sex (reference: female), and age were added as control variables, the odds ratios were 4.2 and 3.0.

CONCLUSION

Determining tumor localization preoperatively with the new localization-based classification of parotid tumors is helpful not only for predicting the histopathological type but also for predicting surgical complications, particularly postoperative facial nerve paralysis.

Clinical outcomes and cost-effectiveness of superficial parotidectomy versus extracapsular dissection of the parotid gland: a single-centre retrospective study of 161 patients

Improvements in preoperative diagnostics and intraoperative techniques have made the surgical excision of benign parotid gland tumours less invasive. Extracapsular dissection (ECD) has become more popular in comparison to superficial parotidectomy (SP), the gold standard. Although clinical outcomes have been reported, reports on cost-effectiveness are limited. The aim of this retrospective study was to analyse the surgical outcomes and cost-effectiveness of ECD versus SP in benign parotid tumour surgery. A retrospective cohort of 161 patients treated between 2012 and 2020 was collected. Data concerning demographics, clinical outcomes, and cost-efficiency were recorded. Analysis of the 161 unilateral parotidectomy cases (59 SP, 102 ECD) showed a significantly longer operation time, anaesthesia time, and length of stay for SP patients (all P < 0.001). Regarding postoperative complications, transient facial nerve weakness (P < 0.001) and haematoma formation (P = 0.016) were more prevalent in the SP patients. The frequency of positive margins was lower for SP (P = 0.037). No case of recurrence was identified with either technique. ECD showed excellent clinical outcomes as well as a reduction in complications when compared to SP. ECD is a viable alternative for superficial benign parotid gland tumours after thorough preoperative clinical, pathological, and radiological examination. The reduction in operation, anaesthesia, and hospitalization times with ECD is likely to result in a gain in cost-effectiveness.

Parotid Gland Tumors: A Multicenter Analysis of 1020 Cases. Increasing Incidence of Warthin's Tumor

We assessed the frequency of the parotid gland tumor entities and correlated sex and age in different tumor types. Retrospective data were obtained from three major otorhinolaryngology clinics in Karlsruhe and Pforzheim, Germany within a 10-year period. In total, 1020 cases of parotidectomy for benign and malignant lesions were identified. We found 864 (84.7%) and 156 (15.3%) patients with benign and malignant tumors of the parotid gland, respectively. The most common benign parotid tumor was Warthin's tumor, followed by pleomorphic adenoma. The most common primary malignant tumor types were acinic cell carcinoma and mucoepidermoid carcinoma. Secondary malignant tumors of the parotid gland included lymphoma and metastatic, cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma. The frequency of Warthin's tumors was higher than that of pleomorphic adenomas. A large proportion of the malignant parotid tumors represent metastases from squamous cell carcinoma of the skin of the head and neck.

Microscopic Parotidectomy: A Prospective Study

To assess the parameters' setting of the microscope during parotidectomy and the impact of microscopic parotidectomy on facial nerve functional status. A prospective study was conducted on 28 patients in a tertiary care center, who underwent microscopic parotidectomy. Microscope's settings' like magnification, focal length, diameter of the visualized field, and clock position were recorded. Facial nerve functional status was also recorded. All surgeries were performed by right-handed surgeons using Leica F 20 M525 microscope. Clock position of microscope for right parotidectomy ranged between 7 and 10 o clock and for left, it ranged between 7 and 12 o clock. Magnification ranged between 1.3 × and 3.2 ×; magnifications of 1.3 × and 1.8 × were preferred from incision to separation of parotid from sternocleidomastoid muscle, 1.8 × and 2 × for dissection of the facial nerve trunk, and 2 × and 3.2 × for individual branches of the facial nerve. Focal length ranged between 251 and 410 mm and the diameter of the visualized field ranged between 7 and 14.7 cm. Out of 24 cases of benign lesions, 2 (8.3%) developed facial paresis which resolved in 3 months. Two out of four cases of malignancy developed permanent palsy as nerve branches were sacrificed to achieve tumor clearance. Using a microscope for parotidectomy is advantageous for facial nerve dissection, reducing chances of facial paralysis. The microscope was also found to be useful for teaching. The use of appropriate microscopic parameters avoids the glitch of transition from open to microscopic approach.

Extracapsular dissection with a transparotid facial nerve dissection approach versus partial superficial parotidectomy for benign tumours in the tail of the parotid gland: a single-centre retrospective study of 89 patients

The aims of this study were (1) to evaluate the transparotid facial nerve dissection approach (TFND), in which the intraparotid cervicofacial or temporofacial division is identified first through a superficial lobe incision; and (2) to compare extracapsular dissection with a TFND (ECD-TFND) with partial superficial parotidectomy with a retrograde approach (PSP) for benign tumours in the tail of the parotid gland with respect to surgical outcomes. Eighty-nine patients underwent PSP or ECD-TFND for benign tumours in the tail of the parotid gland: 49 were treated surgically with PSP and 40 with ECD-TFND. The mean ( ± standard deviation) surgical time did not differ significantly between the groups: 64 ± 22.4 min for PSP and 59 ± 19.8 min for ECD-TFND (P = 0.302). There was a significant difference in sialocele: 18 (36.7%) patients in the PSP group and four (10%) in the ECD-TFND group (P = 0.002). There was also a significant difference in facial nerve injuries: temporary paralysis was observed in 13 (26.5%) patients in the PSP group and two (5%) in the ECD-TFND group (P = 0.007). It appears that TFND is a viable and safe approach when performing ECD for benign tumours in the tail of the parotid gland. ECD-TFND should be preferred over PSP for benign tumours in the tail of the parotid gland.

Apparent Diffusion Coefficient (ADC) Histogram Analysis in Parotid Gland Tumors: Evaluating a Novel Approach for Differentiation between Benign and Malignant Parotid Lesions Based on Full Histogram Distributions

The aim of this study was to assess the diagnostic value of ADC distribution curves for differentiation between benign and malignant parotid gland tumors and to compare with mean ADC values. 73 patients with parotid gland tumors underwent head-and-neck MRI on a 1.5 Tesla scanner prior to surgery and histograms of ADC values were extracted. Histopathological results served as a reference standard for further analysis. ADC histograms were evaluated by comparing their similarity to a reference distribution using Chi2-test-statistics. The assumed reference distribution for benign and malignant parotid gland lesions was calculated after pooling the entire ADC data. In addition, mean ADC values were determined. For both methods, we calculated and compared the sensitivity and specificity between benign and malignant parotid gland tumors and three subgroups (pleomorphic adenoma, Warthin tumor, and malignant lesions), respectively. Moreover, we performed cross-validation (CV) techniques to estimate the predictive performance between ADC distributions and mean values. Histopathological results revealed 30 pleomorphic adenomas, 22 Warthin tumors, and 21 malignant tumors. ADC histogram distribution yielded a better specificity for detection of benign parotid gland lesions (ADChistogram: 75.0% vs. ADCmean: 71.2%), but mean ADC values provided a higher sensitivity (ADCmean: 71.4% vs. ADChistogram: 61.9%). The discrepancies are most pronounced in the differentiation between malignant and Warthin tumors (sensitivity ADCmean: 76.2% vs. ADChistogram: 61.9%; specificity ADChistogram: 81.8% vs. ADCmean: 68.2%). Using CV techniques, ADC distribution revealed consistently better accuracy to differentiate benign from malignant lesions (“leave-one-out CV” accuracy ADChistogram: 71.2% vs. ADCmean: 67.1%). ADC histogram analysis using full distribution curves is a promising new approach for differentiation between primary benign and malignant parotid gland tumors, especially with respect to the advantage in predictive performance based on CV techniques.

Comparison of Different Machine Models Based on Multi-Phase Computed Tomography Radiomic Analysis to Differentiate Parotid Basal Cell Adenoma From Pleomorphic Adenoma

Objective

This study explored the value of different radiomic models based on multiphase computed tomography in differentiating parotid pleomorphic adenoma (PA) and basal cell tumor (BCA) concerning the predominant phase and the optimal radiomic model.

Methods

This study enrolled 173 patients with pathologically confirmed parotid tumors (training cohort: n=121; testing cohort: n=52). Radiomic features were extracted from the nonenhanced, arterial, venous, and delayed phases CT images. After dimensionality reduction and screening, logistic regression (LR), K-nearest neighbor (KNN) and support vector machine (SVM) were applied to develop radiomic models. The optimal radiomic model was selected by using ROC curve analysis. Univariate and multivariable logistic regression was performed to analyze clinical-radiological characteristics and to identify variables for developing a clinical model. A combined model was constructed by integrating clinical and radiomic features. Model performances were assessed by ROC curve analysis.

Results

A total of 1036 radiomic features were extracted from each phase of CT images. Sixteen radiomic features were considered valuable by dimensionality reduction and screening. Among radiomic models, the SVM model of the arterial and delayed phases showed superior predictive efficiency and robustness (AUC, training cohort: 0.822, 0.838; testing cohort: 0.752, 0.751). The discriminatory capability of the combined model was the best (AUC, training cohort: 0.885; testing cohort: 0.834).

Conclusions

The diagnostic performance of the arterial and delayed phases contributed more than other phases. However, the combined model demonstrated excellent ability to distinguish BCA from PA, which may provide a non-invasive and efficient method for clinical decision-making.

Patient safety and quality improvements in parotid surgery

Parotidectomy is the mainstay treatment for tumors of the parotid gland. In an effort to improve clinical outcomes, several modern surgical techniques and perioperative interventions have been evaluated and refined. This review discusses current and actively debated perioperative interventions aimed at improving patient safety and the quality of parotidectomy. Relevant high-impact literature pertaining to preoperative diagnostic modalities, intraoperative surgical techniques, and postoperative care will be described.

Parotid pleomorphic and non-pleomorphic adenomas: a mono-institutional series of 512 patients

PURPOSE

Pleomorphic adenoma (PA) is the most common benign parotid tumor, with a well-known propensity to recur. Many factors have been advocated as prognostic, but there is no consensus on how they affect local control. We studied how PA recurrence-free survival (RFS) may be affected by the most relevant risk factors in a time-to-event analysis, comparing them with those observed in a population of non-PA (NPA).

METHODS

Patients undergoing parotidectomy for benign lesions between 2002 and 2018 in a single academic tertiary referral center were included. A description of patients, tumors, and treatment characteristics was performed, highlighting differences between PA and NPA. Analysis of PA RFS and relative risk factors was also conducted.

RESULTS

Eight hundred fifty patients underwent parotidectomy for benign lesions, 455 (53.5%) for PA and 57 (6.7%) for NPA. Significant differences between PA and NPA were age at surgery, surgical procedure, and resection margins. Recurrence occurred in 3.1% of PA, with a median disease-free interval of 54 months. 2-, 5-, and 10-year RFS were 99.2, 98.5, and 93.9%, respectively. Age < 18 years (HR = 31.31, p < 0.001), intraoperative tumor spillage (HR = 6.57, p = 0.041), extensive pseudo-capsule interruption (HR = 5.85, p = 0.023), and resection margins < 1 mm (HR = 3.16, p = 0.085) were associated with RFS.

CONCLUSION

Patients affected by NPA were significantly older and treated with more conservative surgical procedures compared to those with PA. In PA, younger age, major pseudo-capsule defects, and surgical margins were the most relevant factors affecting local control. These results confirm the importance of an appropriate surgical management and long-term follow-up in PA.

Prospective study on complications using different techniques for parotidectomy for benign tumors

OBJECTIVES

Long-term prospective studies on procedure-related complications after parotid surgery for benign neoplasms (BNs) are scarce. This is the first prospective study on the use of extracapsular dissection (ECD) for BNs, and it aimed to examine the incidence of postoperative complications after parotid surgery for BN.

METHODS

We collected data obtained in a prospective study of parotidectomy for BN at a university hospital and analyzed the transient and long-term complications.

RESULTS

The incidence rates of transient facial palsy immediately and 18 months after surgery were 15.0% and 3.7%, respectively. The rates of immediate postoperative facial palsy in patients who underwent ECD, partial superficial, superficial, and total parotidectomy were 5.8%, 29.3%, 20.0%, and 44.1%, respectively. Significant risk factors for facial palsy included multiple and larger lesions as well as surgery duration and extension.

CONCLUSIONS

Postoperative facial palsy remains a common complication after parotidectomy for BN and is associated with the extent of parotidectomy, presence of multiple neoplasms, and operative duration. The results of this study showed that ECD could be a safe technique for avoiding facial palsy. Level of Evidence: 2.

Selective deep lobe parotidectomy via retroauricular hairline (Roh's) incision for deep lobe parotid pleomorphic adenoma

OBJECTIVE

Deep lobe parotid tumour is commonly removed with the covering superficial lobe of parotid gland. Total or subtotal parotidectomy leads to an increase in surgical morbidity. This study evaluated recurrence and function after selective deep lobe parotidectomy via retroauricular hairline (Roh's) incision for pleomorphic adenoma.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-eight patients with deep lobe parotid pleomorphic adenomas underwent selective deep lobe parotidectomy with preservation of the superficial lobe and the facial lobe via Roh's incision. Each patient was evaluated with any complications, cosmetic and salivary functions and local recurrence.

RESULTS

Superficial lobe-preserving surgery via Roh's incision was successfully applied to all patients without injury to the facial nerve and the Stensen's duct for a median operation time of 65 min. Facial nerve paralysis was found only temporarily in 9 (32%) patients, and other complications were minimal. None of the patients had postoperative Frey's syndrome. Salivary secretory function in the operated side was well preserved. No recurrence was found in the patients for a median follow-up of 94 months.

CONCLUSIONS

Selective deep lobe parotidectomy via Roh's incision is a reliable option of treatment for deep lobe parotid pleomorphic adenoma.

The importance of the patient's perspective in function-sparing parotid surgery for benign neoplasms: clinical reappraisal

Objective

Function-sparing surgery is the cornerstone for the treatment of benign parotid neoplasms. We assessed the incidences and determinants of the main postoperative complications, reappraising their influence on the patient’s quality of life (QoL).

Methods

Patients who underwent parotid surgery for benign neoplasms were reviewed (2016-2019). Parotidectomy Outcome Inventory-8 (POI-8) and condition-specific questionnaires were used to investigate the patient’s perspective.

Results

We enrolled 211 patients. Preservation of the posterior branch of the great auricular nerve (GAN) seemed to reduce early dysfunction (87% vs 96%, p = 0.053), but not the late one. Deep lobe dissection and resection of more than one parotid segment favoured first bite syndrome (FBS) and Frey’s syndrome (FS), respectively (16% vs 3%, p = 0.003; 37% vs 15%, p = 0.003). Neither GAN impairment, FBS, nor FS influenced patient QoL. Facial weakness affected 19 patients (9%), being more likely after total parotidectomy (23% vs 7%, p = 0.034). According to POI-8, QoL was mainly jeopardised by fear of revision surgery, especially in females (p= 0.005) and those experiencing early complications (p= 0.004).

Conclusions

Reappraisal of the patient’s perspective after functional parotid surgery is fundamental to tailor preoperative counselling.

An update on extracapsular dissection for the management of parotid gland pleomorphic adenoma

Superficial parotidectomy has been the gold standard for surgical removal of benign mobile parotid gland tumours. The comparatively newer technique of extracapsular dissection, which involves careful dissection of the tumour itself without the need for formal gland excision, has gained popularity in recent years. Tumours can be removed via smaller incision, and the technique reduces the risk of Frey's syndrome (gustatory sweating) and hollowing at the site of surgery. The risk of facial nerve damage can also be lower with extracapsular dissection. If done carefully, the incidence of tumour recurrence, particularly for pleomorphic adenomas, is comparable with formal parotidectomy. We provide a brief update overview of the current evidence for extracapsular dissection in the treatment of benign parotid tumours and include several meta-analyses which provide evidence for the safety of the technique. We have also included our audited results of over 100 recent extracapsular dissections, with 0% incidence of permanent facial nerve weakness, reported Frey's syndrome and recurrence rates over the last 5 years.

Predictors of Sialocele or Salivary Fistula After Partial Superficial Parotidectomy for Benign Parotid Tumor: A Retrospective Study

PURPOSE

Partial superficial parotid (PSP) resection is the mainstay of treatment for benign parotid tumor. Unfortunately, the post-surgical formation of sialocele or salivary fistula is a well-recognized complication of parotid surgery. The aim of this study was to determine the predictors of sialocele or salivary fistula after PSP resection for parotid benign tumor.

METHODS

This retrospective cohort study includes patients who underwent PSP resection for benign parotid tumors from January 1, 2015 to December 31, 2019. The predictor variables were demographic data, systemic disease, smoking history, tumor size and type, surgical approach, and area. The outcome variables were the occurrence of sialocele or salivary fistula after PSP resection. Each possible risk factor was then examined using univariate analysis. Variables associated with sialocele or salivary fistula in the univariate analysis were then included in a multiple logistic regression model, and analyzed for possible factors related to the occurrence of sialocele or salivary fistula after partial superficial parotid resection.

RESULTS

The sample was composed of 872 subjects with a mean age of 51.0 ± 8.3, and 59.5% were male. The frequency of sialocele or salivary fistula after partial superficial parotid resection was 10.4% (n = 92). Based on the multiple logistic regression model, hypertension and location of the lesion were associated with sialocoele formation. Hypertension was associated with a decreased risk for the formation of sialocele or salivary fistula (ORs = 0.6, 95% CI = [0.4,1.003], P = .051). When compared the superior lesions, anterior lesions were associated with a decreased risk for the formation of sialocele or salivary fistula (ORs = 0.32, 95% CI = [0.111,0.92], P = .034) and lesions in the middle were associated with an increased risk for sialocele or salivary fistula development (ORs = 2.315,95% CI = [1.199,4.469], P = .012).

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of sialocele or salivary fistula development was 10.4% in patients undergoing partial superficial parotidectomy in this study. Moreover, middle and anterior tumor location was shown to increase sialocele or salivary fistula risk.

Observation Rather than Surgery for Benign Parotid Tumors: Why, When, and How

Surgery is the preferred treatment of benign parotid lesions, but it carries a risk of complications. Therefore, the approach toward the surgery of these lesions should seek to avoid complications. There are no guidelines or recommendations for when not to operate. Integration of comorbidities and other factors shift the scales from surgery toward observation in a small subset of patients presenting with parotid tumors. When observation is chosen, the patient should be followed frequently and cautiously, and the surgeon should be prepared to change strategy to surgical excision if in doubt.

Risk Factors of Postoperative Facial Palsy for Benign Parotid Tumors: Outcome of 1,018 Patients

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the rate of postoperative facial palsy in benign parotid tumors, as well as its risk factors, pathology, and clinical results.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective analysis.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of data from patients whose initial operation for a benign parotid tumor had been performed in our department between 1999 and 2020.

RESULTS

We included 1,018 patients in this study. The most common tumor observed was pleomorphic adenoma (614 patients), followed by Warthin tumor (234 patients). Fine-needle aspiration cytology and frozen section biopsy were used to identify the tumor histopathology. The overall rate of postoperative facial nerve palsy was 19.5%; the rate was significantly higher in patients with large-diameter tumors or deep lobe tumors. Postoperative facial palsy improved within 24 months of surgery in all cases. There were no cases with permanent facial palsy.

CONCLUSIONS

Postoperative facial nerve palsy developed regularly after surgery to remove benign parotid tumors despite preservation of the nerve. Palsy rate was high in patients with large tumors or deep lobe tumors. Despite the high risk of facial palsy in these patients and the benign nature of the tumor, we recommend surgery rather than follow-up observation, as the risk of postoperative facial palsy may increase as the tumor grows. It is important to provide an accurate explanation on the risks of postoperative complications to all patients to obtain appropriate informed consent for surgery.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 2021.

Can Ultrasound in Combination with Virtual Touch Imaging Quantification Predict the Dignity of a Parotid Tumor?

Pre-operative evaluation of a parotid gland tumor is crucial in guiding treatment. This study evaluates the diagnostic performance of B-mode ultrasound in combination with Virtual Touch imaging quantification (VTIQ) in the assessment of parotid lesions. A prospective study of 268 patients with parotid lesions was conducted. Pre-operative ultrasound findings and VTIQ data were compared against histologic results. Ill-defined margins on ultrasound were associated with a significantly higher risk of malignancy (odds ratio [OR] = 1224.0, 95 % confidence interval [CI]: 151.8-9872.7). Faster mean shear waves on VTIQ (OR = 1.81, 95% CI: 1.47-2.23, per 1 m/s increase) and an area with shear wave velocity >6.0 m/s involving >70 % of the lesion (OR = 19.80, 95 % CI: 6.22-63.07) were associated with higher risk of malignancy. Addition of VTIQ to routine pre-operative B-mode ultrasound can provide supplemental information on the dignity of a parotid tumor, allowing for peri-operative procedural optimization.

Intraoperative botulinum toxin injection for superficial partial parotidectomy: A prospective pilot study

OBJECTIVES

Sialocele and salivary fistula are not serious but troublesome complications after parotidectomy. Various modalities have been introduced to prevent postoperative saliva-related complications. However, clinical trials assessing the prophylactic use of botulinum toxin (BTX) for parotidectomy have not been conducted yet. Herein, we report a pilot study investigating the safety and efficacy of intraoperative BTX (iBTX) injection in partial superficial parotidectomy (PSP).

PARTICIPANTS

Patients with benign parotid tumour were prospectively recruited for this clinical trial from 2017 to 2019. The study participants underwent PSP with iBTX injection. We retrospectively reviewed the clinical information of all the consecutive patients who underwent PSP without iBTX from 2013 to 2019. These patients were divided into two groups: the iBTX group (n = 36) and the control group (n = 54).

RESULTS

Permanent facial palsy was not observed in either group. Two patients (3.7%) had transient marginal palsy in the control group but none had it in the iBTX group. The incidence of sialocele was significantly lower in the iBTX group than in the control group (2.8% vs. 20.4%, P < .05). Although the incidence of salivary fistula was lower in the iBTX group than in the control group (0% vs. 7.4%), no significant difference was determined between the two groups (P = .147). Total drainage volume was significantly lower in the iBTX group than in the control group (55.0 mL vs. 116.6 mL, P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

iBTX injection may be safe and effective in reducing sialocele and postoperative drainage in PSP. It might be a useful option to prevent saliva-related complications after PSP.

Refinement of the surgical indication and increasing expertise are associated with a better quality of pathology specimen in pleomorphic adenomas

BACKGROUND

Traditional surgical philosophy condemns extracapsular dissection for pleomorphic adenoma as a euphemism for the enucleation of this lesion.

OBJECTIVES

The aims of the study were to trace the development of surgical treatment by pleomorphic adenomas of the parotid gland over the last 15 years and explore its effects on the histopathology specimen.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The medical records of all cases with pleomorphic adenomas of the parotid gland between 2006 and 2020 were examined for information on age, gender, and type of surgery. An experienced head and neck pathologist re-evaluated the histology slides from all the cases.

RESULTS

The study included 844 patients. Our analysis showed an increase in the performance of extracapsular dissection from 52.8% (2006) to 63.3% (2020), and an increase in histopathology specimens with tumours completely covered by healthy tissue from 27.7% (2006) to 50% (2020).

CONCLUSIONS

Our decision-making process reached its peak in the last study years, in terms of reduced surgical invasiveness and quality of the pathology specimen.

SIGNIFICANCE

Extracapsular dissection has gained a firm hold as an indispensable tool for the experienced parotid surgeon. Proper indication is based on careful selection of cases and the correct interpretation of preoperative features on palpation and imaging.

Is extracapsular dissection for pleomorphic adenoma rather a euphemism for enucleation that jeopardises the intactness of the capsule?

The aim of this study was to compare several surgical modalities with respect to the incidence of positive margins and focal capsular exposure of pleomorphic adenoma of the parotid gland. The clinical records and histopathological findings of all patients who underwent parotidectomy for pleomorphic adenoma between 2006 and 2020 were retrospectively evaluated (n = 845). The lesion was removed by extracapsular dissection in 577 cases (68%) and facial nerve dissection in 268 (32%). Our analysis did not reveal a statistically significant difference between the examined modalities regarding positive margins (p=0.648) or capsular exposure (p=0.112). Recurrences were detected in 7/845 cases (0.82%) with a mean (range) follow-up time of 82.3 (6-183) months. The choice of surgical method does not seem to have a significant effect on the incidence of positive margins, or on the capsular exposure of a pleomorphic adenoma.

Satellite nodules in pleomorphic adenomas of the parotid gland: A nightmare for less invasive parotid surgery?

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to thoroughly investigate the incidence of satellite nodules (SN) and some of their characteristics (number, distance to main lesion) in a large series of pleomorphic adenomas (PA) and to compare several surgical modalities regarding their efficacy in addressing this critical morphological feature.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The records of all patients treated for primary PA of the parotid gland between 2006 and 2020 were studied retrospectively. All the histological slides of all tumours were critically re-evaluated for this study by an experienced head and neck pathologist.

RESULTS

845 cases made up our initial study sample. SNs were detected in 68/845 cases (8%). No statistically significant difference could be detected in the incidence of SNs in the surgical specimens between the patient groups managed by extracapsular dissection (46/577, 7.9%) and facial nerve dissecting surgery (22/268, 8.2%, p = 0.502). In the group of cases with SNs, no recurrences were detected (mean follow-up time: 71.4 months). The mean distance from the main lesion to the most distant SN was 1.1 mm (0.08-6.3 mm). The mean size of the SN was 1.9 mm (0.1-9.7 mm). Altogether, the mean distance from the main lesion to the outer periphery of the most distant SN was 3.1 mm (0.4-10.5 mm).

CONCLUSION

Our analysis could not award SNs the title of an "extracapsular dissection's nightmare". In the majority of cases, their favourable histological patterns offer the ideal circumstances for their surgical inclusion in a tumour specimen.

Resection of benign tumours of the submandibular gland with harmonic scalpel-assisted minimally extracapsular dissection

Objective

This study was performed to compare the oncologic and functional outcomes in patients with benign submandibular gland (SMG) tumours after harmonic scalpel-assisted minimally extracapsular dissection (HS-MECD) or total gland excision (TGE).

Methods

In total, 133 consecutive patients who were preoperatively diagnosed with benign SMG tumours (pleomorphic adenoma, Warthin’s tumour, basal cell adenoma, or lymphoepithelial cyst) from 2013 to 2016 were included in this two-centre retrospective study. Sixty-four patients underwent HS-MECD and 69 patients underwent TGE. All tumours were within 4 cm. Surgical variables, complications, functional outcomes, and recurrence rates were evaluated.

Results

The operation time, blood loss, drainage time and volume, and length of hospital stay were significantly lower in the HS-MECD than TGE group. HS-MECD reduced local pain and transient facial nerve paralysis outcomes. Incision scars and facial deformities were less visible according to the visual analogue scale. No significant differences were found in either unstimulated or stimulated whole saliva at 1 month postoperatively, whilst higher unstimulated levels were detected in the HS-MECD group at 6 months. The recurrence rate was similar between the two groups.

Conclusion

For benign SMG tumours of <4 cm, HS-MECD represents a less invasive technique than TGE and affords patients increased postoperative functionality.

Single-surgeon parotidectomy outcomes in an academic center experience during a 15-year period

OBJECTIVE

As large single-surgeon series in the literature are lacking, we sought to review a single-surgeon's experience with parotidectomy in an academic center, with a focused analysis of pathology, technique, and facial nerve (FN) weakness. Benchmark values for complications and operative times with routine trainee involvement and without continuous FN monitoring are offered.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

All patients who underwent parotidectomy, performed by D. G. D., for benign and malignant disease between January 2004 and December 2018 at an academic center were reviewed.

RESULTS

A total of 924 parotidectomies, with adequate evaluatable data were identified. The majority of patients had benign tumors (70.9%). Partial/superficial parotidectomy was the most common approach (65.7%). Selective FN branch sacrifice was rare (12.3%), but significantly more common among patients with malignant pathology (33.8% vs 3.5% for benign, P < .0001). Among patients with intact FN, post-operative short- and long-term FN weaknesses were rare (6.5% and 1.7%, respectively). These rates were lower among patients with benign tumors (5.4% and 1.3%). Partial/superficial parotidectomy for benign tumors was associated with a low rate of short- and long-term FN weaknesses (2.7% and 0.9%). Mean OR time was 185 minutes.

CONCLUSION

This is the largest single-surgeon series on parotidectomy, spanning 15 years. We demonstrate excellent long- and short-term FN paresis rates with acceptable operative times without regular use of continuous FN monitoring and with routine trainee involvement. These findings may provide valuable insight into parotid tumor pathology, FN outcomes, and feasibility and expectations of performing parotidectomy in an academic setting.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4.

Is There A Role for Limited Parotid Resections for Primary Malignant Parotid Tumors?

(1) Background: Lateral or total parotidectomy are the standard surgical treatments for malignant parotid tumors. However, some authors have proposed a more limited procedure. (2) Methods: We performed a review of the literature on this topic. Studies were included that met the following criteria: malignant parotid tumors, information about the extent of surgical resection, treated with less than a complete lateral lobectomy, and information on local control and/or survival. Nine articles fulfilled the inclusion criteria. (3) Results: Eight of the nine series reported favorable results for the more limited approaches. Most used them for small, mobile, low-grade cancers in the lateral parotid lobe. Most authors have used a limited partial lateral lobectomy for a presumed benign lesion. The remaining study analyzed pediatric patients treated with enucleation with poor local control. (4) Conclusions: There is weak evidence for recommending less extensive procedures than a lateral parotid lobectomy. In the unique case of a partial lateral parotidectomy performed for a tumor initially thought to be benign but pathologically proved to be malignant, close follow-up can be recommended for low grade T1 that has been excised with free margins and does not have adverse prognostic factors.

Extracapsular Dissection in Pleomorphic Adenomas of the Parotid Gland: Results After 13 Years of Follow-up

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

To assess long-term results after the treatment of parotid pleomorphic adenomas (PPAs) using different surgical techniques and focusing on recurrence rates and the risk of adverse effects.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective analysis.

METHODS

Retrospective analysis of 182 patients treated exclusively for PPAs at a tertiary referral center between 2000 and 2004. Thorough follow-up examinations over a mean period of 13 years were possible in 53.8% (n = 98/182). Tumors were categorized according to the European Salivary Gland Society (ESGS) system to improve the comparison of outcomes. After different surgical resection strategies, recurrence rates, postoperative facial nerve paresis (FNP), and incidence of Frey's syndrome were assessed. The follow-up period included clinical examinations and imaging of every patient in the treating department.

RESULTS

Of 182 patients, extracapsular dissection (ED) was performed in 29.7%, and other surgical modalities (OSMs), including facial nerve dissection, in 70.3%. After the long-term follow-up, 98% of all the patients (n = 96/98) were recurrence free. When recurrence rates were compared, no significant differences were noted (P < .331). ED resulted in significantly lower FNP rates compared to OSMs (P < .001). FNP rates significantly increased with size and location of the tumors according to ESGS categories (temporary and permanent FNP, P = .04). Surgical invasiveness corresponded to a significant increase in the incidence of Frey's syndrome (P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

ED was associated with the lowest complication rates, but not with a higher risk of recurrence, when compared with OSM in the long-term course. As ED can be performed in the majority of PPAs, it can be regarded as the treatment of choice whenever possible.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 131:E445-E451, 2021.

Cross-sectional study on the occurrence of Frey's syndrome following superficial parotidectomy or extracapsular dissection

BACKGROUND

Most studies that examine postoperative outcomes after parotidectomy in patients with benign parotid gland tumors are based on retrospective chart reviews. Data about long-term results in patients with parotid gland surgery with patient contact are still sparsely published.

METHODS

During the period of 1960-2005, a total of 127 patients underwent either extracapsular dissection (ECD) or superficial parotidectomy (SP) and were available for interview. Patients were questioned about their postoperative outcome after parotid gland surgery.

RESULTS

The mean follow-up was 21.5 years. A total of 42 and 85 patients underwent ECD and SP, respectively. No significant differences were observed in the rates of permanent facial paralysis (SP 1.2% vs. ECD 7.1%; p = 0.1053) or recurrence (SP 4.7% vs. ECD 11.9%; p = 0.1557), and Frey's syndrome was diagnosed only after SP (10.6% vs. 0% after ECD, p = 0.0293). Frey's syndrome was detected more often compared to retrospective chart analysis.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that Frey's syndrome is underdiagnosed after SP without standardized follow-up examinations. Long-term follow-up should be applied to detect and treat gustatory sweating.

The diagnostic value of cytology in parotid Warthin's tumors: international multicenter series

INTRODUCTION

Warthin's tumor (WT) is a common benign salivary gland neoplasm with a negligible risk of malignant transformation. However, there is a risk of malignant tumors being misdiagnosed as WT on cytology and inappropriately managed conservatively.

METHODS

Patients from nine centers in Italy and the United Kingdom undergoing parotid surgery for cytologically diagnosed WT were included in this multicenter retrospective series. Definitive histology was compared with preoperative cytological diagnoses. Surgical complications were recorded.

RESULTS

A total of 496 tumors were identified. In 88.9%, the final histological diagnosis was WT. In 21 cases (4.2%) a malignant neoplasm was diagnosed, which had been incorrectly labeled as WT on cytology.

CONCLUSIONS

The risk of undiagnosed malignancy should be balanced against surgical risks when considering the management of WT. Although nonsurgical management remains an appropriate option, there may be a rationale for serial clinical or radiological evaluation if surgical excision is not performed.

Postoperative complications after removal of pleomorphic adenoma from the parotid gland: A long-term follow up of 297 patients from 2002 to 2016 and a review of publications

Pleomorphic adenomas are rounded, lumpy, capsulated lesions that are more common in women. They are typically benign, but can be associated with malignancy in a minority of cases (such as carcinoma ex pleomorphic adenoma), between 3% - 12% of the time, according to available data. The purpose of our study was to evaluate clinical outcomes in patients with benign parotid gland tumours after extracapsular dissection (ECD) or superficial parotidectomy (SP). We made a retrospective study of 297 patients who had had benign tumours of the parotid gland, and had been referred to our department from 2002 - 2016 to have either procedure. We measured the statistical differences between the two techniques (evaluated recurrence rate and complications) with the chi squared test. The chosen level of statistical significance was p<0.05. Median (range) follow-up time was 43 months (25-168) months. Haematoma and hypoaesthesia were significantly more common after SP than after ECD (8.9% compared with 7.7%, and 16.8% compared with 5.6%, respectively). Transient facial nerve injury, Frey syndrome, and facial paralysis were significantly more common after SP than after ECD (23.6% compared with 1.5%, 6.7% compared with 1% and 6,7% compared with 0%, respectively). ECD had the advantage of reduced operating time, lower morbidity and lower recurrence rate, and could be considered the treatment of choice for pleomorphic adenoma of the parotid gland up (to 3cm) which are mobile and sited in the superficial lobe of the parotid gland.