A three-dimensional analysis of the endolymph drainage system in Ménière disease

Meniere's Disease Patients with Distinct Sac Pathoanatomic Findings React Differently to Endolymphatic Duct Blockage

OBJECTIVES

To explore the possible difference in response to endolymphatic duct blockage (EDB) treatment in patients with Meniere's disease (MD) with distinct pathoanatomic characteristics of the sac.

METHODS

In a total of 24 patients with MD receiving EDB treatment, the dynamics of the vertigo attack, hearing, vestibular function, and endolymph hydrops (EH) before surgery and 40 months following surgery in patients with normoplastic extraosseous portion of endolymphatic sac (eES) were compared with that in patients with atrophic eES.

RESULTS

A higher prevalence of complete vertigo control, better cochlear and vestibular function, and lower endolymph to vestibule-volume ratio were found in patients with normoplastic eES than in those with atrophic eES. Moreover, the reversal of EH was found in a total of six patients in normoplastic eES group, but no reversal of EH was detected in the atrophic eES group after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

A difference in response to EDB treatment was shown in the MD patients with normoplastic eES and those with atrophic eES; the reversal of EH was found in the normoplastic eES group, but not in the atrophic eES group after surgery, suggesting two distinct pathologies in the eESs may underlie the pathogenesis of EH in two subgroups of MD patients.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 133:2761-2769, 2023.

Comparison of radiological abnormalities between the jugular bulb and the vestibular aqueduct in patients with Ménière's disease

Objective

Anatomical variations of the inner ear may contribute to the development of Ménière's disease (MD), which is a complex inner ear disorder histopathologically characterized by idiopathic endolymphatic hydrops (ELH). Abnormalities of the vestibular aqueduct (VA) and the jugular bulb (JB) have been suggested as predisposing factors. Yet, few studies have investigated the correlation between JB abnormalities and VA variations as well as its clinical relevance in these patients. In this retrospective study, we investigated the differences in the incidence of radiological abnormalities of the VA and JB in patients with definite MD.

Methods

Anatomical variations of JB and VA were evaluated based on high-resolution CT (HRCT) in a series of 103 patients with MD (93 unilateral cases and 10 bilateral cases). JB-related indices included JB anteroposterior and mediolateral diameter, JB height, JB type regarding to Manjila classification system, and incidences of JB diverticulum (JBD), JB related inner ear dehiscence (JBID), and inner ear adjacent JB (IAJB). VA-related indices included CT-VA visibility, CT-VA morphology (funnel, tubular, filiform, hollow, and obliterated-shaped type), and peri-VA pneumatization. Radiological indices were compared between MD ears and control ears.

Results

Radiological JB abnormalities were comparable between MD ears and control ears. As for VA-related indices, the CT-VA visibility was lower in MD ears than in control ears (p = 0.004). The distribution of CT-VA morphology was significantly different between MD and control ears (p = 0.013), with a higher proportion of obliterated-shaped type in MD ears (22.1%) than in control ears (6.6%).

Conclusion

Compared with JB abnormalities, the anatomical variations of VA are more likely to be an anatomically predisposing factor for MD.

Volumetry improves the assessment of the vestibular aqueduct size in inner ear malformation

OBJECTIVES

Enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA) is a common finding associated with inner ear malformations (IEM). However, uniform radiologic definitions for EVA are missing and various 2D-measurement methods to define EVA have been reported. This study evaluates VA volume in different types of IEM and compares 3D-reconstructed VA volume to 2D-measurements.

METHODS

A total of 98 high-resolution CT (HRCT) data sets from temporal bones were analyzed (56 with IEM; [cochlear hypoplasia (CH; n = 18), incomplete partition type I (IPI; n = 12) and type II (IPII; n = 11) and EVA (n = 15)]; 42 controls). VA diameter was measured in axial images. VA volume was analyzed by software-based, semi-automatic segmentation and 3D-reconstruction. Differences in VA volume between the groups and associations between VA volume and VA diameter were assessed. Inter-rater-reliability (IRR) was assessed using the intra-class-correlation-coefficient (ICC).

RESULTS

Larger VA volumes were found in IEM compared to controls. Significant differences in VA volume between patients with EVA and controls (p < 0.001) as well as between IPII and controls (p < 0.001) were found. VA diameter at the midpoint (VA midpoint) and at the operculum (VA operculum) correlated to VA volume in IPI (VA midpoint: r = 0.78, VA operculum: r = 0.91), in CH (VA midpoint: r = 0.59, VA operculum: r = 0.61), in EVA (VA midpoint: r = 0.55, VA operculum: r = 0.66) and in controls (VA midpoint: r = 0.36, VA operculum: r = 0.42). The highest IRR was found for VA volume (ICC = 0.90).

CONCLUSIONS

The VA diameter may be an insufficient estimate of VA volume, since (1) measurement of VA diameter does not reliably correlate with VA volume and (2) VA diameter shows a lower IRR than VA volume. 3D-reconstruction and VA volumetry may add information in diagnosing EVA in cases with or without additional IEM.

Endolymphatic duct and sac decompression: A new technique for Ménière’s disease treatment

Background:

The present article aims to introduce the endolymphatic duct and sac decompression technique (DASD) and to give a spotlight on its benefits in Ménière’s disease (MD) treatment.

Methods:

Eighty-two patients with intractable MD which met the inclusion criteria were recruited and underwent DASD. This technique allows a meningeal decompression of the duct and the sac from the posterior cranial fossa to the labyrinthine block. The authors considered as main outcomes, the change of the dizziness handicap inventory (DHI) results, with the evaluations of the three sub-scales (Functional scale, Physical scale, and Emotional scale); ear fullness and tinnitus change on the perceptions of the patient; and hearing stage with four-Pure Tone Average (500 hz-1000 hz-2000 hz-4000 hz). The differences between the preoperative and the postoperative score were evaluated. A comparison with the literature was conducted.

Results:

After a 14-month follow-up, patients that underwent DASD reported a remarkable improvement of the symptoms in all three functional scales, confirmed by the total DHI. The difference between preoperative and postoperative scores is statistically significant. The data describe an ear fullness and tinnitus improvement. The multi-frequency tonal average before and after the surgery does not suggest a worsening of the value for any of 82 patients.

Conclusion:

The modification of sac surgery includes the endolymphatic duct in the decompression area allowing inner ear functional improvement, vertigo control, ear fullness improvement with minimal risk of facial nerve paralysis, and hearing loss. DASD is an improved old surgical technique.

Vestibular Aqueduct Size Correlates With the Degree of Cochlear Hydrops in Patients With and Without Menière's Disease

OBJECTIVE

To correlate the CT imaging findings of the visibility and size of the vestibular aqueduct (VA) with the degree of the cochlear hydrops determined in MRI late imaging of the hydrops. Study Design: Retrospective study. Setting: Tertiary referral center. Patients: A total of 127 patients (62 women, 65 men, average age 55.6 yrs): 86 of these were diagnosed with Menière's disease (American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery [AAO-HNS] criteria; 67 unilateral, 19 bilateral).

INTERVENTIONS

Temporal bone CT and hydrops MRI were performed in all patients.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Visibility/width of the VA in temporal bone CT and grade of cochlear hydrops evaluated by MRI.

RESULTS

The width of the VA is significantly smaller in patients diagnosed with Menière's disease (30% non-visible VA), compared with the patients who did not fulfill the diagnostic criteria of Menière's disease (12% non-visible VA) (double sided Spearman correlation, p < 0.001). In all ears of patients diagnosed with Menière's disease the width of the VA was significantly correlated with the degree of the cochlear hydrops (in cases of non-visible VA 65% [34/52] ears presented with hydrops grade 3 or 4; 13% [7/52] ears presented with hydrops grade 1 or 2 and 21% [11/52] ears showed no hydrops) (Spearman correlation p = 0.001/p < 0.01). This is also true for all ears that can be summarized as hydrophic ear disease (symptomatic ears that present with a hydrops in MRI).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of our study could confirm the importance of the VA in the pathogenesis of the endolymphatic hydrops in vivo.

Functional aspects of the Eustachian tube by means of 3D-modeling

The extent of dysfunction of the Eustachian tube (ET) is relevant in understanding the pathogenesis of secondary otological diseases such as acute or chronic otitis media. The underlying mechanism of ET dysfunction remains poorly understood except for an apparent genesis such as a nasopharyngeal tumor or cleft palate. To better describe the ET, its functional anatomy, and the biomechanical valve mechanism and subsequent development of diagnostic and interventional tools, a three-dimensional model based on thin-layer histology was created from an ET in this study. Blackface sheep was chosen as a donor. The 3-D model was generated by the coherent alignment of the sections. It was then compared with the cone-beam computed tomography dataset of the complete embedded specimen taken before slicing. The model shows the topographic relation of the individual components, such as the bone and cartilage, the muscles and connective tissue, as well as the lining epithelium with the lumen. It indicates a limited spiraling rotation of the cartilaginous tube over its length and relevant positional relationships of the tensor and levator veli palatine muscles.

3D-reconstructions of Bast's Valve and Membranous Labyrinth: Insights for Vestibular Implantation and Meniere's Disease

HYPOTHESIS/BACKGROUND

Bast's valve is a poorly understood inner ear structure located at the junction between pars superior and inferior in the membranous labyrinth. Anatomically precise three-dimensional reconstructions (3D-reconstructions) of Bast's valve can help illuminate the morphology of the valve, and point toward its role in normal physiology and pathological states such as endolymphatic hydrops. This is of particular relevance to the development of a vestibular implant, a device intended to rehabilitate deficits in the vestibular system.

METHODS

Six postmortem human temporal bones from healthy donors were scanned using a micro-computed tomography (microCT) scanner. The microCT data allowed 3D-reconstructions of the membranous labyrinth, with a particular focus on Bast's valve, vestibule, and cochlear duct.

RESULTS

The microCT images of Bast's valve showed a rigid lip containing a core of soft tissue, opposing the thin membranous wall of the utricle. The maximum recorded length and width of the rigid lip were 440.4 μm and 88 μm, respectively. The 3D-reconstructions illustrated the slit-like opening of Bast's valve into the utricle, the twisting course of the basal turn of the cochlear duct, and the spatial orientation of utricle and saccule with respect to the stapes footplate.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study provided a novel anatomical perspective on the microscopic structure of Bast's valve. The interplay between endolymphatic hydrops and Bast's valve is an ongoing area of research, but defining this anatomy in 3D will play a key role in furthering our understanding of the disease process. Implications for vestibular implantation are explored through the various 3D-reconstructions.

A Synchrotron and Micro-CT Study of the Human Endolymphatic Duct System: Is Meniere's Disease Caused by an Acute Endolymph Backflow?

Background: The etiology of Meniere's disease (MD) and endolymphatic hydrops believed to underlie its symptoms remain unknown. One reason may be the exceptional complexity of the human inner ear, its vulnerability, and surrounding hard bone. The vestibular organ contains an endolymphatic duct system (EDS) bridging the different fluid reservoirs. It may be essential for monitoring hydraulic equilibrium, and a dysregulation may result in distension of the fluid spaces or endolymphatic hydrops. Material and Methods: We studied the EDS using high-resolution synchrotron phase contrast non-invasive imaging (SR-PCI), and micro-computed tomography (micro-CT). Ten fresh human temporal bones underwent SR-PCI. One bone underwent micro-CT after fixation and staining with Lugol's iodine solution (I2KI) to increase tissue resolution. Data were processed using volume-rendering software to create 3D reconstructions allowing orthogonal sectioning, cropping, and tissue segmentation. Results: Combined imaging techniques with segmentation and tissue modeling demonstrated the 3D anatomy of the human saccule, utricle, endolymphatic duct, and sac together with connecting pathways. The utricular duct (UD) and utriculo-endolymphatic valve (UEV or Bast's valve) were demonstrated three-dimensionally for the first time. The reunion duct was displayed with micro-CT. It may serve as a safety valve to maintain cochlear endolymph homeostasis under certain conditions. Discussion: The thin reunion duct seems to play a minor role in the exchange of endolymph between the cochlea and vestibule under normal conditions. The saccule wall appears highly flexible, which may explain occult hydrops occasionally preceding symptoms in MD on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The design of the UEV and connecting ducts suggests that there is a reciprocal exchange of fluid among the utricle, semicircular canals, and the EDS. Based on the anatomic framework and previous experimental data, we speculate that precipitous vestibular symptoms in MD arise from a sudden increase in endolymph pressure caused by an uncontrolled endolymphatic sac secretion. A rapid rise in UD pressure, mediated along the fairly wide UEV, may underlie the acute vertigo attack, refuting the rupture/K+-intoxication theory.

Correlation between High-Resolution Computed Tomography Scan Findings and Histological Findings in Human Vestibular End Organs and Surgical Implications

BACKGROUND

Histological study of vestibular end organs has been challenging due to the difficulty in preserving their structures for histological analysis and due to their complex geometry. Recently, radiology advances have allowed to deepen the study of the membranous labyrinth.

SUMMARY

A review and analysis of surgical implications related to the anatomy of the vestibular end organ is performed. Radiological advances are key in the advancement of the knowledge of the anatomy and pathology of the vestibule. Thus, application of such knowledge in the development or improvement of surgical procedures may facilitate the development of novel techniques. Key Messages: During the last few decades, the knowledge of the anatomy of the auditory system through histology and radiology had improved. Technological advances in this field may lead to a better diagnosis and therapeutic approach of most common and important diseases affecting the inner ear.

A possible mechanism of the formation of endolymphatic hydrops and its associated inner ear disorders

The pathology of Meniere's disease (MD) is well established to be endolymphatic hydrops. However, the mechanism underlying deafness and vertigo of MD or idiopathic endolymphatic hydrops is still unknown. In order to evaluate the pathogenesis of deafness and vertigo in MD, it seems to be rational to investigate the interrelationship between hydrops and inner ear disorders using animals with experimentally-induced endolymphatic hydrops. In spite of intense efforts by many researchers, the mechanism of vertiginous attack has been unexplained, because animals with experimental hydrops usually did not show vertiginous attack. Recently, there are two reports to succeed to evoke vertiginous attack in animals with experimental hydrops. In the present paper were first surveyed past proposals about underlying mechanism of the development of hydrops and inner ear disorders associated with hydrops, and were discussed the pathogenetic mechanism of vertiginous attack in hydrops. In conclusion, abrupt development of hydrops was thought to play a pivotal role in the onset of vertiginous seizure.

Contributions of Contemporary Human Temporal Bone Histopathology to Clinical Otology

Contemporary techniques have greatly enhanced the contributions of human temporal bone (HTB) histopathology to our understanding of the mechanisms of human otologic disease and disease treatment. Herein, we review some of the most salient contributions of this research to disease management. The field of HTB histopathology is challenged by limited resources as applies to trained investigators, infrastructure, and well-equipped laboratories. This research provides insights into clinical otology that cannot be obtained by any other means. Measures should be taken to preserve and extend the contributions of HTB research.

Volume-rendered computed tomography images of the surgical field for endolymphatic sac surgery

PURPOSE

Identification of the endolymphatic sac has failed occasionally. Postoperative complications have also rarely been reported. Given a safer and more reliable surgery, preoperative anatomical assessments are valuable, however, the vestibular aqueduct has seldom been seen with multi-planar reconstruction (MPR) computed tomography (CT) images yet. Our study aimed to determine the significance and utility of volume-rendered (VR) CT images of the surgical field for identifying the vestibular aqueduct, compared with MPR CT images.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

14 patients with Meniere's disease who underwent endolymphatic sac surgery between 2008 and 2011. Location and size of the vestibular aqueduct were assessed using VR and MPR CT images, independently.

RESULTS

Accuracy of identifying the location differed significantly between VR and MPR CT images (rate of total correct evaluations: 100% by VR CT images vs 75% by MPR CT images, p = 0.02). Size was correctly identified in cases with a small endolymphatic sac using VR CT images (rate of total correct evaluations for size of the vestibular aqueduct: 100% by VR CT vs 57% by MPR CT, p = 0.046). VR CT images also demonstrated clearly the relationship between the endolymphatic sac and high jugular bulb. In two cases, the endolymphatic sac was identified by VR images, not by MPR images.

CONCLUSION

Accurate information about the location and size of vestibular aqueduct can allow sac surgeons to identify a tiny endolymphatic sac more easily and certainly, and also aids surgical trainees to learn sac surgery safely.

Three-dimensional study of vestibular anatomy as it relates to the stapes footplate and its clinical implications: an augmented reality development

BACKGROUND

The anatomy of the membranous labyrinth within the vestibule has direct implications for surgical intervention. The anatomy of the otoliths has been studied, but there is limited information regarding their supporting connective tissue structures such as the membrana limitans in humans.

METHODS

One guinea pig and 17 cadaveric human temporal bones were scanned using micro computed tomography, after staining with 2 per cent osmium tetroxide and preservation with Karnovsky's solution, with a resolution from 1 µm to 55 µm. The data were analysed using VGStudio Max software, rendered in three-dimensions and published in augmented reality.

RESULTS

In 50 per cent of ears, the membrana limitans attached directly to the postero-superior part of the stapes footplate. If attachments were present in one ear, they were present bilaterally in 100 per cent of cases.

CONCLUSION

Micro computed tomography imaging allowed three-dimensional assessment of the inner ear. Such assessments are important as they influence the surgical intervention and the evolution of future innovations.

Gadolinium-enhanced MRI reveals dynamic development of endolymphatic hydrops in Ménière's disease

INTRODUCTION

Meniere's disease is associated with impaired hearing, tinnitus, vertigo, and aural fullness. Many anatomical studies have suggested idiopathic endolymphatic hydrops as the pathological basis of Meniere's disease, which now can be visualized by using gadolinium -enhanced magnetic resonance imaging of the inner ear.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the development of endolymphatic hydrops in Meniere's disease by monitoring the vestibules and cochleae of affected patients.

METHODS

Inner ears of 178 patients with definite unilateral Meniere's disease diagnosis were visualized by 3-dimensional fluid-attenuated inversion recovery and three-dimensional real inversion recovery magnetic resonance imaging following bilateral gadolinium intratympanic injection. The scans were used to evaluate the presence and degree of endolymphatic hydrops in the vestibules and cochlear structures, including the cochlear apical turn, the cochlear middle turn, and the cochlear basal turn. The correlation of endolymphatic hydrops occurrence between the various parts of the inner ear was determined.

RESULTS

Symptomatic endolymphatic hydrops was detected on the affected side in all patients, whereas asymptomatic endolymphatic hydrops was detected on the unaffected contra-lateral side in 32 patients (18.0%). On the affected side, the cochlear apical turn and the cochlear middle turn demonstrated significantly higher rates of endolymphatic hydrops than the cochlear basal turn and the vestibule. The severity of endolymphatic hydrops gradually decreased from the cochlear apical turn to the cochlear basal turn. On the contra lateral side, the incidence and degree of the detected asymptomatic endolymphatic hydrops were significantly greater in the cochleae than in the vestibules (p<0.05), with no significant difference detected between the cochlear turns.

CONCLUSION

Progression of endolymphatic hydrops appears to be directional, initiated in the cochlea. The order of endolymphatic hydrops severity gradually decreases from the cochlear apical turn to the cochlear basal turn and then to the vestibule. Endolymphatic hydrops in the vestibule is associated with symptomatic Meniere's disease.

Otopathology in the United States: History, Current Situation, and Future Perspectives

: Human temporal bone studies have documented the pathophysiologic basis of many pathologic conditions and diseases affecting the ear, contributing to the development of specific clinical knowledge and pathology-oriented treatments. Researchers dedicated to the study of anatomy and histology of the temporal bone emanated from Europe to the United States during the first part of the 20th Century. The first otopathology laboratory was founded in the United States in 1924, at Johns Hopkins University; over time, the otopathology laboratories-considered by some authors as "gold mines" for studying ear diseases-became numerous and very prolific. However, today, only three of the temporal bone laboratories are still running and producing scientific knowledge to the Otology/Neurotology field: the ones at Harvard Medical School, University of Minnesota, and University of California. Molecular biologic assay techniques and new microscopy and computer equipment broadened the possibilities for temporal bone studies; however, the current funding for those laboratories are insufficient to cover the costs for processing and studying human temporal bones. The main objective of this study is to briefly describe the history, current situation, and future perspectives of the otopathology laboratories in the United States.

A 3-D analysis of the protympanum in human temporal bones with chronic ear disease

Eustachian tube dysfunction is believed to be an important factor to cholesteatoma development and recurrence of disease after surgical treatment. Although many studies have described prognostic factors, evaluation methods, or surgical techniques for Eustachian tube dysfunction, they relied on the soft tissues of its structure; little is known about its bony structure-the protympanum-which connects the Eustachian tube to the tympanic cavity, and can also be affected by several inflammatory conditions, both from the middle ear or from the nasopharynx. We studied temporal bones from patients with cholesteatoma, chronic otitis media (with and without retraction pockets), purulent otitis media, and non-diseased ears, looking for differences between the volume of the protympanum, the diameter of the Eustachian tube isthmus, and the distance between the anterior tympanic annulus and the promontory. Light microscopy and 3-D reconstruction software were used for the measurements. We observed a decrease of volume in the lumen of the four middle ear diseased ears compared to the control group. We observed a significant decrease in the volume of the protympanic space in the cholesteatoma group compared to the chronic otitis media group. We also observed a decrease in the bony space (protympanum space) in cholesteatoma, chronic otitis media with retraction pockets, and purulent otitis media compared to the control group. We found a correlation in middle ear diseases and a decrease in the middle ear space. Our findings may suggest that a smaller bony volume in the protympanic area may trigger middle ear dysventilation problems.