A separation of innate and learned vocal behaviors defines the symptomatology of spasmodic dysphonia

"Lombard Effect" and Voice Changes in Adductor Laryngeal Dystonia: A Pilot Study

OBJECTIVES

The aim was to describe the acoustic, auditory-perceptive, and subjective voice changes under the Lombard effect (LE) in adductor laryngeal dystonia (AdLD) patients.

METHODS

Subjective perception of vocal effort (OMNI Vocal Effort Scale OMNI-VES), Maximum Phonation Time (MPT), and the perceptual severity of dysphonia (GRBAS scale) were assessed in condition of stillness and under LE in 10 AdLD patients and in 10 patients with typical voice. Speakers were asked to produce the sustained vowel /a/ and to read a phonetically balanced text aloud. Using the PRAAT software, the following acoustic parameters were analyzed: Mean Pitch (Hz), Minimum and Maximum Intensity (dB), the Fraction of Locally Unvoiced Frames, the Number of Voice Breaks, the Degree of Voice Breaks (%), the Cepstral Peak Prominence-Smoothed (CPPS) (dB).

RESULTS

Under LE, the AdLD group showed a decrease of both G and S parameters of GRBAS and subjective effort, mean MPT increased significantly; in the controls there were no significant changes. In both groups under LE, pitch and intensity of the sustained vowel /a/ significantly increased consistently with LE. In the AdLD group the mean gain of OMNI-VES score and the mean gain of each parameter of the speech analysis were significantly greater than the controls' ones.

CONCLUSION

Auditory feedback deprivation obtained under LE improves subjective, perceptual-auditory, and acoustics parameters of AdLD patients. These findings encourage further research to provide new knowledge into the role of the auditory system in the pathogenesis of AdLD and to develop new therapeutic strategies.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 134:3754-3760, 2024.

Demographic and clinical characteristics of our patients diagnosed with laryngeal dystonia

PURPOSE

Laryngeal dystonia (LD) is a focal dystonia affecting laryngeal musculature with no known etiology or cure. The present study evaluated the sociodemographic and clinical features of patients diagnosed with LD.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

All patients diagnosed with LD at our University Hospital's Ear, Nose, and Throat Department between January 2017 and July 2023 were retrospectively analyzed. The study included 43 patients.

RESULTS

Out of the 43 patients, 19 (44%) were male. At the time of diagnosis, the mean age of the patients was 35.1 years (ranging from 17 to 65 years). The mean elapsed time between the first symptom onset and the first diagnosis was 49.2 months (min. 4 months, max. 240 months). Of the participants, 94% had adductor-type LD. None of the patients had a family history of LD. Of the patients, 9 (20%) experienced a life-altering event or trauma just before the onset of symptoms. All patients who consumed alcohol reported symptom relief with alcohol intake. A total of 67.6% of patients stated that their symptoms were triggered by stress. All of our patients received at least one Botulinum toxin injection, with an average of 2.75 dosages per patient.

CONCLUSION

The gender distribution was approximately equitable between males and females. There was a tendency for men to receive a diagnosis earlier than women following the manifestation of symptoms. A significant number of patients associate the emergence of their symptoms with a stressful event or traumatic experience. This study represents the initial investigation into the sociodemographic characteristics of patients within the Turkish population.

Improved vocal quality and decreased vocal effort after botulinum toxin treatment for laryngeal dystonia

OBJECTIVES

Laryngeal dystonia (LD) is characterized by irregular and involuntary task-specific spasms of the intrinsic laryngeal muscles. There is no curative treatment for it, however, laryngeal botulinum neurotoxin injections (BoNT-I) are considered the standard of care therapy. This study aims to characterize the population of LD patients and to assess the results of laryngeal BoNT-I.

METHODS

A Retrospective cohort study was conducted. Medical records were reviewed for all the patients with LD diagnosis seen in the Voice Unit of the Red de Salud UCChristus between January 2013 and October 2021. Biodemographic, clinical and treatment data were collected. Additionally, a telephonic survey was completed by the patients that underwent laryngeal BoNT-I, including self-reported voice outcomes and Voice Handicap Index 10 (VHI-10).

RESULTS

Of the 34 patients with LD included in the study, 23 received a total of 93 laryngeal BoNT-I and 19 completed the telephone survey. The majority (97%) of the injections corresponded to patients with adductor LD and 3% to abductor LD. Patients received a median of 3 (1-17) injections, with a more frequent cricothyroid approach (94.4%), while the thyrohyoid approach accounted for 5.6% of cases. Most injections were bilateral (96.8%). A significant improvement in the vocal quality and effort was noted after the last injection and the overall BoNT-I treatment (P < 0.001). Similarly, the VHI-10 score improved from a median of 31 (7-40) to 2 (0-19) (P < 0.001) after the last injection. A post-treatment breathy voice was reported in 95% of patients, and dysphagia to liquids and solids in 68% and 21%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Laryngeal BoNT-I is an effective treatment for LD, achieving an improvement in self-reported vocal quality and VHI-10 scores, and a reduction of the self-reported vocal effort. Adverse effects are mild in the majority of cases, constituting a safe and effective therapy for these patients.

Incidence and risk factors for secondary extralaryngeal dystonia in patients with laryngeal dystonia

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Laryngeal dystonia (LD) is a focal dystonia affecting adductor and/or abductor muscles of the larynx. It can be isolated or may spread to extra laryngeal muscles. The aim of this study was to report the characteristics of LD over time in a large single-center study with a long follow-up.

METHODS

Retrospective review of patients with LD referred to our institution between 1991 and 2021. Demographic data, time to diagnosis, type of LD, follow-up and spread of dystonia [SD] were recorded. Risk factors for spread of dystonia during follow-up were analyzed.

RESULTS

Over the 30-year period, 516 patients (77.3 % female, median age 50 years, range 5-87 years) were analyzed. Three hundred and fifteen patients (61 %) had adduction laryngeal dystonia, 136 patients (26.4 %) had abduction laryngeal dystonia, 46 patients (8.9 %) had adductor respiratory laryngeal dystonia, 12 patients (2.3 %) had mixed laryngeal dystonia, and seven patients (1.4 %) had singer's laryngeal dystonia. A previous history of dystonia was found in 47 patients (9.1 %). A laryngeal tremor was found in 68 patients (13.2 %). Since the onset of symptoms, LD was diagnosed after a median of 3 years (IQR: 1.0, 7.0). SD occurred in 55 patients (10.7 %) after a median time of 4 year (IQR: 1.5, 13.0). Patients with mixed laryngeal dystonia had higher probability of SD (p = 0.018).

DISCUSSION

This study reports a large European study of LD, with a long follow-up. SD occurred in 10.5 % of patients. Patients with mixed laryngeal dystonia had a higher probability of SD. A close follow-up may be recommended for patients with mixed laryngeal dystonia.

Temporal Signature of Task-Specificity in Isolated Focal Laryngeal Dystonia

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Laryngeal dystonia (LD) is focal task-specific dystonia, predominantly affecting speech but not whispering or emotional vocalizations. Prior neuroimaging studies identified brain regions forming a dystonic neural network and contributing to LD pathophysiology. However, the underlying temporal dynamics of these alterations and their contribution to the task-specificity of LD remain largely unknown. The objective of the study was to identify the temporal-spatial signature of altered cortical oscillations associated with LD pathophysiology.

METHODS

We used high-density 128-electrode electroencephalography (EEG) recordings during symptomatic speaking and two asymptomatic tasks, whispering and writing, in 24 LD patients and 22 healthy individuals to investigate the spectral dynamics, spatial localization, and interregional effective connectivity of aberrant cortical oscillations within the dystonic neural network, as well as their relationship with LD symptomatology.

RESULTS

Symptomatic speaking in LD patients was characterized by significantly increased gamma synchronization in the middle/superior frontal gyri, primary somatosensory cortex, and superior parietal lobule, establishing the altered prefrontal-parietal loop. Hyperfunctional connectivity from the left middle frontal gyrus to the right superior parietal lobule was significantly correlated with the age of onset and the duration of LD symptoms. Asymptomatic whisper in LD patients had not no statistically significant changes in any frequency band, whereas asymptomatic writing was characterized by significantly decreased synchronization of beta-band power localized in the right superior frontal gyrus.

CONCLUSION

Task-specific oscillatory activity of prefrontal-parietal circuitry is likely one of the underlying mechanisms of aberrant heteromodal integration of information processing and transfer within the neural network leading to dystonic motor output. © 2023 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Laryngeal Sensory Symptoms in Spasmodic Dysphonia

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this research was to determine whether an association between laryngeal hypersensitivity (LH) and spasmodic dysphonia (SD) exists using the LH Questionnaire (LHQ). This study also explored the prevalence of self-reported upper respiratory infection (URI) at the time of SD onset across SD phenotypes.

METHODS

Individuals with and without SD were recruited to complete an online survey measure. All respondents provided demographic information and completed the LHQ. Participants with SD were also asked to provide information about their diagnosed SD subtype and pattern of onset, including whether onset was associated with a URI. The percentage of respondents with and without SD who were classified with LH was determined based on the LHQ. Scores on the LHQ were also compared between the non-SD and the SD groups, as well as between SD phenotypes (adductor SD, abductor SD, and mixed)).

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Significant associations were found between ADSD and LH, mixed SD and LH, and URI at time of SD onset and increased severity of LH symptoms. These findings suggest that laryngeal sensory symptoms may potentially contribute to or result from motor spasms in SD and/or have implications for its pathophysiology.

Spasmodic dysphonia: An overview of clinical features and treatment options

Spasmodic dysphonia (SD) is considered a rare focal laryngeal dystonia characterized by task-specific voice dysfluency resulting from selective intrinsic laryngeal musculature hyperfunction. Symptoms may be attenuated by a sensory trick. Although SD can be seen at times in generalized dystonia syndrome, it is typically a sporadic phenomenon, and the involvement of the laryngeal adductor muscles is more common than that of the abductor muscles. This research reviews the literature for the pathogenesis, clinical characteristics, treatment options, and current management methods of SD. Technological advances have enabled clinicians to better understand the connection between laryngeal function and dysfunction. Refinements in imaging and genetic investigation techniques have helped better understand the underlying mechanisms of this neurolaryngology disorder. Currently, the standard of care for SD is the symptomatic management of botulinum toxin (BT) chemodenervation. This is supported by a large body of literature attesting to its efficacy in many different research studies, particularly in the uncomplicated adductor form of the disorder. Efforts towards surgical treatment predate the development of BT treatment by a decade, but the long-term efficacy has not been proven and, further research is expected. Symptom relief in patients with abductor SD and dystonia with tremors after surgical and BT treatments and those in patients remains suboptimal.

Singing Voice Concern in Tertiary Laryngology Practice

OBJECTIVES

To determine the prevalence and characteristics of patients who identify singing voice as a primary concern when presenting with general voice complaints to a voice clinic.

METHODS

Data were collected from medical records on demographics, medical history, laryngoscopy exam, diagnosis, and subsequent treatments; and from self-report questionnaires including the Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10) and clinical voice questionnaire.

RESULTS

A total of 17% of patients presenting to a voice clinic with general voice problems who completed a VHI-10 identified singing voice as a primary concern. Compared to the reference cohort, patients concerned about singing voice report greater handicap on several questions of the VHI-10, particularly in personal and social life impact, loss of income, unpredictability of vocal clarity, subjective upset, and subjective handicap. Those concerned with singing voice were also more concerned about their vocal problem, and both more likely to be recommended voice therapy and participate in voice therapy despite no statistical differences in categorical diagnoses.

CONCLUSIONS

When considering both professional and recreational singers, voice concerns occurred in 17% of the cohort under study. Patients with singing voice concerns are accounted for largely by recreational singers, who remain poorly characterized in the literature. We underscore the importance of sensitivity and responsivity to the needs of this group of patients.

Use of Botulinum Toxin in Spasmodic Dysphonia: A Review of Recent Studies

Spasmodic dysphonia (SD), also known as laryngeal dystonia, is a neurological voice disorder that causes involuntary spasms of the vocal cord muscles. This impacts speech to varying degrees and results in strained and strangled voice quality, as in adductor spasmodic dysphonia, or weak, quiet, and breathy, as in abductor spasmodic dysphonia. While there is currently no cure for SD, voice therapy and chemodenervation with botulinum toxin (btx) injections remain the mainstay of management. Surgery may be performed in some cases; however, btx injections are widely used to treat both adductor and abductor forms of SD. While btx injections may show vocal improvement in both types of SD, results can depend on several factors such as the general health of the patient, onset and severity of the condition, dosage, interval between injections, and expertise of the practitioner. While many studies have documented the efficacy of btx for improving vocal symptoms in individuals with SD, this review aims to discuss some of those studies from the last 10 years.

Clinical Implications of Dystonia as a Neural Network Disorder

Isolated dystonia is a neurological disorder of diverse etiology, multifactorial pathophysiology, and wide spectrum of clinical presentations. We review the recent neuroimaging advances that led to the conceptualization of dystonia as a neural network disorder and discuss how current knowledge is shaping the identification of biomarkers of dystonia and the development of novel pharmacological therapies.

Symptom Expression Across Voiced Speech Sounds in Adductor Laryngeal Dystonia

OBJECTIVES

Differential diagnosis for adductor laryngeal dystonia (AdLD) is often carried out by comparing symptom expression during sentences with either all voiced or voiced and voiceless consonants. However, empirical research examining the effects of phonetic context on symptoms is sparse. The purpose of this study was to examine whether symptom probabilities varied across voiced speech segments in an all-voiced sentence, and whether this variability was systematic with respect to phonetic features.

METHODS

Eighteen speakers with AdLD read aloud a sentence comprised entirely of voiced speech sounds. Speech segment boundaries and AdLD symptoms (phonatory breaks, frequency shifts, and creak) were labeled separately, and speech segments were coded as symptomatic or asymptomatic based on their temporal overlap. Generalized linear mixed effects models with a binomial outcome variable were used to compare the probability of symptom expression across: 1) all speech segments in the sentence, and 2) four speech sound classes (vowels, approximants, nasals, and obstruents).

RESULTS

Significant symptom variability was found across voiced speech segments in the sentence. Furthermore, the estimated probability of a symptom occurring on vowels and approximants was significantly greater than that of nasals and obstruents.

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that AdLD symptoms are not uniformly distributed across voiced speech segments with systematic variation across speech sound classes.To explain these findings, future work should investigate how the complex interactions between the vocal tract articulators and glottal configurations may influence symptom expression in this population.

The Dystonias

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This article discusses the most recent findings regarding the diagnosis, classification, and management of genetic and idiopathic dystonia.

RECENT FINDINGS

A new approach to classifying dystonia has been created with the aim to increase the recognition and diagnosis of dystonia. Molecular biology and genetic studies have identified several genes and biological pathways involved in dystonia.

SUMMARY

Dystonia is a common movement disorder involving abnormal, often twisting, postures and is a challenging condition to diagnose. The pathophysiology of dystonia involves abnormalities in brain motor networks in the context of genetic factors. Dystonia has genetic, idiopathic, and acquired forms, with a wide phenotypic spectrum, and is a common feature in complex neurologic disorders. Dystonia can be isolated or combined with another movement disorder and may be focal, segmental, multifocal, or generalized in distribution, with some forms only occurring during the performance of specific tasks (task-specific dystonia). Dystonia is classified by clinical characteristics and presumed etiology. The management of dystonia involves accurate diagnosis, followed by treatment with botulinum toxin injections, oral medications, and surgical therapies (mainly deep brain stimulation), as well as pathogenesis-directed treatments, including the prospect of disease-modifying or gene therapies.

The Patho-Neurophysiological Basis and Treatment of Focal Laryngeal Dystonia: A Narrative Review and Two Case Reports Applying TMS over the Laryngeal Motor Cortex

Focal laryngeal dystonia (LD) is a rare, idiopathic disease affecting the laryngeal musculature with an unknown cause and clinically presented as adductor LD or rarely as abductor LD. The most effective treatment options include the injection of botulinum toxin (BoNT) into the affected laryngeal muscle. The aim of this narrative review is to summarize the patho-neuro-physiological and genetic background of LD, as well as the standard recommended therapy (BoNT) and pharmacological treatment options, and to discuss possible treatment perspectives using neuro-modulation techniques such as repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) and vibrotactile stimulation. The review will present two LD cases, patients with adductor and abductor LD, standard diagnostic procedure, treatments and achievement, and the results of cortical excitability mapping the primary motor cortex for the representation of the laryngeal muscles in the assessment of corticospinal and corticobulbar excitability.

Laryngeal Dystonia: Multidisciplinary Update on Terminology, Pathophysiology, and Research Priorities

OBJECTIVE

To delineate research priorities for improving clinical management of laryngeal dystonia, the NIH convened a multidisciplinary panel of experts for a 1-day workshop to examine the current progress in understanding its etiopathophysiology and clinical care.

METHODS

The participants reviewed the current terminology of disorder and discussed advances in understanding its pathophysiology since a similar workshop was held in 2005. Clinical and research gaps were identified, and recommendations for future directions were delineated.

RESULTS

The panel unanimously agreed to adopt the term "laryngeal dystonia" instead of "spasmodic dysphonia" to reflect the current progress in characterizations of this disorder. Laryngeal dystonia was recognized as a multifactorial, phenotypically heterogeneous form of isolated dystonia. Its etiology remains unknown, whereas the pathophysiology likely involves large-scale functional and structural brain network disorganization. Current challenges include the lack of clinically validated diagnostic markers and outcome measures and the paucity of therapies that address the disorder pathophysiology.

CONCLUSION

Research priorities should be guided by challenges in clinical management of laryngeal dystonia. Identification of disorder-specific biomarkers would allow the development of novel diagnostic tools and unified measures of treatment outcome. Elucidation of the critical nodes within neural networks that cause or modulate symptoms would allow the development of targeted therapies that address the underlying pathophysiology. Given the rarity of laryngeal dystonia, future rapid research progress may be facilitated by multicenter, national and international collaborations.

Guidelines for Speech Recording and Acoustic Analyses in Dysarthrias of Movement Disorders

Most patients with movement disorders have speech impairments resulting from sensorimotor abnormalities that affect phonatory, articulatory, and prosodic speech subsystems. There is widespread cross-discipline use of speech recordings for diagnostic and research purposes, despite which there are no specific guidelines for a standardized method. This review aims to combine the specific clinical presentations of patients with movement disorders, existing acoustic assessment protocols, and technological advances in capturing speech to provide a basis for future research in this field and to improve the consistency of clinical assessments. We considered 3 areas: the recording environment (room, seating, background noise), the recording process (instrumentation, vocal tasks, elicitation of speech samples), and the acoustic outcome data. Four vocal tasks, namely, sustained vowel, sequential and alternating motion rates, reading passage, and monologues, are integral aspects of motor speech assessment. Fourteen acoustic vocal speech features, including their hypothesized pathomechanisms with regard to typical occurrences in hypokinetic or hyperkinetic dysarthria, are hereby recommended for quantitative exploratory analysis. Using these acoustic features and experimental speech data, we demonstrated that the hyperkinetic dysarthria group had more affected speech dimensions compared with the healthy controls than had the hypokinetic speakers. Several contrasting speech patterns between both dysarthrias were also found. This article is the first attempt to provide initial recommendations for a standardized way of recording the voice and speech of patients with hypokinetic or hyperkinetic dysarthria; thus allowing clinicians and researchers to reliably collect, acoustically analyze, and compare vocal data across different centers and patient cohorts. © 2020 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Neural endophenotypes and predictors of laryngeal dystonia penetrance and manifestation

Focal dystonias are the most common forms of isolated dystonia; however, the etiopathophysiological signatures of disorder penetrance and clinical manifestation remain unclear. Using an imaging genetics approach, we investigated functional and structural representations of neural endophenotypes underlying the penetrance and manifestation of laryngeal dystonia in families, including 21 probands and 21 unaffected relatives, compared to 32 unrelated healthy controls. We further used a supervised machine-learning algorithm to predict the risk for dystonia development in susceptible individuals based on neural features of identified endophenotypes. We found that abnormalities in prefrontal-parietal cortex, thalamus, and caudate nucleus were commonly shared between patients and their unaffected relatives, representing an intermediate endophenotype of laryngeal dystonia. Machine learning classified 95.2% of unaffected relatives as patients rather than healthy controls, substantiating that these neural alterations represent the endophenotypic marker of dystonia penetrance, independent of its symptomatology. Additional abnormalities in premotor-parietal-temporal cortical regions, caudate nucleus, and cerebellum were present only in patients but not their unaffected relatives, likely representing a secondary endophenotype of dystonia manifestation. Based on alterations in the parietal cortex and caudate nucleus, the machine learning categorized 28.6% of unaffected relative as patients, indicating their increased lifetime risk for developing clinical manifestation of dystonia. The identified endophenotypic neural markers may be implemented for screening of at-risk individuals for dystonia development, selection of families for genetic studies of novel variants based on their risk for disease penetrance, or stratification of patients who would respond differently to a particular treatment in clinical trials.

Acoustic Model of Perceived Overall Severity of Dysphonia in Adductor-Type Laryngeal Dystonia

Purpose This study is a secondary analysis of existing data. The goal of the study was to construct an acoustic model of perceived overall severity of dysphonia in adductory laryngeal dystonia (AdLD). We predicted that acoustic measures (a) related to voice and pitch breaks and (b) related to vocal effort would form the primary elements of a model corresponding to auditory-perceptual ratings of overall severity of dysphonia. Method Twenty inexperienced listeners evaluated the overall severity of dysphonia of speech stimuli from 19 individuals with AdLD. Acoustic features related to primary signs of AdLD (hyperadduction resulting in pitch and voice breaks) and to a potential secondary symptom of AdLD (vocal effort, measures of relative fundamental frequency) were computed from the speech stimuli. Multiple linear regression analysis was applied to construct an acoustic model of the overall severity of dysphonia. Results The acoustic model included an acoustic feature related to pitch and voice breaks and three acoustic measures derived from relative fundamental frequency; it explained 84.9% of the variance in the auditory-perceptual ratings of overall severity of dysphonia in the speech samples. Conclusions Auditory-perceptual ratings of overall severity of dysphonia in AdLD were related to acoustic features of primary signs (pitch and voice breaks, hyperadduction associated with laryngeal spasms) and were also related to acoustic features of vocal effort. This suggests that compensatory vocal effort may be a secondary symptom in AdLD. Future work to generalize this acoustic model to a larger, independent data set is necessary before clinical translation is warranted.

Functional and structural neural bases of task specificity in isolated focal dystonia

BACKGROUND

Task-specific focal dystonias selectively affect movements during the production of highly learned and complex motor behaviors. Manifestation of some task-specific focal dystonias, such as musician's dystonia, has been associated with excessive practice and overuse, whereas the etiology of others remains largely unknown.

OBJECTIVES

In this study, we aimed to examine the neural correlates of task-specific dystonias in order to determine their disorder-specific pathophysiological traits.

METHODS

Using multimodal neuroimaging analyses of resting-state functional connectivity, voxel-based morphometry and tract-based spatial statistics, we examined functional and structural abnormalities that are both common to and distinct between four different forms of task-specific focal dystonias.

RESULTS

Compared to the normal state, all task-specific focal dystonias were characterized by abnormal recruitment of parietal and premotor cortices that are necessary for both modality-specific and heteromodal control of the sensorimotor network. Contrasting the laryngeal and hand forms of focal dystonia revealed distinct patterns of sensorimotor integration and planning, again involving parietal cortex in addition to inferior frontal gyrus and anterior insula. On the other hand, musician's dystonia compared to nonmusician's dystonia was shaped by alterations in primary and secondary sensorimotor cortices together with middle frontal gyrus, pointing to impairments of sensorimotor guidance and executive control.

CONCLUSION

Collectively, this study outlines a specialized footprint of functional and structural alterations in different forms of task-specific focal dystonia, all of which also share a common pathophysiological framework involving premotor-parietal aberrations. © 2019 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.