Clinical Characteristics Suggestive of a Genetic Cause in Cerebral Palsy: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a clinical diagnosis and was long categorized as an acquired disorder, but more and more genetic etiologies are being identified. This review aims to identify the clinical characteristics that are associated with genetic CP to aid clinicians in selecting candidates for genetic testing.

METHODS

The PubMed database was systematically searched to identify genes associated with CP. The clinical characteristics accompanying these genetic forms of CP were compared with published data of large CP populations resulting in the identification of potential indicators of genetic CP.

RESULLTS

Of 1930 articles retrieved, 134 were included. In these, 55 CP genes (described in two or more cases, n = 272) and 79 candidate genes (described in only one case) were reported. The most frequently CP-associated genes were PLP1 (21 cases), ARG1 (17 cases), and CTNNB1 (13 cases). Dyskinesia and the absence of spasticity were identified as strong potential indicators of genetic CP. Presence of intellectual disability, no preterm birth, and no unilateral distribution of symptoms were classified as moderate genetic indicators.

CONCLUSIONS

Genetic causes of CP are increasingly identified. The clinical characteristics associated with genetic CP can aid clinicians regarding to which individual with CP to offer genetic testing. The identified potential genetic indicators need to be validated in large CP cohorts but can provide the first step toward a diagnostic algorithm for genetic CP.

Peripheralized sepiapterin reductase inhibition as a safe analgesic therapy

The development of novel analgesics for chronic pain in the last 2 decades has proven virtually intractable, typically failing due to lack of efficacy and dose-limiting side effects. Identified through unbiased gene expression profiling experiments in rats and confirmed by human genome-wide association studies, the role of excessive tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4) in chronic pain has been validated by numerous clinical and preclinical studies. BH4 is an essential cofactor for aromatic amino acid hydroxylases, nitric oxide synthases, and alkylglycerol monooxygenase so a lack of BH4 leads to a range of symptoms in the periphery and central nervous system (CNS). An ideal therapeutic goal therefore would be to block excessive BH4 production, while preventing potential BH4 rundown. In this review, we make the case that sepiapterin reductase (SPR) inhibition restricted to the periphery (i.e., excluded from the spinal cord and brain), is an efficacious and safe target to alleviate chronic pain. First, we describe how different cell types that engage in BH4 overproduction and contribute to pain hypersensitivity, are themselves restricted to peripheral tissues and show their blockade is sufficient to alleviate pain. We discuss the likely safety profile of peripherally restricted SPR inhibition based on human genetic data, the biochemical alternate routes of BH4 production in various tissues and species, and the potential pitfalls to predictive translation when using rodents. Finally, we propose and discuss possible formulation and molecular strategies to achieve peripherally restricted, potent SPR inhibition to treat not only chronic pain but other conditions where excessive BH4 has been demonstrated to be pathological.

Combining Human and Rodent Genetics to Identify New Analgesics

Most attempts at rational development of new analgesics have failed, in part because chronic pain involves multiple processes that remain poorly understood. To improve translational success, one strategy is to select novel targets for which there is proof of clinical relevance, either genetically through heritable traits, or pharmacologically. Such an approach by definition yields targets with high clinical validity. The biology of these targets can be elucidated in animal models before returning to the patients with a refined therapeutic. For optimal treatment, having biomarkers of drug action available is also a plus. Here we describe a case study in rational drug design: the use of controlled inhibition of peripheral tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4) synthesis to reduce abnormal chronic pain states without altering nociceptive-protective pain. Initially identified in a population of patients with low back pain, the association between BH4 production and chronic pain has been confirmed in more than 12 independent cohorts, through a common haplotype (present in 25% of Caucasians) of the rate-limiting enzyme for BH4 synthesis, GTP cyclohydrolase 1 (GCH1). Genetic tools in mice have demonstrated that both injured sensory neurons and activated macrophages engage increased BH4 synthesis to cause chronic pain. GCH1 is an obligate enzyme for de novo BH4 production. Therefore, inhibiting GCH1 activity eliminates all BH4 production, affecting the synthesis of multiple neurotransmitters and signaling molecules and interfering with physiological function. In contrast, targeting the last enzyme of the BH4 synthesis pathway, sepiapterin reductase (SPR), allows reduction of pathological BH4 production without completely blocking physiological BH4 synthesis. Systemic SPR inhibition in mice has not revealed any safety concerns to date, and available genetic and pharmacologic data suggest similar responses in humans. Finally, because it is present in vivo only when SPR is inhibited, sepiapterin serves as a reliable biomarker of target engagement, allowing potential quantification of drug efficacy. The emerging development of therapeutics that target BH4 synthesis to treat chronic pain illustrates the power of combining human and mouse genetics: human genetic studies for clinical selection of relevant targets, coupled with causality studies in mice, allowing the rational engineering of new analgesics.

Serotonergic perturbations in dystonia disorders-a systematic review

Dystonia is a hyperkinetic movement disorder characterized by sustained or intermittent muscle contractions. Emerging data describe high prevalences of non-motor symptoms, including psychiatric co-morbidity, as part of the phenotype of dystonia. Basal ganglia serotonin and serotonin-dopamine interactions gain attention, as imbalances are known to be involved in extrapyramidal movement and psychiatric disorders. We systematically reviewed the literature for human and animal studies relating to serotonin and its role in dystonia. An association between dystonia and the serotonergic system was reported with decreased levels of 5-hydroxyindolacetic acid, the main metabolite of serotonin. A relation between dystonia and drugs affecting the serotonergic system was described in 89 cases in 49 papers. Psychiatric co-morbidity was frequently described, but likely underestimated as it was not systematically examined. Currently, there are no good (pharmaco)therapeutic options for most forms of dystonia or associated non-motor symptoms. Further research using selective serotonergic drugs in appropriate models of dystonia is required to establish the role of the serotonergic system in dystonia and to guide us to new therapeutic strategies.

Clinical and genetic studies in a family with a novel mutation in the sepiapterin reductase gene

OBJECTIVES

Sepiapterin reductase deficiency is a rare, but treatable inherited disorder of tetrahydrobiopterin and neurotransmitter metabolism. This disorder is most probably underdiagnosed. To date, only 44 cases have been described in the literature. We present the clinical and genetic investigations in a family with a complex movement disorder.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We examined two affected sisters and three healthy family members. The cerebrospinal fluid was analyzed for neurotransmitter and pterins, and the sepiapterin reductase gene (SPR) was sequenced.

RESULTS

The sisters had a complex movement disorders with dystonia and diurnal fluctuations. Both had oculogyric crises, and the older sister also hypersomnia. Both sisters had raised prolactin levels twice above the reference level. One sister had a dramatic response to levodopa, the other responded, but developed dyskinesia despite low doses. Both patients improved dramatically over time with levodopa (2.3 and 1.5 mg/kg/day). Very low levels of homovanillic acid and 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid and increased levels of sepiapterin and dihydrobiopterin were measured in the cerebrospinal fluid before treatment. DNA analyses revealed a novel homozygous mutation in exon 2 in the SPR gene, c.364A>G/p.(Tyr123Cys), located in a highly conserved region in the gene. Both parents and the healthy sister were carriers for the same mutation.

CONCLUSIONS

A new homozygous mutation in the SPR gene was found in two sisters with dopa-responsive dystonia. This important and treatable neurotransmitter disorder must be considered in patients with a complex movement disorder with diurnal fluctuations with or without intellectual impairment. Patients with these symptoms should undergo levodopa trial, cerebrospinal fluid investigations, and genetic analyses.

Sepiapterin reductase deficiency: a treatable mimic of cerebral palsy

OBJECTIVE

Sepiapterin reductase deficiency (SRD) is an under-recognized levodopa-responsive disorder. We describe clinical, biochemical, and molecular findings in a cohort of patients with this treatable condition. We aim to improve awareness of the phenotype and available diagnostic and therapeutic strategies to reduce delayed diagnosis or misdiagnosis, optimize management, and improve understanding of pathophysiologic mechanisms.

METHODS

Forty-three individuals with SRD were identified from 23 international medical centers. The phenotype and treatment response were assessed by chart review using a detailed standardized instrument and by literature review for cases for which records were unavailable.

RESULTS

In most cases, motor and language delays, axial hypotonia, dystonia, weakness, oculogyric crises, and diurnal fluctuation of symptoms with sleep benefit become evident in infancy or childhood. Average age of onset is 7 months, with delay to diagnosis of 9.1 years. Misdiagnoses of cerebral palsy (CP) are common. Most patients benefit dramatically from levodopa/carbidopa, often with further improvement with the addition of 5-hydroxytryptophan. Cerebrospinal fluid findings are distinctive. Diagnosis is confirmed by mutation analysis and/or enzyme activity measurement in cultured fibroblasts.

INTERPRETATION

Common, clinical findings of SRD, aside from oculogyric crises and diurnal fluctuation, are nonspecific and mimic CP with hypotonia or dystonia. Patients usually improve dramatically with treatment. Consequently, we recommend consideration of SRD not only in patients with levodopa-responsive motor disorders, but also in patients with developmental delays with axial hypotonia, and patients with unexplained or atypical presumed CP. Biochemical investigation of cerebrospinal fluid is the preferred method of initial investigation. Early diagnosis and treatment are recommended to prevent ongoing brain dysfunction.