Torticollis and blepharospasm in systemic lupus erythematosus

Exploration of potential immune mechanisms in cervical dystonia

BACKGROUND

Although there are many possible causes for cervical dystonia (CD), a specific etiology cannot be identified in most cases. Prior studies have suggested a relationship between autoimmune disease and some cases of CD, pointing to possible immunological mechanisms.

OBJECTIVE

The goal was to explore the potential role of multiple different immunological mechanisms in CD.

METHODS

First, a broad screening test compared neuronal antibodies in controls and CD. Second, unbiased blood plasma proteomics provided a broad screen for potential biologic differences between controls and CD. Third, a multiplex immunoassay compared 37 markers associated with immunological processes in controls and CD. Fourth, relative immune cell frequencies were investigated in blood samples of controls and CD. Finally, sequencing studies investigated the association of HLA DQB1 and DRB1 alleles in controls versus CD.

RESULTS

Screens for anti-neuronal antibodies did not reveal any obvious abnormalities. Plasma proteomics pointed towards certain abnormalities of immune mechanisms, and the multiplex assay pointed more specifically towards abnormalities in T lymphocytes. Abnormal immune cell frequencies were identified for some CD cases, and these cases clustered together as a potential subgroup. Studies of HLA alleles indicated a possible association between CD and DRB1*15:03, which is reported to mediate the penetrance of autoimmune disorders.

CONCLUSIONS

Altogether, the association of CD with multiple different blood-based immune measures point to abnormalities in cell-mediated immunity that may play a pathogenic role for a subgroup of individuals with CD.

Thyroid disease in cervical dystonia

There are many possible etiologies for cervical dystonia (CD), but a cause cannot be identified in most cases. Most recent attention has focused on genetic causes, although a few prior studies have highlighted autoimmune mechanisms instead. Because autoimmune disorders frequently co-exist, the current study evaluated the hypothesis that autoimmune disorders might be more common in CD than neurological controls. The frequency of 32 common autoimmune disorders was evaluated using a systematic survey comparing 300 subjects with CD with 391 neurological controls. The frequency of thyroid disease was significantly higher in CD (20%) compared with controls (6%). Regression analyses that accounted for age and sex revealed an odds ratio of 4.5 (95% CI 2.5-8.1, p < 0.001). All other autoimmune disorders occurred with similar frequencies in CD and controls. Although these studies do not establish a mechanistic link between CD and autoimmune disease, they suggest the need for further attention to a potential relationship, and more specifically with thyroid disease.

A metabolomic study of cervical dystonia

INTRODUCTION

Cervical dystonia is the most common of the adult-onset focal dystonias. Most cases are idiopathic. The current view is that cervical dystonia may be caused by some combination of genetic and environmental factors. Genetic contributions have been studied extensively, but there are few studies of other factors. We conducted an exploratory metabolomics analysis of cervical dystonia to identify potentially abnormal metabolites or altered biological pathways.

METHODS

Plasma samples from 100 cases with idiopathic cervical dystonia and 100 controls were compared using liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry-based metabolomics.

RESULTS

A total of 7346 metabolic features remained after quality control, and up to 289 demonstrated significant differences between cases and controls, depending on statistical criteria chosen. Pathway analysis revealed 9 biological processes to be significantly associated at p < 0.05, 5 pathways were related to carbohydrate metabolism, 3 pathways were related to lipid metabolism.

CONCLUSION

This is the first large scale metabolomics study for any type of dystonia. The results may provide potential novel insights into the biology of cervical dystonia.

Blepharospasm with elevated anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody titer

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether serum levels of anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody (anti-AChR-Abs) are related to clinical parameters of blepharospasm (BSP).

METHODS

Eighty-three adults with BSP, 60 outpatients with hemifacial spasm (HFS) and 58 controls were recruited. Personal history, demographic factors, response to botulinum toxin type A (BoNT-A) and other neurological conditions were recorded. Anti-AChR-Abs levels were quantified using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

RESULTS

The anti-AChR Abs levels were 0.237 ± 0.022 optical density units in the BSP group, which was significantly different from the HFS group (0.160 ± 0.064) and control group (0.126 ± 0.038). The anti-AChR Abs level was correlated with age and the duration of response to the BoNT-A injection.

CONCLUSION

Patients with BSP had an elevated anti-AChR Abs titer, which suggests that dysimmunity plays a role in the onset of BSP. An increased anti-AChR Abs titer may be a predictor for poor response to BoNT-A in BSP.

Movement and Other Neurodegenerative Syndromes in Patients with Systemic Rheumatic Diseases: A Case Series of 8 Patients and Review of the Literature

Patients with rheumatic diseases can present with movement and other neurodegenerative disorders. It may be underappreciated that movement and other neurodegenerative disorders can encompass a wide variety of disease entities. Such disorders are strikingly heterogeneous and lead to a wider spectrum of clinical injury than seen in Parkinson's disease. Therefore, we sought to stringently phenotype movement and other neurodegenerative disorders presenting in a case series of rheumatic disease patients. We integrated our findings with a review of the literature to understand mechanisms which may account for such a ubiquitous pattern of clinical injury.Seven rheumatic disease patients (5 Sjögren's syndrome patients, 2 undifferentiated connective tissue disease patients) were referred and could be misdiagnosed as having Parkinson's disease. However, all of these patients were ultimately diagnosed as having other movement or neurodegenerative disorders. Findings inconsistent with and more expansive than Parkinson's disease included cerebellar degeneration, dystonia with an alien-limb phenomenon, and nonfluent aphasias.A notable finding was that individual patients could be affected by cooccurring movement and other neurodegenerative disorders, each of which could be exceptionally rare (ie, prevalence of ∼1:1000), and therefore with the collective probability that such disorders were merely coincidental and causally unrelated being as low as ∼1-per-billion. Whereas our review of the literature revealed that ubiquitous patterns of clinical injury were frequently associated with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings suggestive of a widespread vasculopathy, our patients did not have such neuroimaging findings. Instead, our patients could have syndromes which phenotypically resembled paraneoplastic and other inflammatory disorders which are known to be associated with antineuronal antibodies. We similarly identified immune-mediated and inflammatory markers of injury in a psoriatic arthritis patient who developed an amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)-plus syndrome after tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-inhibitor therapy.We have described a diverse spectrum of movement and other neurodegenerative disorders in our rheumatic disease patients. The widespread pattern of clinical injury, the propensity of our patients to present with co-occurring movement disorders, and the lack of MRI neuroimaging findings suggestive of a vasculopathy collectively suggest unique patterns of immune-mediated injury.

Pathologic changes in the brain in cervical dystonia pre- and post-mortem - a commentary with a special focus on the cerebellum

In a recent issue of Experimental Neurology, Prudente et al. (2012) investigated the neuropathology of cervical dystonia in six patients. Their most important finding was a patchy loss of cerebellar Purkinje cells in the cerebellum. In this article we discuss their findings in the context of a review including primary and secondary cervical dystonia. An update is given of the current knowledge on structural and functional brain abnormalities in idiopathic cervical dystonia with a special focus on the cerebellum.

Neuropathology of cervical dystonia

The aim of this study was to search for neuropathological changes in postmortem brain tissue of individuals with cervical dystonia (CD). Multiple regions of formalin-preserved brains were collected from patients with CD and controls and examined with an extensive battery of histopathological stains in a two-stage study design. In stage one, 4 CD brains underwent a broad screening neuropathological examination. In stage two, these 4 CD brains were combined with 2 additional CD brains, and the subjective findings were quantified and compared to 16 age-matched controls. The initial subjective neuropathological assessment revealed only two regions with relatively consistent changes. The substantia nigra had frequent ubiquitin-positive intranuclear inclusions known as Marinesco bodies. Additionally, the cerebellum showed patchy loss of Purkinje cells, areas of focal gliosis and torpedo bodies. Other brain regions showed minor or inconsistent changes. In the second stage of the analysis, quantitative studies failed to reveal significant differences in the numbers of Marinesco bodies in CD versus controls, but confirmed a significantly lower Purkinje cell density in CD. Molecular investigations revealed 4 of the CD cases and 2 controls to harbor sequence variants in non-coding regions of THAP1, and these cases had lower Purkinje cell densities regardless of whether they had CD. The findings suggest that subtle neuropathological changes such as lower Purkinje cell density may be found in primary CD when relevant brain regions are investigated with appropriate methods.

Movement disorders in autoimmune diseases

Movement disorders have been known to be associated with a variety of autoimmune diseases, including Sydenham's chorea, pediatric autoimmune neuropsychiatric disorders associated with streptococcus, systemic lupus erythematosus, antiphospholipid syndrome, gluten sensitivity, paraneoplastic and autoimmune encephalopathies. Tremors, dystonia, chorea, ballism, myoclonus, parkinsonism, and ataxia may be the initial and even the only presentation of these autoimmune diseases. Although antibodies directed against various cellular components of the central nervous system have been implicated, the pathogenic mechanisms of these autoimmune movement disorders have not yet been fully elucidated. Clinical recognition of these autoimmune movement disorders is critically important as many improve with immunotherapy or dietary modifications, particularly when diagnosed early. We discuss here the clinical features, pathogenic mechanisms, and treatments of movement disorders associated with autoimmune diseases, based on our own experience and on a systematic review of the literature.

Cervical Dystonia

Cervical dystonia, which is the most common form of focal dystonia, presents with sustained neck spasms, abnormal head posture, head tremor, and pain. One of the interesting and unique features of cervical dystonia is the geste antagoniste. There is not a well-described pathophysiology for cervical dystonia, but several hypotheses report involvement at the central and peripheral level. Treatment options include: oral medical therapy, botulinum toxin injection, and surgery. Oral medical therapy has limited efficacy in control of the symptoms of cervical dystonia. Two types of botulinum toxin, types A and B, are being used for treatment of cervical dystonia, with equivalent benefit. Surgery is an option when other treatments fail or become ineffective. The surgical procedures are brain lesioning, brain stimulation, and peripheral surgical intervention. Several trials are currently ongoing in the United States and Europe to evaluate the efficacy of deep brain surgery in cervical dystonia.

Homocysteine and serum markers of immune activation in primary dystonia

The cause of primary dystonia remains unknown. Several reports point to immune system disturbances in primary dystonia and a recent study demonstrated hyperhomocysteinemia in cervical dystonia. Homocysteine (HCY) is an amino acid and elevated HCY concentrations were shown to be associated with immune system activation and increased neopterin serum concentrations. We examined HCY serum concentrations together with serum markers of immune activation in patients with different types of primary dystonia. Eighty-three patients with different types of primary dystonia were included and investigated at least 3 months following botulinum toxin treatment. Thirty-six healthy volunteers with similar age and sex distribution served as controls. Total serum HCY, kynurenine, and tryptophan concentrations were determined by high-performance liquid chromatography; neopterin, folate, and vitamin B12 concentrations were measured by immunoassays. Routine blood analysis, including C-reactive protein (CRP), erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), and white blood count (WBC), was performed. Patients with primary dystonia had significantly higher HCY concentrations compared to controls. Among the dystonia subtypes, no significant difference of HCY serum concentrations was observed. CRP and ESR were within the normal range in >90% of the patients and all had normal WBC. Neopterin, kynurenine, and tryptophan serum concentrations were similar in patients and controls and not correlated with HCY serum concentrations. The results provide evidence against enhanced cellular immune activation in patients with primary dystonia. However, hyperhomocysteinemia was present in all dystonia subtypes and unrelated to immune activation in this study. HCY is a neuronal excitotoxic amino acid and hyperhomocysteinemia is considered an independent vascular risk factor. Further studies are required to define the background of hyperhomocysteinemia in primary dystonia.

Juvenile parkinsonism as a manifestation of systemic lupus erythematosus: case report and review of the literature

Involvement of the central nervous system in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) has been well described. It usually includes psychiatric disturbance, seizures, and cranial nerve disorders. Movement disorders are less common, chorea being the one most frequently described. A parkinsonian syndrome may be an extremely rare manifestation of cerebral lupus. We report on a case of juvenile parkinsonism as a manifestation of SLE and review the literature.

The neuropathology and pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a chronic, multisystem, autoimmune disease in which neuropsychiatric involvement occurs in about 50% of patients and carries a poor prognosis. Despite extensive research, the precise mechanisms of nervous tissue injury remain the least well understood. This article summarizes the important clinical neuropsychiatric features of SLE and, reviewing classical histopathological and more recent experimental studies, discusses theories concerning their presumed pathogenesis. The distinctive production of diverse autoantibodies seems to be related to defective clearance of apoptotic cells. Antibody-mediated neural cell injury and rheological disturbances represent the two principal suggested mechanisms of tissue injury. An interplay between these processes, underlying genetic factors, their modification by hormones, complicated by a number of secondary factors, may explain the wide spectrum of features encountered in this disease.