Technical Note: kV-independent coronary calcium scoring: A phantom evaluation of score accuracy and potential radiation dose reduction

Coronary artery calcium scoring assessment in ultra-low-dose chest computed tomography

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the effect of non-electrocardiogram (ECG) -triggered ultra-low-dose CT (ULD-CT) with different reconstruction protocols on coronary artery calcium (CAC) scoring assessment, compared with ECG-triggered CAC CT (CAC-CT).

METHODS

This prospective study included 115 patients who underwent CAC-CT and ULD-CT scans under the same topogram images. CAC-CT adopted a prospective ECG-triggered sequential acquisition with a tube potential of 120 kV, and the reconstruction protocol was standard Qr36 + slice 3 mm (CACQr-3mm group). ULD-CT adopted a non-ECG-triggered high-pitch acquisition with a tube potential of Sn100 kV, and four groups of images (named ULDQr-3mm, ULDSa-3mm, ULDQr-1.5mm, and ULDSa-1.5mm) were reconstructed using different reconstruction algorithms (standard Qr36, kV-independent Sa36) and slice thicknesses (3 mm, 1.5 mm). The accuracy of CAC detection by ULD-CT was calculated. The agreement of the CAC score between ULD-CT and CAC-CT scans was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) and Bland-Altman plot, and the agreement of risk categorization was assessed using weighted kappa.

RESULTS

The sensitivity and specificity of the ULDSa-1.5mm group for detecting positive CAC were 100% and 97.4%, respectively (k = 0.980). The CAC score for the ULDSa-3mm and ULDSa-1.5mm groups demonstrated excellent agreement with the CACQr-3mm group (ICC = 0.992, 0.990, respectively), with a mean difference of -12.3 and - 12.4. The agreement of risk categorization based on absolute and percentile CAC score between the ULDSa-1.5mm and CACQr-3mm groups was excellent (weighted k = 0.954, 0.983, respectively), and risk reclassification rates were low (3.5%, 2.8%, respectively). The effective dose was reduced by approximately 77.2% for the ULD-CT compared to the CAC-CT (0.18 mSv vs. 0.79 mSv, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Reconstruction with a 1.5-mm slice thickness and kV-independent iterative algorithmic protocol in ULD-CT yielded excellent agreement in CAC score quantification and risk categorization compared with ECG-triggered CAC-CT.

Artificial intelligence in coronary artery calcium measurement: Barriers and solutions for implementation into daily practice

Coronary artery calcification (CAC) measurement is a valuable predictor of cardiovascular risk. However, its measurement can be time-consuming and complex, thus driving the desire for artificial intelligence (AI)-based approaches. The aim of this review is to explore the current status of CAC volume measurement using AI-based systems for the automated prediction of cardiovascular events. We also make proposals for the implementation of these systems into clinical practice. Research to date on applying AI to CAC scoring has shown the potential for automation and risk stratification, and, overall, efficacy and a high level of agreement with categorisation by trained clinicians have been demonstrated. However, research in this field has not been uniform or directed. One contributing factor may be a lack of integration and communication between computer scientists and cardiologists. Clinicians, institutions, and organisations should work together towards applying this technology to improve processes, preserve healthcare resources, and improve patient outcomes.

Radiation dose optimization for photon-counting CT coronary artery calcium scoring for different patient sizes: a dynamic phantom study

PURPOSE

To systematically assess the radiation dose reduction potential of coronary artery calcium (CAC) assessments with photon-counting computed tomography (PCCT) by changing the tube potential for different patient sizes with a dynamic phantom.

METHODS

A hollow artery, containing three calcifications of different densities, was translated at velocities corresponding to 0, < 60, 60-75, and > 75 beats per minute within an anthropomorphic phantom. Extension rings were used to simulate average- and large -sized patients. PCCT scans were made with the reference clinical protocol (tube potential of 120 kilovolt (kV)), and with 70, 90, Sn100, Sn140, and 140 kV at identical image quality levels. All acquisitions were reconstructed at a virtual monoenergetic energy level of 70 keV. For each calcification, Agatston scores and contrast-to-noise ratios (CNR) were determined, and compared to the reference with Wilcoxon signed-rank tests, with p < 0.05 indicating significant differences.

RESULTS

A decrease in radiation dose (22%) was achieved at Sn100 kV for the average-sized phantom. For the large phantom, Sn100 and Sn140 kV resulted in a decrease in radiation doses of 19% and 3%, respectively. Irrespective of CAC density, Sn100 and 140 kVp did not result in significantly different CNR. Only at Sn100 kV were there no significant differences in Agatston scores for all CAC densities, heart rates, and phantom sizes.

CONCLUSION

PCCT at tube voltage of 100 kV with added tin filtration and reconstructed at 70 keV enables a ≥ 19% dose reduction compared to 120 kV, independent of phantom size, CAC density, and heart rate.

KEY POINTS

• Photon-counting CT allows for reduced radiation dose acquisitions (up to 19%) for coronary calcium assessment by reducing tube voltage while reconstructing at a normal monoE level of 70 keV. • Tube voltage reduction is possible for medium and large patient sizes, without affecting the Agatston score outcome.

Standardization and Quantitative Imaging With Photon-Counting Detector CT

ABSTRACT

Computed tomography (CT) images display anatomic structures across 3 dimensions and are highly quantitative; they are the reference standard for 3-dimensional geometric measurements and are used for 3-dimensional printing of anatomic models and custom implants, as well as for radiation therapy treatment planning. The pixel intensity in CT images represents the linear x-ray attenuation coefficient of the imaged materials after linearly scaling the coefficients into a quantity known as CT numbers that is conveyed in Hounsfield units. When measured with the same scanner model, acquisition, and reconstruction parameters, the mean CT number of a material is highly reproducible, and quantitative applications of CT scanning that rely on the measured CT number, such as for assessing bone mineral density or coronary artery calcification, are well established. However, the strong dependence of CT numbers on x-ray beam spectra limits quantitative applications and standardization from achieving robust widespread success. This article reviews several quantitative applications of CT and the challenges they face, and describes the benefits brought by photon-counting detector (PCD) CT technology. The discussed benefits of PCD-CT include that it is inherently multienergy, expands material decomposition capabilities, and improves spatial resolution and geometric quantification. Further, the utility of virtual monoenergetic images to standardize CT numbers is discussed, as virtual monoenergetic images can be the default image type in PCD-CT due to the full-time spectral nature of the technology.

Radiation Dose Reduction for Coronary Artery Calcium Scoring Using a Virtual Noniodine Algorithm on Photon-Counting Detector Computed-Tomography Phantom Data

Background: On the basis of the hypothesis that virtual noniodine (VNI)-based coronary artery calcium scoring (CACS) is feasible at reduced radiation doses, this study assesses the impact of radiation dose reduction on the accuracy of this VNI algorithm on a photon-counting detector (PCD)-CT. Methods: In a systematic in vitro setting, a phantom for CACS simulating three chest sizes was scanned on a clinical PCD-CT. The standard radiation dose was chosen at volumetric CT dose indices (CTDI_Vol) of 1.5, 3.3, 7.0 mGy for small, medium-sized, and large phantoms, and was gradually reduced by adjusting the tube current resulting in 100, 75, 50, and 25%, respectively. VNI images were reconstructed at 55 keV, quantum iterative reconstruction (QIR)1, and at 60 keV/QIR4, and evaluated regarding image quality (image noise (IN), contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR)), and CACS. All VNI results were compared to true noncontrast (TNC)-based CACS at 70 keV and standard radiation dose (reference). Results: IN_TNC was significantly higher than IN_VNI, and IN_VNI at 55 keV/QIR1 higher than at 60 keV/QIR4 (100% dose: 16.7 ± 1.9 vs. 12.8 ± 1.7 vs. 7.7 ± 0.9; p < 0.001 for every radiation dose). CNR_TNC was higher than CNR_VNI, but it was better to use 60 keV/QIR4 (p < 0.001). CACS_VNI showed strong correlation and agreement at every radiation dose (p < 0.001, r > 0.9, intraclass correlation coefficient > 0.9). The coefficients of the variation in root-mean squared error were less than 10% and thus clinically nonrelevant for the CACS_VNI of every radiation dose. Conclusion: This phantom study suggests that CACS_VNI is feasible on PCD-CT, even at reduced radiation dose while maintaining image quality and CACS accuracy.

Low-dose coronary calcium scoring CT using a dedicated reconstruction filter for kV-independent calcium measurements

In this prospective, pilot study, we tested a kV-independent coronary artery calcium scoring CT protocol, using a novel reconstruction kernel (Sa36f). From December 2018 to November 2019, we performed an additional research scan in 61 patients undergoing clinical calcium scanning. For the standard protocol (120 kVp), images were reconstructed with a standard, medium-sharp kernel (Qr36d). For the research protocol (automated kVp selection), images were reconstructed with a novel kernel (Sa36f). Research scans were sequentially performed using a higher (cohort A, n = 31) and a lower (cohort B, n = 30) dose optimizer setting within the automatic system with customizable kV selection. Agatston scores, coronary calcium volumes, and radiation exposure of the standard and research protocol were compared. A phantom study was conducted to determine inter-scan variability. There was excellent correlation for the Agatston score between the two protocols (r = 0.99); however, the standard protocol resulted in slightly higher Agatston scores (29.4 [0-139.0] vs 17.4 [0-158.2], p = 0.028). The median calcium volumes were similar (11.5 [0-109.2] vs 11.2 [0-118.0] mm³; p = 0.176), and the number of calcified lesions was not significantly different (p = 0.092). One patient was reclassified to another risk category. The research protocol could be performed at a lower kV and resulted in a substantially lower radiation exposure, with a median volumetric CT dose index of 4.1 vs 5.2 mGy, respectively (p < 0.001). Our results showed that a consistent coronary calcium scoring can be achieved using a kV-independent protocol that lowers radiation doses compared to the standard protocol. KEY POINTS: • The Sa36f kernel enables kV-independent Agatston scoring without changing the original Agatston weighting threshold. • Agatston scores and calcium volumes of the standard and research protocols showed an excellent correlation. • The research protocol resulted in a significant reduction in radiation exposure with a mean reduction of 22% in DLP and 25% in CTDI_vol.

Technical note: Evaluation of Artificial 120-kilovolt computed tomography images for radiation therapy applications

PURPOSE

The purpose of this work is to evaluate the scaled CT number accuracy of an artificial 120 kV reconstruction technique based on phantom experiments in the context of radiation therapy planning.

METHODS

An abdomen-shaped electron density phantom was scanned on a clinical CT scanner capable of artificial 120 kV reconstruction using different tube potentials from 70 kV to 150 kV. A series of tissue equivalent phantom inserts (lung, adipose, breast, solid water, liver, inner bone, 30%/50% CaCO3, cortical bone) were placed inside the phantom. Images were reconstructed using a conventional quantitative reconstruction kernel as well as the artificial 120 kV reconstruction kernel. Scaled CT numbers of inserts were measured from images acquired at different kVs and compared with those acquired at 120 kV, which were deemed as the ground truth. The relative error was quantified as the percentage deviation of scaled CT numbers acquired at different tube potentials from their ground truth values acquired at 120 kV.

RESULTS

Scaled CT numbers measured from images reconstructed using the conventional reconstruction demonstrated a strong kV-dependence. The relative error in scaled CT number ranged from 0.6% (liver insert) to 31.1% (cortical bone insert). The artificial 120 kV reconstruction reduced the kV-dependence, especially for bone tissues. The relative error in scaled CT number was reduced to 0.4% (liver insert) and 2.6% (30% CaCO₃ insert) using this technique. When tube potential selection was limited to the range of 90 kV to 150 kV, the relative error was further restrained to <1.2% for all tissue types.

CONCLUSION

Phantom results demonstrated that using the artificial 120 kV technique, it was feasible to acquire raw projection data at a desired tube potential and then reconstruct images with scaled CT numbers comparable to those obtained directly at 120 kV. In radiotherapy applications, this technique may allow optimization of tube potential without complicating clinical workflow by eliminating the necessity of maintaining multiple sets of CT calibration curves. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Tube voltage-independent coronary calcium scoring on a first-generation dual-source photon-counting CT-a proof-of-principle phantom study

To evaluate the accuracy of coronary artery calcium (CAC) scoring at various tube voltages and different monoenergetic image reconstructions on a first-generation dual-source photon-counting detector CT (PCD-CT). A commercially available anthropomorphic chest phantom with calcium inserts was scanned at different tube voltages (90 kV, Sn100kV, 120 kV, and Sn140kV) on a first-generation dual-source PCD-CT system with quantum technology using automatic exposure control with an image quality (IQ) level of 20. The same phantom was also scanned on a conventional energy-integrating detector CT (120 kV; weighted filtered back projection) for reference. Extension rings were used to emulate different patient sizes. Virtual monoenergetic images at 65 keV and 70 keV applying different levels of quantum iterative reconstruction (QIR) were reconstructed from the PCD-CT data sets. CAC scores were determined and compared to the reference. Radiation doses were noted. At an IQ level of 20, radiation doses ranged between 1.18 mGy and 4.64 mGy, depending on the tube voltage and phantom size. Imaging at 90 kV or Sn100kV was associated with a size-dependent radiation dose reduction between 23% and 48% compared to 120 kV. Tube voltage adapted image reconstructions with 65 keV and QIR 3 at 90 kV and with 70 keV and QIR 1 at Sn100kV allowed to calculate CAC scores comparable to conventional EID-CT scans with a percentage deviation of ≤ 5% for all phantom sizes. Our phantom study indicates that CAC scoring with dual-source PCD-CT is accurate at various tube voltages, offering the possibility of substantial radiation dose reduction.

Coronary Artery Calcium Scoring: Toward a New Standard

OBJECTIVES

Although the Agatston score is a commonly used quantification method, rescan reproducibility is suboptimal, and different CT scanners result in different scores. In 2007, McCollough et al (Radiology 2007;243:527-538) proposed a standard for coronary artery calcium quantification. Advancements in CT technology over the last decade, however, allow for improved acquisition and reconstruction methods. This study aims to investigate the feasibility of a reproducible reduced dose alternative of the standardized approach for coronary artery calcium quantification on state-of-the-art CT systems from 4 major vendors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

An anthropomorphic phantom containing 9 calcifications and 2 extension rings were used. Images were acquired with 4 state-of-the-art CT systems using routine protocols and a variety of tube voltages (80-120 kV), tube currents (100% to 25% dose levels), slice thicknesses (3/2.5 and 1/1.25 mm), and reconstruction techniques (filtered back projection and iterative reconstruction). Every protocol was scanned 5 times after repositioning the phantom to assess reproducibility. Calcifications were quantified as Agatston scores.

RESULTS

Reducing tube voltage to 100 kV, dose to 75%, and slice thickness to 1 or 1.25 mm combined with higher iterative reconstruction levels resulted in an on average 36% lower intrascanner variability (interquartile range) compared with the standard 120 kV protocol. Interscanner variability per phantom size decreased by 34% on average. With the standard protocol, on average, 6.2 ± 0.4 calcifications were detected, whereas 7.0 ± 0.4 were detected with the proposed protocol. Pairwise comparisons of Agatston scores between scanners within the same phantom size demonstrated 3 significantly different comparisons at the standard protocol (P < 0.05), whereas no significantly different comparisons arose at the proposed protocol (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

On state-of-the-art CT systems of 4 different vendors, a 25% reduced dose, thin-slice calcium scoring protocol led to improved intrascanner and interscanner reproducibility and increased detectability of small and low-density calcifications in this phantom. The protocol should be extensively validated before clinical use, but it could potentially improve clinical interscanner/interinstitutional reproducibility and enable more consistent risk assessment and treatment strategies.

Coronary Calcium Scoring with First Generation Dual-Source Photon-Counting CT-First Evidence from Phantom and In-Vivo Scans

We evaluated the accuracy of coronary artery calcium (CAC) scoring on a dual-source photon-counting detector CT (PCD-CT). An anthropomorphic chest phantom underwent ECG-gated sequential scanning on a PCD-CT at 120 kV with four radiation dose levels (CTDIvol, 2.0–8.6 mGy). Polychromatic images at 120 kV (T3D) and virtual monoenergetic images (VMI), from 60 to 75 keV without quantum iterative reconstruction (no QIR) and QIR strength levels 1–4, were reconstructed. For reference, the same phantom was scanned on a conventional energy-integrating detector CT (120 kV; filtered back projection) at identical radiation doses. CAC scoring in 20 patients with PCD-CT (120 kV; no QIR and QIR 1–4) were included. In the phantom, there were no differences between CAC scores of different radiation doses (all, p > 0.05). Images with 70 keV, no QIR (CAC score, 649); 65 keV, QIR 3 (656); 65 keV; QIR4 (648) and T3D, QIR4 (656) showed a <1% deviation to the reference (653). CAC scores significantly decreased at increasing QIR levels (all, p < 0.001) and for each 5 keV-increase (all, p < 0.001). Patient data (median CAC score: 86 [inter-quartile range: 38–978] at 70 keV) confirmed relationships and differences between reconstructions from the phantom. First phantom and in-vivo experience with a clinical dual-source PCD-CT system shows accurate CAC scoring with VMI reconstructions at different radiation dose levels.