The neuropathology of intervertebral discs removed for low-back pain

The role of nerve fibers and their neurotransmitters in regulating intervertebral disc degeneration

Intervertebral disc degeneration (IVDD) has been the major contributor to chronic lower back pain (LBP). Abnormal apoptosis, senescence, and pyroptosis of IVD cells, extracellular matrix (ECM) degradation, and infiltration of immune cells are the major molecular alternations during IVDD. Changes at tissue level frequently occur at advanced IVD tissue. Ectopic ingrowth of nerves within inner annulus fibrosus (AF) and nucleus pulposus (NP) tissue has been considered as the primary cause for LBP. Innervation at IVD tissue mainly included sensory and sympathetic nerves, and many markers for these two types of nerves have been detected since 1940. In fact, in osteoarthritis (OA), beyond pain transmission, the direct regulation of neuropeptides on functions of chondrocytes have attracted researchers' great attention recently. Many physical and pathological similarities between joint and IVD have shed us the light on the neurogenic mechanism involved in IVDD. Here, an overview of the advances in the nervous system within IVD tissue will be performed, with a discussion on in the role of nerve fibers and their neurotransmitters in regulating IVDD. We hope this review can attract more research interest to address neuromodulation and IVDD itself, which will enhance our understanding of the contribution of neuromodulation to the structural changes within IVD tissue and inflammatory responses and will help identify novel therapeutic targets and enable the effective treatment of IVDD disease.

Comparison of In Vivo Intradiscal Pressure between Sitting and Standing in Human Lumbar Spine: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Background: Non-specific low back pain (LBP) is highly prevalent today. Disc degeneration could be one of the causes of non-specific LBP, and increased intradiscal pressure (IDP) can potentially induce disc degeneration. The differences in vivo IDP in sitting and standing postures have been studied, but inconsistent results have been reported. The primary objective of this systematic review is to compare the differences in vivo IDP between sitting and standing postures. The secondary objective of this review is to compare effect size estimates between (1) dated and more recent studies and (2) healthy and degenerated intervertebral discs. Methods: An exhaustive search of six electronic databases for studies published before November 2021 was conducted. Articles measuring in vivo IDP in sitting and standing postures were included. Two independent researchers conducted the screening and data extraction. Results: Ten studies that met the inclusion criteria were included in the systematic review, and seven studies with nine independent groups were included in meta-analyses. The sitting posture induces a significantly higher IDP on the lumbar spine (SMD: 0.87; 95% CI = [0.33, 1.41]) than the standing posture. In studies published after 1990 and subjects with degenerated discs, there are no differences in vivo IDP between both postures. Conclusions: Sitting causes higher loads on the lumbar spine than standing in the normal discs, but recent studies do not support this conclusion. Furthermore, the degenerated discs showed no difference in IDP in both postures.

Spatially defined single-cell transcriptional profiling characterizes diverse chondrocyte subtypes and nucleus pulposus progenitors in human intervertebral discs

A comprehensive understanding of the cellular heterogeneity and molecular mechanisms underlying the development, homeostasis, and disease of human intervertebral disks (IVDs) remains challenging. Here, the transcriptomic landscape of 108 108 IVD cells was mapped using single-cell RNA sequencing of three main compartments from young and adult healthy IVDs, including the nucleus pulposus (NP), annulus fibrosus, and cartilage endplate (CEP). The chondrocyte subclusters were classified based on their potential regulatory, homeostatic, and effector functions in extracellular matrix (ECM) homeostasis. Notably, in the NP, a PROCR⁺ resident progenitor population showed enriched colony-forming unit-fibroblast (CFU-F) activity and trilineage differentiation capacity. Finally, intercellular crosstalk based on signaling network analysis uncovered that the PDGF and TGF-β cascades are important cues in the NP microenvironment. In conclusion, a single-cell transcriptomic atlas that resolves spatially regulated cellular heterogeneity together with the critical signaling that underlies homeostasis will help to establish new therapeutic strategies for IVD degeneration in the clinic.

Spatially defined single-cell transcriptional profiling characterizes diverse chondrocyte subtypes and nucleus pulposus progenitors in human intervertebral discs

A comprehensive understanding of the cellular heterogeneity and molecular mechanisms underlying the development, homeostasis, and disease of human intervertebral disks (IVDs) remains challenging. Here, the transcriptomic landscape of 108 108 IVD cells was mapped using single-cell RNA sequencing of three main compartments from young and adult healthy IVDs, including the nucleus pulposus (NP), annulus fibrosus, and cartilage endplate (CEP). The chondrocyte subclusters were classified based on their potential regulatory, homeostatic, and effector functions in extracellular matrix (ECM) homeostasis. Notably, in the NP, a PROCR⁺ resident progenitor population showed enriched colony-forming unit-fibroblast (CFU-F) activity and trilineage differentiation capacity. Finally, intercellular crosstalk based on signaling network analysis uncovered that the PDGF and TGF-β cascades are important cues in the NP microenvironment. In conclusion, a single-cell transcriptomic atlas that resolves spatially regulated cellular heterogeneity together with the critical signaling that underlies homeostasis will help to establish new therapeutic strategies for IVD degeneration in the clinic.

Spatially defined single-cell transcriptional profiling characterizes diverse chondrocyte subtypes and nucleus pulposus progenitors in human intervertebral discs

A comprehensive understanding of the cellular heterogeneity and molecular mechanisms underlying the development, homeostasis, and disease of human intervertebral disks (IVDs) remains challenging. Here, the transcriptomic landscape of 108 108 IVD cells was mapped using single-cell RNA sequencing of three main compartments from young and adult healthy IVDs, including the nucleus pulposus (NP), annulus fibrosus, and cartilage endplate (CEP). The chondrocyte subclusters were classified based on their potential regulatory, homeostatic, and effector functions in extracellular matrix (ECM) homeostasis. Notably, in the NP, a PROCR+ resident progenitor population showed enriched colony-forming unit-fibroblast (CFU-F) activity and trilineage differentiation capacity. Finally, intercellular crosstalk based on signaling network analysis uncovered that the PDGF and TGF-β cascades are important cues in the NP microenvironment. In conclusion, a single-cell transcriptomic atlas that resolves spatially regulated cellular heterogeneity together with the critical signaling that underlies homeostasis will help to establish new therapeutic strategies for IVD degeneration in the clinic.

Innervation of the Human Intervertebral Disc: A Scoping Review

OBJECTIVE

Back pain is an elusive symptom complicated by a variety of possible causes, precipitating and maintaining factors, and consequences. Notably, the underlying pathology remains unknown in a significant number of cases. Changes to the intervertebral disc (IVD) have been associated with back pain, leading many to postulate that the IVD may be a direct source of pain, typically referred to as discogenic back pain. Yet despite decades of research into the neuroanatomy of the IVD, there is a lack of consensus in the literature as to the distribution and function of neural elements within the tissue. The current scoping review provides a comprehensive systematic overview of studies that document the topography, morphology, and immunoreactivity of neural elements within the IVD in humans.

METHOD

Articles were retrieved from six separate databases in a three-step systematic search and were independently evaluated by two reviewers.

RESULTS

Three categories of neural elements were described within the IVD: perivascular nerves, sensory nerves independent of blood vessels, and mechanoreceptors. Nerves were consistently localized within the outer layers of the annulus fibrosus. Neural ingrowth into the inner annulus fibrosus and nucleus pulposus was found to occur only in degenerative and disease states.

CONCLUSION

While the pattern of innervation within the IVD is clear, the specific topographic arrangement and function of neural elements in the context of back pain remains unclear.

Contribution of the sensory innervation of the spine in low back pain: review and clinical commentary

Few validated tests allow a precise aetiological diagnosis of Low Back Pain (LBP), and the difficulty of clinical evaluations could be one of the reasons to explain the lack of effectiveness in the therapeutic management of chronic LBP. However, an implication of a sensory impairment in the control of sensorimotor circuits could be suggested. Interactive and specific responses between nociceptive nerve fibres and the paraspinal musculature motor control could have clinical implications, in particular through kinematic evaluation. Following an introduction to the link between the sensory innervation of the spine and pain, we then summarise the maladaptive movement in LBP at the kinematic and neuropathological level. A clinical objectification of these kinematic adaptations at the lumbar spine level, would clarify the aetiological diagnosis causes of chronic LBP, and so help optimising therapeutic strategies by proposing a relevant and precise clinical model of this painful condition.

The degenerative lumbar disc: not a disease, but still an important consideration for OMPT practice: a review of the history and science of discogenic instability

BACKGROUND

A recent AAOMPT position paper was published that opposed the use of the term 'degenerative disc disease' (DDD), in large part because it appears to be a common age-related finding. While common, there are significant physiologic and biomechanical changes that occur as a result of discogenic degeneration, which are relevant to consider during the practice of manual therapy.

METHODS

A narrative review provides an overview of these considerations, including a historical perspective of discogenic instability, the role of the disc as a pain generator, the basic science of a combined biomechanical and physiologic cycle of degeneration and subsequent discogenic instability, the influence of rotation on the degenerative segment, the implications of these factors for manual therapy practice, and a perspective on an evidence-based treatment approach to patients with concurrent low back pain and discogenic degeneration.

CONCLUSIONS

As we consider the role of imaging findings such as DDD, we pose the following question: Do our manual interventions reflect the scientifically proven biomechanical aspects of DDD, or have we chosen to ignore the helpful science as we discard the harmful diagnostic label?

Sensory nerve ingrowth, cytokines, and instability of discogenic low back pain: A review

Introduction

Many patients suffer from discogenic low back pain. However, the mechanisms, diagnosistic strategy, and treatment of discogenic low back pain all remain controversial. The purpose of this paper was to review the pathological mechanisms of discogenic low back pain.

Methods

Many authors have investigated the pathological mechanisms of discogenic low back pain using animal models and examining human patients. Central to most investigations is understanding the innervation and instabilities of diseased intervertebral discs and the role of inflammatory mediators. We discuss three pathological mechanisms of discogenic low back pain: innervation, inflammation, and mechanical hypermobility of the intervertebral disc.

Results

Sensory nerve fibers include C-fibers and A delta-fibers, which relay pain signals from the innervated outer layers of the intervertebral disc under normal conditions. However, ingrowth of these sensory nerve fibers into the inner layers of intervertebral disc occurs under disease conditions. Levels of neurotrophic factors and some cytokines are significantly higher in diseased discs than in normal discs. Stablization of the segmental hypermobility, which can be induced by intervertebral disc degeneration, suppresses inflammation and prevents sensitization of sensory nerve fibers innervating the disc.

Conclusions

Pathological mechanisms of discogenic low back pain include sensory nerve ingrowth into inner layers of the intervertebral disc, upregulation of neurotrophic factors and cytokines, and instability. Inhibition of these mechanisms is important in the treatment of discogenic low back pain.

Pathomechanisms of discogenic low back pain in humans and animal models

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Although explored in humans and animal models, the pathomechanisms of discogenic low back pain (LBP) remain unknown.

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to review the literature about the pathomechanisms of discogenic LBP.

METHODS

Animal models of discogenic pain and specimens from degenerated human intervertebral discs (IVDs) have provided clues about the pathomechanisms of discogenic LBP. Painful discs are characterized by a confluence of innervation, inflammation, and mechanical hypermobility. These three possible mechanisms are discussed in this review.

RESULTS

Animal models and specimens from humans have revealed sensory innervation of lumbar IVDs and sensory nerve ingrowth into the inner layer of IVDs. Cytokines such as tumor necrosis factor-α and interleukins induce this ingrowth. Nerve growth factor has also been recently identified as an inducer of ingrowth. Finally, disc degeneration induces several collagenases; their action results in hypermobility and pain.

CONCLUSIONS

To treat discogenic LBP, it is important to prevent sensitization of sensory nerve fibers innervating the IVD, to suppress pathogenic increases of cytokines, and to decrease disc hypermobility.

Upregulation of BDNF and NGF in cervical intervertebral discs exposed to painful whole-body vibration

STUDY DESIGN

In vivo study defining expression of the neurotrophins, brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) and nerve growth factor (NGF), in cervical intervertebral discs after painful whole-body vibration (WBV).

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this study is to determine if BDNF and NGF are expressed in cervical discs after painful WBV in a rat model.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

WBV is a possible source of neck pain and has been implicated as increasing the risk for disc disorders. Typically, aneural regions of painful human lumbar discs exhibit hyperinnervation, suggesting nerve ingrowth as potentially contributing to disc degeneration and pain. BDNF and NGF are upregulated in painfully degenerate lumbar discs and hypothesized to contribute to this pathology.

METHODS

Male Holtzman rats underwent 7 days of repeated WBV (15 Hz, 30 min/d) or sham exposures, followed by 7 days of rest. Cervical discs were collected for analysis of BDNF and NGF expression through RT-qPCR and Western blot analysis. Immunohistochemistry also evaluated their regional expression in the disc.

RESULTS

Vibration significantly increases BDNF messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) levels (P=0.036), as well as total-NGF mRNA (P=0.035). Protein expression of both BDNF (P=0.006) and the 75-kDa NGF (P=0.045) increase by nearly 4- and 10-fold, respectively. Both BDNF mRNA (R=0.396; P=0.012) and protein (R=0.280; P=0.035) levels are significantly correlated with the degree of behavioral sensitivity (i.e., pain) at day 14. Total-NGF mRNA is also significantly correlated with the extent of behavioral sensitivity (R=0.276; P=0.044). Both neurotrophins are most increased in the inner annulus fibrosus and nucleus pulposus.

CONCLUSION

The increases in BDNF and NGF in the cervical discs after painful vibration are observed in typically aneural regions of the disc, consistent with reports of its hyperinnervation. Yet, the induction of nerve ingrowth into the disc was not explicitly investigated. Neurotrophin expression also correlates with behavioral sensitivity, suggesting a role for both neurotrophins in the development of disc pain.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

N/A.

Intradiscal electrothermal therapy treatment for back pain

The intradiscal electrothermal therapy (IDET) procedure is a minimally invasive technique designed to treat discogenic chronic low back pain. The debate surrounding IDET ranges from the concept of the procedure, the technique and patient selection, to its effectiveness. The procedure provides modest improvement; however, it is considered less invasive and destructive than other modalities of treatments available at the present time, and has lower cost. The effectiveness evidence is limited at the present time, but based on the results of six recently published positive single-arm studies, it appears that patients experienced a perceptible clinical benefit from the IDET procedure. Thus, IDET is recommended in patients with moderate functional impairment, relatively well-maintained disc heights and discogenic pain caused by annular tears or protrusions less than 3-4 mm after the failure of less invasive procedures.

Cell signaling pathways related to pain receptors in the degenerated disk

Many of the causes of low back pain are still unknown; sufficient evidence indicates that both degenerative and mechanical change within the intervertebral disk (IVD) is a relevant factor. This article reviews intracellular signaling pathways related to pain receptors in the degenerated IVD. Several reports have demonstrated the number of nerve fibers in the IVD was increased in degenerated disks. In recent years, some groups have reported that an increase in nerve fibers is associated with the presence of inflammatory mediators and/or neurotrophins in the IVD. Cell signaling events, which are regulated by inflammatory mediators and neurotrophins, must be identified to clarify the mechanism underlying low back pain. Major intracellular signaling pathways (nuclear factor kappa β, mitogen-activated protein kinases, and Wnts) potentially play vital roles in mediating the molecular events responsible for the initiation and progression of IVD degeneration. These signaling pathways may represent therapeutic targets for the treatment of IVD degeneration and its associated back pain.

Paraspinal muscle activation in accordance with mechanoreceptors in the intervertebral discs

Paraspinal muscle forces were derived computationally based on the hypothesis that the intervertebral disc has a transducer function and the muscle is activated according to a sensor-driving control mechanism. A three-dimensional finite element model of the musculoskeletal system, which consisted of a detailed whole lumbar spine, pelvis, simplified trunk model, and muscles, was developed and combined with an optimization technique to calculate muscle forces in isometric forward flexed and erect standing postures. Minimization of deviations in the nucleus pressure and averaged tensile stress in the annulus fibers at five discs was used for muscle force calculations. The results indicated that all the muscles were properly activated to maintain posture and stabilize the lumbar spine. The nucleus pressure difference was decreased during the iterative calculations and its resulting value at the L4/L5 level was consistent with in vivo measurements. Muscle activation produced vertebra motion, which resulted in a relatively uniform stress distribution in the intervertebral discs. This can minimize the risk of injury at a specific level and increase the ability of the spine to sustain a load.

The molecular basis of intervertebral disc degeneration

BACKGROUND

Intervertebral disc (IVD) degeneration remains a clinically important condition for which treatment is costly and relatively ineffective. The molecular basis of degenerative disc disease has been an intense focus of research recently, which has greatly increased our understanding of the biology underlying this process.

PURPOSE

To review the current understanding of the molecular basis of disc degeneration.

STUDY DESIGN

Review article.

METHODS

A literature review was performed to identify recent investigations and current knowledge regarding the molecular basis of IVD degeneration.

RESULTS

The unique structural requirements and biochemical properties of the disc contribute to its propensity toward degeneration. Mounting evidence suggests that genetic factors account for up to 75% of individual susceptibility to IVD degeneration, far more than the environmental factors such as occupational exposure or smoking that were previously suspected to figure prominently in this process. Decreased extracellular matrix production, increased production of degradative enzymes, and increased expression of inflammatory cytokines contribute to the loss of structural integrity and accelerate IVD degeneration. Neurovascular ingrowth occurs, in part, because of the changing degenerative phenotype.

CONCLUSIONS

A detailed understanding of the biology of IVD degeneration is essential to the design of therapeutic solutions to treat degenerative discs. Although significant advances have been made in explaining the biologic mediators of disc degeneration, the inhospitable biochemical environment of the IVD remains a challenging environment for biological therapies.

New hypothesis of chronic back pain: low pH promotes nerve ingrowth into damaged intervertebral disks

The pathogenesis of low back pain is still elusive. Here, we proposed a new hypothesis that low pH is a possible cause of the development and progression of low back pain. We propose that low pH promotes the production of the inflammatory mediators and the depletion of proteoglycan in the damaged intervertebral disk. The inflammation response, evoked by the dorsal root ganglia, changes the delicate nutrient balance in the nucleus, resulting in a vicious cycle and leading to choronic back pain. Our hypothesis may explain many of the available clinical and experimental data on low back pain, thus it may help elucidate the pathogenesis of low back pain and improve clinical management.

Increased expression of netrin-1 and its deleted in colorectal cancer receptor in human diseased lumbar intervertebral disc compared with autopsy control

STUDY DESIGN

The expression of netrin-1 and its deleted in colorectal cancer (DCC) receptor was investigated in human lumbar discs using immunohistochemistry.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the expression of netrin-1 and DCC receptor in human diseased and healthy lumbar intervertebral discs (IVDs) and to clarify the correlation between netrin-1 expression and the degree of neurovascular ingrowth.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Previous studies have shown neurovascular ingrowth into the inner regions of degenerated IVD and suggested that the ingrowth may contribute to discogenic low back pain. Netrin-1 is an axon guidance molecule that regulates axons seeking their final targets and has been identified as involved in various pathological conditions, so is its DCC receptor. However, the role of netrin-1 in diseased IVDs remains unknown.

METHODS

Thirty-five diseased IVD specimens were collected from 34 patients with different lumbar diseases during posterior lumbar interbody fusion. Eight normal discs were obtained at autopsy as control. Using polyclonal or monoclonal antibody, the disc slides were immmunostained to detect the expression and distribution of netrin-1, the DCC, the neuronal marker (neurofilament), and the vascular endothelial cell marker (CD34).

RESULTS

Netrin-1 and DCC immunopositive cells distributed substantially from the annulus fibrosus to the nucleus pulposus (NP), and the immunopositivity was detected in the disc cells, endothelial cells and granulation tissue cells in the diseased discs. The percentage of netrin-1 positive disc cells of the NP was more than that of the annulus fibrosus. The expression of netrin-1 and DCC was weak in the normal discs. A significant positive correlation between the percentage of netrin-1 immunopositive disc cells and neurovascular scores was found.

CONCLUSION

The increased expression of netrin-1 and DCC in diseased IVDs compared with controls suggested that they might play an important role in the process of neurovascular ingrowth.

MRI FINDINGS AFTER AN EXPERIMENTAL DISC LESION

Purpose: A minipig model was used to demonstrate MRI findings in the first three months after an annular disruption. Methods: An incision was made into one of the lumbar discs in each of eight minipigs in the outer and middle parts of the annulus. The remaining intact discs in the lumbar and thoracolumbar regions were used as controls. MR imaging was performed one month and three months after trauma using both a 1.0 T and a 1.5 T MR unit. The histologic analysis was also carried out to demonstrate morphological changes in disc. Results: Eighty-eight percent of the injured discs had a diminished area of bright signal in the nucleus pulposus, also in cases where no signs of trauma in the annulus could be detected in MRI. The degeneration process of the nucleus pulposus was shown to progress during follow-up. High intensity zones were detected in 50% of the injured discs and they tended to appear already after one month follow-up. Histological examination showed that the high-intensity zone contained clusters of nuclear cells originating in the nucleus pulposus. Conclusion: It is concluded that lesions producing high-intensity zones can be induced in an experimental animal model and it can already be detected one month after the trauma. Degeneration process of the nucleus is generally initiated after a peripheral annular lesion.

Pharmacological inhibition of tumor necrosis factor may reduce pain behavior changes induced by experimental disc puncture in the rat: an experimental study in rats

STUDY DESIGN

Pain behavior assessment in rats following disc puncture (DP) and simultaneous tumor necrosis factor (TNF) inhibition.

OBJECTIVE

To assess if treatment with TNF inhibition could reduce the pain behavior changes induced by DP in the rat.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Anular tears with leakage of nucleus pulposus have been suggested to be one possible cause of low back pain (LBP). In an experimental model, it was recently shown that DP might induce specific pain behavior changes. The aim of the present study was to a study if inhibition of TNF might reduce such pain behavior changes.

METHODS

Sixty rats underwent facetectomy and puncture of the fourth lumbar disc. The rats were simultaneously treated with doxycycline locally at 0.3 and 3.0 mg/kg and systemically at 3.0 mg/kg, or infliximab locally at 0.5 and 5.0 mg/kg, and systemically at 5.0 mg/kg, (n ∇ 10 for each subseries). The rats were videotaped at 1, 3, 7, 14, and 21 days after surgery. The videos were analyzed regarding presence of wet-dog shakes (WDS). Data from a previous study with sham surgery and DP without treatment were included for comparison.

RESULTS

All groups treated with doxycycline resulted in a statistically significant reduction of WDS compared to the group without treatment (DP). In infliximab treated animals, WDS decreased with statistically significance compared to the nontreated DP group at all analyzed days except for the group with high dose local treatment where a statistically significant reduction was obtained only at days 14 and 21.

CONCLUSION

The present study showed that TNF inhibition induced a marked reduction of wet dog shakes. It is not fully understood if wet-dog shakes may relate to LBP, but in view of recent clinical findings one may consider clinical studies of TNF inhibition for the treatment of LBP.

Innervation of anulus tears: an experimental animal study

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective immunohistological study in an animal model.

OBJECTIVE

To identify and describe the phenotype of neoinnervation in experimental anular tears.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Controversy surrounds neoinnervation of degenerate discs which has been proposed as the anatomic basis for discogenic pain. Ablation of neoinnervation has been postulated as the theoretical basis for the claimed successes of procedures such as intradiscal electrotherapy. The animal model of disc degeneration previously developed in our research center provides an opportunity to investigate the innervation of anular tears in an extensively characterized lesion.

METHODS

A surgical anular tear was created in 5 lumbar discs in 11 sheep which were killed at 1, 2, 3, and 12 months. Each spine was x-rayed and divided into motion segments for histologic analysis. Serial sections through the tear were immunostained for protein gene product 9.5, tyrosine hydroxylase, and calcitonin gene receptor protein.

RESULTS

Neoinnervation of the periphery of the anular tear was observed. Ingrowing nerves penetrated marginally deeper than the normal anular innervation but no nerves were identified in the inner anulus or nucleus. A minority of the new axons were calcitonin gene receptor protein or tyrosine hydroxylase positive.

CONCLUSION

The anulus tears in this model are innervated only peripherally to a depth only marginally greater than that of the normal anulus.

Use of Temporary Implantable Biomaterials to Reduce Leg Pain and Back Pain in Patients with Sciatica and Lumbar Disc Herniation

The principle etiology of leg pain (sciatica) from lumbar disc herniation is mechanical compression of the nerve root. Sciatica is reduced by decompression of the herniated disc, i.e., removing mechanical compression of the nerve root. Decompression surgery typically reduces sciatica more than lumbar back pain (LBP). Decompression surgery reduces mechanical compression of the nerve root. However, decompression surgery does not directly reduce sensitization of the sensory nerves in the epidural space and disc. In addition, sensory nerves in the annulus fibrosus and epidural space are not protected from topical interaction with pain mediators induced by decompression surgery. The secondary etiology of sciatica from lumbar disc herniation is sensitization of the nerve root. Sensitization of the nerve root results from a) mechanical compression, b) exposure to cellular pain mediators, and/or c) exposure to biochemical pain mediators. Although decompression surgery reduces nerve root compression, sensory nerve sensitization often persists. These observations are consistent with continued exposure of tissue in the epidural space, including the nerve root, to increased cellular and biochemical pain mediators following surgery. A potential contributor to lumbar back pain (LBP) is stimulation of sensory nerves in the annulus fibrosus by a) cellular pain mediators and/or b) biochemical pain mediators that accompany annular tears or disruption. Sensory fibers located in the outer one-third of the annulus fibrosus increase in number and depth as a result of disc herniation. The nucleus pulposus is comprised of material that can produce an autoimmune stimulation of the sensory nerves located in the annulus and epidural space leading to LBP. The sensory nerves of the annulus fibrosus and epidural space may be sensitized by topical exposure to cellular and biochemical pain mediators induced by lumbar surgery. Annulotomy or annular rupture allows the nucleus pulposus topical access to sensory nerve fibers, thereby leading to LBP. Coverage of the annulus and adjacent structures in the epidural space by absorbable viscoelastic gels appears to reduce LBP following surgery by protecting sensory fibers from cellular and biochemical pain mediators.

Intervertebral disc degeneration

Disc degeneration in the human spine is a complex phenomenon characterised by biochemical change in the nucleus pulposus and inner annulus and the formation of clefts and fissures radiating from the central area of the disc towards the periphery. In addition, and probably independent of these phenomena, discrete defects in the outer annular attachement are seen which are likely to be due to mechanical stress and failure. The presence of stress tears in disc tissue and their failure to heal can initiate or accelerate the degeneration of the central component of the intervertebral disc. We postulate that discogenic pain may be linked to damage to the outer portion of the annulus fibrosus. Although it would seem logical to assume that discs with sustained high intradiscal pressure would be more prone to pain referred in the outer annular layers because of higher tensile strain, analysis of prospective studies has failed to confirm a relationship between typical pain reproduction at discography and high pressure values. It is concluded that, at present, the only consistent morphological changes present in patients with pain reproduction at discography are the presence of various annular defects involving the outer layers. Whether nerve ingrowth during attempts at repair of these defects is a consistent feature remains to be established.

[Non-specific lower back pain: In search of the origin of pain]

Lower back pain is a condition considered benign and with a specific cause determined only in 15% of patients. In the past years this concept has varied, because many papers have described no benign condition leading to back pain, citing their capacity to cause disability. Through many different diagnostic techniques it is possible to identify the structures capable of producing back pain. This identification, and the level of evidence of the interventional techniques, is the aim of this paper.

Nerve growth factor in rheumatic diseases

OBJECTIVES

The nervous system modulates the immune response in many autoimmune syndromes by neurogenic inflammation. One of the pivotal mediators is nerve growth factor (NGF), which is known for its effects on neuronal survival and growth. There is considerable evidence that NGF acts as an important mediator of many immune responses. This article reviews the role of NGF in rheumatic diseases and strategies for potential therapeutic interventions.

METHODS

We conducted a database search using Medline and Medpilot. Eight hundred abstracts containing the keyword NGF and 1 of the following terms were reviewed: arthritis, neurogenic inflammation, rheumatoid arthritis, osteoarthritis, collagen arthritis, arteritis, psoriasis, psoriatic arthritis, Sjogren syndrome, systemic lupus erythematosus, gout, osteoporosis, lower back pain, lumbar disc herniation, nerve root compression, spondyloarthritis, spondylarthropathy, algoneurodystrophy, fibromyalgia, Kawasaki syndrome, polyarteritis nodosa, cytokine, vasculitis, pain, therapy, and antagonist. Articles were analyzed based on relevance and content. Most clinical trials and studies with human specimens were included. Studies with experimental animal models were selected if they contained relevant data.

RESULTS

NGF is overexpressed in many inflammatory and degenerative rheumatic diseases. Concentrations differ to some extent and sometimes even show contradictory results. NGF is found in serum, synovial fluid, and cerebrospinal fluid, and tissue specimens. NGF concentrations can be correlated with the extent of inflammation and/or clinical activity in many conditions. In rheumatoid arthritis, NGF levels are significantly higher as compared with osteoarthritis.

CONCLUSIONS

NGF is a significant mediator and modulator of inflammation. NGF sometimes shows detrimental and sometimes regenerative activity. These findings indicate potential therapeutic interventions using either NGF antagonists or recombinant NGF.

What is mechanical back pain and how best to treat it?

Back pain is one of the most common patient complaints brought forth to physicians. Mechanical back pain accounts for 97% of cases, arising from spinal structures such as bone, ligaments, discs, joints, nerves, and meninges. Acute back pain in the absence of progressive neurologic deficits and other underlying nonmechanical causes may be treated conservatively, with specific emphasis on maintaining activity levels and function. Mechanical back pain persisting for more than 4 to 6 weeks may warrant further diagnostic testing and imaging. Common causes of mechanical back pain include spinal stenosis, herniated discs, zygapophysial joint pain, discogenic pain, vertebral fractures, sacroiliac joint pain, and myofascial pain. A wide variety of treatments are available, with different treatments specifically targeted toward different causes. A balanced approach, which takes into account patient psychosocial factors and incorporates multidisciplinary care, increases the likelihood of success from back pain interventions.

Percutaneous endoscopic laser annuloplasty for discogenic low back pain

BACKGROUND

Laser-assisted spinal endoscopy (LASE) kit has been used for percutaneous intradiscal decompression to evaporate and shrink the posterior and central nucleus for improvement of leg and radicular pain due to contained disc herniation. Percutaneous endoscopic laser annuloplasty (PELA), a new minimally invasive technique, uses LASE to directly coagulate the inflamed disc granulation tissue associated with annular tears. The small diameter of the endoscope including Ho:YAG laser, irrigation, and light, plus the extreme posterolateral approach into the posterior annulus, enables one to minimize damage to normal nuclear tissue. The authors sought to demonstrate the safety and efficacy of PELA for controlling discogenic low back pain (DLBP) due to abnormal disc tissues, new vessels, and nerves in the central torn posterior annulus.

METHODS

Clinical outcomes of PELA were investigated in patients having DLBP with an annulus-torn degenerative disc or contained disc herniation. Thirty patients treated at a single level and achieving a mean follow-up of 9.7 months were analyzed. Outcomes were assessed using the visual analog scale (VAS) for back pain, the Korean Oswestry Disability Index (KODI), and the modified Macnab's criteria.

RESULTS

The mean back pain VAS score improved from 8.0 to 2.4, and the mean KODI score improved from 79.0 to 22.4 (P < .001). Results by the modified Macnab's criteria also showed a good outcome, with a success rate of 90.0%. There were no serious complications observed during follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Percutaneous endoscopic laser annuloplasty using the Ho:YAG laser provides favorable outcomes for carefully selected groups of patients with DLBP.

Postdiskogram CT features of lidocaine-sensitive and lidocaine-insensitive severely painful disks at provocation lumbar diskography

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

At lumbar diskography, intradiskal lidocaine can eliminate or reduce provoked diskogenic pain. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the postdiskogram CT features of lidocaine-sensitive and lidocaine-insensitive severely painful disks.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Intradiskal lidocaine was injected at 182 severely painful levels in 111 patients. Clinical records/imaging studies were reviewed for response to intradiskal lidocaine (complete/substantial, partial, and no pain improvement), evidence of diskographic contrast leakage (fluoroscopic/CT images), and the overall postdiskogram CT appearance in these severely painful disks. The assessed traditional Dallas grade (degeneration/radial tear [RT]) was supplemented by identified postdiskogram CT features of annular derangement (annular gap [AG], RT into peripheral annular tear [PAT], isolated PAT, lamellar annular tear, free/attached annular fragments, bucket-handle tear, and peripheral annular pocket).

RESULTS

Isolated degenerative changes (40%) and radial defects with or without degeneration (60%) subsets were noted. Dallas grade 3 degeneration was most commonly observed (69%) with increased features of annular derangement in disks with a worsening Dallas grade. Complete/substantial versus no pain improvement was significantly associated with disk state (diskographic leakage, contained), radial defect (none, RT, or AG), and "RT-into-PAT" and were statistically significant in univariate models (P < .001). The associations remained significant in multivariate models. Higher Dallas degenerative grade and presence of free annular fragments were associated with a greater chance of no pain relief.

CONCLUSION

Severely painful disks demonstrated complex annular derangement with both radial defects (RTs and AGs) or degenerative changes present, alone or in combination. Complete/substantial pain improvement after lidocaine administration is associated with disk state, radial defect (RT and AG), and RT-into-PAT.

Puncture of a lumbar intervertebral disc induces changes in spontaneous pain behavior: an experimental study in rats

STUDY DESIGN

Changes in spontaneous behavior was studied in rats after a controlled puncture of a lumbar intervertebral disc.

OBJECTIVE

To study if puncture of a lumbar disc would induce recordable changes in spontaneous pain behavior.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Anular tears are common and may be found both in patients with low back pain and in asymptomatic patients. It has been suggested that anular injury may relate to low back pain either by stimulation of local sensory receptors in the posterior part of the anulus fibrosus or by ingrowth of newly formed nerve fibers into the deeper parts of the disc. The objective of the study was to analyze if a controlled puncture of a lumbar intervertebral disc might induce recordable changes in spontaneous behavior of rats.

METHODS

After anesthesia, the L4-L5 disc was punctured in 10 rats. Ten other rats received sham surgery. Spontaneous behavior was assessed at days 1, 3, 7, 14, and 21 after surgery.

RESULTS

Statistically significant differences in behavior were seen at all days analyzed. Most consistent were increases in "grooming" and in "wet-dog shakes."

CONCLUSION

Puncture of a lumbar intervertebral disc in the rat produces changes in spontaneous behavior mainly seen as increased "grooming" and "wet-dog shakes," 2 behaviors that have been suggested to indicate stress and pain.

The nerve supply of the lumbar intervertebral disc

The anatomical studies, basic to our understanding of lumbar spine innervation through the sinu-vertebral nerves, are reviewed. Research in the 1980s suggested that pain sensation was conducted in part via the sympathetic system. These sensory pathways have now been clarified using sophisticated experimental and histochemical techniques confirming a dual pattern. One route enters the adjacent dorsal root segmentally, whereas the other supply is non-segmental ascending through the paravertebral sympathetic chain with re-entry through the thoracolumbar white rami communicantes. Sensory nerve endings in the degenerative lumbar disc penetrate deep into the disrupted nucleus pulposus, insensitive in the normal lumbar spine. Complex as well as free nerve endings would appear to contribute to pain transmission. The nature and mechanism of discogenic pain is still speculative but there is growing evidence to support a 'visceral pain' hypothesis, unique in the muscloskeletal system. This mechanism is open to 'peripheral sensitisation' and possibly 'central sensitisation' as a potential cause of chronic back pain.

Pain improvement after intradiskal lidocaine administration in provocation lumbar diskography: association with diskographic contrast leakage

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Our aim was to evaluate the relationship of pain reduction, after intradiskal lidocaine administration during provocation lumbar diskography, to the presence of contrast leakage on postdiskographic imaging.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Intradiskal lidocaine was injected at 182 significantly painful disk levels in 111 patients. The clinical records and imaging studies were reviewed for response to the lidocaine injection and for the presence/absence of diskographic contrast leakage on postdiskographic images and CT. Pain response was assigned the following grades: 1) complete or substantial improvement, 2) partial improvement, or 3) no significant improvement after lidocaine administration. Fluoroscopic imaging and postdiskographic CT were evaluated for the presence or absence of contrast leakage.

RESULTS

Eighty-two (45%) significantly painful treated disks were contained, and 100 (55%) demonstrated contrast leakage. In leaking disks, 74 (74%) demonstrated complete or near-complete pain reduction after lidocaine administration, 15 (15%) demonstrated partial improvement, and 11 (11%) demonstrated no pain relief. In contained disks, 56 disks (69%) demonstrated no improvement after lidocaine administration, 9 (11%) demonstrating partial relief, and 17 (20%) demonstrated complete or substantial improvement. Results comparing leaking disks versus contained disks and complete versus no improvement were statistically significant (P<.001).

CONCLUSION

Painful disks exhibiting diskographic leakage tend to be highly responsive to intradiskal lidocaine administration, whereas painful disks without diskographic leakage tend not to improve. This observation has implications with respect to targeting the origin of a patient's back pain and may have specific implications with respect to choice of treatment.

Systematic approach to interpretation of the lumbar spine MR imaging examination

The lumbar spine MR imaging study is one of the most frequently ordered MR imaging examinations in the United States. Numerous possible causes exist for low back pain, which contributes to the diagnostic challenge that imagers face in arriving at clinically relevant diagnoses from the anatomic information provided by MR imaging. In this article, the authors suggest a systematic approach to MR imaging interpretation. The evaluation may be altered, based on individual preferences and the specific clinical scenario. The author also highlights commonly encountered disease processes, pertinent MR imaging anatomy, and some common diagnostic pitfalls. Normal and abnormal spine MR images are also shown.

Nonlinear finite element analysis of anular lesions in the L4/5 intervertebral disc

Degenerate intervertebral discs exhibit both material and structural changes. Structural defects (lesions) develop in the anulus fibrosus with age. While degeneration has been simulated in numerous previous studies, the effects of structural lesions on disc mechanics are not well known. In this study, a finite element model (FEM) of the L4/5 intervertebral disc was developed in order to study the effects of anular lesions and loss of hydrostatic pressure in the nucleus pulposus on the disc mechanics. Models were developed to simulate both healthy and degenerate discs. Degeneration was simulated with either rim, radial or circumferential anular lesions and by equating nucleus pressure to zero. The anulus fibrosus ground substance was represented as a nonlinear incompressible material using a second-order polynomial, hyperelastic strain energy equation. Hyperelastic material parameters were derived from experimentation on sheep discs. Endplates were assumed to be rigid, and annulus lamellae were assumed to be vertical in the unloaded state. Loading conditions corresponding to physiological ranges of rotational motion were applied to the models and peak rotation moments compared between models. Loss of nucleus pulposus pressure had a much greater effect on the disc mechanics than the presence of anular lesions. This indicated that the development of anular lesions alone (prior to degeneration of the nucleus) has minimal effect on disc mechanics, but that disc stiffness is significantly reduced by the loss of hydrostatic pressure in the nucleus. With the degeneration of the nucleus, the outer innervated anulus or surrounding osteo-ligamentous anatomy may therefore experience increased strains.

Projection field of primary afferent fibers innervating the ventral portion of the lumbar intervertebral disc in the spinal cord dorsal horn

In the present study, we investigated the central projection of afferent fibers innervating the lumbar intervertebral disc using the fluorescent neurotracer 1,1'-dioctadecyl-3,3,3',3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine perchlorate (Dil). The tracer Dil was applied to the ventrolateral portion of the L5-L6 intervertebral disc in 11 adult rats. Fluorescent sites were observed microscopically on spinal cord transverse sections. Fluorescent spots in laminae I-III were plotted on the central projection map of cutaneous afferents. In six of 11 rats, Dil was restricted to the application site. Of these six rats, three showed no evident fluorescent sites. In the remaining three rats, small fluorescent spots were scattered in the dorsal horn. Fluorescent spots in dorsal horn lamina I were located in the central projection fields of the low back and groin skin. Fluorescent spots were observed, also sporadically, in Clarke's column in T12-L1 segments. The central projection of afferent fibers innervating the rat lumbar intervertebral disc was indistinct with Dil labeling. We presumed this was due to the scarcity of central terminal arbors of disc afferent fibers. Spotty projections in laminae I-IllIIere present near the central projection fields of the loin and groin, indicating that pain would be perceived in the groin.

Intradiscal therapy: a review of current treatment modalities

STUDY DESIGN

A systematic review of the medical literature regarding current intradiscal therapeutic methods.

OBJECTIVES

To establish an understanding of the current intradiscal treatment options for the management of low back pain.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Current treatment of intradiscal disease is rapidly evolving and as such should be a multidisciplinary effort that follows a logical, orderly algorithm. Minimally invasive techniques, namely, intradiscal electrothermal therapy (IDET), radiofrequency ablation (RFA), percutaneous endoscopic laser discectomy (PELD), and cryoablation have challenged the conventional surgical management of back pain.

METHODS

Thirty-eight research reports, published between 1986 and 2005, were systematically reviewed for disease classification, surgical intervention, and treatment outcomes (neurologic status, pain scores, and ambulation).

RESULTS

The surgical literature on the management of intradiscal disease continues to be limited to large series with short clinical follow-ups. Arthrodesis continues to be the primary treatment modality in the majority of patients. Newer treatment options including IDET, RFA, PELD, and cryoablation have shown promising results with regards to symptomatic relief and early return to function.

CONCLUSION

Low back pain is an extremely common and potentially debilitating problem. Adding biophysical methods to well-tested biomechanical and newly investigated biomolecular solutions allows for multiple avenues of therapeutic interventions. With future clinical and basic science studies regarding intradiscal therapies forthcoming, we may soon alter our current treatment algorithms for the management of discogenic back pain.

Immunohistochemical demonstration of lumbar intervertebral disc innervation in the dog

Low back pain is a common ailment in dogs, particularly in specific breeds such as the German shepherd dog. A number of structures such as facet joint capsules, ligaments, dorsal root ganglia, periosteum, vertebral endplates and meninges have been associated with this condition. Yet, in spite of all diagnostic efforts, the origin of pain remains obscure in a substantial proportion of all cases. A further structure often being involved in vertebral column disorders is the intervertebral disc. The presence of nerves, however, is a precondition for pain sensation and, consequently, structures lacking innervation can be left out of consideration as a cause for low back pain. Nerve fibres have been demonstrated at the periphery of the intervertebral disc in man, rabbit and rat. With regard to the dog, however, the extent of intervertebral disc innervation is still being disputed. The goal of the present study, therefore, was to substantiate and expand current knowledge of intervertebral disc innervation. Protein gene product (PGP) 9.5 was used for immunohistochemical examination of serial transversal and sagittal paraffin sections of lumbar discs from adult dogs. This general marker revealed nerve fibres to be confined to the periphery of the intervertebral discs. These results indicate that even limited pathological processes affecting the outer layers of the intervertebral disc are prone to cause low back pain.

Epidural steroid therapy for back and leg pain: mechanisms of action and efficacy

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Epidural steroid injection (ESI) is one of the most common nonsurgical interventions prescribed for back and leg pain symptoms. Although the use of ESI is widespread, proof of efficacy among the broad population of low back pain patients is lacking and use is predicated to a great extent on the cost and morbidity of the perceived "next step" in many patient's care-surgery.

PURPOSE

To review the relative indications and clinical features that predict success with ESI therapy, and to provide a physiological rationale to guide clinical decision-making.

STUDY DESIGN/SETTING

Review of literature and clinical experience.

RESULTS

Clinical studies have alternately supported and refuted the efficacy of ESI in the treatment of patients with back and leg pain. Steroid medications do benefit some patients with radicular pain, but the benefit is often limited in duration, making efficacy difficult to prove over time. Steroids appear to speed the rate of recovery and return to function, however, allowing patients to reduce medication levels and increase activity while awaiting the natural improvement expected in most spinal disorders. Fluoroscopic verification of needle placement, with contrast injection, greatly improves steroid delivery while reducing risks. Although it is assumed that the benefit of steroids is related to their effect on inflammation, that remains unproven, and it is possible that benefit is gained through an unrecognized action.

CONCLUSIONS

Randomized, controlled trials are needed to conclusively identify those patients most likely to benefit from ESI, and when and for how long. Until then, epidural steroids provide a reasonable alternative to surgical intervention in selected patients with back and/or leg pain, whose symptoms are functionally limiting. When appropriate goals are established and proper patients are selected, sufficient short-term benefit has been documented to warrant continued use of this tool.

Percutaneous Laser Disc Decompression in the Treatment of Discogenic Back Pain

OBJECTIVE

Our aim was to evaluate the effects of percutaneous laser disc decompression (PLDD) as discogenic pain treatment using the MacNab criteria.

BACKGROUND DATA

Discogenic back pain is believed to be produced from tears in the posterior longitudinal ligament and annulus fibrosus. This pain is exacerbated through increases in intradiscal pressure via provocative discograms and transmitted through the sinuvertebral nerve.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 37 patients were selected based on clinical findings and provocative discograms. These patients underwent PLDD to the affected disc and were interviewed via telephone and outcome evaluated based on the MacNab criteria.

RESULTS

Survey results revealed that 14 patients (44%) reported a good response, 14 (44%) reported a fair response, and four (12.5%) reported a poor response. The 28 patients (88%) who reported a good and fair response were considered to be successful cases.

CONCLUSION

PLDD is a safe, effective, and minimally invasive procedure that can be used to treat patients with discogenic back pain.