Lack of concordance in parapneumonic effusion management in children in central Europe

Parapneumonic empyema in children: a scoping review of the literature

Community-acquired pneumonia can lead to a serious complication called empyema, which refers to pus within the pleural space. While it poses a significant threat to morbidity, particularly in children, it is fortunately not associated with high mortality rates. However, determining the best course of management for children, including decisions regarding antibiotic selection, administration methods, and treatment duration, remains a topic of ongoing debate. This scoping review aims to map the existing literature on empyema in children, including types of studies, microbiology, therapies (both antimicrobial and surgical) and patient outcomes. We systematically searched PubMed and SCOPUS using the terms "pediatric" (encompassing children aged 0 to 18 years) and "pleural empyema" to identify all relevant studies published since 2000. This search adhered to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA ScR) checklist.A total of 127 studies was included. Overall, 15 attempted to compare medical treatments (alone or in combination with pleural drainage or fibrinolysis) with more invasive surgical approaches, and six studies compared diverse surgical interventions. However, the diversity of study designs makes it difficult to derive firm conclusions on the optimal approach to pediatric empyema. The heterogeneity in inclusion criteria, pharmacological/surgical approaches and settings limit the ability to draw definitive conclusions. Overall, 78 out of 10,896 children (0.7%) included in the review died, with mortality being higher in Asia and Africa. Our scoping review highlights important gaps regarding several aspects of empyema in children, including specific serotypes of the most common bacteria involved in the etiology, the optimal pharmacological and surgical approach, and the potential benefits of newer antibiotics with optimal lung penetration. New trials, designed on a multi-country level a higher number of patients and more rigorous inclusion criteria and designs, should be urgently funded.

Therapy of parapneumonic empyema in children: a protocol for a scoping review of the literature

Background

Empyema (the presence of pus in the pleural space) is a severe complication of community-acquired pneumonia and significant cause of morbidity, but, fortunately, not mortality in children. Between 0.6 and 2% of pneumonias are complicated by empyema and the three main pathogens involved are Streptococcus pneumoniae, Staphylococcus aureus and group A Streptococcus 1,2,3,4. Optimal management in children, especially the choice of antibiotics, method of administration and duration of therapy, pleural dranage or surgery, are still a matter of debate and currently, lack of strong specific recommendations. This paper displays the study protocol for a scoping review that aims to summarize the available literature on the microbiological epidemiology, the medical and surgical treatment options, and the outcomes of pleural empyema in pediatric population.

Methods

Comprehensive research combining the terms pediatric (children aged 0 to 18 years) and pleural empyema will be performed on PubMed and SCOPUS to identify all eligible studies. At first, two reviewers will screen the abstract and then their full text to determine the articles that meet the inclusion criteria. This work will be carried out independently, everyone on a different Excel spreadsheet and each researcher will be blinded to the decision of the other researcher. When the process is completed, in case of discordance, any disagreement will be identified and resolved through discussion or with help of a third author.

Dissemination

The findings of this review will be published in a peer-reviewed journal.

Inflammatory rebound and postinfectious inflammatory response in children with pleural infection: A single-center retrospective study

INTRODUCTION

As pleural inflammation plays a central role in pleural infection (PI), corticosteroids are increasingly being considered as a potential therapy. However, the timing of treatment and the identification of patients who might benefit most remain unresolved. The aim of this study was therefore to investigate the inflammatory trajectories of children with PI.

METHODS

This retrospective single-center study included children aged 3 months to 17 years and 11 months hospitalized for PI due to Streptococcus pyogenes, Streptococcus pneumonia, and Staphylococcus aureus over 10 years. An inflammatory rebound was defined biologically as a reincrease in C-reactive protein (CRP) of at least 50 mg/L after an initial decrease in CRP of at least 50 mg/L.

RESULTS

We included 53 cases of PI, including 16 due to S. pyogenes, 27 due to S. pneumonia, and 10 due to S. aureus. An inflammatory rebound occurred in 20 patients (38%) after a median of 4.5 (3-6) days. This inflammatory rebound occurred in 9 (56%) children with S. pyogenes, 8 (30%) children with S. pneumonia, and 3 (30%) children with S. aureus. Children with an inflammatory rebound also had a higher rate of persistent fever after Day 7 and a longer length of stay (p = .01 for both).

CONCLUSION

We postulate that the inflammatory rebound identified in nearly 40% of our patients corresponds to an early postinfectious inflammatory response, and thus that corticosteroids may be most beneficial for children with PI if administered early (between Days 2 and 5).

Conservative Treatment of Parapneumonic Effusion in Children: Experience From a 10-Year Consecutive Case Series

BACKGROUND

In children with parapneumonic effusion (PPE), it remains unclear when conservative treatment with antibiotics suffixes or when pleural drainage is needed. In this study we evaluate clinical features and outcomes of children with PPE.

METHODS

A retrospective, multicentre cohort study at 4 Dutch pediatric departments was performed, including patients 1-18 years treated for PPE between January 2010 and June 2020.

RESULTS

One hundred thirty-six patients were included (mean age 8.3 years, SD 4.8). 117 patients (86%) were treated conservatively and 19 (14%) underwent pleural drainage. Patients undergoing pleural drainage had mediastinal shift more frequently compared with conservatively treated patients (58 vs. 3%, difference 55%; 95% CI: 32%-77%). The same accounted for pleural septations/pockets (58 vs. 11%, difference 47%; 95% CI: 24%-70%), pleural thickening (47 vs. 4%, difference 43%; 95% CI: 20%-66%) and effusion size (median 5.9 vs. 2.7 cm; P = 0.032). Conservative management was successful in 27% of patients (4 of 15) with mediastinal shift, 54% of patients (13 of 24) with septations/pockets, 36% of patients (5 of 14) with pleural thickening, and 9% of patients (3 of 32) with effusions >3 cm, all radiological signs generally warranting pleural drainage. In patients treated conservatively, median duration of hospitalization was 5 days (IQR 4-112) compared with 19 days (IQR 15-24) in the drainage group ( P < 0.001), without significant difference in readmission rate (11 vs. 4%, difference 6%; 95% CI: -8%-21%).

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that the greater amount of children with PPE could be treated conservatively with antibiotics only, especially in absence of mediastinal shift, pleural septations/pockets, pleural thickening or extensive effusions.

Management of parapneumonic pleural effusion in children: Is there a role for corticosteroids when conventional nonsurgical management fails? A single-center 15-year experience

OBJECTIVE

Description of the use of corticosteroids for the management of parapneumonic pleural effusion in children.

METHODS

Retrospective single-center observational study of all children hospitalized with a diagnosis of parapneumonic pleural effusion during a 15-year period.

RESULTS

We documented 97 cases of parapneumonic effusion during the study period, with a median age (interquartile range [IQR]) of 43 (33-61) months. Most of the children benefited from an evacuation of the pleural effusion (89/97, 91.8%): 21 patients (21.6%) were treated with needle thoracocentesis only, while a chest tube was inserted in 68 children (70.1%). Thirty-two patients (33%) were treated with intrapleural fibrinolysis. Fifty-five children (56.7%) received corticosteroids for persistent fever. The median time (IQR) between hospital admission and initiation of corticosteroids was 5.5 (4-7) days. When corticosteroids were initiated, children had been febrile for 9 (IQR: 8-11) days. The fever ceased in a median (IQR) of 0 (0-1) day after corticosteroids initiation. Only one patient required a video-assisted thoracoscopy that was necessary for morphological reasons (morbid obesity). No children treated with corticosteroids required surgery. All children were discharged from hospital. The median (IQR) hospital length of stay was 11 (8-14) days, with no difference between children with and those without corticosteroids.

CONCLUSION

Our findings indicate that corticosteroids may be a part of the therapeutic armamentarium for children with parapneumonic effusion when conventional nonsurgical management fails.

Conservative and surgical modalities in the management of paediatric parapneumonic effusion and empyema: a protocol for a living systematic review and network meta-analysis

INTRODUCTION

Parapneumonic effusion and empyema are common complications of paediatric pneumonia. Acceptable treatment modalities for large parapneumonic effusions include antibiotics alone or in conjunction with surgical interventions. Clear guidelines on the best treatment approach are lacking and mostly based on evidence prior to widespread pneumococcal conjugate 13-valent vaccination (PCV-13).

METHODS AND ANALYSIS

A living systematic review and network meta-analysis will be performed comparing the five treatment modalities: (1) antibiotics alone; (2) chest tube drainage without fibrinolytics; (3) chest tube drainage with fibrinolytics; (4) video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery and (5) open thoracotomy. The review protocol is reported following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Protocols guidelines. Eligible studies are randomised controlled trials comparing any pair of interventions in paediatric patients with empyema or parapneumonic effusion. The following databases will be searched: Ovid MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), Web of Science, LILACS and Google Scholar. Citation screening and data extraction will be completed using a validated crowdsourcing methodology using InsightScope. To assess the risk of bias, we will use the revised Cochrane risk of bias tool for randomised trials. The primary outcome of the study is the length of stay. Secondary outcomes are (1) periprocedural complications and (2) need for re-intervention. A frequentist network meta-analysis design will be implemented with a random-effects model comparing different interventions. In a subgroup analysis, studies and patients will be stratified by the size of pleural effusion and the date of trial (pre/post-PCV-13). Eligible citations and available results will be uploaded to an online database, hosted on Open Science Framework. The database will be updated at least every 4 months with any newly published research.

ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION

No ethics review is required for this study. Results will be published in a peer-reviewed journal. Data will be available as part of an online database summarising the evidence of this living systematic review.

PROSPERO REGISTRATION

Pending peer review.

Population-Based Cohort of Children With Parapneumonic Effusion and Empyema Managed With Low Rates of Pleural Drainage

Introduction: The most appropriate treatment for parapneumonic effusion (PPE), including empyema, is controversial. We analyzed the experience of our center and the hospitals in its reference area after adopting a more conservative approach that reduced the use of chest tube pleural drainage (CTPD). Methods: Review of the clinical documentation of all PPE patients in nine hospitals from 2010 to 2018. Results: A total of 318 episodes of PPE were reviewed; 157 had a thickness of <10 mm. The remaining 161 were 10 mm or thicker and were subdivided into three increasing sizes: PE+1, PE+2, and PE+3. There was a strong relationship between the size of the effusion and complicated effusion/empyema, defined by its appearance on imaging studies or by the physical or bacteriological characteristics of the pleural fluid. The size of effusion was also strongly related to the duration of fever and intravenous treatment and was the best independent predictor of the length of hospital stay (LHS) (p < 0.001). CTPD was placed in 2.9% of PE+1 patients, 19.3% of PE+2, and 63.9% of PE+3 (p < 0.001). The referral of patients with PE+1 decreased over time (p = 0.033), as did the use of CTPD in the combined PE+1/PE+2 group (p = 0.018), without affecting LHS (p = 0.814). There were no changes in the use of CTPD in the PE+3 group (p = 0.721). Conclusions: The size of the PPE is strongly correlated with its severity and with LHS. Most patients can be treated with antibiotics alone.

Consensus Document on Community-Acquired Pneumonia in Children. SENP-SEPAR-SEIP

Community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) is a prevalent disease among children and is frequently associated with both diagnostic and therapeutic uncertainties. Consensus has been reached between SEPAR, SENP and SEIP, and their conclusions are as follows.

Pleural Tap-Guided Antimicrobial Treatment for Pneumonia with Parapneumonic Effusion or Pleural Empyema in Children: A Single-Center Cohort Study

Parapneumonic effusion or pleural empyema (PPE/PE) is a frequent complication of community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) in children. Different management approaches exist for this condition. We evaluated a 14-day treatment with amoxicillin (AMX) with/without clavulanic acid (AMC) confirmed or modified by microbiological findings from pleural tap. Children ≤16 years of age with radiologically diagnosed PPE/PE and initial diagnostic pleural tap were included at University Children’s Hospital Zurich from 2001–2015. AMX/AMC was given for 14 days and rationalized according to microbiological pleural tap results. Clinical and radiological follow-up was scheduled until six months or full recovery. In 114 of 147 (78%) children with PPE/PE a pathogen was identified by culture, polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and/or antigen testing. Streptococcus pneumoniae was detected in 90 (79%), S. pyogenes in 13 (11%), and Staphylococcus aureus in seven cases (6%), all but two cultured pathogens (96%) were sensitive to AMX/AMC. One-hundred two of 147 (69%) patients received treatment with AMX/AMC for 14 days. They recovered more rapidly than patients with a different management (p = 0.026). Of 139 children with follow-up, 134 (96%) patients fully recovered. In conclusion, 14-day AMX/AMC treatment confirmed and rarely modified by microbiological findings from pleural tap resulted in full recovery in >95% of children with PPE/PE.

When should parapneumonic pleural effusions be drained in children?

Pneumonia is an important health problem in children, and parapneumonic pleural effusion (PPE) is a frequent complication. There is no standard strategy for treating PPE, reflected in the few international guidelines that have been published on the issue. Compared to adults, there is no consensus on the utility of pleural fluid analysis in paediatric PPE. This is because of the lack of good evidence either in favour or against it and the risks of procedural sedation for acquiring pleural fluid for analysis to guide management. In this paper we provide a succinct review of the different approaches to the management of PPE, including diagnosis, pleural fluid analysis (Light's criteria) and treatment, both medical and surgical.

Therapy of 645 children with parapneumonic effusion and empyema-A German nationwide surveillance study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the initial management of pediatric parapneumonic effusion or pleural empyema (PPE/PE) with regard to length of hospital stay (LOS).

METHODS

Collection of pediatric PPE/PE cases using a nationwide surveillance system (ESPED) from 10/2010 to 06/2013, in all German pediatric hospitals. Inclusion of PPE/PE patients <18 years of age requiring drainage or with a PPE/PE persistence >7 days. Staging of PPE/PE based on reported pleural sonographic imaging. Comparison of LOS after diagnosis between children treated with different forms of initial invasive procedures performed ≤3 days after PPE/PE diagnosis: pleural puncture, draining catheter, intrapleural fibrinolytic therapy, surgical procedures.

RESULTS

Inclusion of 645 children (median age 5 years); median total LOS 17 days. Initial therapy was non-invasive in 282 (45%) cases and invasive in 347 (55%) cases (pleural puncture: 62 [10%], draining catheter: 153 [24%], intrapleural fibrinolytic therapy: 89 [14%], surgical procedures: 43 [7%]). LOS after diagnosis did not differ between children initially treated with different invasive procedures. Results remained unchanged when controlling for sonographic stage, preexisting diseases, and other potential confounders. Repeated use of invasive procedures was observed more often after initial non-invasive treatment or pleural puncture alone than after initial pleural drainage, intrapleural fibrinolytic therapy or surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Initial treatment with intrapleural fibrinolytic therapy or surgical procedures did not result in shorter LOS than initial pleural puncture alone. Larger prospective studies are required to investigate which children benefit significantly from more intensive forms of initial invasive treatment. Pediatr Pulmonol. 2017;52:540-547. © 2016 The Authors. Pediatric Pulmonology Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.