"One-Pot" Sample Processing Method for Proteome-Wide Analysis of Microbial Cells and Spores

Germination of Bacillus spores by LiCl

Spores of Bacillus subtilis have been found to germinate when incubated with LiCl, but not with other monovalent or divalent metal cations. Bacillus megaterium spores also germinated with LiCl, but B. cereus spores did not. In B. subtilis, the LiCl germination was via the activation of spores' GerA germinant receptor (GR), and in B. megaterium, it was the GerU GR. Notably, LiCl germination was much slower than normal physiological germinant triggered GR germination. In B. subtilis spores, rates of LiCl germination were increased in spores with a more fluid IM and decreased in spores with a less fluid IM. Analyses of the GerA germinant binding site suggested that Li+ could bind in a specific site in the B. subtilis GerAB subunit where normally a Na+ likely binds. Importantly, NaCl strongly inhibited LiCl germination of B. subtilis spores, much more so than the larger cation in KCl, although neither salt inhibited L-alanine germination via the GerA GR. These findings increase the understanding of features of mechanisms of germination of Bacillus spores.IMPORTANCEThe ability of some bacteria to form spores upon nutrient starvation confers properties of metabolic dormancy and enhanced resistance to environmental stressors that would otherwise kill vegetative cells. Since spore-forming bacteria include several notable pathogens and economically significant spoilage organisms, insight into how spores are stimulated to germinate and form new vegetative cells is important. Here, we reveal that relatively high concentrations of the inorganic salt lithium chloride trigger the germination of Bacillus subtilis and Bacillus megaterium spores by stimulating one of the spores of each species cohort of nutrient germinant receptors. This is significant since novel germinants and increased knowledge of the germination process should provide opportunities for improved control of spores in healthcare, food, and environmental sectors.

The ionic liquid-assisted sample preparation method pTRUST allows sensitive proteome characterization of a variety of bacterial endospores to aid in the search for protein biomarkers

Bacterial endospores are ubiquitous and are responsible for various human infections. Recently, we reported that an ionic liquid (IL)-based sample preparation method (named pTRUST) facilitated highly efficient shotgun analysis of the Bacillus subtilis spore proteome in trace samples. In this study, we evaluated the efficiency and applicability of the pTRUST technology using three different spore preparations: one purified from the closely related subspecies B. subtilis natto and two from B. licheniformis and B. cereus. We showed that the pTRUST method allowed rapid solubilization and processing of all tested spore samples prepared for highly sensitive mass spectrometry (MS) analysis. Bioinformatics analysis using the BLAST program suggested that a set of 25 proteins commonly identified between the above three species and B. subtilis spores may be universal biomarkers among various bacterial species, including 43 spore-producing bacteria associated with industrial dairy processing environments and product spoilage. In contrast, the two identified proteins, D4FV94 in B. subtilis natto and Q737A2 in B. cereus, are likely species-specific biomarkers, because their orthologs are absent or rare in all organisms. The sensitivity and applicability of pTRUST, along with the putative protein biomarkers identified in this study, will facilitate a wide spectrum of spore research for biological and clinical applications.

A simplified non-reduced peptide mapping method with faster and efficient enzymatic digestion for characterization of native disulfide bonds in monoclonal and bispecific antibodies

Development of monoclonal and bispecific antibody-based protein therapeutics requires detailed characterization of native disulfide linkages, which is commonly achieved through peptide mapping under non-reducing conditions followed by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) analysis. One major challenge of this method is incomplete protein digestion due to insufficient denaturation of antibodies under non-reducing conditions. For a long time, researchers have explored various strategies with the aim of efficiently digesting antibody drugs when the disulfide bonds remain intact, but few could achieve this by using a simple and generic approach with well controlled disulfide scrambling artifacts. Here, we report a simple method for fast and efficient mapping of native disulfides of monoclonal and bispecific antibody-based protein therapeutics. The method was optimized to achieve optimal digestion efficiency by denaturing proteins with 8 M urea plus 0-1.25 M guanidine-HCl at elevated temperature (50 °C), followed by two-step digestion with trypsin/Lys-C mix using a one-pot reaction. The only parameter that needs to be optimized for different proteins is the concentration of guanidine-HCl present. This simplified sample preparation eliminated buffer exchange and can be completed within three hours. By using this new method, all native disulfide bonds were confirmed for these monoclonal and bispecific antibodies with high confidence. When compared with a commercial kit utilizing low-pH digestion condition, the new method demonstrated higher digestion efficiency and shorter sample preparation time. These results suggest this new one-pot-two-step digestion method is suitable for the characterization of antibody disulfide bonds, particularly for those antibodies with digestion-resistant domains under typical digestion conditions.

Ionic liquid-assisted sample preparation mediates sensitive proteomic analysis of Bacillus subtilis spores

Endospore-forming bacteria are ubiquitous. Bacterial endospores are multilayered proteinaceous structures that protects the bacterial genome during stress conditions. They are also responsible for a wide range of critical clinical infections in humans. Precise analysis of spore-forming pathogens remains a major challenge in the field of proteomics because spore structures are highly resistant to conventional solubilizers and denaturing agents, such as sodium dodecyl sulfate and urea. We present an ionic liquid-assisted (i-soln) technique of sample preparation, called pTRUST, which enables shotgun analysis of Bacillus subtilis spores even when the starting materials are in the sub-microgram range. In proteomic analysis, this technique shows 50-2000-fold higher sensitivity than other conventional gel-based or gel-free methods (including one-pot sample processing). Using this technique, we identified 445 proteins with high confidence from trace amounts of highly pure spore preparations, including 52 of the 79 proteins (approximately 70%) previously demonstrated to be localized in spores in the SubtiWiki database and detected through direct protein analysis. Consequently, 393 additional proteins were identified as candidates for spore constitutive proteins. Twenty of these newly identified candidates were produced as green fluorescent protein fusion proteins, and each was evaluated for authenticity as a spore constituent using fluorescence microscopy analysis. The pTRUST method's sensitivity and reliability using the i-soln system, together with hitherto unreported proteins in spores, will enable an array of spore research for biological and clinical applications.

Heat 'n Beat: A Universal High-Throughput End-to-End Proteomics Sample Processing Platform in under an Hour

Proteomic analysis by mass spectrometry of small (≤2 mg) solid tissue samples from diverse formats requires high throughput and comprehensive proteome coverage. We developed a nearly universal, rapid, and robust protocol for sample preparation, suitable for high-throughput projects that encompass most cell or tissue types. This end-to-end workflow extends from original sample to loading the mass spectrometer and is centered on a one-tube homogenization and digestion method called Heat 'n Beat (HnB). It is applicable to most tissues, regardless of how they were fixed or embedded. Sample preparation was divided into separate challenges. The initial sample washing and final peptide cleanup steps were adapted to three tissue sources: fresh frozen (FF), optimal cutting temperature (OCT) compound embedded (FF-OCT), and formalin-fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE). Third, for core processing, tissue disruption and lysis were decreased to a 7 min heat and homogenization treatment, and reduction, alkylation, and proteolysis were optimized into a single step. The refinements produced near doubled peptide yield when compared to our earlier method ABLE delivered a consistently high digestion efficiency of 85-90%, reported by ProteinPilot, and required only 38 min for core processing in a single tube, with the total processing time being 53-63 min. The robustness of HnB was demonstrated on six organ types, a cell line, and a cancer biopsy. Its suitability for high-throughput applications was demonstrated on a set of 1171 FF-OCT human cancer biopsies, which were processed for end-to-end completion in 92 h, producing highly consistent peptide yield and quality for over 3513 MS runs.

Integrative Metabolomics and Proteomics Allow the Global Intracellular Characterization of Bacillus subtilis Cells and Spores

Reliable and comprehensive multi-omics analysis is essential for researchers to understand and explore complex biological systems more completely. Bacillus subtilis (B. subtilis) is a model organism for Gram-positive spore-forming bacteria, and in-depth insight into the physiology and molecular basis of spore formation and germination in this organism requires advanced multilayer molecular data sets generated from the same sample. In this study, we evaluated two monophasic methods for polar and nonpolar compound extraction (acetonitrile/methanol/water; isopropanol/water, and 60% ethanol) and two biphasic methods (chloroform/methanol/water, and methyl tert-butyl ether/methanol/water) on coefficients of variation of analytes, identified metabolite composition, and the quality of proteomics profiles. The 60% EtOH protocol proved to be the easiest in sample processing and was more amenable to automation. Collectively, we annotated 505 and 484 metabolites and identified 1665 and 1562 proteins in B. subtilis vegetative cells and spores, respectively. We also show differences between vegetative cells and spores from a multi-omics perspective and demonstrate that an integrative multi-omics analysis can be implemented from one sample using the 60% EtOH protocol. The results obtained by the 60% EtOH protocol provide comprehensive insight into differences in the metabolic and protein makeup of B. subtilis vegetative cells and spores.

Expression of the 2Duf protein in wild-type Bacillus subtilis spores stabilizes inner membrane proteins and increases spore resistance to wet heat and hydrogen peroxide

AIMS

This work aimed to characterize spore inner membrane (IM) properties and the mechanism of spore killing by wet heat and H2O2 with spores overexpressing the 2Duf protein, which is naturally encoded from a transposon found only in some Bacillus strains with much higher spore resistance than wild-type spores.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Killing of Bacillus subtilis spores by wet heat or hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) was slower when 2Duf was present, and Ca-dipicolinic acid release was slower than killing. Viabilities on rich plates of wet heat- or H2O2 -treated spores +/- 2Duf were lower when NaCl was added, but higher with glucose. Addition of glucose but not Casamino acids addition increased treated spores' viability on minimal medium plates. Spores with 2Duf required higher heat activation for germination, and their germination was more wet-heat resistant than that of wild-type spores, processes that involve IM proteins. IM permeability and lipid mobility were lower in spores with 2Duf, although IM phospholipid composition was similar in spores +/- 2Duf.

CONCLUSIONS

These results and previous work suggests that wet heat and H2O2 kill spores by damaging an IM enzyme or enzymes involved in oxidative phosphorylation.

Identification and characterization of new proteins crucial for bacterial spore resistance and germination

2Duf, named after the presence of a transmembrane (TM) Duf421 domain and a small Duf1657 domain in its sequence, is likely located in the inner membrane (IM) of spores in some Bacillus species carrying a transposon with an operon termed spoVA ^2mob. These spores are known for their extreme resistance to wet heat, and 2Duf is believed to be the primary contributor to this trait. In this study, we found that the absence of YetF or YdfS, both Duf421 domain-containing proteins and found only in wild-type (wt) B. subtilis spores with YetF more abundant, leads to decreased resistance to wet heat and agents that can damage spore core components. The IM phospholipid compositions and core water and calcium-dipicolinic acid levels of YetF-deficient spores are similar to those of wt spores, but the deficiency could be restored by ectopic insertion of yetF, and overexpression of YetF increased wt spore resistance to wet heat. In addition, yetF and ydfS spores have decreased germination rates as individuals and populations with germinant receptor-dependent germinants and increased sensitivity to wet heat during germination, potentially due to damage to IM proteins. These data are consistent with a model in which YetF, YdfS and their homologs modify IM structure to reduce IM permeability and stabilize IM proteins against wet heat damage. Multiple yetF homologs are also present in other spore forming Bacilli and Clostridia, and even some asporogenous Firmicutes, but fewer in asporogenous species. The crystal structure of a YetF tetramer lacking the TM helices has been reported and features two distinct globular subdomains in each monomer. Sequence alignment and structure prediction suggest this fold is likely shared by other Duf421-containing proteins, including 2Duf. We have also identified naturally occurring 2duf homologs in some Bacilli and Clostridia species and in wt Bacillus cereus spores, but not in wt B. subtilis. Notably, the genomic organization around the 2duf gene in most of these species is similar to that in spoVA ^2mob, suggesting that one of these species was the source of the genes on this operon in the extremely wet heat resistant spore formers.

Time-Resolved Proteomics of Germinating Spores of Bacillus cereus

Bacillus cereus is a spore-forming human pathogen that is a burden to the food chain. Dormant spores are highly resistant to harsh environmental conditions, but lose resistance after germination. In this study, we investigate the B. cereus spore proteome upon spore germination and outgrowth so as to obtain new insights into the molecular mechanisms involved. We used mass spectrometry combined with co-expression network analysis and obtained a unique global proteome view of the germination and outgrowth processes of B. cereus spores by monitoring 2211 protein changeovers. We are the first to examine germination and outgrowth models of B. cereus spores experimentally by studying the dynamics of germinant receptors, other proteins involved in spore germination and resistance, and coat and exosporium proteins. Furthermore, through the co-expression analysis of 1175 proteins identified with high quality data, germination proteome data were clustered into eight modules (termed black, blue, brown, green, red, turquoise, grey, and yellow), whose associated functions and expression profiles were investigated. Germination related proteins were clustered into blue and brown modules, the abundances of which decreased after finishing germination. In the brown and blue we identified 124 proteins that could be vital during germination. These proteins will be very interesting to study in future genetic studies regarding their function in spore revival in B. cereus.

Changes in the Spore Proteome of Bacillus cereus in Response to Introduction of Plasmids

Fluorescent fusion proteins were expressed in Bacillus cereus to visualize the germinosome by introducing a plasmid that carries fluorescent fusion proteins of germinant receptor GerR subunits or germinosome scaffold protein GerD. The effects of plasmid insertion and recombinant protein expression on the spore proteome were investigated. Proteomic analysis showed that overexpression of the target proteins had negligible effects on the spore proteome. However, plasmid-bearing spores displayed dramatic abundance changes in spore proteins involved in signaling and metabolism. Our findings indicate that the introduction of a plasmid alone alters the spore protein composition dramatically, with 993 proteins significantly down-regulated and 415 proteins significantly up-regulated among 3323 identified proteins. This shows that empty vector controls are more appropriate to compare proteome changes due to plasmid-encoded genes than is the wild-type strain, when using plasmid-based genetic tools. Therefore, researchers should keep in mind that molecular cloning techniques can alter more than their intended targets in a biological system, and interpret results with this in mind.

Moderate high-pressure superdormancy in Bacillus spores: properties of superdormant spores and proteins potentially influencing moderate high-pressure germination

Resistant bacterial spores are a major concern in industrial decontamination processes. An approach known as pressure-mediated germination-inactivation strategy aims to artificially germinate spores by isostatic pressure to mitigate their resistance to inactivation processes. The successful implementation of such a germination-inactivation strategy relies on the germination of all spores. However, germination is heterogeneous, with some “superdormant” spores germinating extremely slowly or not at all. The present study investigated potential underlying reasons for moderate high-pressure (150 MPa; 37°C) superdormancy of Bacillus subtilis spores. The water and dipicolinic acid content of superdormant spores was compared with that of the initial dormant spore population. The results suggest that water and dipicolinic acid content are not major drivers of moderate high-pressure superdormancy. A proteomic analysis was used to identify proteins that were quantified at significantly different levels in superdormant spores. Subsequent validation of the germination capacity of deletion mutants revealed that the presence of protein YhcN is required for efficient moderate high-pressure germination and that proteins MinC, cse60, and SspK may also play a role, albeit a minor one.

IMPORTANCE Spore-forming bacteria are ubiquitous in nature and, as a consequence, inevitably enter the food chain or other processing environments. Their presence can lead to significant spoilage or safety-related issues. Intensive treatment is usually required to inactivate them; however, this treatment harms important product quality attributes. A pressure-mediated germination-inactivation approach can balance the need for effective spore inactivation and retention of sensitive ingredients. However, superdormant spores are the bottleneck preventing the successful and safe implementation of such a strategy. An in-depth understanding of moderate high-pressure germination and the underlying causes of superdormancy is necessary to advance the development of mild high pressure-based spore control technologies. The approach used in this work allowed the identification of proteins that have not yet been associated with reduced germination at moderate high pressure. This research paves the way for further studies on the germination and superdormancy mechanisms in spores, assisting the development of mild spore inactivation strategies.

Dynamics of Germinosome Formation and FRET-Based Analysis of Interactions between GerD and Germinant Receptor Subunits in Bacillus cereus Spores

Spores of the bacterium Bacillus cereus can cause disease in humans due to contamination of raw materials for food manufacturing. These dormant, resistant spores can survive for years in the environment, but can germinate and grow when their surroundings become suitable, and spore germination proteins play an important role in the decision to germinate. Since germinated spores have lost dormant spores’ extreme resistance, knowledge about the formation and function of germination proteins could be useful in suggesting new preservation strategies to control B. cereus spores. In this study, we confirmed that the GerR germinant receptor’s (GR) A, B, and C subunits and GerD co-localize in B. cereus spore inner membrane (IM) foci termed germinosomes. The interaction between these proteins was examined by using fusions to the fluorescent reporter proteins SGFP2 and mScarlet-I and Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET). This work found that the FRET efficiency was 6% between GerR(A-C-B)–SGFP2 and GerD–mScarlet-I, but there was no FRET between GerD–mScarlet-I and either GerRA–SGFP2 or GerRC–SGFP2. These results and that GerD does not interact with a GR C-subunit in vitro suggest that, in the germinosome, GerD interacts primarily with the GR B subunit. The dynamics of formation of germinosomes with GerR(A-C-B)–SGFP2 and GerD–mScarlet-I was also followed during sporulation. Our results showed heterogeneity in the formation of FRET positive foci of GerR(A-C-B)–SGFP2 and GerD–mScarlet-I; and while some foci formed at the same time, the formation of foci in the FRET channel could be significantly delayed. The latter finding suggests that either the GerR GR can at least transiently form IM foci in the absence of GerD, or that, while GerD is essential for GerR foci formation, the time to attain the final germinosome structure with close contacts between GerD and GerR can be heterogeneous.

High Resolution Analysis of Proteome Dynamics during Bacillus subtilis Sporulation

Bacillus subtilis vegetative cells switch to sporulation upon nutrient limitation. To investigate the proteome dynamics during sporulation, high-resolution time-lapse proteomics was performed in a cell population that was induced to sporulate synchronously. Here, we are the first to comprehensively investigate the changeover of sporulation regulatory proteins, coat proteins, and other proteins involved in sporulation and spore biogenesis. Protein co-expression analysis revealed four co-expressed modules (termed blue, brown, green, and yellow). Modules brown and green are upregulated during sporulation and contain proteins associated with sporulation. Module blue is negatively correlated with modules brown and green, containing ribosomal and metabolic proteins. Finally, module yellow shows co-expression with the three other modules. Notably, several proteins not belonging to any of the known transcription regulons were identified as co-expressed with modules brown and green, and might also play roles during sporulation. Finally, levels of some coat proteins, for example morphogenetic coat proteins, decreased late in sporulation.

Analysis of 5'-NAD capping of mRNAs in dormant spores of Bacillus subtilis

Spores of Gram-positive bacteria contain 10s-1000s of different mRNAs. However, Bacillus subtilis spores contain only ∼ 50 mRNAs at > 1 molecule/spore, almost all transcribed only in the developing spore and encoding spore proteins. However, some spore mRNAs could be stabilized to ensure they are intact in dormant spores, perhaps to direct synthesis of proteins essential for spores' conversion to a growing cell in germinated spore outgrowth. Recent work shows that some growing B. subtilis cell mRNAs contain a 5'-NAD cap. Since this cap may stabilize mRNA in vivo, its presence on spore mRNAs would suggest that maintaining some intact spore mRNAs is important, perhaps because they have a translational role in outgrowth. However, significant levels of only a few abundant spore mRNAs had a 5'-NAD cap, and these were not the most stable spore mRNAs and had likely been fragmented. Even higher levels of 5'-NAD-capping were found on a few low abundance spore mRNAs, but these mRNAs were present in only small percentages of spores, and had again been fragmented. The new data are thus consistent with spore mRNAs serving only as a reservoir of ribonucleotides in outgrowth.

Levels and Characteristics of mRNAs in Spores of Firmicute Species

Spores of firmicute species contain 100s of mRNAs, whose major function in Bacillus subtilis is to provide ribonucleotides for new RNA synthesis when spores germinate. To determine if this is a general phenomenon, RNA was isolated from spores of multiple firmicute species and relative mRNA levels determined by transcriptome sequencing (RNA-seq). Determination of RNA levels in single spores allowed calculation of RNA nucleotides/spore, and assuming mRNA is 3% of spore RNA indicated that only ∼6% of spore mRNAs were present at >1/spore. Bacillus subtilis, Bacillus atrophaeus, and Clostridioides difficile spores had 49, 42, and 51 mRNAs at >1/spore, and numbers of mRNAs at ≥1/spore were ∼10 to 50% higher in Geobacillus stearothermophilus and Bacillus thuringiensis Al Hakam spores and ∼4-fold higher in Bacillus megaterium spores. In all species, some to many abundant spore mRNAs (i) were transcribed by RNA polymerase with forespore-specific σ factors, (ii) encoded proteins that were homologs of those encoded by abundant B. subtilis spore mRNAs and are proteins in dormant spores, and (iii) were likely transcribed in the mother cell compartment of the sporulating cell. Analysis of the coverage of RNA-seq reads on mRNAs from all species suggested that abundant spore mRNAs were fragmented, as was confirmed by reverse transcriptase quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) analysis of abundant B. subtilis and C. difficile spore mRNAs. These data add to evidence indicating that the function of at least the great majority of mRNAs in all firmicute spores is to be degraded to generate ribonucleotides for new RNA synthesis when spores germinate. IMPORTANCE Only ∼6% of mRNAs in spores of six firmicute species are at ≥1 molecule/spore, many abundant spore mRNAs encode proteins similar to B. subtilis spore proteins, and some abundant B. subtilis and C. difficile spore mRNAs were fragmented. Most of the abundant B. subtilis and other Bacillales spore mRNAs are transcribed under the control of the forespore-specific RNA polymerase σ factors, F or G, and these results may stimulate transcription analyses in developing spores of species other than B. subtilis. These findings, plus the absence of key nucleotide biosynthetic enzymes in spores, suggest that firmicute spores' abundant mRNAs are not translated when spores germinate but instead are degraded to generate ribonucleotides for new RNA synthesis by the germinated spore.

Identification of Native Cross-Links in Bacillus subtilis Spore Coat Proteins

The resistance properties of the bacterial spores are partially due to spore surface proteins, ∼30% of which are said to form an insoluble protein fraction. Previous research has also identified a group of spore coat proteins affected by spore maturation, which exhibit an increased level of interprotein cross-linking. However, the proteins and the types of cross-links involved, previously proposed based on indirect evidence, have yet to be confirmed experimentally. To obtain more insight into the structural basis of the proteinaceous component of the spore coat, we attempted to identify coat cross-links and the proteins involved using new peptide fractionation and bioinformatic methods. Young (day 1) and matured (day 5) Bacillus subtilis spores of wild-type and transglutaminase mutant strains were digested with formic acid and trypsin, and cross-linked peptides were enriched using strong cation exchange chromatography. The enriched cross-linked peptide fractions were subjected to Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance tandem mass spectrometry, and the high-quality fragmentation data obtained were analyzed using two specialized software tools, pLink2 and XiSearch, to identify cross-links. This analysis identified specific disulfide bonds between coat proteins CotE-CotE and CotJA-CotJC, obtained evidence of disulfide bonds in the spore crust proteins CotX, CotY, and CotZ, and identified dityrosine and ε-(γ)-glutamyl-lysine cross-linked coat proteins. The findings in this Letter are the first direct biochemical data on protein cross-linking in the spore coat and the first direct evidence of the cross-linked building blocks of the highly ordered and resistant structure called the spore coat.

Analysis of disulphide bond linkage between CoA and protein cysteine thiols during sporulation and in spores of Bacillus species

Spores of Bacillus species have novel properties, which allow them to lie dormant for years and then germinate under favourable conditions. In the current work, the role of a key metabolic integrator, coenzyme A (CoA), in redox regulation of growing cells and during spore formation in Bacillus megaterium and Bacillus subtilis is studied. Exposing these growing cells to oxidising agents or carbon deprivation resulted in extensive covalent protein modification by CoA (termed protein CoAlation), through disulphide bond formation between the CoA thiol group and a protein cysteine. Significant protein CoAlation was observed during sporulation of B. megaterium, and increased largely in parallel with loss of metabolism in spores. Mass spectrometric analysis identified four CoAlated proteins in B. subtilis spores as well as one CoAlated protein in growing B. megaterium cells. All five of these proteins have been identified as moderately abundant in spores. Based on these findings and published studies, protein CoAlation might be involved in facilitating establishment of spores' metabolic dormancy, and/or protecting sensitive sulfhydryl groups of spore enzymes.

Bacterial Spore mRNA - What's Up With That?

Bacteria belonging to the orders Bacillales and Clostridiales form spores in response to nutrient starvation. From a simplified morphological perspective, the spore can be considered as comprising a central protoplast or core, that is, enveloped sequentially by an inner membrane (IM), a peptidoglycan cortex, an outer membrane, and a proteinaceous coat. All of these structures are characterized by unique morphological and/or structural features, which collectively confer metabolic dormancy and properties of environmental resistance to the quiescent spore. These properties are maintained until the spore is stimulated to germinate, outgrow and form a new vegetative cell. Spore germination comprises a series of partially overlapping biochemical and biophysical events - efflux of ions from the core, rehydration and IM reorganization, disassembly of cortex and coat - all of which appear to take place in the absence of de novo ATP and protein synthesis. If the latter points are correct, why then do spores of all species examined to date contain a diverse range of mRNA molecules deposited within the spore core? Are some of these molecules "functional," serving as translationally active units that are required for efficient spore germination and outgrowth, or are they just remnants from sporulation whose sole purpose is to provide a reservoir of ribonucleotides for the newly outgrowing cell? What is the fate of these molecules during spore senescence, and indeed, are conditions within the spore core likely to provide any opportunity for changes in the transcriptional profile of the spore during dormancy? This review encompasses a historical perspective of spore ribonucleotide biology, from the earliest biochemical led analyses - some of which in hindsight have proved to be remarkably prescient - through the transcriptomic era at the turn of this century, to the latest next generation sequencing derived insights. We provide an overview of the key literature to facilitate reasoned responses to the aforementioned questions, and many others, prior to concluding by identifying the major outstanding issues in this crucial area of spore biology.

Investigating Synthesis of the MalS Malic Enzyme during Bacillus subtilis Spore Germination and Outgrowth and the Influence of Spore Maturation and Sporulation Conditions

The spores formed by Bacillus subtilis remain in a quiescent state for extended periods due to their dormancy and resistance features. Dormancy is linked to a very low level of core water content and a phase-bright state of spores. The present report, focusing on proteins MalS and PdhD (pyruvate dehydrogenase subunit D) and complementary to our companion report published in this issue, aims to shed light on a major dilemma in the field, i.e., whether protein synthesis, in particular that of MalS, takes place in phase-bright spores. Clustered MalS-GFP in dormant spores diffuses throughout the spore as germination proceeds. However, fluorescence intensity measurements, supported by Western blot analysis and SILAC proteomics, confirm that there is no new MalS protein synthesis in bright-phase dormant spores.

Spore-forming bacteria of the orders Bacillales and Clostridiales play a major role in food spoilage and foodborne diseases. When environmental conditions become favorable, these spores can germinate as the germinant receptors located on the spore’s inner membrane are activated via germinant binding. This leads to the formation of vegetative cells via germination and subsequent outgrowth and potential deleterious effects on foods. The present report focuses on analysis of the synthesis of the MalS (malic enzyme) protein during Bacillus subtilis spore germination by investigating the dynamics of the presence and fluorescence level of a MalS-GFP (MalS-green fluorescent protein) fusion protein using time-lapse fluorescence microscopy. Our results show an initial increase in MalS-GFP fluorescence intensity within the first 15 min of germination, followed by a discernible drop and stabilization of the fluorescence throughout spore outgrowth as reported previously (L. Sinai, A. Rosenberg, Y. Smith, E. Segev, and S. Ben-Yehuda, Mol Cell 57:695–707, 2015, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2014.12.019). However, in contrast to the earlier report, both Western blotting and SILAC (stable isotopic labeling of amino acids in cell culture) analysis showed there was no increase in MalS-GFP levels during the 15 min after the addition of germinants and that MalS synthesis did not begin until more than 90 min after germinant addition. Thus, the increase in MalS-GFP fluorescence early in germination is not due to new protein synthesis but is perhaps due to a change in the physical environment of the spore cores. Our findings also show that different sporulation conditions and spore maturation times affect expression of MalS-GFP and the germination behavior of the spores, albeit to a minor extent, but still result in no changes in MalS-GFP levels early in spore germination.

IMPORTANCE The spores formed by Bacillus subtilis remain in a quiescent state for extended periods due to their dormancy and resistance features. Dormancy is linked to a very low level of core water content and a phase-bright state of spores. The present report, focusing on proteins MalS and PdhD (pyruvate dehydrogenase subunit D) and complementary to our companion report published in this issue, aims to shed light on a major dilemma in the field, i.e., whether protein synthesis, in particular that of MalS, takes place in phase-bright spores. Clustered MalS-GFP in dormant spores diffuses throughout the spore as germination proceeds. However, fluorescence intensity measurements, supported by Western blot analysis and SILAC proteomics, confirm that there is no new MalS protein synthesis in bright-phase dormant spores.

Integrative Analysis of Proteome and Transcriptome Dynamics during Bacillus subtilis Spore Revival

This study demonstrated the progress of macromolecular synthesis during Bacillus subtilis spore germination and outgrowth. The transcriptome analysis has additionally allowed us to trace gene expression during this transformation process. For the first time, the basic survival kit for spore-based life has been identified. In addition, in this analysis based on monitoring of protein levels in germinating and outgrowing spores, the transition from (ribo)nucleotide and amino acid biosynthesis to the restoration of all metabolic pathways can be clearly seen. The integrative multi-omics approach applied in this study thus has helped us to achieve a comprehensive overview of the molecular mechanisms at the basis of spore germination and outgrowth as well as to identify important knowledge gaps in need of further study.

Bacillus subtilis spores can reactivate their metabolism through germination upon contact with germinants and can develop into vegetative cells upon outgrowth. However, the mechanisms at the basis of the molecular machinery that triggers the spore germination and outgrowth processes are still largely unclear. To gain further insights into these processes, the transcriptome and proteome changes occurring during the conversion of spores to vegetative cells were analyzed in the present study. For each time point sampled, the changes in the spore proteome were quantitatively monitored relative to the proteome of metabolically ¹⁵N-labeled vegetative cells. Of the quantified proteins, 60% are shared by vegetative cells and spores, indicating that the spores have a minimal protein set, sufficient to resume metabolism upon completion of germination. These shared proteins thus represent the most basic “survival kit” for spore-based life. We observed no significant change in the proteome or the transcriptome until the spore’s completion of germination. Our analysis identified 34 abundant mRNA transcripts in the dormant spores, 31 of which are rapidly degraded after germination. In outgrowing spores, we identified 3,152 differentially expressed genes and have demonstrated the differential expression of 322 proteins with our mass spectrometry analyses. Our data also showed that 173 proteins from dormant spores, including both proteins unique to spores and proteins shared with vegetative cells, were lost after completion of germination. The observed diverse timings of synthesis of different protein sets in spore outgrowth revealed a putative core strategy underlying the revival of ‘life’ from the B. subtilis spore.

IMPORTANCE This study demonstrated the progress of macromolecular synthesis during Bacillus subtilis spore germination and outgrowth. The transcriptome analysis has additionally allowed us to trace gene expression during this transformation process. For the first time, the basic survival kit for spore-based life has been identified. In addition, in this analysis based on monitoring of protein levels in germinating and outgrowing spores, the transition from (ribo)nucleotide and amino acid biosynthesis to the restoration of all metabolic pathways can be clearly seen. The integrative multi-omics approach applied in this study thus has helped us to achieve a comprehensive overview of the molecular mechanisms at the basis of spore germination and outgrowth as well as to identify important knowledge gaps in need of further study.

Abhyankar W, N. Swarge B, van der Wel N, Kramer G, Brul S, J. de Koning L. Artificial Sporulation Induction (ASI) by kinA Overexpression Affects the Proteomes and Properties of Bacillus subtilis Spores

To facilitate more accurate spore proteomic analysis, the current study focuses on inducing homogeneous sporulation by overexpressing kinA and assesses the effect of synchronized sporulation initiation on spore resistance, structures, the germination behavior at single-spore level and the proteome. The results indicate that, in our set up, the sporulation by overexpressing kinA can generate a spore yield of 70% within 8 h. The procedure increases spore wet heat resistance and thickness of the spore coat and cortex layers, whilst delaying the time to spore phase-darkening and burst after addition of germinant. The proteome analysis reveals that the upregulated proteins in the kinA induced spores, compared to spores without kinA induction, as well as the 'wildtype' spores, are mostly involved in spore formation. The downregulated proteins mostly belong to the categories of coping with stress, carbon and nitrogen metabolism, as well as the regulation of sporulation. Thus, while kinA overexpression enhances synchronicity in sporulation initiation, it also has profound effects on the central equilibrium of spore formation and spore germination, through modulation of the spore molecular composition and stress resistance physiology.

Vegetative Cell and Spore Proteomes of Clostridioides difficile Show Finite Differences and Reveal Potential Protein Markers

Clostridioides difficile-associated infection (CDI) is a health-care-associated infection caused, as the name suggests, by obligate anaerobic pathogen C. difficile and thus mainly transmitted via highly resistant endospores from one person to the other. In vivo, the spores need to germinate into cells prior to establishing an infection. Bile acids and glycine, both available in sufficient amounts inside the human host intestinal tract, serve as efficient germinants for the spores. It is therefore, for better understanding of C. difficile virulence, crucial to study both the cell and spore states with respect to their genetic, metabolic, and proteomic composition. In the present study, mass spectrometric relative protein quantification, based on the 14N/15N peptide isotopic ratios, has led to quantification of over 700 proteins from combined spore and cell samples. The analysis has revealed that the proteome turnover between a vegetative cell and a spore for this organism is moderate. Additionally, specific cell and spore surface proteins, vegetative cell proteins CD1228, CD3301 and spore proteins CD2487, CD2434, and CD0684 are identified as potential protein markers for C. difficile infection.

Evaluation of Sample Preparation Methods for Fast Proteotyping of Microorganisms by Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Tandem mass spectrometry-based proteotyping allows characterizing microorganisms in terms of taxonomy and is becoming an important tool for investigating microbial diversity from several ecosystems. Fast and automatable sample preparation for obtaining peptide pools amenable to tandem mass spectrometry is necessary for enabling proteotyping as a high-throughput method. First, the protocol to increase the yield of lysis of several representative bacterial and eukaryotic microorganisms was optimized by using a long and drastic bead-beating setting with 0.1 mm silica beads, 0.1 and 0.5 mm glass beads, in presence of detergents. Then, three different methods to obtain greater digestion yield from these extracts were tested and optimized for improve efficiency and reduce application time: denaturing electrophoresis of proteins and in-gel proteolysis, suspension-trapping filter-based approach (S-Trap) and, solid-phase-enhanced sample preparation named SP3. The latter method outperforms the other two in terms of speed and delivers also more peptides and proteins than with the in-gel proteolysis (2.2 fold for both) and S-trap approaches (1.3 and 1.2 fold, respectively). Thus, SP3 directly improves tandem mass spectrometry proteotyping.

Analysis of the mRNAs in Spores of Bacillus subtilis

Large-scale shotgun sequencing (RNA-seq) analysis of mRNAs in dormant Bacillus subtilis spores prepared on plates or in liquid generally found the same ∼46 abundant mRNA species, with >250 mRNAs detected at much lower abundances. Knowledge of the amount of phosphate in a single B. subtilis spore allowed calculation of the amount of mRNA in an individual spore as ∼10⁶ nucleotides (nt). Given the levels of abundant spore mRNAs compared to those of other mRNAs, it was calculated that the great majority of low-abundance mRNAs are present in only small fractions of spores in populations. Almost all of the most abundant spore mRNAs are encoded by genes expressed late in sporulation in the developing spore under the control of the forespore-specific RNA polymerase sigma factor, σ^G, and most of the encoded proteins are in spores. Levels of the most abundant spore mRNAs were also relatively stable for a week at 4°C after spore harvest. RNA-seq analysis of mRNAs in highly purified and less-well-purified spores made in liquid, as well as from spores that were chemically decoated to remove possible contaminating mRNA, indicated that low-abundance mRNAs in spores were not contaminants in purified spore preparations, and several sources of low-abundance mRNAs in spores are suggested. The function of at least the great majority of spore mRNAs seems most likely to be the generation of ribonucleotides for new RNA synthesis by their degradation early in spore revival.IMPORTANCE Previous work indicates that dormant Bacillus subtilis spores have many hundreds of mRNAs, some of which are suggested to play roles in spores' "return to life" or revival. The present work finds only ∼46 mRNAs at ≥1 molecule spore, with others in only fractions of spores in populations, often very small fractions. Less-abundant spore mRNAs are not contaminants in spore preparations, but how spores accumulate them is not clear. Almost all abundant spore mRNAs are synthesized in the developing spore late in its development, most encode proteins in spores, and abundant mRNAs in spores are relatively stable at 4°C. These findings will have a major impact on thinking about the roles that spore mRNAs may play in spore revival.

Membrane Proteomes and Ion Transporters in Bacillus anthracis and Bacillus subtilis Dormant and Germinating Spores

Bacterial endospores produced by Bacillus and Clostridium species can remain dormant and highly resistant to environmental insults for long periods, but they can also rapidly germinate in response to a nutrient-rich environment. Multiple proteins involved in sensing and responding to nutrient germinants, initiating solute and water transport, and accomplishing spore wall degradation are associated with the membrane surrounding the spore core. In order to more fully catalog proteins that may be involved in spore germination, as well as to identify protein changes taking place during germination, unbiased proteomic analyses of membrane preparations isolated from dormant and germinated spores of Bacillus anthracis and Bacillus subtilis were undertaken. Membrane-associated proteins were fractionated by SDS-PAGE, gel slices were trypsin digested, and extracted peptides were fractionated by liquid chromatography and analyzed by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-tandem time of flight mass spectrometry. More than 500 proteins were identified from each preparation. Bioinformatic methods were used to characterize proteins with regard to membrane association, cellular function, and conservation across species. Numerous proteins not previously known to be spore associated, 6 in B. subtilis and 68 in B. anthracis, were identified. Relative quantitation based on spectral counting indicated that the majority of spore membrane proteins decrease in abundance during the first 20 min of germination. The spore membranes contained several proteins thought to be involved in the transport of metal ions, a process that plays a major role in spore formation and germination. Analyses of mutant strains lacking these transport proteins implicated YloB in the accumulation of calcium within the developing forespore.IMPORTANCE Bacterial endospores can remain dormant and highly resistant to environmental insults for long periods but can also rapidly germinate in response to a nutrient-rich environment. The persistence and subsequent germination of spores contribute to their colonization of new environments and to the spread of certain diseases. Proteins of Bacillus subtilis and Bacillus anthracis were identified that are associated with the spore membrane, a position that can allow them to contribute to germination. A set of identified proteins that are predicted to carry out ion transport were examined for their contributions to spore formation, stability, and germination. Greater knowledge of spore formation and germination can contribute to the development of better decontamination strategies.

Improving deep proteome and PTMome coverage using tandem HILIC-HPRP peptide fractionation strategy

Despite being orthogonal to reverse-phase separation and valuable for posttranslational modification (PTM) pre-enrichment, hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) has not been widely adopted for large-scale proteomic applications. Here, we first evaluated the performance of HILIC in comparison with the popular high-pH reverse-phase (HPRP) separation, as the first dimension for tryptic peptide fractionation in a shotgun workflow to characterize the complex 293T cell proteome. The data indicated that the complementary nature of HILIC and HPRP for peptide separation was mainly due to different hydrophobicity preferences. Realizing that uncaptured components from one mode can be resolved in the other mode, we then designed and compared two multidimensional separation schemes using HILIC and HPRP in tandem for peptide prefractionation, in terms of identification efficiency and coverage at peptide, protein, and PTM levels. A total of 22,604 and 23,566 peptides corresponding to 4481 and 4436 proteins from 293T cell lysate were detected using HILIC-HPRP- and HPRP-HILIC-based shotgun proteomics workflow, respectively. In addition, without assistance of enrichment techniques, the tandem fractionation methods aided to identify 46 different PTMs from over 10,000 of spectra using blind modification search algorithm. We concluded that HILIC is a valuable alternative option for peptide prefractionation in a large-scale proteomic study, but can be further augmented with the use of a secondary HPRP separation.

Fluoride movement into and out of Bacillus spores and growing cells and effects of fluoride accumulation on spore properties

AIMS

To investigate effects of fluoride ion (F^- ) on, and kinetics of its movement into and out of, spores and growing cells of Bacillus species.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Effects of F^- on Bacillus cell growth, spore germination and outgrowth and heat resistance were investigated, as well as F^- movement into and out of spores using ¹⁹ F-NMR. F^- inhibited Bacillus subtilis spore germination and outgrowth, and YhdU, now named FluC, was crucial to prevent F^- accumulation in growing cells and to minimize F^- inhibition of spore germination. Dormant wild-type, yhdU and coat defective B. subtilis spores, and Bacillus cereus spores incubated in 40 mmol l^-1 NaF for 48 h accumulated 2-2·6 mol l^-1  F^- and its movement into Bacillus spores was highest at low pH. Bacillus subtilis spores lacking Ca-dipicolinic acid accumulated higher F^- levels than wild-type spores.

CONCLUSIONS

These results are consistent with F^- incorporation into the dormant spore core, and as HF and/or NaF, but not CaF₂ . YhdU played no significant role in F^- uptake or efflux in dormant spores, but assisted in F^- export early in spore germination.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF STUDY

This knowledge provides new insight into effects of F^- on Bacillus cells and spores and how this anion moves into, and out of spores.

A Metabolic Labeling Strategy for Relative Protein Quantification in Clostridioides difficile

Clostridioides difficile (formerly Clostridium difficile) is a Gram-positive, anaerobe, spore-forming pathogen, which causes drug-induced diseases in hospitals worldwide. A detailed analysis of the proteome may provide new targets for drug development or therapeutic strategies to combat this pathogen. The application of metabolic labeling (ML) would allow for accurate quantification of significant differences in protein abundance, even in the case of very small changes. Additionally, it would be possible to perform more accurate studies of the membrane or surface proteomes, which usually require elaborated sample preparation. Such studies are therefore prone to higher standard deviations during the quantification. The implementation of ML strategies for C. difficile is complicated due to the lack in arginine and lysine auxotrophy as well as the Stickland dominated metabolism of this anaerobic pathogen. Hence, quantitative proteome analyses could only be carried out by label free or chemical labeling methods so far. In this paper, a ML approach for C. difficile is described. A cultivation procedure with 15N-labeled media for strain 630Δerm was established achieving an incorporation rate higher than 97%. In a proof-of-principle experiment, the performance of the ML approach in C. difficile was tested. The proteome data of the cytosolic subproteome of C. difficile cells grown in complex medium as well as two minimal media in the late exponential and early stationary growth phase obtained via ML were compared with two label free relative quantification approaches (NSAF and LFQ). The numbers of identified proteins were comparable within the three approaches, whereas the number of quantified proteins were between 1,110 (ML) and 1,861 (LFQ) proteins. A hierarchical clustering showed clearly separated clusters for the different conditions and a small tree height with ML approach. Furthermore, it was shown that the quantification based on ML revealed significant altered proteins with small fold changes compared to the label free approaches. The quantification based on ML was accurate, reproducible, and even more sensitive compared to label free quantification strategies.

"One-Pot" Sample Processing Method for Proteome-Wide Analysis of Microbial Cells and Spores

PURPOSE

Bacterial endospores, the transmissible forms of pathogenic bacilli and clostridia, are heterogeneous multilayered structures composed of proteins. These proteins protect the spores against a variety of stresses, thus helping spore survival, and assist in germination, by interacting with the environment to form vegetative cells. Owing to the complexity, insolubility, and dynamic nature of spore proteins, it has been difficult to obtain their comprehensive protein profiles.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

The intact spores of Bacillus subtilis, Bacillus cereus, and Peptoclostridium difficile and their vegetative counterparts were disrupted by bead beating in 6 m urea under reductive conditions. The heterogeneous mixture was then double digested with LysC and trypsin. Next, the peptide mixture was pre-fractionated with zwitterionic hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (ZIC-HILIC) followed by reverse-phase LC-FT-MS analysis of the fractions.

RESULTS

"One-pot" method is a simple, robust method that yields identification of >1000 proteins with high confidence, across all spore layers from B. subtilis, B. cereus, and P. difficile.

CONCLUSIONS AND MEDICAL RELEVANCE

This method can be employed for proteome-wide analysis of non-spore-forming as well as spore-forming pathogens. Analysis of spore protein profile will help to understand the sporulation and germination processes and to distinguish immunogenic protein markers.