Identifying protein complexes from heterogeneous biological data

DPCT: A Dynamic Method for Detecting Protein Complexes From TAP-Aware Weighted PPI Network

Detecting protein complexes from the Protein-Protein interaction network (PPI) is the essence of discovering the rules of the cellular world. There is a large amount of PPI data available, generated from high throughput experimental data. The enormous size of the data persuaded us to use computational methods instead of experimental methods to detect protein complexes. In past years, many researchers presented their algorithms to detect protein complexes. Most of the presented algorithms use current static PPI networks. New researches proved the dynamicity of cellular systems, and so, the PPI is not static over time. In this paper, we introduce DPCT to detect protein complexes from dynamic PPI networks. In the proposed method, TAP and GO data are used to make a weighted PPI network and to reduce the noise of PPI. Gene expression data are also used to make dynamic subnetworks from PPI. A memetic algorithm is used to bicluster gene expression data and to create a dynamic subnetwork for each bicluster. Experimental results show that DPCT can detect protein complexes with better correctness than state-of-the-art detection algorithms. The source code and datasets of DPCT used can be found at https://github.com/alisn72/DPCT.

The Applications of Clustering Methods in Predicting Protein Functions

Background:

The understanding of protein function is essential to the study of biological processes. However, the prediction of protein function has been a difficult task for bioinformatics to overcome. This has resulted in many scholars focusing on the development of computational methods to address this problem.

Objective:

In this review, we introduce the recently developed computational methods of protein function prediction and assess the validity of these methods. We then introduce the applications of clustering methods in predicting protein functions.

Protein complex detection based on flower pollination mechanism in multi-relation reconstructed dynamic protein networks

Background

Detecting protein complex in protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks plays a significant part in bioinformatics field. It enables us to obtain the better understanding for the structures and characteristics of biological systems.

Methods

In this study, we present a novel algorithm, named Improved Flower Pollination Algorithm (IFPA), to identify protein complexes in multi-relation reconstructed dynamic PPI networks. Specifically, we first introduce a concept called co-essentiality, which considers the protein essentiality to search essential interactions, Then, we devise the multi-relation reconstructed dynamic PPI networks (MRDPNs) and discover the potential cores of protein complexes in MRDPNs. Finally, an IFPA algorithm is put forward based on the flower pollination mechanism to generate protein complexes by simulating the process of pollen find the optimal pollination plants, namely, attach the peripheries to the corresponding cores.

Results

The experimental results on three different datasets (DIP, MIPS and Krogan) show that our IFPA algorithm is more superior to some representative methods in the prediction of protein complexes.

Conclusions

Our proposed IFPA algorithm is powerful in protein complex detection by building multi-relation reconstructed dynamic protein networks and using improved flower pollination algorithm. The experimental results indicate that our IFPA algorithm can obtain better performance than other methods.

Integrating network topology, gene expression data and GO annotation information for protein complex prediction

The prediction of protein complexes based on the protein interaction network is a fundamental task for the understanding of cellular life as well as the mechanisms underlying complex disease. A great number of methods have been developed to predict protein complexes based on protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks in recent years. However, because the high throughput data obtained from experimental biotechnology are incomplete, and usually contain a large number of spurious interactions, most of the network-based protein complex identification methods are sensitive to the reliability of the PPI network. In this paper, we propose a new method, Identification of Protein Complex based on Refined Protein Interaction Network (IPC-RPIN), which integrates the topology, gene expression profiles and GO functional annotation information to predict protein complexes from the reconstructed networks. To demonstrate the performance of the IPC-RPIN method, we evaluated the IPC-RPIN on three PPI networks of Saccharomycescerevisiae and compared it with four state-of-the-art methods. The simulation results show that the IPC-RPIN achieved a better result than the other methods on most of the measurements and is able to discover small protein complexes which have traditionally been neglected.

A multi-network clustering method for detecting protein complexes from multiple heterogeneous networks

Background

The accurate identification of protein complexes is important for the understanding of cellular organization. Up to now, computational methods for protein complex detection are mostly focus on mining clusters from protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks. However, PPI data collected by high-throughput experimental techniques are known to be quite noisy. It is hard to achieve reliable prediction results by simply applying computational methods on PPI data. Behind protein interactions, there are protein domains that interact with each other. Therefore, based on domain-protein associations, the joint analysis of PPIs and domain-domain interactions (DDI) has the potential to obtain better performance in protein complex detection. As traditional computational methods are designed to detect protein complexes from a single PPI network, it is necessary to design a new algorithm that could effectively utilize the information inherent in multiple heterogeneous networks.

Results

In this paper, we introduce a novel multi-network clustering algorithm to detect protein complexes from multiple heterogeneous networks. Unlike existing protein complex identification algorithms that focus on the analysis of a single PPI network, our model can jointly exploit the information inherent in PPI and DDI data to achieve more reliable prediction results. Extensive experiment results on real-world data sets demonstrate that our method can predict protein complexes more accurately than other state-of-the-art protein complex identification algorithms.

Conclusions

In this work, we demonstrate that the joint analysis of PPI network and DDI network can help to improve the accuracy of protein complex detection.

Protein Complex Detection via Effective Integration of Base Clustering Solutions and Co-Complex Affinity Scores

With the increasing availability of protein interaction data, various computational methods have been developed to predict protein complexes. However, different computational methods may have their own advantages and limitations. Ensemble clustering has thus been studied to minimize the potential bias and risk of individual methods and generate prediction results with better coverage and accuracy. In this paper, we extend the traditional ensemble clustering by taking into account the co-complex affinity scores and present an Ensemble H ierarchical Clustering framework (EnsemHC) to detect protein complexes. First, we construct co-cluster matrices by integrating the clustering results with the co-complex evidences. Second, we sum up the constructed co-cluster matrices to derive a final ensemble matrix via a novel iterative weighting scheme. Finally, we apply the hierarchical clustering to generate protein complexes from the final ensemble matrix. Experimental results demonstrate that our EnsemHC performs better than its base clustering methods and various existing integrative methods. In addition, we also observed that integrating the clusters and co-complex affinity scores from different data sources will improve the prediction performance, e.g., integrating the clusters from TAP data and co-complex affinities from binary PPI data achieved the best performance in our experiments.

PCE-FR: A Novel Method for Identifying Overlapping Protein Complexes in Weighted Protein-Protein Interaction Networks Using Pseudo-Clique Extension Based on Fuzzy Relation

Identifying overlapping protein complexes in protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks can provide insight into cellular functional organization and thus elucidate underlying cellular mechanisms. Recently, various algorithms for protein complexes detection have been developed for PPI networks. However, majority of algorithms primarily depend on network topological feature and/or gene expression profile, failing to consider the inherent biological meanings between protein pairs. In this paper, we propose a novel method to detect protein complexes using pseudo-clique extension based on fuzzy relation (PCE-FR). Our algorithm operates in three stages: it first forms the nonoverlapping protein substructure based on fuzzy relation and then expands each substructure by adding neighbor proteins to maximize the cohesive score. Finally, highly overlapped candidate protein complexes are merged to form the final protein complex set. Particularly, our algorithm employs the biological significance hidden in protein pairs to construct edge weight for protein interaction networks. The experiment results show that our method can not only outperform classical algorithms such as CFinder, ClusterONE, CMC, RRW, HC-PIN, and ProRank +, but also achieve ideal overall performance in most of the yeast PPI datasets in terms of composite score consisting of precision, accuracy, and separation. We further apply our method to a human PPI network from the HPRD dataset and demonstrate it is very effective in detecting protein complexes compared to other algorithms.

Protein complex detection based on partially shared multi-view clustering

Background

Protein complexes are the key molecular entities to perform many essential biological functions. In recent years, high-throughput experimental techniques have generated a large amount of protein interaction data. As a consequence, computational analysis of such data for protein complex detection has received increased attention in the literature. However, most existing works focus on predicting protein complexes from a single type of data, either physical interaction data or co-complex interaction data. These two types of data provide compatible and complementary information, so it is necessary to integrate them to discover the underlying structures and obtain better performance in complex detection.

Results

In this study, we propose a novel multi-view clustering algorithm, called the Partially Shared Multi-View Clustering model (PSMVC), to carry out such an integrated analysis. Unlike traditional multi-view learning algorithms that focus on mining either consistent or complementary information embedded in the multi-view data, PSMVC can jointly explore the shared and specific information inherent in different views. In our experiments, we compare the complexes detected by PSMVC from single data source with those detected from multiple data sources. We observe that jointly analyzing multi-view data benefits the detection of protein complexes. Furthermore, extensive experiment results demonstrate that PSMVC performs much better than 16 state-of-the-art complex detection techniques, including ensemble clustering and data integration techniques.

Conclusions

In this work, we demonstrate that when integrating multiple data sources, using partially shared multi-view clustering model can help to identify protein complexes which are not readily identifiable by conventional single-view-based methods and other integrative analysis methods. All the results and source codes are available on https://github.com/Oyl-CityU/PSMVC.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-016-1164-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

A two-layer integration framework for protein complex detection

Background

Protein complexes carry out nearly all signaling and functional processes within cells. The study of protein complexes is an effective strategy to analyze cellular functions and biological processes. With the increasing availability of proteomics data, various computational methods have recently been developed to predict protein complexes. However, different computational methods are based on their own assumptions and designed to work on different data sources, and various biological screening methods have their unique experiment conditions, and are often different in scale and noise level. Therefore, a single computational method on a specific data source is generally not able to generate comprehensive and reliable prediction results.

Results

In this paper, we develop a novel Two-layer INtegrative Complex Detection (TINCD) model to detect protein complexes, leveraging the information from both clustering results and raw data sources. In particular, we first integrate various clustering results to construct consensus matrices for proteins to measure their overall co-complex propensity. Second, we combine these consensus matrices with the co-complex score matrix derived from Tandem Affinity Purification/Mass Spectrometry (TAP) data and obtain an integrated co-complex similarity network via an unsupervised metric fusion method. Finally, a novel graph regularized doubly stochastic matrix decomposition model is proposed to detect overlapping protein complexes from the integrated similarity network.

Conclusions

Extensive experimental results demonstrate that TINCD performs much better than 21 state-of-the-art complex detection techniques, including ensemble clustering and data integration techniques.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-016-0939-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

WCOACH: Protein complex prediction in weighted PPI networks

Protein complexes are aggregates of protein molecules that play important roles in biological processes. Detecting protein complexes from protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks is one of the most challenging problems in computational biology, and many computational methods have been developed to solve this problem. Generally, these methods yield high false positive rates. In this article, a semantic similarity measure between proteins, based on Gene Ontology (GO) structure, is applied to weigh PPI networks. Consequently, one of the well-known methods, COACH, has been improved to be compatible with weighted PPI networks for protein complex detection. The new method, WCOACH, is compared to the COACH, ClusterOne, IPCA, CORE, OH-PIN, HC-PIN and MCODE methods on several PPI networks such as DIP, Krogan, Gavin 2002 and MIPS. WCOACH can be applied as a fast and high-performance algorithm to predict protein complexes in weighted PPI networks. All data and programs are freely available at http://bioinformatics.aut.ac.ir/wcoach.

A density-based clustering approach for identifying overlapping protein complexes with functional preferences

Background

Identifying protein complexes is an essential task for understanding the mechanisms of proteins in cells. Many computational approaches have thus been developed to identify protein complexes in protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks. Regarding the information that can be adopted by computational approaches to identify protein complexes, in addition to the graph topology of PPI network, the consideration of functional information of proteins has been becoming popular recently. Relevant approaches perform their tasks by relying on the idea that proteins in the same protein complex may be associated with similar functional information. However, we note from our previous researches that for most protein complexes their proteins are only similar in specific subsets of categories of functional information instead of the entire set. Hence, if the preference of each functional category can also be taken into account when identifying protein complexes, the accuracy will be improved.

Results

To implement the idea, we first introduce a preference vector for each of proteins to quantitatively indicate the preference of each functional category when deciding the protein complex this protein belongs to. Integrating functional preferences of proteins and the graph topology of PPI network, we formulate the problem of identifying protein complexes into a constrained optimization problem, and we propose the approach DCAFP to address it. For performance evaluation, we have conducted extensive experiments with several PPI networks from the species of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Human and also compared DCAFP with state-of-the-art approaches in the identification of protein complexes. The experimental results show that considering the integration of functional preferences and dense structures improved the performance of identifying protein complexes, as DCAFP outperformed the other approaches for most of PPI networks based on the assessments of independent measures of f-measure, Accuracy and Maximum Matching Rate. Furthermore, the function enrichment experiments indicated that DCAFP identified more protein complexes with functional significance when compared with approaches, such as PCIA, that also utilize the functional information.

Conclusions

According to the promising performance of DCAFP, the integration of functional preferences and dense structures has made it possible to identify protein complexes more accurately and significantly.

A least square method based model for identifying protein complexes in protein-protein interaction network

Protein complex formed by a group of physical interacting proteins plays a crucial role in cell activities. Great effort has been made to computationally identify protein complexes from protein-protein interaction (PPI) network. However, the accuracy of the prediction is still far from being satisfactory, because the topological structures of protein complexes in the PPI network are too complicated. This paper proposes a novel optimization framework to detect complexes from PPI network, named PLSMC. The method is on the basis of the fact that if two proteins are in a common complex, they are likely to be interacting. PLSMC employs this relation to determine complexes by a penalized least squares method. PLSMC is applied to several public yeast PPI networks, and compared with several state-of-the-art methods. The results indicate that PLSMC outperforms other methods. In particular, complexes predicted by PLSMC can match known complexes with a higher accuracy than other methods. Furthermore, the predicted complexes have high functional homogeneity.

A novel algorithm for detecting protein complexes with the breadth first search

Most biological processes are carried out by protein complexes. A substantial number of false positives of the protein-protein interaction (PPI) data can compromise the utility of the datasets for complexes reconstruction. In order to reduce the impact of such discrepancies, a number of data integration and affinity scoring schemes have been devised. The methods encode the reliabilities (confidence) of physical interactions between pairs of proteins. The challenge now is to identify novel and meaningful protein complexes from the weighted PPI network. To address this problem, a novel protein complex mining algorithm ClusterBFS (Cluster with Breadth-First Search) is proposed. Based on the weighted density, ClusterBFS detects protein complexes of the weighted network by the breadth first search algorithm, which originates from a given seed protein used as starting-point. The experimental results show that ClusterBFS performs significantly better than the other computational approaches in terms of the identification of protein complexes.