Effect of the brachypod mutation on early stages of chondrogenesis in mouse embryonic hind limbs: an ultrastructural analysis

Endochondral ossification and the evolution of limb proportions

Mammals have remarkably diverse limb proportions hypothesized to have evolved adaptively in the context of locomotion and other behaviors. Mechanistically, evolutionary diversity in limb proportions is the result of differential limb bone growth. Longitudinal limb bone growth is driven by the process of endochondral ossification, under the control of the growth plates. In growth plates, chondrocytes undergo a tightly orchestrated life cycle of proliferation, matrix production, hypertrophy, and cell death/transdifferentiation. This life cycle is highly conserved, both among the long bones of an individual, and among homologous bones of distantly related taxa, leading to a finite number of complementary cell mechanisms that can generate heritable phenotype variation in limb bone size and shape. The most important of these mechanisms are chondrocyte population size in chondrogenesis and in individual growth plates, proliferation rates, and hypertrophic chondrocyte size. Comparative evidence in mammals and birds suggests the existence of developmental biases that favor evolutionary changes in some of these cellular mechanisms over others in driving limb allometry. Specifically, chondrocyte population size may evolve more readily in response to selection than hypertrophic chondrocyte size, and extreme hypertrophy may be a rarer evolutionary phenomenon associated with highly specialized modes of locomotion in mammals (e.g., powered flight, ricochetal bipedal hopping). Physical and physiological constraints at multiple levels of biological organization may also have influenced the cell developmental mechanisms that have evolved to produce the highly diverse limb proportions in extant mammals. This article is categorized under: Establishment of Spatial and Temporal Patterns > Regulation of Size, Proportion, and Timing Comparative Development and Evolution > Regulation of Organ Diversity Comparative Development and Evolution > Organ System Comparisons Between Species.

Differentiation of cartilaginous anlagen in entire embryonic mouse limbs cultured in a rotating bioreactor

Mechanisms involved in development of the embryonic limb have remained the same throughout eons of genetic and environmental evolution under Earth gravity (1 g). During the spaceflight era it has been of interest to explore the ancient theory that form of the skeleton develops in response to gravity, and that changes in gravitational forces can change the developmental pattern of the limb. This has been shown in vivo and in vitro, allowing the hypergravity of centrifugation and microgravity of space to be used as tools to increase our knowledge of limb development. In recapitulations of spaceflight experiments, premetatarsals were cultured in suspension in a bioreactor, and found to be shorter and less differentiated than those cultured in standard culture dishes. This study only measured length of the metatarsals, and did not account for possible changes due to the skeletal elements having a more in vivo 3D shape while in suspension vs. flattened tissues compressed by their own weight. A culture system with an outcome closer to in vivo and that supports growth of younger limb buds than traditional systems will allow studies of early Hox gene expression, and contribute to the understanding of very early stages of development. The purpose of the current experiment was to determine if entire limb buds could be cultured in the bioreactor, and to compare the growth and differentiation with that of culturing in a culture dish system. Fore and hind limbs from E11-E13 ICR mouse embryos were cultured for six days, either in the bioreactor or in center-well organ culture dishes, fixed, and embedded for histology. E13 specimens grown in culture dishes were flat, while bioreactor culture specimens had a more in vivo-like 3D limb shape. Sections showed excellent cartilage differentiation in both culture systems, with more cell maturation, and hypertrophy in the specimens cultured in the bioreactor. Younger limb buds fused together during culture, so an additional set of E11.5 limb buds was cultured with and without encapsulation in alginate prior to culturing in the bioreactor. Encapsulated limbs grown in the bioreactor did not fuse together, but developed only the more proximal elements while limbs grown in culture dishes formed proximal and distal elements. Alginate encapsulation may have reduced oxygenation to the progress zone of the developing limb bud resulting in lack of development of the more distal elements. These results show that the bioreactor supports growth and differentiation of skeletal elements in entire E13 limb buds, and that a method to culture younger limb buds without fusing together needs to be developed if any morphometric analysis is to be performed.

Mechanisms of GDF-5 action during skeletal development

Mutations in GDF-5, a member of the TGF-beta superfamily, result in the autosomal recessive syndromes brachypod (bp) in mice and Hunter-Thompson and Grebe-type chondrodysplasias in humans. These syndromes are all characterised by the shortening of the appendicular skeleton and loss or abnormal development of some joints. To investigate how GDF-5 controls skeletogenesis, we overexpressed GDF-5 during chick limb development using the retrovirus, RCASBP. This resulted in up to a 37.5% increase in length of the skeletal elements, which was predominantly due to an increase in the number of chondrocytes. By injecting virus at different stages of development, we show that GDF-5 can increase both the size of the early cartilage condensation and the later developing skeletal element. Using in vitro micromass cultures as a model system to study the early steps of chondrogenesis, we show that GDF-5 increases chondrogenesis in a dose-dependent manner. We did not detect changes in proliferation. However, cell suspension cultures showed that GDF-5 might act at these stages by increasing cell adhesion, a critical determinant of early chondrogenesis. In contrast, pulse labelling experiments of GDF-5-infected limbs showed that at later stages of skeletal development GDF-5 can increase proliferation of chondrocytes. Thus, here we show two mechanisms of how GDF-5 may control different stages of skeletogenesis. Finally, our data show that levels of GDF-5 expression/activity are important in controlling the size of skeletal elements and provides a possible explanation for the variation in the severity of skeletal defects resulting from mutations in GDF-5.

Exposure to altered gravity affects all stages of endochondral cartilage differentiation

Chondrogenesis has a number of well-defined steps: (1) condensation, which involves cell aggregation, adhesion and communication; (2) activation of cartilage genes, which is accompanied by rounding up of the cells and intracellular differentiation; and (3) production and secretion of cartilage specific matrix molecules. Our studies show that each of these steps is affected by exposure to gravitational changes. Clinorotation and centrifugation affected initial aggregation and condensation. In the CELLS experiment, where cells were exposed to microgravity after some condensation occurred preflight, intracellular differentiation and matrix production were delayed relative to controls. Once cartilage has developed, in rats, further differentiation (hypertrophy, matrix production) was also affected by spaceflight and hind limb suspension. For the process of chondrogenesis to proceed as we know it, loading and other factors present at 1g are required at each step of the process. This requirement means that not only will skeletal development and bone healing, processes involving chondrogenesis, be altered by long term exposure to microgravity, but that continuous intervention will be necessary to correct any defects produced by altered gravity environments.

Clinorotation reduces number, but not size, of cartilaginous nodules formed in micromass cultures of mouse limbbud cells

In previous studies we used a ground based model to investigate the cellular responses to microgravity by exposing micromass cultures of embryonic limb cells to simulated weightlessness on a clinostat. Cultures set up in T-flasks and rotated at 30 rpm showed that clinostatted cultures had less chondrocyte differentiation than stationary or rotation controls, as assessed by number of nodules/culture stained with cartilage specific Alcian blue. In the current study, nodule size and shape of these nodules was assessed by interactive measurement of area, perimeter, circularity, and equivalent diameters, using the Optimas imaging software. Results show no significant difference in any of the measurements, indicating that clinorotation has no effect on expansion of the nodules either by differentiation of cells within the nodule, or by recruitment of cells into the nodule. The reduction in number of nodules without an alteration in size and shape indicates that the effect of simulated microgravity is to reduce the cell interactions required for the initial condensation of cells into a nodule, probably by interference with cell adhesion molecules.

Studies of chondrogenesis in rotating systems

A great deal of energy has been exerted over the years researching methods for regenerating and repairing bone and cartilage. Several techniques, especially bone implants and grafts, show great promise for providing a remedy for many skeletal disorders and chondrodystrophies. The bioreactor (rotating-wall vessel, RWV) is a cell culture system that creates a nurturing environment conducive to cell aggregation. Chondrocyte cultures have been studied as implants for repair and replacement of damaged and missing bone and cartilage since 1965 [Chesterman and Smith, J Bone Joint Surg 50B:184-197, 1965]. The ability to use large, tissue-like cartilage aggregates grown in the RWV would be of great clinical significance in treating skeletal disorders. In addition, the RWV may provide a superior method for studying chondrogenesis and chondrogenic mutations. Because the RWV is also reported to simulate many of the conditions of microgravity it is a very useful ground-based tool for studying how cell systems will react to microgravity.

Alterations in cell surface galactosyltransferase activity during limb chondrogenesis in brachypod mutant mouse embryos

The autosomal mutation brachypod (bpH/bpH) in the mouse affects the development of precartilage mesenchymal condensation in the limb-bud. We have previously shown that this defect is localized to the expression of terminal N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc) glycoproteins in the plasma membrane (Elmer and Wright, '83). The present study is focused on cell surface galactosyltransferase (GalTase), an ectoenzyme that transfers galactose to its GlcNAc substrate. Purified plasma membrane preparations derived from wild-type (+/+), heterozygote (+/bpH) and brachypod (bpH/bpH) embryonic mouse limb cells were assayed for GalTase activity during in vitro and in utero chondrogenesis using High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC). On embryonic day E12, prior to overt expression of the mutant gene, no significant difference in GalTase activity was observed. By the third day in culture, all major chondrogenic elements of the autopod were present in +/+ and +/bpH embryos, whereas the mutant autopods were markedly deficient in staining and appeared consistently shorter. The accumulation of alcianophilic cartilage matrix in the wild-type was accompanied by a 29% increase in GalTase activity, which reflected the net change (29%) observed during development from days E12 to E13 in utero. The GalTase activity for the in utero E13 mutant (13%) was significantly different from control. In culture, day E12 mutant autopods actually decreased in their GalTase level by 3 days so that the activity was reduced to only 57% of the wild-type. Though GalTase activity in the heterozygote showed an intermediate expression, optical image analysis did not reveal consistent differences in cartilage development when compared to +/+, arguing against a gene-dosage effect at the gross anatomical level. These data indicate that an increase in plasma membrane GalTase activity is a natural developmental event that occurs during limb-bud chondrogenesis and a decrease in GalTase activity contributes to the dysmorphogenesis in brachypod limb-buds.

Suppression of morphogenesis in embryonic mouse limbs exposed in vitro to excess gravity

This paper is a report of the first investigation of the effect of excess gravity on in vitro mammalian limb chondrogenesis. Limb buds from mice of various gestational stages were exposed to excess gravity (2.6G) using a culture centrifuge. Both forelimbs and hind limbs were cultured and the development of various limb elements was scored after four to six days. The 2.6G force significantly depressed the development of limb elements when applied during the teratogen-sensitive period of chondrogenesis. There was a proximodistal gradient of sensitivity to excess gravity in the limb with proximal structures being less susceptible than distal ones. In some cases, proximal limb elements present prior to explantation disappeared upon exposure to excess gravity. Hypergravity's teratogenic effect is assumed to operate via changes in tension and/or pressure on the cells, accompanied by alterations in cell morphometry and membrane properties.

Immunohistochemical localization of cyclic AMP during normal and abnormal chick and mouse limb development

This paper describes the immunohistochemical localization of cAMP during limb chondrogenesis in talpid3 chick, brachypod mouse, and normal embryos. Comparisons were made between chick wing buds at Stages 22, 25, and 30, and mouse hind limb buds at Days 11, 12.5 and 14. At Stage 22, the normal mesenchyme in the chick displayed areas of bright fluorescence compared to a lesser intense and more evenly distributed fluorescence in talpid3. Sections of the central region from normal Stage 25 limb buds exhibited an intense fluorescence that was uniformly distributed, whereas, in talpid3 staining was more mosaic with some areas fluorescing brightly and others showing little fluorescence. At Stage 30 the staining pattern was similar between normal and talpid3, with the fluorescence being brighter in the cartilage tissue than in the surrounding soft tissue. Difference in the staining patterns of normal and brachypod limb tissue were not detectable. At Days 11 and 12.5, tissue from both genotypes displayed a very bright, uniform fluorescence. In the 14-day hind limb buds, the staining patterns were comparable to those observed in Stage 30 chick wing buds. However, under in vitro conditions conducive for the expression of the chondrogenic phenotype, differences in the intensity and extensiveness of fluorescent staining were detectable in cultures derived from 12-day normal and brachypod hind limb mesenchyme. Compared to the control, the uneven distribution of immunofluorescence in the talpid3 limb buds and the differences in intensity and extensiveness of fluorescence in the brachypod cultures support the hypothesis that cAMP is involved in limb cartilage differentiation.