Long-term protection against HIV-1 infection conferred by tat or rev antisense RNA was affected by the design of the retroviral vector

Stable gene expression occurs from a minority of integrated HIV-1-based vectors: transcriptional silencing is present in the majority

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-based vectors are being increasingly used in vitro for gene transfer and in vivo for gene therapy. The proportion of integrated retroviral vectors that are silenced or remain transcriptionally active, and the stability of gene expression in the latter remains poorly explored. To study this, T cells were infected with an HIV-1-based vector construct containing a long terminal repeat-driven reporter gene. Only a small percentage of detectable integrated vector expressed gene product. In clones derived from cells with transcriptionally active vector, gene expression was remarkably stable with more than 80% continuing to express for greater than 18 months. Failure to continue expressing the vector was associated with epigenetic changes. Our data suggest that there are two forms of vector silencing: one occurring immediately after integration affecting the majority of the vectors, and one occurring in the much longer term affecting a small minority of vectors which had previously established expression.

Development of a self-inactivating tet-on retroviral vector expressing bone morphogenetic protein 4 to achieve regulated bone formation

The aims of this study were to explore the possibility of improving the design of self-inactivating (SI) retroviral vectors and to develop an SI vector that would allow optimal tet-on-regulated therapeutic gene expression. To minimize any interference between the viral promoter and the inducible promoter, we deleted different regulatory elements in the 3'LTR and examined their effects on transgene expression in transfected or transduced cells. In transfected cells, such deletions reduced the transgene expression. The insertion of a polyadenylation sequence could not completely compensate for this effect. We observed three patterns of transgene expression in cells transduced with these tet-on retroviral vectors: (1) high levels of both basal and inducible expression, (2) low levels of both basal and inducible expression, and (3) low levels of basal and high levels of inducible expression. After using the optimal vector to transduce muscle-derived stem cells, we were able to regulate the strong in vitro expression of transgenes-including enhanced green fluorescent protein and bone morphogenetic protein 4-via the addition or withdrawal of doxycycline (Dox). Implantation of the transduced cells and subsequent Dox-dependent induction of gene expression resulted in bone formation in vivo. Thus, we have developed an optimal SI retroviral vector that maintains a high titer, efficiently transduces muscle-derived stem cells, and enables both high levels of inducible gene expression in vitro and robust regulated bone formation in vivo.

Promoter choice affects the potency of HIV-1 specific RNA interference

RNA interference (RNAi) is mediated by small interfering (si) RNAs that target and degrade mRNA in a sequence-specific manner. Cellular expression of siRNA can be achieved by the use of expression cassettes driven by RNA polymerase III (pol III) promoters. Here, we demonstrate that a modified tRNA(met)-derived (MTD) promoter effectively drives the cellular expression of HIV-1-specific siRNA. We observed up to 56% greater inhibition of virus production when the MTD promoter was used to drive the expression of short hairpin (sh) RNA targeting the HIV-1 transactivator protein tat compared to cassettes containing other pol III promoters such as H1, U6+1 and U6+27. We conclude that the MTD promoter is ideally suited to drive intracellular expression of HIV-1 specific siRNA and may serve as an important component of future RNAi vector delivery systems.

Additive and antagonist effects of therapeutic gene combinations for suppression of HIV-1 infection

A previously described Moloney-based vector expressing a double copy anti-tat antisense tRNA (DC-tRNA-AT) (Biasolo et al., 1996. J. Virol. 70, 2154-2161) was modified to increase the copy number of the antisense molecule and to target the intra-cytoplasmic localization of the HIV genome. To this end, an anti-U5 hammerhead ribozyme, engineered as a hybrid small adenoviral VAI RNA (VAIalpha), was inserted into the vector as a single molecule or in combination with the double copy anti-tat sequence. The retroviral vector expressing only VAIalpha (DC-VAIalpha) inhibited HIV-1 replication to an extent comparable to that of DC-tRNA-AT. A more effective inhibition was produced by the vector expressing multiple copies of the anti-tat antisense (DC-6tRNA-AT). This higher effectiveness correlated with anti-tat stochiometry, i.e. with the absolute number of therapeutic molecules being produced on a per cell basis at the steady state. Surprisingly, when the tRNA-AT and VAIalpha genes were combined in the same vector (DC-AT-VAIalpha), an enhancement of viral replication was noticed. This study indicates that it is possible to potentiate the antiviral activity of a retroviral vector by increasing the steady-state level of the therapeutic molecule. Results also show that the combined expression of two singularly active therapeutic RNAs can have antagonistic rather than synergistic effects.

Investigation of RNA transcripts containing HIV-1 packaging signal sequences as HIV-1 antivirals: generation of cell lines resistant to HIV-1

Based on the success of RNA decoy approaches using RRE and TAR sequences to inhibit HIV-1 replication, we studied the ability of HIV-1 packaging signal sequences to interfere with viral RNA encapsidation and formation of infectious particles. We made a variety of plasmid constructs in which the sequence context or number of repeats of the viral packaging signal was varied, and investigated the ability of these transcripts to inhibit replication of HIV-1 in stably transfected Jurkat T lymphocytes. We found that certain lines showed strong inhibition of HIV-1 replication, an effect that persisted at high input amounts of virus and significantly delayed viral replication for up to 4 weeks. An investigation of the mechanism of inhibition revealed that in these cell lines the packaging efficiency of the genomic HIV-1 transcript was unaffected. Further studies identified an antiviral effect on both HIV-1 and HIV-2 that did not correlate with decoy expression, and was substantially independent of CD4 expression or cellular proliferative capacity. Study of these resistant cell lines may lead to new insights into mechanisms of inhibition of HIV-1 replication.

Antisense RNA sequences targeting the 5' leader packaging signal region of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 inhibits viral replication at post-transcriptional stages of the life cycle

Antisense RNA has proven a potent inhibitor of gene expression and has the potential to inhibit retroviral replication at a number of stages in the virus life cycle by targeting both viral and cellular RNA sequences. Antisense RNA complementary to three target regions in the 5' leader/LTR of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1), the TAR region, the primer binding site and the splice donor (SD)-packaging signal (psi) region were stably expressed from the CMV IE promoter in Jurkat cells, and expression confirmed by RT-PCR. When challenged with HIV-1, cell lines expressing antisense RNA targeting the SD/psi region showed significant inhibition of replication (at up to 10(6) TCID 50/ml). These sequences were also expressed in lymphocytes after transduction using recombinant retroviruses and one sequence complementary to the SD/psi region inhibited replication of HIV-1. A co-transfection assay using COS-1 cells was also developed both to confirm the antiviral potential of these sequences, and to determine the predominant site of action of these molecules. Antisense RNAs targeting the psi region and one sequence complementary to the TAR region inhibited expression of viral protein; furthermore, analyses of relative levels of cellular and virion RNA from these assays suggest each of these antisense molecules exerts its effect at an early stage in the transcription-translation pathway, while the longer of the sequences also inhibited packaging of virion RNA. These results suggest that the packaging signal (psi) of HIV-1 represents an attractive target for antisense RNA-based gene therapy, although the main mode of action of such molecules may well be through antisense effects at an earlier stage of replication than packaging.

Inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 by packageable, multigenic antisense RNA

Viral-based vectors can provide an efficient delivery mechanism for stable expression of antisense RNA. To enhance and propagate the antiviral effect of antisense RNA, two novel human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)-based vector DNAs, designated as pMAG7 and pMAG19, were constructed which contained HIV-1 cis-acting packaging elements and produced multigenic HIV-1 antisense RNA that could target the entire pol, env, vif, vpu, vpr, rev, and tat and portions of gag and nef. The two DNAs were identical except that pMAG19 had additional gag coding sequences. Cotransfection of pMAG DNA and infectious, cloned HIV-1 DNA in 293 cells inhibited virus production (81%-98% reduction in reverse transcriptase activity) of various T cell-tropic and macrophage-tropic clade B isolates, such as NL4-3, YU-2, and JR-CSF. In addition, virion-associated pMAG antisense RNA was detected in residual virus particles produced by pNL4-3 in the presence of pMAG7 DNA, and the antisense sequences were stably transferred by infection of 174 x CEM cells. The results suggest that pMAG DNA may confer broad protection against HIV-1 by reducing initial virus burden due to antisense RNA and subsequent virus spread by propagation of antisense sequences along with wild-type virus.

Interference between effector RNAs expressed from conventional dual-function anti-HIV retroviral vectors can be circumvented using dual-effector-cassette retroviral vectors

Coexpression of different effector molecules from a single vector (a dual-function vector) may provide enhanced efficacy. Thus far most of the reported anti-HIV dual-function vectors express different effector RNAs as a chimeric molecule. In our study involving retroviral vectors coexpressing a U5 ribozyme and either an anti-tat or anti-rev antisense RNA, chimeric vectors exhibit poor potency in several important functional aspects, including inhibition of HIV replication, protection against cytopathic effects, and suppression of target gene function. Surprisingly, such a poor efficacy of chimeric vector function was not associated with a lower level of effector RNA expression. These results indicate that expression of two effector RNAs as a chimeric molecule can lead to interference, reducing their global biological effects. More importantly, we have demonstrated that such interference can be avoided by coexpressing these effector RNAs as separate molecules through a new dual-function vector, called a dual-effector cassette (Dec) vector, developed in this study. We also define some of the design alterations that might affect the efficacy of the Dec vector and demonstrate that forward-designed Dec vectors are more efficacious than reverse-designed Dec vectors, which express a lower level of effector RNA owing to the instability of the 5' effector cassettes in the provirus. We believe that the principle of Dec vector design may also be applicable for the coexpression of other therapeutic RNA effectors in many gene therapy applications.

The antisense sequence of the HIV-1 TAR stem-loop structure covalently linked to the hairpin ribozyme enhances its catalytic activity against two artificial substrates

This work is an in vitro study of the efficiency of catalytic antisense RNAs whose catalytic domain is the wild-type sequence of the hairpin ribozyme, derived from the minus strand of the tobacco ringspot virus satellite RNA. The sequence in the target RNA recognized by the antisense molecule was the stem-loop structure of the human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) TAR region. This region was able to form a complex with its antisense RNA with a binding rate of 2 x 10(4) M(-1)s(-1). Any deletion of the antisense RNA comprising nucleotides of the stem-loop resulted in a decrease in binding rate. Sequences 3' of the stem in the sense RNA also contributed to binding. This stem-loop TAR-antisense segment, covalently linked to a hairpin ribozyme, enhanced its catalytic activity. The highest cleavage rate was obtained when the stem-loop structure was present in both ribozyme and substrate RNAs and they were complementary. Similarly, an extension at the 5'-end of the hairpin ribozyme increased the cleavage rate when its complementary sequence was present in the substrate. Inclusion of the stem-loop at the 3'-end and the extension at the 5'-end of the hairpin ribozyme abolished the positive effect of both antisense units independently. These results may help in the design of hairpin ribozymes for gene silencing.

Examination of antisense RNA and oligodeoxynucleotides as potential inhibitors of avian leukosis virus replication in RP30 cells

Avian leukosis virus (ALV) is an economically important pathogen of chickens. Both antisense RNA and antisense oligodeoxynucleotides (ODN) have been used to diminish the replication and spread of other retroviruses. The use of antisense RNA and ODN to inhibit ALV replication has been examined in cultured RP30 cells. Using an expression system that constitutively transcribes antisense ALV RNA, one transfected cell clone showed a significant reduction in virus growth. However, this effect was not reproducibly observed in other transfected cell lines or in cells in which the antisense transcript was expressed from a regulatable promoter, even though a substantial amount of antisense transcript was generated. Antisense ODN complementary to several different target sites near the 5' end of the ALV genome were also tested for antiviral activity, by comparison of antisense ODN effects to those of randomized sequence controls. An antisense ODN complementary to the ALV primer binding site demonstrated a reproducible reduction in viral replication. However, when the corresponding region was specifically employed as a target for intracellular antisense RNA expression, there again was no significant inhibition of ALV. These results suggest that in vivo expression of antisense RNA is unlikely to be an effective way to generate transgenic poultry that are resistant to field strains of ALV.

Co-packaging of sense and antisense RNAs: a novel strategy for blocking HIV-1 replication

Retroviral vectors were engineered to express either sense (MoTiN-TRPsie+) or sense and antisense (MoTN-TRPsie+/-) RNAs containing the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) trans -activation response (TAR) element and the extended packaging (Psie) signal. The Psie signal includes the dimer linkage structure (DLS) and the Rev response element (RRE). Amphotropic vector particles were used to transduce a human CD4+ T-lymphoid (MT4) cell line. Stable transductants were then tested for sense and antisense RNA production and susceptibility to HIV-1 infection. HIV-1 production was significantly decreased in cells transduced with MoTiN-TRPsie+ and MoTN-TRPsie+/-vectors. Efficient packaging of sense and most remarkably of antisense RNA was observed within the virus progeny. Infectivity of this virus was significantly decreased in both cases, suggesting that the interfering RNAs were co-packaged with HIV-1 RNA. Vector transduction was not expected to occur and was not observed. Inhibition of HIV-1 replication was also demonstrated in human peripheral blood lymphocytes transduced with retroviral vectors expressing antisense RNA. These results suggest that (i) both sense and antisense RNAs were co-packaged with HIV-1 RNA, (ii) the co-packaged sense and antisense RNAs inhibited virus infectivity and (iii) the co-packaged sense and antisense RNAs were not transduced. Sense and antisense RNA-based strategies may also be used to co-package other interfering RNAs (e.g. ribozymes) to cleave HIV-1 virion RNA.

Enhancement or inhibition of HIV-1 replication by intracellular expression of sense or antisense RNA targeted at different intermediates of reverse transcription

OBJECTIVES

To construct retroviral vectors expressing sense or antisense RNA targeted at HIV reverse transcription intermediates, and to test the anti-HIV properties of these constructs in transduced T cells.

DESIGN

Five double-copy retroviral vectors were constructed, in which the expression of the sense or antisense RNA corresponding to HIV minus- or plus-strand strong-stop DNA was driven by the human tRNA(met) promoter.

METHOD

The templates for the sense or antisense RNA were polymerase chain reaction-cloned from HIV pNL43 into a murine leukaemia virus-based vector and corresponding defective virions were packaged in PA317 cells. Human Jurkat T cells transduced with these vectors were challenged with HIV and monitored for viral RNA, viral DNA and p24 production for 23 weeks.

RESULTS

Intracellular expression of HIV sense RU5 sequences (RNA complementary to minus-strand strong-stop DNA) enhanced HIV replication in T cells. Expression of HIV sense or antisense U3RU5 sequences (identical or complementary to plus-strand strong-stop DNA) conferred long-term inhibition of HIV replication, despite continuous presence of viral challenge in the transduced cell cultures.

CONCLUSION

Plus-strand strong-stop DNA as an intermediate in the early process of viral reverse transcription can be explored as an additional target for anti-HIV gene therapy.