Detection of residual disease in acute leukemia using immunological markers

Incorporating measurable ('minimal') residual disease-directed treatment strategies to optimize outcomes in adults with acute myeloid leukemia

Curative-intent therapy leads to complete remissions in many adults with acute myeloid leukemia (AML), but relapse remains common. Numerous studies have unequivocally demonstrated that the persistence of measurable ('minimal') residual disease (MRD) at the submicroscopic level during morphologic remission identifies patients at high risk of disease recurrence and short survival. This association has provided the impetus to customize anti-leukemia therapy based on MRD data, a strategy that is now routinely pursued in acute promyelocytic leukemia (APL). While it is currently uncertain whether this approach will improve outcomes in AML other than APL, randomized studies have validated MRD-based risk-stratified treatment algorithms in acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Here, we review the available studies examining MRD-directed therapy in AML, appraise their strengths and limitations, and discuss avenues for future investigation.

Prognostic and therapeutic implications of minimal residual disease at the time of transplantation in acute leukemia

Relapse remains the major cause of treatment failure after hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) in acute leukemia, even in patients transplanted in morphologic CR. Various techniques now enable the sensitive quantification of 'minimal' amounts of residual disease (MRD) in patients with acute leukemia in remission. Numerous studies convincingly demonstrate that MRD at the time of transplantation is a powerful, independent predictor of subsequent relapse, with current detection levels of one leukemic cell in 10(5)-10(6) normal cells being prognostically relevant. This recognition provides the rationale to assign patients with detectable MRD (that is, 'MRD(+)' patients) to intensified therapies before, during, or after transplantation, although data supporting these strategies are still sparse. Limited evidence from observational studies suggests that outcomes with autologous HCT are so poor that MRD(+) patients should preferentially be assigned to allogeneic HCT, which can cure a subgroup of these patients, particularly if unmanipulated (T-cell replete) grafts and/or minimized immunosuppression are used to optimize the graft-vs-leukemia effect. Emerging data suggest that additional therapy with non-cross-resistant agents to decrease residual tumor burden before transplantation in MRD(+) patients might be beneficial. Further, other studies hint at immunotherapy (for example, rapid withdrawal of immunosuppression and/or donor lymphocyte infusions) as a means to prevent overt relapse if patients remain, or become, MRD(+) after HCT. Ultimately, controlled clinical studies are needed to define the value of MRD-directed therapies, and patients should be encouraged to enter such trials.

Immunotherapy by allogeneic stem cell transplantation

During the past three decades, allogeneic stem cell transplantation (ASCT) has developed from being an experimental therapy in patients with endstage leukemia into a well-established therapy in patients with a range of disorders of the immunohematopoietic system. Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), acute or chronic, attacking host tissue is a major threat. However, donor immunocompetent T cells have a potent graft-versus-leukemia effect. A combination of calcineurin inhibitors and methotrexate is the standard therapy to prevent GVHD. Modulation of the immunosuppressive regimen may induce mild acute and mild chronic GVHD, reduce the risk of relapse, and improve long-term survival. Natural killer cells also play a role in this context. Killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptor incompatibility between recipient and donor may reduce the risk of relapse in patients with myeloid leukemia. Relapse of leukemia is a major cause of death after ASCT. Minimal residual disease and recipient leukemia lineage-specific chimerism are sensitive techniques for early detection of leukemic relapse. Donor lymphocyte infusions can enhance the antitumor effect, especially for patients with molecular relapse. The allogeneic graft-versus-cancer effect has been demonstrated in patients with metastatic breast, renal, colorectal, ovarian, prostatic, and pancreatic carcinoma. Mesenchymal stem cells have immunomodulatory properties and may be used for immunomodulation of GVHD and tissue repair. All things considered, the future looks promising for ASCT.

Leukemia lineage-specific chimerism analysis is a sensitive predictor of relapse in patients with acute myeloid leukemia and myelodysplastic syndrome after allogeneic stem cell transplantation

One of the major complications after allogeneic stem cell transplantation (SCT) in patients with malignant disease is a high frequency of relapse. We have prospectively analyzed the clinical impact of recipient-derived chimeric cells in 30 patients with acute myeloid leukemia and myelodysplastic syndrome after SCT. In order to improve sensitivity and specificity, all samples were cell-separated by using immunomagnetic beads according to the patient's leukemia phenotype, expressed at diagnosis or relapse before SCT. Twelve out of 30 patients experienced a clinical relapse after SCT. Median follow-up time for patients alive and without relapse (n = 15) was 30 (16-47) months. Mixed chimerism in peripheral blood (PB) and bone marrow (BM) > or =1 month post SCT, in the leukemia-affected cell lineage, was detected in 14/30 patients. Ten of these 14 patients relapsed as compared to 2/16 with donor chimerism (DC) (P <0.01). All eight patients with MC in peripheral blood > or =1 month after SCT relapsed vs 4/22 DC patients (P < 0.001). MC was detected a median of 66 (23-332) days before hematological relapse. No correlation was found between T cell MC and relapse. In this study, chimerism analysis showed a higher sensitivity and specificity vs morphological examination. In conclusion, this study may provide a rational basis for treatment with adoptive immunotherapy at an earlier time after SCT than at present, in patients with AML and MDS, in order to treat recurrences of malignant disease.

Regeneration pattern of precursor-B-cells in bone marrow of acute lymphoblastic leukemia patients depends on the type of preceding chemotherapy

Immunofluorescence stainings for the CD10 antigen and terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT) can be used for the detection of leukemic blasts in CD10+ precursor-B-acute lymphoblastic leukemia (precursor-B-ALL) patients, but can also provide insight into the regeneration of normal precursor-B-cells in bone marrow (BM). Over a period of 15 years, we studied the regeneration of CD10+, TdT+, and CD10+/TdT+ cells in BM of children with (CD10+) precursor-B-ALL during and after treatment according to three different treatment protocols of the Dutch Childhood Leukemia Study Group (DCLSG) which differed both in medication and time schedule. This study included a total of 634 BM samples from 46 patients who remained in continuous complete remission (CCR) after treatment according to DCLSG protocols VI (1984-1988; n = 8), VII (1988-1991; n = 10) and VIII (1991-1997; n = 28). After the cytomorphologically defined state of complete remission with CD10+ and CD10+/TdT+ frequencies generally below 1% of total BM cells, a 10-fold increase in precursor-B-cells was observed in protocol VII and protocol VIII, but not in protocol VI. At first sight this precursor-B-cell regeneration during treatment resembled the massive regeneration of the precursor-B-cell compartment after maintenance treatment, and appeared to be related to the post-induction or post-central nervous system (CNS) therapy stops in protocols VII and VIII. However, careful evaluation of the distribution between the 'more mature' (CD10+/TdT-) and the 'immature' (CD10+/TdT+) precursor-B-cells revealed major differences between the post-induction/post-re-induction precursor-B-cell regeneration (low 'mature/immature' ratio: generally <1.0), the post-CNS treatment regeneration (moderate 'mature/immature' ratio: 1.2-2.8), and the post-maintenance regeneration (high 'mature/ immature' ratio: 5.7-7.6). We conclude that a therapy stop of approximately 2 weeks is already sufficient to induce significant precursor-B-cell regeneration even from aplastic BM after induction treatment. Moreover, differences in precursor-B-cell regeneration patterns are related to the intensity of the preceding treatment block, with lower 'mature/immature' ratios after the highly intensive treatment blocks. This information is essential for a correct interpretation of flow cytometric immunophenotyping results of BM samples during follow-up of leukemia patients. Particularly in precursor-B-ALL patients, regeneration of normal precursor-B-cells should not be mistaken for a relapse.

Detection of minimal residual disease in acute leukemia by flow cytometry

Patients with acute leukemia in clinical remission may still have up to 10(10) residual malignant cells (the upper limit of detection by standard morphologic techniques). Sensitive techniques to detect minimal residual disease (MRD) may allow better estimates of the leukemia burden and help the selection of appropriate therapeutic strategies. Flow cytometry and polymerase chain reaction have emerged as the most promising methods for detecting submicrospopic levels of leukemia. Flowcytometric detection of MRD is based on the identification of immunophenotypic combinations expressed on leukemic cells but not on normal hematopoietic cells. It affords the detection of one leukemic cell among 10,000 normal bone marrow cells, and can be currently applied to at least two thirds of all patients with acute leukemia. Prospective studies in large series of patients have demonstrated a strong correlation between MRD levels during clinical remission and treatment outcome. Therefore, MRD assays can be reliably used to assess early response to treatment and predict relapse. In this review, we discuss methodologic aspects and clinical results of flowcytometric detection of MRD in patients with acute leukemia.

The clinical significance of residual disease in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia as detected by polymerase chain reaction amplification by antigen-receptor gene sequences

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) has been applied to detect occult leukemia cells in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia who are otherwise considered in complete remission by traditional morphological examination of bone marrow specimens. To determine whether PCR provides unique prognostic information of use for the clinical investigator, we reviewed the 20 clinical studies published to date. From this review, it is evident that discrepancies exist for the detection of residual disease for patients who remain in complete remission and for those who relapse. However, because of the fundamentally different approaches used to apply the PCR method to each of these studies, an entirely different interpretation can be reached when critical technical factors are considered. The combined data from the various studies suggest that a consistent pattern for residual disease disappearance over many months exists for patients who remain in extended complete remission and a pattern of residual disease persistence and reappearance preceding clinical findings exists for the majority of those who ultimately relapse in the bone marrow.

Detection of minimal residual disease in all: biology, methods, and applications

The PCR technique appears to be the most sensitive method for detecting residual disease in ALL and can be applied to a high percentage of cases by amplifying sequences of the antigen-receptor genes. The PCR studies to date suggest that this sensitive technique can detect residual disease in virtually all patients during the first year of treatment. The residual disease becomes undetectable in the majority of patients by the end of treatment; however, a subset of patients remain PCR positive at a time when therapy is electively discontinued. The development of a highly accurate quantitative PCR technique may allow the possibility of distinguishing the patterns of residual disease for patients who will be cured by treatment from those who relapse. If such a pattern can be discerned, then an immediate benefit for PCR monitoring will be that clinicians will have the opportunity to test whether treating patients at the time of 'molecular relapse' will help to improve the cure rate for this disease. The PCR studies of remission marrows at the end of treatment raise a number of questions about the biology of disease persistence in patients who remain in extended 'remission.' A commitment to obtaining and analyzing bone marrow specimens in patients who have completed therapy is necessary to discern whether novel strategies, such as immunomodulatory manipulations, are needed to control or eradicated residual disease in patients who have completed planned chemotherapy. Thus, the long-term benefit of residual disease monitoring by PCR may be a better understanding of the biology and definition of 'cure' in ALL.

Leukemia-associated changes identified by quantitative flow cytometry: I. CD10 expression

We have compared CD10 antigen expression in normal fetal bone marrow with that of B-linage acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Both quantitative indirect immunofluoresence (QIFI) and direct immunofluorescence (IF) tests with Quantum beads were used to convert median fluorescence intensity (MFI) values into numbers of antigen molecules expressed per cell (AgE). Lymphoid precursors in the fetal marrow and liver expressed 3-12.5 x 10(3) CD10 molecules/cell with an upper limit of 5 x 10(4)/cell (MaxAgE). The median CD10 AgE in the different cases of acute B-lineage ALL were variable and ranged from undetectable to very high values (> 1.8 x 10(5). In 24 of the 72 cases (33%) tested with QIFI the median CD10 AgE was above the highest values seen in normal samples (> 5 x 10(4)/cell). An additional 23.6% of cases had higher median values than the normal median CD10 AgE. Next, CD10 antigen was quantitated in 78 cases during the routine multiparameter analysis of B-lineage leukemia using CD10/class II/CD34 3-color IF test or CD10/TdT 2-color IF test. The aberrant overexpression was confirmed in 43.6% of ALL cases. The CD10bright display suggested ALL diagnosis even when few cells were available for study, e.g., in early relapse and in ALL masquerading as aplastic anemia. The levels of CD10 expression were maintained in relapse. In addition, different CD10 levels were associated with the various chromosomal alterations: high CD10 levels (> 3 x 10(4)/cell) with hyperdiploidy, low CD10 levels (1.8-4 x 10(3)/cell) with the t(1;19) and undetectable levels (< 1.2 x 10(3)/cell) with the t(4;11) translocations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Monitoring minimal residual disease in acute leukemia: expectations, possibilities and initial clinical results

Therapy of acute leukemia may be improved by a more accurate assessment of the effects of treatment on tumor burden and by anticipating relapse with greater precision. The sensitivity limit of assessing residual disease by morphology is usually 5%. Several alternative approaches are available to study minimal residual disease, defined as the presence of leukemic cells not detectable by morphology. These include studies of chromosomal abnormalities by conventional karyotyping, flow cytometry, in situ hybridization and polymerase chain reaction (PCR), investigation of gene rearrangements by Southern blotting and PCR, and immunological methods. Some of these techniques enable the detection of 1 leukemic cells among 10,000 or more normal cells. In the following, the advantages and limitations of sensitive methods for detecting small numbers of leukemic cells are reviewed. The rationale for monitoring residual disease in acute leukemia and the initial results of studies correlating minimal residual disease and clinical outcome are discussed.

Applications of cytometry to study acute leukemia: in vitro determination of drug sensitivity and detection of minimal residual disease

Modern clinical applications of cytometry include the determination of the most powerful antileukemic drugs in each patient at the time of diagnosis and the monitoring of residual disease during and off treatment. The precision of in vitro assays to test the susceptibility of cancer cells to cytotoxic drugs depends on the ability to maintain the cells' viability in culture. We found that bone marrow-derived allogeneic stromal cells are critical to prevent death by apoptosis of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) cells. Thus, we devised an in vitro drug sensitivity assay in which ALL cells are seeded onto stromal cells and viable leukemic cells are counted at the end of cultures by flow cytometry. Our preliminary results indicate that this assay is suitable for evaluating the drug sensitivity of leukemic lymphoblasts and testing the antileukemic activity of potentially effective compounds which have not yet been administered to patients with ALL. The identification of immunophenotypes expressed on leukemic cells but absent or extremely rare among normal hematopoietic progenitors allows close monitoring of the effects of drug treatment in vivo. Phenotypes that afford a detection level of 1 leukemic cell among 10,000 normal bone marrow cells have been identified in 90% of cases of T-ALL, 25% of B-lineage ALL, and 40% of acute myeloid leukemia (AML). In several studies, residual disease emerging during continuation therapy or off treatment almost invariably anticipated overt relapse by 1-7 months. These data indicate the reliability of immunologic techniques to detect occult leukemia.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Detection of residual leukemia with immunologic methods: technical developments and clinical implications

The identification of immunophenotypes expressed on leukemic cells but rare or absent during normal hematopoiesis allows close monitoring of residual leukemia after treatment. Phenotypes that afford a detection level of 1 leukemic cell among 10,000 normal bone marrow cells have been identified in 90% of cases of T-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukemia (T-ALL), 25% of B lineage ALL and 40% of acute myeloid leukemia (AML). Residual disease detected with immunologic techniques in patients with acute leukemia during continuation therapy or off treatment usually anticipates overt relapse. While these data indicate the reliability of these techniques, further studies with homogeneously treated cohorts of patients, currently underway, are needed to precisely define the clinical significance of detecting occult leukemia at different points during treatment. The proportion of patients that can be studied with immunologic methods may increase through the definition of new leukemia-associated phenotypes using existing antibodies. In addition, new useful phenotypes may be identified through a) the development of novel techniques that allow cell permeabilization with preservation of surface membrane molecules and light-scattering properties; b) the generation of new antibodies that recognize leukemia-associated antigens.