The Drug Shortage Crisis in the United States: Impact on Cancer Pharmaceutical Safety

Clinical review of substitutions or alternatives for critical chemotherapy drug shortages in hematologic malignancies

PURPOSE

Over the past decade, drug shortages have become increasingly more problematic for clinicians, with over 300 drug shortages reported in the first quarter of 2023. Shortages of chemotherapy drugs can have a negative impact on patient care, as omission or delay of treatment can lead to worse outcomes. Although many articles have been published on this topic, currently no review articles discuss strategies for using alternative regimens or substitutions in the event of severe chemotherapy drug shortages.

SUMMARY

In this article, we review the literature on antineoplastic agents used to treat hematologic malignancies that experienced a drug shortage from 2010 through 2023, providing recommendations for substitutions and alternative regimens in the event of a critical shortage. In particular, we discuss how shortages of fludarabine, cytarabine, daunorubicin, methotrexate, and platinum agents may be addressed, including supporting clinical evidence.

CONCLUSION

Further publications assessing possible alternatives and substitutions for chemotherapy agents and examining the efficacy of previous strategies are needed to mitigate potentially devastating interruptions to care for patients with cancer during severe drug shortages.

Experience of Pharmacists with Anti-Cancer Medicine Shortages in Pakistan: Results of a Qualitative Study

This study aimed to examine the current situation of anti-cancer drug shortages in Pakistan, namely its determinants, impacts, adopted mitigation strategies, and proposed solutions. Qualitative semi-structured, in-depth interviews were conducted with 25 pharmacists in oncology hospitals in Pakistan from August to October 2021. Data were collected in person and online, recorded, and subjected to inductive thematic analysis after being transcribed verbatim. Most participants experienced anti-cancer drug shortages that increased during the pandemic. Etoposide, paclitaxel, vincristine, dacarbazine, and methotrexate were frequently short. Important causes included the compromised role of regulatory authorities, lack of local production, and inventory mismanagement. The impacts were delayed/suboptimal treatment and out-of-pocket costs for patients, patients' prioritization, increased workload, negative work environment, and patients' trust issues for pharmacists. The participants proposed that a cautious regulator's role is needed to revise policies for all stakeholders and support all stakeholders financially at their level to increase access to these medicines. Based on the outcomes, it is clear that anti-cancer medicine shortages are a current issue in Pakistan. Governmental authorities need to play a role in revising policies for all levels of the drug supply chain and promoting local production of these drugs. Stakeholders should also collaborate and manage inventory.

Anti-cancer medicine shortages in an oncology tertiary hospital of Pakistan: A five-year retrospective study

OBJECTIVE

Anti-cancer medicine shortages are advancing challenges for patients and hospitals. This study aims to evaluate anti-cancer and supportive medicine shortages in a tertiary hospital in Pakistan and propose solutions.

METHOD

A retrospective observational research was performed in a tertiary care hospital in Pakistan from 2016 to 2020. Data was retrieved from the hospital database using a questionnaire regarding short medicines' generic name, brand, dosage, source, total source, frequency, causes, impact, management, and analyzed by Microsoft Excel 2013.

RESULTS

Between January 2016 and December 2020, 43 individual medicine shortages were observed, with an average of 8.6 shortages per year. There were shortages of 22 medicines, including 8 anti-cancer (36.4%) and 14 supportive agents (63.6%). Total shortage days were 27,100, with an average of 1232 days (SD 757) per medicine. Supportive medicines' shortages were frequent, but oncology agents' shortages were constant. The most affected dosage form was injection. Cardiovascular drugs and alkylating agents were the most affected class in supportive and anti-cancer medicines, respectively. The use of "alternative medicine" and "patient needs based importation" were the most common mitigation strategies.

CONCLUSION

Shortages of oncology medicines are challenging in Pakistan. The most prominent causes are the lack of updated governmental regulations, registration, and import issues. The tertiary care hospital has very few sources of supply, so it imports these drugs on a need basis to manage the shortages. But it is still concerning because of the huge financial burden on patients and institutions due to expensive import, and therapy become delayed as the import process takes time. Moreover, the most affected drug class was alkylating agents, and dosage was both injectable and oral medicines.

Exploring the barriers related to the healthcare system in implementing quality intravenous chemotherapy: a qualitative study

PURPOSE

This study aimed to explore barriers related to the healthcare system (HCS) in implementing quality intravenous (IV) chemotherapy (CT) from the perspectives of cancer patients, family caregivers, and healthcare professionals (HCPs).

METHODS

Using an explanatory descriptive qualitative method, this study was conducted in 2019. Forty-one participants (6 patients, 5 family caregivers, 12 oncologists, and 18 nurses) were selected through purposive sampling. In-depth semi-structured interviews and field notes were conducted to collect the data, which were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. Lincoln and Guba's criteria of rigor were employed to ensure the trustworthiness of the study.

RESULTS

Data analysis showed two categories, each with three subcategories: barriers related to healthcare professionals (HCPs) comprised of "educational and communication barriers," "failure to establish trust," and "unskilled healthcare professionals"; barriers related to the health care system management (HCSM), which consists of "inadequate physical and care infrastructures to provide services," "lack of support in the disease trajectory from diagnosis to rehabilitation," and "mismanagement of CT wards/procedures."

CONCLUSION

The identification and removal of the barriers related to HCPs and HCSM in routine care are crucial. Education of and communication with cancer patients and their family caregivers are two important pillars in the quality of intravenous chemotherapy (IV CT) and this education and communication should be based on individualized care and tailored to the unique needs of each patient.

Patients perspectives on drug shortages in six European hospital settings - a cross sectional study

Background

It is known that drug shortages represent a major challenge for all stakeholders involved in the process, but there is little evidence regarding insights into patients′ awareness and perspectives. This study aimed to investigate the patients-perceived drug shortages experience and their view on outcomes in different European hospital settings. Furthermore, we wanted to explore information preferences on drug shortages.

Methods

A retrospective, cross sectional, a mixed method study was conducted in six European hospital settings. One hospital (H) from each of this country agreed to participate: Bosnia and Herzegovina (H-BiH), Croatia (H-CR), Germany (H-GE), Greece (H-GR), Serbia (H-SE) and Poland (H-PO). Recruitment and data collection was conducted over 27 months from November 2017 until January 2020. Overall, we surveyed 607 patients which completed paper-based questionnaire. Questions related to: general information (demographic data), basic knowledge on drug shortages, drug shortages experienced during hospitalization and information preferences on drug shortage. Differences between hospital settings were analyzed using Chi-squared test or Fisher’s exact test. For more complex contingency tables, Monte Carlo simulations (N = 2000) were applied for Fisher’s test. Post-hoc hospital-wise analyses were performed using Fisher’s exact tests. False discovery rate was controlled using the Bonferroni method. Analyses were performed using R: a language and environment for statistical computing (v 3.6.3).

Results

6 % of patients reported experiences with drug shortages while hospitalized which led to a deterioration of their health. The majority of affected patients were hospitalized at hematology and/or oncology wards in H-BiH, H-PO and H-GE. H-BiH had the highest number of affected patients (18.1 %, N = 19/105, p < 0.001) while the fewest patients were in H-SE (1 %, N = 1/100, p = 0.001). In addition, 82.5 %, (N = 501/607) of respondents wanted to be informed of alternative treatment options if there was a drug shortage without a generic substitute available. Majority of these patients (66.4 %, N = 386/501) prefer to be informed by a healthcare professional.

Conclusions

Although drug shortages led to serious medical consequences, our findings show that most of the patients did not perceive shortages as a problem. One possible interpretation is that good hospital management practices by healthcare professionals helped to mitigate the perceived impact of shortages. Our study highlights the importance of a good communication especially between patients and healthcare professionals in whom our patients have the greatest trust.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12913-021-06721-9.

Retrospective cohort analysis of prescription patterns of cancer medications during periods of drug stockouts in Botswana

OBJECTIVE

Cancer drug stockouts occur at high frequencies globally, however, their effects on treatment are understudied in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). We aimed to determine whether causes of suboptimal cancer treatment prescriptions differed between periods of stockout and full treatment supply.

DESIGN

A retrospective cohort study of systemic therapy prescriptions for patients diagnosed with the twelve most common solid tumour cancers treated in 2016.

SETTING

Princess Marina Hospital in Gaborone, Botswana.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients in the retrospective cohort who experienced any suboptimal treatment events, defined as ≥7 days delay or switch from guideline-concordant initiated therapy.

PRIMARY AND SECONDARY OUTCOME MEASURES

Frequency of delays and patterns of prescription changes for specific regimens and cancer types.

RESULTS

167/378 patients contributed to 320 suboptimal events (115 therapy switches, 167 delays and 38 events with both), over 1452 total chemotherapy cycles received. Events during stockout were 43% delays, 43% switches and 14% both during stockout periods and 67.2% delays, 24.4% switches and 8.4% both during non-stockout periods (p<0.001). Majority of switches involved de-escalation of initially prescribed guideline-recommended regimens in patients with breast cancer, Kaposi sarcoma and patients with colorectal cancer, which occurred more frequently during periods of drug stockouts. Among patients with breast cancer, substitution of docetaxel for paclitaxel event occurred exclusively during paclitaxel drug stockout. Delays of ≥7 days events were most frequent in breast cancer patients receiving paclitaxel during stockout, and combination doxorubicin and cyclophosphamide even during periods of non-stockout.

CONCLUSIONS

The aetiology of suboptimal events differed during stockout and non-stockout periods. Prescription patterns that involved de-escalation of initiated therapy and substitution of paclitaxel with docetaxel occurred frequently during periods of drug stockout. Further research needs to be conducted to understand the impact of stockout on survival and barriers to maintaining essential cancer medicines supplies in SSA, and the factors driving frequent delays in therapy delivery.

Opportunities for changes in the drug product design to enhance medication safety in older people: Evaluation of a national public portal for medication incidents

AIMS

Medication safety requires urgent attention in hospital pharmacy. This study evaluated the medication-related problems/errors as reported to the Dutch medication incident registry and disseminated for information to pharmacists. Through analysis by an expert panel we aimed to better understand which problems could have been mitigated by the drug product design. Additionally, the (wider) implications of the problems for current hospital/clinical practice were discussed.

METHODS

Items were extracted from the public Portal for Patient Safety. Items were included if relevant for older people and connected with the drug product design and excluded if they should reasonably have been intercepted by compliance to routine controls or well-known professional standards in pharmaceutical care. To explore any underreporting of well-known incidents, it was investigated if different medication-related problems could be observed in a regional hospital practise over a 1-month period. For 6 included items (cases), the implications for hospital/clinical practise were discussed in an expert panel.

RESULTS

In total, 307 items were identified in the Portal for Patient Safety; all but 14 were excluded. Six cases were added from daily hospital practice. These 20 cases commonly related to confusing product characteristics, packaging issues such as the lack of a single unit package for an oncolytic product, or incorrect or incomplete user instructions.

CONCLUSION

Medication registries provide important opportunities to evaluate real-world medication-related problems. However, underreporting of well-known problems should be considered. The product design can be used as an (additional) risk mitigation measure to support medication safety in hospital practice.

The added value of clinical radiopharmacists in nuclear medicine: The example of glomerular filtration rate assessment in kidney donors

WHAT IS KNOWN AND OBJECTIVES

In Europe, the pharmaceutical supply of chromium-51 has been stopped. However, this isotope is necessary for the evaluation of glomerular filtration rates. It is possible to replace it with technetium-99m, but the validation of this change in the measurement method must be carried out.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of chromium-51 data from January 2018 to January 2019 was performed, followed by a study from January 2019 to January 2020 using the technetium tracer. The patients were different in the both study groups, and none had an eGFR below 50 mL min^-1 . A cost analysis was performed. Patient exposure to ionizing radiation was studied for both methods.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Seventy-eight patients were included in the study. In total, 42 EDTA-⁵¹ Cr and 36 DTPA-^99m Tc examinations were conducted and compared. There were no significant differences between the methods used to assess renal function (P = .351). The results of cost analysis and patient radiation exposure were in favour of DTPA-^99m Tc examinations.

WHAT IS NEW AND CONCLUSION

Within the limitations of a retrospective study of two patient cohorts, there was no significant difference between the results obtained with chromium-51 and technetium-99m tracers. In addition, with the use of DTPA-^99m Tc, operating costs and patient exposure to ionizing radiation were reduced, and clinical activity was maintained for the patients' benefit. Radiopharmacists are able to react quickly to supply contingencies, reduce operating costs and maintain the quality of medical examinations.

Outcomes of a drug shortage requiring switching in patients with ulcerative colitis

BACKGROUND

Drug shortages are common yet their impact on patient care and their commercial ramifications has not been adequately researched. In Australia a shortage of balsalazide (2012-2013) necessitated substitution with alternative 5-aminosalicylate (5-ASA) formulations for ulcerative colitis (UC).

AIM

To assess and compare the clinical and commercial sequelae of non-medical switching from balsalazide to another 5-ASA and/or return to balsalazide once supply resumed.

METHODS

A prospective cohort study of patients on balsalazide for mild-moderate UC was conducted where, strictly due to the national shortage (November 2012- January 2013), were switched to alternative 5-ASA and/or then returned to balsalazide once supply resumed. Clinical (Partial Mayo), endoscopic (Mayo score) activity, adverse effects (to alternative 5-ASA) and percentage market share (of continuous 5-ASA users) from baseline (i.e., time of switching due to shortage) through to five years were assessed.

RESULTS

Of 31 patients switched due to the shortage, 12 (38.7%) resumed balsalazide immediately once supply resumed, 8 (25.8%) prompted by adverse effects to the alternative 5-ASA used. Three patients (9.7%) had documented symptomatic improvement, 15 (48.4%) were unchanged and 13 (41.9%) had symptomatic worsening vs baseline (P < 0.01), after switching to an alternative 5-ASA. At 3 and 5y post switch, overall 26/31 (83.9%) and 23/31 (74.2%) had remained continuously on any 5-ASA therapy respectively. Twelve (38.7%) and 11 (35.5%) patients remained on balsalazide continuously at three and five years respectively after drug supply returned, equating to a loss of market share (within 5-ASA class) of 45.2% and 38.7% respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study of a balsalazide shortage in UC patients exemplifies the detrimental impact of a drug shortage on long term patient, disease and commercial outcomes.

The oral health status, behaviours and knowledge of patients with cardiovascular disease in Sydney Australia: a cross-sectional survey

BACKGROUND

Periodontal disease is a risk factor for atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease and it is recommended internationally that patients with cardiovascular disease should engage in preventative oral health practices and attend regular dental care visits. This study aimed to explore the oral health status, behaviours and knowledge of patients with cardiovascular disease.

METHODS

A cross-sectional questionnaire containing 31 items was administered to patients with cardiovascular disease from cardiac rehabilitation and outpatient clinics in Sydney Australia in 2016-2017.

RESULTS

Of the 318 patients surveyed, 81.1% reported having at least one oral health problem. Over a third (41.2%) of participants had not seen a dentist in the preceding 12 months and 10.7% had received any oral healthcare information in the cardiac setting. Those with valvular conditions were more likely to have received information compared to those with other cardiovascular conditions (40.6% versus 7.4%, p < 0.001). Only half of the participants had adequate oral health knowledge.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite a high incidence of reported oral health problems, many patients lacked knowledge about oral health, were not receiving oral health information from cardiac care providers and had difficulty accessing dental services. Further research is needed to develop oral health strategies in this area.