Structural, Thermodynamic and Kinetic Studies of the Interaction of Eσ70 RNA Polymerase with Promoter DNA. In: Eckstein F, Lilley DMJ, editors. Nucleic Acids and Molecular Biology 4. Berlin: Springer Berlin Heidelberg; 1990. pp. 123-51. [DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-84150-7_8]

Protein-DNA recognition complexes: conservation of structure and binding energy in the transition state

This paper considers how enzymes that catalyze reactions at specific DNA sites have been engineered to overcome the problem of competitive inhibition by excess nonspecific binding sites on DNA. The formation of a specific protein-DNA recognition complex is discussed from both structural and thermodynamic perspectives, and contrasted with formation of nonspecific complexes. Evidence (from EcoRI and BamHI endonucleases) is presented that a wide variety of perturbations of the DNA substrate alter binding free energy but do not affect the free energy of activation for the chemical step; that is, many energetic factors contribute equally to the recognition complex and the transition-state complex. This implies that the specific recognition complex bears a close resemblance to the transition-state complex, such that very tight binding to the recognition site on the DNA substrate does not inhibit catalysis, but instead provides energy that is efficiently utilized along the path to the transition state. It is suggested that this view can be usefully extended to "noncatalytic" site-specific DNA-binding proteins like transcriptional activators and general transcription factors.

Changes in the 17 bp spacer in the P(R) promoter of bacteriophage lambda affect steps in open complex formation that precede DNA strand separation

Tau plots and temperature-shift experiments were used to determine which step in the formation of transcriptionally-competent open complexes is affected by changing the length of the 17 bp spacer separating the -10 and -35 consensus regions of the P(R) promoter of bacteriophage lambda. Abortive initiation assays at 37 degrees C indicate that the primary effect of insertion of a base-pair, thereby increasing spacer length to 18 bp, is a decrease in k(f), the rate constant for conversion from closed (RP(c)) to open (RP(o)) complexes, by approximately a factor of 4. The mutation did not significantly affect K(B), the equilibrium constant for formation of closed complexes, and decreased K(B)k(f) by a factor of 3. Deletion of a bp to create a 16 bp spacer had a much greater effect, decreasing the measured value of k(f) by a factor of about 25 to 30, and K(B)k(f) by a factor of 7 to 8. When the values of the parameters for the deletion mutant were corrected for incomplete occupancy of RP(o) at equilibrium, the effects of the deletion were even greater. In particular, the corrected value of K(B)k(f) was about 15 times lower than the corresponding value for two promoters with wild-type spacing. Based on temperature shift experiments, the changes in spacer length did not affect the equilibrium at 20 degrees C between RP(i), a stable intermediate in which DNA strands are not separated, and RP(o). Although differential sensitivity of single-stranded bases to KMnO(4) indicated that in about 20% of the open complexes at 20 degrees C the DNA strands are not fully separated (RP(o1)), the distribution between these complexes and RP(o2) (DNA strands fully separated) was also not affected significantly by changes in spacer length. Thus, changes in spacer length primarily affect k(2), the rate constant for conversion of RP(c) to RP(i), which corresponds to a nucleation of DNA strand-separation. Application of published data and/or algorithms for determining effects of nucleotide sequence on twist angle or rise at individual bp steps does not provide a simple explanation of the difference in promoter strength between P(R) derivatives with 16 bp spacing and those with 18 bp spacing.

Direct observation of one-dimensional diffusion and transcription by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

The dynamics of nonspecific and specific Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP)-DNA complexes have been directly observed using scanning force microscopy operating in buffer. To this end, imaging conditions had to be found in which DNA molecules were adsorbed onto mica strongly enough to be imaged, but loosely enough to be able to diffuse on the surface. In sequential images of nonspecific complexes, RNAP was seen to slide along DNA, performing a one-dimensional random walk. Heparin, a substance known to disrupt nonspecific RNAP-DNA interactions, prevented sliding. These observations suggest that diffusion of RNAP along DNA constitutes a mechanism for accelerated promoter location. Sequential images of single, transcribing RNAP molecules were also investigated. Upon addition of 5 microM nucleoside triphosphates to stalled elongation complexes in the liquid chamber, RNAP molecules were seen to processively thread their template at rates of 1.5 nucleotide/s in a direction consistent with the promoter orientation. Transcription assays, performed with radiolabeled, mica-bound transcription complexes, confirmed this rate, which was about three times smaller than the rate of complexes in solution. This assay also showed that the pattern of pause sites and the termination site were affected by the surface. By using the Einstein-Sutherland friction-diffusion relation the loading force experienced by RNAP due to DNA-surface friction is estimated and discussed.

Architecture of a complex between the sigma70 subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase and the nontemplate strand oligonucleotide. Luminescence resonance energy transfer study

We used luminescence energy transfer measurements to determine the localization of 5'- and 3'-ends of a 12-nucleotide nontemplate strand oligonucleotide bound to sigma70 holoenzyme. Five single reactive cysteine mutants of sigma70 (cysteine residues at positions 1, 59, 366, 442, and 596) were labeled with a europium chelate fluorochrome (donor). The oligonucleotide was modified at the 5'- or at the 3'-end with Cy5 fluorochrome (acceptor). The energy transfer was observed upon complex formation between the donor-labeled sigma70 holoenzyme and the acceptor-labeled nontemplate strand oligonucleotide, whereas no interaction was observed with the template strand oligonucleotide. The oligonucleotide was bound in one preferred orientation. This observation together with the sequence specificity of single-stranded oligonucleotide interaction suggests that two mechanisms of discrimination between the template and nontemplate strand are used by sigma70: sequence specificity and strand polarity specificity. The bound oligonucleotide was found to be close to residue 442, confirming that the single-stranded DNA binding site of sigma70 is located in an alpha-helix containing residue 442. The 5'-end of the oligonucleotide was oriented toward the COOH terminus of the helix.

DNA-melting at the Bacillus subtilis flagellin promoter nucleates near -10 and expands unidirectionally

A central step in promoter activation by RNA polymerase (RNAP) is the localized separation of the DNA strands to form the transcription bubble. We have used potassium permanganate footprinting to monitor DNA strand-separation by the Bacillus subtilis sigmaD RNAP at the strong promoter, Phag, directing transcription of flagellin. The susceptibility of individual thymine bases to permanganate oxidation is influenced by temperature, Mg2+, nucleotides, and the RNAP delta subunit. In the absence of delta, sigmaD RNAP establishes a partially opened complex even at 0 degrees C with permanganate reactivity localized between -11 and -4 (RP(-4)). The region of strand separation expands to near -1 at 20 degrees C (RP(-1)) and to +3 at 40 degrees C (RP(+3)). The delta subunit inhibits the downstream propagation of the transcription bubble and thereby increases the concentration of early intermediates in the melting pathway. Indeed, E delta sigmaD forms a distinct nucleated complex (RPn) at 0 degrees C with a structural distortion localized to an AT base step within the -10 element. We propose a model for promoter melting in which strand separation nucleates within the conserved -10 consensus and subsequently propagates downstream. Mg2+ and nucleoside triphosphates (NTPs) favor the downstream propagation of the transcription bubble and strongly stimulate the RP(-1) to RP(+3) conversion. The NTP effects are apparently mediated by binding of substrate to the initiating NTP site: purines are more effective than pyrimidines and GMP alone can greatly increase the level of DNA-melting. The binding of substrates, but not Mg2+ alone, can effectively overcome the anti-melting effect of delta.

The bacterial enhancer-binding protein NTRC is a molecular machine: ATP hydrolysis is coupled to transcriptional activation

NTRC is a prokaryotic enhancer-binding protein that activates transcription by sigma 54-holoenzyme. NTRC has an ATPase activity that is required for transcriptional activation, specifically for isomerization of closed complexes between sigma 54-holoenzyme and a promoter to open complexes. In the absence of ATP hydrolysis, there is known to be a kinetic barrier to open complex formation (i.e., the reaction proceeds so slowly that the polymerase synthesizes essentially no transcripts even from a supercoiled template). We show here that open complex formation is also thermodynamically unfavorable. In the absence of ATP hydrolysis the position of equilibrium between closed and open complexes favors the closed ones. Use of linear templates with a region of heteroduplex around the transcriptional start site--"preopened" templates--does not bypass the requirement for either NTRC or ATP hydrolysis, providing evidence that the rate-limiting step in open complex formation does not lie in DNA strand denaturation per se. These results are in contrast to recent findings regarding the ATP requirement for initiation of transcription by eukaryotic RNA polymerase II; in the latter case, the ATP requirement is circumvented by use of a supercoiled plasmid template or a preopened linear template.

Open complex formation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase: the mechanism of polymerase-induced strand separation of double helical DNA

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase is able to site-specifically melt 12 bp of promoter DNA at temperatures far below those normally associated with DNA melting. Here we consider several models to explain how RNA polymerase destabilizes duplex DNA. One popular model proposes that upon binding to the promoter, RNA polymerase untwists the spacer DNA between the -10 and -35 regions, which results in a destabilization of the -10 region at a TA base step where melting initiates. Promoter untwisting may result, in part, from extensive wrapping of the DNA around RNA polymerase. Formation of the strand-separated open complex appears to be facilitated by specific protein-DNA interactions which occur predominantly on the non-template strand. Recent evidence suggests that these include important contacts with sigma factor region 2.3, which we propose binds the displaced single strand of DNA.

The bacteriophage T4 middle promoter PuvsX: analysis of regions important for binding of the T4 transcriptional activator MotA and for activation of transcription

Bacteriophage T4 middle promoters, which are transcribed using phage-modified host RNA polymerase and the T4 transcriptional activator, MotA, match the host sigma 70 consensus sequence at -10, but they have a different consensus ((t/a)(t/a)TGCTT(t/c)A) (a MotA box) at -30. While the T4 middle promoter PuvsX has these -10 and -30 motifs, it also has matches to the MotA box at -35, -51, -70, and -87. We show that MotA binds to PuvsX DNA, footprinting a region that includes the MotA boxes at -30, -35, and -51. Very high levels of MotA are required for footprinting and gel-shift experiments, and protein-DNA complexes formed in the presence of both phage-modified polymerase and MotA are more resistant to HindIII cleavage than those formed with either protein alone. These results suggest that MotA-DNA interactions may be stabilized by phage-modified polymerase. Sequences between -18 and -38 are absolutely required for MotA activation of transcription, but sequences upstream of -38 are stimulatory, particularly when chloride instead of glutamate is the major anion. Our results dissect PuvsX into a core promoter, downstream of -38, which is required for MotA activation, and an upstream region that enhances transcription especially under conditions less favourable for protein-DNA interactions.

Two open complexes and a requirement for Mg2+ to open the lambda PR transcription start site

Potassium permanganate (KMnO4) footprinting in the absence and presence of magnesium (Mg2+) at the lambda PR promoter identified two different open complexes with Escherichia coli E sigma 70 RNA polymerase (designated RPo1 and RPo2). The single-stranded region in RPo1 (formed in the absence of Mg2+) was at most 12 bases long, whereas that in RPo2 (formed in the presence of Mg2+) spanned at least 14 bases. Only in RPo2 did the single-stranded region extend to the start point of transcription (+1, +2). These results provide a structural basis for the requirement for uptake of Mg2+ in the formation of RPo2 from RPo1, as deduced from kinetic studies at this promoter.

Upstream curved sequences influence the initiation of transcription at the Escherichia coli galactose operon

The two overlapping promoters that control mRNA synthesis at the galactose operon contain three phased stretches of adenine residues, located around positions -84.5, -74 and -63, with respect ot the start of the P1 promoter. As a result, the corresponding DNA sequence is bent, an anomaly that is relieved by the addition of small concentrations of drugs like distamycin A or netropsin. By abortive initiation assays performed on several DNA fragments derived from the wild-type promoter or from various mutants we show that the curved sequence increases the strength of the P1 promoter. In the absence of cyclic AMP (cAMP) and of the corresponding receptor protein (CRP), the upstream curved sequences enhance the rate of isomerization from the closed to the open complex at P1. This effect is abolished when distamycin A is bound in the bent region. In the presence of cAMP-CRP, a more drastic change is observed: activation of the gal P1 promoter takes place at a different formal step, depending whether the upstream curved sequence is present or not (enhancement of the rate of conversion from a closed to an open complex instead of an increase in the affinity of the enzyme during closed complex formation). These data, together with previous results obtained with other mutants of the gal control region, suggest that several closed complexes corresponding to different nucleoprotein arrangements are formed during open complex formation at gal P1, in the presence of CRP.

Factor-independent activation of Escherichia coli rRNA transcription. II. characterization of complexes of rrnB P1 promoters containing or lacking the upstream activator region with Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

A region upstream from the Escherichia coli rrnB P1 promoter, the upstream activator region (UAR), increases the activity of the promoter in vivo and the rate of association with RNA polymerase (E sigma 70) in vitro in the presence of the two initiating nucleotides. We have used four types of chemical and enzymatic footprinting probes to determine whether rrnB P1-E sigma 70 complexes formed in the presence of the initiating nucleotides (RPinit) differ from typical open complexes (RPo) formed in the absence of the initiating nucleotides and to examine the structural differences between rrnB P1 complexes containing the UAR and those lacking the UAR. We find that the rrnB P1-RPinit complex closely resembles open complexes formed at other E sigma 70 promoters, indicating that the formation of the first phosphodiester bond does not result in a major rearrangement of the promoter-RNA polymerase complex. An unusual potassium permanganate modification at position -18 in both RPo and RPinit indicates the possible presence of a subtle difference in the -10, -35 spacer structure compared to some other E. coli promoters. We show that the E sigma 70-rrnB P1 complex formed with the promoter containing the UAR has DNase I and hydroxyl radical cleavage patterns in the -50 region different from those observed with the same promoter lacking the UAR. These results are interpreted to indicate that E sigma 70 may interact with a region further upstream from that contacted by RNA polymerase bound at most other promoters and/or that unusual structural properties of this region are induced by bound E sigma 70.