Testing for interlocus genetic exchange in the MHC: a reply to Andersson and co-workers

Mhc-DRB and -DQA1 nucleotide sequences of three lowland gorillas. Implications for the evolution of primate Mhc class II haplotypes

Mhc-DRB and -DQA1 second-exon and -DRB 3'-untranslated-region nucleotide sequences of three lowland gorillas with no known family relationship with each other and of two HLA homozygous typing cell lines were determined and compared with published primate Mhc-DRB and -DQA1 sequences. Eleven distinct MhcGogo-DRB second-exon sequences were found, which represent the gorilla counterparts of the HLA-DRB1*03, -DRB1*10, -DRB3, -DRB5, and -DRB6 allelic lineages. One Gogo-DRB second-exon sequence does not have an obvious human counterpart and is tentatively designated Gogo-DRBY*01. The gorilla equivalents of the HLA-DRB2 and -DRB8 loci were identified as judged on Mhc-DRB 3'-untranslated-region sequences. In addition, four different Gogo-DQA1 alleles belonging to three different allelic lineages were detected. The Mhc-DRB-DQA1 haplotypes of these gorillas were deduced based on the obtained Mhc-DRB and -DQA1 sequences and the two published Mhc-DRB haplotypes of the lowland gorilla Sylvia. All deduced Gogo-DRB-DQA1 haplotypes show gene constellations different from known HLA-DRB-DQA1 haplotypes, while some of the Gogo-DRB haplotypes presented here contain more DRB genes than the HLA-DRB haplotypes. Based on phylogenetic trees, bootstrap analyses, and the gorilla, chimpanzee, and human Mhc-DRB haplotypes described, we propose that at least two Mhc-DRB loci, here tentatively designated Mhc-DRBI and -DRBII, existed on an ancient primate Mhc-DRB haplotype. The Mhc-DRB1*01, -DRB1*02 (-DRB1*15 and -DRB1*16), -DRB1*03 (-DRB1*03, -DRB1*08, -DRB1*11, -DRB1*12, -DRB1*13, and DRB1*14), and -DRB1*10 allelic lineages and -DRB3 and -DRBY loci probably evolved from the hypothetical primate Mhc-DRBI locus, whereas the present primate Mhc-DRB2, -DRB4, and -DRB6 loci originate from the ancient Mhc-DRBII locus of this core primate Mhc-DRB haplotype.

Mhc-DRB diversity of the chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes)

Fifty-four chimpanzee Patr-DRB and five human HLA-DRB second exons were cloned and sequenced from thirty-five chimpanzees and four human B-cell lines and compared with known Mhc-DRB sequences of these two species. Equivalents of the HLA-DRB1*02, -DRB1*03, -DRB1*07 allelic lineages and the HLA-DRB3, -DRB4, -DRB5, -DRB6, and -DRB7 loci were all found in the chimpanzee. In addition, two chimpanzee Patr-DRB lineages (Patr-DRBX and -DRBY) were found for which no human counterparts have been described. None of the Patr-DRB sequences is identical to known HLA-DRB sequences. The Patr-DRB1*0702 and HLA-DRB1*0701 alleles are the most similar sequences in a comparison between the two species and differ by only two nucleotides out of 246 sequenced. Equivalents of the HLA-DRB1*01, -DRB1*04, and -DRB1*09 alleles were not found in our sample of chimpanzees. A per locus comparison of the number of Patr-DRB alleles with the HLA-DRB alleles shows that the Patr-DRB3, -DRB4, -DRB5, and -DRB6 locus are, thus far, more polymorphic than their human homologs. The polymorphism of the Patr-DRB1 locus seems to be less extensive than that reported for the HLA-DRB1 locus. Nevertheless, the Patr-DRB1 locus seems to be the most polymorphic of the Patr-DRB loci. Phylogenetic analyses indicate that the HLA-DRB1*09 allele may have originated from a recombination between a Mhc-DRB5 allele and the DRB1 allele of a Mhc-DR7 haplotype. Although recombination seems to increase the diversity of the Patr-DRB alleles, its contribution to the generation of Patr-DRB variation is probably low. Hence, most Patr-DRB diversity presumably accumulated via recurrent point mutations. Finally, two distinct Patr-DRB haplotypes are deduced, one of which (the chimpanzee equivalent of the HLA-DR7 haplotype) is probably older than 6-8 million years.

Ancestral haplotypes: conserved population MHC haplotypes

We describe here a number of Caucasoid MHC haplotypes that extend from HLA-B to DR and that have been conserved en bloc. These haplotypes and recombinants between any two of them account for 73% of unselected haplotypes in our Caucasoid population. The existence of ancestral haplotypes implies conservation of large chromosomal segments. Irrespective of the mechanisms involved in preservation of ancestral haplotypes, it is clear that these haplotypes carry several MHC genes, other than HLA, which may be relevant to antigen presentation, autoimmune responses, and transplantation rejection. In light of the existence of ancestral haplotypes, it is critical to evaluate MHC associations with disease and transplantation outcome in terms of associations with ancestral haplotypes rather than individual alleles.

Sequence differences between HLA-B and TNF distinguish different MHC ancestral haplotypes

The HLA-B locus is extremely polymorphic. We have sequenced a region, CL, telomeric of HLA-B that also shows a high degree of allelic variation which we have shown previously by RFLP analysis. The polymorphism can be accounted for by sequence variation in duplicated, reiterated sequence elements called geometric elements. Comparison of the CL1 and CL2 sequences from the 57.1, 8.1, 18.2 and 7.1 ancestral haplotypes revealed that the lengths of the elements vary, both between the duplicated loci within a haplotype and between haplotypes, apparently because certain sequences are inserted or deleted. It is possible, using the polymerase chain reaction, to amplify these elements in genomic DNA from ancestral haplotypes for which sequence data of the CL region are not available and to obtain gel patterns which are characteristic of different ancestral haplotypes. The most striking feature of the data is the fact that the majority of the CL patterns are haplospecific; i.e. have a particular pattern that is unique for a particular ancestral haplotype and can be used to type these ancestral haplotypes. At least 12 different allelic patterns have been identified within a panel of 29 cell lines representing 16 ancestral haplotypes. For these 16 ancestral haplotypes, all examples of each haplotype have the same CL pattern. The haplotypic nature of the patterns confirms that ancestral haplotypes are conserved chromosomal segments and that coding and non-coding sequences are identical by descent from a remote ancestor.

Haplospecific polymorphism between HLA B and tumor necrosis factor

Polymorphisms were sought between HLA B and tumor necrosis factor (TNF) using three genomic probes. Extensive polymorphism was detected within a panel of 50 cell lines including 37 homozygotes representing 21 different ancestral haplotypes (AH). Following Taq I digestion of genomic DNA, we observed three allelic patterns with probe X (R17A) and four with probe V (R9A). Seven different allelic patterns were found with probe Y (M20A) after Taq I + Rsa I digestion. Family studies showed that the Y, X, and V alleles were inherited and segregated with HLA haplotypes. A striking feature of the allelic patterns detected by these probes was that cells with the same AH had identical Y, X, and V alleles (i.e., the alleles were haplotypic). Of 15 different Y-X-V haplotypes observed, 11 were found to be specific for a particular AH (i.e., were haplospecific). Four were shared by more than one AH, but in these instances there were extensive similarities in other regions within the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), for example, the Japanese 46.2 (HLA Bw46-DRw8) and the Chinese 46.1 (Bw46-DR9) share all alleles between HLA C and C4 and differ only in class II, suggesting their relatively recent divergence by recombination between C4 and DR. Surprisingly, two insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM)-resistant but race-specific AHs 52.1 (Bw52-DRB1*1502, Japanese) and 7.1 (B7-DRB1*1501, Caucasoid) carry the same Y-X-V haplotype, suggesting the possibility of localizing gene(s) relevant to IDDM. The present study confirms that MHC AHs have been conserved en bloc, including the region between HLA B and TNF.