Dissection of 5' upstream sequences for selective expression of the Nicotiana plumbaginifolia rbcS-8B gene

Enhancer redundancy in development and disease

Shadow enhancers are seemingly redundant transcriptional cis-regulatory elements that regulate the same gene and drive overlapping expression patterns. Recent studies have shown that shadow enhancers are remarkably abundant and control most developmental gene expression in both invertebrates and vertebrates, including mammals. Shadow enhancers might provide an important mechanism for buffering gene expression against mutations in non-coding regulatory regions of genes implicated in human disease. Technological advances in genome editing and live imaging have shed light on how shadow enhancers establish precise gene expression patterns and confer phenotypic robustness. Shadow enhancers can interact in complex ways and may also help to drive the formation of transcriptional hubs within the nucleus. Despite their apparent redundancy, the prevalence and evolutionary conservation of shadow enhancers underscore their key role in emerging metazoan gene regulatory networks.

Regulated genes in transgenic plants

Transgenic plants are an effective system for the study of regulated gene expression. Developmental control of expression can be monitored by assaying different tissues or by assaying a plant at different developmental stages. Analysis of the petunia 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase gene, which is highly expressed in flowers, allowed identification of an upstream region that confers tissue-specific and developmentally regulated expression. The cell specificity of expression in floral tissues has been defined by histochemical localization. This expression is contrasted to that of the 35S promoter of cauliflower mosaic virus, a nominally constitutive promoter that shows a definite specificity of expression in floral tissues. Moreover, this expression differs in transgenic hosts of different species.

Evolutionary hierarchies of conserved blocks in 5'-noncoding sequences of dicot rbcS genes

Background

Evolutionary processes in gene regulatory regions are major determinants of organismal evolution, but exceptionally challenging to study. We explored the possibilities of evolutionary analysis of phylogenetic footprints in 5'-noncoding sequences (NCS) from 27 ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase small subunit (rbcS) genes, from three dicot families (Brassicaceae, Fabaceae and Solanaceae).

Results

Sequences of up to 400 bp encompassing proximal promoter and 5'-untranslated regions were analyzed. We conducted phylogenetic footprinting by several alternative methods: generalized Lempel-Ziv complexity (C_LZ), multiple alignments with DIALIGN and ALIGN-M, and the MOTIF SAMPLER Gibbs sampling algorithm. These tools collectively defined 36 conserved blocks of mean length 12.8 bp. On average, 12.5 blocks were found in each 5'-NCS. The blocks occurred in arrays whose relative order was absolutely conserved, confirming the existence of 'conserved modular arrays' in promoters. Identities of half of the blocks confirmed past rbcS research, including versions of the I-box, G-box, and GT-1 sites such as Box II. Over 90% of blocks overlapped DNase-protected regions in tomato 5'-NCS. Regions characterized by low C_LZ in sliding-window analyses were also frequently associated with DNase-protection. Blocks could be assigned to evolutionary hierarchies based on taxonomic distribution and estimated age. Lineage divergence dates implied that 13 blocks found in all three plant families were of Cretaceous antiquity, while other family-specific blocks were much younger. Blocks were also dated by formation of multigene families, using genome and coding sequence information. Dendrograms of evolutionary relations of the 5'-NCS were produced by several methods, including: cluster analysis using pairwise C_LZ values; evolutionary trees of DIALIGN sequence alignments; and cladistic analysis of conserved blocks.

Conclusion

Dicot 5'-NCS contain conserved modular arrays of recurrent sequence blocks, which are coincident with functional elements. These blocks are amenable to evolutionary interpretation as hierarchies in which ancient, taxonomically widespread blocks can be distinguished from more recent, taxon-specific ones.

Untranslated regions from C4 amaranth AhRbcS1 mRNAs confer translational enhancement and preferential bundle sheath cell expression in transgenic C4 Flaveria bidentis

Many aspects of photosynthetic gene expression are posttranscriptionally regulated in C4 plants. To determine if RbcS mRNA untranslated regions (UTRs) in themselves could confer any characteristic C4 expression patterns, 5'- and 3'-UTRs of AhRbcS1 mRNA from the C4 dicot amaranth were linked to a gusA reporter gene. These were constitutively transcribed from a cauliflower mosaic virus promoter and assayed for posttranscriptional expression patterns in transgenic lines of the C4 dicot Flaveria bidentis. Three characteristic C4 expression patterns were conferred by heterologous AhRbcS1 UTRs in transgenic F. bidentis. First, the AhRbcS1 UTRs conferred strong translational enhancement of gusA expression, relative to control constructs lacking these UTRs. Second, while the UTRs did not appear to confer tissue-specific expression when analyzed by beta-glucuronidase activity assays, differences in gusA mRNA accumulation were observed in leaves, stems, and roots. Third, the AhRbcS1 UTRs conferred preferential gusA expression (enzyme activity and gusA mRNA accumulation) in leaf bundle sheath cells. AhRbcS1 UTR-mediated translational enhancement was also observed in transgenic C3 plants (tobacco [Nicotiana tabacum]) and in in vitro translation extracts. These mRNAs appear to be translated with different efficiencies in C4 versus C3 plants, indicating that processes determining overall translational efficiency may vary between these two categories of higher plants. Our findings suggest that the AhRbcS1 5'-UTR functions as a strong translational enhancer in leaves and other tissues, and may work synergistically with the 3'-UTR to modulate overall levels of Rubisco gene expression in different tissues and cell types of C4 plants.

Repeated sequences from the Arabidopsis thaliana genome function as enhancers in transgenic tobacco

Sixteen segments of Arabidopsis thaliana DNA that function as enhancers in transgenic tobacco plants were isolated using the pROA97 enhancer cloning vehicle and library transformation of Nicotiana tabacum. The sequences were compared for AT content, homology, repeated motifs, and expression pattern in transgenic N. tabacum. The sequences were average with respect to the AT content of A. thaliana DNA. They could be placed into seven homology groups. Five of the sequences are single-copy sequences. The remaining eleven sequences represent two homology groups. Homology Group I contains seven sequences with minor differences. Homology Group II contains four sequences with minor differences. Two repeated motifs were identified (5'-CCTCT-3' and 5'-AAGGAT-3'). Both repeated motifs are found in other plant enhancers, and in the promoter region of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S gene. In the 35S gene TATA region, the motifs can form two alternative stem-loop structures. The TATATAA sequence is located in the loop region of both stem-loop structures.

Analysis of LE-ACS3, a 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid synthase gene expressed during flooding in the roots of tomato plants

The plant hormone ethylene is produced in response to a variety of environmental stresses. Previous work has shown that flooding or anaerobic stress in the roots of tomato plants caused an increase in the production of the ethylene precursor 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) in the roots, due to flooding-induced activity of ACC synthase (EC 4.4.1.14). RNA was extracted from roots and leaves of tomato plants flooded over a period of 48 h. Blot analysis of these RNAs hybridized with probes for four different ACC synthases revealed that the ACC synthase gene LE-ACS3 is rapidly induced in roots. LE-ACS2 is also induced, but at later times. The genomic clone for LE-ACS3 was isolated and sequenced. At all time points, the probe from the LE-ACS3 coding region hybridized to two bands in the RNA blots. Hybridization using the first and third introns of LE-ACS3 separately as probes indicate that flooding may inhibit processing of the LE-ACS3 transcript. Sequence homology analysis identified three putative cis-acting response elements in the promoter region, corresponding to the anaerobic response element from the maize adh1 promoter, the root-specific expression element from the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter and a recognition element for chloroplast DNA binding factor I from the maize chloroplast ATP synthase promoter.

A functional map of the fruit-specific promoter of the tomato 2A11 gene

The 5' region of the fruit-specific tomato gene, 2A11, contains both positive and negative regulatory elements. We divided the 5' promoter region of the 2A11 gene into small fragments, ranging in size from 211 to 634 bp and used these short DNA fragments in in vitro protein-binding studies. These studies revealed the presence of at least four fruit-specific and one leaf- and fruit-active protein-binding domains. These promoter fragments, as well as other overlapping fragments, were tested for their ability to enhance expression from a truncated heterologous promoter in transgenic plants. This analysis showed the presence of four fruit-specific and three general or leaf-active positive regulatory elements. Comparison of the results obtained with these two approaches allowed us to draw a functional map of the 2A11 promoter.

Genes encoding the small subunit of RUBISCO belong to two highly conserved subfamilies in Nicotianeae

The sequences of seven complementary DNAs or genes encoding the small subunit (SSU) of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase oxygenase (RUBISCO) in several Nicotianeae were examined. Two new SSU genes isolated from Nicotiana sylvestris were included. Both sequence comparisons and Southern analyses with specific probes reveal that SSU genes fall into two homogeneous subfamilies that are highly conserved in Nicotianeae and are also present in other Solanaceae. Additional criteria such as number of introns and level of expression fitted to this classification. Homogeneity must have been maintained by gene conversion and/or an unusually high fidelity of DNA replication, whereas traces of slippage-stranded DNA mispairing and/or transposition probably explain local changes. Taken as a whole, these results show that the divergence between the two subfamilies predated the divergence between genera inside the Solanaceae, but that Nicotianeae retained the most simple SSU gene family structure.

Cloning and chromosomal mapping of nuclear genes encoding chloroplast and cytosolic glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate-dehydrogenase from Arabidopsis thaliana

Both cDNA and genomic clones for the nuclear genes encoding chloroplast (cp) (gapA and gapB) and cytosolic (gapC) glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) from Arabidopsis thaliana have been isolated and characterized. Genomic Southern-blot analyses indicate that there is only one copy of each gapA, gapB and gapC gene in A. thaliana. Comparison of the deduced amino acid (aa) sequences shows that the A and B subunits are highly similar (80% positional aa identity), while there is less similarity between the cp and cytosolic subunits (45% aa identity). These relationships are consistent with the idea that the cp and cytosolic GAPDHs evolved from different lineages, as suggested in our previous study of tobacco GAPDHs [Shih et al., Cell 47 (1986) 73-80]. In addition, the chromosomal locations for the three gap genes were determined by restriction fragment length polymorphism mapping; the three gap genes are not closely linked, gapA (55.8 cM) and gapC (0.0 cM) are on chromosome 3, and gapB (51.3 cM) is on chromosome 1.

Functional tagging of regulatory elements in the plant genome

In comparison with animals, relatively few plant genes have been identified that have been shown to be under organ-, tissue- or cell-type-specific regulation. In this paper, we describe how the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene (gusA or uidA), fused to a weak promoter (a truncated (-90 bp) CaMV35S promoter), can be used to identify tissue-specific markers in transgenic tobacco plants. The rationale was that the expression of gusA would be determined primarily by position effect. Quantitative analysis revealed that, of 184 -90-gus transgenic plants, 73% exhibited gusA gene activation in leaf tissue, and the level of GUS enzyme activity varied over a 300-fold range within the population. In comparison, transformation with a promoterless gusA gene resulted in GUS expression in 78% of all plants analyzed (in leaf and/or root) and expression levels were three-fold or more lower. Qualitative GUS analysis of single locus -90-gus transformants revealed differential expression in diverse tissues. The spatial pattern of GUS activity was unique to individual transformants, was a reflection of differential gusA gene transcription, and was stably transmissible to progeny. Evidence for preferential expression in roots not only of the -90-gus, but also the promoterless gusA gene is presented. The value of the -90 bp promoter-gusA sequence, which is termed an 'interposon', as a tool both to identify native enhancer sequences in situ and to investigate position effects in plants, is discussed.

Structural and functional analysis of promoter from gliadin, an endosperm-specific storage protein gene of Triticum aestivum L

To identify cis-regulatory elements of the gliadin gene, a study of the gliadin gene promoter was conducted by transient expression analysis of plasmid DNAs which were introduced into plant protoplasts by electroporation. The promoter region (-592 bp to +18 bp from the translational start) of this developmentally regulated gene, when fused upstream to the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) reporter cassette was unable to direct significant CAT expression in wheat or tobacco suspension cells. Because this monocot gene promoter appeared to be under stringent tissue-specific control, a hybrid promoter approach using a nopaline synthase (nos) promoter was employed. A series of 3' deletions of the gliadin promoter were placed upstream of either a nonfunctional -101 nos or a nearly wild-type -155 nos promoter fused in turn to a CAT reporter gene cassette. Transient expression analysis of these plasmid DNAs in tobacco cells showed that the gliadin fragment could either restore the activity of the non-functional nos promoter (series I) or enhance the activity of the functional nos promoter (series II). The degree of restoration of the promoter function conferred by gliadin fragments of the first series was proportional to the enhancing effect of the same fragments in the second series of constructs. The transcriptional activity of the gliadin (-592 bp to -77 bp) -nos hybrid promoter was reduced by 26% upon 3' deletion of sequences in the region -141 bp to -77 bp, which contains both the TATA and CCAAT boxes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The Cauliflower Mosaic Virus 35S Promoter: Combinatorial Regulation of Transcription in Plants

Appropriate regulation of transcription in higher plants requires specific cis elements in the regulatory regions of genes and their corresponding trans-acting proteins. Analysis of the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter has contributed to the understanding of transcriptional regulatory mechanisms. The intact 35S promoter confers constitutive expression upon heterologous genes in most plants. Dissection into subdomains that are able to confer tissue-specific gene expression has demonstrated that the promoter has a modular organization. When selected subdomains are combined, they confer expression not detected from the isolated subdomains, suggesting that synergistic interactions occur among cis elements. The expression patterns conferred by specific combinations of 35S subdomains differ in tobacco and petunia. This indicates that a combinatorial code of cisregulatory elements may be interpreted differently in different species.

Techniques in plant molecular biology--progress and problems

Progress in plant molecular biology has been dependent on efficient methods of introducing foreign DNA into plant cells. Gene transfer into plant cells can be achieved by either direct uptake of DNA or the natural process of gene transfer carried out by the soil bacterium Agrobacterium. Versatile gene-transfer vectors have been developed for use with Agrobacterium and more recently vectors based on the genomes of plant viruses have become available. Using this technology the expression of foreign DNA, the functional analysis of plant DNA sequences, the investigation of the mechanism of viral DNA replication and cell to cell spread, as well as the study of transposition, can be carried out. In addition, the versatility of the gene-transfer vectors is such that they may be used to isolate genes not amenable to isolation using conventional protocols. This review concentrates on these aspects of plant molecular biology and discusses the limitations of the experimental systems that are currently available.

Analysis of the promotors of the single-copy genes for plastocyanin and subunit delta of the chloroplast ATP synthase from spinach

The promotors of the single-copy genes for subunit delta of the chloroplast ATP synthase (atpD) and plastocyanin (PC) from spinach have been sequenced, dissected and analysed in transgenic F0 and F1 tobacco plants using the bacterial GUS gene as a reporter for promotor activity. The transcription of these genes is photo-controlled. The results have been compared with those obtained for the spinach rbcS-1 gene, one of the light-regulated genes encoding the small subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase, and for the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S RNA promotor. We find that the 5' upstream regions of about 1200 nucleotides contain all the sequences required for light regulation, organ-, tissue- and development-specific expression, and that they are structurally diverse. Their cis-acting elements are functionally defined. The proximal regions of the spinach promotors contain potential TATA, CAAT and T-cyt boxes at appropriate positions, but only sequence elements with low similarity to published light-responsive elements. Positive light-stimulated regions, regions with constitutive, light-independent enhancing effects and with 'silencer'-like activity in complete darkness are found in proximal and far upstream promotor segments. Highest activity of these promotors is correlated with the presence of chloroplasts but is not confined to photosynthetic tissue. Surprisingly, expression is observed in the phloem regions of transgenic leaves, leaf and floral stems, in the vascular area of anthers and in pollen. No histochemical staining has been detected in roots. The distal region of atpD located between -1137 and -590 contains elements for expression in the outer phloem, the region from -590 to -185 for activity in the inner phloem of floral stems. Similar tissue-specific patterns are observed with a fusion between the caufliflower mosaic virus 35S RNA promotor and the GUS gene.

GT-1 binding site confers light responsive expression in transgenic tobacco

Light-dependent expression of rbcS, the gene encoding the small subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase, which is the key enzyme involved in carbon fixation in higher plants, is regulated at the transcriptional level. Sequence analysis of the gene has uncovered a conserved GT motif in the -150 to -100 region of many rbcS promoters. This motif serves as the binding site of a nuclear factor, designated GT-1. Analysis of site-specific mutants of pea rbcS-3A promoter demonstrated that GT-1 binding in vitro is correlated with light-responsive expression of the rbcS promoter in transgenic plants. However, it is not known whether factors other than GT-1 might also be required for activation of transcription by light. A synthetic tetramer of box II (TGTGTGGTTAATATG), the GT-1 binding site located between -152 to -138 of the rbcS-3A promoter, inserted upstream of a truncated cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter is sufficient to confer expression in leaves of transgenic tobacco. This expression occurs principally in chloroplast-containing cells, is induced by light, and is correlated with the ability of box II to bind GT-1 in vitro. The data show that the binding site for GT-1 is likely to be a part of the molecular light switch for rbcS activation.

Interdependence and nodule specificity of cis-acting regulatory elements in the soybean leghemoglobin lbc3 and N23 gene promoters

The qualitative and quantitative contributions of four separate cis-acting DNA elements controlling the root nodule-specific soybean leghemoglobin lbc3 gene were analyzed in transgenic Lotus corniculatus plants. Expression from internal deletions in the 5' region between positions -49 and -1956 was monitored from a CAT reporter gene. The strong positive element (SPE; -1090, -947) responsible for high-level expression was demonstrated to be an organ-specific element by deleting proximal nodule-specific control elements. Deletion of the downstream qualitative organ-specific element (OSE; -139, -102) containing the putative nodulin consensus sequences 5'AAAGAT and 5'CTCTT resulted in a low expression level. Efficient SPE enhancement is therefore dependent on the organ-specific element, which by itself does not enhance expression. This quantitative effect of the immediate upstream region carrying the consensus sequences was also found in hybrid promoter studies using the soybean nodulin N23 gene promoter, suggesting the involvement of these motifs in a regulatory mechanism for nodulin genes. Deletion of the lbc3 negative element (NE, -102, -49) linking the SPE and OSE onto the TATA box did not lead to unregulated expression. These results indicate that interaction between positive, negative and neutral qualitative elements controls lbc3 expression. Binding of the nuclear protein NAT2 at the lbc3 weak positive element (WPE; -230, -170) is probably not directly required for this mechanism.

Site-specific mutations alter in vitro factor binding and change promoter expression pattern in transgenic plants

The 35S promoter of cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) is able to confer high-level gene expression in most organs of transgenic plants. A cellular factor from pea and tobacco leaf tissue, which recognizes nucleotides in a tandemly repeated TGACG motif at the -75 region of this promoter, has been detected by DNase I footprinting and gel retardation assays. This factor is named activation sequence factor 1 (ASF-1). A cellular factor binding to the two TGACG motifs can also be detected in tobacco root extracts. Mutations at these motifs inhibit binding of ASF-1 to the 35S promoter in vitro. When examined in transgenic tobacco, these mutations cause a 50% drop in leaf expression of the 35S promoter. In addition, these same mutations attenuate stem and root expression of the 35S promoter about 5- to 10-fold when compared to the level of expression in leaf. In contrast, mutations at two adjacent CCAAT-box-like sequences have no dramatic effect on promoter activity in vivo. A 21-base-pair element containing the two TGACG motifs is sufficient for binding of ASF-1 in vitro when inserted in a green-tissue-specific promoter. In vivo, the insertion of an ASF-1 binding site caused high levels of expression in root. Thus, a single factor binding site that is defined by site-specific mutations is shown to be sufficient to alter the expression pattern of promoters in vivo.

Nuclear proteins binding to a cauliflower mosaic virus 35S truncated promoter

Proteins present in tobacco nuclear extracts bind to a truncated cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter fragment (from -90 to +2 relative to the transcription start site) in a sequence specific manner. Gel mobility shift assays show the presence of two protein-DNA complexes that are not competed by a -47/+2 promoter fragment. DNAse I protection and DNA methylation interference reveal two protected sites in the slower migrating complex; both include the pentamer TGACG, separated by a stretch of eight nucleotides where G methylation does not prevent the binding of the proteins. The faster complex is the prevalent form at low protein concentrations. As the protein concentration increases a non-linear rise in the amount of the slower migrating complex relative to the faster one is seen suggesting that cooperative effects are involved in the binding to the second site.