Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-related chronic relapsing inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy with multifocal unusual onion bulbs in sural nerve biopsy. A clinicomorphological study with qualitative and quantitative light and electron microscopy

Recommendations on diagnostic strategies for chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy

BACKGROUND

Chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (CIDP) is an immune mediated treatable peripheral neuropathy, the diagnosis of which is straightforward in more than half of cases. Numerous sets of electrophysiological criteria have been published. However, in some cases, electrophysiological data are not sufficient and patients that may benefit from treatment escape accurate diagnosis.

OBJECTIVE

To describe a step by step diagnostic procedure for neurologists facing a peripheral neuropathy of undetermined cause, to help make an accurate diagnosis of CIDP.

METHODS

A group of French experts was established, neurologists and neurophysiologists being recruited on the basis of personal experience with patients suffering from CIDP and also on publications in the field. A full literature review was conducted on the topic of diagnostic criteria and procedures for the diagnosis of CIDP, and meetings were scheduled to reach a consensus on the best diagnostic workup in different clinical situations.

RESULTS

Six meetings were conducted and a consensus was reached, based on the available literature and experience in the management of such patients. Discussions resulted in defining five clinical situations in which a diagnosis of CIDP may be considered, and procedures were detailed in each case, including the location of nerve biopsy and use of non-conventional electrophysiological testing and imaging procedures.

CONCLUSION

The guidelines in the diagnostic procedure reported here result from a consensus of French experts in the field of peripheral neuropathy and allow a diagnosis of CIDP to be made in the most frequently encountered situations. These recommendations may be of value for physicians as they rely on the rational use of available techniques in typical clinical situations.

Infectious Neuropathies

Peripheral neuropathies can result from several infective agents, ranging from viruses, especially retroviruses, to parasites and bacilli. Leprosy, which often is considered a disorder of the past, still is common in dome geographic areas, especially in Africa, South America, and Asia. An increasing number of cases of neuropathies occurs in patients who have HIV or Lyme disease. The important point is that all these neuropathies are treatable and often preventable.

Polyradiculonévrites inflammatoires démyélinisantes chroniques : stratégie diagnostique

Chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (CIDP) comprises a group of dysimmune neuropathies easily diagnosed in more than half of the patients. Diagnosis is based on clinical, electrophysiological and biological clues. In some patients, diagnosis is unclear because of the debated value of the available clues. In such circumstances, dysimmune neuropathies may not be diagnosed, leading to insufficient treatment. This is an important category of patients because immunomodulatory drugs have proven efficacy. The CIDP spectrum includes a relatively wide range of diseases. Besides the easily recognized classic forms, there are many clinical variants, sometimes with a paucisymptomatic presentation leading to uncertain diagnosis. The French CIDP study group has established guidelines for diagnostic strategy in CIDP patients. The first part of this paper is devoted to the clinical aspects of the disease, classical forms and variants. In the second part, the results of electrophysiological studies are reported. In a third chapter, complementary examinations useful for diagnosis are discussed. The fourth chapter deals with the diagnostic strategy, discussed in relation to the different situations which may be encountered in clinical practice. details the technical modalities of appropriate electrophysiological studies and presents normal results together with those indicating demyelinating neuropathy. Nerve biopsy technique and results are given in appendix II.

Can antiglycolipid antibodies present in HIV-infected individuals induce immune demyelination?

Of the eight clinically defined neuropathies associated with HIV infection, there is compelling evidence that acute and chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (IDPN) have an autoimmune pathogenesis. Many non-HIV infected individuals who suffer from sensory-motor nerve dysfunction have autoimmune indicators. The immunopathogenesis of demyelination must involve neuritogenic components in myelin. The various antigens suspected to play a role in HIV-seronegative IDPN include (i) P2 protein; (ii) sulfatide (GalS); (iii) various gangliosides (especially GM1); (iv) galactocerebroside (GalC); and (v) glycoproteins or glycolipids with the carbohydrate epitope glucuronyl-3-sulfate. These glycoproteins or glycolipids may be individually targeted, or an immune attack may be raised against a combination of any of these epitopes. The glycolipids, however, especially GalS, have recently evoked much interest as mediators of immune events underlying both non-HIV and HIV-associated demyelinating neuropathies. The present review outlines the recent research findings of antiglycolipid antibodies present in HIV-infected patients with and without peripheral nerve dysfunction, in an attempt to arrive at some consensus as to whether these antibodies may play a role in the immunopathogenesis of HIV-associated inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy.

Role of HIV in the pathogenesis of distal symmetrical peripheral neuropathy

We report the results of a clinical, electrophysiological and pathological study conducted in 18 AIDS patients presenting a distal symmetrical predominantly sensory polyneuropathy (DSPN) characterized by painful dysesthesias as main complaint. Onset of the neuropathy was at CDC (Center for Disease Control) stage II in 2 patients, at CDC stage III in 5 patients and at CDC stage IV in the remainder. Electrophysiological investigation confirmed the presence of an axonal alteration in the sensory nerves, but also revealed motor involvement in all cases. The neuropathological features of sensory nerves were fiber loss and axonal degeneration with macrophagic activation. The expression of monocyte-macrophage markers and of major histocompatibility complex class II antigens appeared up-regulated in endoneurial ramified cells, while expression of CR3, a complement receptor involved in the process of phagocytosis, was down-regulated. In six nerve biopsy samples and in two out of five DSPN dorsal root ganglia we found HIV-related mRNA and protein located in scattered cells of the endoneurium which we presume to be macrophages. These data suggest that: (a) DSPN may occur early in the course of the disease and is not limited to later stages; (b) DSPN is not a ganglionitis but is actually a sensory-motor neuropathy; (c) the virus enters the peripheral nervous system and induces changes in the immunocompetent cell population with activation of macrophages. Storage of the virus inside macrophages may act both as a reservoir for the virus and as a putative cause of nerve damage, probably through release of cytotoxins and/or interaction with trophic factors.

Correlation of neuromuscular pathology in acquired immune deficiency syndrome patients with cytomegalovirus infection and zidovudine treatment

Peripheral nerve and skeletal muscle specimens from 115 autopsied adult AIDS patients were examined for types and incidence of histological abnormalities. Focal perivascular chronic inflammatory infiltrates featuring plasma cells were found in 85% of nerve and muscle specimens. These foci were specifically associated with cytomegalovirus (CMV)-infected capillary or venous endothelial cells in neuromuscular specimens of 31/115 patients, with increasing incidence in patients surviving longer with the diagnosis of AIDS. Neuromuscular CMV was identified histologically in 19% of AIDS patients with an AIDS-defining illness for 3 months or less, with the incidence increasing to 46% of patients who had the diagnosis for 2 years or longer. Vascular damage from CMV endothelial infection may result in regional ischemic and/or inflammatory damage to nerves, producing myelinated fiber loss and axonal degeneration, leading to denervation atrophy of myofibers found in skeletal muscle specimens in a majority of the patients. Myelinated fiber loss within the sural nerve was determined by morphometric quantitation for a subset of 50 patients, and correlated with the presence of histologically identifiable neuromuscular CMV, clinical history of zidovudine administration, and chemotherapy for alleviation of Kaposi's sarcoma. CMV infection and zidovudine treatment were both positively correlated with myelinated fiber loss, while Kaposi's sarcoma chemotherapy did not independently increase the incidence of myelinated fiber loss.

Potential role of the viral protease in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 associated pathogenesis

Infection with the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) results in a variety of pathological changes culminating in the acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS). While most of these changes can readily be accounted for either by direct effects of HIV-1 on the immune system or by indirect effects of secondary infectious agents as a result of faulty immune surveillance, the direct cause for a number of disease states, including some neuropathies, myopathies, nephropathy, thrombocytopenia, wasting syndromes and increased incidence of cancers (primarily lymphoma) has remained an enigma. We have recently shown that the HIV-1 protease, a viral encoded enzyme necessary for virus maturation and infectivity, can cleave a variety of host cell cytoskeletal proteins in vitro. Potential substrates for the HIV-1 protease are found in all of the cell types affected in these unexplained diseases. Recent proposals suggest that elements of the cytoskeleton may play an important role in the regulation of large scale genetic regulation. We propose that some of the degenerative changes associated with infection by HIV-1 are a direct consequence of cleavage of host cell cytoskeletal proteins, which in turn may be responsible for the increased incidence of cancer in HIV-1 infected individuals as a result of the perturbation of the regulation of gene expression by cytoskeletal components.

Ultrastructural changes associated with peripheral neuropathy in HIV/AIDS

Light and electron microscopic studies were performed on neuromuscular biopsy specimens from 12 neurologically affected seropositive patients, 7 with the acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS), 2 with AIDS-related complex, and 3 with no symptoms except for neuropathy. All patients had an axonal injury associated or unassociated with demyelination and peripheral neurogenic atrophy. Capillary lesions were consistently present, which seems to be a new finding. Moreover, tubuloreticular inclusions (TRIs) were found in endomysial (9 of 12 cases) and endoneurial (7 of 12 cases) vessels. Statistical analysis showed that TRIs in more than 20% of endomysial vessels correlated with a survival time shorter than 12 months (P = 0.028). Thus the quantification of TRIs seems to be one of the vital prognostic elements in this patient population.

Unmyelinated fibers in sural nerve biopsies of chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy

Seven patients aged 29 to 76 years with various clinical subtypes of chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP) were investigated. Sural nerve biopsies were performed between 7 months and 19 years after onset of disease. Quantitative electron microscopy revealed involvement of primary unmyelinated fibers (UF) in all cases. When compared with age-matched controls from the literature and two controls of our own, there was an increase of degenerating primary UF in all cases, a definite decrease of density per mm2 or number per nerve after subtraction of regenerates of myelinated and unmyelinated fibers in five cases, an increase of denervated Schwann cell complexes of the unmyelinated type in three cases, and an increased incidence of a high ratio (greater than or equal to 3) of primary UF per Schwann cell complex in five cases. Presumably due to the small number and heterogeneity of cases, the results did not correlate with type and duration of CIDP, but were obviously influenced by the degree of demyelination. The possible causes of UF damage in CIDP are discussed.