Chemical characterization and location of ionic interactions involved in the assembly of the C1 complex of human complement

Mapping surface accessibility of the C1r/C1s tetramer by chemical modification and mass spectrometry provides new insights into assembly of the human C1 complex

C1, the complex that triggers the classic pathway of complement, is a 790-kDa assembly resulting from association of a recognition protein C1q with a Ca(2+)-dependent tetramer comprising two copies of the proteases C1r and C1s. Early structural investigations have shown that the extended C1s-C1r-C1r-C1s tetramer folds into a compact conformation in C1. Recent site-directed mutagenesis studies have identified the C1q-binding sites in C1r and C1s and led to a three-dimensional model of the C1 complex (Bally, I., Rossi, V., Lunardi, T., Thielens, N. M., Gaboriaud, C., and Arlaud, G. J. (2009) J. Biol. Chem. 284, 19340-19348). In this study, we have used a mass spectrometry-based strategy involving a label-free semi-quantitative analysis of protein samples to gain new structural insights into C1 assembly. Using a stable chemical modification, we have compared the accessibility of the lysine residues in the isolated tetramer and in C1. The labeling data account for 51 of the 73 lysine residues of C1r and C1s. They strongly support the hypothesis that both C1s CUB(1)-EGF-CUB(2) interaction domains, which are distant in the free tetramer, associate with each other in the C1 complex. This analysis also provides the first experimental evidence that, in the proenzyme form of C1, the C1s serine protease domain is partly positioned inside the C1q cone and yields precise information about its orientation in the complex. These results provide further structural insights into the architecture of the C1 complex, allowing significant improvement of our current C1 model.

Analysis of human C1q by combined bottom-up and top-down mass spectrometry: detailed mapping of post-translational modifications and insights into the C1r/C1s binding sites

C1q is a subunit of the C1 complex, a key player in innate immunity that triggers activation of the classical complement pathway. Featuring a unique structural organization and comprising a collagen-like domain with a high level of post-translational modifications, C1q represents a challenging protein assembly for structural biology. We report for the first time a comprehensive proteomics study of C1q combining bottom-up and top-down analyses. C1q was submitted to proteolytic digestion by a combination of collagenase and trypsin for bottom-up analyses. In addition to classical LC-MS/MS analyses, which provided reliable identification of hydroxylated proline and lysine residues, sugar loss-triggered MS(3) scans were acquired on an LTQ-Orbitrap (Linear Quadrupole Ion Trap-Orbitrap) instrument to strengthen the localization of glucosyl-galactosyl disaccharide moieties on hydroxylysine residues. Top-down analyses performed on the same instrument allowed high accuracy and high resolution mass measurements of the intact full-length C1q polypeptide chains and the iterative fragmentation of the proteins in the MS(n) mode. This study illustrates the usefulness of combining the two complementary analytical approaches to obtain a detailed characterization of the post-translational modification pattern of the collagen-like domain of C1q and highlights the structural heterogeneity of individual molecules. Most importantly, three lysine residues of the collagen-like domain, namely Lys(59) (A chain), Lys(61) (B chain), and Lys(58) (C chain), were unambiguously shown to be completely unmodified. These lysine residues are located about halfway along the collagen-like fibers. They are thus fully available and in an appropriate position to interact with the C1r and C1s protease partners of C1q and are therefore likely to play an essential role in C1 assembly.

Modulation of the proteolytic activity of the complement protease C1s by polyanions: implications for polyanion-mediated acceleration of interaction between C1s and SERPING1

The complement system plays crucial roles in the immune system, but incorrect regulation causes inflammation and targeting of self-tissue, leading to diseases such as systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis and age-related macular degeneration. In vivo, the initiating complexes of the classical complement and lectin pathways are controlled by SERPING1 [(C1 inhibitor) serpin peptidase inhibitor, clade G, member 1], which inactivates the components C1s and MASP-2 (mannan-binding lectin serine peptidase 2). GAGs (glycosaminoglycan) and DXS (dextran sulfate) are able to significantly accelerate SERPING1-mediated inactivation of C1s, the key effector enzyme of the classical C1 complex, although the mechanism is poorly understood. In the present study we have shown that C1s can bind to DXS and heparin and that these polyanions enhanced C1s proteolytic activity at low concentrations and inhibited it at higher concentrations. The recent determination of the crystal structure of SERPING1 has given rise to the hypothesis that both the serpin (serine protease inhibitor)-polyanion and protease-polyanion interactions might be required to accelerate the association rate of SERPING1 and C1s. To determine what proportion of the acceleration was due to protease-polyanion interactions, a chimaeric mutant of alpha1-antitrypsin containing the P4-P1 residues from the SERPING1 RCL (reactive-centre loop) was produced. Like SERPING1, this molecule is able to effectively inhibit C1s, but is unable to bind polyanions. DXS exerted a biphasic effect on the association rate of C1s which correlated strongly with the effect of DXS on C1s proteolytic activity. Thus, whereas polyanions are able to bind C1s and modulate its activity, polyanion interactions with SERPING1 must also play a vital role in the mechanism by which these cofactors accelerate the C1s-SERPING1 reaction.

Identifying residues in antigenic determinants by chemical modification

Chemical modification of the side chains of amino acid residues was one of the first methods developed to investigate epitopes in protein antigens. The principle of the method is that alteration of the structure of a key residue of an epitope by a chemical modification will alter reactivity with antibody by affecting either specificity or avidity or both. Chemical modification has the advantage that it can be applied to discontinuous as well as continuous epitopes and may be of value in identifying cryptic epitopes. We consider here the several recent studies that have applied site-specific chemical modification to the identification of epitopes on antigens, including the use of formaldehyde, glutaraldehyde, and acid anhydrides, to produce allergoids where determinants important to reaction with IgE are modified but the ability to elicit an IgG response is retained. It is noteworthy that modification of amino groups with charge reversal appears to be the most useful approach. The approach to the use of site-specific chemical modification as a tool for the study of protein function is discussed, and emphasis is placed on the necessity to (1) validate the specificity of modification and (2) assess potential conformational change that may occur secondary to modification. Finally, a list of chemical reagents used for protein modification is presented, together with properties and references to use.

Assembly of C1 and the MBL- and ficolin-MASP complexes: structural insights

The classical pathway C1 complex, and the MBL-MASP and ficolin-MASP complexes involved in activation of the lectin pathway have several features in common. Both types of complexes are assembled from two subunits: an oligomeric recognition protein (C1q, MBL, L-, H- or M-ficolin), and a protease component, which is either a tetramer (C1s-C1r-C1r-C1s) or a dimer ((MASP)(2)). Recent functional and 3-D structural investigations have revealed that C1r/C1s and the MASPs associate through a common mechanism involving their N-terminal CUB1-EGF region. In contrast, the C1s-C1r-C1r-C1s tetramer and the (MASP)(2) dimers appear to have evolved distinct strategies to associate with their partner proteins. The purpose of this article is to review these recent advances.

Mass spectrometry analysis of the oligomeric C1q protein reveals the B chain as the target of trypsin cleavage and interaction with fucoidan

C1q is a subunit of the C1 complex that triggers activation of the complement classical pathway through recognition and binding of immune complexes. C1q also binds to nonimmune ligands such as the sulfated polysaccharide fucoidan, a potent anticomplementary agent. C1q was submitted for the first time to mass spectrometry analysis, yielding insights into its assembly and its interaction with fucoidan. The MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry technique on membrane allowed partial preservation of noncovalent interactions, allowing precise analysis of its substructure and estimation of the C1q molecular weight at 459520-461883, with an average mass of 460793 g x mol(-1). The disulfide-linked A-B and C-C dimers as well as the noncovalent structural unit (A-B:C)-(C:B-A) were detected, providing experimental support to the C1q model based on covalent and noncovalent associations of six heterotrimers. Trypsin treatment of native C1q led to proteolysis of the B chain only, at a single cleavage site (Arg(109)) located in the globular region. Unlike DNA, fucoidan protected C1q from trypsin cleavage, indicating that this polysaccharide binds to the B moiety of the globular head. Given the involvement of the C1q globular heads in the recognition of IgG, this interaction may account for the observed anticomplementary activity of fucoidan.

Complement inhibition reduces material-induced leukocyte activation with PEG modified polystyrene beads (Tentagel™) but not polystyrene beads

With isolated leukocytes, inhibiting complement reduced material-induced leukocyte activation (CD11b) with polyethylene glycol modified polystyrene beads (PS-PEG), but not with polystyrene beads (PS). The PS-PEG beads (TentaGel) were complement activating as measured by SC5b-9 levels consistent with the sensitivity of these beads to leukocyte inhibition with complement inhibitors. Following contact with PS and PS-PEG beads, isolated leukocytes in plasma and in the absence in platelets were found to significantly upregulate CD11b, while TF expression and exposure of phosphatidylserine remained at background levels. Complement inhibition by means of sCR1 partially reduced CD11b upregulation on PS-PEG beads, but had no effect with PS beads. Pyridoxal-5-phosphate (P5P) was able to significantly reduce both CD11b upregulation and exposure of phosphatidylserine with PS-PEG beads, although it did not appear to inhibit SC5b-9 production. Pentamidine and NAAGA inhibited complement and were effective in reducing CD11b upregulation with both PS and PS-PEG. However, they also had an inhibitory effect on leukocyte signaling mechanisms, precluding their utility for further study in this context. Leukocyte adhesion occurred to similar extents on both PS and PS-PEG beads. While sCR1 and P5P blocked adhesion and activation (for adherent leukocytes) on PS-PEG beads, they had no effect on leukocytes adherent to PS beads. The role of complement in leukocyte activation and adhesion was found to be material-dependent. Thus, leukocyte-material compatibility may be resolved by complement inhibition in some but not all cases. For these other materials (example here was PS), other mechanisms, such as fibrinogen adsorption and direct leukocyte release, may need exploitation to minimize leukocyte activation and adhesion.

Interaction of the C1 complex of complement with sulfated polysaccharide and DNA probed by single molecule fluorescence microscopy

The complex C1 triggers the activation of the Complement classical pathway through the recognition and binding of antigen-antibody complex by its subunit C1q. The globular region of C1q is responsible for C1 binding to the immune complex. C1q can also bind nonimmune molecules such as DNA and sulfated polysaccharides, leading either to the activation or inhibition of Complement. The binding site of these nonimmune ligands is debated in the literature, and it has been proposed to be located either in the globular region or in the collagen-like region of C1q, or in both. Using single molecule fluorescence microscopy and DNA molecular combing as reporters of interactions, we have probed the C1q binding properties of T4 DNA and of fucoidan, an algal sulfated fucose-based polysaccharide endowed with potent anticomplementary activity. We have been able to visualize the binding of C1q as well as of C1 and of the isolated collagen-like region to individual DNA strands, indicating that the collagen-like region is the main binding site of DNA. From binding assays with C1r, one of the protease components of C1, we concluded that the DNA binding site on the collagen-like region is located within the stalk part. Competition experiments between fucoidan and DNA for the binding of C1q showed that fucoidan binds also to the collagen-like region part of C1q. Unlike DNA, the binding of fucoidan to collagen-like region involves interactions with the hinge region that accommodate the catalytic tetramer C1r2-C1s2 of C1. This binding property of fucoidan to C1q provides a mechanistic basis for the anticomplementary activity of the sulfated polysaccharide.

X-ray structure of the Ca2+-binding interaction domain of C1s. Insights into the assembly of the C1 complex of complement

C1, the complex that triggers the classical pathway of complement, is assembled from two modular proteases C1r and C1s and a recognition protein C1q. The N-terminal CUB1-EGF segments of C1r and C1s are key elements of the C1 architecture, because they mediate both Ca2+-dependent C1r-C1s association and interaction with C1q. The crystal structure of the interaction domain of C1s has been solved and refined to 1.5 A resolution. The structure reveals a head-to-tail homodimer involving interactions between the CUB1 module of one monomer and the epidermal growth factor (EGF) module of its counterpart. A Ca2+ ion is bound to each EGF module and stabilizes both the intra- and inter-monomer interfaces. Unexpectedly, a second Ca2+ ion is bound to the distal end of each CUB1 module, through six ligands contributed by Glu45, Asp53, Asp98, and two water molecules. These acidic residues and Tyr17 are conserved in approximately two-thirds of the CUB repertoire and define a novel, Ca2+-binding CUB module subset. The C1s structure was used to build a model of the C1r-C1s CUB1-EGF heterodimer, which in C1 connects C1r to C1s and mediates interaction with C1q. A structural model of the C1q/C1r/C1s interface is proposed, where the rod-like collagen triple helix of C1q is accommodated into a groove along the transversal axis of the C1r-C1s heterodimer.

Structural biology of the C1 complex of complement unveils the mechanisms of its activation and proteolytic activity

C1 is the multimolecular protease that triggers activation of the classical pathway of complement, a major element of antimicrobial host defense also involved in immune tolerance and various pathologies. This 790,000 Da complex is formed from the association of a recognition protein, C1q, and a catalytic subunit, the Ca2+-dependent tetramer C1s-C1r-C1r-C1s comprising two copies of each of the modular proteases C1r and C1s. Early studies mainly based on biochemical analysis and electron microscopy of C1 and its isolated components have allowed for characterization of their domain structure and led to a low-resolution model of the C1 complex in which the elongated C1s-C1r-C1r-C1s tetramer folds into a more compact, "8-shaped" conformation upon interaction with C1q. A major strategy used over the past years has been to dissect the C1 proteins into modular segments to characterize their function and solve their structure by either X-ray crystallography or nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR). The purpose of this review is to focus on this information, with particular emphasis on the architecture of the C1 complex and the mechanisms underlying its activation and proteolytic activity.

Activation of human complement serine-proteinase C1r is down-regulated by a Ca(2+)-dependent intramolecular control that is released in the C1 complex through a signal transmitted by C1q

The activation of human C1, a Ca(2+)-dependent complex proteinase comprising a non-enzymic protein, C1q, and two serine proteinases, C1r and C1s, is based primarily on the intrinsic property of C1r to autoactivate. The aim of the present study was to investigate the mechanisms involved in the regulation of C1r autoactivation, with particular attention to the role of Ca2+ ions. Spontaneous activation of proenzyme C1r was observed upon incubation in the presence of EDTA, whereas Ca2+ ions reduced markedly the activation process. Several lines of evidence indicated that Ca2+ inhibited the intramolecular activation reaction but had little or no effect on the intermolecular activation reaction. C1q caused partial release of this inhibitory effect of Ca2+. Complete stabilization of C1r in its proenzyme form was obtained upon incorporation within the Ca(2+)-dependent C1s-C1r-C1r-C1s tetramer, and a comparable effect was observed when C1s was replaced by its Ca(2+)-binding alpha-fragment. Both tetramers, C1s-C1r-C1r-C1s and C1s alpha-C1r-C1r-C1s alpha, readily associated with C1q to form 16.0 S and 14.7 S complexes respectively in which C1r fully recovered its activation potential. Both complexes showed indistinguishable activation kinetics, indicating that the gamma B catalytic region of C1s plays no role in the mechanism that triggers C1r activation in C1. The collagen-like fragments of C1q retained the ability to bind to C1s-C1r-C1r-C1s, but, in contrast with intact C1q, failed to induce C1r activation in the resulting complex at temperatures above 25 degrees C. On the basis of these observations it is proposed that activation of the serine-proteinase domain of C1r is controlled by a Ca(2+)-dependent intramolecular mechanism involving the Ca(2+)-binding alpha-region, and that this control is released in C1 by a signal originating in C1q and transmitted through the C1q/C1r interface.