Exocytosis reconstituted from the sea urchin egg is unaffected by calcium pretreatment of granules and plasma membrane

Membrane fusion of secretory vesicles of the sea urchin egg in the absence of NSF

The role of cytosolic ATPases such as N-ethylmaleimide (NEM)-sensitive fusion protein (NSF) in membrane fusion is controversial. We examined the physiology and biochemistry of ATP and NSF in the cortical system of the echinoderm egg to determine if NSF is an essential factor in membrane fusion during Ca(2+)-triggered exocytosis. Neither exocytosis in vitro, nor homotypic cortical vesicle (CV) fusion required soluble proteins or nucleotides, and both occurred in the presence of non-hydrolyzable analogs of ATP. While sensitive to thiol-specific reagents, CV exocytosis is not restored by the addition of cytosolic NSF, and fusion and NSF function are differentially sensitive to thiol-specific agents. To test participation of tightly bound, non-exchangeable NSF in CV-CV fusion, we cloned the sea urchin homolog and developed a species-specific antibody for western blots and physiological analysis. This antibody was without effect on CV exocytosis or homotypic fusion, despite being functionally inhibitory. NSF is detectable in intact cortices, cortices from which CVs had been removed and isolated CVs treated with ATP-gamma-S and egg cytosol to reveal NSF binding sites. In contrast, isolated CVs, though all capable of Ca(2+)-triggered homotypic fusion, contain less than one hexamer of NSF per CV. Thus NSF is not a required component of the CV fusion machinery.

The biology of cortical granules

An egg-that took weeks to months to make in the adult-can be extraordinarily transformed within minutes during its fertilization. This review will focus on the molecular biology of the specialized secretory vesicles of fertilization, the cortical granules. We will discuss their role in the fertilization process, their contents, how they are made, and the molecular mechanisms that regulate their secretion at fertilization. This population of secretory vesicles has inherent interest for our understanding of the fertilization process. In addition, they have import because they enhance our understanding of the basic processes of secretory vesicle construction and regulation, since oocytes across species utilize this vesicle type. Here, we examine diverse animals in a comparative approach to help us understand how these vesicles function throughout phylogeny and to establish conserved themes of function.

Plasma membrane resident 'fusion complexes' mediate reconstituted exocytosis

Calcium-triggered exocytosis is thought to be mediated by membrane-associated protein complexes. In sea urchin eggs, high concentrations of calcium activate multiple 'fusion complexes' per cortical vesicle-plasma membrane docking site. Some of these fusion complexes are known to reside in the vesicle membrane. It is not known if fusion complexes also reside in the plasma membrane, or if plasma membrane-resident fusion complexes require cognate partners in the vesicle membrane. Using reconstitution, we show that N-ethylmaleimide treatment of either vesicles or plasma membrane fragments prior to reconstitution does not completely inhibit exocytosis. Treatment of both components did result in complete inhibition. Upon reconstitution, cortical vesicles and the early endosomes formed by compensatory endocytosis both contributed, on average, two fusion complexes per reconstituted docking site. The plasma membrane contributed, on average, two fusion complexes per docking site when assembled with cortical vesicles, but only one complex when reconstituted with endosomes. We conclude that there are at least two types of plasma membrane-resident fusion complexes that participate in reconstituted cortical vesicle-plasma membrane fusion. The activity of one of these fusion complexes is target-specific for cortical vesicles, while the second type also supports fusion with endosomes.

Sea urchin egg preparations as systems for the study of calcium-triggered exocytosis

This paper reviews recent work in our laboratory on the mechanism of calcium-triggered exocytosis. Upon echinoderm egg fertilization, cortical secretory vesicle exocytosis is massive and synchronous. By combining physiological and molecular analyses with a variety of purified membrane isolates containing secretory vesicles that fuse to the plasma membrane or each other, we have characterized the final steps of this calcium-triggered exocytosis. Our kinetic analysis led to a functional definition of the fusion complex whose activation by calcium follows Poisson statistics. The properties of this complex are compared with the properties of the heterotrimeric SNARE protein complex that is present in the cortical vesicle system. Our data do not support the hypothesis that this particular heterotrimeric complex is by itself the biological fusogen.

Reconstitution of regulated exocytosis in cell-free systems: a critical appraisal

Regulated exocytosis involves the tightly controlled fusion of a transport vesicle with the plasma membrane. It includes processes as diverse as the release of neurotransmitters from presynaptic nerve endings and the sperm-triggered deposition of a barrier preventing polyspermy in oocytes. Cell-free model systems have been developed for studying the biochemical events underlying exocytosis. They range from semi-intact permeabilized cells to the reconstitution of membrane fusion from isolated secretory vesicles and their target plasma membranes. Interest in such cell-free systems has recently been reinvigorated by new evidence suggesting that membrane fusion is mediated by a basic mechanism common to all intracellular fusion events. In this chapter, we review some of the literature in the light of these new developments and attempt to provide a critical discussion of the strengths and limitations of the various cell-free systems.

Biochemical and functional studies of cortical vesicle fusion: the SNARE complex and Ca2+ sensitivity

Cortical vesicles (CV) possess components critical to the mechanism of exocytosis. The homotypic fusion of CV centrifuged or settled into contact has a sigmoidal Ca2+ activity curve comparable to exocytosis (CV-PM fusion). Here we show that Sr2+ and Ba2+ also trigger CV-CV fusion, and agents affecting different steps of exocytotic fusion block Ca2+, Sr2+, and Ba2+-triggered CV-CV fusion. The maximal number of active fusion complexes per vesicle, <n\>Max, was quantified by NEM inhibition of fusion, showing that CV-CV fusion satisfies many criteria of a mathematical analysis developed for exocytosis. Both <n\>Max and the Ca2+ sensitivity of fusion complex activation were comparable to that determined for CV-PM fusion. Using Ca2+-induced SNARE complex disruption, we have analyzed the relationship between membrane fusion (CV-CV and CV-PM) and the SNARE complex. Fusion and complex disruption have different sensitivities to Ca2+, Sr2+, and Ba2+, the complex remains Ca2+- sensitive on fusion-incompetent CV, and disruption does not correlate with the quantified activation of fusion complexes. Under conditions which disrupt the SNARE complex, CV on the PM remain docked and fusion competent, and isolated CV still dock and fuse, but with a markedly reduced Ca2+ sensitivity. Thus, in this system, neither the formation, presence, nor disruption of the SNARE complex is essential to the Ca2+-triggered fusion of exocytotic membranes. Therefore the SNARE complex alone cannot be the universal minimal fusion machine for intracellular fusion. We suggest that this complex modulates the Ca2+ sensitivity of fusion.

Calcium can disrupt the SNARE protein complex on sea urchin egg secretory vesicles without irreversibly blocking fusion

The homotypic fusion of sea urchin egg cortical vesicles (CV) is a system in which to correlate the biochemistry and physiology of membrane fusion. Homologues of vesicle-associated membrane protein (VAMP), syntaxin, and SNAP-25 were identified in CV membranes. A VAMP and syntaxin immunoreactive band at a higher apparent molecular mass (approximately 70 kDa) was detected; extraction and analysis confirmed that the band contained VAMP, SNAP-25, and syntaxin. This complex was also identified by immunoprecipitation and by sucrose gradient analysis. VAMP in the complex was insensitive to proteolysis by tetanus toxin. All criteria identify the SNARE complex as that described in other secretory systems. Complexes exist pre-formed on individual CV membranes and form between contacting CV. Most notably, CV SNARE complexes are disrupted in response to [Ca2+]free that trigger maximal fusion. N-Ethylmaleimide, which blocks fusion at or before the Ca2+-triggering step, blocks complex disruption by Ca2+. However, disruption is not blocked by lysophosphatidylcholine, which transiently arrests a late stage of fusion. Since removal of lysophosphatidylcholine from Ca2+-treated CV is known to allow fusion, complex disruption occurs independently from the membrane fusion step. As Ca2+ disrupts rather than stabilizes the complex, the presumably coiled-coil SNARE interactions are not needed at the time of fusion. These findings rule out models of fusion in which SNARE complex formation goes to completion ("zippers-up") after Ca2+ binding removes a "fusion-clamp."

Reconstitution of calcium-triggered membrane fusion using "reserve" granules

Calcium-gated secretion of proteins involves the transfer of "reserve" granules, exocytotic vesicles that are cytoplasmic and, hence, plasma membrane-naive, from the cell interior to the surface membrane where they dock prior to fusion. Docking and subsequent priming steps are thought to require cytoplasmic factors. These steps are believed to induce fusion competence. We have tested this hypothesis by isolating reserve granules from sea urchin eggs and determining under which conditions these granules will fuse. We find that isolated reserve granules, lacking soluble cofactors, support calcium-dependent membrane fusion in vitro. Preincubation with adenosine 5'-3-O-(thio)triphosphate and guanosine 5'-3-O-(thio)triphosphate did not prevent fusion. Thus, isolated reserve granules have all the necessary components required for calcium-gated fusion prior to docking.

The N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive protein thiol groups necessary for sea-urchin egg cortical-granule exocytosis are highly exposed to the medium and are required for triggering by Ca2+

It is known that sea-urchin egg cortical-granule exocytosis is inhibited by agents such as N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) which modify thiol groups. The fusion-related proteins modified by these agents have yet to be identified, nor is there information regarding the topography of these thiol groups. Furthermore, the step in cortical-granule exocytosis at which these thiol groups participate is unknown. In this study we have investigated the topological properties of, and the temporal requirement for the function of, the fusion-related thiol groups by treating the isolated exocytotic apparatus with high-molecular-mass dextrans and BSA carrying thiol-reactive 3-(2-pyridyldithio)propionate groups. The dextran derivatives inhibited exocytosis. The BSA derivative was much less inhibitory. Inhibition was reversed by treatment with dithiothreitol. When NEM was added to the dextran-derivative-treated exocytotic apparatus, treatment with dithiothreitol completely reversed inhibition, indicating that the dextran derivatives inhibit by reacting at the NEM-sensitive sites. A pulse of Ca2+ applied in the presence of inhibitors did not trigger any fusion following the removal of the inhibitor by dithiothreitol. These data show that the thiol groups, the modification of which by NEM inhibits exocytosis, are exposed to the medium in terms of their accessibility to macromolecules. They also show that the fusion-related thiol groups are required during the Ca(2+)-dependent stage of exocytosis.

A protein factor extracted from murine brains confers physiological Ca2+ sensitivity to exocytosis in sea urchin eggs

Exocytosis in sea urchin eggs can be reconstituted in vitro using the cell ghosts (the isolated cortices). When the isolated cortices were handled in the medium primarily composed of non-chaotropic ions, exocytosis can be induced by a micromolar level of Ca2+. However, when the cortices are exposed to chaotropic anions such as Cl-, it is induced only at higher Ca2+ concentrations of 10(-5) to 10(-4) M, due to the chaotropic anionic effect, by which a specific protein(s) is dissociated from the cortex. The dissociated protein can be added back to the cortex to restore the original Ca2+ sensitivity [(1984) Dev. Biol. 101, 125-135]. A protein which has the similar effect on the isolated cortex was also found in the extract of murine brain. This protein was neither calmodulin, a G-protein or a kinase. The data suggest the general regulatory mechanism of the Ca2+ sensitivity of exocytosis by a protein factor widely distributed among cells.

Proteins on exocytic vesicles mediate calcium-triggered fusion

In many exocytic systems, micromolar concentrations of intracellular Ca2+ trigger fusion. We find that aggregates of secretory granules isolated from sea urchin eggs fuse together when perfused with greater than or equal to 10 microM free Ca2+. Mixing of membrane components was demonstrated by transfer of fluorescent lipophilic dye, and melding of granule contents was seen with differential interference microscopy. A technique based upon light scattering was developed to conveniently detect fusion. Two protein modifiers, trypsin and N-ethylmaleimide, inhibit granule-granule fusion at concentrations similar to those that inhibit granule-plasma membrane fusion. We suggest that molecular machinery sufficient for Ca(2+)-triggered fusion resides on secretory granules as purified and that at least some of these essential components are proteinaceous.

Phosphoprotein inhibition of calcium-stimulated exocytosis in sea urchin eggs

We have investigated the role of protein phosphorylation in the control of exocytosis in sea urchin eggs by treating eggs with a thio-analogue of ATP. ATP gamma S (adenosine 5'-O-3-thiotriphosphate) is a compound which can be used as a phosphoryl donor by protein kinases, leading to irreversible protein thiophosphorylation (Gratecos, D., and E.H. Fischer. 1974. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 58:960-967). Microinjection of ATP gamma S inhibits cortical granule exocytosis, but has no effect on the sperm-egg signal transduction mechanisms which normally cause exocytosis by generating an increase in [Ca2+]i. ATP gamma S requires cytosolic factors for its inhibition of cortical granule exocytosis: it does not affect exocytosis when applied directly to the isolated exocytotic apparatus. Our data suggest that ATP gamma S irreversibly inhibits exocytosis via thiophosphorylation of proteins associated with the egg cortex. We have identified two thiophosphorylated proteins (33 and 27 kD) that are associated with the isolated exocytotic apparatus. They may mediate the inhibition of exocytosis by ATP gamma S. In addition, we show that okadaic acid, an inhibitor of phosphoprotein phosphatases, prevents cortical granule exocytosis at fertilization without affecting calcium mobilization. Like ATP gamma S, okadaic acid has no effect on exocytosis in vitro. Our results suggest that an inhibitory phosphoprotein can obstruct calcium-stimulated exocytosis in sea urchin eggs; on the other hand, they do not readily support the idea that a protein phosphatase is an essential component of the mechanism controlling exocytosis.

Reassociation of cortical secretory vesicles with sea urchin egg plasma membrane: assessment of binding specificity

An assay has been developed for quantitating the reassociation of cortical secretory vesicles (CVs) with fragments of sea urchin egg plasma membrane attached to glass slides (PM lawns). Binding of S. pupuratus CVs to homologous PM lawns increased with time and CV concentration. The observation that CV binding was blocked by chymotrypsin digestion of the PM fragments suggested that a PM protein(s) is required for reassociation. The possibility that the extent of CV lysis that occurred during CV preparation (15.4 +/- 3.8% as assessed by ovoperoxidase assay) influenced reassociation was investigated by determining the effect of CV content proteins (isolated as fertilization product) on binding. Various concentrations of fertilization product (up to equivalent amounts of fertilization product and CV protein) had no effect on CV binding. The specificity of binding was investigated by assessing the ability of CVs to bind to PM lawns prepared from human red blood cells, and by determining the ability of heterologous vesicles to bind to egg PM fragments. PM lawns from HRBCs did not support CV binding; however, PM lawns prepared from the eggs of several species of sea urchin did bind S. pupuratus CVs. Vesicles from a partially purified preparation of yolk platelets bound to egg PM lawns with low efficiency (1/7 that of CVs), but immunofluorescence analysis with an anti-hyalin monoclonal antibody demonstrated that 74 +/- 9% of the bound vesicles were CVs that contaminated the yolk platelet preparation. Dioleoylphosphatidyl choline liposomes were also unable to bind to egg PM lawns. These results are consistent with hypothesis that CV binding to egg PM lawns is a specific, protein-mediated event.