An experiment in enzyme evolution. Studies with Pseudomonas aeruginosa amidase

Experimental Evolution of Innovation and Novelty

How does novelty, a new, genetically based function, evolve? A compelling answer has been elusive because there are few model systems where both the genetic mechanisms generating novel functions and the ecological conditions that govern their origin and spread can be studied in detail. This review article considers what we have learned about the evolution of novelty from microbial selection experiments. This work reveals that the genetic routes to novelty can be more highly variable than standard models have led us to believe and underscores the importance of considering both genetics and ecology in this process.

The Experimental Study of Bacterial Evolution and Its Implications for the Modern Synthesis of Evolutionary Biology

Since the 1940s, microbiologists, biochemists and population geneticists have experimented with the genetic mechanisms of microorganisms in order to investigate evolutionary processes. These evolutionary studies of bacteria and other microorganisms gained some recognition from the standard-bearers of the modern synthesis of evolutionary biology, especially Theodosius Dobzhansky and Ledyard Stebbins. A further period of post-synthesis bacterial evolutionary research occurred between the 1950s and 1980s. These experimental analyses focused on the evolution of population and genetic structure, the adaptive gain of new functions, and the evolutionary consequences of competition dynamics. This large body of research aimed to make evolutionary theory testable and predictive, by giving it mechanistic underpinnings. Although evolutionary microbiologists promoted bacterial experiments as methodologically advantageous and a source of general insight into evolution, they also acknowledged the biological differences of bacteria. My historical overview concludes with reflections on what bacterial evolutionary research achieved in this period, and its implications for the still-developing modern synthesis.

Toward a systems biology perspective on enzyme evolution

Large superfamilies of enzymes derived from a common progenitor have emerged by duplication and divergence of genes encoding metabolic enzymes. Division of the functions of early generalist enzymes enhanced catalytic power and control over metabolic fluxes. Later, novel enzymes evolved from inefficient secondary activities in specialized enzymes. Enzymes operate in the context of complex metabolic and regulatory networks. The potential for evolution of a new enzyme depends upon the collection of enzymes in a microbe, the topology of the metabolic network, the environmental conditions, and the net effect of trade-offs between the original and novel activities of the enzyme.

Adaptive evolution of Escherichia coli K-12 MG1655 during growth on a Nonnative carbon source, L-1,2-propanediol

Laboratory adaptive evolution studies can provide key information to address a wide range of issues in evolutionary biology. Such studies have been limited thus far by the inability of workers to readily detect mutations in evolved microbial strains on a genome scale. This limitation has now been overcome by recently developed genome sequencing technology that allows workers to identify all accumulated mutations that appear during laboratory adaptive evolution. In this study, we evolved Escherichia coli K-12 MG1655 with a nonnative carbon source, l-1,2-propanediol (l-1,2-PDO), for approximately 700 generations. We found that (i) experimental evolution of E. coli for approximately 700 generations in 1,2-PDO-supplemented minimal medium resulted in acquisition of the ability to use l-1,2-PDO as a sole carbon and energy source so that the organism changed from an organism that did not grow at all initially to an organism that had a growth rate of 0.35 h(-1); (ii) six mutations detected by whole-genome resequencing accumulated in the evolved E. coli mutant over the course of adaptive evolution on l-1,2-PDO; (iii) five of the six mutations were within coding regions, and IS5 was inserted between two fuc regulons; (iv) two major mutations (mutations in fucO and its promoter) involved in l-1,2-PDO catabolism appeared early during adaptive evolution; and (v) multiple defined knock-in mutant strains with all of the mutations had growth rates essentially matching that of the evolved strain. These results provide insight into the genetic basis underlying microbial evolution for growth on a nonnative substrate.

Evolution of efficient pathways for degradation of anthropogenic chemicals

Anthropogenic compounds used as pesticides, solvents and explosives often persist in the environment and can cause toxicity to humans and wildlife. The persistence of anthropogenic compounds is due to their recent introduction into the environment; microbes in soil and water have had relatively little time to evolve efficient mechanisms for degradation of these new compounds. Some anthropogenic compounds are easily degraded, whereas others are degraded very slowly or only partially, leading to accumulation of toxic products. This review examines the factors that affect the ability of microbes to degrade anthropogenic compounds and the mechanisms by which new pathways emerge in nature. New approaches for engineering microbes with enhanced degradative abilities include assembly of pathways using enzymes from multiple organisms, directed evolution of inefficient enzymes, and genome shuffling to improve microbial fitness under the challenging conditions posed by contaminated environments.

A compromise required by gene sharing enables survival: Implications for evolution of new enzyme activities

Evolution of new enzymatic activities is believed to require a period of gene sharing in which a single enzyme must serve both its original function and a new function that has become advantageous to the organism. Subsequent gene duplication allows one copy to maintain the original function, while the other diverges to optimize the new function. The physiological impact of gene sharing and the constraints imposed by the need to maintain the original activity during the early stages of evolution of a new activity have not been addressed experimentally. We report here an investigation of the evolution of a new activity under circumstances in which both the original and the new activity are critical for growth. Glutamylphosphate reductase (ProA) has a very low promiscuous activity with N-acetylglutamylphosphate, the normal substrate for ArgC (N-acetylglutamylphosphate reductase). A mutation that changes Glu-383 to Ala increases the promiscuous activity by 12-fold but decreases the original activity by 2,800-fold. The impairment in Pro and Arg synthesis results in 14-fold overexpression of E383A ProA, providing sufficient N-acetylglutamylphosphate reductase activity to allow a strain lacking ArgC to grow on glucose. Thus, reaching the threshold level of NAGP reductase activity required for survival required both a structural mutation and overexpression of the enzyme. Notably, overexpression does not require a mutation in the regulatory region of the protein; amino acid limitation attributable to the poor catalytic abilities of E383A ProA causes a physiological response that results in overexpression.

The antigenic and catalytically active formamidase of Paracoccidioides brasiliensis: protein characterization, cDNA and gene cloning, heterologous expression and functional analysis of the recombinant protein

Paracoccidioides brasiliensis is a well-characterized pathogen of humans. To identify proteins involved in the fungus-host interaction, P. brasiliensis yeast proteins were separated by liquid isoelectric focusing, and fractions were subjected to sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Western blot analysis. Immunoreactive bands were detected with pooled sera of patients with P. brasiliensis infection. A protein species with a molecular mass of 45 kDa was subsequently purified to homogeneity by preparative gel electrophoresis. The amino acid sequence of four endoproteinase Lys-C-digested peptides indicated that the protein was a formamidase (FMD) (E.C. 3.5.1.49) of P. brasiliensis. The complete cDNA and a genomic clone (Pbfmd) encoding the isolated FMD were isolated. An open reading frame predicted a 415-amino acid protein. The sequence contained each of the peptide sequences obtained from amino acid sequencing. The Pbfmd gene contained five exons interrupted by four introns. Northern and Southern blot analysis suggested that there is one copy of the gene in P. brasiliensis and that it is preferentially expressed in mycelium. The complete coding cDNA was expressed in Escherichia coli to produce a recombinant fusion protein with glutathione S-transferase (GST). The purified recombinant protein was recognized by sera of patients with proven paracoccidioidomycosis and not by sera of healthy individuals. The recombinant 45-kDa protein was shown to be catalytically active; FMD activity was detected in P. brasiliensis yeast and mycelium.

Structural adaptation to selective pressure for altered ligand specificity in the Pseudomonas aeruginosa amide receptor, amiC

The AmiC protein in Pseudomonas aeruginosa is the negative regulator and ligand receptor for an amide-inducible aliphatic amidase operon. In the wild-type PAC1 strain, amidase expression is induced by acetamide or lactamide, but not by butyramide. A mutant strain of P. aeruginosa, PAC181, was selected for its sensitivity to induction by butyramide. The molecular basis for the butyramide inducible phenotype of P.aeruginosa PAC181 has now been determined, and results from a Thr-->Asn mutation at position 106 in PAC181-AmiC. In the wild-type PAC1-AmiC protein this residue forms part of the side wall of the amide-binding pocket but does not interact with the acetamide ligand directly. In the crystal structure of PAC181-AmiC complexed with butyramide, the Thr-->Asn mutation increases the size of the ligand binding site such that the mutant protein is able to close into its 'on' configuration even in the presence of butyramide. Although the mutation allows butyramide to be recognized as an inducer of amidase expression, the mutation is structurally sub-optimal, and produces a significant decrease in the stability of the mutant protein.

Molecular characterisation of formamidase from Methylophilus methylotrophus

A 3.2-kbp PstI fragment of DNA encoding formamidase from the methylotrophic bacterium Methylophilus methylotrophus which had previously been cloned (pNW3) [Wyborn, N.R., Scherr, D.J. & Jones, C.W. (1994) Microbiology 140, 191-195], was subcloned as a 2.3 kbp HindIII fragment (pNW323). Nucleotide sequencing showed that the subclone contained two genes which encoded formamidase (fmdA) and a possible regulatory protein (fmdB). Predicted molecular masses for FmdA and FmdB were 44438 Da (compared with approximately 44500 Da by electrospray mass spectrometry and 51000 Da by SDS/PAGE of the purified enzyme) and 12306 Da, respectively. The derived amino acid sequence of formamidase was supported by N-terminal amino acid sequencing of the enzyme and of proteolytic fragments prepared from it using V8 endoproteinase and was 57% similar to that of the acetamidase from Mycobacterium smegmatis. The structural similarities between these two enzymes, and their existence as a separate class of bacterial amidase, were confirmed by immunological investigations.

Microbial systems and directed evolution of protein activities

Recent advances in recombinant DNA methodology have had an important impact on the capacity to manipulate protein-coding sequences. The appearance of new, powerful screening systems completes a scenario for conducting directed evolution experiments. We review here some of the latest developments in experimental approaches to directed evolution, utilizing microbial systems. These include phage display, surface display, operator-repressor systems, and novel mutagenesis approaches. We also highlight the achievements and limitations of current methodologies. We present strategies used by our own group that permitted isolation of specificity mutants of beta-lactamase. Possible improvements for the future of the variation-selection approach to the study and manipulation of proteins are presented.

Cloning and DNA sequence of amiC, a new gene regulating expression of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa aliphatic amidase, and purification of the amiC product

Using in vitro-constructed deletions and subcloned DNA fragments, we have identified a new gene, amiC, which regulates expression of the inducible Pseudomonas aeruginosa aliphatic amidase activity. The DNA sequence of the gene has been determined, and an open reading frame encoding a polypeptide of 385 amino acids (molecular mass, 42,834 Da) has been identified. A search of sequence libraries has failed to find homologies with other published sequences. The amiC translation termination codon (A)TGA overlaps the initiation codon for the downstream amiR transcription antitermination factor gene, implying that the amiCR operon is coordinately regulated. Disruption of the amiC open reading frame by insertion and deletion leads to constitutive amidase synthesis, suggesting that AmiC is a negative regulator. This is confirmed by the finding that a broad-host-range expression vector carrying amiC (pSW41) represses amidase expression in a series of previously characterized P. aeruginosa amidase-constitutive mutants. The AmiC polypeptide has been purified from PAC452(pSW41), and N-terminal amino acid sequencing has confirmed the gene identification.

Directed evolution of amidase in Methylophilus methylotrophus; purification and properties of amidases from wild-type and mutant strains

The obligately methylotrophic bacterium Methylophilusmethylotrophus hydrolyses acetamide and acrylamide using a cytoplasmic amidase. In previous work, continuous culture was used to isolate spontaneous mutants which overexpressed either the wild-type amidase (strain MM6) or a mutant amidase with an apparently higher K cat (strain MM8). We now report that NTG mutagenesis of strain MM8 followed by acrylamide-limited growth at low dilution rate (D 0·025 h-1; 37 °C) led to the selection of a strain which continued to overexpress the amidase, but which exhibited an unexpectedly low amidase activity and a greatly decreased K m for acrylamide (strain MM15). Amidases from the wild-type and mutant strains were purified and shown to be homotetramers (subunit M r 38000, pI 4·1). The N-terminal amino acid sequence of the wild-type enzyme was 90% homologous with the aliphatic amidase from Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Southern blotting using an oligonucleotide probe for this region showed that overexpression of the enzyme in the mutant strains was not due to gene amplification. Compared with the wild-type and MM6 enzymes, the MM8 enzyme exhibited a threefold higher K m and a slightly lower K m for acrylamide, whereas the MM15 enzyme exhibited a similar K cat and an eightfold lower K m for acrylamide. The MM15 enzyme also reacted more extensively with the thiol group reagent DTNB, had a significantly lower sedimentation coefficient and exhibited a more relaxed substrate specificity, all of which were compatible with a looser tetrameric structure. It was also much more susceptible than the other three enzymes to inactivation by high temperature or by freezing and thawing (MM15»MM8>MM6/wild-type), both of which variably dissociated the enzyme into inactive dimers and monomers. The amidase activity of strain MM15 was almost 15-fold higher following growth at 25 °C than at 37 °C, since at this lower temperature the enzyme exhibited a similar K cat to the MM8 enzyme and was not significantly dissociated. However, as strain MM15 readily outgrew the organism from which it was derived (strain MM8) during acrylamide-limited continuous culture at 37 °C, it is clear that under these conditions a low K m was a greater selective advantage than a high K cat.