In situ lymphoproliferation in renal transplant biopsies

Substantial proliferation of human renal tubular epithelial cell-reactive CD4+CD28null memory T cells, which is resistant to tacrolimus and everolimus

BACKGROUND

In spite of maintenance treatment with immunosuppressive drugs, tubulitis still occurs and can lead to structural kidney graft damage. We hypothesize that human renal tubular epithelial cells (TECs) trigger selective proliferation of recipient T-cell subsets with variable sensitivity to immunosuppressive drugs.

METHODS

Recipient peripheral blood mononuclear cells were cocultured with donor-derived TECs for 7 days. The proliferation of the total CD4 T-cell pool was assessed. Next, we analyzed which CD4 T-cell subset proliferated and how this response was affected by tacrolimus, everolimus, prednisolone, and mycophenolic acid (MPA) in clinically relevant concentrations.

RESULTS

CD4 T-cell proliferation upon TEC encounter was mainly executed by memory T cells. Interestingly, 38%±7% of the proliferating CD4 T-cell pool showed a CD28 phenotype. These proliferating CD4CD28 memory T cells produced high levels of interferon-γ, tumor necrosis factor-α, and the cytolitic protease granzyme B. TEC-reactive CD4 T-cell proliferation was significantly suppressed by tacrolimus, everolimus, prednisolone, and MPA (P<0.05). Surprisingly and in contrast to prednisolone and MPA, neither tacrolimus nor everolimus could inhibit the CD4CD28 T-cell proliferative response.

CONCLUSION

Our data show substantial proliferation of TEC-reactive CD4CD28 memory T cells, which are resistant to tacrolimus and everolimus. This phenomenon might play an important mechanistic role during cellular rejection under full immunosuppression.

Renal allograft rejection: the contribution of chemokines to the adhesion and retention of alphaE(CD103)beta7 integrin-expressing intratubular T cells

Recruitment of activated T cells to the tubules is a defining feature of cell-mediated renal allograft rejection. Many of these intratubular T cells express the alphaE(CD103)beta7 integrin, potentially allowing adhesion to epithelial cells which express the only defined counter-receptor, E-cadherin. However, the potential of rejection-associated intratubular chemokines to modulate the adhesive function of this integrin has not been investigated. This study demonstrated that CCL7 is expressed within the tubules during renal allograft rejection. Modelling with CD103-expressing MOLT-16 T cells demonstrated chemotactic responses to the chemokines CXCL10, CXCL12, CCL5 and, most significantly, CCL7 (p<0.001); these responses were consistent with the expression of CXCR3, CXCR4 and CCR1 by these cells. A solid-phase adhesion assay showed little background binding of MOLT-16 cells to immobilised human E-cadherin.Fc fusion protein but alphaEbeta7 integrin-specific adhesion was greatly increased by the addition of either Mn2+ or 10nM CCL7 (p<0.01 or <0.001, respectively). Treatment of activated human peripheral T cells with TGFbeta1 for 3 days induced the expression of CD103 on a mean 53% of these cells; a similar proportion of CD103+ and CD103- T cells within these cultures expressed receptors for the chemokine CCL7. CD103+ T cell fractions were sorted from mitogen- or alloantigen-activated, TGFbeta1-treated T cell cultures and also showed specific enhancement of adhesion to E-cadherin.Fc fusion protein following stimulation with Mn2+ or 10nM CCL7 (p<0.01 in all cases); CD103- T cells were not adherent under any conditions. Together these data suggest that although the alphaEbeta7 integrin is induced on activated intratubular T cells by the presence of TGFbeta, the adhesive function of this integrin is promoted by the presence of chemokines such as CCL7, which are also expressed within tubules during renal allograft rejection.

Lymphoid cell proliferation in renal transplants: biologic and diagnostic implications

It is unclear whether alloreaction develops in peripheral lymphoid organs and effector cells being recruited to the target organs, or the entire process of alloreaction can happen within the transplanted kidneys. Interstitial inflammatory cell (IIC) proliferation was evaluated by MIB-1 antigen immunostain and the rate expressed as positive cells/1000 cells. This rate was higher in acute cell-mediated rejection (ACR) (25.7, n = 14) compared with normal kidney (0.4, n = 8), acute tubular necrosis (1.2, n = 8), chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN, 2.4, n = 20), and native kidneys with diverse diseases (9.2, n = 63); but was comparable to that in CAN with significant IIC (20.6, n = 16). 10.1% and 8.3% of T lymphocytes underwent proliferation in ACR with or without CAN, whereas only rare B lymphocytes or macrophages showed this change (<1.2%), regardless of diagnostic categories. All biopsies diagnosed as ACR in conjunction with a high rate of MIB-1 + IIC and 9/12 biopsies with CAN and significant IIC in which ACR was diagnosed due to a high rate of MIB-1 + IIC, responded to anti-rejection therapy. Proliferation of IIC involves predominantly T lymphocytes. These observations provide support for the concept of in situ alloimmunization, and facilitate the diagnosis of ACR.

Implications of Immunohistochemical Detection of C4d along Peritubular Capillaries in Late Acute Renal Allograft Rejection

BACKGROUND

Immunohistochemical detection of the C4d complement product along peritubular capillaries (PC) may indicate humoral rejection of renal allografts. We examined the frequency of PC C4d expression in renal-allograft biopsies with acute rejection (AR) arising more than 6 months after transplantation and the impact of this finding.

METHODS

C4d was detected by immunoperoxidase in 2-micron paraffin sections of consecutive biopsies obtained over a 3-year period. The extent was classified as diffuse (> or =50% PC C4d+), focal (<50% C4d+), and negative (C4d-). Clinical data were obtained by retrospective chart review. Fifty-five AR episodes with Banff 97 types 1A (n = 13), 1B (n = 26), 2A (n = 11), 2B (n = 3), and 3 (n = 2) met inclusion criteria.

RESULTS

PC C4d expression was diffuse in 23 (42%), focal in 9 (16%), and negative in 23 (42%) biopsies. AR episodes with focal and diffuse C4d expression had higher proportionate elevation of serum creatinine at biopsy and 4 weeks after diagnosis (P< or =0.05). Biopsies with diffuse PC C4d had interstitial hemorrhage (56.5%) and plasmacytic infiltrates (52%) more frequently than C4d- biopsies (22% and 16%), P = 0.02, but had no other distinctive histologic features. Graft loss was greater in diffuse (65%) compared with focal C4d+ (33%) and C4d- (33%) groups 1 year after diagnosis, P = 0.03. Other clinical and pathologic parameters did not differ significantly, including treatment received for AR.

CONCLUSION

Evidence of acute cellular with occult humoral rejection is identified in more than 40% of late AR episodes. Late acute humoral rejection may be associated with interstitial hemorrhage and plasma cells and contributes significantly to graft loss.

Tubulitis in renal allograft rejection: role of transforming growth factor-beta and interleukin-15 in development and maintenance of CD103+ intraepithelial T cells

BACKGROUND

Renal tubules normally show no lymphocyte infiltration, but tubulitis is a feature of renal allograft rejection with many intratubular T cells expressing CD8 and CD103 (the alphaEbeta7 integrin). We investigated the development and maintenance of allospecific CD103 T cells within the tubular microenvironment.

METHODS

Mixed lymphocyte cultures were supplemented with transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta1 to model the expression and function of CD103 observed in situ on intratubular lymphocytes. Immunocytochemical techniques were used to identify cells coexpressing CD8 and interleukin (IL)-15Ralpha, to enumerate proliferating intratubular T cells, and to quantify IL-15 expression within the tubules of control and rejection-graded transplant biopsy specimens. These results were compared with a parallel analysis of the phenotype and proliferation of allospecific T cells expanded in vitro in the presence of TGF-beta1 and IL-15.

RESULTS

TGF-beta1 only induced the expression of adhesive CD103 after at least one cycle of alloantigen-specific cell division in vitro. In the renal allograft, a similar proportion of intratubular T cells was observed to proliferate during and after acute rejection. Tubular epithelial cells expressed IL-15 constitutively, whereas intratubular CD8 T cells expressed IL-15 receptor alpha. IL-15 and TGF-beta1 synergized to promote expansion and survival of allospecific CD8 CD103 T cells in vitro, but IL-15 down-regulated perforin expression.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that activated, allospecific CD8 T cells are recruited to tubules during acute rejection where they encounter TGF-beta, up-regulate CD103 expression, and bind E-cadherin. A proportion of these cells proliferates and is maintained in a state of low perforin expression by the combined action of TGF-beta and IL-15.

Post-transplant renal tubulitis: the recruitment, differentiation and persistence of intra-epithelial T cells

Tubulitis is used by the Banff protocol as a major criterion to grade acute renal allograft rejection. This review integrates results from in vitro and in vivo studies to develop a chronological model to explain the development and functions of tubular inflammation during the rejection process. Proteoglycan-immobilized chemokines are the primary motivators for the vectorial recruitment of specific immune cell populations from the blood, through the endothelium and interstitial tissues to the renal tubules. After penetration of the basement membrane, T cells encounter TGF-beta that can induce expression of the alphaEbeta7 integrin on proliferating cells. This allows adhesion to E-cadherin on the baso-lateral surfaces of tubular epithelial cells and provides an explanation for the epithelial-specific cytotoxicity observed during acute rejection. Tubular epithelium is also a rich source of IL-15 that can stimulate IL-15 receptor-expressing intratubular CD8+ T cells. This anti-apoptotic microenvironment may explain the long-term persistence of cycling T cells within intact tubules after episodes of acute rejection. These memory-like T cells may have local immunoregulatory properties, including the production of additional TGF-beta, but could also modify normal tubular homeostasis resulting in epithelial to mesenchymal transdifferentiation, tubulointerstitial fibrosis and, ultimately, graft failure.

Tubulitis after renal transplantation: demonstration of an association between CD103+ T cells, transforming growth factor beta1 expression and rejection grade

BACKGROUND

Tubulitis is a defining feature for the diagnosis and management of acute renal allograft rejection. Lymphocytes extracted from rejecting renal tissue are known to express the alphaEbeta7-integrin (CD103), a receptor for E-cadherin expressed on epithelial cells. In this study, expression of CD103 was examined in situ in tubulitis associated with acute rejection.

METHODS

Immuno-labeling detected CD8+ and CD103+ lymphocytes and E-cadherin on epithelial cells in cryostat sections from 34 diagnostic biopsy specimens and a limited number of transplant nephrectomies. CD8+ and CD103+ intratubular cells were enumerated as mean numbers per tubular crosssection and median values were compared between rejection grades as were median ratios of CD103+ to CD8+ cells. Active transforming growth factor (TGF) beta1 was quantified in paraffin sections by immunofluorescence and confocal microscopical analysis. A parallel in vitro study quantified CD103+ T cells after allospecific activation with and without exogenous TGFbeta1.

RESULTS

CD8+ T cells were present in tubules and tubular interstitium in acute rejection. CD103+ T cells were restricted exclusively to the tubules. The numbers of intratubular CD8+ and CD103+ cells and the ratio of intratubular CD103+ to CD8+ cells increased significantly with tubulitis score (P values 0.005, 0.009, and 0.02, respectively). TGFbeta1 expression was wide-spread in tubules also increasing significantly with tubulitis score (P=0.034). In chronic rejection, CD103+ T cells and TGFbeta1 were present within both tubules and interstitial cell populations. The in vitro study demonstrated that addition of TGFbeta1 to activated, alloantigen-specific T cells increased the proportion of CD8+ cells that also expressed CD103.

CONCLUSIONS

These data indicate that specific upregulation of the alphaEbeta7-integrin by activated, intratubular T cells in acute renal allograft rejection could be a consequence of exposure to high local concentrations of TGFbeta1. The capacity of CD103+ T cells to bind E-cadherin on tubular epithelial cells may be an important factor in the pathogenesis of specific tissue damage observed in acute renal allograft rejection.

Intragraft proliferating T lymphocytes are associated with moderate acute pulmonary rejection

Acute allograft rejection is characterized by infiltration of the donor organ by host lymphoid cells, predominantly T lymphocytes. However, the site of proliferation and clonal expansion of alloreactive T lymphocytes is not well defined in man. A group of normal transbronchial biopsies (TBB, n=9) from clinically well lung transplant recipients was compared to TBB showing acute rejection (at least grade A2, n=9), using CD3- and Ki67-specific antibodies to double-label proliferating T lymphocytes. Few double-labeled lymphocytes were present in the normal biopsies (range, 0-3 cells). However, five of the rejection biopsies contained significant numbers of proliferating T lymphocytes (range, 19-47; Fisher's exact test; P=0.029). Furthermore, this positive group contained all three cases of grade A3 rejection in the study, as well as a case with persistent grade A2 rejection on follow-up biopsy. These data demonstrate that T lymphocytes do proliferate in transplanted human lungs; such proliferation is associated with more severe rejection.

Renal allograft rejection: beta-chemokine involvement in the development of tubulitis

BACKGROUND

Tubulitis is a defining feature of renal allograft rejection. Graft dysfunction may result from damage inflicted on tubular epithelial cells by intratubular cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Graft cells are known to produce chemokines during acute rejection, but it is not known whether changes in expression of specific chemokines can influence the composition of the intratubular lymphocyte population. We examined expression of individual chemokines in biopsy sections showing different pathological rejection grades.

METHODS

Sections from Banff-graded transplant biopsies were examined for the presence of beta-chemokines (MCP-1, MIP-1alpha, MIP-1beta, and RANTES) by immunofluorescence and semiquantitative confocal laser scanning microscopy.

RESULTS

Beta-chemokines were expressed predominantly at the basolateral surface of tubular epithelial cells. Expression of MCP-1 and MIP-1beta was significantly higher in sections showing grade 2 rather than grade 1 acute rejection. RANTES and MIP-1alpha showed no significant variation in level of expression between rejection grades.

CONCLUSIONS

Beta-chemokines are expressed by tubular epithelial cells during acute rejection. Consistent expression of RANTES and MIP-1alpha suggests a general role in recruiting T lymphocytes. However, MCP-1 and MIP-1beta may play a more subtle role in recruitment of specific T-cell subsets, such as Th1 cells, during acute cellular rejection.

Ex vivo propagation and characterization of lymphocytes from rejecting rat-kidney allografts

Today, most clinically used methods for analysis of alloreactivity in organ transplantation are based on humoral immunity. In order to study the cellular alloresponse, a rat kidney transplantation model with culturing of graft infiltrating lymphocytes was developed. Kidney transplantations between inbred rat strains were performed with the animals initially immunosuppressed with cyclosporine. In order to initiate acute cellular rejection, immunosuppression was withdrawn after 10 days. Infiltrating lymphocytes were analysed using an in vitro culture system, allowing cells to propagate from the biopsies to culture medium. The propagated cells were counted and analysed for subtype activation markers and donor-specificity using flow cytometry and a proliferation assay. Syngeneically transplanted animals and animals given constant immunosuppression upon transplantation were used as controls. During rejection, significantly more T lymphocytes were propagating from the biopsies compared to controls. A higher percentage of the propagated T lymphocytes in the rejection group expressed activation markers [CD25 and major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II antigen] compared to spleen- and peripheral blood T lymphocytes from the same individuals. Propagated mononuclear cells from biopsies in the rejection group were proliferating and showed donor-specific reactivity whereas mononuclear spleen cells from animals in the same group did not show this donor specificity. In conclusion, we have presented a rat kidney allotransplantation model with in vitro propagation of graft-infiltrating, activated and donor-specific T lymphocytes. This technique offers a possibility to study cellular reactivity in allotransplantation.

Mechanisms of lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity in acute renal allograft rejection

BACKGROUND

Graft-infiltrating T-cell (GIC) lines cultured from biopsies obtained during acute renal allograft rejection exhibit donor-specific cytotoxicity toward proximal tubular epithelial cell (PTEC) lines cultured from corresponding biopsies. This system allows for study of the relative contributions of perforin/granzyme B (GrB)- and Fas ligand (FasL)-based cytotoxicity to killing of PTEC.

METHODS

Expression of perforin, GrB and FasL was analyzed by immunocytochemical staining of cytocentrifuge preparations of GIC lines cultured from 10 renal allograft biopsies. Specific inhibitors of the perforin/GrB- and FasL-based pathways were used in 51Cr release and apoptosis assays to determine their relative contributions to cytotoxicity of GIC lines toward corresponding donor PTEC lines.

RESULTS

Cells with a strong granular pattern were observed upon immunocytochemical staining of GIC lines with anti-perforin or anti-GrB monoclonal antibodies. A diffuse staining pattern was observed upon staining with anti-FasL polyclonal antibodies. Six of eight GIC lines cultured from biopsies with acute rejection showed cytotoxicity toward corresponding donor PTEC lines, whereas two GIC lines cultured from biopsies without rejection did not. Preincubation of cytotoxic GIC lines with concanamycin A, an inhibitor of the perforin/GrB-based pathway, caused inhibition of both lysis and apoptosis of PTEC. Inhibition was not observed upon incubation with monoclonal antibodies that inhibit Fas.

CONCLUSIONS

The perforin/GrB-based pathway is mainly responsible for cytotoxicity of GIC lines toward corresponding donor PTEC lines, suggesting that this pathway predominates in tubular epithelial cell destruction by cytotoxic T lymphocytes during acute renal allograft rejection in vivo.

Demonstration of the proliferation marker Ki-67 in renal biopsies: correlation to clinical findings

Assessment of cell proliferation in renal biopsy samples is a potentially promising analytical tool to evaluate disease activity. So far no information is available on the correlation between proliferative activity in different anatomic compartments of the kidney and clinical symptoms. To elucidate this issue, we examined renal biopsy specimens from 20 patients with systemic vasculitis (15 Wegener's granulomatosis, five microscopic polyangiitis), 20 patients with immunoglobulin (Ig) A nephropathy (IgAN), 13 patients with minimal-change disease (MCD), 11 patients with tubulointerstitial nephritis, and five patients with diabetes mellitus. The streptavidin-biotin-peroxidase complex technique was applied to autoclave-pretreated, formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections to label different cell types with the antibody MIB1 directed against the Ki-67 antigen. Proliferation index (PI) was estimated as the number of positively stained nuclei per glomerular cross-section or per square millimeter section area. The interstitial cells were discriminated by additional staining of Ki-67-processed samples with specific immune markers. In patients with vasculitis, PI was considerably elevated in the extracapillary glomerular compartment (0.86), in proximal tubules (6.24), and in the interstitium (8.62). High proliferative activity was also noted in interstitium (3.98) and proximal tubules (1.35) of patients with IgAN. Of particular interest was the increased interstitial proliferative activity (15.0) in diabetic patients. Resident renal cells, but not infiltrating cells, seemed to constitute the majority of the proliferating cell population in the interstitium. In systemic vasculitis, clinical disease activity was significantly correlated to endocapillary (r(s) = 0.58), extracapillary (r(s) = 0.67), proximal tubular (r(s) = 0.67), and interstitial PI (r(s) = 0.61). By multiple linear regression analysis, proximal tubular PI was correlated to the presence of hematuria (beta = 0.72) and to interstitial fibrosis score (beta = 0.59). Interstitial PI was independently correlated to antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCA) titer (beta = 0.7) and interstitial fibrosis score (beta = 0.55), and it was the only one PI correlated to serum creatinine concentration (beta = 0.53). The independent association between interstitial PI and serum creatinine (beta = 0.64) was also found in IgAN. Proximal tubular PI was correlated to interstitial fibrosis score (beta = 0.59) and proteinuria (beta = 0.54). In MCD, high PI values were noted in proximal tubular cells (1.42) but not in glomeruli and the interstitium. In conclusion, assessment of proliferation activity by immunohistology provides additional information beyond conventional pathological techniques to evaluate disease activity and prognosis in renal biopsies.

Renal allograft rejection--in situ demonstration of cytotoxic intratubular cells

A nonisotopic in situ hybridization method to detect perforin mRNA was developed in cytospin preparations of IL-2-stimulated normal human lymphocytes and applied to formalin-fixed acutely rejected renal transplant material. Individual cells expressing perforin mRNA were localized in severely damaged tubular areas, and a number of these cells appeared to be located inside the tubular basement membrane in close association with tubular epithelial cells. Immunoperoxidase staining in acetone-fixed cryostat sections of acutely rejected kidney confirmed that a considerable proportion of infiltrating cells was CD8+; many of these were in an intratubular location. In addition, perforin protein was identified in individual cells in similar locations to perforin mRNA-positive cells. Again, some intratubular cells were identified. Our findings illustrate that these cells can be fully activated with definite cytotoxic potential. Previously we have demonstrated that T lymphocytes proliferate within the tubular compartment during tubulitis, a characteristic condition in acute renal allograft rejection, and that there is associated tubular epithelial cell proliferation. In this study we think that we have further clarified the consequences of invasion of tubules by lymphoid cells. Our in situ hybridization method in rapid and convenient and may be applied to archival material.