Activation ofClostridium perfringens cytotoxic enterotoxin(s) in vivo and in vitro: Role in triggers for sudden infant death

SIDS pathogenesis: pathological findings indicate infection and inflammatory responses are involved

This article explores the pathological evidence that supports the hypothesis that infection and inflammation are underlying mechanisms in SIDS. It reviews the pathological findings in relation to the risk factors reported for SIDS and compares these findings with other hypotheses suggested as causes of these unexplained deaths in infants. The roles of environmental factors and bacterial products such as soluble curlin detectable in SIDS sera in triggering cytokine cascades and aberrant inflammatory responses resulting in a toxic shock-like event are also explored. Areas for future research are outlined.

Ethnicity, infection and sudden infant death syndrome

Epidemiological studies found the incidence of SIDS among Indigenous groups such as Aboriginal Australians, New Zealand Maoris and Native Americans were significantly higher than those for non-Indigenous groups within the same countries. Among other groups such as Asian families in Britain, the incidence of SIDS has been lower than among groups of European origin. Cultural and childrearing practices as well as socio-economic factors have been proposed to explain the greater risk of SIDS among Indigenous peoples; however, there are no definitive data to account for the differences observed. We addressed the differences among ethnic groups in relation to susceptibility to infection because there is evidence from studies of populations of European origin that infectious agents, particularly toxigenic bacteria might trigger the events leading to SIDS. The risk factors for SIDS parallel those for susceptibility to infections in infants, particularly respiratory tract infections which are also major health problems among Indigenous groups. Many of the risk factors identified in epidemiological studies of SIDS could affect three stages in the infectious process: (1) frequency or density of colonisation by the toxigenic species implicated in SIDS; (2) induction of temperature-sensitive toxins; (3) modulation of the inflammatory responses to infection or toxins. In this review we compare genetic, developmental and environmental risk factors for SIDS in ethnic groups with different incidences of SIDS: low (Asians in Britain); moderate (European/Caucasian); high (Aboriginal Australian). Our findings indicate: (1) the major difference was high levels of exposure to cigarette smoke among infants in the high risk groups; (2) cigarette smoke significantly reduced the anti-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-10 responses which control pro-inflammatory responses implicated in SIDS; (3) the most significant effect of cigarette smoke on reduction of IL-10 responses was observed for donors with a single nucleotide polymorphism for the IL-10 gene that is predominant among both Asian and Aboriginal populations. If genetic makeup were a major factor for susceptibility to SIDS, the incidence of these deaths should be similar for both populations. They are, however, significantly different and most likely reflect differences in maternal smoking which could affect frequency and density of colonisation of infants by potentially pathogenic bacteria and induction and control of inflammatory responses.

The role of bacterial toxins in sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)

There is increasing evidence for the involvement of bacterial toxins in some cases of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), particularly the pyrogenic toxins of Staphylococcus aureus. This had led to the hypothesis that some SIDS deaths are due to induction of inflammatory mediators by infectious agents or their products during a period in which the infant is unable to control these normally protective responses. The genetic, developmental and environmental risk factors identified for SIDS are assessed in relation to frequency or density of mucosal colonisation by toxigenic bacteria and their effects on induction and control of inflammatory responses to the toxins.

Intestinal epithelial damage in sids babies and its similarity to that caused by bacterial toxins in the rabbit

Sections of the duodenum, jejunum, ileum, caecum and large intestine from 14 sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) babies were examined by scanning (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The type and amount of damage was characterised and quantitated and compared with the presence of Clostridium perfringens, Clostridium difficile, Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus in faecal samples from the babies and toxins from the bacteria in faecal samples and serum from the babies. The data were compared with the damage that these toxins cause to the rabbit intestinal epithelium (see the previous paper in this issue). Damage was present in most of the SIDS samples, varying from 0 to 96%, and most damage occurred when the faecal samples contained the above bacteria and their toxins. Damage varied from removal of microvilli, damage to villus tips, separation of and removal of epithelial cells from the lamina propria, and removal of enterocytes leaving goblet and tuft cells, to damage and breakdown of the lamina propria. The results support the hypothesis that the cause of death in a significant proportion of SIDS babies may result from the absorption of toxins from the intestinal tract initiating a toxic shock reaction.

Review of risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome

Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) accounts for the largest number of deaths during the first year of life in developed countries. The possible causes of SIDS are numerous and, to date, there is no adequate unifying pathological explanation for SIDS. Epidemiological studies have played a key role in identifying risk factors, knowledge of which has underpinned successful preventive programmes. This review critically assesses information on the main risk factors and causal hypotheses put forward for SIDS, focusing on research published since 1994. The overall picture that emerges from this review is that affected infants are not completely normal in development, but possess some inherent weakness, which may only become obvious when the infant is subjected to stress. Initially there may be some minor impairment or delay in development of respiratory, cardiovascular or neuromuscular function. None of these is likely to be sufficient, in isolation, to cause death and, provided the infant survives the first year of life, may no longer be of any significance. However, when a compromised infant is confronted with one or more stressful situations, several of which are now clearly identified as risk factors, and from which the majority of infants would normally escape, the combination may prove fatal.

Toxigenic bacteria and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS): nasopharyngeal flora during the first year of life

Many developmental and environmental risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) are similar to those for susceptibility to respiratory tract infection, and toxigenic bacteria have been implicated in some SIDS cases. We assessed nasopharyngeal flora of healthy infants in relation to risk factors to determine which species best lit the mathematical model proposed for the common bacterial toxin hypothesis and if these findings complemented results obtained from SIDS cases which occurred during the period of the survey. Longitudinal studies were carried out between April 1993 and March 1996 on 253 healthy infants and their mothers. 150 from a multiply deprived area, 103 from an affluent area. Concurrent SIDS infants (37) were screened for nasopharyngeal flora. Among healthy infants < or = 3 months of age, the predominant isolate was Staphylococcus aureus 57% compared with 86% for SIDS infants in that age range (P< 0.02). There were significant associations between isolation of different species from both mother and baby but no association between isolation of any species with: area of residence: parental smoking habits; breast or bottle feeding; symptoms of viral infection: seasonality. We conclude that S. aureus fits the mathematical model for SIDS. Both staphylococci and/or their toxins were identified in a significant proportion of SIDS cases. Isolation of staphylococci from healthy infants was associated with the 2-4-month age range, a risk factor consistently found in all epidemiological studies of SIDS. This might reflect the developmental stage in which 80-90% of infants express the Lewis(a) antigen which we have shown to be one of the receptors for S. aureus.

Infection, inflammation and sleep: more pieces to the puzzle of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)

Risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) parallel those for respiratory tract infections; however, infectious agents suggested to be involved in SIDS do not fulfil Koch's postulates. No single agent has been identified in all cases and there is no suitable animal model for SIDS which could be used to test the candidate organisms. Based on epidemiological and experimental work by our group and others, we suggested some SIDS deaths are due to pathophysiological responses elicited by combinations of microbial products and/or cigarette smoke during a developmental stage when infants' endocrine responses are less able to "damp down" the effects of inflammatory mediators. Here we review evidence from studies on interactions between developmental and environmental risk factors that could affect 1) mucosal colonization of infants by potentially pathogenic bacteria, and 2) induction and control of infants', inflammatory responses to infectious agents. New evidence suggests that there are genetic factors involved in the induction of inflammatory responses to some bacterial antigens implicated in SIDS. Further investigation of the role of infection, exposure to cigarette smoke and inflammation in infants, particularly differences in ethnic groups at increased risk of SIDS, could lead to new insights into the events leading to a fatal outcome and perhaps to new intervention schemes to reduce further the incidence of these deaths.

The effect of enteric bacterial toxins on the catecholamine levels of the rabbit

The rabbit catecholamine responses to bacterial toxins commonly found in Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) victims were studied as part of a proposed animal model for SIDS. Six bacterial toxins commonly isolated from SIDS baby feces and a comparison endotoxin were injected intravenously (i.v.) and intraluminarily (i.l.) to determine their effects on catecholamine levels. I.v. injected toxins clearly altered catecholamine levels causing sharp rises in adrenaline and noradrenaline levels and at critical toxin concentrations sudden death ensued. Clostridium perfringens enterotoxin and alpha-toxin, Clostridium difficile enterotoxin (A) and cytotoxin (B), Escherichia coli STa toxin and staphylococcal enterotoxin B caused rises in catecholamine levels similar to that caused by E. coli endotoxin. Control rabbits showed very little or no obvious change in catecholamine levels. Clostridium difficile enterotoxin (A) and cytotoxin (B) injected i.v. exhibited synergy. Toxins injected into the duodenum, jejunum, ileum, cecum and large intestine caused behavioural changes ranging from reduced appetite and diarrhea to, in rare cases, death. Changes in the catecholamine levels of these animals however were not significantly different from those of the control animals. The results are discussed in relation to the possible effect of certain conditions (physiological, viral infections and environmental) which increase toxin permeability and allow absorption of these toxins, possibly resulting in sudden infant death.

Human disease associated with Clostridium perfringens enterotoxin

Clostridium perfringens continues to be a common cause of food-borne disease. Characteristics of this organism that contribute to its ability to cause food-borne illness include the formation of heat-resistant spores that survive normal cooking/heating temperatures, a rapid growth rate in warm food, and the production of enterotoxin (CPE) in the human gut. Time and temperature abuse associated with food preparation contributes to the majority of outbreaks of C. perfringens food-borne disease. CPE-induced diarrhea has been reported in the absence of a defined food vehicle. These cases have been typically associated with the elderly and following a course of antibiotic therapy. The incidence of CPE-induced diarrhea may be expected to increase with the growing population of immunocompromised (disease-, treatment-, or age-induced) individuals. Clostridium perfringens has been implicated as a possible contributor to the development of SIDS in susceptible individuals. Specifically, it has been hypothesized that CPE acts as a triggering agent, initiating the events associated with the development of SIDS. Continued refinement of both immunoassays and molecular methods for toxin and gene detection, respectively, will facilitate their eventual availability as commercial kits, providing rapid and simplified methods for the detection of C. perfringens isolates that produce or have the capacity to produce CPE as well as other toxins associated with this organism.

Clostridium perfringens type A enterotoxin (CPE): more than just explosive diarrhea

The bacterial pathogen Clostridium perfringens is the most prolific toxin-producing species within the clostridial group. The toxins are responsible for a wide variety of human and veterinary diseases, many of which are lethal. C. perfringens type A strains are also associated with one of the most common forms of food-borne illness (FBI). The toxicosis results from the production and gastrointestinal absorption of a protein-enterotoxin known as CPE. The regulation, expression, and mechanism of action of CPE has been of considerable interest as the protein is unique. CPE expression is sporulation associated, although the mechanism of cpe-gene regulation is not fully elucidated. Cloning studies suggest the involvement of global regulators, but these have not been identified. Although very few type A strains are naturally enterotoxigenic, the cpe gene appears highly conserved. In FBI strains, cpe is chromosomally encoded; whereas in veterinary strains, cpe may be plasmid-encoded. Variation in cpe location suggests the involvement of transposable genetic element(s). CPE-like proteins are produced by some C. perfringens types C and D; and silent remnants of the cpe gene can be found in C. perfringens type E strains associated with the iota toxin gene. CPE has received attention for its biomedical importance. The toxin has been implicated in sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) because of its superantigenic nature. CPE can destroy a wide variety of cell types both in vitro and in vivo, suggesting that it could have potential in the construction of immunotoxins to neoplastic cells. It is obvious that CPE is an interesting protein that deserves continued attention.

Can superantigens trigger sudden infant death?

A majority of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) victims have respiratory or gastrointestinal infections prior to death. This has led to an investigation of the role of pathogenic bacteria and the potentially lethal toxins they produce as triggers for sudden infant death. A small group of bacteria have been consistently identified in SIDS victims as compared to controls, and remarkably, three of these produce superantigenic toxins. Superantigens exert a powerful effect on the immune system, stimulating T-cells, which subsequently induces the formation of large amounts of cytokines. Generation of an overwhelming inflammatory response may lead to death by shock, or other, as yet unrecognized effects of the toxin on the respiratory or cardiac systems. A SIDS/superantigen model is proposed which may explain many of the pathological characteristics of SIDS and establish quantifiable markers for SIDS.