Neurosurgical treatment of traumatic frontobasal CSF fistulae in 300 patients (1967-1989)

Cerebrospinal Fluid Leaks After Anterior Skull Base Trauma: A Systematic Review of the Literature

BACKGROUND

Anterior skull base (ASB) fractures are reported in 4% of head injuries and represent 21% of all skull fractures. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leaks may follow, severely exacerbating outcomes. We systematically reviewed the literature to analyze and compare the roles of endoscopic surgery, open surgery, and combined approaches in the management of CSF leak repair after posttraumatic ASB fractures.

METHODS

PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus databases were searched in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines. Studies reporting clinical data of patients with CSF leaks after ASB fracture were reviewed, focusing on management strategies and posttreatment outcomes.

RESULTS

We included 29 articles comprising 888 patients. The average age at diagnosis was 34 years (range, 18-91 years), with a male predominance (54%) and a male/female ratio of 2.9:1 (647:241). Clinical data were available for 888 patients with CSF leaks after ASB fracture, reporting a median follow-up time of 33.5 months (standard deviation, ±29; range, 0.5-330.0 months). Open surgical repair was the most common approach (67.9%), followed by endoscopic surgical repair (32.1%). The endoscopy cohort showed lower rates of complications (0.7% vs. 11.1%) and fistula recurrence (2.8% vs. 5.3%) compared with open surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

ASB fractures are frequently treated as late surgery, 24 hours from injury or later, especially for endoscopic surgery. Overall, the endoscopic approach is preferred, mostly because of its safety and effectiveness, offering lower failure rates than does open surgery.

A Novel Combined Transorbital Transnasal Endoscopic Approach for Reconstruction of Posttraumatic Complex Anterior Cranial Fossa Defect

The transorbital neuroendoscopic surgery (TONES), endoscopic transnasal skull base procedures, and the concept of multiportal minimal access neurosurgery are novel, rapidly evolving approaches in the management of complex skull base lesions. A 27-year-old male presented with a history of road traffic accident with nasal bleed, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) rhinorrhea, and left eye deformity. There was left upper eyelid ecchymosis, orbital dystopia, left pupil was dilated, and fixed with no extraocular movements. The computed tomography scan showed basifrontal contusion and complex comminuted anterior cranial fossa (ACF) fracture involving left cribriform plate and left orbital roof with fracture fragment impinging on the superior rectus muscle with suspicious orbital CSF leak. There was no improvement with conservative management. Hence, a novel combined TONES, transnasal endoscopic multiportal surgery was undertaken for the removal of fracture fragments and multi-layered closure of the complex ACF defect. The patient had a complete resolution of orbital dystopia and visual loss with no evidence of CSF leak postoperatively.

The Endonasal Endoscopic Management of Cerebrospinal Fluid Rhinorrhea

Introduction

Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) rhinorrhea is the result of a bony defect at the skull base with disruption of the arachnoid, dura mater, and sinonasal mucosa that leads to an active CSF leak and flow of clear fluid from the nose. The endoscopic repair of CSF leaks and skull defects have been used by an increasing number of surgeons and is the standard of care for repairing CSF leaks.

Materials and methods

We conducted a retrospective study of all cases of CSF leaks managed via the endonasal endoscopic approach from 2010 to 2020 at a tertiary referral hospital of King Fahad Specialist Hospital, Dammam (KFSH-D).

Results

Over 10 years, 61 procedures were performed on a total of 56 patients (average age, 39.9 years) with 26 spontaneous CSF leaks and 30 traumatic CSF leaks. The leak sites were frontal bone in 14% of the cases, the roof of the ethmoid in 25%, the cribriform plate of ethmoid in 39%, and the walls of sphenoid sinus in 21%; multiple site defects were found in eight patients. The defect was localized by high-resolution computed tomography (CT) of the paranasal sinuses and skull base and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in all patients. CT cisternography, intrathecal fluorescein injection, and topical application of fluorescein dye were used in patients as required. A combination of free grafts and flaps materials were used in most patients. A middle and inferior turbinate graft was used in 12 patients, a septal cartilage graft in 18 patients, and a pedicled nasoseptal flap in 12 patients. The success rate was 92% after the first closure attempt. A recurrence of CSF leaks was observed in four patients. The mean hospitalization time was 6.5 days. The postoperative follow-up period ranged from one year to 10 years with a mean postoperative follow-up time of three years.

Conclusions

The endonasal endoscopic approach is the current standard of care for repairing most CSF leaks and skull base defects. We have had an excellent experience with endonasal endoscopic CSF leak repair, with high success rates and low morbidity. Our results support the effectiveness and safety of this technique and should encourage otolaryngologists to apply the procedure in cases of CSF leak.

The endoscopic endonasal approach for cerebrospinal fluid leak repair in the elderly

INTRODUCTION

Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) rhinorrhea can lead to CNS infections, carrying significant morbidity and mortality, especially in the elderly. Endoscopic endonasal surgery is a validated technique in the repair of anterior skull base CSF leaks. The aim of this study is to assess diagnostic management, surgical technique and clinical outcome in a consecutive series of elderly patients.

METHODS

Patients older than 65 years treated for anterior skull base CSF leaks through endoscopic endonasal surgery between 2003 and 2014 were retrospectively reviewed. All patients underwent preoperative nasal endoscopy, laboratory and radiological assessment. In doubtful cases endoscopic exploration was performed after intrathecal fluorescein (IF) injection. Patients were discharged between 3 and 4 days after surgery, and the endoscopic follow-up ranged from 3 to 24 months.

RESULTS

20 patients (age range 65-92) presented with 10 spontaneous and 10 traumatic/iatrogenic CSF leaks. In 40% of patients formal rhinoscopy and radiological assessment did not localize the CSF leak and IF injection was performed. IF enabled the identification of the skull base defect in all cases, with no adverse effects. In 11 cases the dura was repaired with fascia lata graft. All patients had successful endoscopic repair of the CSF fistula with no complications nor recurrences during follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic endonasal surgery is a minimally invasive procedure for CSF leak treatment. In our experience, IF injection proved safe and efficient in detecting skull base defects not identified by preoperative imaging. Endoscopic endonasal surgery proved effective and reliable also in elderly patients, with short hospitalization times and no morbidity.

Surgical treatment of complex traumatic frontobasal lesions: personal experience in 74 patients

OBJECT

The author's personal series included 148 patients who sustained traumatic frontobasal injuries and were treated between 1986 and 1999. Included in this study are 74 of 148 patients with acute injuries and complex frontobasal lesions involving the frontal sinus, the cribriform/ethmoid roof complex, one or both orbital roofs, and the planum sphenoidale.

METHODS

Surgery was delayed for up to 4 weeks postinjury in most patients (67 cases), whereas 17 with space-occupying hematomas and perforating injuries required early surgery. In 30 patients additional surgery was required to treat maxillofacial fractures, which was performed as a one-stage procedure together with the neurosurgical operation. The author performed a standard bifrontal craniotomy in which an intradural or combined intradural-extradural approach was used in all cases. Four patients developed ascending meningitis in the preoperative period. As a result of surgical treatment one patient died, another two patients suffered from permanent defects, and three suffered from transitory neurological worsening. In two patients recurrence of a cerebrospinal fluid fistula occurred within a 3-month period posttreatment but was successfully obliterated during reoperation. In the author's experience the intradural approach is comparable in terms of the morbidity, mortality, and success rates with extracranial approaches; additionally the intradural approach provides full visualization of the intracranial lesion. Useful olfactory nerve function can only be preserved if both olfactory nerves are left intact and not crushed during initial injury; this occurred in only five patients in this series.

CONCLUSIONS

If possible, surgical treatment of more complex lesions should be delayed until the 2nd or 3rd week following traumatic injury. With antibiotic prophylaxis the risk that ascending meningitis will occur prior to surgery is low. If the patient is systemically stable and brain swelling has resolved, even extensive one-stage neurosurgical/maxillofacial procedures are well tolerated.

Detailed evaluation of 2959 allogeneic and xenogeneic dense connective tissue grafts (fascia lata, pericardium, and dura mater) used in the course of 20 years for duraplasty in neurosurgery

Surgical experience with 2959 allogeneic and xenogeneic dense connective tissue grafts (1767 of fascia lata, 909 of pericardium, and 283 of dura mater), used in 2665 neurosurgical operations performed in the course of 20 years (1976 to 1995) is reported. Duraplasty using either allogeneic or xenogeneic grafts has had a similar, and favourable clinical outcome. Nevertheless, the pliable deep frozen fascia lata grafts, which could be used in any location, have been reserved for sella turcica plugging, anterior cranial base plasty, aneurysmal wrapping, and surgery of lipomyelomeningocele. Pericardium and dura mater grafts were in the majority of cases used over the brain convexity and posterior cranial fossa. Ovine pericardium proved to be superior to bovine and allogeneic pericardia because of its workability, flexibility, reduced thickness, and better transparency. Postsurgical complications occurred in 7.3%, and they were: 1) cerebrospinal fluid fistulas in 2.8%; 2) meningites in 2.3% (aseptic 1.4%, bacterial 0.8%, and tumoural 0.1% meningites); 3) pseudomeningoceles in 2.2%; 4) wound infections in 0.6%; 5) malresorptive hydrocephalus in 0.5%; and 6) adhesions to nerve tissue in 0.5%. The majority of complications healed without surgery. Forty-eight grafts (1.6%) failed to fulfil the requirements of the surgeon, and 46 of them were re-operated upon. Though another thirty-nine grafts healed successfully, 39 shunts (1.5%) had to be performed for malresorptive hydrocephalus (0.9%), and/or for a big pseudomeningocele (0.6%). So, the pure complication rate in 2665 duraplasties was 3.1%. The complex evaluation of the allogeneic and xenogeneic grafts (fascia, pericardium, and dura mater), used for duraplasty in neurosurgery during the last 20 years proved them, as remarkably good, with a success rates of 96.9%.

Osteoplastic frontal sinusotomy and extradural microsurgical repair of frontobasal cerebrospinal fluid fistulas

The choice of the surgical approach and operative technique for the management of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) fistulas of the anterior cranial fossa are still a controversially discussed topic. Although "extracranial" approaches through the paranasal sinuses are becoming increasingly more popular among otolaryngologists and maxillo-facial surgeons, most neurosurgeons traditionally prefer the "intracranial" repair of CSF fistulas by a craniotomy. We present an approach through the frontal sinus for the repair of dural defects behind the posterior wall of the frontal sinus and at the floor of the anterior cranial fossa. The operative procedure comprises the following main steps: 1) exposure of the anterior wall of the frontal sinus by a bicoronal incision; 2) excision of the anterior wall without frontal burr holes; 3) bilateral removal of the posterior wall of the frontal sinus; 4) extradural inspection of the dura behind the frontal sinus and above the cribriform plate, ethmoidal roof, and orbital roof bilaterally; 5) closure of dural tears by direct suture and a periosteal graft; 6) reinsertion of the anterior wall of the frontal sinus and fixation with titanium micro plates. Twenty-five patients operated upon using this technique are described. The aetiology of the frontobasal lesion was traumatic in 23, and an ethmoid carcinoma in two. In all patients, the dural fistulas were successfully repaired during the initial procedure. One patient died from sudden circulatory arrest after an uneventful postoperative course of nine days. Otherwise, there were no postoperative complications. This technique affords atraumatic extradural inspection and repair of dural fistulas bilaterally behind the frontal sinus, and above the cribriform plate and the ethmoidal and orbital roofs with none or minimal brain retraction. It therefore allows early repair of CSF fistulas also in patients with severe brain injury. Although we consider the extradural closure of fistulas the method of choice, this approach also allows for a combined extradural-intradural procedure, thus enabling the surgeon to treat associated intradural pathologies, such as traumatic lesions or tumours of the frontal cranial base.