Seatbelt induced chance fracture in an infant. Case report and literature review

Fragility of L5 Vertebral Fracture After Rod Fracture at the Lumbosacral Junction Following Long-Segment Spinal Fusion Surgery for Adult Spine Deformity

We report a case of vertebral fracture in a patient with rod fractures after adult spinal deformity surgery, which occurred at the same level as the rod fractures, even though intervertebral bone fusion in the fusion range had been achieved. A 77-year-old female underwent corrective spinal surgery for adult spinal deformity from T12 to the pelvis but had a subsequent uppermost instrumented vertebral fracture, resulting in pseudarthrosis and severe kyphosis. The patient underwent proximal fusion extension to the T4, which improved alignment. A right-sided rod fracture at the lumbosacral junction occurred after 18 months; however, it showed no symptoms. After a month, the patient experienced severe low back pain with left leg pain and was diagnosed with bilateral rod fractures associated with L5 hyperextension vertebral fracture. The patient underwent revision surgery to repair the fractured rods with a multiple-rod construct. Rod fractures can occur even when bone fusion is achieved within the fusion range. When rod fractures are detected at the lumbosacral junction even if the interbody fusion was achieved, a hyperextension vertebral fracture may occur.

Thoracic hyperextension injury with opening wedge distraction fracture in DISH -consideration of surgical strategy based on intraoperative pathological findings

Diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH) is a well-recognized disease characterized by calcifications and ossifications of the entheses mainly in the spine. Patients with DISH are prone to sustaining spinal injuries even after minor trauma because of the long-lever arm mechanism induced by any type of force acting on the rigid yet brittle spine. The number of cases of trauma in DISH-affected spines is predicted to increase during the coming decades because of an increase in DISH-related comorbidities. Generally, posterior fixation with spinal instrumentation spanning three levels above and below the injured site is regarded as a standard treatment for hyperextension fractures of the thoracolumbar spine in patients with DISH. However, no consensus has been reached regarding whether additional anterior fixation is needed for hyperextension injuries with remarkable vertebral body wedge. We experienced one case of hyperextension injury at the thoracic level in patient with DISH. A remarkable remodeling phenomenon in the fractured vertebral body was intraoperatively noticed, which was pathologically confirmed. This is the first report to have confirmed pathologically new bone formation in the anterior column wedge despite the fact that only 1 month had passed since the first injury. Although whether additional anterior fixation is needed for hyperextension injuries with remarkable vertebral body wedge is controversial, this report supports that posterior fixation alone might be an adequate treatment.

Pediatric Chance fractures: a multicenter perspective

BACKGROUND

Chance fractures or flexion-distraction injuries of the spine are uncommon in children. Previous reports have been limited to isolated case reports or very small retrospective series. This is the largest series reported in the English literature.

METHODS

This was a multicenter retrospective review of pediatric Chance fractures treated at 3 large level-1 pediatric trauma centers. We analyzed the demographics, causes, circumstances, treatment, complications, and clinical outcome of 35 patients younger than 18 years old with a Chance fracture. We hypothesize that surgical treatment provides the best results.

RESULTS

There were 20 females and 15 males, with an average age of 9 years (range, 1.6 to 17 y). The most common level of injury was at L2 and L3 (20/35). Fifteen children (43%) had a neurological deficit at the time of injury and only 8 fully recovered. One patient deceased before formal orthopaedic treatment. Patients were treated at the discretion of the surgeon and the surgically treated group (20/34) had greater initial kyphotic deformity (22 degrees) than those treated nonoperatively (14/34; 11.4 degrees) and less posttreatment residual kyphotic deformity (3.5 vs. 20 degrees, respectively). The complication rate related to treatment was 26% (9/34) and most complications in the nonoperative group were related to progression of kyphosis whereas in the surgical group most complications are related to discomfort over the hardware (4 patients). Fifteen children (43%) had neurological deficit at presentation, 7 did not fully recover, for an incidence of permanent neurologic deficit of 10% among restrained patients versus 42% for unrestrained patients. Twenty-one patients (62%) had a good final clinical outcome defined by no chronic pain or neurologic deficit, this represented 45% good outcome in the nonoperative group compared with 84% in the operative group (NS).

CONCLUSIONS

In this multicenter retrospective study, surgical treatment of Chance fractures in children seems to produce better clinical outcome, the appropriate use of restraints reduce the incidence of definitive neurologic deficit.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 3, comparative study.

Chance fractures in the pediatric population

OBJECT

The pediatric Chance fracture (PCF) is an uncommon injury, but it has been increasingly reported. Knowledge is limited to few case reports and short series. To understand the various aspects of this injury, the authors reviewed the current literature.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted using the PubMed and Ovid online databases and relevant key words. All articles that were in English and provided information regarding PCF as a sole or part of the objective were retrieved.

RESULTS

Seventy-three articles were found to fulfill the inclusion criteria. Relevant information about PCF collected from these articles included: 1) mode of trauma, 2) associated injuries, 3) radiological classification, and 4) treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Chance fractures in children are potentially devastating injuries largely caused by motor vehicle collisions, and these fractures may be more common than previously thought. Concomitant intraabdominal injuries are common and should be suspected, particularly when a seat belt sign is observed. Blunt abdominal aortic injuries are rarely associated, but should be evaluated for and treated appropriately. Magnetic resonance imaging is best for defining ligamentous injury, which aids in defining the pattern of injury, facilitating appropriate treatment regimens.

Pediatric lumbar Chance fractures in British Columbia: chart review and analysis of the use of shoulder restraints in MVAs

Chance fractures of the skeletally immature spine classically occur in frontal motor vehicle accidents (MVAs) when the occupants are restrained by a lap belt only and undergo traumatic hyperflexion of the torso during the impact. We retrospectively examined all MVA-related Chance fractures at British Columbia's Children's Hospital since 1986, by collecting injury and seat-belt use information from chart data and imaging studies. Twenty-six patients were included in the study, 14 wore a lap belt only, seven wore a three-point restraint properly, and five were reportedly misusing the shoulder portion of a three-point restraint. The subjects ranged in age from 3 to 16 with a mean age of 10.6 years. Eleven of the 26 (42%) patients sustained abdominal viscera injuries, seven of the 26 patients suffered neurologic injury (spinal cord and/or spinal nerve injury) associated with their spinal fracture, with two cases of complete paralysis, and there was a 38% incidence of head injury. Concomitant injuries (i.e. to the head, abdomen and abdominal contents) tended to be mitigated by the presence of a properly worn shoulder restraint. This leads to the conclusion that Chance fractures can be sustained even when the occupant is using a shoulder belt to restrain their torso. The mechanism responsible for this is unknown. This may indicate that Chance fractures can be caused by a lesser degree of torso hyperflexion than previously thought. Alternatively, we also speculate that Chance fractures can occur while the torso is restrained by the shoulder belt if the hips submarine beneath the lap belt and the torso experiences hyperflexion secondary to forward excursion of the pelvis and legs during the collision. Future work is necessary to confirm these mechanisms and to find ways to prevent them. These studies will need to use computational or experimental child surrogates that can sit in a slouched posture and submarine during a collision.

Pediatric seatbelt injuries: unusual Chance's fracture associated with intra-abdominal lesions in a child

The authors report the case of a 7-year-old child involved in a motor vehicle accident. She sustained an unusual flexion-distraction vertebral injury. This spinal injury was related to seatbelt use and was associated with intra-abdominal lesions. The spinal lesion consisted of a posterior ligamentous disruption with widening of the posterior intervertebral space at two adjacent lumbar levels. The purpose of this case report is to describe an atypical and perhaps often unrecognized spinal lesion and to explain our approach to diagnosis and treatment.

Pediatric spinal injury

Spine injury in children thankfully is still a relatively rare injury. The incidence of pediatric spine injuries has been reported as 2% to 5% of all spine injuries. The biological differences of children make differences in fracture patterns and alter the management necessary for successful treatment. The other factors that affect fracture production and associated injuries are head size relative to the body size, flexibility of the spine and supporting structures, the growth plates, and the elasticity and compressibility of the bone. The majority of compression injuries in children are made up of falls from a height. Spinal injuries in children remain a challenge despite some technical changes in assessment and treatment.

Pediatric chance fracture associated with pedicle screw use: a case report

STUDY DESIGN

A previously undescribed clinic entity is presented, along with suggestions to prevent its reoccurrence.

OBJECTIVE

To identify a potential pitfall in the use of pedicle screw instrumentation in trauma cases. Also, to emphasize the need to identify and treat noncontiguous spinal fractures.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

No previous cases have yet been described with this particular complication, which would be remedied easily with established methods. Pedicle screw instrumentation previously has been associated primarily with complications due to aberrant screw insertion and injury to adjoining tissues, or due to fracture of the construct itself in the absence of fusion formation.

METHODS

A 15-year-old girl suffered a traumatic T12-L1 fracture dislocation and paraplegia. After pedicle screw instrumentation, her apparently benign L3 fracture progressed to a severely displaced Chance fracture. This was repaired with caudal laminar hook compression instrumentation.

RESULTS

Postoperatively, at a 1-year follow-up, the patient's spinal deformity was completely alleviated, though she remains paraplegic.

CONCLUSIONS

Unstable traumatic spinal injuries treated with pedicular instrumentation should have additional laminar hook compression configuration reinforcement at the ends of the constructs to prevent further stress-induced injury from the screws alone. Instrumentation constructs should not end at even minimally fractured levels.