Separation of vegetable oil triglycerides by subcritical fluid chromatography with octadecyl packed columns and CO2/modifier mobile phases

Supercritical fluid chromatography is not (only) normal-phase chromatography

Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), now using carbon dioxide as a major component of the mobile phase, has been known for over 60 years but still some misunderstandings remain about its capabilities. Amongst them, SFC is often described as a normal-phase chromatographic technique, based on different considerations: polarity of the stationary phase, elution order of the analytes, relative non-polarity of the mobile phase, non-linear retention behaviour, or adsorption retention mechanisms. All of these assumptions are true to a certain extent, and in certain circumstances. But also, all of these assumptions are wrong in different circumstances. In this paper, the criteria to categorize SFC as a normal-phase chromatographic method will be examined individually, considering all knowledge acquired from the early years of its development. Finally, it will appear that the "normal-phase" glass lens is greatly reducing the true extent of SFC's possibilities.

Facilitated on-line supercritical fluid extraction - supercritical fluid chromatography for nonpolar and polar compounds from milk thistle seeds

Plant seeds, as those from milk thistle (Silybum marianum), are a valuable source of nonpolar and polar compounds with potentially interesting biological activity. The main nonpolar compounds are triglycerides, which are also the main components of all vegetable oils. In addition, specific polar compounds - flavonolignans, called silymarin, have been found in large amounts in milk thistle seeds extract. These flavonoids derivatives have different biological activity, for instance hepatoprotective effects. In order to extract and analyze both nonpolar (triglycerides) and polar compounds (flavonolignans) from milk thistle seeds through a sequential methodology, an on-line supercritical fluid extraction - supercritical fluid chromatography (SFE-SFC) method was developed. Different ways of transferring the extracts from SFE to SFC (i.e. direct on-column transfer and loop transfer) were compared, and particularly for their effect on chromatographic quality. In this respect, nonpolar and polar compounds caused different issues, especially as polar compounds required a significant portion of co-solvent in the extraction step, favoring early elution in the chromatographic column. First, on-line SFE-SFC was used for triglycerides analysis and allowed the comparison of transfer modes. Then, on-line kinetics were performed to measure defatting time before polar molecules extraction. Finally, the eventual benefit of loop transfer was also investigated for the analysis of flavonolignans, polar molecules whose analysis can be difficult by on-line SFE-SFC. The aim of this paper is to discuss the versatility of on-line SFE-SFC and how challenging the coupling can be, especially when both non-polar and polar molecules must be analyzed independently in a single sample.

Ultra high efficiency/low pressure supercritical fluid chromatography (UHE/LP-SFC) for triglyceride analysis: Identification, quantification, and classification of vegetable oils

Triglycerides of vegetable oils have been extensively studied. Non-aqueous reversed-phase liquid chromatography and silver-ion chromatography are most frequently used to achieve their separation. In previous works, we presented the use of supercritical fluid chromatography with long columns (75 cm) packed with fused-core particles to provide ultra-high-performance separations, with a low-toxicity fluid (carbon dioxide) compared to the usual liquid-phase methods. In the present paper, we describe the quantification of triglycerides with supercritical fluid chromatography and evaporative light-scattering detection. Thanks to the isocratic elution mode, this quantification can be simplified, assuming (a) identical response coefficients for compounds having a close structure, (as only triglycerides are quantified), and (b) constancy of the response coefficient along the analysis (no elution gradient). Therefore, the relative concentrations of triglycerides were easily assessed. Only one calibration curve for one reference compound (in this case triolein) was required. The resulting relative concentrations are in good accordance with the numerous publications available. Relative quantification with UV detection at 210 nm is also proposed, facilitated by the very low UV absorption of carbon dioxide and with a calibration curve taking account of the variation of UV response according to double bond number. Nineteen vegetable oils are compared. The identification of triglycerides was carried out based on previous knowledge of these oils, but also with the help of a Goiffon retention diagram, based on the relationship between the logarithm of retention factor and the total double bond number. Finally, cluster analyses were computed, based on evaporative light-scattering detection or UV quantification data. They allow a quick comparison of the triglyceride content between the oils, in the goal to exchange one by the other for certain applications, or to compare a new oil to well-known ones.

Modelling of ceramide interactions with porous graphite carbon in non-aqueous liquid chromatography

Interactions of solutes on porous graphitic carbon (PGC) with non-aqueous mobile phases are studied by the linear solvation energy relationship (LSER). Studies have been carried out with eight binary mixtures composed of a weak solvent (acetonitrile or methanol) and a strong solvent (tetrahydrofuran, n-butanol, CH2Cl2, 1,1,2-trichloro-2,2,1-trifluoroethane). The systematic analysis of a set of test compounds was performed for each solvent mixture in isocratic mode (50:50). The results were compared to those obtained on PGC with hydro-organic liquids and supercritical fluids. They were then correlated with the observed retention behaviour of lipid compounds, more particularly ceramides.

Glycolipid class profiling by packed-column subcritical fluid chromatography

The potential of packed-column subcritical fluid chromatography (SubFC) for the separation of lipid classes has been assessed in this study. Three polar stationary phases were checked: silica, diol, and poly(vinyl alcohol). Carbon dioxide (CO2) with methanol as modifier was used as mobile phase and detection performed by evaporative light scattering detection. The influence of methanol content, temperature, and pressure on the chromatographic behavior of sphingolipids and glycolipids were investigated. A complete separation of lipid classes from a crude wheat lipid extract was achieved using a modifier gradient from 10 to 40% methanol in carbon dioxide. Solute selectivity was improved using coupled silica and diol columns in series. Because the variation of eluotropic strength depending on the fluid density changes, a normalized separation factor product (NSP) was used to select the nature, the number and the order of the columns to reach the optimum glycolipid separation.

Advantages of the use of monolithic stationary phases for modelling the retention in sub/supercritical chromatography

The low viscosity of supercritical fluids enables the coupling of columns, which favours both the high efficiency of separation and the ability of tuning the selectivity. However, it increases the inlet pressure then modifies the fluid density, i.e. the eluotropic strength of the mobile phase. In this case, the latter is rather different depending on the number of coupled columns. This fact prevents the calculation of the chromatographic parameters for coupled columns from the results obtained from one. In subcritical conditions, by using silica rod columns, which have bimodal porous structure, the flow resistance parameter is dramatically reduced. Consequently, the addition of monolithic columns induces only slight internal pressure changes and the fluid density does not vary with the column length. In this case, the calculation of retention factor and selectivity based on retention values obtained on each separate column provides accurate results allowing to determine the optimum column length in regard to the studied separation. After a better characterisation of the stationary phase included in the Chromolith column, this paper describes the beta-carotene isomers separation obtained by coupling up to six Chromolith columns to an octadecyl bonded particulate one. These compounds were studied because of the difficulty to separate these cis/trans isomers. No abnormal apparent dead volume change due to fluid density variation was reported, and good correlations between experimental and calculated retention factors and selectivities were observed. The optimum separation requires five highly porous columns coupled to a YMC Pack Pro. Moreover, the use of monolith packing allows to decrease both the retention factor and the analytical time by comparison to previous studies.

Isolation of ceramide fractions from skin sample by subcritical chromatography with packed silica and evaporative light scattering detection

Separative method of lipid classes from the stratum corneum was developed with packed silica and supercritical CO2 containing 10% of methanol at 15 degrees C, 15 MPa and 3 ml min(-1). The elution order of lipid classes was first esterified cholesterol, triglycerides, squalene co-eluted in a single peak, then free fatty acids, free cholesterol, ceramides and finally glycosylceramides. The ceramides were eluted in several fractions which depended on the number of hydroxyl groups in the molecule, i.e. more hydroxyl groups were contained in ceramides, more important was the retention. Moreover, the retention was not altered by the presence of carbon double bond and variation of the alkyl chain length. The ceramide response with the evaporative light scattering detector was improved by turning the influence of the solvent nature on the response to advantage. Therefore, addition of various solvents with or without triethylamine and formic acid were tested in post-column due to the incompatibility of such modifiers with silica stationary phase. Thereby the solvent conditions for the separation and the detection can be adjusted almost independently. The response was greatly increased by post-column addition of 1% (v/v) triethylamine and its equivalent amount of formic acid in dichloromethane introduced at 0.1 ml min(-1) into the mobile phase. This device had allowed the detection of 400 ng of ceramide with a S/N = 21, whereas no peak was observed in absence of the post-column addition. Finally, the method was applied to the treatment of skin sample which led to highly enriched ceramide fraction.