The effects of different levels of dietary restriction on non-neoplastic diseases in male Sprague-Dawley rats

The Impact of Varying Food Availability on Gene Expression in the Liver: Testing the Match-Mismatch Hypothesis

Background

During early phases of life, such as prenatal or early postnatal development and adolescence, an organism's phenotype can be shaped by the environmental conditions it experiences. According to the Match-Mismatch hypothesis (MMH), changes to this environment during later life stages can result in a mismatch between the individual's adaptations and the prevailing environmental conditions. Thus, negative consequences in welfare and health can occur. We aimed to test the MMH in the context of food availability, assuming adolescence as a sensitive period of adaptation.

Methods

We have previously reported a study of the physiological and behavioral effects of match and mismatch conditions of high (ad libitum) and low (90% of ad libitum intake) food availability from adolescence to early adulthood in female C57BL/6J mice (n = 62). Here, we performed RNA-sequencing of the livers of a subset of these animals (n = 16) to test the effects of match and mismatch feeding conditions on the liver transcriptome.

Results

In general, we found no effect of the match-mismatch situations. Contrarily, the amount of food available during early adulthood (low vs. high) drove the differences we observed in final body weight and gene expression in the liver, regardless of the amount of food available to the animals during adolescence. Many of the differentially expressed genes and the corresponding biological processes found to be overrepresented overlapped, implicating common changes in various domains. These included metabolism, homeostasis, cellular responses to diverse stimuli, transport of bile acids and other molecules, cell differentiation, major urinary proteins, and immunity and inflammation.

Conclusions

Our previous and present observations found no support for the MMH in the context of low vs high food availability from adolescence to early adulthood in female C57BL/6J mice. However, even small differences of approximately 10% in food availability during early adulthood resulted in physiological and molecular changes with potential beneficial implications for metabolic diseases.

The impact of varying food availability on health and welfare in mice: Testing the Match-Mismatch hypothesis

During early phases of life, an organism's phenotype can be shaped by the environmental conditions which it experiences. If the conditions change subsequently, the mismatch between the environment in early and later life could have negative effects on the individual's health and welfare. The aim of this study was to systematically test the predictions of this Match-Mismatch hypothesis in laboratory mice. Therefore, female C57BL/6 J mice were exposed to matching or mismatching combinations of low and high food availability in adolescence and early adulthood. A comprehensive analysis of various physiological and behavioral parameters was conducted. No indication of a mismatch effect was found, which might be attributed to the specific ecology of mice. Alternatively, food availability might cause a shaping of the phenotype only during the prenatal or early postnatal development. However, various effects of low vs high food availability were found regarding the individuals' physiology and, to a small extent, their behavior. Low food availability caused higher concentrations of fecal corticosterone metabolites, as well as higher liver and lower spleen weights, suggesting an adaptation of the metabolism to this situation.

Ethics of feeding: the omnivore dilemma

The way in which animals are fed is an important aspect of their welfare. Not only does food provide the energy and nutrients vital for survival, but feeding is also associated with a number of other factors contributing to the well-being of animals. The feeding method can determine the animals’ abilities to fulfil basic behavioural needs, such as foraging. The aim of this paper is to review and discuss the dilemma of choosing between ad libitum feeding (AL) and dietary restriction (DR). AL can produce obese individuals with severe health problems, though it does appear to be compatible with welfare-friendly management systems. On the other hand, DR is often associated with improved physical health and longevity but can leave animals suffering from hunger, frustration or aggression. The species discussed are the laboratory rat, pigs and poultry all of which are omnivores sharing many characteristics in their eating habits. The welfare implications of different feeding methods depend upon the definition of welfare used. Based on a definition of welfare in terms of functioning, DR could be considered the best way to feed animals, because it results in improved physical health and longevity. If welfare is defined in terms of natural living, it is also a requirement for the animal to be able to engage in natural foraging behaviours. From the feelings-based approach, DR can be viewed as preferable only in circumstances when animals are anticipated to live so long that they would otherwise suffer from the negative long-term consequences of AL. It is argued that incentives are needed to make farmers spend resources to ensure that farm animals are allowed to have their foraging-related needs fulfilled. Feeding of laboratory animals creates special dilemmas when it is important either to under- or over-nourish the animals for experimental purposes, in such instances there is a need for Refinement.

The diet board: welfare impacts of a novel method of dietary restriction in laboratory rats

Laboratory rats are commonly fed ad libitum (AL). Moderate dietary restriction (DR) decreases mortality and morbidity when compared with AL feeding, but there are several obstacles to the implementation of DR. Traditional methods of restricted feeding disrupt normal diurnal eating rhythms and are not compatible with group housing. We have designed a novel method, the diet board, to restrict the feeding of group-housed rats. Animals fed from the diet board had 15% lower body weight than the AL-fed animals at the age of 17 weeks. The welfare effects of diet board feeding were assessed by comparing the stress physiology of diet board fed animals with that of AL-fed animals. Diet board feeding was associated with higher serum corticosterone levels and lower faecal secretion of IgA, suggesting the diet board causes a stress reaction. However, the AL-fed group had larger adrenal glands with higher adrenaline and noradrenaline content than the diet board animals. No gastric ulcers were found in any of the animals at necropsy. The diet board thus appears to cause a stress reaction when compared with AL-fed rats, but no apparent pathology was associated with this reaction. The diet board could help to solve the health problems associated with AL feeding, while allowing the rats to be group-housed and to maintain their normal diurnal eating rhythms. The diet board can also be seen as a functional cage furniture item, dividing the cage into compartments and thus increasing the structural complexity of the environment. In conclusion, the diet board appears to possess refinement potential compared with traditional methods of DR.

A novel dietary restriction method for group-housed rats: weight gain and clinical chemistry characterization

Laboratory rodents are usually fed ad libitum. Moderate dietary restriction decreases mortality and morbidity compared with ad libitum feeding. There are, however, problems in achieving dietary restriction. Traditional methods of restricted feeding may interfere with the diurnal rhythms of the animals and are not compatible with group-housing of rodents. We have invented a novel method, the diet board, for restricting the feed intake of laboratory rats. The use of the diet board moderately decreased weight gain of rats when compared with ad libitum-fed animals. The diet board retarded skeletal growth only minimally, whereas major differences were found in body fat depositions. Serum free fatty acid, triglyceride and cholesterol values were lower in diet-restricted rats, while the opposite was true for serum creatine kinase. There were no differences in total protein, albumin or alanine aminotransferase. Moreover, differences in interindividual variances in parameters were not detected between the groups; hence this study could not combine the diet board with reduction potential. The diet board provides mild to moderate dietary restriction for group-housed rats and is unlikely to interfere with the diurnal eating rhythm. The diet board can also be seen as a cage furniture item, dividing the open cage space and increasing the structural complexity of the environment. In conclusion, the diet board appears to possess refinement potential when compared with traditional methods of dietary restriction.

Nonneoplastic pathology in male Sprague-Dawley rats fed the American Institute of Nutrition-93M purified diet at ad libitum and dietary-restricted intakes

This study evaluates the effects of age and chronic dietary restriction (DR) on nonneoplastic diseases in rats that were fed the American Institute of Nutrition (AIN)-93M purified diet. Male Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats were divided into an ad libitum (AL) group and a DR group that was fed the AIN-93M diet with intake reduced by 31%. Nonneoplastic disease profiles were developed to clarify whether the AIN-93M diet fulfills long-term nutritional requirements of rats. Subsets of rats were killed at 58 and 114 weeks of age, and histopathology was performed. At 58 weeks of age, the 2 main types of nonneoplastic diseases in AL rats were liver vacuolization and cardiomyopathy. Dietary restriction reduced the severity and incidence of both lesions. At 114 weeks of age, the most common lesions in AL rats were cardiomyopathy, nephropathy, liver vacuolization, and degeneration with renal failure and genitourinary infections causing the greatest mortality. Dietary restriction reduced the incidence and severity of these lesions. Nonneoplastic diseases accounted for 28.9% and 0.0% of total mortalities in the AL and DR groups, respectively; however, there was a higher incidence of unknown deaths in the DR rats (52.6%) compared to AL rats (28.9%), which may have limited the success of DR to improve survival. Although the AIN-93M diet supported chronic rat growth, alterations in some dietary component concentrations may be required to lower body weight in chronic rodent and human studies. Factors such as diet composition and digestibility may alter nonneoplastic diseases and mortality in rats and humans in a similar fashion.

Diet restriction and ageing in the dog: major observations over two decades

This report reviews decade two of the lifetime diet restriction study of the dog. Labrador retrievers (n 48) were paired at age 6 weeks by sex and weight within each of seven litters, and assigned randomly within the pair to control-feeding (CF) or 25 % diet restriction (DR). Feeding began at age 8 weeks. The same diet was fed to all dogs; only the quantity differed. Major lifetime observations included 1.8 years longer median lifespan among diet-restricted dogs, with delayed onset of late life diseases, especially osteoarthritis. Long-term DR did not negatively affect skeletal maturation, structure or metabolism. Among all dogs, high static fat mass and declining lean body mass predicted death, most strongly at 1 year prior. Fat mass above 25 % was associated with increasing insulin resistance, which independently predicted lifespan and chronic diseases. Metabolizable energy requirement/lean body mass most accurately explained energy metabolism due to diet restriction; diet-restricted dogs required 17 % less energy to maintain each lean kilogram. Metabonomics-based urine metabolite trajectories reflected DR-related differences, suggesting that signals from gut microbiota may be involved in the DR longevity and health responses. Independent of feeding group, increased hazard of earlier death was associated with lower lymphoproliferative responses to phytohaemagglutinin, concanavalin A, and pokeweed mitogen; lower total lymphocytes, T-cells, CD4 and CD8 cells; lower CD8 percentages and higher B-cell percentages. When diet group was taken into account, PWM responses and cell counts and percentages remained predictive of earlier death.

Effect of a caloric restriction regimen on the angiogenic capacity of aorta and on the expression of endothelin-1 during ageing

Ageing is accompanied by impaired angiogenesis, as well as by a deficient expression of several angiogenic growth factors and the alteration of endothelial functions. Caloric restriction (CR) is the only intervention that can extend lifespan and retard age-related-decline functions in mammals by reducing the rate of ageing and the progression of the associated diseases. Herein, we have investigated the effects of ageing and of a caloric restriction regimen (mild or severe) on the angiogenic response and on the expression of endothelin-1 (ET-1) in the aorta of male 3-, 12- or 24-month-old Sprague-Dawley rats fed ad libitum (AL), fed ad libitum and fasted 1 day a week (mild CR) or fasted every other in alternate days (severe CR). Our findings, using the rat aorta ring assay, show that the angiogenic capacity of aorta decreases with ageing in the oldest rats only. Furthermore, caloric restriction counteracts the age-related changes caloric restrictions actually give raise to a similar recovery. Interestingly, the mRNA ET-1 levels as well as ET-1 expression in aorta sprouting decreases both in middle and in aged animals. Mild and severe caloric restriction regimens prevents ET-1 changes.

Comparative study on the preventing effects of oral vanadyl sulfate and dietary restriction on the age-related glucose intolerance in rats

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Aging is associated with a progressive impairment of glucose tolerance. The aim of this study was to explore the protective effects of the chronic oral administration of the insulino-mimetic agent vanadyl sulfate (VOSO4) as compared with those exerted by a long-lasting dietary restriction.

METHODS

Male Sprague-Dawley rats, either fed ad libitum (AL) or subjected to 40% dietary restriction (DR), were used. VOSO4 (0.5 mg/mL drinking water) was administered to a subgroup of AL rats for two months, starting at 16 months of age. Rats were subjected to an intravenous glucose tolerance test (IVGTT) at 16 and 18 months of age. Finally, the beta-cell responsiveness to glucose was evaluated in vitro by the isolated perfused pancreas preparation.

RESULTS

The IVGTT performed in 16-month-old rats showed that DR prevented the development of the moderate glucose intolerance observed in AL rats. The IVGTT performed at 18 months of age confirmed the beneficial effect of DR and showed that VOSO4 was able to prevent the further age-related progression of glucose intolerance observed in AL rats. Pancreas perfusion studies showed that no increase in insulin secretion occurred in both VOSO4-treated and DR rats with respect to the age-matched AL controls, consistently with the in vivo observation of post-loading insulinaemic changes.

CONCLUSIONS

On the basis of these results, we conclude that the beneficial effect of both treatments is mostly related to an improvement of tissue sensitivity to insulin rather than to an insulinotropic effect.

Molecular events in kidney ageing

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Ageing of the kidney is a problem of clinical and basic interest. The problem of renal dysfunction and end-stage renal disease is a major burden on the health system, and old donor age is a major limitation on the use of donor organs and on survival of transplanted kidneys. Moreover, stresses linked to nephropathies, postoperative stress, inflammation and allograft rejection can lead to premature senescence of renal cells thus accelerating organ atrophy. Age-related and disease or stress-related nephron loss could reflect both the limited ability of epithelial cells to repair and replicate in the face of environmental stresses, and limitations on the number of cell replications caused by telomere shortening. Therefore, elucidating cellular senescence mechanisms is relevant to kidney diseases and kidney transplantation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent findings suggest additive effects of replicative and environmental stress-induced senescence in cellular and organ ageing. In particular, ATM/p53/p21 and Ras/p38/p16 pathways have been shown to co-contribute to the overall cellular senescence, which is caused by extrinsic and intrinsic stimuli. Moreover, the role of epigenetic factors, including protein acylation/deacetylation, chromatin remodeling or caloric restriction, is the focus of recent studies on ageing and senescence.

SUMMARY

Despite significant progress, cellular senescence is still better understood in vitro than in vivo. So far, p16 remains the best marker of chronological age in the kidney, and can be considered as an indicator of premature senescence caused by stresses or disease. The beneficial effects of caloric restriction on organ ageing and the role of histone acetylation in pathologic states in rodents are of considerable interest, and deserve future studies.

The effects of different levels of dietary restriction on neoplastic pathology in the male Sprague-Dawley rat

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

The primary purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of varied levels of dietary restriction (DR) on neoplastic pathologies in rodents at 58 and 110 weeks of age.

METHODS

Male Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats were divided into four nutritional groups; an ad libitum (AL) control group, and three dietary restricted (DR) groups that were fed the NIH-31 diet reduced in amount by 10, 25, and 40%.

RESULTS

At 110 weeks of age, compared to AL rats, the incidence of benign tumors was significantly lower in all DR groups while primary tumors were significantly lower in the 10 and 40% DR groups; no malignant tumors were detected in the 10% DR group. Most defined mortalities were caused by neoplastic lesions. All levels of DR reduced the percentage of tumor-bearing animals, the incidence of skin tumors (combined), and the total number of tumors. Pituitary, skin, and pancreatic tumors were the most prolific lesions; pituitary and skin tumors were the most fatal. Compared to AL rats, the time to onset of skin and pancreatic tumors was longer in all of the DR groups.

CONCLUSION

In many cases, the incidences of neoplastic lesions were similar among the DR groups, clearly indicating that the DR effect is not linear and that even a very low level of DR (10%) can have a significant effect on many important neoplastic lesions and tumor burden. The main effect of DR was to decrease the incidence of some neoplastic lesions and to increase the time to onset and/or decrease the progression of tumors, thereby increasing the 110-week survival rate of DR rats.