A soft elastomer alternative to polypropylene for pelvic organ prolapse repair: a preliminary study

Profiling of the macrophage response to polypropylene mesh burden in vivo

Pelvic organ prolapse (POP) surgical repair with polypropylene mesh (PPM) offers improved anatomical outcomes compared to reconstruction using native tissue. However, PPM repair is hampered by complications, most commonly pain or mesh exposure, occurring in over 10 % of cases. This maladaptive response is, in part, attributed to the host response to a foreign material. Previous studies have demonstrated that mesh properties, such as weight, pore size, and porosity, influence downstream outcomes. In addition, computational models and in vivo mechanistic studies demonstrate that mesh deforms after tensioning in prolapse surgery resulting in collapsed pores and wrinkles. To further investigate the role of pore collapse in mesh complications, PPM was implanted flat, or in configurations that would deform upon tensioning in a POP repair surgery using a non-human primate model. After twelve weeks, we analyzed mesh-tissue complexes to characterize the overall host response, profile the macrophage response, and observe the influence of macrophages in downstream healing outcomes that may lead to complications. The results confirm that mesh deformations reproduce mesh exposure and thinning of vagina. In the PPM configurations with the greatest deformation, mesh burden was the highest, which resulted in an overall decrease in the number of cells within the implantation site. Among the cells that were present, we observed a predominance of M1 pro-inflammatory macrophages. While flat mesh was associated with an organized cellular response, deformed mesh led to an increasingly disorganized response as mesh burden increased. Nearly half of the responding macrophages expressed markers associated both with M1 and M2 phenotypes concurrently, suggesting the possibility of newly recruited macrophages responding even 12 weeks after implantation and/or a repetitive microinjury in which macrophages are continuously recruited and polarized without resolution of the host response. Biochemically, we observed a predominantly M1 pro-inflammatory signaling environment and decreased collagen content as a response to implanted mesh. This study evidences the importance of PPM mesh properties, which may alter mesh burden upon tensioning and impact downstream healing outcomes and emphasizes the need for devices that maintain their geometry following implantation in POP surgical repair.

Vaginal host response to polycarbonate urethane, an alternative material for the repair of pelvic organ prolapse

Complications following surgical repair of pelvic organ prolapse (POP) with polypropylene mesh (PPM) are common. Recent data attributes complications, in part, to stiffness mismatches between the vagina and PPM. We developed a 3D printed elastomeric membrane (EM) from a softer polymer, polycarbonate urethane (PCU). EMs were manufactured with more material given the low inherent material strength of PCU. We hypothesized that the EMs would be associated with an improved host response as compared to PPM. A secondary goal was to optimize the material distribution (fiber width and device thickness) within EMs, in regards to the host response. EM constructs (2 × 1 cm2) with varied polymer stiffness, fiber width, and device thickness were implanted onto the vagina of New Zealand white rabbits for 12 weeks and compared to similarly sized PPMs. Sham implanted animals served as controls. Mixed effects generalized linear models were used to compare the effect of construct type accounting for differences in independent variables. EMs had an overall superior host response compared to PPM as evidenced by preservation of vaginal smooth muscle morphology (p-values<0.01), decreased total cellular response to construct fibers (p-values<0.001), and a reduced percent of macrophages (p-values<0.02) independent of how the material was distributed. Both PPM and EMs negatively impacted vaginal contractility and glycosaminoglycan (GAG) content relative to Sham (all p-values<0.001) with EMs having less of an impact on GAGs (p-values<0.003). The results suggest that softer PCU EMs made with more material are well tolerated by the vagina and comprises a future material for POP repair devices. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Prolapse is a debilitating condition in which loss of support to the vagina causes it and the organs supported by it to descend from their normal position in the pelvis. Surgical solutions to rebuild support involves the use of polypropylene mesh which is orders of magnitude stiffer than the vagina. This mismatch results in complications including exposure of the mesh into the vagina and pain. To provide an innovative solution for women, we have developed an elastomeric membrane from a soft polymer that matches the stiffness of the vagina. Here, we show in a rabbit animal model that this device incorporates better into the vagina and is associated with an overall improved host response as compared to polypropylene mesh.

Regenerative Medicine in Gynecology

The female reproductive tract undergoes dynamic changes across the life span. Congenital abnormalities, life events, and medical interventions can negatively affect the structure and function of reproductive tract organs, resulting in lifelong sequelae. The objective of regenerative gynecology is to discover and promote endogenous mechanisms by which a healthy tissue maintains overall tissue integrity after injury, after disease, or with age. In this review, we discuss some of the key state-of-the-art cell-based and scaffolding therapies that have been applied to regenerate gynecologic tissues and organs primarily in animal and tissue culture models. We further discuss the limitations of current technologies, problems of implementation and scalability, and future outlook of the field.

The use of animal models in preclinical investigations for the development of a surgical mesh for pelvic organ prolapse

INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS

Polypropylene (PP) mesh for the treatment of pelvic organ prolapse (POP) has raised substantial concerns over long-term complications, leading to its ban in multiple countries. In response, emerging materials are being explored as alternatives for prolapse surgery. Preclinical animal models have historically played a pivotal role in validating medical devices, prior to clinical trials. Successful translation of these materials necessitates the identification of suitable animal models that replicate the female human pelvis and its biomechanical properties. Preclinical in vivo testing assesses the safety of surgical mesh and treatment efficacy in preventing POP recurrence.

METHODS

The research critically reviews animal models used for preclinical pelvic mesh testing over the last decade and proposes a promising model for future preclinical studies.

RESULTS

Rats were the most common mammal used for toxicity and biocompatibility investigations through abdominal implantation. Although non-human primates serve as a gold standard for efficacy testing, ethical considerations limit their use owing to their close biological and cognitive resemblance to humans. Consequently, sheep were the most preferred large animal model owing to their reproductive system similarities and propensity for spontaneous POP following parity.

CONCLUSION

The study contributes valuable insights into the selection of appropriate animal models for preclinical pelvic mesh testing, offering guidance that is crucial for enhancing the safety and efficacy of novel surgical interventions in the treatment of POP.

Polypropylene Pelvic Mesh: What Went Wrong and What Will Be of the Future?

Background: Polypropylene (PP) pelvic mesh is a synthetic mesh made of PP polymer used to treat pelvic organ prolapse (POP). Its use has become highly controversial due to reports of serious complications. This research critically reviews the current management options for POP and PP mesh as a viable clinical application for the treatment of POP. The safety and suitability of PP material were rigorously studied and critically evaluated, with consideration to the mechanical and chemical properties of PP. We proposed the ideal properties of the ‘perfect’ synthetic pelvic mesh with emerging advanced materials. Methods: We performed a literature review using PubMed/Medline, Embase, Cochrane Library (Wiley) databases, and ClinicalTrials.gov databases, including the relevant keywords: pelvic organ prolapse (POP), polypropylene mesh, synthetic mesh, and mesh complications. Results: The results of this review found that although PP is nontoxic, its physical properties demonstrate a significant mismatch between its viscoelastic properties compared to the surrounding tissue, which is a likely cause of complications. In addition, a lack of integration of PP mesh into surrounding tissue over longer periods of follow up is another risk factor for irreversible complications. Conclusions: PP mesh has caused a rise in reports of complications involving chronic pain and mesh exposure. This is due to the mechanical and physicochemical properties of PP mesh. As a result, PP mesh for the treatment of POP has been banned in multiple countries, currently with no alternative available. We propose the development of a pelvic mesh using advanced materials including emerging graphene-based nanocomposite materials.

Biomaterials science and engineering to address unmet needs in women's health

Medical conditions that primarily or disproportionately affect women have historically been poorly studied. In contrast to the musculoskeletal and cardiovascular systems, there is no lengthy record of biomaterials research addressing women's health needs. In this article, the historical reasons for this discrepancy are examined. The anatomy of both the nonpregnant and pregnant reproductive tissues is reviewed, including the ovaries, uterus, and (fetal) placenta. Examples of biomaterials-related women's health research are described, including tissue engineering, organoids, and microphysiological systems. The future of the field is considered with dual focuses. First, there is a significant need for novel approaches to advance women's health through materials and biomaterials, particularly in complex biomimetic hydrogels. Second, there is an exciting opportunity to enlarge the community of biomaterials scientists and engineers working in women's health to encourage more contributions to its rapidly emerging product development pipeline.

Graphical abstract

Mesh Deformation: a mechanism underlying polypropylene prolapse mesh complications in vivo

Polypropylene meshes used in pelvic organ prolapse (POP) repair are hampered by complications. Most POP meshes are highly unstable after tensioning ex vivo, as evidenced by marked deformations (pore collapse and wrinkling) that result in altered structural properties and material burden. By intentionally introducing collapsed pores and wrinkles into a mesh that normally has open pores and remains relatively flat after implantation, we reproduce mesh complications in vivo. To do this, meshes were implanted onto the vagina of rhesus macaques in nondeformed (flat) vs deformed (pore collapse +/- wrinkles) configurations and placed on tension. Twelve weeks later, animals with deformed meshes had two complications, 1) mesh exposure through the vaginal epithelium, and 2) myofibroblast proliferation with fibrosis - a mechanism of pain. The overarching response to deformed mesh was vaginal thinning associated with accelerated apoptosis, reduced collagen content, increased proteolysis, deterioration of mechanical integrity, and loss of contractile function consistent with stress shielding - a precursor to mesh exposure. Regional differences were observed, however, with some areas demonstrating myofibroblast proliferation and matrix deposition. Variable mechanical cues imposed by deformed meshes likely induce these two disparate responses. Utilizing meshes associated with uniform stresses on the vagina by remaining flat with open pores after tensioning is critical to improving outcomes. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Pain and exposure are the two most reported complications associated with the use of polypropylene mesh in urogynecologic procedures. Most meshes have unstable geometries as evidenced by pore collapse and wrinkling after tensioning ex vivo, recapitulating what is observed in meshes excised from women with complications in vivo. We demonstrate that collapsed pores and wrinkling results in two distinct responses 1) mesh exposure associated with tissue degradation and atrophy and 2) myofibroblast proliferation and matrix deposition consistent with fibrosis, a tissue response associated with pain. In conclusion, mesh deformation leads to areas of tissue degradation and myofibroblast proliferation, the likely mechanisms of mesh exposure and pain, respectively. These data corroborate that mesh implantation in a flat configuration with open pores is a critical factor for reducing complications in mesh-augmented surgeries.

Design, mechanical and degradation requirements of biodegradable metal mesh for pelvic floor reconstruction

Pelvic organ prolapse (POP) is the herniation of surrounding tissue and organs into the vagina and or rectum, and is a result of weakening of pelvic floor muscles, connective tissue,...