Development of an echocardiographic scoring system to predict biventricular repair in neonatal hypoplastic left heart complex

Contemporary management of borderline left ventricle

Borderline left ventricle cases present considerable difficulties in determining the most effective surgical approaches. The evolution of approaches in the field has shifted from classical systemic pulmonary shunts to orthodox univentricular palliation and has subsequently seen the emergence of biventricular repair concepts. The concept of biventricular repair for borderline left heart conditions has developed through studies that aim to establish predictive scoring systems for identifying appropriate candidates. Despite continuous efforts, a definitive scoring system for guiding this decision is still difficult to find. There is a growing trend to provide neonatal patients with borderline ventricles with options other than univentricular palliation. Several centres have developed personalized strategies, including hybrid and staged ventricular recruitment approaches. These strategies provide sufficient time for personalized decision-making, taking into account the individual circumstances of each patient. This article presents an overview of the changing approaches to borderline left ventricular cases. It discusses the use of predictive scoring systems and emphasizes the advancements in staged strategies that improve the likelihood of successful biventricular repairs.

Borderline Ventricles: From Evaluation to Treatment

A heart with a borderline ventricle refers to a situation where there is uncertainty about whether the left or right underdeveloped ventricle can effectively support the systemic or pulmonary circulation with appropriate filling pressures and sufficient physiological reserve. Pediatric cardiologists often deal with congenital heart diseases (CHDs) associated with various degrees of hypoplasia of the left or right ventricles. To date, no specific guidelines exist, and surgical management may be extremely variable in different centers and sometimes even in the same center at different times. Thus, the choice between the single-ventricle or biventricular approach is always controversial. The aim of this review is to better define when "small is too small and large is large enough" in order to help clinicians make the decision that could potentially affect the patient's entire life.

Neonates and Infants with Left Heart Obstruction and Borderline Left Ventricle Undergoing Biventricular Repair: What Do We Know about Long-Term Outcomes? A Critical Review

BACKGROUND

The decision to perform biventricular repair (BVR) in neonates and infants presenting with either single or multiple left ventricle outflow obstructions (LVOTOs) and a borderline left ventricle (BLV) is subject to extensive discussion, and limited information is known regarding the long-term outcomes. As a result, the objective of this study is to critically assess and summarize the available data regarding the prognosis of neonates and infants with LVOTO and BLV who underwent BVR.

METHODS

In February 2023, we conducted a review study with three different medical search engines (the National Library of Medicine, Science Direct, and Cochrane Library) for Medical Subject Headings and free text terms including "congenital heart disease", "outcome", and "borderline left ventricle". The search was refined by adding keywords for "Shone's complex", "complex LVOT obstruction", "hypoplastic left heart syndrome/complex", and "critical aortic stenosis".

RESULTS

Out of a total of 51 studies, 15 studies were included in the final analysis. The authors utilized heterogeneous definitions to characterize BLV, resulting in considerable variation in inclusion criteria among studies. Three distinct categories of studies were identified, encompassing those specifically designed to evaluate BLV, those focused on Shone's complex, and finally those on aortic stenosis. Despite the challenges associated with comparing data originating from slightly different cardiac defects and from different eras, our results indicate a favorable survival rate and clinical outcome following BVR. However, the incidence of reintervention remains high, and concerns persist regarding residual pulmonary hypertension, which has been inadequately investigated.

CONCLUSIONS

The available data concerning neonates and infants with LVOTO and BLV who undergo BVR are inadequate and fragmented. Consequently, large-scale studies are necessary to fully ascertain the long-term outcome of these complex defects.

Hybrid Palliation for Hypoplastic Borderline Left Ventricle: One More Chance to Biventricular Repair

Treatment options for hypoplastic borderline left ventricle (LV) are critically dependent on the development of the LV itself and include different types of univentricular palliation or biventricular repair performed at birth. Since hybrid palliation allows deferring major surgery to 4-6 months, in borderline cases, the decision can be postponed until the LV has expressed its growth potential. We aimed to evaluate anatomic modifications of borderline LV after hybrid palliation. We retrospectively reviewed data from 45 consecutive patients with hypoplastic LV who underwent hybrid palliation at birth between 2011 and 2015. Sixteen patients (mean weight 3.15 Kg) exhibited borderline LV and were considered for potential LV growth. After 5 months, five patients underwent univentricular palliation (Group 1), eight biventricular repairs (Group 2) and three died before surgery. Echocardiograms of Groups 1 and 2 were reviewed, comparing LV structures at birth and after 5 months. Although, at birth, all LV measurements were far below the normal limits, after 5 months, LV mass in Group 2 was almost normal, while in Group 1, no growth was evident. However, aortic root diameter and long axis ratio were significantly higher in Group 2 already at birth. Hybrid palliation can be positively considered as a "bridge-to-decision" for borderline LV. Echocardiography plays a key role in monitoring the growth of borderline LV.

Fetal Echocardiography in Predicting Postnatal Outcome in Borderline Left Ventricle

OBJECTIVES

 Prenatal prediction of postnatal univentricular versus biventricular circulation in patients with borderline left ventricle (bLV) remains challenging. This study investigated prenatal fetal echocardiographic parameters and postnatal outcome of patients with a prenatally diagnosed bLV.

METHODS

 We report a retrospective study of bLV patients at four prenatal centers with a follow-up of one year. BLV was defined as z-scores of the left ventricle (LV) between -2 and -4. Single-ventricle palliation (SVP), biventricular repair (BVR), and no surgical or catheter-based intervention served as the dependent outcome. Prenatal ultrasound parameters were used as independent variables. Cut-off values from receiver operating characteristic curves (ROC) were determined for significant discrimination between outcomes.

RESULTS

 A total of 54 patients were diagnosed with bLV from 2010 to 2018. All were live births. Out of the entire cohort, 8 (15 %) received SVP, 34 (63 %) BVR, and 12 (22 %) no intervention. There was no significant difference with regard to genetic or extracardiac anomalies. There were significantly more patients with endocardial fibroelastosis (EFE) in the SVP group compared to the BVR group (80 % vs. 10 %), (p < 0.001). Apex-forming LV (100 % vs. 70 %) and lack of retrograde arch flow (20 % vs. 80 %) were associated with no intervention (p < 0.001). With respect to BVR vs. SVP, the LV sphericity index provided the highest specificity (91.7 %) using a cutoff value of ≤ 0.5.

CONCLUSION

 The majority of bLV patients maintained biventricular circulation. EFE, retrograde arch flow, and LV sphericity can be helpful parameters for counseling parents and further prospective studies can be developed.

Echocardiographic scores for biventricular repair risk prediction of congenital heart disease with borderline left ventricle: a review

The aim of this review is to highlight the strengths and limitations of major echocardiographic biventricular repair (BVR) prediction models for borderline left ventricle (LV) in complex congenital heart disease (CHD). A systematic search in the National Library of Medicine for Medical Subject Headings and free text terms including echocardiography, CHD, and scores, was performed. The search was refined by adding keywords for critical aortic stenosis (AS), borderline LV, complex left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) obstruction, hypoplastic left heart syndrome/complex (HLHS/HLHC), and unbalanced atrio-ventricular septal defects (uAVSD). Fifteen studies were selected for the final analysis. We outlined what echocardiographic scores for different types of complex CHD with diminutive LV are available. Scores for CHD with LVOT obstruction including critical AS, HLHS/HLHC, and aortic arch hypoplasia have been validated and implemented by several studies. Scores for uAVSD with right ventricle (RV) dominance have also been established and implemented, the first being the atrioventricular valve index (AVVI). In addition to AVII, both LV/RV inflow angle and LV inflow index have all been validated for the prediction of BVR. We conclude with a discussion of limitations in the development and validation of each of these scores, including retrospective design during score development, heterogeneity in echocardiographic parameters evaluated, variability in the definition of outcomes, differences in adopted surgical and Interventional strategies, and institutional differences. Furthermore, scores developed in the past two decades may have little clinical relevance now. In summary, we provide a review of echocardiographic scores for BVR in complex CHD with a diminutive LV that may serve as a guide for use in modern clinical practice.

Imaging of Left Ventricular Hypoplasia

Left ventricular hypoplasia is a common finding in various forms of congenital heart disease. Echocardiography in the setting of left ventricular hypoplasia must comprehensively assess the size and function of all left-sided structures including the mitral valve, left ventricular outflow tract, aortic valve and aortic arch. Of most importance in any variation of left ventricular hypoplasia is the left ventricular inlet. In neonates, the left ventricular inlet often determines the adequacy of the left ventricle and is the most difficult component to treat surgically.

Biventricular Conversion for Hypoplastic Left Heart Variants: An Update

Ongoing concerns with single-ventricle palliation morbidity and poor outcomes from primary biventricular strategies for neonates with borderline left heart structures have led some centers to attempt alternative strategies to obviate the need for ultimate Fontan palliation and limit the risk to the child during the vulnerable neonatal period. In certain patients who are traditionally palliated toward single-ventricle circulation, biventricular circulation is possible. This review aims to delineate the current knowledge regarding converting certain patients with borderline left heart structures from single-ventricle palliation toward biventricular circulation.

Fetal growth of left-sided structures and postnatal surgical outcome in borderline left heart varies by cardiac phenotype

OBJECTIVES

There are two borderline left-heart phenotypes in the fetus: (1) severe aortic stenosis (AS), which is associated with a 'short, fat', globular left ventricle (LV), LV systolic dysfunction and LV growth arrest; and (2) severe left-heart hypoplasia (LHH), which is associated with a 'long, skinny' LV, laminar flow across hypoplastic mitral and aortic valves and arch hypoplasia. Both phenotypes may be counseled for possible single-ventricle palliation. We aimed to compare the rates of left-sided cardiac structure growth and Z-score change over gestation and to describe the postnatal outcomes associated with these two phenotypes. We hypothesized that the left-sided structures would grow faster in fetuses with LHH compared to those with AS, and that those with LHH would be more likely to achieve biventricular circulation.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study using data collected in an institutional cardiology database between April 2001 and April 2018. We included fetuses with severe AS or severe LHH, and with at least two fetal echocardiograms. Inclusion criteria for the AS group included: aortic-annulus Z-score < -2.0, severe AS, depressed LV function, retrograde systolic flow in the aortic arch and endocardial fibroelastosis. Inclusion criteria for the LHH group included: aortic-annulus Z-score < -2.0, hypoplastic but apex-forming LV, normal LV function and retrograde systolic flow in the aortic arch. Exclusion criteria were: abnormal cardiac connections, other forms of structural congenital heart disease, cardiomyopathy, history of fetal aortic valvuloplasty and participation in a maternal hyperoxygenation study. Measurements and respective Z-scores for the aortic-valve annulus, mitral-valve annulus, LV long- and short-axis dimensions, along with aortic-arch measurements, were collected longitudinally for each fetus and plotted over time for both cohorts. Mean slopes of change in dimension and Z-scores over gestation were calculated and compared between the two groups using mixed generalized linear regression accounting for repeated measures. A subanalysis was performed, matching six fetuses from each group for initial aortic-annulus Z-score and gestational age, due to the significant differences in these two variables between the original cohorts.

RESULTS

In total, 53 fetuses with 158 echocardiograms were included. In the AS cohort, there were 20 (38%) fetuses with 65 echocardiograms, and in the LHH cohort there were 33 (62%) fetuses with 93 echocardiograms. On the first echocardiogram, LHH fetuses had a later gestational age and a larger aortic-annulus diameter. The rate of aortic-annulus growth was greater in the LHH group compared with the AS group (mean ± SD, 0.15 ± 0.01 mm/week for LHH vs 0.07 ± 0.01 mm/week for AS (P < 0.001)). While the LHH group had a decrease in aortic-annulus Z-score over time, this was at a slower rate than the decrease in the AS group (mean ± SD, -0.04 ± 0.02/week for LHH vs -0.13 ± 0.02/week for AS (P < 0.001)). A similar pattern was seen for the mitral-valve and LV short-axis-dimension Z-scores. Subanalysis of six fetuses from each group matched for initial aortic-annulus Z-score and gestational age demonstrated similar findings, with the LHH group Z-scores decreasing at a slower rate than those in the AS group. Fifty-two of the 53 fetuses were liveborn, one LHH fetus dying in utero. Of the 20 liveborn in the AS cohort, 15 (75%) infants underwent single-ventricle palliation, two (10%) underwent biventricular repair and three (15%) died prior to intervention. Of the 32 liveborn in the LHH cohort, three (9.4%) underwent single-ventricle palliation, 28 (87.5%) achieved biventricular circulation, of which six required no surgery, and one (3.1%) died prior to intervention.

CONCLUSIONS

The left-sided cardiac structures grow at a faster rate in fetuses with severe LHH than they do in fetuses with severe AS, and the Z-scores decrease at a slower rate in fetuses with severe LHH than they do in those with severe AS. The majority of infants in the LHH group did not undergo single-ventricle palliation. This information can be useful in counseling families on the expected growth potential of the fetus's aortic valve, mitral valve and LV, depending on the cardiac phenotype. © 2022 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.

Total anomalous pulmonary venous connection mimicking hypoplastic left heart syndrome

A newborn with supracardiac total anomalous pulmonary venous connection vein presented the small left ventricle with z score of -7.5, retrograde blood supply in the transverse arch, and the dutcus-dependent systemic circulation. The patient underwent the repair of the anomalous pulmonary vein and bilateral pulmonary arterial banding soon after the birth and then transcatheter pulmonary arterial debanding at the age of 10 months because of an appropriate growth of the left ventricle.

Fetal echocardiographic predictors of biventricular circulation in hypoplastic left heart complex

OBJECTIVES

To determine which echocardiographic features of hypoplastic left heart complex (HLHC) in the fetal period are predictive of biventricular (BV) circulation and to evaluate the long-term outcome of patients with HLHC, including rates of mortality, reintervention and development of further cardiac disease.

METHODS

Echocardiograms of fetuses with HLHC obtained at 18-26 weeks and 27-36 weeks' gestation between 2004 and 2017 were included in the analysis. The primary outcome was successful BV circulation (Group 1). Group 2 included patients with single-ventricle palliation, death or transplant. Univariate analysis was performed on data obtained at 18-26 and 27-36 weeks and multivariate logistic regression was performed on data obtained at 27-36 weeks only.

RESULTS

Of the 51 included cases, 44 achieved successful BV circulation (Group 1) and seven did not (Group 2). Right-to-left/bidirectional foramen ovale (FO) flow and a higher mitral valve (MV) annulus Z-score were associated with successful BV circulation on both univariate and multivariate analysis. Bidirectional or left-to-right FO flow, left ventricular length (LVL) Z-score of < -2.4 and a MV Z-score of < -4.5 correctly predicted 80% of Group 2 cases. Late follow-up was available for 41 patients. There were two late deaths in Group 2. Thirteen patients in Group 1 required reintervention, 12 developed mitral stenosis and five developed isolated subaortic stenosis.

CONCLUSIONS

BV circulation is common in fetuses with HLHC. Higher MV annulus and LVL Z-scores and right to left direction of FO flow are important predictors of BV circulation. Long-term sequelae in those with BV circulation may include mitral and subaortic stenosis. © 2020 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.

Small and borderline left ventricular outflow tract - a perplexing maladie

The left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) comprises of the subvalvular area, the aortic valve, and the supravalvular region. Obstructive lesion of LVOT is a spectrum with varying levels and degree of obstruction with or without associated hypoplasia of the left ventricle. Decision-making in small and borderline LVOT can be challenging. Imaging modalities such as echocardiography and magnetic resonance imaging and scores based on imaging aid in the decision making in truly borderline cases. Newer treatment strategies like staged left ventricular rehabilitation and hybrid procedure have come to the fore in the past decade or so. Although these do not address small LVOT per se, they delay the decision-making to a more appropriate age. The goal of management in these cases is to achieve a biventricular repair whenever feasible. Several surgical techniques could be employed to achieve this goal. However, it is important to be cognizant of the fact that an overzealous approach to achieve a biventricular repair might be counterproductive. A univentricular palliation could be a safer alternative; especially considering the possibility of a future transplant candidacy.

Role of echocardiographic scoring systems in predicting successful biventricular versus univentricular palliation in neonates with critical aortic stenosis

BACKGROUND

There are several published echo-derived scores to help predict successful biventricular versus univentricular palliation in neonates with critical aortic stenosis. This study aims to determine whether any published scoring system accurately predicted outcomes in these neonates.

METHODS

Single centre, retrospective cohort study including neonates who underwent aortic valve intervention (surgical valvotomy or balloon valvuloplasty) with the intention of biventricular circulation. Primary outcome was survival with biventricular circulation at hospital discharge. Data from their initial neonatal echocardiogram were used to compute the following scores - Rhodes, CHSS 1, Discriminant, CHSS 2, and 2 V.

RESULTS

Between 01/1999 and 12/2017, 68 neonates underwent aortic valve intervention at a median age of 4 days (range 1-29 days); 35 surgical valvotomy and 33 balloon valvuloplasty. Survival with biventricular circulation was maintained in 60/68 patients at hospital discharge. Of the remaining eight patients, three were converted to univentricular palliation, four died, and one underwent heart transplant prior to discharge. None of the binary score predictions of biventricular versus univentricular (using that score's proposed cut-offs) were significantly associated with the observed outcome in this cohort. A high percentage of those predicted to need univentricular palliation had successful biventricular repair: 89.4% by Rhodes, 79.3% by CHSS 1, 85.2% by Discriminant, and 66.7% by CHSS 2 score. The 2 V best predicted outcome and agreed with the local approach in most cases.

CONCLUSION

This study highlights the limitations of and need for alternative scoring systems/cut-offs for consistently accurate echocardiographic prediction of early outcome in neonates with critical aortic stenosis.

Biventricular Conversion in the Borderline Hypoplastic Heart

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The development of biventricular repair and conversion pathways for patients with borderline hypoplastic heart disease represents an area of recent inquiry and innovation. This review summarizes emerging techniques and novel treatment algorithms for borderline hypoplastic heart disease with a focus on surgical advances within the last 10 years.

RECENT FINDINGS

Many patients with borderline hypoplastic heart disease are amenable to primary biventricular repair, or biventricular conversion following single-ventricle palliation coupled with ventricular rehabilitation strategies. New insights into the potential for growth and recovery of borderline ventricles have been uncovered. However, questions remain regarding optimal patient selection and the long-term outcomes of select patient groups treated with single-ventricle palliation versus biventricular repair/conversion or transplantation. Efforts to direct a greater proportion of borderline hypoplastic heart patients towards a biventricular circulation are accelerating and represent important avenues for progress and future research in the field of congenital heart disease.

Prediction of biventricular repair by echocardiography in borderline ventricle

Objective:

In recent years, attempting the biventricular pathway or biventricular conversions in patients with borderline ventricle has become a hot topic. However, inappropriate pursuit of biventricular repair in borderline candidates will lead to adverse clinical outcomes. Therefore, it is important to accurately assess the degree of ventricular development before operation and whether it can tolerate biventricular repair. This review evaluated ventricular development using echocardiography for a better prediction of biventricular repair in borderline ventricle.

Data sources:

Articles from January 1, 1990 to April 1, 2019 on biventricular repair in borderline ventricle were accessed from PubMed, using keywords including “borderline ventricle,” “congenital heart disease,” “CHD,” “echocardiography,” and “biventricular repair.”

Study selection:

Original articles and critical reviews relevant to the review's theme were selected.

Results:

Borderline left ventricle (LV): (1) Critical aortic stenosis: the Rhodes score, Congenital Heart Surgeons Society regression equation and another new scoring system was proposed to predict the feasibility of biventricular repair. (2) Aortic arch hypoplasia: the LV size and the diameter of aortic and mitral valve (MV) annulus should be taken into considerations for biventricular repair. (3) Right-dominant unbalanced atrioventricular septal defect (AVSD): atrioventricular valve index (AVVI), left ventricular inflow index (LVII), and right ventricle (RV)/LV inflow angle were the echocardiographic indices for biventricular repair. Borderline RV: (1) pulmonary atresia/intact ventricular septum (PA/IVS): the diameter z-score of tricuspid valve (TV) annulus, ratio of TV to MV diameter, RV inlet length z-score, RV area z-score, RV development index, and RV-TV index, etc. Less objective but more practical description is to classify the RV as tripartite, bipartite, and unipartite. The presence or absence of RV sinusoids, RV dependent coronary circulation, and the degree of tricuspid regurgitation should also be noted. (2) Left-dominant unbalanced AVSD: AVVI, LV, and RV volumes, whether apex forming ventricles were the echocardiographic indices for biventricular repair.

Conclusions:

Although the evaluation of echocardiography cannot guarantee the success of biventricular repair surgery, echocardiography can still provide relatively valuable basis for surgical decision making.

Short-term results in infants with multiple left heart obstructive lesions

OBJECTIVE

Deciding on a surgical pathway for neonates with ≥2 left heart obstructive lesions is complex. Predictors of the successful biventricular (2V) repair in these patients are poorly defined. The goal of our study was to identify patients who underwent the 2V repair and assess anatomic and echocardiographic predictors of success.

DESIGN

Infants born between July 2015 and August 2017 with ≥2 left heart obstructive lesions with no prior interventions were identified (n = 19). Patients with aortic or mitral valve (MV) atresia and critical aortic stenosis were excluded. Initial echocardiograms were reviewed for aortic, MV, tricuspid valve annulus size, and left (LV) and right (RV) ventricle diastolic longitudinal dimensions. The valve morphology and presence of a ventricular septal defect (VSD) and coarctation were assessed. Clinical outcomes included successful 2V repair, complications, and repeat interventions or surgeries. Failed 2V repair was defined as a takedown to single ventricle (1V) physiology, cardiac transplantation, or death.

RESULTS

For 2V repair, 14/19 patients were selected and for 1V, 5/19 patients were selected. Initial surgical procedures of the 2V group were simple coarctation repair (5), complex coarctation/arch reconstruction +/- septal defect closure (6), hybrid stage 1 (2), and none (1). Three of the 2V patients required reintervention in the first 90 days. The LV to RV diastolic longitudinal ratio >0.75 and mitral/tricuspid ratio of <0.8 were observed in 13/14 of the 2V patients. The LV:RV ratio and the aortic valve z score were significantly larger in the 2V group compared to the 1V group. All patients in the 1V group had a nonapex forming LV. There was no mortality with follow-up to three years of age.

CONCLUSIONS

This study showed excellent short-term and midterm surgical results in the 2V population. The LV:RV diastolic longitudinal ratio may be a useful tool in the risk stratification of a successful 2V repair even in cases with a small MV.

Pre-intervention morphologic and functional echocardiographic characteristics of neonates with critical left heart obstruction: a Congenital Heart Surgeons Society (CHSS) inception cohort study

AIMS

The aims of this study were to provide a detailed descriptive analysis of pre-intervention morphologic and functional echocardiographic parameters in a large, unselected, multicentre cohort of neonates diagnosed with critical left heart obstruction and to compare echocardiographic features between the different subtypes of left-sided lesions.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Pre-intervention echocardiograms for 651 patients from 19 Congenital Heart Surgeons' Society (CHSS) institutions were reviewed in a core lab according to a standardized protocol including >150 morphologic and functional variables. The four most common subtypes of lesions were: aortic atresia (AA)/mitral atresia (MA) (29% of patients), AA/mitral stenosis (MS) (20%), aortic stenosis (AS)/MS (26%), and isolated AS (iAS) (18%). Only 17% of patients with AS/MS had an apex-forming left ventricle, compared with 0% of those with AA/MA and AA/MS (P < 0.0001). Aortic arch hypoplasia and coarctation were common across all four groups, while those with AA/MA and AA/MS had the smallest ascending aorta diameters. Flow in the ascending aorta was retrograde in 43% and 10% of the patients with AS/MS and iAS, respectively. The right ventricle was apex forming in 100% of patients with AA/MA and AA/MS, 96% with AS/MS and 70% with iAS (P < 0.0001). Moderate to severe tricuspid regurgitation was present in 13% of all patients.

CONCLUSION

This large multi-institutional study generates insight into the distribution of the functional and morphologic spectrum in patients with critical left-sided heart disease and identifies differences in these functional and morphologic characteristics between the main anatomic subtypes of critical left heart obstruction.

Assessing the borderline ventricle in a term infant: combining imaging and physiology to establish the right course

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The purpose of this review is to describe the challenges associated with the diagnosis and treatment of children with borderline ventricles. A borderline ventricle is one in which there is concern that it will not be able to support its circulation. If a biventricular repair is attempted and fails, outcome is often poor. Thus, this early decision is important.

RECENT FINDINGS

For the borderline right ventricle, options to add an additional source of pulmonary blood flow make the surgical strategy a bit more flexible than for patients with a borderline left ventricle. In general, outcome for a so-called one and one-half ventricle repair are generally good, though the long-term outcome and the effects of this physiology on lifelong exercise performance and quality of life remain to be seen. For the small left ventricle, often multiple surgeries are required to 'force' blood into the left ventricle and potentially help it grow. Though this strategy is successful in some, in others it results in significant residual cardiac issues including pulmonary hypertension.

SUMMARY

Determining whether a patient will be better off in the long term with a marginal biventricular repair versus a Fontan circulation remains one of the most difficult problems in the field of pediatric cardiology and cardiac surgery.

The Role of Echocardiography and Intracardiac Exploration in the Evaluation of Candidacy for Biventricular Repair in Patients With Borderline Left Heart Structures

BACKGROUND

Predictors for single ventricle palliation (SVP) or successful biventricular repair (BVR) in patients with borderline left-side heart structures are not well defined. The goal was to evaluate the role of echocardiography and intracardiac exploration in determining feasibility of BVR.

METHODS

All neonates surgically treated from 1995 to 2015 with mitral valve (MV), aortic valve, or left ventricle end-diastolic dimension z score of -2 or less for whom management was controversial were included. Data were analyzed using Fisher's exact test, Kruskal-Wallis test, and Kaplan-Meier analysis.

RESULTS

The cohort consisted of 42 patients: 7 SVP (17%) and 35 BVR (83%). Median follow-up was 7 years (range, 6 months to 18 years). Intracardiac exploration was performed in 29 patients (69%). There was poor correlation between echocardiographic and intraoperative MV measurements (intraclass correlation coefficient 0.14). Preoperative echocardiography significantly underestimated MV size in 14 patients (54%). Two BVR patients were converted to SVP, and 4 (including 1 converted patient) had cardiac-related deaths. All patients with MV greater than 8 mm on preoperative echocardiography had successful BVR. An intraoperative MV less than 8 mm and an abnormal subvalvar apparatus was present in 5 of 6 SVP (83%) and 3 of 3 (100%) failed BVR patients who had intracardiac exploration, and in only 1 of 20 successful BVR patients (5%) who had an intracardiac exploration.

CONCLUSIONS

The decision to proceed to BVR in patients with borderline left-side heart structures should not rely strictly on echocardiographic measurements. Intracardiac exploration of the MV and subvalvar apparatus is useful before committing a patient to SVP. Patients with low MV z scores, especially those with a normal subvalvar apparatus, may undergo BVR with good outcomes.

Characterising adequacy or inadequacy of the borderline left ventricle: what tools can we use?

Borderline left ventricle refers to a spectrum of left ventricular underdevelopment, typically associated with other cardiac anomalies. The left ventricle may be mildly hypoplastic, as is sometimes seen accompanying aortic coarctation, or it can be severely hypoplastic, as is seen in hypoplastic left heart syndrome. For patients with a borderline left ventricle that is at either extreme, the treatment decision is relatively straightforward. Those with the most severe form of left ventricle hypoplasia will require single ventricle palliation or cardiac transplantation, whereas those with the mildest form may not need any intervention. It is the management strategy of children that fall within the grey zone of the spectrum, which continues to be controversial and remains variable within and among different institutions. Cardiac diseases with associated left ventricle hypoplasia include critical aortic stenosis, mitral stenosis, coarctation of the aorta, arch hypoplasia, cor triatriatum, unbalanced common atrioventricular canal, Shone's complex, total anomalous pulmonary venous return, and complex conotruncal abnormalities. In this review, we will discuss the assessment and management of infants with borderline left ventricle with critical aortic stenosis or arch obstruction and associated mitral anomalies.