Hydrogen metabolic patterns driven by Clostridium-Streptococcus community shifts in a continuous stirred tank reactor

Unrevealing the role of metal oxide nanoparticles on biohydrogen production by Lactobacillus delbrueckii

The positive interaction between Clostridium sp. and lactic acid-producing bacteria (Lactobacillus sp) is commonly seen in various high-rate hydrogen production systems. However, the exact role of the hydrogen production ability of Lactobacillus sp in a dark fermentation production system is rarely studied. Lactobacillus delbrueckii was herein used for the first time, to the best of the author's knowledge, to demonstrate biohydrogen production under anaerobic conditions. At first, the pH condition was optimized, followed by the addition of nanoparticles for enhanced biohydrogen production. Under optimized conditions of pH 6.5, substrate concentration 10 g/L, and 100 mg/L of NiO/Fe₂O₃, the maximum hydrogen yield (HY) of 1.94 mol/mol hexose was obtained, which is 18 % more than the control. The enhanced H₂ production upon the addition of nanoparticles is supported via the external electron transfer (EET) mechanism, which regulates the metabolic pathway regulation with increased production of acetate and butyrate and reduced formation of lactate.

Debottlenecking the biological hydrogen production pathway of dark fermentation: insight into the impact of strain improvement

Confronted with the exhaustion of the earth’s fossil fuel reservoirs, bio-based process to produce renewable energy is receiving significant interest. Hydrogen is considered as an attractive energy carrier that can replace fossil fuels in the future mainly due to its high energy content, recyclability and environment-friendly nature. Biological hydrogen production from renewable biomass or waste materials by dark fermentation is a promising alternative to conventional routes since it is energy-saving and reduces environmental pollution. However, the current yield and evolution rate of fermentative hydrogen production are still low. Strain improvement of the microorganisms employed for hydrogen production is required to make the process competitive with traditional production methods. The present review summarizes recent progresses on the screening for highly efficient hydrogen-producing strains using various strategies. As the metabolic pathways for fermentative hydrogen production have been largely resolved, it is now possible to engineer the hydrogen-producing strains by rational design. The hydrogen yields and production rates by different genetically modified microorganisms are discussed. The key limitations and challenges faced in present studies are also proposed. We hope that this review can provide useful information for scientists in the field of fermentative hydrogen production.

Hydrogen can be generated by microorganisms.

Dark fermentation is efficient for biological hydrogen production.

Strain improvement is critical to enhancing hydrogen-producing ability.

Novel strategies towards efficient molecular biohydrogen production by dark fermentative mechanism: present progress and future perspective

In the scenario of alarming increase in greenhouse and toxic gas emissions from the burning of conventional fuels, it is high time that the population drifts towards alternative fuel usage to obviate pollution. Hydrogen is an environment-friendly biofuel with high energy content. Several production methods exist to produce hydrogen, but the least energy intensive processes are the fermentative biohydrogen techniques. Dark fermentative biohydrogen production (DFBHP) is a value-added, less energy-consuming process to generate biohydrogen. In this process, biohydrogen can be produced from sugars as well as complex substrates that are generally considered as organic waste. Yet, the process is constrained by many factors such as low hydrogen yield, incomplete conversion of substrates, accumulation of volatile fatty acids which lead to the drop of the system pH resulting in hindered growth and hydrogen production by the bacteria. To circumvent these drawbacks, researchers have come up with several strategies that improve the yield of DFBHP process. These strategies can be classified as preliminary methodologies concerned with the process optimization and the latter that deals with pretreatment of substrate and seed sludge, bioaugmentation, co-culture of bacteria, supplementation of additives, bioreactor design considerations, metabolic engineering, nanotechnology, immobilization of bacteria, etc. This review sums up some of the improvement techniques that profoundly enhance the biohydrogen productivity in a DFBHP process.

Electron bifurcation reactions in dark fermentation: An overview for better understanding and improvement

Electron bifurcation (EB) is the most recently found mode of energy conservation, which involves both exergonic and endergonic electron transfer reactions to minimize energy loss. Several works have been devoted on EB reactions (EBRs) in anaerobic digestion but limited in dark fermentative hydrogen production (DF). Two main electron carriers in DF are ferredoxin (Fd) and reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH), complicatedly involved in EB. Here, i) the importance of EB involvement in DF, ii) all EBRs possible to present in DF, as well as iii) the limitation of previous studies that tried incorporating any of EBRs in DF metabolic model, were highlighted. In addition, the concept of using metagenomic analysis for estimating the share of each EB reaction in the metabolic model, was proposed. This review is expected to initiate a new wave for studying EB, as a tool for explaining and predicting DF products.

Knowing the enemy: homoacetogens in hydrogen production reactors

One of the bottlenecks of the hydrogen production by dark fermentation is the low yields obtained because of the homoacetogenesis persistence, a metabolic pathway where H₂ and CO₂ are consumed to produce acetate. The central reactions of H₂ production and homoacetogenesis are catalyzed by enzyme hydrogenase and the formyltetrahydrofolate synthetase, respectively. In this work, genes encoding for the formyltetrahydrofolate synthetase (fthfs) and hydrogenase (hydA) were used to investigate the diversity of homoacetogens as well as their phylogenetic relationships through quantitative PCR (qPCR) and next-generation amplicon sequencing. A total of 70 samples from 19 different H₂-producing bioreactors with different configurations and operating conditions were analyzed. Quantification through qPCR showed that the abundance of fthfs and hydA was strongly associated with the type of substrate, organic loading rate, and H₂ production performance. In particular, fthfs sequencing revealed that homoacetogens diversity was low with one or two dominant homoacetogens in each sample. Clostridium carboxivorans was detected in the reactors fed with agave hydrolisates; Acetobacterium woodii dominated in systems fed with glucose; Blautia coccoides and unclassified Sporoanaerobacter species were present in reactors fed with cheese whey; finally, Eubacterium limosum and Selenomonas sp. were co-dominant in reactors fed with glycerol. Altogether, quantification and sequencing analysis revealed that the occurrence of homoacetogenesis could take place due to (1) metabolic changes of H₂-producing bacteria towards homoacetogenesis or (2) the displacement of H₂-producing bacteria by homoacetogens. Overall, it was demonstrated that the fthfs gene was a suitable marker to investigate homoacetogens in H₂-producing reactors. KEY POINTS: • qPCR and sequencing analysis revealed two homoacetogenesis phenomena. • fthfs gene was a suitable marker to investigate homoacetogens in H2 reactors.

Dynamics of dark fermentation microbial communities in the light of lactate and butyrate production

BACKGROUND

This study focuses on the processes occurring during the acidogenic step of anaerobic digestion, especially resulting from nutritional interactions between dark fermentation (DF) bacteria and lactic acid bacteria (LAB). Previously, we have confirmed that DF microbial communities (MCs) that fed on molasses are able to convert lactate and acetate to butyrate. The aims of the study were to recognize the biodiversity of DF-MCs able and unable to convert lactate and acetate to butyrate and to define the conditions for the transformation.

RESULTS

MCs sampled from a DF bioreactor were grown anaerobically in mesophilic conditions on different media containing molasses or sucrose and/or lactate and acetate in five independent static batch experiments. The taxonomic composition (based on 16S_rRNA profiling) of each experimental MC was analysed in reference to its metabolites and pH of the digestive liquids. In the samples where the fermented media contained carbohydrates, the two main tendencies were observed: (i) a low pH (pH ≤ 4), lactate and ethanol as the main fermentation products, MCs dominated with Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium, Leuconostoc and Fructobacillus was characterized by low biodiversity; (ii) pH in the range 5.0-6.0, butyrate dominated among the fermentation products, the MCs composed mainly of Clostridium (especially Clostridium_sensu_stricto_12), Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium and Prevotella. The biodiversity increased with the ability to convert acetate and lactate to butyrate. The MC processing exclusively lactate and acetate showed the highest biodiversity and was dominated by Clostridium (especially Clostridium_sensu_stricto_12). LAB were reduced; other genera such as Terrisporobacter, Lachnoclostridium, Paraclostridium or Sutterella were found. Butyrate was the main metabolite and pH was 7. Shotgun metagenomic analysis of the selected butyrate-producing MCs independently on the substrate revealed C.tyrobutyricum as the dominant Clostridium species. Functional analysis confirmed the presence of genes encoding key enzymes of the fermentation routes.

CONCLUSIONS

Batch tests revealed the dynamics of metabolic activity and composition of DF-MCs dependent on fermentation conditions. The balance between LAB and the butyrate producers and the pH values were shown to be the most relevant for the process of lactate and acetate conversion to butyrate. To close the knowledge gaps is to find signalling factors responsible for the metabolic shift of the DF-MCs towards lactate fermentation. Video Abstract.

Prokaryotic population dynamics and interactions in an AnSBBR using tequila vinasses as substrate in co-digestion with acid hydrolysates of Agave tequilana var. azul bagasse for hydrogen production

AIMS

The purpose of this study was to characterize the prokaryotic community and putative microbial interactions between H₂ -producing bacteria (HPB) and non-HPB using two anaerobic sequencing batch biofilm reactors (AnSBBRs) fed with tequila vinasses in co-digestion with acid hydrolysates of Agave tequilana var. azul bagasse (ATAB).

METHODS AND RESULTS

Two AnSBBRs were operated for H₂ production to correlate changes in physicochemical and biological variables by principal component analysis (PCA). Results indicated that H₂ yield was supported by Ethanoligenens harbinense and Clostridium tyrobutyricum through the PFOR pathway. However, only E. harbinense was able to compete for sugars against non-HPB. Competitive exclusion associated with competition for sugars, depletion of essential trace elements, bacteriocin production and resistance to inhibitory compounds could be carried out by non-HPB, increasing their relative abundances during the dark fermentation (DF) process.

CONCLUSIONS

The global scenario obtained by PCA correlated the decrease in H₂ production with the lactate:acetate molar ratio in the influent. At the beginning of co-digestion, this ratio had the minimum value considered for a net gain of ATP. This fact could cause the reduction of the relative abundance of C. tyrobutyricum.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

This is the first study that demonstrated the feasibility of H₂ production by Clostridiales from acid hydrolysates of ATAB in co-digestion with tequila vinasses.

Dynamics and Complexity of Dark Fermentation Microbial Communities Producing Hydrogen From Sugar Beet Molasses in Continuously Operating Packed Bed Reactors

This study describes the dynamics and complexity of microbial communities producing hydrogen-rich fermentation gas from sugar-beet molasses in five packed-bed reactors (PBRs). The bioreactors constitute a part of a system producing hydrogen from the by-products of the sugar-beet industry that has been operating continuously in one of the Polish sugar factories. PBRs with different working volumes, packing materials, construction and inocula were tested. This study focused on analysis (based on 16S rRNA profiling and shotgun metagenomics sequencing) of the microbial communities selected in the PBRs under the conditions of high (>100 cm3/g COD of molasses) and low (<50 cm3/g COD of molasses) efficiencies of hydrogen production. The stability and efficiency of the hydrogen production are determined by the composition of dark fermentation microbial communities. The most striking difference between the tested samples is the ratio of hydrogen producers to lactic acid bacteria. The highest efficiency of hydrogen production (130-160 cm3/g COD of molasses) was achieved at the ratios of HPB to LAB ≈ 4:2.5 or 2.5:1 as determined by 16S rRNA sequencing or shotgun metagenomics sequencing, respectively. The most abundant Clostridium species were C. pasteurianum and C. tyrobutyricum. A multiple predominance of LAB over HPB (3:1-4:1) or clostridia over LAB (5:1-60:1) results in decreased hydrogen production. Inhibition of hydrogen production was illustrated by overproduction of short chain fatty acids and ethanol. Furthermore, concentration of ethanol might be a relevant marker or factor promoting a metabolic shift in the DF bioreactors processing carbohydrates from hydrogen-yielding toward lactic acid fermentation or solventogenic pathways. The novelty of this study is identifying a community balance between hydrogen producers and lactic acid bacteria for stable hydrogen producing systems. The balance stems from long-term selection of hydrogen-producing microbial community, operating conditions such as bioreactor construction, packing material, hydraulic retention time and substrate concentration. This finding is confirmed by additional analysis of the proportions between HPB and LAB in dark fermentation bioreactors from other studies. The results contribute to the advance of knowledge in the area of relationships and nutritional interactions especially the cross-feeding of lactate between bacteria in dark fermentation microbial communities.

State-of-the-art technologies for continuous high-rate biohydrogen production

Dark fermentation is a technically feasible technology for achieving carbon dioxide-free hydrogen production. This review presents the current findings on continuous hydrogen production using dark fermentation. Several operational strategies and reactor configurations have been suggested. The formation of attached mixed-culture microorganisms is a typical prerequisite for achieving high production rate, hydrogen yield, and resilience. To date, fixed-bed reactors and dynamic membrane bioreactors yielded higher biohydrogen performance than other configurations. The symbiosis between H₂-producing bacteria and biofilm-forming bacteria was essential to avoid washout and maintain the high loading rates and hydrogenic metabolic flux. Recent research has initiated a more in-depth comparison of microbial community changes during dark fermentation, primarily with computational science techniques based on 16S rRNA gene sequencing investigations. Future techno-economic analysis of dark fermentative biohydrogen production and perspectives on unraveling mitigation mechanisms induced by attached microorganisms in dark fermentation processes are further discussed.

Continuous thermophilic hydrogen production from an enzymatic hydrolysate of agave bagasse: Inoculum origin, homoacetogenesis and microbial community analysis

In this research, the performance of two thermophilic inocula of different origin on continuous hydrogen production from an enzymatic hydrolysate of agave bagasse were compared; one of them was obtained from a thermophilic reactor and the second one was taken from a mesophilic reactor and acclimated to thermophilic conditions. The acclimation process in one-step quickly established a high-performance hydrogen producing community, obtaining a volumetric hydrogen production rate of 3811 ± 19 mL H2/L-d with an hydrogen yield of 121 L H2/kg bagasse compared to 1473 ± 6 mL H2/L-d and 26.6 L H2/kg obtained with the thermophilic-origin inoculum. The differences in the performance of both inocula were closely linked to the profile of volatile fatty acids produced, the homoacetogenic pathway and the microbial community, the latter being the determining factor. The use of mesophilic-origin inoculum acclimated to thermophilic conditions can significantly improve the hydrogen production from lignocellulosic bagasse.

Bioenergy from biofuel residues and waste

This section presents a review of the scientific literature published in 2018 on topics relating to sustainable bioenergy from biofuel residues and waste. This review is divided into the following sections: Feedstocks, Bioethanol, Biodiesel, Biohydrogen, Hydrogen, Biofuel Residues, Microalgae, and Lignocelluloses.

Enhancing biohydrogen production from Agave tequilana bagasse: Detoxified vs. Undetoxified acid hydrolysates

The aim of this work was to compare the biohydrogen production potential of undetoxified and detoxified acid hydrolysates from A. tequilana bagasse. Detoxification was carried out with activated carbon at different concentrations and pH values. Results indicated that pH was not a significant variable, while the lowest evaluated concentration of activated carbon (1% p/v) significantly promoted the highest removal of acetic acid (89%) with minimal losses of fermentable sugars. Regarding dark fermentation experiments, central composite designs were used to optimize COD and pH variables for both substrates, undetoxified and detoxified hydrolysates (activated carbon 1% p/v and pH 0.6). At optimal conditions, the detoxified hydrolysate produced 33% more biohydrogen than the undetoxified one. Hydrogen molar yields were 1.71 and 1.23 mol H₂/mol_sugar, respectively. This improvement was correlated to changes in metabolic byproducts, since the detoxified hydrolysate produced only acetic and butyric acids, while lactic acid was detected in the undetoxified hydrolysate.