Innate immunity to prions: anti-prion systems turn a tsunami of prions into a slow drip

Anti-Prion Systems in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

[PSI+] is a prion (infectious protein) of Sup35p, a subunit of the translation termination factor, and [URE3] is a prion of Ure2p, a mediator of nitrogen catabolite repression. Here, we trace the history of these prions and describe the array of anti-prion systems in S. cerevisiae. These systems work together to block prion infection, prion generation, prion propagation, prion segregation, and the lethal (and near-lethal) effects of most variants of these prions. Each system lowers the appearance of prions 2- to 15-fold, but together, ribosome-associated chaperones, the Hsp104 disaggregase, and the Sup35p-binding Upf proteins lower the frequency of [PSI+] appearance by ~5000-fold. [PSI+] variants can be categorized by their sensitivity to the various anti-prion systems, with the majority of prion isolates sensitive to all three of the above-mentioned systems. Yeast prions have been used to screen for human anti-prion proteins, and five of the Bag protein family members each have such activity. We suggest that manipulation of human anti-prion systems may be useful in preventing or treating some of the many human amyloidoses currently found to be prions with the same amyloid architecture as the yeast prions.

MIL-CELL: a tool for multi-scale simulation of yeast replication and prion transmission

The single-celled baker's yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, can sustain a number of amyloid-based prions, the three most prominent examples being [URE3], [PSI+], and [PIN+]. In the laboratory, haploid S. cerevisiae cells of a single mating type can acquire an amyloid prion in one of two ways (i) spontaneous nucleation of the prion within the yeast cell, and (ii) receipt via mother-to-daughter transmission during the cell division cycle. Similarly, prions can be lost due to (i) dissolution of the prion amyloid by its breakage into non-amyloid monomeric units, or (ii) preferential donation/retention of prions between the mother and daughter during cell division. Here we present a computational tool (Monitoring Induction and Loss of prions in Cells; MIL-CELL) for modelling these four general processes using a multiscale approach describing both spatial and kinetic aspects of the yeast life cycle and the amyloid-prion behavior. We describe the workings of the model, assumptions upon which it is based and some interesting simulation results pertaining to the wave-like spread of the epigenetic prion elements through the yeast population. MIL-CELL is provided as a stand-alone GUI executable program for free download with the paper. MIL-CELL is equipped with a relational database allowing all simulated properties to be searched, collated and graphed. Its ability to incorporate variation in heritable properties means MIL-CELL is also capable of simulating loss of the isogenic nature of a cell population over time. The capability to monitor both chronological and reproductive age also makes MIL-CELL potentially useful in studies of cell aging.

Prions in Microbes: The Least in the Most

Prions are infectious proteins that mostly replicate in self-propagating amyloid conformations (filamentous protein polymers) and consist of structurally altered normal soluble proteins. Prions can arise spontaneously in the cell without any clear reason and are generally considered fatal disease-causing agents that are only present in mammals. However, after the seminal discovery of two prions, [PSI+] and [URE3], in the eukaryotic model microorganism Saccharomyces cerevisiae, at least ten more prions have been discovered, and their biological and pathological effects on the host, molecular structure, and the relationship between prions and cellular components have been studied. In a filamentous fungus model, Podospora anserina, a vegetative incomparability-related [Het-s] prion that directly triggers cell death during anastomosis (hyphal fusion) was discovered. These prions in eukaryotic microbes have extended our understanding to overcome most fatal human prion/amyloid diseases. A prokaryotic microorganism (Clostridium botulinum) was reported to have a prion analog. The transcriptional regulators of C. botulinum-Rho can be converted into the self-replicating prion form ([RHO-X-C+]), which may affect global transcription. Here, we outline the major issues with prions in microbes and the lessons learned from the relatively uncovered microbial prion world.

A structural basis for prion strain diversity

Recent cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) studies of infectious, ex vivo, prion fibrils from hamster 263K and mouse RML prion strains revealed a similar, parallel in-register intermolecular β-sheet (PIRIBS) amyloid architecture. Rungs of the fibrils are composed of individual prion protein (PrP) monomers that fold to create distinct N-terminal and C-terminal lobes. However, disparity in the hamster/mouse PrP sequence precludes understanding of how divergent prion strains emerge from an identical PrP substrate. In this study, we determined the near-atomic resolution cryo-EM structure of infectious, ex vivo mouse prion fibrils from the ME7 prion strain and compared this with the RML fibril structure. This structural comparison of two biologically distinct mouse-adapted prion strains suggests defined folding subdomains of PrP rungs and the way in which they are interrelated, providing a structural definition of intra-species prion strain-specific conformations.

Methionine Sulfoxide Reductases Suppress the Formation of the [PSI+] Prion and Protein Aggregation in Yeast

Prions are self-propagating, misfolded forms of proteins associated with various neurodegenerative diseases in mammals and heritable traits in yeast. How prions form spontaneously into infectious amyloid-like structures without underlying genetic changes is poorly understood. Previous studies have suggested that methionine oxidation may underlie the switch from a soluble protein to the prion form. In this current study, we have examined the role of methionine sulfoxide reductases (MXRs) in protecting against de novo formation of the yeast [PSI⁺] prion, which is the amyloid form of the Sup35 translation termination factor. We show that [PSI⁺] formation is increased during normal and oxidative stress conditions in mutants lacking either one of the yeast MXRs (Mxr1, Mxr2), which protect against methionine oxidation by reducing the two epimers of methionine-S-sulfoxide. We have identified a methionine residue (Met124) in Sup35 that is important for prion formation, confirming that direct Sup35 oxidation causes [PSI⁺] prion formation. [PSI⁺] formation was less pronounced in mutants simultaneously lacking both MXR isoenzymes, and we show that the morphology and biophysical properties of protein aggregates are altered in this mutant. Taken together, our data indicate that methionine oxidation triggers spontaneous [PSI⁺] prion formation, which can be alleviated by methionine sulfoxide reductases.

UPF1-From mRNA Degradation to Human Disorders

Up-frameshift protein 1 (UPF1) plays the role of a vital controller for transcripts, ready to react in the event of an incorrect translation mechanism. It is well known as one of the key elements involved in mRNA decay pathways and participates in transcript and protein quality control in several different aspects. Firstly, UPF1 specifically degrades premature termination codon (PTC)-containing products in a nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD)-coupled manner. Additionally, UPF1 can potentially act as an E3 ligase and degrade target proteins independently from mRNA decay pathways. Thus, UPF1 protects cells against the accumulation of misfolded polypeptides. However, this multitasking protein may still hide many of its functions and abilities. In this article, we summarize important discoveries in the context of UPF1, its involvement in various cellular pathways, as well as its structural importance and mutational changes related to the emergence of various pathologies and disease states. Even though the state of knowledge about this protein has significantly increased over the years, there are still many intriguing aspects that remain unresolved.

Anti-Prion Systems in Saccharomyces cerevisiae Turn an Avalanche of Prions into a Flurry

Prions are infectious proteins, mostly having a self-propagating amyloid (filamentous protein polymer) structure consisting of an abnormal form of a normally soluble protein. These prions arise spontaneously in the cell without known reason, and their effects were generally considered to be fatal based on prion diseases in humans or mammals. However, the wide array of prion studies in yeast including filamentous fungi revealed that their effects can range widely, from lethal to very mild (even cryptic) or functional, depending on the nature of the prion protein and the specific prion variant (or strain) made by the same prion protein but with a different conformation. This prion biology is affected by an array of molecular chaperone systems, such as Hsp40, Hsp70, Hsp104, and combinations of them. In parallel with the systems required for prion propagation, yeast has multiple anti-prion systems, constantly working in the normal cell without overproduction of or a deficiency in any protein, which have negative effects on prions by blocking their formation, curing many prions after they arise, preventing prion infections, and reducing the cytotoxicity produced by prions. From the protectors of nascent polypeptides (Ssb1/2p, Zuo1p, and Ssz1p) to the protein sequesterase (Btn2p), the disaggregator (Hsp104), and the mysterious Cur1p, normal levels of each can cure the prion variants arising in its absence. The controllers of mRNA quality, nonsense-mediated mRNA decay proteins (Upf1, 2, 3), can cure newly formed prion variants by association with a prion-forming protein. The regulator of the inositol pyrophosphate metabolic pathway (Siw14p) cures certain prion variants by lowering the levels of certain organic compounds. Some of these proteins have other cellular functions (e.g., Btn2), while others produce an anti-prion effect through their primary role in the normal cell (e.g., ribosomal chaperones). Thus, these anti-prion actions are the innate defense strategy against prions. Here, we outline the anti-prion systems in yeast that produce innate immunity to prions by a multi-layered operation targeting each step of prion development.

J Proteins Counteract Amyloid Propagation and Toxicity in Yeast

Simple Summary

Dozens of diseases are associated with misfolded proteins that accumulate in highly ordered fibrous aggregates called amyloids. Protein quality control (PQC) factors keep cells healthy by helping maintain the integrity of the cell’s proteins and physiological processes. Yeast has been used widely for years to study how amyloids cause toxicity to cells and how PQC factors help protect cells from amyloid toxicity. The so-called J-domain proteins (JDPs) are PQC factors that are particularly effective at providing such protection. We discuss how PQC factors protect animals, human cells, and yeast from amyloid toxicity, focusing on yeast and human JDPs.

Abstract

The accumulation of misfolded proteins as amyloids is associated with pathology in dozens of debilitating human disorders, including diabetes, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, and Huntington’s diseases. Expressing human amyloid-forming proteins in yeast is toxic, and yeast prions that propagate as infectious amyloid forms of cellular proteins are also harmful. The yeast system, which has been useful for studying amyloids and their toxic effects, has provided much insight into how amyloids affect cells and how cells respond to them. Given that an amyloid is a protein folding problem, it is unsurprising that the factors found to counteract the propagation or toxicity of amyloids in yeast involve protein quality control. Here, we discuss such factors with an emphasis on J-domain proteins (JDPs), which are the most highly abundant and diverse regulators of Hsp70 chaperones. The anti-amyloid effects of JDPs can be direct or require interaction with Hsp70.

Anti-Prion Systems Block Prion Transmission, Attenuate Prion Generation, Cure Most Prions as They Arise and Limit Prion-Induced Pathology in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Simple Summary

Virus and bacterial infections are opposed by their hosts at many levels. Similarly, we find that infectious proteins (prions) are severely restricted by an array of host systems, acting independently to prevent infection, generation, propagation and the ill effects of yeast prions. These ‘anti-prion systems’ work in normal cells without the overproduction or deficiency of any components. DNA repair systems reverse the effects of DNA damage, with only a rare lesion propagated as a mutation. Similarly, the combined effects of several anti-prion systems cure and block the generation of all but 1 in about 5000 prions arising. We expect that application of our approach to mammalian cells will detect analogous or even homologous systems that will be useful in devising therapy for human amyloidoses, most of which are prions.

Abstract

All variants of the yeast prions [PSI+] and [URE3] are detrimental to their hosts, as shown by the dramatic slowing of growth (or even lethality) of a majority, by the rare occurrence in wild isolates of even the mildest variants and by the absence of reproducible benefits of these prions. To deal with the prion problem, the host has evolved an array of anti-prion systems, acting in normal cells (without overproduction or deficiency of any component) to block prion transmission from other cells, to lower the rates of spontaneous prion generation, to cure most prions as they arise and to limit the damage caused by those variants that manage to elude these (necessarily) imperfect defenses. Here we review the properties of prion protein sequence polymorphisms Btn2, Cur1, Hsp104, Upf1,2,3, ribosome-associated chaperones, inositol polyphosphates, Sis1 and Lug1, which are responsible for these anti-prion effects. We recently showed that the combined action of ribosome-associated chaperones, nonsense-mediated decay factors and the Hsp104 disaggregase lower the frequency of [PSI+] appearance as much as 5000-fold. Moreover, while Btn2 and Cur1 are anti-prion factors against [URE3] and an unrelated artificial prion, they promote [PSI+] prion generation and propagation.

Antiprion systems in yeast cooperate to cure or prevent the generation of nearly all [PSI+] and [URE3] prions

[PSI⁺] and [URE3] are prions of Saccharomyces cerevisiae based on amyloids of Sup35p and Ure2p, respectively. In normal cells, antiprion systems block prion formation, cure many prions that arise, prevent infection by prions, and prevent toxicity of those prions that escape the other systems. The upf1Δ, ssz1Δ, and hsp104^T160M single mutants each develop [PSI⁺] at 10- to 15-fold, but the triple mutant spontaneously generates [PSI⁺] at up to ∼5,000-fold the wild-type rate. Most such [PSI⁺] variants are cured by restoration of any one of the three defective antiprion systems, defining a previously unknown type of [PSI⁺] variant and proving that these three antiprion systems act independently. Generation of [PSI⁺] variants stable in wild-type cells is also increased in upf1Δ ssz1Δ hsp104^T160M strains 25- to 500-fold. Btn2 and Cur1 each cure 90% of [URE3] prions generated in their absence, but we find that btn2Δ or cur1Δ diminishes the frequency of [PSI⁺] generation in an otherwise wild-type strain. Most [PSI⁺] isolates in a wild-type strain are destabilized on transfer to a btn2Δ or cur1Δ host. Single upf1Δ or hsp104^T160M mutants show the effects of btn2Δ or cur1Δ but not upf1Δ ssz1Δ hsp104^T160M or ssz1Δ hsp104^T160M strains. The disparate action of Btn2 on [URE3] and [PSI⁺] may be a result of [PSI⁺]'s generally higher seed number and lower amyloid structural stability compared with [URE3]. Thus, prion generation is not a rare event, but the escape of a nascent prion from the surveillance by the antiprion systems is indeed rare.

Structural Bases of Prion Variation in Yeast

Amyloids are protein aggregates with a specific filamentous structure that are related to a number of human diseases, and also to some important physiological processes in animals and other kingdoms of life. Amyloids in yeast can stably propagate as heritable units, prions. Yeast prions are of interest both on their own and as a model for amyloids and prions in general. In this review, we consider the structure of yeast prions and its variation, how such structures determine the balance of aggregated and soluble prion protein through interaction with chaperones and how the aggregated state affects the non-prion functions of these proteins.

Differential Interactions of Molecular Chaperones and Yeast Prions

Baker’s yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae is an important model organism that is applied to study various aspects of eukaryotic cell biology. Prions in yeast are self-perpetuating heritable protein aggregates that can be leveraged to study the interaction between the protein quality control (PQC) machinery and misfolded proteins. More than ten prions have been identified in yeast, of which the most studied ones include [PSI+], [URE3], and [PIN+]. While all of the major molecular chaperones have been implicated in propagation of yeast prions, many of these chaperones differentially impact propagation of different prions and/or prion variants. In this review, we summarize the current understanding of the life cycle of yeast prions and systematically review the effects of different chaperone proteins on their propagation. Our analysis clearly shows that Hsp40 proteins play a central role in prion propagation by determining the fate of prion seeds and other amyloids. Moreover, direct prion-chaperone interaction seems to be critically important for proper recruitment of all PQC components to the aggregate. Recent results also suggest that the cell asymmetry apparatus, cytoskeleton, and cell signaling all contribute to the complex network of prion interaction with the yeast cell.