Anatomical hemispherectomy for intractable seizures: excellent seizure control, low morbidity and no superficial cerebral haemosiderosis

Hemispherotomy Revised: A complication overview and a systematic review meta-analysis

Introduction

Hemispherectomy/hemispherotomy has been employed in the management of catastrophic epilepsy. However, initial reports on the associated mortality and morbidity raised several concerns regarding the technique's safety. Their actual, current incidence needs to be systematically examined to redefine hemispherotomy's exact role.

Research question

Our current study examined their incidence and evaluated the association of the various hemispherotomy surgical techniques with the reported complications.

Material & methods

A PRISMA-compliant systematic review and meta-analysis was performed. We searched PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science until December 2022. Fixed- and random-effects models were employed. Egger's regression test was used for estimating the publication bias, while subgroup analysis was utilized for defining the role of the different hemispherotomy techniques.

Results

We retrieved a total of 37 studies. The overall procedure mortality was 5%, with a reported mortality of 7% for hemispherectomy and 3% for hemispherotomy. The reported mortality has decreased over the last 30 years from 32% to 2%. Among the observed post-operative complications aseptic meningitis and/or fever occurred in 33%. Hydrocephalus requiring a shunt insertion occurred in 16%. Hematoma evacuation was necessary in 8%, while subgaleal effusion in another 8%. Infections occurred in 11%. A novel post-operative cranial nerve deficit occurred in 11%, while blood transfusion was necessary in 28% of the cases.

Discussion and conclusion

Our current analysis demonstrated that the evolution from hemispherectomy to hemispherotomy along with neuroanesthesia advances, had a tremendous impact on the associated mortality and morbidity. Hemispherotomy constitutes a safe surgical procedure in the management of catastrophic epilepsies.

Modified hemispherectomy for infantile hemiparesis and epilepsy

Objective

To investigate the effect and medical imaging of modified hemispherectomy on patients with infantile hemiparesis and medically refractory epilepsy.

Patients and methods

Forty-three patients with infantile hemiparesis and refractory epilepsy who underwent hemispherectomy were enrolled. The treatment effect and medical imaging were analyzed.

Results

Anatomical hemispherectomy was successfully performed in all patients (100%). In all patients, the muscular tension decreased and the contracted limbs relaxed. In the pathological examination of the resected brain tissue, secondary cicatricial gyri with concomitant cortical dysplasia was present in 36 cases and polycerebellar gyrus malformation and porencephalia in the other 7 cases. Followed up for 7-15 years (mean 11.3), all patients were alive without a long-term sequela. Epilepsy was satisfactorily controlled, with complete seizure relief in 39 cases (91%) classified as Engel I and basic control in the other 4 (9%) defined as Engel II. The posthemispherectomy medical imaging demonstrated that the intracranial space on the operative side shrank, and the healthy cerebral hemisphere shifted markedly toward the hemispherectomy side, with expanded lateral ventricle on the healthy side and thickened skull and enlarged frontal sinus on the operative side. After 4-5 years, the intracranial space on the operative side disappeared in 75% of the patients, demonstrating enlarged cerebral peduncle on the healthy side.

Conclusion

Further modified hemispherectomy in patients with infantile hemiparesis and medically refractory epilepsy demonstrated markedly ameliorated effects on epilepsy control and the prevention of superficial cerebral hemosiderosis in the long-term follow-up.

Hemispherotomy for Epilepsy: The Procedure Evolution and Outcome

Hemispherectomy is a unique epilepsy surgery procedure that has undergone significant modification and evolution since Dandy's early description. This procedure is mainly indicated to treat early childhood and infancy medically intractable epilepsy. Various epileptic syndromes have been treated with this procedure, including hemimegalencephaly (HME), Rasmussen's encephalitis, Sturge-Weber syndrome (SWS), perinatal stroke, and hemispheric cortical dysplasia. In terms of seizure reduction, hemispherectomy remains one of the most successful epilepsy surgery procedures. The modification of this procedure over many years has resulted in lower mortality and morbidity rates. HME might increase morbidity and lower the success rate. Future studies should identify the predictors of outcomes based on the pathology and the type of hemispherectomy. Here, based on a literature review, we discuss the evolution of hemispherectomy techniques and their outcomes and complications.

Anatomical hemispherectomy revisited-outcome, blood loss, hydrocephalus, and absence of chronic hemosiderosis

PURPOSE

To evaluate microsurgical trans-sylvian trans-ventricular anatomical hemispherectomy with regard to seizure outcome, risk of hydrocephalus, blood loss, and risk of chronic hemosiderosis in patients with intractable seizures selected for surgery using current preoperative assessment techniques.

METHODS

Out of 86 patients who underwent hemispherectomy between February 2000 and April 2019, by a single surgeon, at a tertiary care referral center, 77 patients (ages 0.2-20 years; 40 females) who had an anatomical hemispherectomy were analyzed. Five of these were 'palliative' surgeries. One-stage anatomical hemispherectomy was performed in 55 children, two-stage anatomical hemispherectomy after extraoperative intracranial monitoring in 16, and six hemispherectomies were done following failed previous resection. Mean follow-up duration was 5.7 years (range 1-16.84 years). Forty-six patients had postoperative MRI scans.

RESULTS

Ninety percent of children with non-palliative hemispherectomy achieved ILAE Class-1 outcome. Twenty-seven patients were no longer taking anticonvulsant medications. Surgical failures (n = 4) included one patient with previous meningoencephalitis, one with anti-GAD antibody encephalitis, one with idiopathic neonatal thalamic hemorrhage, and one with extensive tuberous sclerosis. There were no failures among patients with malformations of cortical development. Estimated average blood loss during surgery was 387 ml. Ten (21%) children developed hydrocephalus and required a shunt following one-stage hemispherectomy, whereas 10 (50%) patients developed hydrocephalus among those who had extraoperative intracranial monitoring. Only 20% of the shunts malfunctioned in the first year. Early malfunctions were related to the valve and later to fracture disconnection of the shunt. One patent had a traumatic subdural hematoma. None of the patients developed clinical signs of chronic 'superficial cerebral hemosiderosis' nor was there evidence of radiologically persistent chronic hemosiderosis in patients who had postoperative MRI imaging.

CONCLUSION

Surgical results of anatomical hemispherectomy are excellent in carefully selected cases. Post-operative complications of hydrocephalus and intraoperative blood loss are comparable to those reported for hemispheric disconnective surgery (hemispherotomy). The rate of shunt malfunction was less than that reported for patients with hydrocephalus of other etiologies Absence of chronic 'superficial hemosiderosis', even on long-term follow-up, suggests that anatomical hemispherectomy should be revisited as a viable option in patients with intractable seizures and altered anatomy such as in malformations of cortical development, a group that has a reported high rate of seizure recurrence related to incomplete disconnection following hemispheric disconnective surgery.

Rasmussen's encephalitis presenting as focal cortical dysplasia

Rasmussen's encephalitis is a rare syndrome characterized by intractable seizures, often associated with epilepsia partialis continua and symptoms of progressive hemispheric dysfunction. Seizures are usually the hallmark of presentation, but antiepileptic drug treatment fails in most patients and is ineffective against epilepsia partialis continua, which often requires surgical intervention. Co-occurrence of focal cortical dysplasia has only rarely been described and may have implications regarding pathophysiology and management. We describe a rare case of dual pathology of Rasmussen's encephalitis presenting as a focal cortical dysplasia (FCD) and discuss the literature on this topic.

Rates and predictors of seizure freedom in resective epilepsy surgery: an update

Epilepsy is a debilitating neurological disorder affecting approximately 1 % of the world's population. Drug-resistant focal epilepsies are potentially surgically remediable. Although epilepsy surgery is dramatically underutilized among medically refractory patients, there is an expanding collection of evidence supporting its efficacy which may soon compel a paradigm shift. Of note is that a recent randomized controlled trial demonstrated that early resection leads to considerably better seizure outcomes than continued medical therapy in patients with pharmacoresistant temporal lobe epilepsy. In the present review, we provide a timely update of seizure freedom rates and predictors in resective epilepsy surgery, organized by the distinct pathological entities most commonly observed. Class I evidence, meta-analyses, and individual observational case series are considered, including the experiences of both our institution and others. Overall, resective epilepsy surgery leads to seizure freedom in approximately two thirds of patients with intractable temporal lobe epilepsy and about one half of individuals with focal neocortical epilepsy, although only the former observation is supported by class I evidence. Two common modifiable predictors of postoperative seizure freedom are early operative intervention and, in the case of a discrete lesion, gross total resection. Evidence-based practice guidelines recommend that epilepsy patients who continue to have seizures after trialing two or more medication regimens should be referred to a comprehensive epilepsy center for multidisciplinary evaluation, including surgical consideration.

The periinsular functional hemispherotomy

The surgical treatment of refractory epilepsy has evolved as new innovations have been created. Disconnective procedures such as hemispherectomy have evolved. Presently, hemispherotomy has replaced hemispherectomy to reduce complication rates while maintaining good seizure control. Several disconnective techniques have been described including the Rasmussen, vertical, and lateral approaches. The lateral approach, or periinsular hemispherectomy, was derived from modifications on the functional hemispherectomy and involves removal of the temporal lobe mesial structures, exposure of the atrium via the circular sulcus, internal capsule transection under the central sulcus, intraventricular callosotomy, and frontobasal disconnection. The purpose of this article is to describe and illustrate in detail the anatomy and operative technique for periinsular hemispherotomy, as well as to discuss the nuances and issues involved with this procedure.

Suicide in people with epilepsy: how great is the risk?

PURPOSE

Suicide is more common in populations with epilepsy, but estimates vary concerning the magnitude of the risk. We aimed to estimate the risk using meta-analysis.

METHODS

A literature search identified 74 articles (76 cohorts of people with epilepsy) in whom the number of deaths by suicide in people with epilepsy and the number of person-years at risk could be estimated. Standardized mortality ratios (SMRs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were calculated for each cohort, for groups of cohorts, and for the total population.

RESULTS

The overall SMR was 3.3 (95% CI 2.8-3.7) based on 190 observed deaths by suicide compared with 58.4 expected. The SMR was significantly increased in people with incident or newly diagnosed epilepsy in the community (SMR 2.1), in populations with mixed prevalence and incidence cases (SMR 3.6), in those with prevalent epilepsy (SMR 4.8), in people in institutions (SMR 4.6), in people seen in tertiary care clinics (SMR 2.28), in people with temporal lobe epilepsy (SMR 6.6), in those following temporal lobe excision (SMR 13.9), and following other forms of epilepsy surgery (SMR 6.4). The SMR was significantly low overall in two community-based studies of people with epilepsy and developmental disability.

DISCUSSION

We confirm that the risk of suicide is increased in most populations of people with epilepsy. Psychiatric comorbidity has been demonstrated to be a risk factor for suicide in the general population and in people with epilepsy, and such comorbidity should thus be identified and treated.

The surgery of epilepsy

The idea of surgical treatment for epilepsy is not new. However, widespread use and general acceptance of this treatment has only been achieved during the past three decades. A crucial step in this direction was the development of video electroencephalographic monitoring. Improvements in imaging resulted in an increased ability for preoperative identification of intracerebral and potentially epileptogenic lesions. High resolution magnetic resonance imaging plays a major role in structural and functional imaging; other functional imaging techniques (e.g., positron emission tomography and single-photon emission computed tomography) provide complementary data and, together with corresponding electroencephalographic findings, result in a hypothesis of the epileptogenic lesion, epileptogenic zone, and the functional deficit zone. The development of microneurosurgical techniques was a prerequisite for the general acceptance of elective intracranial surgery. New less invasive and safer resection techniques have been developed, and new palliative and augmentative techniques have been introduced. Today, epilepsy surgery is more effective and conveys a better seizure control rate. It has become safer and less invasive, with lower morbidity and mortality rates. This article summarizes the various developments of the past three decades and describes the present tools for presurgical evaluation and surgical strategy, as well as ideas and future perspectives for epilepsy surgery.

Ictal SPECT in Sturge-Weber syndrome

We report on a patient with right-sided Sturge-Weber syndrome (SWS), in whom earlier functional hemispherectomy failed. Subtraction of ictal and interictal single-photon-emission-computed-tomography (SPECT) superimposed on individual MRI showed a right fronto-orbital hyperperfusion, with a left-sided EEG seizure pattern. Ictal SPECT supported our assumption that right frontal originated seizure pattern propagated to left hemisphere via the remaining right frontal bridge. Right orbito-frontal resection and disconnection from corpus callosum resulted in seizure freedom.

Early hemispherectomy in catastrophic epilepsy

The authors report their experience about a neuro-cognitive and epileptic long-term follow-up of children with catastrophic epilepsy treated with hemispherectomy in the first 5 years of life. Nineteen children with resistant epilepsy that significantly interfered with their neuro-cognitive development underwent hemispherectomy within 5 years of life (mean: 2 years, 3 months; range: 5 months to 5 years). All patients were assessed before surgery and after, at least at the end of the follow-up (mean: 6 years and 6 months; range: 2-11 years and 2 months) with a full clinical examination including motor ability and functional status evaluation as well as behaviour observation, neuroimaging and an ictal/interictal prolonged scalp video-EEG. A seizure-free outcome was obtained in 73.7% of patients. Gross motility generally improved and cognitive competence did not worsen, with an evident progress in two cases. Consistently with previous reports, evolution was worse in cortical dysplasia than in progressive or acquired vascular cerebropathies. The excellent epileptic outcome and the lack of developmental deterioration in comparison with other more aged series seem to suggest a possible better evolution in earlier surgery treatment. To confirm this suggestion, however, further experience with larger series is needed.

Hemispherectomy for intractable epilepsy in adults: The first reported series

Hemispherectomy for intractable unihemispheric epilepsy (IUE) has long been established in pediatric patients. This study reports the first series examining hemispherectomy exclusively in adult patients (>18 years old). Nine adults with IUE underwent hemispherectomy at the University of Minnesota. All patients had unilateral hemiplegia and visual field loss. Seven patients (77.8%) were Engel class I/II at last follow-up. Five (83.3%) of the six patients with >30 years of follow-up were seizure free. No surgery-related mortality, hydrocephalus, or superficial cerebral hemosiderosis occurred. Hemispherectomy is an effective procedure in appropriately selected adult patients, resulting in excellent long-term seizure control and no mortality.

Supercalifragilistic hemosiderosis: a rare and unusual complication that really sounds atrocious

Anatomical Hemispherectomy for Intractable Seizures: Excellent Seizure Control, Low Morbidity and No Superficial Cerebral Haemosiderosis

O'Brien DF, Basu S, Williams DH, May PL

Childs Nerv Syst 2006;22:489–498.

Objective

This current study was performed to evaluate whether superficial cerebral hemosiderosis (SCH) is still a complication of modern day anatomical hemispherectomy.

Methods

We report a 13-year institutional experience with anatomical hemispherectomy for intractable epilepsy. Seizure control at a mean follow-up interval of 7 years was 83%. Though one patient died post-operatively from a nonneurosurgical complication, mortality was otherwise zero and morbidity minimal. The much-described complication of SCH following anatomical hemispherectomy was nonexistent. We explain the history of SCH as a complication of anatomical hemispherectomy, and the measures that are presently taken to prevent it.

Conclusions

We suggest that the importance of SCH in modern epilepsy surgery is probably over-emphasized.