Limits of the surgically induced model of myelomeningocele in the fetal sheep

Evolution and Variations of the Ovine Model of Spina Bifida

Spina bifida is the most common congenital anomaly of the central nervous system and the first non-fatal fetal lesions to be addressed by fetal intervention. While research in spina bifida has been performed in rodent, nonhuman primate, and canine models, sheep have been a model organism for the disease. This review summarizes the history of development of the ovine model of spina bifida, previous applications, and translation into clinical studies. Initially used by Meuli et al. [Nat Med. 1995;1(4):342-7], fetal myelomeningocele defect creation and in utero repair demonstrated motor function preservation. The addition of myelotomy in this model can reproduce hindbrain herniation malformations, which is the leading cause of mortality and morbidity in humans. Since inception, the ovine models have been validated numerous times as the ideal large animal model for fetal repair, with both locomotive scoring and spina bifida defect scoring adding to the rigor of this model. The ovine model has been used to study different methods of myelomeningocele defect repair, the application of various tissue engineering techniques for neuroprotection and bowel and bladder function. The results of these large animal studies have been translated into human clinical trials including Management of Meningocele Study (MOMS) trial that established current standard of care for prenatal repair of spina bifida defects, and the ongoing trials including the Cellular Therapy for In Utero Repair of Myelomeningocele (CuRe) trial using a stem cell patch for repair. The advancement of these life savings and life-altering therapies began in sheep models, and this notable model continues to be used to further the field including current work with stem cell therapy.

Ultrasonography and elastography of the brain and cerebellum of English Bulldog fetuses

The aim of this study was to evaluate B-mode ultrasonography and ARFI elastography of the central nervous system of canine fetuses as complementary methods to predict gestational age, monitor fetal development and establish standards. Ultrasound examinations were performed on 26 English Bulldog bitches at 34, 49 and 60 days of gestation. The circumference (C), area (A) and diameters of the short (D1) and long (D2) axis of the two cerebral hemispheres of the fetuses in cross-section were measured. Fetal cerebellum shape, echotexture, echogenicity, and transverse diameter (TCD) were evaluated in cross-section. Elastography was performed obtaining color elastograms and mean shear wave velocity (SWV m/s) of the fetal brain and cerebellar tissues. Ultrasound variables were correlated with gestational day (GD). Brain masses had a circular to oval shape, hyperechoic echogenicity, and homogeneous echotexture. C and D1 were the more accurate variables to predict gestational day, with the formulas: GD = 19.38 + 2,06∗C (R² = 81%) and GD = 18.93 + 7.45∗D1 (R² = 82%). Cerebellum had a "banana" shape, with hyperechogenic edges, hypoechoic echogenicity, and homogeneous echotexture. The TCD (P = 0.0001) and cerebellar stiffness (P = 0.0006) were greater at 60 days than at 49 days of gestation. The brain mass SWV was correlated positively with GD (P = 0.0001) and showed a gradual increase (P = 0.0001) in the three gestational timepoints evaluated. According to qualitative elastography, both brain mass and cerebellum became more rigid over the course of gestational days. It was possible to verify the development of the brain and cerebellum of canine fetuses during pregnancy by ultrasonographic characteristics and B-mode dimensions, as well as by evaluating the elasticity of these tissues through elastography. These unpublished findings allow a better follow-up of the central nervous system development in the prenatal period and may help in future studies with canine fetuses that present cerebral and cerebellar abnormalities.

Associations between fetal heart rate variability and umbilical cord occlusions-induced neural injury: An experimental study in a fetal sheep model

INTRODUCTION

This study evaluated the association between fetal heart rate variability (HRV) and the occurrence of hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy in a fetal sheep model.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The experimental protocol created a hypoxic condition with repeated cord occlusions in three phases (A, B, C) to achieve acidosis to pH <7.00. Hemodynamic, gasometric and HRV parameters were analyzed during the protocol, and the fetal brain, brainstem and spinal cord were assessed histopathologically 48 h later. Associations between the various parameters and neural injury were compared between phases A, B and C using Spearman's rho test.

RESULTS

Acute anoxic-ischemic brain lesions in all regions was present in 7/9 fetuses, and specific neural injury was observed in 3/9 fetuses. The number of brainstem lesions correlated significantly and inversely with the HRV fetal stress index (r = -0.784; p = 0.021) in phase C and with HRV long-term variability (r = -0.677; p = 0.045) and short-term variability (r = -0.837; p = 0.005) in phase B. The number of neurological lesions did not correlate significantly with other markers of HRV.

CONCLUSIONS

Neural injury caused by severe hypoxia was associated with HRV changes; in particular, brainstem damage was associated with changes in fetal-specific HRV markers.

State of the art in translating experimental myelomeningocele research to the bedside

Myelomeningocele (MMC), the commonest type of spina bifida (SB), occurs due to abnormal development of the neural tube and manifest as failure of the complete fusion of posterior arches of the spinal column, leading to dysplastic growth of the spinal cord and meninges. It is associated with several degrees of motor and sensory deficits below the level of the lesion, as well as skeletal deformities, bladder and bowel incontinence, and sexual dysfunction. These children might develop varying degrees of neuropsychomotor delay, partly due to the severity of the injuries that affect the nervous system before birth, partly due to the related cerebral malformations (notably hydrocephalus-which may also lead to an increase in intracranial pressure-and Chiari II deformity). Traditionally, MMC was repaired surgically just after birth; however, intrauterine correction of MMC has been shown to have several potential benefits, including better sensorimotor outcomes (since exposure to amniotic fluid and its consequent deleterious effects is shortened) and reduced rates of hydrocephalus, among others. Fetal surgery for myelomeningocele, nevertheless, would not have been made possible without the development of experimental models of this pathological condition. Hence, the aim of the current article is to provide an overview of the animal models of MMC that were used over the years and describe how this knowledge has been translated into the fetal treatment of MMC in humans.

Prenatal Neural Tube Anomalies: A Decade of Intrauterine Stem Cell Transplantation Using Advanced Tissue Engineering Methods

Neural tube defects (NTDs) are among the most common congenital defects during neurulation. Spina bifida is a type of NTD that can occur in different forms. Since myelomeningocele (MMC) is the most severe form of spina bifida, finding a satisfactory treatment for MMC is a gold standard for the treatment of spina bifida. The Management of Myelomeningocele Study (MOMS) demonstrated that intrauterine treatment of spina bifida could ameliorate the complications associated with spina bifida and would also reduce the placement of ventriculoperitoneal (VP) shunt by 50%. Recently developed tissue engineering (TE) approaches using scaffolds, stem cells, and growth factors allow treatment of the fetus with minimally invasive methods and promising outcomes. The application of novel patches with appropriate stem cells and growth factors leads to better coverage of the defect with fewer complications. These approaches with less invasive surgical procedures, even in animal models with similar characteristics as the human MMC defect, paves the way for the modern application of less invasive surgical methods. Significantly, the early detection of these problems and applying these approaches can increase the potential efficacy of MMC treatment with fewer complications. However, further studies should be conducted to find the most suitable scaffolds and stem cells, and their application should be evaluated in animal models. This review intends to discuss advanced TE methods for treating MMC and recent successes in increasing the efficacy of the treatment.

Heritable spina bifida in sheep: A potential model for fetal repair of myelomeningocele

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

In 2004, a heritable occurrence of spina bifida was reported in sheep on a farm in the United States. We maintained and characterized the spina bifida phenotype in this flock to assess its potential as an alternative surgical model.

METHODS

A breeding strategy was developed in which the sheep were crossed to maintain or increase the occurrence of spina bifida. Measurements and observations were recorded regarding lesion size, birthweight, ambulatory capacity, or urological function, and necropsies were performed on spina bifida afflicted lambs in conjunction with magnetic resonance imaging to determine the character of the spina bifida defects and assess the presence of Chiari-like malformations or hydrocephalus.

RESULTS

The defects were observed to be more prevalent in ram lambs, and the rate of spina bifida per litter could be increased through backcrossing or by selection of a productive ewe breed. The lambs displayed a range of ambulatory and urological deficits which could be used to evaluate new fetal repair methodologies. Finally, affected lambs were shown to demonstrate severe Chiari malformations and hydrocephalus.

CONCLUSIONS

We have determined that use of these sheep as a natural source for spina bifida fetuses is feasible and could supplement the deficits of current sheep models for myelomeningocele repair.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

Exploring fetal response to acidosis in ewes: Choosing an adequate experimental model

INTRODUCTION

Knowledge of fetal physiology during labor has been largely generated from animal models. Our team recently developed a new index to assess parasympathetic activity using different experimental protocols to obtain acidosis. The objective of the present study was to discuss the different protocols and to review other models proposed in the literature.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Pregnant ewes underwent a surgical procedure at the 123±2 days gestational age (term=145 days). Three experimental protocols were used: protocol A consisted of 25%, 50% and 75% umbilical cord occlusion (UCO) for 20min. Protocol B consisted of partial 75% UCO until reaching a pH<7.10. Protocol C consisted of brief, repetitive complete occlusion until severe acidosis occurred. Hemodynamic and blood gas parameters were compared to those of the stability period before UCO.

RESULTS

Protocol A led to a progressive response depending on the degree of occlusion (decrease in fetal heart rate, arterial hypertension and pH). Protocol B led to severe acidosis, although the duration of UCO varied per animal. Protocol C also progressively led to acidosis. We observed high inter individual variability in the acidosis response.

CONCLUSION

Pregnant ewes are a relevant model for exploring fetal response to acidosis. The frequency of UCO and partial or complete occlusion should be adapted to the expected effects. Knowledge of these protocols is important to respect ethical guidelines and to reduce the required number of animals. Moreover, it is important to consider the high individual variability of the acidosis response in the interpretation of the results.

Safety and efficacy of fetal surgery techniques to close a spina bifida defect in the fetal lamb model: A systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To determine the safety and efficacy of different neurosurgical techniques for closure of spina bifida (SB) in the fetal lamb model.

METHOD

Systematic review of studies reporting on fetal lambs undergoing induction and closure of SB compared with non-operated normal lambs (negative controls) and/or lambs not undergoing closure of the defect (positive controls). Primary outcomes were (1) survival at birth (safety) and/or (2) presence of Somatosensory Evoked Potentials on hind limbs and/or improvement in quantitative histological spinal cord findings and/or reversal of hindbrain herniation (efficacy).

RESULTS

Out of 1311, 36 full-text articles were eligible. Nineteen were included for quality assessment. Due to high bias, only 2 adequately powered studies were included in the final analysis. An open approach using a 2-layer closure (muscle flap or acellular-dermal-matrix patch plus skin) was the only safe (patch + skin) and effective (both techniques) technique for prenatal closure in this animal model. No comparable level of evidence was identified for other techniques.

CONCLUSION

The experimental literature on prenatal SB closure underscores the lack of standardization. At present, there is animal experimental evidence that a 2-layer closure by hysterotomy is safe and effective. This technique is currently clinically used in a subset of patients. As new clinical techniques are introduced, it would seem logic to preclinically validate them against this experimental standard.

Two-Port Fetoscopic Repair of Myelomeningocele in Fetal Lambs

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility and the effectiveness of a fetoscopic myelomeningocele (MMC) repair with a running single suture using a 2-port access in the sheep model.

METHODS

Eighteen fetuses underwent surgical creation of a MMC defect at day 75. Fetuses were then randomized into 3 groups. Four fetuses remained untreated (control group). In the other 14 fetuses, a prenatal repair was performed at day 90: 7 fetuses had an open repair (oMMC), and 7 fetuses had a fetoscopic repair (fMMC) using a single-layer running suture through a 2-port access. Lambs were sacrificed at term, and histological examinations were performed.

RESULTS

Hindbrain herniation was observed in all live lambs in the control group. A complete closure of the defect was achieved in all the lambs of the fMMC group. A complete healing of the defect and no hindbrain herniation were observed in all live lambs of the oMMC and fMMC groups. The durations of surgeries were not statistically different between the oMMC and the fMMC groups (60 vs. 53 min, p = 0.40), as was the risk of fetal loss (fMMC: 1/7, oMMC: 3/7, p = 0.56).

DISCUSSION

Fetoscopic repair of MMC can be performed using a single-layer running suture through a 2-port access and may be promising to reduce the risk of premature rupture of membranes.

Fetoscopic patch coverage of experimental myelomenigocele using a two-port access in fetal sheep

PURPOSE

This study aims to assess the feasibility and the effectiveness of a fetoscopic myelomeningocele (MMC) coverage using a sealed inert patch through a two-port access, in the sheep model.

METHODS

Forty-four fetuses underwent surgical creation of a MMC defect at day 75 and were divided into four groups according to the MMC repair technique, performed at day 90. Group 1 remained untreated. Group 2 had an open surgery using suture of the defect. Groups 3 and 4 underwent defect coverage using a Gore®-polytetrafluoroethylene patch secured with surgical adhesive (Bioglue®), with an open approach (group 3) and a fetoscopic one (group 4). Lambs were killed at term, and histological examinations were performed.

RESULTS

Fetoscopic patch coverage was achieved in all the lambs of group 4. All the fetuses of group 2 had a complete closure of the defect whereas only 38% in group 3 and 14% in group 4. Fetal loss rate seems to be lower in group 4 than in groups 2 and 3.

CONCLUSION

Fetoscopic coverage of MMC defect can be performed using a sealed patch through a two-port access, but the patch and glue correction may not be the ideal technique to repair fetal MMC.