Intramedullary nail versus extramedullary plate fixation for unstable intertrochanteric fractures: decision analysis

Long vs short intramedullary nails for reverse pertrochanteric fractures: A biomechanical study

There is currently no definitive evidence for the implant of choice for the treatment of reverse pertrochanteric fractures. Here, we aimed to compare the stability provided by two implant options: long and short intramedullary nails. We performed finite element simulations of different patterns of reverse pertrochanteric fractures with varying bone quality, and compared the short vs long nail stabilization under physiological loads. For each variable combination, the micromotions at the fracture site, bone strain, and implant stress were computed. Mean micromotions at the fracture surface and absolute and relative fracture surface with micromotions >150 µm were slightly lower with the short nail (8%, 3%, and 3%, respectively). The distal fracture extension negatively affected the stability, with increasing micromotions on the medial side. Bone strain above 1 % was not affected by the nail length. Fatigue stresses were similar for both implants, and no volume was found above the yield and ultimate stress in the tested conditions. This simulation study shows no benefit of long nails for the investigated patterns of reverse pertrochanteric fractures, with similar micromotions at the fracture site, bone strain, and implant stress.

Finite element analysis of fixation stability according to reduction position for internal fixation of intertrochanteric fractures

In recent years, finite element analysis (FEA) has been instrumental in comparing the biomechanical stability of various implants for femur fracture treatment and in studying the advantages and disadvantages of different surgical techniques. This analysis has proven helpful for enhancing clinical treatment outcomes. Therefore, this study aimed to numerically analyze fixed stability according to location using FEA. In this study, a virtual finite element model was created based on a clinically anatomically reduced patient. It incorporated positive and negative support derived from intramedullary and extramedullary reduction from the anteroposterior (AP) view and neutral support from the lateral view. The generated model was analyzed to understand the biomechanical behavior occurring in each region under applied physiological loads. The simulation results of this study showed that the average von Mises stress (AVMS) of the nail when performing intramedullary reduction for femoral fixation was 187% of the anatomical reduction and 171% of the extramedullary reduction, and individually up to 2.5 times higher. In other words, intramedullary reduction had a very high possibility of fixation failure compared to other reduction methods. This risk is amplified significantly, especially in situations where bone strength is compromised due to factors such as old age or osteoporosis, which substantially affects the stability of fixation. Extramedullary reduction, when appropriately positioned, demonstrates greater stability than anatomical reduction. It exhibits stable fixation even in scenarios with diminished bone strength. In instances in which the bone density was low in the support position, as observed in the lateral view, the AVMS on the nail appeared to be relatively low, particularly in cases of positive support. Additionally, the femur experienced lower equivalent stress only in the extramedullary reduction-negative position. Moreover, by comparing different reduction methods and bone stiffness values using the same femoral shape, this study offers insights into the selection of appropriate reduction methods. These insights could significantly inform decision making regarding surgical strategies for intertrochanteric fractures.

How to get better TAD? Relationship between anteversion angle of nail and position of femoral neck guide pin during nailing of intertrochanteric fractures

Background

To demonstrate the correlation between guide pin-shaft angle (PSA) at the anteroposterior film and anteversion angle of guide pin at the lateral film and investigate whether excellent tip–apex distance (TAD) can be obtained by changing the entry point via axial rotation of the main intramedullary nail.

Methods

Fifty patients with intertrochanteric femoral fractures (IFFs) undergoing internal fixation with intramedullary nails under 2D fluoroscopy were retrospectively enrolled. Both of the PSA at the anteroposterior film and anteversion angle at the lateral film before and after adjustment of the guide pin were collected. Pearson correlation analysis was performed to investigate their correlation. Intraoperative and postoperative outcomes were recorded. Furthermore, the software of Mimics 10.0 and Pro/E were used to establish the 3D models of the proximal femur and main intramedullary nail/guide pin, respectively. Surgery was simulated on the Pro/E software platform and solid geometry analysis was conducted to calculate the correlation between the PSA and the anteversion angle.

Results

Pearson correlation analysis indicated there was a positive correlation between PSA and anteversion angle, with the correlation coefficient of 0.902 (p < 0.01). By altering the PSA and anteversion angle, TAD was adjusted to be less than 25 mm in all patients. The mean operative time, fluoroscopy time and length of hospital stay were 65.82 ± 11.16 min, 2.03 ± 0.79 min and 6.66 ± 2.49 d. Thirty-one patients received blood transfusions (3.55 ± 1.95 U). Fracture reduction was considered to be good or acceptable in all patients. Complications occurred only in 6 patients (12.00%). At a 3-month follow-up, the mean Timed Up and Go was 31.54 ± 20.95 s and Harris Hip Score was 72.88 ± 8.79. The 3D surgery model also showed when the main intramedullary nail was externally rotated or internally rotated of 20° at the standard location, the PSA of guide pin at the anteroposterior position and anteversion angle of the guide pin at the lateral position were simultaneously increased or decreased.

Conclusion

Our findings suggest altering the PSA and anteversion angle may be beneficial for obtaining excellent TAD and achieving superior outcomes.

Bipolar hemiarthroplasty using microarc oxidation-coated cementless stem in patients with unstable intertrochanteric fracture

PURPOSE

Treatment for an unstable intertrochanteric fracture in elderly patients is challenging. Bipolar hemiarthroplasty (HA) using microarc oxidation (MAO) coating has been a treatment option alternative to internal fixation. However, the outcome of bipolar HA using MAO-coated stem in these patients is unknown.

METHODS

From July 2007 to April 2016, 234 (older than 65 years) patients (234 hips) who were diagnosed as having unstable intertrochanteric fractures were treated with bipolar HA using a fully MAO-coated standard-length rectangular cementless stem. During the arthroplasty, the greater trochanteric and the medial fracture fragments were attached to the stem and fixed with two to three 16-gauge wires. Forty-eight patients (48 hips) died within postoperative 2 years. The remaining 186 patients (186 hips) were followed up for a mean of 4.3 (range 2-10) years.

RESULTS

With the exception of 4 patients who died during hospitalization, 176 of 230 ( 76.5%) patients could ambulate independently with or without an assistive device at the time of hospital discharge. Venous thromboembolism occurred in seven patients (3.0%). One hip dislocated due to a fall 1 month after the arthroplasty. Periprosthetic femoral fracture occurred in four patients and periprosthetic acetabular fracture in one patient. One patient had periprosthetic of acute pyelonephritis. There was no focal osteolysis around the femoral stem.

CONCLUSION

The result of cementless HA using MAO-coated stem enabled early ambulation in most (76.5%) of elderly patients with unstable intertrochanteric fractures and the results were encouraging.

Local Postoperative Complications after Surgery for Intertrochanteric Fractures Using Cephalomedullary Nails

Purpose

Cephalomedullary nails (CMN) are commonly used for the surgical treatment of intertrochanteric fractures. This study aimed to evaluate overall postoperative local complications by reviewing patients who received surgical treatment using three different types of implants.

Materials and Methods

The study sample included 353 patients (107 males, 246 females) who underwent surgery using CMN for intertrochanteric fractures. Three different types of implants were used: i) the Gamma3® (Stryker) in 80 cases, ii) the Targon® PF (Aesculap) in 225 cases, and iii) the Compression Hip Nail® (Trademedics) in 48 cases. The mean age was 82.6 (range, 60–109) years and the average follow-up period was 15 (range, 6–80) months. Postoperative local complications and risk factors of cut-out were assessed.

Results

The most common complication was cut-out (n=26). Other complications included non-union (n=3), periprosthetic fracture (n=2), avascular necrosis (n=1), heterotopic ossification (n=1), and sleeve pull out (n=1). Multivariate analysis revealed that the cut-out group had a higher rate of poor reduction compared to the non-complicated group (P<0.001). Although the mean tip-apex distance (TAD) was 18.4 mm in the non-complicated group, lower than that of the cut-out group (P=0.001), multivariate analysis revealed that TAD was not a significant risk factor for cut-out (P=0.065).

Conclusion

Cut-out is the most common local complication associated with surgical treatment of intertrochanteric fractures using CMN. Proper reduction appears to be important in lowering the risk of cut-out. Maintaining low TAD is another critical factor in achieving sufficient fixation of lag screw to the subchondral bone of the femoral head.

Is the Best Plate a Nail? A Review of 3230 Unstable Intertrochanteric Fractures of the Proximal Femur

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the functional outcomes, revision, and mortality rates of 3 implants used for unstable intertrochanteric hip fractures; the sliding hip screw (SHS), with or without a trochanteric stabilization plate (TSP); and a cephalomedullary nail (CMN).

DESIGN

Multicentre National Prospective Cohort Study.

SETTING

Northern Ireland.

PATIENT/PARTICIPANTS

Patients were identified from a prospective database. Fractures were classified according to OTA/AO A31A2.2, A2.3, and A3. All patients had a minimum of 12 months of follow-up.

INTERVENTION

Patients received either an SHS, an SHS in combination with a TSP, or a CMN. Implant choice was at the discretion of the operating surgeon.

OUTCOME MEASURE

Primary outcome was 12-month mortality analyzed by the Kaplan-Meier survival analysis. Secondary outcomes included 12-month functional status using a validated score and all time revision of implants for any reason.

RESULTS

In total, 3230 patients met the inclusion criteria (2474 SHS, 158 SHS + TSP, and 598 CMN). CMN use increased over time, with concomitant reduction in SHS use. There was no significant difference in functional outcomes at 12 months (analysis of variance, P = 0.177). Although men were significantly younger, they were at a higher risk of 12-month mortality. CMNs had statistically significantly lower 12-month mortality rates (P = 0.0148). The highest revision rate (4.04%) was seen in patients treated with SHS alone (P = 0.041).

CONCLUSIONS

The use of a CMN in unstable intertrochanteric hip fractures conveys the best results in functional outcomes, 12-month mortality, and has lower revision rates compared with an SHS ± TSP.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Early Clinical Efficacy Comparison Study of Gamma3 Nail, Percutaneous Compression Plate (PCCP) and Femoral Head Replacement (FHR) Treatment on Senile Unstable Intertrochanteric Fractures

PURPOSE

This study aimed to analyze the early clinical efficacy of Gamma 3 nail, percutaneous compression plate (PCCP) and femoral head replacement (FHR) treatments on senile unstable intertrochanteric fractures.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Totally 116 patients were included to perform an retrospective study, which involved analysis of the operation time, intraoperative blood loss, and hemoglobin reduction on the first postoperative day compared with preoperative levels, fracture gap, neck shaft angle and tip apex distance on the first postoperative X-ray, hospital stay, time from surgery to mobilization, Harris hip scores and Barthel index six months after operation, and complications postoperative meanwhile were evaluated respectively among three groups.

RESULTS

The Harris hip score and Barthel index and time from surgery to mobilization after FHR treatment were superior to another two surgical methods, but had more blood loss and greater hemoglobin reduction. The mean PCCP hemoglobin reduction was notably shorter than that of the other two groups. Gamma 3 treatment had a lower operation time and blood loss than those treated with PCCP and FHR.

CONCLUSIONS

Gamma 3 and PCCP treatments are a priority for senile unstable intertrochanteric fractures if patients are in good health and perform fair activities of daily living prior to the operation, but had a significantly longer mobilization time than that in FHR. Therefore, considering the senile patients who unable to tolerate long immobilization time, FHR treatment is a considerable choice for faster recovery of independent function and achieve a good clinical efficacy as well as improve quality of life.

Procedural outcomes of double vs. single fluoroscopy for fixing intertrochanteric femur fractures

OBJECTIVE

This study compares reducing radiation and operation time between single and double C-arm fluoroscopy in the treatment of intertrochanteric femur fractures with intramedullary nails.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Forty four patients participated in the study. Patients were divided into two groups as single (23 patients) and double fluoroscope (21 patients). The time of preparation, the duration of the surgery, the total amount of blood loss, and the total duration of radiation exposure were compared, retrospectively. The collo-diaphyseal angle was compared with that of the contralateral hip on postoperative radiographs. Furthermore, the tip-apex distance and the position of the screws in the femoral head were recorded.

RESULTS

The mean preparation periods, collo-diaphyseal angles and blood loss did not differ between groups. In the double-fluoroscopy group, the duration of surgery was 15.9 min shorter (p < 0.001), and the radiation time was 25.7 s shorter (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

The double fluoroscopy technique can significantly reduce surgical and radiation exposure times during surgery.

Trends in the management of intertrochanteric femur fractures in the United States 2005-2011

OBJECTIVES

In the last 2 decades, surgical treatment of intertrochanteric (IT) femur fractures has shown a continuing trend towards the increased use of intramedullary nails (IMN) and decreased use of sliding hip screws (SHS). Recent trends in the United States regarding the use of these implants, including charges and reimbursement, have not been investigated.

METHODS

A national database of Medicare patients (PearlDiver, Inc.) was queried using Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes for patients with surgical dates from 2005-2011.

RESULTS

A total of 34,759 SHS or IMN procedures for intertrochanteric femur fractures were identified from 2005-2011. There was a significant increase in the percentage of IMN compared to SHS, from 46.9% IMN in 2005 to 79.1% in 2011. The average charges for IMN and SHS increased. Statistically higher rates of PE (p&lt;0.001), DVT (p&lt;0.001), MI (p&lt;0.001), respiratory failure (p&lt;0.001), UTI (p&lt;0.001), pneumonia (p&lt;0.001), CVA (p&lt;0.001) and blood transfusion (p&lt;0.001) were noted in the IMN group. The SHS group had higher 1 year (4.3% vs 3.8%, p = 0.012) and 2 year (5.8% vs 5.0%, p = 0.002) mortality rates.

CONCLUSIONS

The previously recognised trend of increasing use of IMN for IT femur fractures has continued. The overall incidence of operative IT femur fractures is not increasing at this time. The cost of IMN remains higher than SHS.

Redisplacement after reduction with intramedullary nails in surgery of intertrochanteric fracture: cause analysis and preventive measures

OBJECTIVE

During the implantation of intramedullary nail in surgery of intertrochanteric fracture, the fact that the originally satisfactory reduction may incur redisplacement remains a major concern. In this article, we will analyze the reasons of redisplacement and describe some methods that can improve the quality of reduction.

METHODS

From January 2012 to October 2014, 67 patients with intertrochanteric fracture were treated using Gamma3 or PFNA system. All the surgical procedures were monitored by fluoroscopy on the AP and lateral views, and the X-ray films were used to evaluate all cases.

RESULTS

Redisplacement occurred in ten cases intraoperatively. According to the fracture type, re-occurring deformities appeared in 31-A2 and 31-A3 commonly, 6 and 3 cases. We found the redisplacement emerged usually in operative procedure and some manipulations should be taken to obtain an anatomic reduction.

CONCLUSIONS

When reduction is achieved in the surgery of intertrochanteric fracture, surgeons tend to overlook the occurrence of redisplacement, or not to treat it that has emerged timely. Internal fixation in nonanatomic reduction may increase the likelihood of fixation failure postoperatively. For the importance of accurate reduction of the fracture, once redisplacement occurs during the surgery, some methods or tricks are applicable to it to restore the anatomic reduction.

A cost analysis of internal fixation versus nonoperative treatment in adult midshaft clavicle fractures using multiple randomized controlled trials

BACKGROUND

To determine whether the cost of nonoperative treatment, including those who require delayed operative treatment, is less than those receiving initial operative management.

METHODS

We identified 4 recent randomized controlled trials comparing operative and nonoperative treatment of displaced midshaft clavicle fractures in adults with a minimum of 1-year follow-up. A decision tree was then created from these data using reoperation for those treated with surgery or delayed operative treatment of those treated nonoperatively as end points. Actual costs estimated from 2013 Medicare reimbursement rates were applied and adjusted to better reflect private insurance rates. We then performed a 2-way sensitivity analysis to test the stability of our model.

RESULTS

Based on our decision tree, the expected costs for operative and nonoperative treatment were $14,763.21 and $3112.65, respectively, producing a cost savings of $11,650.56 with nonoperative treatment. After application of a 2-way sensitivity analysis, our model remains valid until delayed operative treatment for nonoperative patients approaches 95% and reoperation after initial operative management falls below 15%.

CONCLUSIONS

From the perspective of a single payer, initial nonoperative treatment of midshaft clavicle fractures followed by delayed surgery as needed is less costly than initial operative fixation.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Economic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Clinical and Radiologic Outcomes among Bipolar Hemiarthroplasty, Compression Hip Screw and Proximal Femur Nail Antirotation in Treating Comminuted Intertrochanteric Fractures

Purpose

In comminuted intertrochanteric fractures, various operative options have been introduced. The purpose of this study was to determine whether there were differences in clinical and radiologic outcomes among bipolar hemiarthroplasty (BH), compression hip screw (CHS) and proximal femur nail antirotation (PFNA) in treating comminuted intertrochanteric fractures (AO/OTA classification, A2 [22, 23])

Materials and Methods

We retrospectively evaluated total 150 patients (BH, 50; CHS, 50; PFNA, 50) who were operated due to intertrochanteric fractures from March 2010 to December 2012 and were older than 65 years at the time of surgery. We compared these three groups for radiologic and clinical outcomes at 12 months postoperatively, including Harris Hip Score, mobility (Koval stage), visual analogue scale and radiologic limb length discrepancy (shortening).

Results

There was no statistical significance among three groups in clinical outcomes including Harris Hip Score, mobility (Koval stage), visual analogue scale. However, there was significant differences in radiologic limb discrepancy in plain radiographs at 12 months postoperatively (radiologic shortening: BH, 2.3 mm; CHS, 5.1 mm; PFNA, 3.0 mm; P=0.000).

Conclusion

There were no clinical differences among BH, PFNA, and CHS in this study. However, notable limb length shortening could be originated during fracture healing in osteosynthesis, compared to arthroplasty (BH<PFNA<CHS).

Determining the best treatment for coronal angular deformity of the knee joint in growing children: a decision analysis

This study aimed to determine the best treatment modality for coronal angular deformity of the knee joint in growing children using decision analysis. A decision tree was created to evaluate 3 treatment modalities for coronal angular deformity in growing children: temporary hemiepiphysiodesis using staples, percutaneous screws, or a tension band plate. A decision analysis model was constructed containing the final outcome score, probability of metal failure, and incomplete correction of deformity. The final outcome was defined as health-related quality of life and was used as a utility in the decision tree. The probabilities associated with each case were obtained by literature review, and health-related quality of life was evaluated by a questionnaire completed by 25 pediatric orthopedic experts. Our decision analysis model favored temporary hemiepiphysiodesis using a tension band plate over temporary hemiepiphysiodesis using percutaneous screws or stapling, with utilities of 0.969, 0.957, and 0.962, respectively. One-way sensitivity analysis showed that hemiepiphysiodesis using a tension band plate was better than temporary hemiepiphysiodesis using percutaneous screws, when the overall complication rate of hemiepiphysiodesis using a tension band plate was lower than 15.7%. Two-way sensitivity analysis showed that hemiepiphysiodesis using a tension band plate was more beneficial than temporary hemiepiphysiodesis using percutaneous screws.