Management of labyrinthine fistula: hearing preservation versus prevention of residual disease

Endoscopic diving technique for hearing preservation in managing labyrinth-invading cholesteatomas

PURPOSE

Complete removal of the matrix over the existing fistula in the event of an extensive cholesteatoma with labyrinth invasion can result in total deafness. This study aimed to present a novel method of underwater endoscopic labyrinth dissection using continuous steroid irrigation (CSI) and systemic steroid administration for hearing preservation.

METHODS

The endoscopic diving technique (EDT) was used to dissect semicircular canals, revealing the underwater anatomy of membranous labyrinth structures, in two cadaver temporal bones. EDT with CSI was used in three clinical cases with extensive cholesteatoma.

RESULTS

On cadaver temporal bones, the anatomy of the lateral (LSC), superior (SSC), and posterior membranous semicircular canals with their respective ampullas and common crus was documented. In the first case managed with transcanal EDT, the LSC was eroded across almost its entire length. The fallopian canal was circumferentially eroded at the second genu and part of the mastoid segment. The cholesteatoma matrix was completely removed, and the membranous LSC was preserved. In the second and third cases, we were able to remove the cholesteatoma matrix along the eroded bony semicircular canals while keeping the membranes intact. No sensorineural hearing loss was detected in the postoperative masked pure-tone audiometry at a mean follow-up time of 12 months or cholesteatoma recurrence at the follow-up imaging.

CONCLUSIONS

EDT with CSI can be safely utilized in the course of temporal bone labyrinth dissections and provides advantages during cholesteatoma removal over the eroded labyrinth on preservation of the membranous structures, and thus may help preserve cochlear function.

Presentation, Management, and Hearing Outcomes of Labyrinthine Fistula Secondary to Cholesteatoma: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

The current study systematically reviewed the literature to compare auditory outcomes of patients treated for labyrinthine fistula (LF) based on characteristics of disease and surgical management.

DATABASES REVIEWED

PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science.

METHODS

Original series (at least five cases) published from 2000 reporting management and hearing results of LF secondary to cholesteatoma were included. Proportion and odds-ratio (OR) meta-analyses were conducted through inverse variance random-effects models based on logit transformation.

RESULTS

The prevalence of LF is estimated to be 7% (95% confidence interval [CI], 5-9%). Fistulae involving the lateral semicircular canal (90%; 95% CI, 87-93%) and larger than 2 mm (53%; 95% CI, 43-64%) were common, whereas membranous involvement was less frequent (20%; 95% CI, 12-30%). Complete removal of the cholesteatoma matrix overlying the LF was mostly applied. Bone conduction (BC) preservation was frequently achieved (81%; 95% CI, 76-85%); new-onset postoperative anacusis was rarely reported (5%; 95% CI, 4-8%). A higher chance of BC preservation was associated with sparing the perilymphatic space (OR, 4.67; 95% CI, 1.26-17.37) or membranous labyrinth (OR, 4.56; 95% CI, 2.33-8.93), exclusive lateral semicircular canal involvement (OR, 3.52; 95% CI, 1.32-9.38), smaller size (<2 mm; OR, 3.03; 95% CI, 1.24-7.40), and intravenous steroid infusion (OR, 7.87; 95% CI, 2.34-26.42).

CONCLUSION

LF occurs in a significant proportion of patients with cholesteatoma. In the past two decades, complete removal of the cholesteatoma matrix followed by immediate sealing has been favored, supported by the high proportion of BC preservation. Hearing preservation depends primarily on characteristics of the LF, and specific surgical strategies should be pursued. Intraoperative and postoperative intravenous steroid infusion is recommended.

Analysis of postoperative effects of different semicircular canal surgical technique in patients with labyrinthine fistulas

Objective

Different semicircular canal surgery techniques have been used to treat patients with labyrinthine fistulas caused by middle ear cholesteatoma. This study evaluated postoperative hearing and vestibular function after various semicircular canal surgeries.

Materials and methods

In group 1, from January 2008 to December 2014, 29 patients with middle ear cholesteatoma complicated by labyrinthine fistulas were treated with surgery involving covering the fistulas with simple fascia. In group 2, from January 2015 to October 2021, 36 patients with middle ear cholesteatoma complicated by labyrinthine fistulas were included. Cholesteatomas on the surface of type I labyrinthine fistulas were cleaned using the “under water technique” and capped with a “sandwich” composed of fascia, bone meal, and fascia. Cholesteatomas on the surface of type II and III fistulas were cleaned using the “under water technique,” and the labyrinthine fistula was plugged with a “pie” composed of fascia, bone meal, and fascia, and then covered with bone wax.

Results

Some patients with labyrinthine fistulas in group 1 exhibited symptoms of vertigo after surgery. In group 2 Patients with type II labyrinthine fistulas experienced short-term vertigo after semicircular canal occlusion, but no cases of vertigo were reported during long-term follow-up. “sandwich.” In patients with type II labyrinthine fistulas, the semicircular canal occlusion influenced postoperative hearing improvement. However, postoperative patient hearing was still superior to preoperative hearing.

Conclusion

The surface of type I labyrinthine fistulas should be capped by a “sandwich” composed of fascia, bone meal, and fascia. Type II and III labyrinthine fistulas should be plugged with a “pie” composed of fascia, bone meal, and fascia, covered with bone wax.

Labyrinthine fistulas: Surgical outcomes and an additional diagnostic strategy

PURPOSE

To evaluate perioperative findings and audiological and vestibular outcomes in patients operated for cholesteatoma with labyrinthine fistulas. Also to assess radiological fistula size.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients who underwent surgery for a labyrinthine fistula caused by a cholesteatoma between 2015 and 2020 in a tertiary referral center were retrospectively investigated. Fistula size was determined on preoperative CT scan. Bone and air conduction pure tone average thresholds were obtained pre- and postoperatively. Clinical outcomes, such as vertigo and otorrea were also evaluated. Main purpose was to determine whether there is a correlation between fistula size and postoperative hearing. Furthermore, perioperative findings and vestibular outcomes are evaluated.

RESULTS

21 patients (22 cases) with a labyrinthine fistula were included. There was no significant change after surgery in bone conduction pure tone average (preoperatively 27.6 dB ± 26.7; postoperatively 30.3 dB ± 34.3; p = 0.628) or air conduction pure tone average (preoperatively 58.7 dB ± 24.3; postoperatively 60.2 dB ± 28.3; p = 0.816). Fistula size was not correlated to postoperative hearing outcome. There were two patients with membranous labyrinth invasion: one patient was deaf preoperatively, the other acquired total sensorineural hearing loss after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Sensorineural hearing loss after cholesteatoma surgery with labyrinthine fistula is rare. Fistula size and postoperative hearing loss are not correlated, however, membranous labyrinthine invasion seems to be related to poor postoperative hearing outcomes. Therefore, additional preoperative radiological work up, by MRI scan, in selected cases is advocated to guide the surgeon to optimize preoperative counselling.

[A case of hearing preservation during surgical treatment of distributed fistula labyrinth in a patient with chronic purulent means otitis and cholesteatoma]

The article provides a brief overview of the epidemiology, diagnosis, clinical manifestations and surgical methods of treatment of labyrinthine fistulas (LF) in patients with chronic suppurative otitis media (CSOM) with cholesteatoma. The efficacy of various LF treatment techniques, their complications, and the principles of prevention of cochleovestibular disorders during surgical treatment are described. The prognostic criteria for the deterioration of bone conduction thresholds during LF surgery, which include a large LF size, the opening of the membranous labyrinth, and the extent of damage to the structures of the inner ear, are presented. A clinical case of surgical treatment of widespread LF in CSOM with cholesteatoma is presented, which proves the possibility of preserving the auditory and vestibular functions while observing the stages of sanitation, manipulations on the LF and obliteration of semicircular canals defects with auto tissues. Combined surgery of such a plan must certainly be accompanied by local instillation of solutions of hormonal preparations in case of a deficiency of perilymphatic fluid in the labyrinth and postoperative antibacterial and hormonal therapy.

Post-operative hearing among patients with labyrinthine fistula as a complication of cholesteatoma using "under water technique"

Introduction

During surgery in patients with labyrinthine fistula the mandatory complete removal of the cholesteatoma while preserving inner ear and vestibular function is a challenge. Options so far have been either the complete removal of the cholesteatoma or leaving the matrix on the fistula. We evaluated an alternative “under water” surgical technique for complete cholesteatoma resection, in terms of preservation of postoperative inner ear and vestibular function.

Methods

From 2013 to 2019, 20 patients with labyrinthine fistula due to cholesteatoma were operated. We used the canal wall down approach and removal of matrix on the fistula was done as the last step during surgery using the “under water technique”. The pre and postoperative hearing tests and the vestibular function were retrospectively examined.

Results

There was no significant difference between pre and post-operative bone conduction thresholds; 20% experienced an improvement of more than 10 dB, with none experiencing a postoperative worsening of sensorineural hearing loss. Among seven patients who presented with vertigo, two had transient vertigo postoperatively but eventually recovered.

Conclusion

Our data show that the “under water technique” for cholesteatoma removal at the labyrinthine fistula is a viable option in the preservation of inner ear function and facilitating complete cholesteatoma removal.

Underwater Endoscopic Ear Surgery for Closure of Cholesteatomatous Labyrinthine Fistula With Preservation of Auditory Function

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the outcomes of the underwater endoscopic ear surgery (UWEES) technique for closure of cholesteatomatous labyrinthine fistula (LF) with preservation of auditory function.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case review study.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

A total of 12 patients with cholesteatomatous LF.

INTERVENTION

Surgical method of closure using UWEES for cholesteatomatous LF to minimize inner ear damage. Artificial cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) was used as the perfusate, except for earlier cases when saline was employed.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Comparison of bone conductance hearing level (BCHL) before and after surgery. A change of BCHL less than 10 dB was defined as successful preservation of bone conductance hearing.

RESULTS

All cases of LF were treated successfully by closure using the UWEES technique. Seven cases were type I, one was type IIa, and four were type III according to the Milewski and Dornhoffer classification of LF. The average LF size was 3.1 mm (1-7 mm). Eleven patients were evaluated and their bone conductance hearing was well preserved in all of them (11/11). One patient was too young for preoperative evaluation of BCHL, but hearing preservation was verified 2 years later at the age of 6 years. Remarkably, none of the patients complained of vertigo, except for only a slight manifestation on postoperative day 1.

CONCLUSION

The UWEES technique was effective for closure of cholesteatomatous LF with preservation of auditory function.

"Sandwich technique" enables preservation of hearing and antivertiginous effect in cholesteatomatous labyrinthine fistula

Purpose

The aim of the study was to assess hearing, surgical and clinical results of the treatment in patients with cholesteatomatous labyrinthine fistula (LF) focusing on the different techniques and materials used in the management.

Methods

Study group included 465 patients. Cases with LFs discovered or confirmed during surgical procedure were thoroughly analyzed.

Results

LFs were noted in 11.4% of all cases. Thirty-eight patients, with all follow-up data available, were included into the further analysis. Most LFs were located in the lateral semicircular canal (87%). LFs were assessed as small in 2 cases, as medium in 24 patients while 12 were described as large. Based on Dornhoffer and Milewski classification, 50% of LFs were classified as IIa, 24% as IIb, 6 LFs were very deep (type III), while 4—superficial (type I). The size and type of LF did not influence postsurgical complaints (p = 0.1070, p = 0.3187, respectively). Vertigo was less frequent in LFs treated by “sandwich technique”, especially those with opened endosteum. In 30 (79%) patients, hearing improved or did not change after surgery. Hearing outcomes were significantly better in the ears operated by means of CWU technique (p = 0.0339), in LFs with intact membranous labyrinth (p = 0.0139) and when “sandwich technique” was performed (p = 0.0159). Postsurgical bone conduction thresholds levels were significantly better in LFs covered by “sandwich method” (p = 0.0440).

Conclusion

“Sandwich technique” (temporal fascia–bone pate–temporal fascia) enables preservation of hearing as well as antivertiginous effect in patients with cholesteatomatous labyrinthine fistula.

Chronic Ear Disease

Chronic ear disease is composed of a spectrum of otologic disorders intrinsically tied to Eustachian tube dysfunction. Presentation can range from asymptomatic findings on physical examination to critically ill patients with intracranial complications. Internists represent the first line in diagnosis of these conditions, making awareness of the common signs and symptoms essential. With surgical management often required, partnership between internal medicine and otolaryngology is fundamental in the management of patients with chronic ear disease.