The devil is in the details: a small-lesion sensitive weakly supervised learning framework for prostate cancer detection and grading

Harnessing artificial intelligence for prostate cancer management

Prostate cancer (PCa) is a common malignancy in males. The pathology review of PCa is crucial for clinical decision-making, but traditional pathology review is labor intensive and subjective to some extent. Digital pathology and whole-slide imaging enable the application of artificial intelligence (AI) in pathology. This review highlights the success of AI in detecting and grading PCa, predicting patient outcomes, and identifying molecular subtypes. We propose that AI-based methods could collaborate with pathologists to reduce workload and assist clinicians in formulating treatment recommendations. We also introduce the general process and challenges in developing AI pathology models for PCa. Importantly, we summarize publicly available datasets and open-source codes to facilitate the utilization of existing data and the comparison of the performance of different models to improve future studies.

SAMPLER: unsupervised representations for rapid analysis of whole slide tissue images

BACKGROUND

Deep learning has revolutionized digital pathology, allowing automatic analysis of hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) stained whole slide images (WSIs) for diverse tasks. WSIs are broken into smaller images called tiles, and a neural network encodes each tile. Many recent works use supervised attention-based models to aggregate tile-level features into a slide-level representation, which is then used for downstream analysis. Training supervised attention-based models is computationally intensive, architecture optimization of the attention module is non-trivial, and labeled data are not always available. Therefore, we developed an unsupervised and fast approach called SAMPLER to generate slide-level representations.

METHODS

Slide-level representations of SAMPLER are generated by encoding the cumulative distribution functions of multiscale tile-level features. To assess effectiveness of SAMPLER, slide-level representations of breast carcinoma (BRCA), non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC), and renal cell carcinoma (RCC) WSIs of The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) were used to train separate classifiers distinguishing tumor subtypes in FFPE and frozen WSIs. In addition, BRCA and NSCLC classifiers were externally validated on frozen WSIs. Moreover, SAMPLER's attention maps identify regions of interest, which were evaluated by a pathologist. To determine time efficiency of SAMPLER, we compared runtime of SAMPLER with two attention-based models. SAMPLER concepts were used to improve the design of a context-aware multi-head attention model (context-MHA).

FINDINGS

SAMPLER-based classifiers were comparable to state-of-the-art attention deep learning models to distinguish subtypes of BRCA (AUC = 0.911 ± 0.029), NSCLC (AUC = 0.940 ± 0.018), and RCC (AUC = 0.987 ± 0.006) on FFPE WSIs (internal test sets). However, training SAMLER-based classifiers was >100 times faster. SAMPLER models successfully distinguished tumor subtypes on both internal and external test sets of frozen WSIs. Histopathological review confirmed that SAMPLER-identified high attention tiles contained subtype-specific morphological features. The improved context-MHA distinguished subtypes of BRCA and RCC (BRCA-AUC = 0.921 ± 0.027, RCC-AUC = 0.988 ± 0.010) with increased accuracy on internal test FFPE WSIs.

INTERPRETATION

Our unsupervised statistical approach is fast and effective for analyzing WSIs, with greatly improved scalability over attention-based deep learning methods. The high accuracy of SAMPLER-based classifiers and interpretable attention maps suggest that SAMPLER successfully encodes the distinct morphologies within WSIs and will be applicable to general histology image analysis problems.

FUNDING

This study was supported by the National Cancer Institute (Grant No. R01CA230031 and P30CA034196).

One label is all you need: Interpretable AI-enhanced histopathology for oncology

Artificial Intelligence (AI)-enhanced histopathology presents unprecedented opportunities to benefit oncology through interpretable methods that require only one overall label per hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) slide with no tissue-level annotations. We present a structured review of these methods organized by their degree of verifiability and by commonly recurring application areas in oncological characterization. First, we discuss morphological markers (tumor presence/absence, metastases, subtypes, grades) in which AI-identified regions of interest (ROIs) within whole slide images (WSIs) verifiably overlap with pathologist-identified ROIs. Second, we discuss molecular markers (gene expression, molecular subtyping) that are not verified via H&E but rather based on overlap with positive regions on adjacent tissue. Third, we discuss genetic markers (mutations, mutational burden, microsatellite instability, chromosomal instability) that current technologies cannot verify if AI methods spatially resolve specific genetic alterations. Fourth, we discuss the direct prediction of survival to which AI-identified histopathological features quantitatively correlate but are nonetheless not mechanistically verifiable. Finally, we discuss in detail several opportunities and challenges for these one-label-per-slide methods within oncology. Opportunities include reducing the cost of research and clinical care, reducing the workload of clinicians, personalized medicine, and unlocking the full potential of histopathology through new imaging-based biomarkers. Current challenges include explainability and interpretability, validation via adjacent tissue sections, reproducibility, data availability, computational needs, data requirements, domain adaptability, external validation, dataset imbalances, and finally commercialization and clinical potential. Ultimately, the relative ease and minimum upfront cost with which relevant data can be collected in addition to the plethora of available AI methods for outcome-driven analysis will surmount these current limitations and achieve the innumerable opportunities associated with AI-driven histopathology for the benefit of oncology.

SAMPLER: Empirical distribution representations for rapid analysis of whole slide tissue images

Deep learning has revolutionized digital pathology, allowing for automatic analysis of hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) stained whole slide images (WSIs) for diverse tasks. In such analyses, WSIs are typically broken into smaller images called tiles, and a neural network backbone encodes each tile in a feature space. Many recent works have applied attention based deep learning models to aggregate tile-level features into a slide-level representation, which is then used for slide-level prediction tasks. However, training attention models is computationally intensive, necessitating hyperparameter optimization and specialized training procedures. Here, we propose SAMPLER, a fully statistical approach to generate efficient and informative WSI representations by encoding the empirical cumulative distribution functions (CDFs) of multiscale tile features. We demonstrate that SAMPLER-based classifiers are as accurate or better than state-of-the-art fully deep learning attention models for classification tasks including distinction of: subtypes of breast carcinoma (BRCA: AUC=0.911 ± 0.029); subtypes of non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC: AUC=0.940±0.018); and subtypes of renal cell carcinoma (RCC: AUC=0.987±0.006). A major advantage of the SAMPLER representation is that predictive models are >100X faster compared to attention models. Histopathological review confirms that SAMPLER-identified high attention tiles contain tumor morphological features specific to the tumor type, while low attention tiles contain fibrous stroma, blood, or tissue folding artifacts. We further apply SAMPLER concepts to improve the design of attention-based neural networks, yielding a context aware multi-head attention model with increased accuracy for subtype classification within BRCA and RCC (BRCA: AUC=0.921±0.027, and RCC: AUC=0.988±0.010). Finally, we provide theoretical results identifying sufficient conditions for which SAMPLER is optimal. SAMPLER is a fast and effective approach for analyzing WSIs, with greatly improved scalability over attention methods to benefit digital pathology analysis.