Analysis of subclonal expansion of colorectal carcinomas by flow cytometry

Molecular subtypes of colorectal cancers determined by PCR-based analysis

Tumor tissue consists of a heterogeneous cell population. The allelic imbalance (AI) ratio, determined in isolated tumor glands, is a good index of tumor heterogeneity. However, associations of the patterns of AI and microsatellite instability (MSI) development, observed in most cases of colorectal cancer (CRC), with tumor progression have not been reported previously. In this study, we examined whether CRC genetic profiles stratified by a combination of the AI ratio and MSI facilitate categorization of CRC, and whether these genetic profiles are associated with specific molecular alterations in CRC. A crypt isolation method was used to isolate DNA from tumors and normal glands obtained from 147 sporadic CRCs. AI and MSI statuses were determined using PCR‐based microsatellite analysis and stratified based on AI ratio and MSI status. DNA methylation status (high methylation, intermediate methylation and low methylation status and mutations in KRAS,BRAF, and TP53 were examined. In addition, mucin markers were immunostained. Based on this analysis, four subgroups were categorized. Subgroup 1 was characterized by a high MSI status and BRAF mutation; subgroup 2 was closely associated with a high AI ratio, which accumulated during the early phases of colorectal carcinogenesis, and TP53 mutation; subgroup 3 was associated with a low AI ratio, seen during the later phases of colorectal carcinogenesis, and KRAS mutation; and subgroup 4 was defined as a minor subgroup. These results confirmed that classification of distinct molecular profiles provides important insights into colorectal carcinogenesis.

Analysis of allelic imbalances at multiple cancer-related chromosomal loci and microsatellite instability within the same tumor using a single tumor gland from colorectal carcinomas

Genetic changes related to colorectal carcinomas are accumulated in individual tumor glands during disease progression. Microsatellite allelic analysis of individual tumor glands from 30 colorectal carcinomas using a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay coupled with crypt isolation was used to detect intratumoral genetic heterogeneity, the sequence of allelic imbalances (AIs) and the microsatellite instability status of single tumor glands during neoplastic progression. In addition, the CpG islands methylated phenotype (CIMP) status was examined using a methylation-specific PCR method. The specimens were divided into 2 groups: a pooled gland sample, which was composed of more than 50 tumor glands, and a single tumor gland sample. The latter consisted of 10 single tumor glands, which were obtained from the same tumor separately. Most colorectal carcinomas (27 of 30 tumors) examined were heterogeneous for at least one genetic alteration, with from 2 to 7 genotypically different subclones detected per tumor. In 12 of the 27 heterogeneous tumors, it was possible to define the order of genetic alterations during the tumor progression. By analyzing multiple single tumor glands within the same tumor, we found that various subclonal expansions were seen within the same tumors. Finally, the AI pattern of single tumor glands was not correlated with CIMP status. Most carcinomas appeared to have a heterogeneous composition. This may have resulted from the successful progression of one clone that had different AIs in many chromosomal regions. This suggests that knowledge of the different genotypes of multiple single tumor glands may help clarify the process of tumor progression.

Analysis of Ki-ras and p53 gene mutations in laterally spreading tumors of the colorectum

A laterally spreading tumor (LST) is considered to be a specific subtype of superficial colorectal tumors, in view of its characteristic clinicopathological features. We attempted to compare genetic alterations found in LST (>10 mm) with those found in IIa-type adenomas (10 mm or less (small superficial elevated lesion)) and conventional polypoid adenomas (>10 mm). In addition, multiple sampling by microdissection was performed for 14 LST to examine genetic heterogeneity in the Ki-ras and p53 gene mutation patterns. Polymerase chain reaction, single-strand conformation polymorphism and direct sequencing were used to analyze Ki-ras and p53 gene mutations in 73 sporadic colorectal adenomas: 28 LST; 22 IIa-type adenomas; and 23 polypoid adenomas. Ki-ras gene mutations were found more frequently in LST (6/28 tumors) and polypoid adenomas (6/23 tumors) than in IIa-type adenomas (2/22 tumors), although this difference was not statistically significant. The frequency of p53 gene mutations in the 28 LST was 25% (7/28), which was significantly higher than that found in IIa-type adenomas (P < 0.05). However, although p53 gene mutations were found more frequently in LST than in polypoid adenomas, this difference was not statistically significant. Seven LST exhibited a combination of wild-type and mutant-type tumor cells having the p53 gene mutation pattern, whereas a pattern of different Ki-ras gene mutations was found in two of three LST that exhibited Ki-ras gene mutation heterogeneity. We suggest that the LST exhibited a characteristic pattern in terms of the Ki-ras as well as the p53 gene mutation pattern, thereby supporting the hypothesis that LST is a specific subtype of colorectal tumors.

Analysis of genetic alterations, classified according to their DNA ploidy pattern, in the progression of colorectal adenomas and early colorectal carcinomas

DNA aneuploidy is a biological marker of the oncogenic potential of colorectal adenomas. The accumulation of genetic alterations of cancer-related genes is also essential for colorectal carcinogenesis. However, it is unclear whether there is any relationship between these genetic alterations and the DNA ploidy of colon tumour cells in the progression of colorectal adenomas and early colorectal carcinomas. Here we have studied the DNA ploidy state and genetic alterations occurring in colorectal tumours using the crypt isolation technique. Crypts isolated from a total of 106 colorectal tumors (adenoma, 93; early carcinoma, 13) were examined using a combination of flow cytometric analysis of DNA content, polymerase chain reaction-microsatellite assay, and single-strand conformation polymorphism assay for evidence of chromosomal allelic imbalance (AI; 17p; 5q; 18q) or p53 gene mutation. In addition, we examined microsatellite instability (MSI) with BAT 26 primer sets. DNA multiploidy was infrequently detected in colorectal adenomas (15.1%), in contrast to early carcinomas (46.2%). There was a significant difference in the incidence of AI of chromosome 18q between diploid adenomas and aneuploid populations of multiploid adenomas (18.1% vs 57.1%, p = 0.0043). Mutation of p53 was also found more frequently in aneuploid populations of early multiploid colorectal carcinomas than in early diploid colorectal carcinomas (66.7% vs 0%, p = 0.021). MSI was found in only 2 of 93 adenomas, with no MSI detected in early colorectal cancers. The two MSI-positive adenomas were diploid. We subdivided multiploid adenomas into two groups: those with a low or a high DNA index (DI). The incidence of genetic alterations of high-DI adenomas did not differ from those of low-DI adenomas. Allelic imbalance involving loci on chromosome 18q and mutations of p53 seems to be associated with the progression of diploidy to multiploidy in colorectal tumours. On the other hand, MSI may be associated with the development of some diploid tumours. In addition, the incidence of genetic alterations in the colorectal adenomas that we examined appears to be independent of the tumour's DNA index.

Evolution of DNA ploidy state and DNA index in colorectal adenomas and carcinomas using the crypt isolation technique: new hypothesis in colorectal tumorigenesis

The evolution of DNA diploid, aneuploid and multiploid (diploid and aneuploid) states that represent DNA types that are independent of genetic alterations in colorectal tumors were examined. Changes in the DNA index (DI) accompanying tumor development from adenoma to carcinoma were assessed. In colorectal adenomas and early cancers, the DNA was diploid or multiploid. A pure aneuploid state was observed in advanced carcinomas only, whereas the aneuploid DI values of adenomas were characterized by two distinct peaks. The DI values for the carcinomas were randomly distributed. However, in advanced carcinomas, aneuploid carcinomas tended to have lower DI whereas aneuploid populations within multiploid carcinomas tended to have higher DI. Early cancers were subdivided into two groups: a cancer region associated with an adenomatous region (group A tumors) and a cancer region that exhibited an absence of or a very limited adenomatous region (group B tumors). Group A tumor DI were lower than group B. It is suggested that low DI adenomas might transform into group A tumors, which consequently progress to advanced aneuploid carcinomas. In addition, group B tumors might derive predominantly from high DI adenomas or from group A tumors by high DI evolution, and might progress into advanced multiploid carcinomas. Therefore, the evolution of the DNA index might play an important role in the development of colorectal tumors.

Application of the crypt isolation technique to the assessment of genetic alterations of colorectal carcinomas

The crypt isolation technique (CIT) allows for the isolation of pure tumor crypts from colon tumor tissue. In a previous study we reported on the genetic alterations found in colorectal tumor crypts using the CIT; however, a direct comparison of the genetic alterations found in colorectal carcinomas using either conventional methods (CM) or the CIT has not previously been performed. Here, we analyzed the impact of this method on the genetic analysis of colon tumor cells by comparing the observed frequency of genetic alterations in colon tumors isolated using CM or the CIT. We used a combination of the CIT and the fluorescent polymerase chain reaction assay to accurately assess the incidence of allelic imbalances (AI) at a number of chromosomal loci (17p, 5q, 18q, 1p, 8p, 22q), microsatellite instability (MSI), and mutations of cancer-related genes (p53 and APC genes) in 48 sporadic colorectal carcinomas. In addition, genetic alterations seen in multiploid tumors (defined as tumors with both diploid and aneuploid cell populations) identified by the CIT were also examined. The incidence of AI at the chromosomal loci tested was more frequently detected in samples isolated from tumors using the CIT than in those isolated from the same tumors using CM. In contrast, we observed no differences in the frequency of MSI or cancer-related gene mutation between the two groups. Although there was no difference in the frequency of genetic alterations between tumors with evidence of multiploidy, sorting of diploid and aneuploid populations allowed detection of distinct genetic changes. The crypt isolation method thus appears to be useful in that it allows purification of tumor cells and the accurate assessment of their genetic alterations. In addition, it may also be of benefit in clarifying the genetic profile of multiploid tumor cell populations.

Analysis of Ki-ras gene mutations associated with DNA diploid, aneuploid, and multiploid colorectal carcinomas using a crypt isolation technique

BACKGROUND AND AIM

Current evidence suggests a possible relationship between DNA ploidy status and Ki-ras gene mutations in human cancers. However, the conventional method does not enable accurate determination of DNA ploidy status of a tumor cell. The present study attempts to clarify whether Ki-ras gene mutations are associated with DNA ploidy status in sporadic colorectal carcinomas using a crypt isolation technique coupled with DNA cytometric sorting.

METHODS

Polymerase chain reaction and single-strand conformation polymorphism and direct sequencing were used to analyze Ki-ras gene mutations in 82 sporadic colorectal carcinomas: 21 diploid, 12 aneuploid, and 49 multiploid. In addition, microsatellite instability (MSI) was assessed using seven microsatellite markers to study the relationship to Ki-ras mutations.

RESULTS

Ki-ras mutations were found in 12 of 21 diploid carcinomas and in 8 of 12 aneuploid carcinomas. In contrast, Ki-ras gene mutations were detected infrequently in the 34 multiploid carcinomas examined, 8 of which were seen in diploid populations and 10 in aneuploid populations. On the other hand, Ki-ras gene mutations were inversely correlated with MSI, which was found in diploid carcinomas only.

CONCLUSIONS

The low frequency of Ki-ras gene mutations that we observed in multiclonal colorectal carcinomas suggests that development of multiclonal colorectal carcinoma may involve a mechanism different from that involved in the development of diploid or aneuploid colorectal carcinomas.

Intratumor genetic heterogeneity in advanced human colorectal adenocarcinoma

Colorectal carcinogenesis is widely accepted as one of the best-characterized examples of stepwise progression. The existing colorectal carcinogenesis model assumes genetic homogeneity of individual tumors for the main known genetic alterations: K-ras and p53 genes point mutations and loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of chromosome 5q and 18q. The object of the present study was to demonstrate the existence of an intratumor genetic heterogeneity in advanced sporadic colorectal carcinoma for these genetic alterations. Using improved tissue microdissection and DNA extraction, for each tumor, amplifiable DNA was obtained from 15 to 20 areas, of which 1 to 2 concerned lymph node metastases (LNM). This study revealed that 10 of 15 (67%) analyzed tumors were heterogeneous for at least 1 genetic alteration, with between 2 and 6 genotypically different clones detected per tumor. No correlation was observed between the genotype of these subclones and histological differentiation or invasive propensity. Intratumor heterogeneity was more frequently observed for LOH than for point mutations, 67% and 58% for LOH at APC and DCC locus, and 20% for mutation of either the K-ras or p53 gene. In 5 of the 9 (56%) heterogeneous cases with available LNM, the genotype observed in the LNM was different from that of the main clone in the primary tumor, and moreover, 2 of the LNM displayed a genotype undetected in the primary tumor. In conclusion, intratumor genetic heterogeneity was demonstrated in advanced sporadic colorectal carcinoma and was represented as topographically distinct genotypic subclones. Taking into account such a significant genetic heterogeneity of colorectal tumors, the use of genetic markers for prognosis management should be reconsidered.

Genetic alterations in DNA diploid, aneuploid and multiploid colorectal carcinomas identified by the crypt isolation technique

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) and microsatellite instability (MSI) commonly occur in colorectal carcinomas. However, the role of these genetic alterations in determining DNA ploidy status of tumors (diploid, aneuploid and multiploid) remains unclear. In the present study, we attempted to clarify the relationship between genetic alterations and DNA ploidy status. Crypt isolation coupled with DNA cytometric sorting and polymerase chain reaction assay (17 microsatellite markers) were used to study allelic losses and MSI in 59 colorectal carcinomas (diploid, 15; aneuploid, 10 and multiploid, 34). Of the 15 diploid carcinomas, 6 exhibited MSI in which allelic losses were rarely found. The other 9 diploid tumors mostly exhibited allelic losses, but none displayed MSI status. Whereas allelic losses frequently occurred in the aneuploid carcinomas and the aneuploid populations of multiploid carcinomas, they were rarely detected in the diploid populations of multiploid carcinomas. MSI status was not observed in aneuploid carcinomas nor in either population of multiploid carcinomas. Although multiploid carcinomas genetically resemble aneuploid carcinomas in the expression of the severe LOH phenotype, the genetic alterations seen in the diploid populations of multiploid carcinomas may differ from those of diploid carcinomas. Furthermore, all diploid, aneuploid and both the diploid and aneuploid fractions of the multiploid tumors that were non-MSI exhibited a high rate of LOH, suggesting that LOH is independent of the tumor's ploidy status.