Defective sexual development in an infant with 46, XY, der(9)t(8;9)(q23.1;p23)mat

Prenatal diagnosis of del(9)(p24): a sex reverse case

BACKGROUND

We report on a fetus with sex reversal and del(9)(p24) consequent to a malsegregation of a maternal balanced complex translocation involving chromosomes 7, 9 and 11.

METHODS

Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) was performed in order to verify the presence of the SRY gene and the absence of DMRT1 and DMRT2 genes located in 9p24.3 region and frequently associated with sex reversal.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

The prenatal karyotype revealed an unbalanced male fetus. The postmortem examination showed a malformed fetus with female external genitalia. Lack of DMRT1-2 genes established by FISH.

Three patients with 9p deletions including DMRT1 and DMRT2: A girl with XY complement, bilateral ovotestes, and extreme growth retardation, and two XX females with normal pubertal development

It is well documented that distal 9p monosomy can be associated with XY sex reversal. Recently, the possibility of DMRT1 and/or DMRT2 (the genes for doublesex and mab-3 related transcription factor 1 and 2) being the sex determining genes(s) at 9p has been raised. DMRT1 and DMRT2 map near the 9p telomere, distal of marker D9S1779. We describe here three unrelated females with distal 9p monosomy, one with XY complement and two with XX complements. In each individual, fluorescent in situ hybridization predicted the loss of the DMRT genes. Patient 1, an XY individual with monosomy 9pter --> p24.1 approximately 24.2 and trisomy 7q32 --> qter had normal female external genitalia, a blind ending vagina, no uterus, a Fallopian tube on the right, and bilateral ovotestes with primitive ovarian tissue. She also had extreme growth retardation. Around 80 cases of distal 9p monosomy have been reported previously, but there has been no report of ovotestes or gonads comprising ovarian tissue in a XY patient with 9p deletion. Findings in Patient 1 suggest that the phenotypic spectrum of the heterozygous DMRT deletion may include true hermaphroditism. Patients 2 and 3 were 12- and 14-year-old females with XX complements, normal external genitalia, and normal pubertal development. Patient 2 had pure monosomy 9pter --> p23 and Patient 3 had monosomy 9pter --> p22.3 approximately 23 combined with trisomy 3pter --> p23 approximately 24. To date, detailed reports on the gonadal status of XX 9p-females have been limited to prepubertal girls. Patients 2 and 3 are the first females reported to have distal 9p monosomy and a normal puberty.

Genitourinary phenotype in XX patients with distal 9p monosomy

Although testicular development has been shown to be variably impaired in XY patients with distal 9p monosomy, ovarian and other genitourinary phenotype has poorly been studied in XX patients monosomic for the distal 9p region. Thus, we studied a 13-month-old infant with 46,XX,der(9)t(9;10)(p23;p13) (case 1) and an 11-year-old girl with 46,XX,der(9)t(9;16)(p23;q22) (case 2). Case 1 had primary hypogonadism (basal serum follicle stimulating hormone [FSH], 40.0 mIU/mL; leteinizing hormone [LH], 1.2 mIU/mL; estradiol [E2], <10 pg/mL), whereas case 2 had age-appropriate pubertal development (breast, Tanner stage 4; pubic hair, Tanner stage 3; menarche 11.7 years of age) and hormone values (FSH, 7.3 mIU/mL; LH, 6.7 mIU/mL; E2, 47 pg/mL). In addition, case 1 had hypoplastic labia majora, short distance between the vaginal orifice and the anus, and five renal cysts, and case 2 had anal atresia, short distance between the vaginal orifice and the anus, bilateral hydronephrosis of grade 3 with probable ureteropelvic junction stenosis, and renal dysfunction (serum creatinine, 1.52 mg/dL; urea nitrogen, 34.5mg/dL). Fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis for five regions and microsatellite analysis for 10 loci on 9p confirmed hemizygosity for the distal 9p region with the breakpoints between IFNA and D9S285 in case 1 and between D9S168 and D9S286 in case 2. The results, in conjunction with the previous data in XX patients with molecularly defined distal 9p monosomy, are consistent with the presence of a gene(s) involved in the development of indifferent gonad or subsequent ovarian differentiation in a approximately 11 Mb region distal to D9S168. In addition, it is possible that a gene(s) for anoperineal and renal development also maps distal to D9S168 and that for external genital development maps distal to D9S285 at the position approximately 16 Mb from the 9p telomere.

Gonadoblastoma in a patient with del(9)(p22) and sex reversal: report of a case and review of the literature

Studies of distinct clinical prototypes have significantly contributed to our understanding of evolutionary abnormalities and their association with neoplasia. We describe a phenotypic female, aged 20 years at report, who was examined as an infant for developmental retardation. The clinical characteristics of the 9p- syndrome were present and the external genitalia were those of a normal female. The karyotype was 46XY,del(9)(p22). The parental karyotypes were normal. No SRY deletion or mutation was detected. Sonography showed the presence of a uterus. Basal luteinizing hormone values were normal; follicle stimulating hormone values were high (40 IU/L). Stimulation with human chorionic gonadotropin did not produce any rise in testosterone. The gonads were removed and histologic analysis disclosed dysgenetic gonads with gonadoblastoma in situ. This case constitutes the fourth case of gonadoblastoma developing in an individual with 9p- syndrome and sex reversal. This and analogous prototypes point to a locus (or loci) on the short arm of chromosome 9, which either constitutes a nonspecific suppressor gene or a gonadoblastoma suppressor gene. An alternative hypothesis would be that a gonad not normally differentiated is more prone to gonadoblastoma development without any specific gene involvement.

Sex-determining gene(s) on distal 9p: clinical and molecular studies in six cases

We report on clinical and molecular findings in five karyotypic males (cases 1-5) and one karyotypic female (case 6) with distal 9p monosomy. Cases 1-3 and 6 had female external genitalia, case 4 showed ambiguous external genitalia, and case 5 exhibited male external genitalia with left cryptorchidism and right intrascrotal testis. Gonadal explorations at gonadectomy in cases 3 and 4 revealed that case 3 had left streak gonad and right agonadism, and case 4 had bilateral hypoplastic testes. Endocrine studies in cases 1-4 and 6 showed that cases 1, 3, and 6 had definite primary hypogonadism, with basal FSH levels of 54, 39, and 41 IU/L, respectively, whereas case 2 with severe malnutrition was unremarkable for the baseline values, and case 4 had fairly good testicular function. Fluorescence in situ hybridization and microsatellite analyses demonstrated that all cases had hemizygosity of the 9p sex-determining region distal to D9S1779, with loss of the candidate sex-determining genes DMRT1 and DMRT2 from the abnormal chromosome 9. Sequence analysis in cases 1-4 and 6 showed that they had normal sequences of each exon of DMRT1 and the DM domain of DMRT2 on the normal chromosome 9, and that cases 1-4 had normal SRY sequence. The results provide further support for the presence of a sex-determining gene(s) on distal 9p and favor the possibility of DMRT1 and/or DMRT2 being the sex-determining gene(s). Furthermore, as hemizygosity of the 9p sex-determining region was associated with a wide spectrum of gonadogenesis from agonadism to testis formation in karyotypic males and with primary hypogonadism regardless of karyotypic sex, it is inferred that haploinsufficiency of the 9p sex-determining gene(s) primarily hinders the formation of indifferent gonad, leading to various degrees of defective testis formation in karyotypic males and impaired ovary formation in karyotypic females.