Hybrid minimally invasive surgery--a bridge between laparoscopic and translumenal surgery

A New Era of Minimally Invasive Surgery: Progress and Development of Major Technical Innovations in General Surgery Over the Last Decade

Minimally invasive surgery (MIS) continues to play an important role in general surgery as an alternative to traditional open surgery as well as traditional laparoscopic techniques. Since the 1980s, technological advancement and innovation have seen surgical techniques in MIS rapidly grow as it is viewed as more desirable. MIS, which includes natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) and single-incision laparoscopic surgery (SILS), is less invasive and has better cosmetic results. The technological growth and adoption of NOTES and SILS by clinicians in the last decade has however not been uniform. We look at the differences in new developments and advancement in the different techniques in the last 10 years. We also aim to explain these differences as well as the implications in general surgery for the future.

Hybrid surgery for early gastric cancer

Endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD) is the most suitable treatment option in terms of minimally invasive treatment for potential node-negative early gastric cancers (EGCs). Furthermore, making the resection area of the primary lesion as small as possible is ideal for the patient's quality of life, even for potential node-positive EGC. An endoluminal approach is a reasonable option with which to minimize stomach resection area, because this procedure can be accurately demarcated from the inside. From this point of view, endoscopic full-thickness resection (EFTR) may be optimal, while laparoscopic assistance would be more desirable to create a more secure procedure. However, hybrid EFTR for EGCs has two limitations, which must be solved. First, concerns regarding iatrogenic tumor seeding via transluminal communication between the inside and outside of the tract exist. The second limitation relates to the determination of lymphadenectomy. Conventional lymphadenectomy, which involves the removal of the majority of feeding arteries, can lead to necrosis of the remaining gastric wall. Therefore, the resection area of lymphadenectomy should also be carefully determined. To address these two problems, a non-exposed hybrid EFTR combined with sentinel node navigation surgery (SNNS) would be the most ideal method of minimally invasive surgery for EGCs.

Transvaginal route for kidney extraction in laparoscopic donor nephrectomy

Background and Objectives:

The aim of this retrospective study was to compare conventional laparoscopic living-donor nephrectomy with transvaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery–assisted living-donor nephrectomy in terms of feasibility and reproducibility.

Methods:

A total of 115 consecutive female patients who underwent laparoscopic living-donor nephrectomy (n = 70) or transvaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery–assisted living-donor nephrectomy (n = 45) were included and compared in terms of operative characteristics, as well as donor and recipient outcomes.

Results:

No significant difference was observed between the laparoscopic living-donor nephrectomy and transvaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery–assisted living-donor nephrectomy groups in terms of mean duration of warm and cold ischemia, operation time, length of hospital stay, arterial anastomoses, visual analog scale pain scores, serum creatinine levels, and receiver outcomes, whereas a significantly higher number of venous anastomoses was noted in the laparoscopic living-donor nephrectomy group than in the transvaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery–assisted living-donor nephrectomy group (P = .029).

Conclusions:

Transvaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery–assisted living-donor nephrectomy seems to be a feasible and reproducible alternative to conventional laparoscopic living-donor nephrectomy in female donors provided the viability of the vagina as an organ retrieval route.

Toward scar-free surgery: an analysis of the increasing complexity from laparoscopic surgery to NOTES

BACKGROUND

NOTES is an emerging technique for performing surgical procedures, such as cholecystectomy. Debate about its real benefit over the traditional laparoscopic technique is on-going. There have been several clinical studies comparing NOTES to conventional laparoscopic surgery. However, no work has been done to compare these techniques from a Human Factors perspective. This study presents a systematic analysis describing and comparing different existing NOTES methods to laparoscopic cholecystectomy.

METHODS

Videos of endoscopic/laparoscopic views from fifteen live cholecystectomies were analyzed to conduct a detailed task analysis of the NOTES technique. A hierarchical task analysis of laparoscopic cholecystectomy and several hybrid transvaginal NOTES cholecystectomies was performed and validated by expert surgeons. To identify similarities and differences between these techniques, their hierarchical decomposition trees were compared. Finally, a timeline analysis was conducted to compare the steps and substeps.

RESULTS

At least three variations of the NOTES technique were used for cholecystectomy. Differences between the observed techniques at the substep level of hierarchy and on the instruments being used were found. The timeline analysis showed an increase in time to perform some surgical steps and substeps in NOTES compared to laparoscopic cholecystectomy.

CONCLUSION

As pure NOTES is extremely difficult given the current state of development in instrumentation design, most surgeons utilize different hybrid methods-combination of endoscopic and laparoscopic instruments/optics. Results of our hierarchical task analysis yielded an identification of three different hybrid methods to perform cholecystectomy with significant variability among them. The varying degrees to which laparoscopic instruments are utilized to assist in NOTES methods appear to introduce different technical issues and additional tasks leading to an increase in the surgical time. The NOTES continuum of invasiveness is proposed here as a classification scheme for these methods, which was used to construct a clear roadmap for training and technology development.

Recent advances of natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery in urological surgery

Natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery designates a surgical procedure that utilizes one or more patent natural orifices of the body with the intention to puncture a hollow viscera in order to enter the abdominal cavity. First carried out at the beginning of the 2000s in experimental models, it can be considered the natural evolution of laparoscopy towards the ideal of scarless surgery, as the avoidance of a large abdominal scar is associated with better cosmetic results and better recovery. However, the technology currently available does not allow the performance of complete pure natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery procedures. The surgical tools used are not specially designed for this approach, so difficulties in retracting organs, bleeding control and clashing of instruments are the main obstacle surgeons face. For this reason, the current available technique is the so-called hybrid approach, where a natural orifice approach is combined with some abdominal trocars, using the natural orifice as the exit door for the specimen removal. As not many comparative studies have been published evaluating the advantages of natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery in front of traditional laparoscopic surgery, a review of the history of natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery, and an assessment of the available evidence of this technique regarding renal and urological pelvic surgery are performed in this article.

Feasibility and safety of functional cholecystectomy by pure NOTES: a pilot animal study

BACKGROUND

NOTES cholecystectomy has become one of the hottest areas of research. But most of the cases need the assistance of the laparoscope. This study is conducted to evaluate the feasibility and safety of a newly proposed operative method-functional cholecystectomy by pure NOTES.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The functional cholecystectomy was performed on eight female miniature pigs. An incision was made on the vaginal wall, and an endoscope was inserted into the peritoneal cavity to create a pneumoperitoneum to expose the intra-abdominal viscera, gallbladder, and cystic duct. The cystic duct was isolated and closed with a clip. Then, an injection needle was inserted into the gallbladder to suck up the bile. After the gallbladder was washed with saline, an incision was made on the wall of the gallbladder, and the tip of the endoscope was inserted into the gallbladder cavity. After the endoscope was withdrawn, the gallbladder incision was closed with clips in four pigs and was suspended in the other four pigs. The vaginal incision was closed with clips. All the animals were closely monitored and euthanized 28 days after the procedure. Necropsy was performed.

RESULTS

The functional cholecystectomy was successfully completed in all eight pigs. No severe intraoperative complications occurred. The animals recovered well postoperatively. At necropsy, no macroscopic signs of intraperitoneal infection or bile leakage in the peritoneal cavity were observed, and the clips were still present on the cystic duct in a good position in all cases. The gallbladder incision healed, with no sign of bile leakage or injury to the adjacent organs.

CONCLUSIONS

We successfully performed the functional cholecystectomy by transvaginal approach on pigs, which appears to be feasible, safe, and convenient. Functional cholecystectomy provides a new fitting path to pure NOTES.

Natural orifice transluminal endoscopy surgery: A review

Minimally invasive surgery started spreading worldwide in 1987, when the first laparoscopic cholecystectomy was performed. Meanwhile, improvement of endoscopic equipment and instruments allowed gastroenterologists to attempt more aggressive endoluminal interventions, even beyond the wall barrier. The first transgastric peritoneoscopy, in 2004, brought to light the concept of natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES). The idea of incisionless surgery is attractive and has become a new goal for both surgeons and other people interested in this field of investigation. The authors present a review of all developments concerning NOTES, including animal studies and human experience.

Feasibility of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery-assisted living donor nephrectomy: is kidney vaginal delivery the approach of the future?

BACKGROUND

Natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) uses natural orifices to access the abdominal cavity. We adapted NOTES to perform transvaginal NOTES-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy in living donors.

OBJECTIVE

To assess the feasibility and reproducibility of this procedure and compare it with conventional laparoscopic living donor nephrectomy (LLDN).

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

From July 2009 to October 2010, 20 women underwent transvaginal NOTES-assisted living donor nephrectomy (LDN) in our centre. We compared the prospectively collected clinical data of each donor with those of a contemporaneous matched pair of conventional LLDNs (40 donors).

SURGICAL PROCEDURE

The procedure was performed using three abdominal trocars and one trocar through the vaginal wall.

MEASUREMENTS

Variables evaluated for donors were procedure length, blood loss, warm ischaemia time (WIT), complications, hospital stay, and first-month creatinine nadir. In the transvaginal LDN group, sexual function was assessed with the Female Sexual Function Index questionnaire before and after surgery. Variables evaluated for recipients were complications, graft function, and creatinine evolution.

RESULTS AND LIMITATIONS

The procedure was completed in all cases. Operative variables were similar for both groups except for WIT, which was longer in the transvaginal LDN group (p<0.001) without consequences for graft functioning. One transvaginal LDN case had postoperative bleeding requiring immediate open surgery. All transvaginal LDN donors reported unaltered sexual function after surgery and satisfaction with the results. All recipients had immediate urine output, and all had a functioning graft at last follow-up except for one recipient of the transvaginal LDN group who required transplantectomy. Despite promising results, randomised controlled studies with longer follow-up are warranted to further elucidate the potential of this novel technique.

CONCLUSIONS

Transvaginal NOTES-assisted LDN appears to be a feasible and reproducible surgical technique. The WIT was longer in the transvaginal group, and there was no effect on graft function after the short follow-up.

Polymer Rigidity Control for Endoscopic Shaft-Guide ‘Plastolock’ — A Feasibility Study

Flexible endoscopes are used for diagnostic and therapeutic interventions in the human body for their ability to be advanced through tortuous trajectories. However, this very same property causes difficulties as well. For example, during surgery, a rigid shaft would be more beneficial since it provides more stability and it allows for better surgical accuracy. In order to keep the flexibility and to obtain the rigidity when needed, a shaft-guide with controllable rigidity could be used. In this article, we introduce the plastolock shaft-guide concept, which uses thermoplastics that are reversibly switched from rigid to compliant by changing their temperatures from 5°C to 43°C. These materials are used to make a shaft that can be rendered flexible to follow the flexible endoscope and rigid to guide it. To find polymers that are suitable for the plastolock concept, an extensive database and internet search was performed. The results suggest that many suitable materials are available or can be custom synthesized to meet the requirements. The thermoplastic polymer Purasorb® PLC 7015 was obtained and a dynamic mechanical analysis showed that it is suitable for the plastolock concept. A simple production test indicated that this material is suitable for prototyping by molding. Overall, the results in this article show that the plastolock concept can offer simple, scalable solutions for medical situations that desire stiffness at one instance and flexibility at another.

Durability of the self-approximating translumenal access technique (STAT) for potential use in natural orifice translumenal surgery (NOTES)

BACKGROUND

The self-approximating translumenal access technique (STAT) has been shown to provide a safe and reliable means of abdominal access for natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES). However, the feasibility of using STAT for translumenal organ resection is unknown. This study aimed to evaluate the technical performance of organ resection using STAT, the integrity of the STAT gastric tunnel after organ resection, and the postoperative morbidity of organ resection using STAT.

METHODS

In this study, 14 domestic swine underwent transgastric organ resection (7 cholecystectomies, 7 uterine horn resections) followed by sequential removal of two different sizes of standardized specimens. Evaluation of operative injury to the tunnel and difficulty of specimen extraction was performed. After 2 weeks of observation, necropsy was performed for evaluation and documentation of gross findings.

RESULTS

The mean operating room time (intubation recovery) was 4.1 h. A tunnel with a mean length of 12 cm and a mean width of 4 cm was created. The tunnel remained fully intact in 14 of 14 animals after organ resection, in 13 of 13 animals after balloon extraction, and in 12 of 14 animals after rigid specimen extraction (1 clinically significant tear occurred). Postoperatively, all the animals gained weight appropriately. Necropsy findings included adhesions (n = 4), bile leak (n = 2), minor lap-port abscess (n = 1), and ventral hernia (n = 1).

CONCLUSIONS

Although this study was a limited, prospective, animal survival study without a control arm, it again indicates that STAT allows safe abdominal access, a reliable means of closure, and directed endoscope positioning. Although one significant mucosal tear did occur, this study suggests STAT will tolerate the mechanical forces of peroral transgastric procedures provided the organ resected is small to moderate in size (<8 × 3 cm).

Transgastric organ resection solely with the prototype R-scope and the self-approximating transluminal access technique

BACKGROUND

The self-approximating transluminal access technique (STAT) has been demonstrated to provide safe transluminal access and in-line endoscope positioning to target abdominal organs during natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES). To date, organ resection with NOTES has typically required percutaneous assistance. We hypothesized that the in-line positioning and partial stability provided by STAT would allow single-access NOTES procedures if a multiarticulated endoscope could be used.

OBJECTIVE

Assessment of single-site NOTES, using STAT and a prototype, multi-articulated endoscope.

DESIGN

Animal survival study.

SETTING

Penn State Hershey Medical Center Research Laboratories.

INTERVENTIONS

Thirteen pigs underwent NOTES using a prototype endoscope with 2 articulated channels, a grasping forceps, and an insulated-tip needle-knife. The gallbladder was dissected using a fundus down technique, and hemoclips and a detachable loop were placed on the cystic duct and artery before removal. After a 2- to 3-week observation period, animals were euthanized and necropsy performed.

RESULTS

All target organs were successfully resected without laparoscopic assistance. Significant complications were 2 perforations (1 caused by a prototype duodenal occlusion device and 1 caused by enterotomy during cholecystectomy) and 1 entrapment of the small bowel with an endoloop. Postoperatively, all animals gained weight appropriately with 1 killed on postoperative day 12 because of lethargy (cystic duct leak/biloma).

LIMITATIONS

This is a limited animal survival study without control arm.

CONCLUSIONS

The combination of the R-scope and STAT does allow effective, single-site NOTES procedures; however, although the R-scope provides improved tissue manipulation and visibility, the complications incurred here suggest that further improvements in devices and technique will be required for safe and effective single-site NOTES procedures.

Endoscopic transgastric pure NOTES cholecystectomy with naso-gallbladder drainage tube placement and injection of a hyaluronic acid mixture (with Video)

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic transgastric pure natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) cholecystectomy is a difficult procedure, and most human female cases are performed as hybrid NOTES, using a transvaginal route. We tried a transgastric pure NOTES procedure without laparoscopic procedure in an animal study after placing an endoscopic naso-gallbladder drainage (ENGBD) tube and injecting a hyaluronic acid (HA) mixture.

METHODS

We performed the method in four pigs, using a standard single-channel endoscope. The ENGBD tube was placed first and the HA mixture was injected between the gallbladder (GB) serosa and liver bed.

RESULTS

We determined the gastrotomy site using an ENGBD tube, which made the GB approach easy under fluoroscopic guidance. The scope was not retroflexed, but was rotated at the stomach fornix. The connecting tissues between the GB serosa and liver bed expanded following the injection of the HA mixture, facilitating GB removal with a Hook knife. The GB wall, liver, and vessels were observed clearly during the procedure, and there were no incorrect cuts.

CONCLUSION

We successfully performed a transgastric pure NOTES cholecystectomy in pigs. An ENGBD tube was useful as a guide to the GB, and for recognizing the cystic duct, and injecting the HA mixture facilitated the GB dissection.

Natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery gastrotomy closure with an over-the-endoscope clip: a randomized, controlled porcine study (with videos)

BACKGROUND

Secure endoscopic closure of transgastric natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) access is of paramount importance. The over-the-scope clip (OTSC) system has previously been shown to be effective for NOTES gastrotomy closure.

OBJECTIVE

To compare OTSC gastrotomy closure with surgical closure.

DESIGN

Randomized, controlled animal study.

SETTING

Animal facility laboratory.

ANIMALS

Thirty-six female domestic pigs.

INTERVENTIONS

Gastrotomies were created by using a needle-knife and an 18-mm balloon. The animals were subsequently randomized to either open surgical repair with interrupted sutures or endoscopic repair with 12-mm OTSCs. In addition, pressurized leak tests were performed in ex vivo specimens of 18-mm scalpel incisions closed with suture (n = 14) and of intact stomachs (n = 10).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

The mean time for endoscopic closure was 9.8 minutes (range 3-22, SD 5.5). No complications occurred during either type of gastrotomy closure. At necropsy, examination of all OTSC and surgical closures demonstrated complete sealing of gastrotomy sites without evidence of injury to adjacent organs. Pressurized leak tests showed a mean burst pressure of 83 mm Hg (range 30-140, SD 27) for OTSC closures and 67 mm Hg (range 30-130, SD 27.7) for surgical sutures. Ex vivo hand-sewn sutures of 18-mm gastrotomies (n = 14) exhibited a mean burst pressure of 65 mm Hg (range 20-140, SD 31) and intact ex vivo stomachs (n = 10) had a mean burst pressure of 126 mm Hg (range 90-170, SD 28). The burst pressure of ex vivo intact stomachs was significantly higher compared with OTSC closures (P < .01), in vivo surgical closures (P < .01), and ex vivo hand-sewn closures (P < .01). There was a trend toward higher burst pressures in the OTSC closures compared with surgical closures (P = .063) and ex vivo hand-sewn closures (P = .094). In vivo surgical closures demonstrated similar burst pressures compared with ex vivo hand-sewn closures (P = .848).

LIMITATIONS

Nonsurvival setting.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic closure by using the OTSC system is comparable to surgical closure in a nonsurvival porcine model. This technique is easy to perform and is suitable for NOTES gastrotomy closure.

Single-port access laparoscopic radical left colectomy in humans

BACKGROUND

Transumbilical single-port access (SPA) surgery is a rapidly evolving field that combines in part the cosmetic advantage of natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) with the ability to perform the operation with standard laparoscopic instruments. We report our experience with the first transumbilical single-port access radical left colectomy conforming to surgical oncologic principle and minimally invasive colectomy technique.

METHODS

Umbilical single-port access (embryonic natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery) left colectomy was performed in a patient with sigmoid colon adenocarcinoma in situ. During the same procedure, a single-port access cholecystectomy was performed for chronic cholecystitis.

RESULTS

Transumbilical single-port access radical left colectomy was feasible with conventional laparoscopic instruments. A 39-cm pathologic specimen with sufficient surgical margins and lymph nodes (34) was resected. Final diagnosis revealed an adenocarcinoma in situ. Operative time for left colectomy and cholecystectomy was 213 minutes. No intraoperative or postoperative complications were recorded.

CONCLUSION

Single-port access radical left colectomy is feasible when performed by experienced laparoscopic surgeons. Carcinologic surgical principles can be respected using this colectomy technique. Single-port access left colectomy may have a clinical advantage over natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery in offering the safety of laparoscopic colectomy. It has yet to be determined whether or not this approach would offer patient benefits, except in cosmesis, compared with standard laparoscopic left colectomy.

Transvaginal cholecystectomy with endoscopic submucosal dissection instruments and single-channel endoscope: a survival study in porcine model

BACKGROUND

Natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery has received much attention in recent years. Instead of using prototype devices, we explored the feasibility and practicability of using readily available off-the-shelf devices to perform Natural Orifice Transluminal Endoscopic Surgery in an animal model.

METHODS

Twenty pigs underwent transvaginal cholecystectomy, 16 of which were used for surviving study after the procedure. A single-channel endoscope and standard instruments for endoscopic submucosal dissection (hook knife and Insulated Tip knife) were used for cholecystectomy. A single 5-mm laparoscopic port was inserted for gallbladder retraction.

RESULTS

Completion of the procedure was achieved in all 20 pigs. In 16 pigs, which were used for surviving study after surgery, 15 survived. Death of 1 pig was due to leakage of urine from the colpotomy and urogenital sinus. Technical success was achieved in the access, dissection, and retrieval of specimen in all the animals.

CONCLUSIONS

A hybrid approach with single-channel endoscope together with endoscopic submucosal dissection instruments for transvaginal cholecystectomy was shown to be safe and feasible in this pig model and this serves as a good training model before application of this technique in human. A distinct pattern of complications was identified and needed to be addressed.

Feasibility of transvaginal NOTES-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy

BACKGROUND

Recently, the feasibility of a transvaginal hybrid natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) nephrectomy was demonstrated in a 23-yr-old woman with a nonfunctional atrophic kidney.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the feasibility and reproducibility of transvaginal NOTES-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy in female patients with and without renal cancer.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

Between March 2008 and June 2009, 14 female patients were submitted to transvaginal NOTES-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy for T1-T3a N0M0 renal cancer (n=10), lithiasis (n=2), or renal atrophy (n=2) at the Hospital Clinic of Barcelona, Spain.

SURGICAL PROCEDURE

Under general anaesthesia, female patients underwent laparoscopic nephrectomy by transvaginal NOTES using a deflectable camera by vaginal access and two additional 5- and 10-mm trocars in the abdomen. The renal artery and vein were dissected and taken separately between clips. The dissected kidney was removed via the vagina after enlarging the vaginal trocar incision.

MEASUREMENTS

All data referring to patient demographics, surgery, pathology, and perioperative outcomes were recorded.

RESULTS AND LIMITATIONS

The procedure was completed in all patients. The mean age of the women was 59.1 yr. The mean operative time was 132.9 min and the mean estimated blood loss was 111.2 ml. None of the patients required a blood transfusion and the use of analgesics was low. The mean hospital stay was 4 d. In one case, a major complication (a colon injury) occurred. The patient underwent surgery and a temporary colostomy was performed. The patient has already undergone reconstruction.

CONCLUSIONS

Transvaginal NOTES-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy is feasible and reproducible and may be an alternative technique for treatment of women with renal cancer. Proper selection of patients is warranted for success of this new approach. However, longer follow-up in an increasing number of patients is needed to establish its role in the treatment of renal cancer.

NOTES-assisted transvaginal splenectomy: the next step in the minimally invasive approach to the spleen

HYPOTHESIS

Natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) has marked yet another step forward in less-invasive surgical procedures. Access to solid organs located deep in the left hypochondrium can be difficult using this technique but the transvaginal approach with the patient positioned in full lateral decubitus may be an option.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We present the case of a 60-year-old woman with a symptomatic splenic polycystic tumor. The procedure was carried out by a multidisciplinary team using a standard flexible videogastroscope and endoscopic instruments. Transvaginal visualization of the spleen and standard dissection of attachments were feasible, and splenectomy was completed using transvaginal stapling of the splenic hilum. The organ was extracted transvaginally.

RESULTS

The postoperative course was uneventful. The patient had minimal postoperative pain and minimal scars, and was discharged on the second postoperative day.

CONCLUSIONS

Transvaginal access can be safely used for operative visualization, hilum transection, and spleen removal with conventional instrumentation, reducing parietal wall trauma to a minimum. The clinical, esthetic, and functional advantages require further analysis.

Status of access and closure techniques for NOTES

Natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) is a novel surgical concept that may provide a multitasking platform for minimally invasive surgery in the 21st century. With NOTES, natural hollow organs are used to gain access to body cavities via the mouth, anus, vagina, and urethra, thereby eliminating skin incisions. Access to the body cavity through the entry portal for the NOTES procedure and closure of the portal after surgery are important treatment considerations. In this review, access and closure techniques for NOTES-related procedures are discussed. Technical descriptions for access are also described. Closure techniques using experimental and commercially available devices are also reviewed. Based on the experimental and early clinical experiences to date, the future of NOTES appears quite promising. Nonetheless, ongoing fundamental research is necessary to determine the safety and benefit of these procedures. While technical challenges are currently present, the issues are being resolved with the development of optimal instrumentation and techniques. We believe that once standardized safe and reliable access and closure techniques are established, a major shift in minimally invasive surgery will likely be inevitable.

[Training design and improvement of technical skills in the transvaginal cholecystectomy (NOTES)]

INTRODUCTION

The current surgical scenario of the surgery through natural orifices or <<no-scar surgery>> requires acquiring new technical skills by the surgeon. We introduce the initial experience of the Minimally Invasive Surgery Centre Jesús Usón (MISCJU) in the design and setting-up of a surgical training programme using the the natural orifices approach for the acquisition of surgical skills and abilities, based on the preliminary trials in simulators and a pig model.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

After initial training, using a laparoscopic pelvic-trainer, 7 female pigs, with weights between 35-40 kg, were operated on. The transvaginal approach was completed using a one-channel gastroscope in all the animals. After accessing the abdomen, the abdominal cavity was explored, and the surgery was concluded with the endoscopic cholecystectomy.

RESULTS

Endoscopic cholecystectomy was successfully completed in 6 cases. In one of the animals, the procedure was stopped because of technical problems regarding the endoscope leaning to one end. The average surgical time was 107.14 min (range, 80-150 min). The transvaginal approach enabled the abdominal to be explored and the dissection, ligature and section of the cystic duct and the cystic artery. After cholecystectomy, the gallbladder was extracted through the vagina. After the procedure necropsy did not reveal intra-abdominal lesions or intraoperative complications.

CONCLUSIONS

The pure transvaginal cholecystectomy is a feasible and reproducible procedure in the animal model. A systematized training model, which includes physiopathology knowledge as well as technical knowledge, in order to translate these procedures to the clinical practice in a safe way, is needed.

[Non-randomised, comparative, prospective study of transvaginal endoscopic cholecystectomy versus transparietal laparoscopic cholecystectomy]

INTRODUCTION

We present a non-randomised comparative study of two patients series followed up prospectively, in which convention laparoscopic cholecystectomy is compared with transvaginal cholecystectomy, a hybrid transluminal endoscopic procedure, with the objective of assessing the clinical safety of the procedures and its efficacy in the resolution of cholelithiasis.

PATIENTS AND METHOD

A non-randomised prospective clinical series of 40 female patients, operated on for cholelithiasis using endoscopic surgery, 20 with a conventional laparoscopic approach and 20 using a transvaginal endoscopic approach. Surgical wound infection, urinary infection, evisceration, eventration, mortality and other complications.

RESULTS

Scheduled operations were performed on the 40 patients as indicated. There were no complications during the operations. There was no mortality associated with the procedures and there was only one post-surgical complication, a urinary tract infection in one patient operated on by the transvaginal approach. The mean follow up was the same in both groups (9 months). The mean hospital stay was less than 0.8 days in both groups. The duration of the surgery was longer in the transvaginal approach group, with a mean of 69.5 min, compared to 46.2 min in the laparoscopy group.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the cosmetic benefit is obvious, no differences were found as regards parietal problems in this series. The duration of the transvaginal surgery is higher than that of the transparietal, but the times of both are acceptable. In this study, the non-inferiority in the safety and efficacy of the transvaginal approach is able to be assessed.

Single-port endoscopic cholecystectomy: a bridge between laparoscopic and translumenal endoscopic surgery

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The intentional puncture of the normal viscera is likely the most important issue limiting the widespread use of natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES). We developed a new procedure for cholecystectomy using a flexible endoscope via a single port placed in the abdominal wall without visceral puncture (single-port endoscopic cholecystectomy; SPEC) as a bridge between laparoscopic surgery and NOTES. This study aimed to evaluate the technical feasibility of SPEC.

METHODS

Five pigs were subjected to SPEC. An endoscope was inserted through a 12-mm port placed in the right upper abdomen. After grasping and retracting the gallbladder using a 2-mm retractor that was directly introduced into the peritoneal cavity, gallbladder excision with ligation of the cystic artery and duct using endoclips was carried out.

RESULTS

A complete gallbladder excision was carried out easily and safely in all cases. No major adverse events occurred. The mean operating time was 67 min (range 52-84 min).

CONCLUSIONS

SPEC is a technically feasible procedure. It is simpler, easier, and safer than NOTES cholecystectomy. SPEC could be a less invasive alternative to the conventional four-port laparoscopic cholecystectomy.

Transgastric cholecystectomy using a prototype endoscope with 2 deflecting working channels (with video)

BACKGROUND

Transgastric cholecystectomy has been shown to be feasible in animal models and human case reports but cumbersome with current available instrumentation.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate a prototype endoscope with 2 working channels with deflectors at the distal tip for performance of transgastric cholecystectomy.

DESIGN

Animal study, nonsurvival and survival.

ANIMALS

Sixteen male pigs.

SETTING

University hospital.

INTERVENTION

Transgastric cholecystectomy in 6 nonsurvival pigs by using several different dual-channel endoscopes and 10 survival pigs by using the Olympus dual-channel endoscope with an up-down deflecting channel to the left of the objective lens and a left-right deflecting channel located below the lens. Gallbladder fundic retraction was performed with the aid of one laparoscopic grasper.

RESULTS

Cholecystectomy was successful in all survival animals. Median procedure time was 81 minutes (range 31-163 minutes), with a decrease over time. Visualization of all structures was achieved, and clipping of the cystic duct and artery was successful in all cases. Dissection of the gallbladder via the left-right channel was enhanced with retraction via the up-down deflecting channel. Nine of 10 animals survived without complications. One animal died, on postoperative day 2, secondary to peritonitis due to a leak from the gastrotomy site.

CONCLUSIONS

This endoscope, with deflecting working channels, allows transgastric cholecystectomy in pigs. The endoscope was stable enough to be used without an overtube and facilitated retraction and dissection. This endoscope is promising for use in transgastric cholecystectomy in human beings.

Endoscopic full-thickness resection with laparoscopic assistance as hybrid NOTES for gastric submucosal tumor

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Laparoscopic wedge resection using a linear stapler is widely accepted as a treatment for gastric submucosal tumor (SMT). Although this surgery is simple, it can lead to excessive normal tissue removal. To avoid the latter, we have introduced endoscopic full-thickness resection with laparoscopic assistance, known as laparoscopy-assisted endoscopic full-thickness resection (LAEFR). Herein, we present the preliminary results of LAEFR for gastric SMT patients.

METHODS

Four patients with gastric SMT underwent LAEFR. LAEFR consists of four major procedures: (1) a circumferential incision as deep as the submucosal layer around the lesion by the endoscopic submucosal dissection technique, (2) endoscopic full-thickness (from the muscle layer to the serosal layer) incision around the three-fourths or two-thirds circumference on the above-mentioned submucosal incision under laparoscopic supervision, (3) completion of the full-thickness incision laparoscopically from inside the peritoneal cavity, and (4) handsewn closure of the gastric-wall defect.

RESULTS

LAEFR was successfully carried out without any intraoperative or postoperative adverse events. Mean operating time and estimated blood loss were 201 min and 27 mL, respectively. Contrast roentgenography on postoperative day 3 showed neither gastric deformity nor disturbance of gastric emptying in all the patients.

CONCLUSIONS

LAEFR may be considered one of the so-called hybrid natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) techniques because a peroral endoscope advances into the peritoneal cavity. LAEFR enabled whole-layer excision as small as possible with an adequate margin. LAEFR is a safe and minimally invasive treatment for patients with gastric SMT, and could be a more reasonable and economical alternative to other laparoscopic procedures.

Hybrid transvaginal cholecystectomy, NOTES, and minilaparoscopy: analysis of a prospective clinical series

INTRODUCTION

Natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) makes it possible to perform intraperitoneal surgical procedures with a minimal number of access points in the abdominal wall. It is not yet possible to perform these interventions without the help of abdominal wall entryways, so these procedures are hybrids, a fusion of minilaparoscopy and transluminal endoscopic surgery. In this paper we present a prospective clinical series of 15 patients who underwent transvaginal hybrid cholecystectomy for cholelithiasis.

METHODS

This was a prospective clinical series of 15 consecutive female patients, nonrandomly chosen and without a control group, who underwent a fusion transvaginal NOTES and minilaparoscopy procedure with two entryways for cholelithiasis. One was umbilical and measured 5 mm in diameter, and the other was in the right upper quadrant and measured 3 mm in diameter.

RESULTS

The scheduled surgical intervention was performed on the 15 patients in whom it had been indicated. There were no intraoperative complications. One patient had mild hematuria that resolved in less than 12 h; there were no other complications after average follow-up of 124 days. Nine patients were discharged in 24 h, and two were discharged less than 12 h after the procedure.

DISCUSSION

Hybrid transvaginal cholecystectomy is a good surgical model for minimally invasive surgery, a combination of NOTES and minilaparoscopy. It can be performed in surgical settings where laparoscopy is practised regularly, using the instruments normally used for endoscopy and laparoscopic surgery. Owing to the reproducibility of the intervention and the ease of vaginal closure, hybrid transvaginal cholecystectomy will permit further development of NOTES in the future.

N.O.T.E.S.: the progression of a novel and emerging technique

Natural Orifice Transluminal Endoscopic Surgery (NOTES) is the latest and perhaps most significant innovation in surgery since Phillipe Mouret of France performed the first laparoscopic cholecystectomy in 1987. This new "minimum-invasive" concept that promises scar-free surgery is steadily gathering momentum. It is another milestone in our quest to eliminate surgical trauma, speed patient recovery time and decrease surgical wound-related complications. On 22 July 2005, the Natural Orifice Surgery Consortium for Assessment and Research (NOSCAR) published a white paper highlighting the barriers to NOTES development, which included the need for appropriate selection of access points, effective closure of the enterotomy site, innovative tools, stable platforms and improved endoscopic orientation. These are just some of the many issues that need to be resolved before the NOTES concept and technique could become a common feature of modern surgery. The publication of the white paper ushered in the beginning of multiple research projects using animal models to test the application of NOTES and its newly developed instruments. The success in animal models was followed by several highly selected successful human trials. National and international surgical innovation departments should now be created where medical industry personnel including inventors, designers and engineers can work together with the medical and surgical providers to address all the limitations affecting NOTES progress.

Cholecystectomy by a combined transgastric and transparietal approach using two flexible endoscopes

OBJECTIVE

This experimental study was designed to assess the technical feasibility and benefits of our novel approach for transgastric NOTES (natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery) cholecystectomy.

METHODS

Four pigs were subjected to NOTES cholecystectomy by the combined transgastric and transparietal approach using two flexible endoscopes. Under the guidance of a transparietal endoscope inserted through a trocar placed in the right upper abdomen, a gastrotomy was constructed, and a peroral endoscope was advanced into the peritoneal cavity through the gastrotomy and moved on retroflexion toward the gallbladder. Gallbladder excision with ligation of the cystic artery and duct using endoclips was performed using the peroral endoscope. After gastrotomy closure with endoclips inside the stomach, intraperitoneal lavage were carried out using the transparietal endoscope.

RESULTS

A complete gallbladder excision was carried out without major adverse events in all cases. The gastrotomies were successfully closed using endoclips (n = 3) or by the omentum-plug method (n = 1).

CONCLUSION

This approach is technically feasible and makes transgastric NOTES cholecystectomy easier and safer.

Flexible transgastric peritoneoscopy and liver biopsy: a feasibility study in human beings (with videos)

BACKGROUND

Multiple studies have demonstrated the feasibility of natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery in animal models.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the feasibility of transgastric peritoneoscopy and liver biopsy in human beings.

SETTING

Our institutional review board approved the procedures in the operating room with the patients under general anesthesia.

DESIGN AND INTERVENTIONS

During laparoscopic gastric bypass surgery a flexible endoscope was introduced into the peritoneal cavity through the gastric-wall incision. A peritoneoscopy with a liver biopsy was performed, then the flexible endoscope was withdrawn into the stomach, and gastric bypass surgery was completed laparoscopically.

PATIENTS

Three patients who were morbidly obese (mean weight 115.22 +/- 9.07 kg [254 +/- 20 lb]).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

The ability to navigate a flexible endoscope inside the peritoneal cavity, to visualize the intra-abdominal organs, and to perform a liver biopsy without laparoscopic assistance.

RESULTS

It was very easy to navigate the flexible endoscope inside the abdomen by using torque, advancement, and withdrawal of the endoscopic shaft, as well as by movement of the endoscope tip. The flexible endoscope provided an excellent view and adequate illumination of the peritoneal cavity. The orientation of the flexible endoscope inside the peritoneal cavity was technically easy, even in the retroflex position. Systematic visualization of the liver, the spleen, the omentum, and the small and large intestine was easily achieved through the flexible endoscope without laparoscopic assistance. A liver biopsy was successfully completed in all cases by obtaining adequate tissue samples for histologic examination.

LIMITATION

This was a pilot feasibility study.

CONCLUSIONS

Transgastric flexible endoscopic peritoneoscopy in human beings is technically feasible, simple, and can become a valuable tool that complements and facilitates laparoscopic interventions inside the peritoneal cavity.

Infection prevention in NOTES

Prevention of infection during natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) was identified as one of the most important challenges for translumenal surgery. Does infection prevention during NOTES warrant such attention? This article summarizes the accumulated data about septic complications during translumenal surgery.

[Natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery]

In Natural Orifice Transluminal Endoscopic Surgery (NOTES) a flexible endoscope is passed through a natural orifice of the body and intra-abdominal procedures can be performed through a transvisceral (transgastric, -colonic, -vaginal or -vesical) incision. Principally, this state-of-the-art technology decreases invasiveness and postoperative pain, prevents postoperative hernia formation and improves cosmetic results. However, numerous questions regarding the technique are unanswered yet. Further research is necessary to extend the armamentarium of minimally invasive surgery. This article reviews the current state of experimental results and clinical approaches of NOTES.