Assessment of muscle activity and fatigue during laparoscopic surgery

Assessing posture and fatigue during neonatal positive pressure ventilation

Healthcare professionals (HCPs) are often required to complete their work under suboptimal ergonomic conditions in critical situations, inducing fatigue and musculoskeletal injury risk. These risks may vary depending on equipment and technique choices, which could require differing postures. Neonatal positive pressure ventilation (PPV) is administered to newborns who require resuscitation by holding a face mask over the nose and mouth and forcing air into the lungs with a device, such as a T-piece or a self-inflating bag (SIB). This study assessed if varying PPV device type and mask hold strategies impacted fatigue and musculoskeletal injury risk. Results show that using a SIB caused more frequent forearm extensor muscle fatigue (47.61% of trials) compared to the T-piece (14.29% of trials) and increased shoulder musculoskeletal injury risk (mean shoulder elevation angles: 45.58°(SIB) vs. 27.29°(T-piece)). When these devices are clinically comparable, the T-piece should be implemented for improved ergonomic outcomes.

Strain on the surgeon: a systematic review of the methods of measuring strain in abdominal and thoracic surgery

INTRODUCTION

Surgery can be arduous to the operating surgeon - both in terms of cognitive and physical strain. Ergonomic strain has been recognised to drive absenteeism, reduce career longevity and cause injuries. This systematic review aims to 1. Outline the nature of ergonomic strain in the context of abdominal and thoracic surgery, regardless of surgical approach 2. Identify the qualitative and quantitative measures of surgical strain.

METHODS

A systematic review was conducted using Pubmed, MEDLINE and Ovid EMBASE databases (date range: 1990 to Sep 2024). Of the initial 1288 articles identified, a final 71 studies were included in this review (quantitative measures = 36, qualitative measures = 49, of which 14 studies overlapped with the papers reviewed in the quantitative measures section).

RESULTS

The quantitative measures used to measure ergonomic strain included electromyography, electrocardiography, gravimetric position sensors, skin conductance and inertial measurement units. Laparoscopic surgery caused less physical strain than open surgery, however more cognitive strain during the learning curve. Robotic surgery yielded conflicting data in terms of muscle activation when compared to laparoscopic surgery however reported less cognitive and cardiovascular strain. The qualitative measures of strain included a range of self-reported questionnaires, demonstrating important gender differences and scores that typically correlated with objective physical strain.

DISCUSSION

The studies show wide variation in measuring ergonomic strain. Avenues for further research include measuring the impact of learning curves, patient factors on ergonomic strain and the impact of gender.

Port Site Placement and Outcomes for Surgical Obesity and Metabolic Surgeries (PSPOSO) Checklist: A New Reporting Checklist Based on Evidential Assessment of the Number of Trocars and Positions

Since the early 1980s, efforts to standardize ergonomic practices in laparoscopic surgeries have aimed to improve procedural efficiency and reduce complications, but clinical validation remains limited. In metabolic and bariatric surgeries (MBS), innovations in trocar site placements, driven by the popularity of laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy (LSG), have advanced surgical techniques. However, practices often vary based on individual surgeon preferences rather than standardized evidence-based criteria. This study introduces the Port Site Placement and Outcomes for Surgical Obesity and Metabolic Surgeries (PSPOSO) checklist, aiming to standardize port placements and improve reporting consistency. A systematic review and meta-analysis of LSG studies were conducted following PRISMA guidelines. Data were extracted from 34 studies involving 7173 cases. Key variables included port configurations, manipulation angles, and outcomes such as operative time and excess weight loss percentage (EWL%). Innovative methods were used to estimate manipulation and azimuth angles from available intraoperative images. Statistical analyses and meta-regression were performed to identify associations between port configurations and surgical outcomes. Findings revealed substantial variability in port placements, with no significant effect of manipulation angles or port numbers on operative time or EWL% at 6, 12, and 24 months (p-values > 0.05). High residual heterogeneity suggests that factors beyond manipulation angles and port counts contribute to outcome variability. The PSPOSO checklist provides a framework for standardizing port placement and ergonomic parameters in MBS, enhancing reproducibility and safety. Future studies should validate the checklist across diverse clinical settings to refine surgical approaches and improve patient outcomes. PROSPERO: CRD42024598674.

Application and exploration of surgical assistive arms in thoracoscopic surgery: a single-center retrospective study

BACKGROUND

The detection of pulmonary nodules is increasing every year, as well as the need for surgical treatment in more patients, which places a significant burden on surgeons. Surgeon fatigue not only increases surgical risk, but also poses a health hazard to the surgeons. How to reduce surgeon fatigue is an important issue that needs to be addressed urgently.

METHODS

We collected 917 patients who underwent thoracoscopic surgery between 2022 and 2023. They were categorized into thoracoscopy group, mechanical arm group and pneumatic arm group according to the procedure. Data related to the perioperative period (operative time, blood loss, serious adverse events, etc.) of different patients were retrospectively analyzed. The related scale of fatigue index was also designed to quantify and analyze the fatigue index of doctors.

RESULTS

There were 316, 302 and 299 patients in the thoracoscopic, mechanical and pneumatic arm groups, respectively. There was no statistically significant difference in operative time, bleeding, mean length of hospital stay, and serious adverse events among the three groups. Although there was no significant difference in overall surgical fatigue scores among the three groups, the use of robotic and pneumatic arms significantly reduced the fatigue of surgeons and assistants in complicated surgeries.

CONCLUSION

Compared to traditional thoracoscopic surgery, the application of surgical assistance robotic arm does not increase perioperative risk. Moreover, in longer thoracoscopic procedures, it significantly reduces fatigue for both the surgeons and their assistants. However, current robotic arms still have certain limitations and require continuous improvements to better meet clinical demands.

Effect of whole-day work on surgical performance during simulated laparoscopic surgery: study protocol for a controlled cross over laboratory trial

Introduction

Laparoscopy has become a fundamental aspect of surgery, presenting new challenges such as fatigue, encompassing both muscular and cognitive components. Given its potential to affect surgical precision and create difficulties for the surgeon, it is crucial to study the mechanisms of fatigue for patient safety and the well-being of surgeons. This study aims to demonstrate the influence of general fatigue on surgeons' performance, incorporating assessments of movement quality through balance, kinematics, and muscle activation, as well as perceived workload. Additionally, the study seeks to evaluate how surgeons' experience may affect fatigue outcomes.

Methods and analysis

A controlled cross-over laboratory trial involving 29 residents and surgeons from the obstetrics and gynecology department of Nantes University Hospital is underway. Recruitment started in March 2023 and ended in September 2023. Participants with varying levels of experience perform two one-hour sessions of training box exercises, one in the morning (control condition) and the other at the end of a workday. The primary outcome is a composite score derived from the time to complete the Suturing and Knot Tying Training and Testing (SUTT) exercise, along with the number and quality of stitches. Secondary outcomes include perceived fatigue, discomfort, physical strain, muscle tension, mental workload, muscle activation (measured by surface electromyography), balance (measured using a force platform), and kinematics (measured using motion capture).

Ethics and dissemination

The study received ethical approval from the local ethics committee CERNI in December 2022 (n°13,122,022). Results will be presented in international conferences, submitted to peer-reviewed journals, and serve as a feasibility study for subsequent publications.

Robotic assisted common bile duct exploration for management of complex gallstone disease

BACKGROUND

Minimally invasive cholecystectomy and common bile duct exploration offers single-stage management for complex gallstone disease (cholelithiasis and choledocholithiasis). The Robotic platform presents benefits in improving operative precision, which has not been extensively evaluated in the acute setting of managing complex gallstone disease, as well as in performing transcholedochal or postcholecystectomy common bile duct exploration. The authors report an early series of emergent and expedited robotic-assisted cholecystectomy with common bile duct exploration (RC-CBDE) or robotic common bile duct exploration (R-CBDE) alone.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A retrospective analysis from a specialist unit in the United Kingdom was undertaken from April 2022 to September 2023, inclusive. All patients who underwent RC-CBDE or R-CBDE were included. Data was collated on patient demographics, perioperative investigations, intraoperative approach, and postoperative outcomes.

RESULTS

Twenty-three consecutive patients were identified. The median (IQR) age was 51 (33-66) years. Median (IQR) Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI) was 1 (0-4). Five patients underwent operative intervention as an emergency and 18 on an expedited basis. Two patients underwent postcholecystectomy R-CBDE. Fourteen (61%) were transcholedochal and nine were transcystic (39%) CBDE. Median (IQR) bilirubin was 51 (34-253). Median (IQR) operative time was 176 (124-222) minutes. Median (IQR) postoperative length of stay was 2 (0-4) days. There were no bile leaks requiring intervention. The clearance rate of CBDS was 100%. No patients developed postoperative pancreatitis. One patient required intervention for port site hernia following RC-CBDE. One patient developed subhepatic collection postoperatively and required laparoscopic washout and placement of drains. No patients had retained stones after a 3-month follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Early experience confirms that RC-CBDE and R-CBDE in feasible, safe, and effective treatment for complex gallstone disease. Integrated adjuncts (intraoperative robotic ultrasound - IORUS and Firefly - fluorescence guided surgery - FGS) and superior ergonomics of the robotic platform may assist in reducing the learning curve and increase wider uptake of this complex procedure.

The compatibility of exoskeletons in perioperative environments and workflows: an analysis of surgical team members' perspectives and workflow simulation

Surgical team members in perioperative environments experience high physical demands. Interventions such as exoskeletons, external wearable devices that support users, have the potential to reduce these work-related physical demands. However, barriers such as workplace environment and task compatibility may limit exoskeleton implementation. This study gathered the perspectives of 33 surgical team members: 12 surgeons, four surgical residents, seven operating room (OR) nurses, seven surgical technicians (STs), two central processing technicians (CPTs), and one infection control nurse to understand their workplace compatibility. Team members were introduced to passive exoskeletons via demonstrations, after which surgical staff (OR nurses, STs, and CPTs) were led through a simulated workflow walkthrough where they completed tasks representative of their workday. Five themes emerged from the interviews (workflow, user needs, hindrances, motivation for intervention, and acceptance) with unique subthemes for each population. Overall, exoskeletons were largely compatible with the duties and workflow of surgical team members.

Influence of Intraoperative Active and Passive Breaks in Simulated Minimally Invasive Procedures on Surgeons' Perceived Discomfort, Performance, and Workload

Laparoscopic surgeons are at high risk of experiencing musculoskeletal discomfort, which is considered the result of long-lasting static and awkward body postures. We primarily aimed to evaluate whether passive and active work breaks can reduce ratings of perceived discomfort among laparoscopic surgeons compared with no work breaks. We secondarily aimed to examine potential differences in performance and workload across work break conditions and requested the surgeons evaluate working with passive or active work breaks. Following a balanced, randomized cross-over design, laparoscopic surgeons performed three 90 min laparoscopic simulations without and with 2.5 min passive or active work breaks after 30 min work blocks on separate days. The simulation included the following tasks: a hot wire, peg transfer, pick-and-place, pick-and-tighten, pick-and-thread, and pull-and-stick tasks. Ratings of perceived discomfort (CR10 Borg Scale), performance per subtask, and perceived workload (NASA-TLX) were recorded, and the break interventions were evaluated (self-developed questionnaire). Statistical analyses were performed on the rating of perceived discomfort and a selection of the performance outcomes. Twenty-one participants (9F) were included, with a mean age of 36.6 years (SD 9.7) and an average experience in laparoscopies of 8.5 years (SD 5.6). Ratings of perceived musculoskeletal discomfort slightly increased over time from a mean level of 0.1 to 0.9 but did not statistically significantly differ between conditions (p = 0.439). Performance outcomes of the hot wire and peg transfer tasks did not statistically significantly differ between conditions. The overall evaluation by the participants was slightly in favor regarding the duration and content of active breaks and showed a 65% likelihood of implementing them on their own initiative in ≥90 min-lasting laparoscopic surgeries, compared with passive breaks. Both passive and active breaks did not statistically significantly influence ratings of perceived discomfort or perceived workload in a 90 min simulation of laparoscopic surgery, with an overall low mean level of perceived discomfort of 0.9 (SD 1.4). As work breaks do not lead to performance losses, rest breaks should be tested in real-life situations across a complete working shift, where perceived discomfort may differ from this laboratory situation. However, in this respect, it is crucial to investigate the acceptance and practicality of intraoperative work breaks in feasibility studies in advance of assessing their effectiveness in follow-up longitudinal trials.

Exploring the Impact of Hand Dominance on Laparoscopic Surgical Skills Development Using Network Models

BACKGROUND

Laparoscopic surgery demands high precision and skill, necessitating effective training protocols that account for factors such as hand dominance. This study investigates the impact of hand dominance on the acquisition and proficiency of laparoscopic surgical skills, utilizing a novel assessment method that combines Network Models and electromyography (EMG) data.

METHODS

Eighteen participants, comprising both medical and non-medical students, engaged in laparoscopic simulation tasks, including peg transfer and wire loop tasks. Performance was assessed using Network Models to analyze EMG data, capturing muscle activity and learning progression. The NASA Task Load Index (TLX) was employed to evaluate subjective task demands and workload perceptions.

RESULTS

Our analysis revealed significant differences in learning progression and skill proficiency between dominant and non-dominant hands, suggesting the need for tailored training approaches. Network Models effectively identified patterns of skill acquisition, while NASA-TLX scores correlated with participants' performance and learning progression, highlighting the importance of considering both objective and subjective measures in surgical training.

CONCLUSIONS

The study underscores the importance of hand dominance in laparoscopic surgical training and suggests that personalized training protocols could enhance surgical precision, efficiency, and patient outcomes. By leveraging advanced analytical techniques, including Network Models and EMG data analysis, this research contributes to optimizing clinical training methodologies, potentially revolutionizing surgical education and improving patient care.

Advances in objective assessment of ergonomics in endoscopic surgery: a review

Background

Minimally invasive surgery, in particular endoscopic surgery, has revolutionized the benefits for patients, but poses greater challenges for surgeons in terms of ergonomics. Integrating ergonomic assessments and interventions into the multi-stage endoscopic procedure contributes to the surgeon's musculoskeletal health and the patient's intraoperative safety and postoperative recovery.

Objective

The purpose of this study was to overview the objective assessment techniques, tools and assessment settings involved in endoscopic procedures over the past decade and to identify the potential factors that induce differences in high workloads in endoscopic procedures and ultimately to design a framework for ergonomic assessment in endoscopic surgery.

Methods

Literature searches were systematically conducted in the OVID, pubmed and web of science database before October 2022, and studies evaluating ergonomics during the process of endoscopic procedures or simulated procedures were both recognized.

Results

Our systematic review of 56 studies underscores ergonomic variations in endoscopic surgery. While endoscopic procedures, predominantly laparoscopy, typically incur less physical load than open surgery, extended surgical durations notably elevate ergonomic risks. Surgeon characteristics, such as experience level and gender, significantly influence these risks, with less experienced and female surgeons facing greater challenges. Key assessment tools employed include electromyography for muscle fatigue and motion analysis for postural evaluation.

Conclusion

This review aims to provide a comprehensive analysis and framework of objective ergonomic assessments in endoscopic surgery, and suggesting avenues for future research and intervention strategies. By improving the ergonomic conditions for surgeons, we can enhance their overall health, mitigate the risk of WMSDs, and ultimately improve patient outcomes.

Physical and mental health impairments experienced by operating surgeons and camera-holder assistants during laparoscopic surgery: a cross-sectional survey

Introduction

Surgeons may experience physical and mental health problems because of their jobs, which may lead to chronic muscle damage, burnout, or even withdrawal. However, these are often ignored in camera-holder assistants during laparoscopic surgery. We aimed to analyze the differences between operating surgeons and camera-holder assistants.

Methods

From January 1, 2022, to December 31, 2022, a cross-sectional survey was conducted to evaluate the muscle pain, fatigue, verbal scolding, and task load for operating surgeons and camera-holder assistants. The Nordic Musculoskeletal Questionnaire, the Space Administration Task Load Index, and the Surgical Task Load Index (SURG-TLX) were combined in the questionnaire.

Results

2,184 operations were performed by a total of 94 operating surgeons and 220 camera assistants. 81% of operating surgeons and 78% of camera-holder assistants reported muscle pain/discomfort during the procedure. The most affected anatomic region was the shoulders for operating surgeons, and the lower back for camera-holder assistants. Intraoperative fatigue was reported by 41.7% of operating surgeons and 51.7% of camera-holder assistants. 55.2% of camera-holder assistants reported verbal scolding from the operating surgeons, primarily attributed to lapses in laparoscope movement coordination. The SURG-TLX results showed that the distributions of mental, physical, and situational stress for operating surgeons and camera-holder assistants were comparable.

Conclusion

Like operating surgeons, camera-holder assistants also face similar physical and mental health impairments while performing laparoscopic surgery. Improvements to the working conditions of the camera-holder assistant should not be overlooked.

Five-Year Experience Training Surgeons with a Laparoscopic Simulation Training Program for Bariatric Surgery: a Quasi-experimental Design

PURPOSE

Nearly 200,000 laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (LRYGB) are performed yearly. Reported learning curves range between 50 and 150, even 500 cases to decrease the operative risk. Simulation programs could accelerate this learning curve safely; however, trainings for LRYGB are scarce. This study aims to describe and share our 5-year experience of a simulated program designed to achieve proficiency in LRYGB technical skills.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A quasi-experimental design was used. All recruited participants were previously trained with basic and advanced laparoscopic simulation curriculum completing over 50 h of practical training. Ex vivo animal models were used to practice manual and stapled gastrojejunostomy (GJ) and stapled jejunojejunostomy (JJO) in 10, 3, and 4 sessions, respectively. The main outcome was to assess the manual GJ skill acquisition. Pre- and post-training assessments using a Global Rating Scale (GRS; max 25 pts), Specific Rating Scale (SRS; max 20 pts), performance time, permeability, and leakage rates were analyzed. For the stapled GJ and JJO, execution time was registered. Data analysis was performed using parametric tests.

RESULTS

In 5 years, 68 trainees completed the program. For the manual GJ's pre- vs post-training assessment, GRS and SRS scores increased significantly (from 17 to 24 and from 13 to 19 points respectively, p-value < 0.001). Permeability rate increased while leakage rate and procedural time decreased significantly.

CONCLUSION

This simulated training program showed effectiveness in improving laparoscopic skills for manual GJ and JJO in a simulated scenario. This new training program could optimize the clinical learning curve. Further studies are needed to assess the transfer of skills to the operating room.